This one is gonna bring some haters on the channel... Everything in the video is my personal and honest opinion as a singer and vocal coach. Please be polite in the comment! Thank you 💚 𝗣𝗹𝗲𝗮𝘀𝗲 𝗦𝗨𝗕𝗦𝗖𝗥𝗜𝗕𝗘 𝘁𝗼 𝘀𝘂𝗽𝗽𝗼𝗿𝘁 𝗺𝘆 𝗰𝗵𝗮𝗻𝗻𝗲𝗹! 💚 ➡ tinyurl.com/y25ufe4x ‼𝗝𝗢𝗜𝗡 to get exclusive contents and amazing benefits! ➡ tinyurl.com/4v9bdehh Want to support my channel? Buy me a coffee ☕: tinyurl.com/jacksreaction 𝘛𝘶𝘳𝘯 𝘰𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦 "𝘊𝘊" 𝘣𝘶𝘵𝘵𝘰𝘯 𝘵𝘰 𝘳𝘦𝘢𝘥 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘴𝘶𝘣𝘵𝘪𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘴 𝘪𝘯 𝘺𝘰𝘶𝘳 𝘭𝘢𝘯𝘨𝘶𝘢𝘨𝘦! :) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Attention❗ I am a vocal coach and in this video I will make a commentary on vocal technique. It means that I will have to stop the video on several occasions to be able to analyze and comment on it. If you want to see the video without interruptions, I leave you the link to the original video below! CHAPTERS: 0:00 Intro 1:05 First reaction 5:24 Analysis and commentary ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 📽A new reaction every SUNDAY (première) and every WEDNESDAY here on the channel! ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ⏯Link to original video: kzread.info/dash/bejne/iqyY16mMmqSwc9I.htmlsi=9QqDxl-_U0CzuYYV 🔹Other Reactions (Angelina Jordan): kzread.info/head/PL964wPFv6in2SkuUquaLOJErOC19GK-uJ 🔹My personal channel (cover, singing lessons, personal projects): kzread.info 📧 My website: www.giacomorossi.org 📧 Extreme Mix Voice (EMV) Vocal Trainer: www.extrememixvoice.com

It was her arrangement. It was perfect for the occasion. She sang it the children of the peace prize recipient who is imprisoned. It was a great performance.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Thank you for the info and the comment 💚

@kevingood4644

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reactionan informed vocal coach should have known this before reacting..

I do appriciate your honesty Jack. It is though a possability I think, in this case, that your knowlege about technicalities in singing is taking over a bit too much. Angelina undoubtedly does quite a few unusual choises for this performance. You did mention it, - Angelina did dobbel up on the emotional side for this performance. There was basically at least 4 reasons for this: - Angelina`s childhood dream was to sing at the Nobel Peace Prize consert. This year (2023) iranien Narges Mohammadi won the prize, fighting for womens rigths and equality. - Angelina`s grandmother is iranien, so she is quite updated on womens situation in Iran, and that Narges Mohammadi is, and has been imprisoned for years, in Iran. - Therefor 17 year old Angelina got to sing for Narges` 17 year old twins, both present to receive the prize on their mothers behalf, who they have not seen for 9 years. - Why did Angelina choose this song? As I`m sure you know, this originally was a song for the movie "Unchained" from 1955, about a prisoner longing to be with his loved ones. This is what lies behind all of Angelinas choises for this performance. As we all know that impeccable breath-controll is one of Angelina`s many forses, as it comes to singing, we are aware that Angelina sometimes may "play around" with it, and it happens that even at studio recordings she wants her breath to be heard more than usual. We also understand that in this case it was no "playing around". She was emotional, and she wanted it to show. Because this time it was the right thing to do, artisticly and emotionally. This was her choisees for this occation. And the orcestra supported her all the way, as thay contrasted her with the big build up moments, and she still took it down and kept it low and subtle almost through it all, untill the last powerfull end. You might still see it different, and we can respect you for that. To me though, and many others, this is a pure masterpiece, and one of her best performances. I`m looking forward to meny more reactions from you, and hope that you might get to know and love Angelina even better on the way. Angelina has so much to bring to the world.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Thank you for the comment, this is very touchful, but I deliberately inform myself little or nothing about the performances I go to listen to, precisely because I want to give a genuine and sincere reaction, and secondly because I don't want to be influenced by external factors. I listen and analyze the performance for what it is: a singing performance. All the surrounding factors can help to understand, but not to justify such a performance, in my opinion. However, I remain of the opinion that Angelina is very good artistically.

