Are These Clones Too Weak?

Ойын-сауық

#starwars #shorts #TheBadBatch
Are these clones too weak? The clone commandos in The Bad Batch series haven't really been that threatening so far. They seem to be on a similar level as regular Imperial clone troopers. Hopefully Scorch and his squad of Imperial Commandos will be more intimidating later on in the series
Subscribe for more random, funny Star Wars shorts edits!

Пікірлер: 137

  • @expandedshorts
    @expandedshorts Жыл бұрын

    What do you think about the power level of Imperial Commandos?

  • @Jxtt21

    @Jxtt21

    Жыл бұрын

    I think they’re the same as the republic commandos maybe just a little bit stronger

  • @Wolfsbane1100

    @Wolfsbane1100

    Жыл бұрын

    Imperial Commandos can't really be presented as a threat, the Empire has no major enemies at this point beyond a handful of Separatist holdouts on a few planets. the Bad Batch has to be maintained as titular characters for, presumably, another season. There's not a lot you can do with a TV show if you kill your entire main cast the first time they face an enemy that has a reputation for strength. Besides that, if we all remember, the first time that the Bad Batch went up against Commandos, they got separated from each other and Hunter was captured. It's not for nothing.

  • @nathanskywalker1536

    @nathanskywalker1536

    Жыл бұрын

    I'm with you they made them weak push overs in the bad Bach

  • @maddhattergaming6863

    @maddhattergaming6863

    Жыл бұрын

    I wouyld liek to poitn out the Bad Batch are also commandos with serious experience so commandos goign toe to toe isn't that much of a difference

  • @irishrailenthusiast1977

    @irishrailenthusiast1977

    Жыл бұрын

    Well, I don't think they're weak. They're specialized units designed for infiltration and behind enemy lines kind of jobs. Similar to us regular people that get bored and complacent with everyday mundane jobs. These commandos are also facing clones, clones are highly skilled soldiers , not to mention it's Clone Force 99 they're dealing with, a commando 2.0 squad. It's very reminiscent of the Jedi utilizing the Commandos wrong at the battle of Geonosis. When they're used in the right way they're deadly. Same way BX Series commando droids are ineffective in open warfare but deadly in close quarter infiltration.

  • @ThatHaloGuy020
    @ThatHaloGuy020 Жыл бұрын

    my only problem is that we haven't seen them fight much, also remember that the bad batch are also a specialized clone unit. if cody and crosshair had commandos instead of regs in ep3 that fight would have been over very quickly.

  • @spoktv3343
    @spoktv3343 Жыл бұрын

    I think it's unfair to call the clones weak, at least now, because so far we've only seen commandos fight alone against the Bad Batch, If you ignore the TK trooper who can't hit anything. And the clone with the Zillo beast, I mean what could he realistically have done? The Silo Beast just ate the electric staff. If the Zillo Beast had still been hungry, he probably would have eaten the Bad Batch too.

  • @dmitrykhvostik5975

    @dmitrykhvostik5975

    Жыл бұрын

    Not also forget that the Bad Batch themselves are enhanced clone commando unit.

  • @MellowBTW

    @MellowBTW

    Жыл бұрын

    This did not age well

  • @spoktv3343

    @spoktv3343

    Жыл бұрын

    @@MellowBTW Yes, at the time I was still naive.

  • @MellowBTW

    @MellowBTW

    Жыл бұрын

    @@spoktv3343 the writers just don't respect commandos

  • @Nostromo212
    @Nostromo212 Жыл бұрын

    It probably doesn't help that they're all separated from their squads too. They no longer have their squadmates who they spend their whole lives training with and coordinating with (at least from what we can tell). The whole reason so many Commandos died on Geonosis is because they were just thrown into the front lines as normal soldiers instead of being utilized the way they were intended. The Empire isn't making this exact mistake again but it is still worth noting. Also, Scorch is the only one so far who has seemed capable of taking on the batch by himself. Scorch is also the only Commando we've seen who has been allowed to keep his personalized armor. Maybe the other commandos are newer clones who werr completed later in the war with less experience and Scorch just has seniority? Also it feels like the electro staff commando was set up for failure. Actually, we've only seen them failing against The Batch + Gregor, and a baby Zillo Beast. These are definitely not typical enemies to be stacked up against. Those are just my thoughts anyway haha.

