No he's not anxious, it's equivalent to when a lead guitarist makes faces during a lead solo, it's emotion!

Barry looks so much like younger brother Andy. We'll never know what he could have been

Hello in 2023! The BeeGees wrote this song and Al Green covered it. Andy had a solo career and died 17 yrs after this was performed. Andy was 12 years younger than Barry & 9 yrs younger than the twins, so Andy started singing career 20 yrs after the BeeGees started as children. ❤ Enjoyed your reaction & this performance from so long ago! ❤😊

This is their song, everybody and their brother covered this song. This was written after they got back together after a brake up. They missed each other, their brothers and as Robin said it really wasn't any fun on their own.

There's a haunting sadness in Robin's voice that is beautiful.

Imagine being able to write a song like this and Lonely Nights in the same afternoon. And after being apart for nearly two years! I don’t think there will ever be another band quite like the Bee Gees.

I love how they paint a picture with their songs. They are brilliant.

The Bee Gees are the greatest of the Blessed & this song is the proof of ' the proof is in pudding !!!

Bee Gees are the greatest.

Andy was still alive. This was about their relationship with each other after Robin quit the band for a while and went solo. This is after they reunited. They made it into a love song to appeal to the audience. This is their original song.

For Whom the Bell Tolls Bee Gees live version near Brooklyn Bridge.😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

bee gees my world live 1972

I have always thought that the brothers gibb were true poets , all their songs were beautifully crafted and have stayed the test of time .

Arguably the greatest songwriter's, they gave so much to music for over 40 years, thanks guys

No brother trio will ever be as great as the Bee Gees.They deserve all the accolades they have received. Happy New. It's January I, 2023!!! Barry wrote songs for other artists that became # 1 hits

@HAP3SPEAKZ

Жыл бұрын

Well said

Robin originally formed the group and was the lead singer until Barry discovered his high falsetto. Robin left the band for awhile and later swallowed his pride and returned and Barry became the lead singer.

@Anne.Pinkerton

3 ай бұрын

They were a group in the 50's and since Barry was older, he was automatically the leader. Robin got jealous that Barry was getting all the good stuff and they split ways for a time but eventually realized that it could only work for them to sing TOGETHER!

How can you mend a broken heart? How can you stop the rain from falling down? These guys my Lord their lyrics , their voices, their emotion, their raw vulnerability when they sing is just amazing! There will never be another group like them. Ever!!!

Robins voice gives me goosebumps.

@KcityMikeThomas

Жыл бұрын

Yep. I love the opening by Robin.

The drummer is Geoff Bridgeford who was very much a part of the band in the early seventies. The song was written by Barry and Robin and was their 1'st US number one in 1971. Al Green made a cover that is correct, but it is original a Bee Gees song.

bee gees nights on broadway live 1975

Robin's (atherial vibrato ) one of a kind voice, Incredible vocals by him..❤ 👌 ♥ luv him...

This brought tears to my eyes. So young. Morris looked happy. I don't think they were nervous at all, they've been performing live since they were kids. Don't watch The Last Bee Gee unless you are ready to cry a bit, Barry is very honest.

How Can You Mend and Lonely Days were written on the day they got back together after an 18 month breakup where they disliked each other intensely at times, so it's pretty obvious this song is about them I think also the first two number ones in the US

@RandomJane104

3 жыл бұрын

I think they wrote a lot of songs about their relationship with each other and then made them about romantic relationships.

Very good!! React For whom the bell tolls live Bee Gees..

This is a song Barry and Robin wrote after Robin had left the group for 18 months. They learned a lot and this is about those emotions. It went to number one.

Your probably wondering why I sometimes message you more than once, it’s because I come back to listen more than once. This song was pretty important in a way. The Bee Gees broke up for a couple of years from 1969. This song was more about them getting back together again and realising how much they had missed each other.🎼❤️🇦🇺❤️🇬🇧🕺🏻💃🎸☘️

I hate that people refer them to a disco group! They had soooo many hits and good songs before that time. They actually recording their songs on the soundtrack of Saturday Night Fever before the movie was made. They were asked for songs afterwards!!! People really need to open their eyes ...and ears! Kudos to you my friend!! Love you reaction! Keep ‘me coming. Do many more reactions of the BeeGees please!

another wonderful reaction. You have opened a pandora's box with these boys!!

They broke up in 1969 for about 15 months. Wrote this and lonely days when they first reunited. Al Green covered it and the Bee Gees loved it.