I appreciate your honesty Jack, I think you made a lot of valid technical points. I do not agree though that she lacks breath control here, what she is doing is deliberate and well controlled, although it may not be to your taste, or be "proper vocal technique". You alluded to it in your analysis, she is trying to evoke the uncomfortable emotions of sadness, longing and desperation. The woman she is honouring is a political prisoner and I believe at the time was on a hunger strike. To me, she sang it this way to communicate a tragic story to listeners, not to impress vocal coaches.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Maybe you're right. Thank you for the comment!

@kevingood4644

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reactionHe is.

@francescogalesso1880

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction Angelina penso sia l'unica cantante al mondo capace di contestualizzare una cover. La canzone rappresenta il lamento di un carcerato. E lei sta cantando per una carcerata davanti ai suoi figli. Il suo ansimare è voluto per enfatizzare questo lamento.

@jacks_reaction

Ай бұрын

@@francescogalesso1880 non saprei, continua a sembrarmi una spiegazione forzata per giustificare una performance palesemente sottotono.. ma magari mi sbaglio io

I couldn't disagree more with your reaction to this performance. Other vocal coaches think her breath control is amazing & I think the last few notes at the end are some of the most beautiful sounds I've ever heard. It's one of my favorite performances by her. You are the only reactor I've seen that wasn't blown away by this performance.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Thank you for the comment. I think - maybe - other vocal coaches on KZread are looking for new easy subscribers.. this is not my case. Anyway I think she is an amazing artist, that is why I expected more from this performance! But this doesn't change my opinion of her talent.

@francescogalesso1880

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction Dovresti aver capito che Angelina è un genio con il pieno controllo su quello che fa. Questa performance è stata studiata. Era l'omaggio al premio Nobel, una donna iraniana carcerata. E la nonna di Angelina, che è anche la sua musa è iraniana, la bambina povera con cui ha fatto il famoso patto delle scarpe, dei piedi scalzi era iraniana e ha discusso con lei in quella lingua. Già la scelta della canzona che racconta la storia di un carcerato spiega molte cose. Il suo ansimare non è altro che enfatizzare emotivamente il lamento del carcerato e lo fa davanti ai figli della donna in carcere.

@walterstroup8545

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction Fine you have your own thoughts that are informed by your expertise. That said, I don't really understand why you would accuse "other vocal coaches" who may disagree with you (that is to say, ALL of them as far as I can tell) of simply "looking for new easy subscribers." Would it be fair for them to criticize you as someone looking for "easy subscribers" by trashing artists' interpretive choices simply to prove your 'honesty' bona fides? I would like to believe this would be as unfair as the flailing/defensive/dismissive (my opinion) accusation you've made against them.

❤️ it, Angelina the next Mega Superstar of the World 👍🥰❤️

Obviously you are bothered by the shoulders being raised everytime she took a breath. Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey and many great artists has done the same movements. Angelina and her choices were based on the life story of the recipient and her children. A story worth reading about and then listen to Angelina sing because she gave one of her best heart felt performances anyone can ask for. Angelina has been doing this for a decade and I assure you that she has taken advice as to how to care and keep healthy her vocals. She has great breath control otherwise she would have been done by now. I don't expect all good comments for Angelina but she deserves credit where credit is due.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Thank you for the polite comment. It's not only about the movement of the shoulders, but also how noisy her breath is

@AbbieCrescendo

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction That was probably due to the type of microphone used which picks up all sounds and special effects Angelina sings with to make you feel the importance of her message.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion and I respect yours even though I think this is the best version I have ever heard (and I’m pretty old!). Her arrangement suited the occasion perfectly. May I suggest that you read about the recipient of the award, Narges Mohammadi, then read about the reason the original song was written. You might not change your opinion but you will have a greater understanding as to why she performed it the way she did.