  • @DUTCH_FETT

    @DUTCH_FETT

    Жыл бұрын

    I’m pretty sure a bunch of them dying at Geonosis isn’t canon anymore. That being said, I really hate how in legends they did that because if anything commandos would thrive on the front lines compared to regular units because they are masters of the basics just like the actual special forces in the military, they’re just masters of the basics and they train on some other stuff too but they know everything and more that a regular infantry unit knows so it makes no sense for them to just die compared to the regular grunt

  • @darthnicholas8528

    @darthnicholas8528

    Жыл бұрын

    @@DUTCH_FETT So, with the exception of Delta Squad, would it be accurate to say clone commandos on Geonosis in Legends were given the Rebels death trooper and Kenobi purge trooper treatment?

  • @cheemsdoge
    @cheemsdoge Жыл бұрын

    The commandos feel like they are supposed to fill in the role of the death troopers before the empire implemented them, they guard high priority locations and people and take on extremely sensitive missions.

  • @anotherconsumer3044
    @anotherconsumer3044 Жыл бұрын

    We're simply seeing another example of the trend of cool-looking villains getting killed off unceremoniously because the plot called for it.

  • @jakesimprich9155
    @jakesimprich9155 Жыл бұрын

    With scorch being confirmed I'm sure they're going to kick some ass coming up. Next week is apparently about crossbair and I'm wondering if he would be apart of the team scorch makes to go on the hunt for the bad batch

  • @biggsdarklighter0473

    @biggsdarklighter0473

    Жыл бұрын

    Please just let Crosshair fill in for Sev, that would be great.

  • @STPTTP
    @STPTTP Жыл бұрын

    They’ve kinda been used as cannon fodder instead of like special forces

  • @NurseAmamiya

    @NurseAmamiya

    Жыл бұрын

    The obvious answer is because the empire at this time is beginning it's stages on phasing out clones as soon as possible in place of recruits, which actually make sense

  • @floschreiber7801
    @floschreiber7801 Жыл бұрын

    My 2 cents to this is this: Commandos are dangerous on their own,yes. However-they are not at their full potential in BB because the commandos we see...aren't with their original brothers, their squad. We see them either scattered around as singular instructors to a bunch of inferior troops. Or put together in random blotches of multiple fellow commandos who don't exactly seem to be their batch brothers- but with the ship they were facing something the Zillo beast. Juvenile or mot it was a threat that even an army had trouble dealing with. The explanation as to why for example see Scorch score a few good hits on the BB (I think being one of the first enemies to actually give them trouble) is due to his training (Delta Squad was the best of the best of the standard commandos after all). Would he have been with his squad though, the people he has trained with since birth to become extremely dangerous and precise killing machines, balancing each other out in perfect harmony to form one deadly killing instrument, it would jabd probably gone differently. However, for story purposes we can of course have the BB's butt get kicked every time they encounter the Imperials . However. They could be building up to something (if they actually wanna cater to "us" legends fans and not just toss a bone and move along). and this is my theory: People other then Rampart are now after the bad batch. Rampart had failed and kept their survival a secret, which is how they also avoided alot of possible threats, the bigger bureaucracy of the Empire simply considered them dead. Any "sightings" could just be a local hoping to skim credits or just a missinformation/mistakes of memories. Bureaucracys are infamously flexible, and the Empire is full of it especially in the early days. However, the Empire has now 2 reasons to go after the bad batch. Sure, they might he nuisance at times to their interest in perhaps one or 2 sectors-but nothing they couldn't deal with eventually, there were bigger things ahead. But now? They had something they needed for a very vital project. One they had Kamino obliterated for, stolen their technology for. It was alot of work to get this far, but they couldn't get further without the one vital key to make it all fit-or make the person that could make it all fit cooperate. Omega So the Empire decides to put back together one of their best squads. Perhaps all the Clone Commando squads were broken up originally during or after Order 66 due to fear thay loyalty to their fellow brothers from birth would be higher then to the Empire. But that was not a concern now. But, one essential part of the Delta Squad was missing. Sev, their sniper. And a Squad had to have 4 people, plus the BB weren't ordinary fors nor clones. They thought differently, fought differently, behaved differently and so were almost unpredictable, if you don't know the members well. Luckily, there is someone that knows them like brothers, since day 1. Who is almost foolishly loyal to the Empire, a trained commando-and a deadly sniper. I think we all know im talking about Croshair. Crosshair is assigned to delta, and they get their armors painted black (Imperial Commando reference) and go after the BB-and finaly give them a good and proper struggle. Anyway that's just my theory as what they could possibly be building towards to-or my hope. I'm wiring this at 1 am so please excuse any spelling mistakes or calling the squad members by their wrong names.

