According to Wikipedia: "Japanese blogger Kota Yamano found the original source of the photograph in the Archives in the National Diet Library Digital Collection. The original source of the photo was a Japanese travel guide published in October 1935, implying that the photograph was taken in 1935 or before, and thus would be unrelated to Earhart and Noonan's 1937 disappearance"

@alanmcneill2407

11 ай бұрын

YES!! The photo was a co incidental likeness of the two fliers, taken 2 years before Earhart's flight. Gardner Island has too much evidence to not be the sight where she landed. A heel from a shoe, a shoe of the type and brand she wore, the cosmetic jar, the pen knife, Noonan's sextant box, a piece of aluminum that was like what was on the plane and the SOS heard in Florida from Earhart that mentioned the "Norchester City", a ship that was wrecked at Gardner Island. Her radio signal gave off harmonic radio waves that bounced off the ionosphere, and down to Florida. The girl who heard Amelia said she knew it was her voice, and that of a man who went crazy and was trying to take the microphone away from Earhart, the girl wrote down everything Earhart said. Navy pilots said they saw signs of habitation on Gardner island, without realizing there had been no inhabitants there for many years. Most researchers believe Gardner island was where she ended up.

@ElectricVehiclesAreGoodF-ti7xd

10 ай бұрын

Whatever the outcome we need to worry how we are going to end up. Many bigger mysteries exist

@RobertLack

9 ай бұрын

The photo is from ONE book in the Japanese Government archives. There are not hundreds of these books or thousands, there is just one of these books. It is not bound together like a normal book with the publishing date, it is a book with medal prongs that can easily be taken apart with a page added to it with the photo. How do they say it is from 1935? There is an ink stamp in the back of the book, like a librarians stamp that says 1935. Easy to fake this. The Marshall Island government said the dock they are standing on wasn't built until 1936 so the photo can't be from 1935. Many eye witnesses place them on Jaluit Island and then on Saipan. No eye witnesses place her and Noonan on Gardner Island.

im 54 and i remember this coming out in the 70s. japan denied everything. they had a show on tv about this with interviews with natives talking about the execution of blonde pilot and 2 men. now there are pictures.

@solitairesmith3553

7 жыл бұрын

maybe same situation as pilot gary powers shot down spying over Russia

@Tojoj22

7 жыл бұрын

Times are repeating 2017 is the new 70s

@AvengerII

7 жыл бұрын

Japan will NEVER admit anything they did anything wrong in World War II. It's not their policy, it's not what they teach in their history books. Individual Japanese historians, soldiers, and a few politicians have been honest about the Imperial Government and military activities before and during World War II but the general Japanese government line is that they were victims in World War II. It infuriates everybody else in the region when the documentation so obviously shows otherwise. If that weren't enough, you have thousands of survivors -- POWs, civilians, comfort women, etc. -- who are still alive to testify to the fact. I have no doubt the Japanese Navy could have captured Earhart and Noonan. There are things about this story that are screwball from the American end: who funded the trip, the government support along the way, the airstrip on Howland Island that was basically unuseable, and scenarios suggesting that the final radio communiques were either a comedy of errors (failure to share radio wavelengths for direct communications in the final stretch) OR scripted to throw off anybody who wasn't in the know about a secret mission. I think the analogy to Gary Powers is closer to the truth than the official US government line. If something (this photo) FINALLY leaked out that demonstrates the storyline that she ended up in Saipan (in captivity) is the actual history, great. If not, well then it doesn't depend on just photo. There are too many people who saw events independently of each other that have corroborating stories. In addition, we have leaked documents from the FDR administration and later reports that clearly support the Saipan scenario more than this crash-and-sink business or the TIGHAR castaway movie script. It's been 80 years... It's about darn time the reality of the case gets disclosed.

@solitairesmith3553

7 жыл бұрын

AvengerII no one has ever said it better than you. thank you

@shanayawagh2552

7 жыл бұрын

I love the way you put your point across. We can't only blame the Japanese. The photo was found in the US archives so somebody in US knew about Amelia Earhart. I just hope that both the governments put their ego aside and get the truth out.

Amelia’s plane lost fuel crashed into the water. They drowned and were eaten by fish. The plane is now being used as a home for a school of fish. Also that photo was taken 2 years before their disappearance.

@kimmyjohnny31

4 жыл бұрын

MaximaL_SchnappS :-: Humans cant be eaten by normal reed dwellers nor can they eat a aluminum plane.