Don't forget she's a great storyteller and she decided to sing it in this way for the sad occasion of the noble price winner. It should be sounds very sad and painful with a non perfect voice 😢 I think we felt the emotions better in this way ❤

With all due respect there is only so much value analysis can give to an art that for me is to do the opposite to free us from such mental restraints so we are free to feel and this requires feeling with the ear of the heart and also singing with the sound of the heart , so one might find human flaws from a human perspective yet also divine perfection because you experience with the inner world , what makes Angelina unique is her ability to trust her own heart in a way very few can for me she is an experience like no other artist , she is a pioneer ,

Angelina got a awesome voice ❤

Respectfully,Angelina got an emotional standing ovation from a cultured,educated audience,including Narges Mohammadi's children,used to the best of everything including music.Her greatest ability is to emotionally touch audiences,especially live.The technical things could criticize many of the greats,but never lessen their impact.

This was arranged out of respect for the Peace Prize recipients on a very solemn occasion, also sung with more respect to the actual meaning of the song, it is about imprisonment. It could be sung with all the tricks, embellishments, dazzling runs, belting, well all of that, occasion like this calls for respect and restraint which she showed, the whole arrangement was beautiful and very fitting.

Hello again, Jack! I always appreciate an honest and well founded reaction, like you always bring. That being said, regarding this performance I strongly disagree with some of the things you said. You DID touch base on what I personally believe was the reason for her choices here, namely her emphasis on conveying the feelings that this song and lyrics should. I believe her way of breathing here more than anything else was meant as exclamation points throughout, and not the result of poor breathing technique. If there is one thing Angelina traditionally has been known and praised for, it would be her excellent breath control. I will just briefly try to recap some of the background for the performance, to see if it can sway your opinion in any way 🙂 Last year's Nobel Peace Prize winner was Iranian Narges Mohammadi, who is imprisoned in Iran for her women's rights work in the country. She was sentenced to 35 years in prison, in addition to receiving 130 whip lashes. Narges has a twin daughter and son, both 17, the same age as Angelina at the time of the performance, and they are living in exile with their uncle in Paris, France. Narges haven't seen them since they were 12 years old, so very much in tune with what the song is talking about. Her children came to Sweden to receive the prize on their mother's behalf, and they also came to this Nobel Peace Prize concert here in Oslo, Norway. They were sitting only a few meters away from Angelina during her performance, and it must have been very emotional for all parties, Angelina included. At the end of the performance you can see her turn toward them, touching her heart and smiling. What makes this performance EXTRA special is the fact that Angelina's absolutely biggest inspiration in life, and the main reason for Angelina being who and what she is, is her grandmother, Mery Zamani. Mery Zamani is Iranian, just like Narges Mohammadi, and I can imagine the conversations Angelina must have had with her grandmother and the rest of her family regrading the topic of women's rights in Iran. Mery herself was considered a child prodigy, albeit in writing and art. She went to Japan at a young age to study art, where she met her husband, who was ALSO very influential in Angelina's life. Angelina's original "Million Miles" was dedicated to him, after he passed when Angelina was 13 years old. Anyway, these are SOME of the reasons why I believe Angelina opted to sing the song the way she did. She did it in the absolutely most solemn, respectful and elegant way she knew how, and I personally think she did an exceptional job at it. I have been following Angelina for 10 years now, and I rank this performance among her very best, perhaps THE best. (But to be honest, I think I still have her performances of "My Funny Valentine" at age 16 and "You Say" at age 15 just slightly ahead 😊 Have a great week, my friend! Much love from Norway ♥♥♥♥♥

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Thank you for the polite comment! I think the story behind is very touchful, but I'm just a singing teacher and I deliberately inform myself little or nothing about the performances I go to listen to, precisely because I want to give a genuine and sincere reaction, and secondly because I don't want to be influenced by external factors. I listen and analyze the performance for what it is: a singing performance. All the surrounding factors can help to understand, but not to justify such a performance, in my opinion. However, I remain of the opinion that Angelina is very good artistically.