  • @HeiwaHero
    @HeiwaHero Жыл бұрын

    Besides plot armor, I feel like the reason they are somewhat neutered is because of the chip, they are indoctrinated stripping them of any individuality and therefore removing the complex out of the box thinking and adaptability that comes with free will.

  • @neofulcrum5013
    @neofulcrum5013 Жыл бұрын

    People need to realize that being elite doesn’t mean being invincible. The mandalorians are some of the greatest warriors in this galaxy but as we’ve seen in the clone wars and even the Mandalorian show, they’re not undefeated. They can still struggle. They can still lose. They’re badass but they’re not gods. Not even the Jedi are unstoppable. I understand people wanting the imperial commandos (or royal guards as they’re labeled in concept art) to do MORE, but don’t go in with the mindset that they can’t ever be beaten. With that out the way, it’s likely that if they’re coming for omega, they might catch the Bad Batch off guard and kidnap her. Though that doesn’t mean it’ll be a cakewalk given the Batch themselves have undergone the same training. Just my thoughts.

  • @battlefieldpro12345

    @battlefieldpro12345

    Жыл бұрын

    Of course they can still be beaten but the complaint is they're not doing enough in the show aside from Scorch. Whenever they appear, it seems like they are normal clones just with katarn armor. It really seems like the writers wanted to just shoehorn in clone commandos as hallow fan service instead of actually making them ACT like commandos but im hoping they get better with the upcoming episodes.

  • @neofulcrum5013

    @neofulcrum5013

    Жыл бұрын

    @@battlefieldpro12345 as I said, I understand people wanting them to do more. That’s a fair critique.

  • @dmitrykhvostik5975
    @dmitrykhvostik5975 Жыл бұрын

    My only problem with them is not using their iconic DC-17m blaster. I'd understand if creators were just Lazy to make a model of this gun, but then we have Wrecker USING THIS. It feels so odd. As for their battle experience, the key difference between commandos and ARC troopers is them operating usually on top secret operations/behind the enemy line so securing huge Top-secret research facility fits to this pretty well.

  • @basedsneedclave175
    @basedsneedclave175 Жыл бұрын

    My main problem with then is the intentional choice to have them use the dc-15 instead of their iconic dc-17 especially when wrecker uses a dc-17.

  • @raccoon4363
    @raccoon4363 Жыл бұрын

    they did them dirty for sure, but it could've been worse

  • @kingmitchum
    @kingmitchum Жыл бұрын

    I kind of had a thought that maybe the RC's in that facility aren't real commandos, and instead they're given the highest quality equipment because of how important the facility is. Maybe those RC's with the markings are actual Commando's.

  • @ventris425productions5

    @ventris425productions5

    Жыл бұрын

    Oh that makes sense, or the the normal commandos had to take a inferior form of commando training so they aren’t as skilled or hardened as the others

  • @kingmitchum

    @kingmitchum

    Жыл бұрын

    @@ventris425productions5 My theory didn't even come from how weak they seem, but just because there's so many of them in one place. I kept thinking there was no way the Empire had so many commandos grouped up on one planet, it'd be extremely wasteful.

  • @ventris425productions5

    @ventris425productions5

    Жыл бұрын

    @@kingmitchum oh, sorry

  • @100StepProgram

    @100StepProgram

    Жыл бұрын

    Has it ever been said how many commandos there are? Because you are right about there seeming to be quite a lot and having them on facility guard duty really doesn’t seem like that’s what they are trained for. Would definitely make sense if they were simply better trained clones in commando armour and not true commandos. Honestly seems like a case of the writers going “we got an important facility so there needs to be dangerous looking guards, let’s just make all the guards commandos.” Without much proper thought put in.

  • @Nostromo212

    @Nostromo212

    Жыл бұрын

    Ooo this is a really good theory too

  • @Kek.B.I
    @Kek.B.I Жыл бұрын

    Their presence has become mere tokenism.