Sorry I’m late with response. Speechless anyway. They will live on forever ❤️❤️

The Bee Gees are the best band ever!!!! Another great song is words. The name of the song is,Words. But I think Barry does most of the song

Barry was 24, Robin & Maurice were 22 - WOW!

Robin's opening song sounds so awesome and then Barry takes over with a completely different voice. This is my favorite Bee Gees song!

@lynnw7155

5 ай бұрын

They had the most beautiful and most beautifully blended voices. The vibrato is amazing.

Andy didn’t die until in the late 80’s. This song was written after their 18 month break-up and after they got back together again. They wrote this song but everyone and their brother has covered it. They actually love performing live. Their live shows were great!!!!! They are so funny too and down to earth.

The brother Andy didn't die until 1988. He was a great singer as well. Check him out. Thanks for the great reaction and keep discovering more Bee Gee songs. You won't be disappointed.

Thank you so much for not stopping the video every ten seconds and letting us enjoy the video too!

Fab

They are a live group and they loved performing live. This was after they got back together. This is their song, they wrote it, they wrote all their own songs snd songs fir other artists. Al Green covered this song as well as others.

1971 the yr I got married & still married to the same guy. Lucky lucky man. 🤣 This is my favorite song. I have one of there concerts. Suggest Massachusetts”!another Robin song.💜

Thank you for realizing that there is more to the BEE GEES than just disco! Keep digging into their catalog of music. They are so diverse in their music that you can't pinpoint a "style" for them. Unless fantastic is a style..🙂💖💖💖

The Bee Gee's never recorded a bad song.. I love love love the Bee Gee's ever since I was 9 years old. All the songs that other artist recorded that the Bee Gees wrote were awesome, after people were tired of listening to the Bee Gee's .. I could never get tired of listening to the Bee Gees.

I've spent 25 years learning how to mend my broken 💔

Al Green covered the Bee Gees written song, which was inspired by their reconciliation after Robin left the trio for 15+ months a breakup that the brothers blamed on youthful egos and pressures of first fame. they said the estrangement was painful for them for they never stopped loving one another. It took a couple of years to "mend" the hurts.

This song is simply gorgeous. When Robin left the group for a couple years, this was the first song they wrote when they reunited. 😌

These guys bring back so many memories! Thanks my friend!

The BeeGees wrote it. Several other artists recorded it. Andy wasn't recording yet. He was 10 years younger. Andy died 35 years ago when he was 30.

This is from a time when music did do the talking.....

This is my favorite song by them. I love it.

They were 8 and 5 when their mom went to their room to have them turn down the radio and found it was her son's singing in perfect three part harmony. They started performing when Barry was 9 and the twins were 6. They were established as the BeeGees in 1958. Their baby brother Andy Gibb was born in 58. You should check out his songs. Amazing artist.

Aaahh wht a song beautiful the words love this song al greene sang this song as well the words 👌

Great reaction, Hap. 👍You're so right about the depth of their lyrics at such young age. I feel their music deeply and sincerely. Loved your comments as always. Thank you for your continuous discover to Bee Gees music.🎶

These guys are the real deal ♥️♥️

This is such a beautiful song. The audience is making me laugh though. I've been at several TV tapings and most of the time they give the audience instructions. I feel like these poor kids were told to not smile or look directly at the BeeGees. Why would you stare blankly at the drummer or a wall when Barry Gibb is standing behind you singing a love song? ;-) Great reaction Hap!

Quincy Jones said the greatest rhythm & blues song he ever heard was 'Fannie, Be Tender With My Love'.

Al Green covered the song but so did a lot of singers, soon as they decided to get back together Robert Stigwood told them to get into the studio immediately and record some songs so it's not surprising both songs were about longing and missing each other

Robin was really known for his voice more than Barry. Just very unique. Mo played the bass, guitar, keyboards. He did most of the backtrack playing on all instruments. BeeGees This song was written 17 years before Andy died and they only sing their original songs and they also wrote this. Al Green covered this song.

@HAP3SPEAKZ

3 жыл бұрын

Oh ok !!! Thanks for confirming Sue!! 👍🏽🎵🎵

@SueProv

3 жыл бұрын

@@HAP3SPEAKZ Hap. I love your reactions. Just sharing info never comdemning you. I get educated by others all the time. Cant wait for you to get thru even to the early 2000s...