@poolhallshark

2 ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction 🙂👍❤

@kevingood4644

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reactionBig mistake.

Jack, you are not the first vocal coach who has had a problem with Angelina's artistic choice of employing "audible breaths". She uses this same technique on I Have Nothing. Since that was a studio recording, they certainly would have had the ability to eliminate that sound if it wasn't intentional. Angelina will at times choose to use vocal techniques that vocal coaches try to correct their students out of using. Some singers sing to highlight the singer while others choose to keep the focus on the song. Angelina will more often opt for the later. I believe that Angelina intentions were to convey the fragility of the character on the edge of breaking. Personally, I don't see this as a failure or a poor performance but rather a delicate masterpiece.

Thank you for your reaction. I have read your remarks down here, but I still think you have missed the boat with this reaction.

I've seen you react to her on several occations pointing out the mastery of her art as well as her highly developed skill level while performing... so now, it's at least confusing (contradictory) to hear you questioning her breath control capacity and her ability to completely control her falsetto with her diaphragm; both essential features for any decent singer. For a coach it should take no more than a couple of reactions to assess all her competency levels and skills. So one moment she is the best and the next she bearly knows how to sing. Problem is that lack of consistency takes away credibility!

@jacks_reaction

Ай бұрын

Thank you for your comment, I think that even the best singers in the world can have a bad day and make bad performances, but they're still great artists. Maybe this is the case. I'm just analyzing THIS performance here.

I will be polite. You have no idea why she was there singing this song and in this particular way. It was at the Nobel Peace Prize Award Ceremony and the committee was honoring an Iranian woman in prison for speaking out about the rights of women. The woman was once being considered for release from prison but under the condition she stop talking about the rights of women. She met with her family (husband and children (twins, a boy and a girl) and she told them although it would be wonderful for the family to be reunited she reminded them how strongly she felt about her views and said it would be impossible for her to agree to those conditions. So, she remains in prison. This event took place in Oslo, where Angelina was born and lived her very early years and the orchestra is a famous Norwegian company, KORK, and Angelina had played with them in her earlier years. And, it must be said Angelina is Norwegian, Swedish, Japanese and Iranian (her famous grandma Mery is Iranian). During rehearsals for the presentation of the song Angelina broke down crying she was so moved by the story of the woman and she was worried she would start to cry during the performance. But, she didn't and was masterful in her delicate approach to singing this classic song. By the way, The woman's (Narges Mohammadi) two teenage children were sitting right in front of Angelina during the performance and all in all it was a wonderful event to honor Narges Mohammadi by Angelina and, of course, the Nobel Peace Prize Organization. Angelina's breathiness was very intentional and I'm shocked for as many times as you have heard Angelina that you couldn't understand it was intentional. Perhaps, now that you understand the story behind the event and the reason she chose this song to sing, things will become clearer to you. If you listen to this again, personally, you will feel the emotion in Angelina's voice. I believe it was a wonderful performance and a striking moment.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Thank you for the comment, this is very touchful, but I deliberately inform myself little or nothing about the performances I go to listen to, precisely because I want to give a genuine and sincere reaction, and secondly because I don't want to be influenced by external factors. I listen and analyze the performance for what it is: a singing performance. All the surrounding factors can help to understand, but not to justify such a performance, in my opinion. However, I remain of the opinion that Angelina is very good artistically.

@kevingood4644

Ай бұрын

Beautifully written and utterly correct.

@kevingood4644

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reactionGoing into any reaction without background reading can lead to big mistakes. Information is power!

@RobertDeMartin

Ай бұрын

@@kevingood4644 Kevin he has no idea what she is doing. It's out of his league. He can only critique in a way which he has been schooled to know. She is way beyond him. He actually didn't remark completely favorably to her closing spectacular notes. He can probably help some young singers but even those who were listening to Angelina must be wondering, "What in the world is he talking about? She was wonderful!"