  • @battlefieldpro12345

    @battlefieldpro12345

    Жыл бұрын

    This guy gets it

  • @Geeza47372
    @Geeza47372 Жыл бұрын

    They've made them glorified guards and that's it. What made clone commandos special to me and many others is how rare they we're and how you felt like you we're a badass while playing as one in Republic Commando. The writers however have simply decided to have hoards of them everywhere on MT Tantis which doesn't even make them feel special anymore. Commandos should only be appearing rarely and in squads of 4 instead of them being everywhere. I would've just had the kamino security guards be guarding Tantis and then have SOME commandos walking around instead of it just being commandos. What would make commandos be special would be having them hunting down the bad batch actively and actually causing damage to them. People suggest Delta Squad a lot for this but I think it would've been better if Crosshair was put into a squad of commandos instead of those elite troopers from the first season.

  • @battlefieldpro12345

    @battlefieldpro12345

    Жыл бұрын

    Exactly. Its like the writers didnt do their research in the comics, books, and RC game. Really just seems like hallow fan service or an intentional decision to prop the BB up over everyone else. Scorch shouldnt be the only one that puts up a huge fight like he did when he first encountered them, they all should be like that.

  • @carlosminetti3685

    @carlosminetti3685

    Жыл бұрын

    I agree they didn’t do their homework but the empire put its own commandos (death troopers) as guards for their high ranking officers so kind of par for the course

  • @Mabra51

    @Mabra51

    Жыл бұрын

    were*

  • @12LoLproductions
    @12LoLproductions Жыл бұрын

    They seem like stormtroopers from Rebels

  • @HamalgamUB
    @HamalgamUB Жыл бұрын

    we need imperial commando

  • @JuanGomez-bs6ue
    @JuanGomez-bs6ue Жыл бұрын

    People forget that Commandos are people, not unstoppable machines.

  • @jacobballou8179
    @jacobballou8179 Жыл бұрын

    If they were following Cannon then the Commandos trained my Mandalorian mercenaries should be able to merk anyone whose not a force user or an original Jango trained ARC trooper. But since this is the new cannon that’s all gone sadly

  • @AntrozLPs
    @AntrozLPs Жыл бұрын

    This is called the Conservation of Ninjutsu. The more badass characters you have in one place, the weaver overall they are because the bad-assery has to be distributed evenly and you can't have them be too strong to overwhelm the main characters.

  • @zurrskirata1321
    @zurrskirata1321 Жыл бұрын

    Thats what we literary need, a serious threat from the Commandos that would make us worry about the Bad Batch. The Clone Commandos are on the same skill level as the Bad batch with the only difference being the enhancement.

  • @MellowBTW
    @MellowBTW Жыл бұрын

    This video aged like wine after the finale lmao

  • @expandedshorts

    @expandedshorts

    Жыл бұрын

    🤣

  • @alecbowman7738
    @alecbowman7738 Жыл бұрын

    That commando shouldn’t have had that much of an issue with that Zillo beast. He could’ve easily tossed that thing across the room with a propulsion blast from his gauntlet.

  • @lillith3159
    @lillith3159 Жыл бұрын

    To be fair, the bad batch are essentially clone commandos on steroids

  • @MountainWo1f
    @MountainWo1f Жыл бұрын

    They kinda are being used a regular soldiers but as an actual threat to the batch we have only ever seen multiple bad batchers vs one commando to my knowledge so although the empires use of these soldiers is ridiculous they are still going to be a challenge for the bad batch.

  • @nikosfilipino
    @nikosfilipino Жыл бұрын

    i have a problem with gregor taking two in the chest near the heart and being totally fine but other clones taking it in their right shoulder and being ded

  • @battlefieldpro12345
    @battlefieldpro12345 Жыл бұрын

    They arent being done justice in this series aside from Scorch in terms of skill. Why the heck are clone commandos being used to contain and monitor the vitals of a biological weapon instead of an Imperial secret research division? It makes no sense. The Empire should be deploying them in squads or platoons to find the Bad Batch (and actually pose a SIGNIFICANT threat) or other high value targets the Empire needs eliminated or to conduct sabatoge operations. They also seem to have the same combat prowess as a normal clone trooper despite them being the elite of the elite. Also I would like to point out we still have no confirmation if they will even use their signature blaster, the DC-17m interchangeable weapon system. Overall, I think the writers just wanted to prop the BB up over the actual clone commandos that are already established in lore and its pretty frustrating as an RC fan.

  • @SonnyBLightSun
    @SonnyBLightSun Жыл бұрын

    The problem with the Clone Commandos being used as Guards and or being used like Stormtroopers is the fact that there build for offensive raids, demolitions, reconnaissance, search and rescue, and unconventional warfare. Commandos are made to be a Soldier that can fill the role of 10. Gregor was a prime example. Commandos are formidable. And the Commando seen being eaten by the zillo likely was one of either 2 or four guarding the young Zillo before it escaped. (The ship was smaller than the one that captured the grown zillo needing less guards.) Killing the imperial crew leaving the commandos to be the last. Picked off one by one like 1979 Alien/1987 Predator due to their survival skills.