@HAP3SPEAKZ

3 жыл бұрын

Looking forward to the ride. 🎵

@susieq9801

3 жыл бұрын

@@HAP3SPEAKZ - This may not be something that you would react to because it's very different but if you want to be utterly amazed by Robin listen to him sing "Somewhere" from the movie "West Side Story". He found the backing track in his producer's office while still in Australia and decided for a lark to do a karaoke to try out his new "big boy" voice as he just turned SIXTEEN! Amazing performance and just done for the heck of it. I could not believe he was only 16. kzread.info/dash/bejne/nHWayqhtn67cp84.html Just subscribed to you! Cheers.

@TWariner

2 ай бұрын

Not at all true. Barry was known for his voice just as much, if not more. Don’t tell lies.

How can u stop the sun from shining makes the world go round aaaawww this song pls listen to al greene sing it when u have time hapz bee gees tops 👌

Please listen to ' I Started a Joke.' to hear Robin's beautiful voice.It's the best.

@lcbcreative

3 жыл бұрын

That song used to make me tear up. Robin has that beautiful Gibb brother quiver in his voice like Barry.

@karenj3611

3 жыл бұрын

Yesss,! Love Robin's voice

@mattieevans5816

3 жыл бұрын

I have been a fan since the sixties,when the first song was Massachusetts.Mostly everything they did was live !!

@amymarckel420

3 жыл бұрын

I love all of the Brothers Gibb, but I’ve always had a soft spot in my heart for Robin and his beautiful vibrato.

@susieq9801

3 жыл бұрын

@@lcbcreative - Robin's vibrato is much more pronounced that Barry's and perfectly natural to him. It was his trademark in the band and Barry said Robin's vibrato was "killer".

It's funny hearing you say about songs being ages ago..............I'm 62 & remember them like it was yesterday.............Andy died in 1988 fella.

Just so many great songs written and performed over their 45 years singing together that you'll be at this for a while! Words, Massachusetts, Nights on Broadway, Jive Talkin', You Should Be Dancin', Tragedy, Love You Inside and Out...in fact, why list them? You can just about pick anything they did and love it! And all the songs they wrote for others....just pure phenomenal talent. No computer enhancement necessary. :)

I had the chance to see them live in Vegas and didn't. You have no idea how I regret it. They played the soundtrack of my teenage years and teenage crushes - so many broken hearts that never mended. ♥️

Very deep lyrics for such a young group.

Hello again My friend! So nice to see another reaction to esrliest BEE GEES songs "How can You mend a broken heart" is a beautiful song, I believe that was in album "Trafalgar", barroque style there's a lot of beautiful songs there: Trafalgar Israel When do I Walking back to Waterloo I see some request in comments and I agree with this: "My world" (1972) "Nights on Broadway" (1975) and I added "Massachusetts (1967) "Mr Natural" (1974)

Great reaction! Robin actually sang more leads then big brother Barry from the late 60's to the early 70's (pre-disco era) or shared the lead with him. They had lots of early hits during this era. The disco era changed everything for Robin and he took a back seat to Barry's famous falsetto. Please react to other early hits with Robin taking the lead such as his signature song "I Started a Joke", "I Can't See Nobody" and "And the Sun Will Shine". All three were sung at theit 1974 Melbourne concert and would be great choices for your reactions. However, if you want the best live version of "Joke", I would suggest using their 1989 concert for your reaction. He actually got a standing ovation whenever he performed this song but at this particular performance he received one that lasted almost one minute and they actually showed it! He loved this song so much that he requested that it be played at his funeral in 2012. Such a beautiful voice from such a wonderful man. I promise that you won't be disappointed!

@amymarckel420

3 жыл бұрын

Just rewatched the 74 Melbourne concert the other day. So good. I could seriously listen to Robin sing all day long.

@lauriebarnes2999

3 жыл бұрын

Amy, my sentiments exactly!

@kthor

2 жыл бұрын

From the late 60’s to early 70’s, Barry sang lead almost twice as many times as Robin did…..when they weren’t both sharing lead.

WHERE DOES THE TIME GO? SUCH A BEAUTIFUL SONG! I NOW AS AN ADULT HAVE APPRECIATION FOR THE BEE GEES .THAT'S WHAT LIFE DOES. AND ONE UNDERSTANDS. WHAT THE SONGS ARE ABOUT. YOUR REACTION WAS VERY ENTHUSIASTIC. AWESOME HAP!💜🤗🎶🙏

@HAP3SPEAKZ

3 жыл бұрын

🙏🏽Thank you

@denikennedy6675

3 жыл бұрын

MY PLEASURE! THANK YOU!