@kevingood4644

Ай бұрын

@@RobertDeMartin If anyone questions Angelina’s breath control my eyes widen! I’ve never come across a vocalist with anywhere near approaching Angelina’s control over everything she sings..

Tra l'altro il video ufficiale è ambientato in una bellissima chiesa con Toby al piano e un brevissimo violoncellista

Certainly entitled to your opinion. To be clear, you are the ONLY vocal coach, in the world, of dozens, who had this opinion. As a vocal coach, please present one of your students performances of this song that was better.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Thank you for the comment. I think - maybe - other vocal coaches on KZread are looking for new easy subscribers.. this is not my case. Anyway I think she is an amazing artist, that is why I expected more from this performance! But this doesn't change my opinion of her talent.

@shodanrich3317

2 ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction I look at your video history. Morisette, Dimash, Diana etc. Same as the other coaches. Challenge stands for one of your students. Chow.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

@@shodanrich3317 this is not a race. Singing is not a competition.

@shodanrich3317

2 ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction NGT, AGT, BGT, Am Idol, The Voice, Grammys, Billboard top 100, Recording contracts etc. Every singer competes against other singers for their livlyhood, fame and fortune.

@chiararaimondi4425

2 ай бұрын

Ciao Giacomo. Premetto che non seguo più di tanto questa cantante e quindi non ho un termine di paragone con altre sue performances. Premetto inoltre che non essendo una vocal coach non ho il titolo per dare un parere tecnico in merito. Posso però affermare che questa esibizione mi ha messo un po' di ansia 😅...alla fine avevo persino l'impressione di avere un leggero affanno...Siccome tu mi dici che è un'ottima interprete, e io ci credo, molto probabilmente, come hai specificato correttamente tu, le ragioni di tale interpretazione possono essere molteplici e tutte condivisibili per quanto mi riguarda. Tengo comunque molto a sottolineare che le reaction e le analisi delle performances fatte da professionisti come lo sei tu, servono a dare una valutazione che non necessariamente deve essere totalmente o parzialmente positiva per accapparrarsi consensi. Qui si tratta di essere onesti con se stessi e con chi ti segue. Poi, ovviamente, si ha la facoltà di concordare o meno. Ti stimo per la tua trasparenza e la tua estrema educazione nel porti verso i tuoi followers (di cui faccio orgogliosamente parte). Grazie, come sempre, @jacks_reaction.🙏

If you are not going to be honest, then why are we here for? Is it possible that because of the reason she is performing here she wanted it to be more airy more emotional, no matter the sounds of her inhale. Do you think it was a performance issue? I think for the amount of her doing that were so much, I think everything was intentional. Though there are certainly people who don't like that, and like more of a clean vocal performance. You might be right, but something tells me that she did it intentional, knowing her for years and always focusing on the emotional side of a performance (plus her being a jazz singer, there are less rules in how clean you should sing). I think you might be bothered by that? And maybe like more of a clean vocal? Let me know what you think I would love to hear what you think about this. Do you still stand by your opinion? Knowing everything I said here? I am not questioning your expertise but rather maybe you didn't evaluate everything before stating your opinion, which can happen. In any case, I respect you even more for being honest, thanks.

@jacks_reaction

Ай бұрын

Thank you for your comment, I think that even the best singers in the world can have a bad day and make bad performances, but they're still great artists. Maybe this is the case. I'm just analyzing THIS performance here.

@TroyArchAngel

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction Fair enough. I still think she may have made this as a style choice of singing to make it sound like she is crying. Or could be her really being emotional while singing this. I can't picture her doing rehearsals before this and then perform it with that much errors. But you might be right too and like I said, I respect you being honest. Because there are a lot of reaction channels that just like everything and won't dare to point errors. Looking forward for more reactions to Angelina. God Bless

@kevingood4644

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reactionIt’s not a bad performance…quite the opposite.