  • @Loki-pk6fz
    @Loki-pk6fz Жыл бұрын

    Honestly I think they are just using the armor at the base because it is effective.

  • @Equinox_NZ
    @Equinox_NZ Жыл бұрын

    It comes down to the Empire making the same mistake as the Jedi and not utilizing the Commandos in their intended role. They're meant to work as a 4 man team on covert OPs, plus theyre only really seen so far fighting heavily augmented clones with plot armor

  • @ArnavKhode
    @ArnavKhode Жыл бұрын

    All clones are strong in their hearts

  • @williamnewnham8976
    @williamnewnham8976 Жыл бұрын

    you realise that clone force 99 is a set of clone commandos to. (Excluding Omega)

  • @upyours75
    @upyours75 Жыл бұрын

    Perhaps the inhibitor chips effected the commandos too

  • @CommanderFoxclone1010
    @CommanderFoxclone1010 Жыл бұрын

    Y'know, Scorch might be "weak" because he isn't with other Delta Squad members... And also because of the chip

  • @deez001
    @deez001 Жыл бұрын

    The thing is the bad batch is also a highly elite fighting force. So they can compete with clone commandos.

  • @Wibbs
    @Wibbs Жыл бұрын

    the bad batch are an enhanced commando unit so it makes sense they’d be able to defeat commandos

  • @TherealManuel
    @TherealManuel Жыл бұрын

    these have to be regular conscripted commandos taught by gregor when he was captured

  • @DavidWilson-rm8ix
    @DavidWilson-rm8ix Жыл бұрын

    It took 2 stun blasts to take down the commando on the ship Echo raided in "Tipping Point"

  • @50Stone
    @50Stone Жыл бұрын

    I suggested elsewhere that the soldiers wearing the Katarn armour now (commando armour) are the surviving loyal Clone Troopers and not surviving Republic Commandoes. The few Commandoes emaining would be better used in leadership roles, as we see Scorch or still performing missions to which they are better suited, also most of the Katarn armour wearing troops we see are plain/unadorned and therefore probably new while the ex-Republic Commandoes armour had already been personnalised after years of use.

  • @ladderson_1
    @ladderson_1 Жыл бұрын

    I mean, having the Commandos carry blasters would be pointless since they don’t do anything against it.

  • @lock2434
    @lock2434 Жыл бұрын

    I don’t think they are weak. The Bad Batch are on the level of commandos if not a few steps above. Each of them excel in a specific category. The bad batch are basically equivalent to the delta squad but they probably have more potential in a team setting due to their inherent defects.

  • @yertnert2624
    @yertnert2624 Жыл бұрын

    Its to show the incompetency of the empire, because they didnt know it feeds off electricity because thats how it got so big and free in the clone wars, yet the weapons used to subdue the beast on malistare is electricity so to them they thought that it was they key to it, but they were wrong, it helps the idea that the Empire thinks they are perfect and order, but so much slips through the cracks of it.

  • @carlosminetti3685
    @carlosminetti3685 Жыл бұрын

    I mean the bad batch are also commandos and probably slightly better with enhancements. I would like to see the commandos do something formidable tho like takeout rebels

  • @darthxeno3434
    @darthxeno3434 Жыл бұрын

    First of all each commando is a dangerous trooper and can act alone they do not need a squad however having a team can make a major difference case and point all lore and when Gregor was in his final stand and before it he was taking out Droids and mind you he want even fully equipped with his commando gear…

  • @tommcduck7031
    @tommcduck7031 Жыл бұрын

    Maybe the zillo beast was so small at some point that the staff would have worked. But the soldier didnt know how much it grew

  • @stephen8805
    @stephen8805 Жыл бұрын

    It’s depressing how clone commandos are used more in bad batch than in the actual clone wars show. Should’ve been used in active missions more.

  • @Nghilifa
    @Nghilifa Жыл бұрын

    The problem is that they're just there for variety's sake, and thus they can't "shine" because then they'd probably foil our protagonists. It'd be better if they weren't there at all, thus presenting "hoardes" of Storm Troopers (and the tactical aptitude of their commanders) as their (the bad batch) main obstacle, rather than elite troops who can't "touch" our heroes due to the requirements of the plot.