Verry talented brothers,this was my younger years and still listening 2021

This song is so dang beautiful thanks for reacting to the Bee Gee's 💙

Andy died in 1988, this was much earlier, this was written just after they got back together. The band broke up for a little while when they were young.

This makes me think about my teenage years 🥺 I so loved them, got me though break-ups Thanks for taking a interest in them!

Fantastic!!! Enjoy your reaction! Love to hear "Will you still love me tomorrow," Done recording it live! Carol King felt it was the best cover of her song ever!

I can see you will enjoy exploring The Bee Gees. They are so good. You are already asking the good questions already.

One of my many favorite songs of The Bee Gees is Run To Me, please check out that song! ♥️🎶 Check out their documentary on HBO To Mend A Broken Heart

Bee Gees Words Nights on Broadway Jive Talk Islands in the stream Islands in the stream was also performed by Kenny Rogers and Dolly Parton live. Don’t miss. TY.

Absolutely beautiful!

Happy I'm pretty sure you werent even born then lol...love the bee gees....they were the kings of beautiful ballads and their harmony was superb!!!! Sadly only Barry survives♡

"How can you mend a broken heart"was written after they had been broken up for a while after some disagreements.Robin went solo for a bit and later he and Barry reunited and Broken heart wss the result.They were brilliant song writers.Al Green later covered that song beautifully.

Have you noticed the audience looking at Andy while he sings? Completely mesmerized 😁 (and yes, I went and googled their names...they were a bit before my time, but I knew some of their songs by watching some "not so young" films, like Saturday Night Fever, and my parents used to listen to them as well in "not so recent" vinyls)

Please try for us, Robin Gibb singing ALONE. his last song before he died in 2012

Sadly, Barry is the only one left. Their younger Andy went solo, but died too soon. Then Maurice , the latest was Robin. Barry barely decided to go back on his own. He's amazing, but it'll never be the same. I do recommend you go back and listen to their songs, you'll be amazed.

Thanks, Hap -- Robin is my favorite -- but Barry being oldest was always the "leader" -- nevertheless, any of them could sing any falsetto notes - Maurice did so on some live concerts when Barry had vocal limitations... I've always said/known that there is no better harmony and collaboration than that of family --

Al green did a cover the beegees wrote it

@remedy9648

3 жыл бұрын

Love this song and thought Al did it justice! 💜

This made me tear up... 🌸 What a great music! “How can you stop the Sun from shining” 🤭 just so touching how they sing & harmonizing.

@giannafrancis5176

3 жыл бұрын

Very deep and insightful and meaningful lyrics for being such young men when they wrote this beautiful, beautiful song.

In the biography Barry saiddong him and Robin had been estranged for about a year and he called him up one day and asked him to come over and they wrote the song that afternoon about them

They first started out with whoever wrote the song sang lead, then they evolved into taking turns taking lead in the same song. Then they decided who ever voice best fit to then sing harmonies.

Love this song and music video!

Superb!

They wrote this, and Al Green sang it first. It wasn’t written for Andy, because Andy was a little boy at the time.

Serious turtle neck right there 😅

Maurice apparently had a knackto play many instruments & was the "techie" brother. He plays bass in a lot of live footage& Maurice sings the falsetto on Nights On Broadway which is usually credited as being the beginning of their falsetto sound

I want to point out a couple of corrections About your reaction. Andy Gibb was Alive and barely a teen at this time. He passed away much later in 1988. Before that, he was a teen idol Singer during the late 70s into the 80s. Also, the Bee Gees wrote and recorded this song first. Al Green covered it a few months later

The song was written by Barry and Robin Gibb. The Bee Gees performed it first. Al Green covered it.

And Barry is still recording songs!

Al Green covered it , the Bee Gees wrote this song for Otis Reading but he died and they did it themselves . Watch the documentary , it’s great .

@Bigeyes2911

3 жыл бұрын

No, they wrote To Love Somebody for Otis Redding

Please react to THIS IS WHERE I CAME IN live by the BEEGEES thanks

Dude, want to see them layin the groundwork???? Please react to BEE GEES {1960} and maybe WINE AND WOMEN.

Andy passed away late 1980s this was 1971

Lovely!

Love your reactions, please check out Celon Dion and the Bee Gees singing Immortality its fantastic, give it a try please.

Such beautiful music~!! Great job!

Not sure if you’ve seen their document titled- How can you mend a broken heart. If you like them now, you’ll love the movie. It’s amazing.