Totalmente en desacuerdo con su análisis, la forma elegida por Angelina para esta actuación se daba en un contexto especial, ya que los hijos de la ganadora de este premio nobel se encontraban presente, y su madre esta presa en Iran por defender los derechos de las mujeres, por tanto su perfomance fue, en este caso moderada. Pienso con respeto le digo, que primero debiera informarse del contexto de la presentación, para asi enfocar su analisis en ese contexto. Y no se moleste en responderme, no es necesario.

@joetomcat7800

2 ай бұрын

I think you can even see the previous conversation with the children of Narges Mohammadi on her beautiful face. She has always been full of respect and empathy. The performance could not have been more appropriate.

mmmm also Atemlos sieht anders aus , Angelina schaut völlig entspannt in die Runde nach dem langen Finish

Grazie per l'analisi Giacomo. Non sono molto d'accordo, ma è giusto che le opinioni non siano univoche. La sua sensibilità nella scelta e in particolare nell'interpretazione della canzone per questa cerimonia è secondo me molto "angiolinesca", non dimenticare che sua nonna è iraniana e Angelina ha probabilmente visitato il paese da bambina e la sua connessione con il paese non è solo di facciata. La scelta di attuare un'arrangiamento più intimo ed emotivo è stata fatta per renderla più adatta all'emozione dell'omaggio alla dolorosa storia di Narges Mohammadi, la "vincitrice" del premio Nobel ed ai suoi figli che erano a ricevere il premio in sua rappresentanza obbligata vista la sua prigionia! E'stato bello anche nel vedere e ascoltare Angelina cantare in modo così incredibilmente maturo e affascinante a 7 anni di distanza dall'ultima volta, nello stesso studio e sicuramente anche con alcuni dei musicisti che l'hanno accompagnata da bambina, quando muoveva i primi passi verso il suo futuro musicale. Angelina è probabilmente l'unica cantante che a soli 17 anni ha già cantato in 2 diverse occasioni alle celebrazioni dei Premi Nobel per la Pace.💛🧡❤

Anch'io voglio essere onesto con te: quando si fa il tuo lavoro ritengo che sia di fondamentale importanza conoscere il contesto in cui si svolge un evento. Da tale conoscenza si deducono quindi le risposte ad alcune delle domande che ti e ci fai,si capiscono meglio le scelte e le si collocano all'interno di un contesto che ne rivela la portata. Tutto questo ti è evidentemente mancato; a chi è stato assegnato il nobel per la pace? Per quale motivo? Di che nazionalità è questo vincitore? Cosa è accaduto prima che cantasse? Di quali origini è la cantante? Sono solo alcune delle domande le cui risposte avrebbero potuto aiutarti a capire l'esibizione. Affermare poi che ha dei problemi da risolvere con la respirazione completa il quadro di una analisi del tutto deficitaria da chi sostiene di averla già ascoltata tante volte. Un infortunio,capita. Mi auguro in futuro meno approssimazione e più conoscenza. Buon lavoro.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Ti ringrazio per il commento, ma ci tengo a precisare che il mio lavoro è l'insegnante di canto, o per essere ancora più precisi "insegnante di tecnica vocale". Io deliberatamente mi informo poco e niente delle esibizioni che vado ad ascoltare, proprio perché voglio dare una reaction genuina e sincera, e in secondo luogo perché non voglio essere condizionato da fattori esterni. Ascolto e analizzo la performance per quello che è: un'esibizione canora. Tutti i fattori di contorno possono aiutare a capire, ma non a giustificare una performance del genere, a mio avviso. Rimango dell'idea comunque che Angelina artisticamente sia molto brava.