  • @gilzineto
    @gilzineto Жыл бұрын

    True... however, their fucking design is brilliant

  • @cybernite60z98
    @cybernite60z98 Жыл бұрын

    I also am disappointed that they dont have their dc 17m blasters and instead use standard blaster carbines

  • @solastro5595
    @solastro5595 Жыл бұрын

    Disney be disney

  • @TheHuntersCantina
    @TheHuntersCantina Жыл бұрын

    Here’s what I’ll say: so far, the only way we’ve seen commandos in the bad batch so far, is in large numbers and quantities, and aren’t really pulling off “special” missions like they are designed for. For example, the empire is treating the commandos like the republic treated the commandos during the first battle of geonosis, where most of the commandos were wiped out because they were fighting in the battle that they didn’t receive training for

  • @tb8517
    @tb8517 Жыл бұрын

    Plot armor

  • @Willxdiana
    @Willxdiana Жыл бұрын

    plot armor

  • @Stringer7390
    @Stringer7390 Жыл бұрын

    I honestly think it’s that the commandos are used to more high stakes battles with little chance of survival. They’re trained to be the best of the best, not babysitting inexperienced recruits

  • @victordodai6311
    @victordodai6311 Жыл бұрын

    i feel like the chips made clones way worse. It's as if their skills were factory reset to standard clone skills

  • @renevalice3056
    @renevalice3056 Жыл бұрын

    Lots of plot armor makes them soft, and arc troopers usually suffer as well for story telling

  • @nicolaschaigneau2001
    @nicolaschaigneau2001 Жыл бұрын

    I'm kinda bothered by the number of clone commandos in the last episode and their use. Did the empire take the whole number of some of their best soldiers made to fight behind the lines and equipped with over the top Katarn armors and just use them as.. regular guards ?

  • @studclone
    @studclone Жыл бұрын

    i think of the training and of the new cloning system where they can clone clone commando's on an anhoter age the so maby is that the reason

  • @BaldMartin1Fan
    @BaldMartin1Fan Жыл бұрын

    It’s called plot armour They’re really good. It’s just the fact that they’re going up against the main characters

  • @CloneCombatEngineer3675
    @CloneCombatEngineer3675 Жыл бұрын

    They nerfed them hard

  • @EzekielDeLaCroix
    @EzekielDeLaCroix Жыл бұрын

    >charges against two people instead of keeping range or waiting for backup. >misses every shot even though he's getting closer >elite commando immediately gets tackled and wrestled like a fish out of water. Mace Windu was right to use them in as frontline assault troops cause if that's how they operate, that's all they're good for. It should be called Clone Trooper aim, not Stormtrooper aim. For God's sake, Obi-Wan, one of the greatest and most battle-hardened Jedi spoke of their accuracy and nobody even in the universe talks about Clones known for their aim and accuracy on a general level.

  • @Sniffed423
    @Sniffed423 Жыл бұрын

    No clone is weak

  • @darthxeno3434
    @darthxeno3434 Жыл бұрын

    No Disney just has a bad way of portraying elite level soldiers….. to help the “good guys” win

  • @runderkexmitecke7972
    @runderkexmitecke7972 Жыл бұрын

    Maybe its because of The Inhibitor Chip 🤷🏼

  • @Emma_2Banks
    @Emma_2Banks Жыл бұрын

    They’ve done to the Commandos what they’ve done to everyone. They over exposed them and made them weak. I hope they keep their hands off Boss and Fixer, and I really hope they don’t decide to bring Sev back in some stupid “no ones ever really gone” way. Filoni has been infected by Disney.

  • @pc_115

    @pc_115

    Жыл бұрын

    star wars fans blame everything on disney 💀

  • @Emma_2Banks

    @Emma_2Banks

    Жыл бұрын

    @@pc_115 maybe because they are the problem 💀

  • @ugiustuskeiserus8066

    @ugiustuskeiserus8066

    Жыл бұрын

    Well the Sev thing never officially happened in Canon yet so they could go an alternate route if they wanted to

  • @teamofone1219
    @teamofone1219 Жыл бұрын

    Maybe the older they get with the accelerated aging the less effective they become.

  • @bouncin2207
    @bouncin2207 Жыл бұрын

    They're the bad guys now, of course they are weaker.

  • @akumaghostblade1265
    @akumaghostblade1265 Жыл бұрын

    Quick question why did they empire nerf this spec ops unit so much? As in they took their gun and wrist gauntlet away.