@enzaovince

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction si,so che si preferisce ascoltare senza avere informazioni per reagire in modo autentico e questa è cosa buona. D'altra parte le condizioni particolari di questa esibizione,in cui alcune tue valutazioni slegate dal contesto hanno indubbiamente una valenza,abbisognavano di un approfondimento contestuale. Ad esempio: Angelina poco prima aveva pianto,forse parlando coi gemelli che le hanno raccontato la vicenda della madre tutt'ora chiusa in carcere per la sua lotta per l'emancipazione delle donne Iraniane. Poi c'era la stanchezza per il lungo volo da Los Angeles ad Oslo,le scarne prove fatte a ridosso dell'esibizione e la sua grande sensibilità ed empatia che,trattandosi del paese natale della nonna oltre che suo di origine, ne ha condizionato la proverbiale serenità. Questo contesto rivela la grande sofferenza e la magnifica reazione,sia pure con tutti i difetti da te sottolineati,di una ragazzina di 17 anni alle prese con un dramma difficile da immaginare. Ti stimo,sono iscritto al tuo canale da tempo e conosco la tua onestà intellettuale la stessa che,ritengo,dovrebbe farti riflettere sul complessivo giudizio precedente alla luce di quanto ora conosci. Un abbraccio.

@jacks_reaction

Ай бұрын

@@enzaovince Ti ringrazio per la risposta, certamente conoscendo questi retroscena possiamo capire meglio il contesto e dare delle "attenuanti" ad Angelina. Sicuramente non è facile cantare in quelle condizioni...

Caro Giacomo, ho sempre apprezzato le tue reazioni e ticonsidero ancora uno dei migliori reattori di Angelina. Ma da collega professionista dell'insegnamento musicale da più di quaranta anni, ritengo che questa volta tu abbia preso una cantonata, scambiando precise scelte stilistiche per deficienza di ossigeno e scarso controllo della respirazione. Ma ti voglio bene lo stesso...

@jacks_reaction

Ай бұрын

Ti ringrazio per il commento e per il rispetto con cui hai posto la tua visione, se posso rispondere però ci terrei a sottolineare che al di là della tecnica, ho trovato poco efficaci le scelte stilistiche che ha adottato in questo brano.. detto tra noi, ho fatto davvero fatica ad arrivare a fondo dell'esibizione. Non ha sviluppi, è sempre sottotono, poco convinta e con pochissime variazioni dinamiche.. la canzone originale è molto più interessante. Detto questo, rimane la mia personale opinione che può non essere condivisa, ma vedo tanti che difendono la performance di Angelina a spada tratta solo per partito preso.. se valutiamo l'esibizione in sé, è oggettivamente una delle meno efficaci da parte sua. Questo non toglie nulla alla sua bravura e profondità artistica!

@giuseppeurna1986

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction Non condivido la sua risposta. Non aggiungo altro

Devi considerare come attenuanti che prima dell’esibizione era in preda ad una crisi di pianto per l’emozione ( dal trucco rigato si nota) 17 anni non espansivissima di carattere in una cerimonia importante…….

😀😀😀😀😀

Voglio anche segnalarti una nuova canzone scritta da Angelina insieme a Toby Gad Bad Valentine che non è ancora uscita ufficialmente ma c'è un'anteprima autorizzata da Toby Gad cantata dal vivo in un locale A mio avviso è strepitosa

que equivocado por favor

Ciao Giacomo! Non so se lo sapevi e se hai seguito, ma di recente sono andati in onda i nuovi concerti evento de Il Volo. Dato che è il tuo preferito dei tre, sarebbe bello se facessi una reaction alla cover di "The show must go on" cantata da Ignazio... Personalmente seguo i ragazzi da tanti anni, ma ogni volta rimango stupita dalle loro performance ❤️‍🔥

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Grazie mille del commento e della richiesta! Show must go on è forse la mia canzone preferita dei Queen quindi sarei molto curioso di sentire la versione di Ignazio.. mi hai dato un'idea per i prossimi video, grazie!

@danielaperani8467

2 ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction mi associo anch'io alla richiesta, aspetto la tua reazione.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

@@danielaperani8467 grazie mille 💚 credo la registrerò a breve perché sono molto curioso

I think your reaction is spot on. I love Angelina. I thought the mmmm was used to much. I thought she ran out of air several times. This is highly unusual for her as she can hold a note forever. The ending of the song was beautiful.. It seemed like her voice did not open up until the very end and then she was still a bit out of air. You are the expert in this arena. I would not want you to say a singer's singing is fantastic if it is not. If you did this, I would not want to listen to your comments. Thank you for critiquing this performance with great kindness.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Thanks a lot for the comment 💚

Hello Jack. Good reaction and bravo for telling it as you hear it. I'm not sure why this rendition is recommended by all the Angels in preference to AJ's Portsmouth performance of the same song. It's not awful, just lacklustre. Context and all that I know. To be honest, think the orchestra is the real star here. To me, Angelina of late, is a bit all "over the place". Don't know if she is trying to become more radio-friendly (commercial imperatives and all that) but her voice seems to be going through a change as well. If you are interested here is the Portsmouth version: kzread.info/dash/bejne/qaV-ybx_fburdqg.htmlfeature=shared. Sound quality a modicum off due to it being fan curated (Big Angie Fan and friends) but it is still top shelf and captures Angie at her best. Cheers.

@jacks_reaction

Ай бұрын

Thanks a lot for the comment! I will listen to that version too. Have a nice day

I'm not a hater, you don't know Angelina very well, and very little respect.....as you didn't start at the front or finish the ending.......boring gibberish......

Sei bravo e competente, ma devi capire che non sei tu a poter insegnare ad Angelina come cantare semmai il contrario. Qui il suo respiro corto, il suo ansimare è voluto. Questa è arte, che va oltre la semplice tecnica. Spiego. Questo era uno spettacolo in onore al premio Nobel per la pace, una donna iraniana carcerata, eseguito davanti ai figli. La scelta di Angelina è caduta non a caso su una canzone dove un carcerato racconta la sua storia. Lei qui sta interpretando il dramma del carcerato che parla ai figli, un lamento che il genio lo comunica con il respiro corto e l'ansimare. Ha fatto la stessa canzone abbastanza fedele a quella dei Righteous Brothers senza ansimare a 8-9 anni la trovi qui kzread.info/dash/bejne/qXue07qxgcWsl6Q.html

E tu saresti un competente di musica?Ma mi faccia il piacere.....Direbbe un grande comico italiano.

@jacks_reaction

Ай бұрын

Grazie per questo commento illuminante! Se insieme a questo può allegare il suo curriculum, mi può gentilmente dimostrare che quello che dice è supportato da anni di studio, esattamente come faccio io. Il mio lo trova pubblicamente sul mio sito web.

@antoniomaurogiovanni1276

Ай бұрын

@@jacks_reaction che Dio mi scampi dal suo curriculum.Secondo te per esprimere un giudizio sui gusti musicali bisogna essere come Mozart....... Almeno.Ma mi rifaccia il piacere,presuntuoso.

@jacks_reaction

Ай бұрын

@@antoniomaurogiovanni1276 Mi scusi, lei arriva dal nulla a offendere me e la mia professionalità sotto un mio video e sarei io il presuntuoso? La gente come lei proprio non conosce né il rispetto né l'educazione. Buona giornata.

I, for one, did not agree at all with your reaction, and as such it diminished the interpretation that Angelina gave for the occasion. Good luck in future endeavors, but in future reactions, if I watch them at all, try to include critical elements in a more balanced way.

A mio avviso hai pienamente ragione Non è certamente una buona esibizione Per rientrare in sintonia con lei dovresti ascoltare l'ultima performance , appena uscita. Canta if i were a boy insieme a Toby gad , coautore della canzone del 2008 e resa famosa da Beyoncé. Tornerai subìto in sintonia

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Grazie mille del commento e del suggerimento, andrò a sentirla con piacere!

She did seem a bit off to me also, but perhaps she was just very emotional and singing more with more emotion then technique.

@jacks_reaction

2 ай бұрын

Maybe you're right! Thanks for the comment 💚

Ciao jack non sono pienamente d'accordo con lei sulla esibizione di Angelina. Nessuno mette in dubbio sulla sua onestà ma non condivido come lei l'abbia sentita sfiatare. Anche io so di canto e le posso dire che al 95% e stata fantastica e un 5% e saltata un pò fuori vocale. Dal all'orecchio di chi non capisce il vocale non se ne rende conto, quindi questa interpretazione e fantastica. Da premettere che il suo stile musicale e Jazz. sol e blues.