  • @tengrisyesugei7995
    @tengrisyesugei7995 Жыл бұрын

    How many stun blasts did Scorch take again?

  • @ClonedGamer001
    @ClonedGamer001 Жыл бұрын

    I don't think so. So far only three commandos have actually been beaten in combat, and in all cases they were operating at a disadvantage. Scorch was a against four other commandos (at least two of whom had inherent genetic advantages), the other RC who got killed in the episode was pushing those same four who were in a defensive position, and clearly had incompetent troopers as backup, and the last was pit against a fucking Zillo Beast with nothing but a shock baton. In none of those circumstances were the odds in their favor.

  • @Thedeafnerd
    @Thedeafnerd Жыл бұрын

    They aren’t that weak, they may be Elite soldiers but because they were commandos and special doesn’t mean they were always unstoppable force, many of them were killed on the first battle of Geonosis because of Jedi’s poor leadership. Thus, the only strongest commando squads was Delta squad and Omega Squad.

  • @SOMA-gj4xc
    @SOMA-gj4xc Жыл бұрын

    IMO, clone commandos where so good coz of their "free will" and creative thinking, now that they are under Empire, they have been reduced to cool looking clanka, coz all they can do is blindly follow orders.

  • @shogunate6645
    @shogunate6645 Жыл бұрын

    Weak?! Hell no. MACE FREAKIN WINDU had trouble fighting the zillo beast so commandos have trouble seems fair. The bad batch are seen to be as skilled if not more than commandos so the should be able to fight a large number of them. Also I think there huge number of commandos seen on mt. Tantiss just show that the empire is making more of them or that whatever going on in tantiss requires better troops than your average ct.

  • @jangoboba420
    @jangoboba420 Жыл бұрын

    Simple answer, now the commando’s are “bad guy’s”, and are fighting our main guys with plot armor. Plus they’re literally fighting a squad of enhanced commandos. It’s really not that deep.

  • @Capt_boba7732
    @Capt_boba7732 Жыл бұрын

    I think the reason is because they are using DC-13 the normal clone gun and not there gun

  • @DaMarakuHD
    @DaMarakuHD Жыл бұрын

    But we have seen commandos being super effective. The bad batch are republic commandos kicking imperial commando’s asses. So its commando on commando fighting. And i get it technically the bad batch have ct numbers instead of cc but they where introduced as an experimental commando unit and they are each modeled somewhat after the characters of delta squad from the games. Stoic leader, goofy heavy demolition expert, nerdy techie, and few words deadly sniper.

  • @TheNerfplayer1642
    @TheNerfplayer1642 Жыл бұрын

    Well the bad batch is clone commandos too just enhanced with desirable qualities in order for them to be more effective in combat. I’d say because of the genetic makeup then are the superior clone commando squad we have seen so far and are far above regular clone commandos. The only squad that could give the bad batch a worthy fight is delta squad if they ever bring the rest of them back.

  • @blakedeslauriers5193
    @blakedeslauriers5193 Жыл бұрын

    The portrayal is a bad one that I hope Dave fixes soon.

  • @creakychair9387
    @creakychair9387 Жыл бұрын

    This is star wars. With the exception of TESB, its illegal for the empire to be competent at anything.

  • @DarkPilot_
    @DarkPilot_ Жыл бұрын

    I also think the commandos were pulled out of their teams and put in scenarios that they haven’t trained for. Like when the Jedi used commandos like normal infantry during the battle of Geonosis.

  • @JimmyTheGhost16
    @JimmyTheGhost16 Жыл бұрын

    I do t doubt that they are effective troopers, to be fair the show is putting them up against the bad batch, I know they aren’t all super soldiers but they also take on droids head on. I’m sure the bad batch know about they’re training and skills.

  • @MiguelRuiz-zq6vs
    @MiguelRuiz-zq6vs Жыл бұрын

    I mean I would like to point out that The Bad Batch is quite literally Commandos as well and have a 100% success rate of their missions. So you have badass operators vs badass operators and everytime the Bad Batch has fought Commandos the Commandos have done fair especially when you consider the Commandos have been largely alone or supported by TK Troopers. While fighting two or more members of the Bad Batch.

  • @Tradetek1
    @Tradetek1 Жыл бұрын

    Weak? They haven’t even done anything with the commandos to show them as weak lmao. They only been shown three times. First time was against the bad batch plus Gregor and it was already 1 commando vs 4 commandos since the bad batch are commandos. Then the 2nd time we see them was literally at the end of season 1 literally nothing bad to say on there and then the zillo beast episodes, still nothing to show that they are weak. Them losing to a zillo beast doesn’t tell anything lmao, a zillo beast would kill one of delta squad already lmao. Yea, the electro staff made literally no sense but it makes no difference, there’s no gun that could take the zillo beast out so the commando would have died anyways. Heck, none of the Jedi could defeat a zillo beast, they ended up having to rely on their army instead.

  • @enzoamore8971

    @enzoamore8971

    Жыл бұрын

    They keep forgetting Bad Batch are commandos too

  • @-SayWhatAgainMF-
    @-SayWhatAgainMF- Жыл бұрын

    This has been bugging me since commandos were introduced in the Bad Batch. Commandos are supposed to be on par with CF99 seeing how they're also technically a commando unit, and probably received the same training as their fellow commando units. The Bad Batch hasn't been the worst Star Wars show D+ has made, but it's still very much a D+ Star Wars show. Legends clone commandos and the Alpha ARC troopers were trained by Mandolorians and were the Republic's most badass spec ops units with unmatched as far as their skill set and combat effectiveness. To see them being used as cannon fodder like they're no better than the average stormtrooper is so disappointing and requires me to suspend my belief, preventing me from truly immersing myself in the show. I hope that they at least try and give some kind of explanation for why the imperial commandos were nerfed into oblivion.

  • @attilafekete7892
    @attilafekete7892 Жыл бұрын

    Congratulations, you realised what plot armor is. Commandos can be the most elite, best of the best, but if they come against a plot armored character aka a bad batch member, they will be just as weak as a stormtrooper.

  • @adamallen8787
    @adamallen8787 Жыл бұрын

    You gotta remember that before the first battle of geonosis there was only 10,000 clone commandos, after the battle around 5000 remained. If any died during the war the only way to replenish the numbers is to recruit gifted normal soldiers which by the bed would probably make up the majority especially after alot of mandalorian trained commandos defected sooooo that could explain the incompetency

  • @righteoustv5417
    @righteoustv5417 Жыл бұрын

    I don’t think they’re all supposed to be like the delta squad. You’ve got your weak links and top guys in the battalion of clone commandos but everyone’s perception of them seems to be that they’re unstoppable, which is dumb. The bad batch didn’t beat them, they escaped them and captured hunter. I’m sure if you put them next to regular clones they’d be seen as badasses. I’d say they’re fine, bad batch is just good at escaping. Order 66 also did wipe the clones minds in a way and don’t operate like they used to with individual personalities.

  • @JackAsh2081
    @JackAsh2081 Жыл бұрын

    Clearly you all didn’t play the game because they went down after like 30 seconds of fighting anything other than a B1 battle droid.😂😂 Even on the medium/normal difficulty.

  • @johnmorin7177
    @johnmorin7177 Жыл бұрын

    clone commandos are ok I LIKE TO SEE clone airborne trooper me like clone commandos it was good game story was very ok. would it make good tv shows no. bad Bach kill clone commandos almost. it is SCORCH why bad Bach not kill clone commandos SCORCH

  • @Cristo179
    @Cristo179 Жыл бұрын

    Idk why they showing us that clone commandos are just like other clone with other armor and a little bit more skilled. I imaginated them as the elite unit, skilled even more than BB or in the same lavel(i mean aiming and shooting). So unfortunetely I don't think they will be much of a threat to Bad Batch 😢

  • @BigBodyBobProductions
    @BigBodyBobProductions Жыл бұрын

    Its called plot armor and poor writing

  • @brantozavur2336
    @brantozavur2336 Жыл бұрын

    First!

  • @badfoody
    @badfoody Жыл бұрын

    they're not weak. the Bad Batch are ALSO commandoes. In fact they're the BEST team in the Republic

  • @calvinjones7101

    @calvinjones7101

    Жыл бұрын

    Idk about best team in the republic, out of commandos they are not the best, and out of the republic definitely not

  • @rcshadow8112
    @rcshadow8112 Жыл бұрын

    Dude, what do you mean? Gregor took them in half an army I would say commandos are still very formidable. Not to mention the clone commandos helped capture or recapture the Zillow beast there’s still formidable they’re not weak. This is a Zillo beast were talking about one of the toughest creatures in a galaxy to kill. I still don’t understand how you think that week because Zillow beasts are very formidable creatures.

Келесі