@dirtytreerat14

4 жыл бұрын

The Flat Earther Hunter sharks are fish though

@kimmyjohnny31

4 жыл бұрын

MaximaL_SchnappS :-: Sharks are fishes yes sorry.

@edwardeverson7039

4 жыл бұрын

No !!!!

@chiasanzes9770

3 жыл бұрын

Another brainwashed American: YOU.

this photo has amelia, the navigator, and the plane? that sounds way too good to be true. if it is real it would be a miracle find

@spartanumismatics8165

7 жыл бұрын

I have to agree, but its reaching to say in the least. Its all circumstantial.

@gavinreid8351

7 жыл бұрын

Xian the photograph has been misinterpreted. It can not be Earhart. It was taken 10 years too early.

@AvengerII

7 жыл бұрын

gavin Reid -- wrong. Even the Japanese source said the photo was taken in 1935. HARDLY 10 years too early. Earhart went missing in the 1937. Two, three years difference? It still raises the question. WHY was what appears to be an earlier generation copy (if not the original copy of the photo) in the US ONI files? The question now is is the Japanese blogger source reliable. HE has to be checked out, too. If you're going to call the conclusions of the program into question, make sure the guy raising the flag is also honest, too. It's not as if Japan doesn't have reasons to hide the facts of its pre-World War II activities, too, right? If you understood what Japan did in the Marshalls prior the outbreak of war with the US, then you'd understand why they have to be questioned. They HID a lot during that period... They also DIDN'T allow the US Navy to search the Marshalls for any possible traces of Earhart because they were establishing a military presence in the area. They were building bases and fortifications illegally in the area.

@semperxian

7 жыл бұрын

thanks gavin i just heard about that. i knew it couldnt be

@clemensJB

6 жыл бұрын

gavin Reid 4 years. Published in a book 1935.

Japan has some explaining to do.

@JDemen82

7 жыл бұрын

Qwen R All those involved are dead.

@SugoiEnglish1

7 жыл бұрын

How do you know? Do tell?

@Daneelro

7 жыл бұрын

Rather, Discovery should have done their homework. Thanks to a blogger bothering to do an archive search, now we know the documentary makers made waaay too many conclusions from a photo they didn't bother to trace to its original publication - which was in 1935...

@samjam2376

7 жыл бұрын

Qwen R I think the producers of this show has some explaining to do.

@AvengerII

7 жыл бұрын

That picture has to be double-checked. There's leaping to conclusions it from both angles. Rush to say it's Earhart, rush to say it's illegitimate or mistaken context ( => likely mistaken context). I'd like to see someone else confirm the Japanese source for the dispute. It's not as if Japan wouldn't want to refute the story that its 1930s military kidnapped and was ultimately responsible for the death of an American icon, right? Seriously, it has to be double-checked. Oh, and FYI -- the Japanese didn't let the US military search the Marshall Islands in 1937... Probably because they were building bases and establishing a military presence in the area. On top of which they US Navy didn't want the IJN to know the Japanese security codes had already been broken. The release of the blogger based in Japan is a bit too convenient, too. There was a reason that photo was in the National Archives... Maybe they were mistaken in the late 1930s (about the context) but I find it interesting they appear to have a more primary resource. The picture in the Japanese blog is at least a second or third generation copy of the photo. Notice it's "dotty" and blurrier than the B & W glossy copy the investigators got a ahold of. WHY is the primary photo (or closer to it) in the US National Archves?!? It's amazing people are missing that point (on top of the fact the Japanese source has to be double-checked, too)!

The problem is the photo is not from 1937, it's from 1935

I watched a documentary on Disney the other day on this, it seems the most accepted theory is that she crashed on an extremely remote island and perished there. They think her plane crashed in shallow water then the tide carried it further out whir destroying the aircraft either further. I honestly don’t think Japan had anything to do with it. And this photo honestly is rather irrelevant when you all is considered

@sydandemily447

3 жыл бұрын

Plus the photo was taken 2 years before she and her partner went missing

@daveh9521

2 жыл бұрын

I saw this photo a long time ago. It was determined then that the woman on the dock is not Earhart.

@GhostKing6790

2 жыл бұрын

No she ran out of gas and crashed near Howland island, where she was supposed to land. No gas to go any further, and Noonan isn't planning on flying anywhere else. Why fly hundred's of miles away when there is a coast guard cutter that can search for you as long as you stay as close to the intended island as you can.

wow that DOES make you think, for sure....

@bootedwho9006

7 жыл бұрын

Pat Lepikko it really does man

We all know she is alive and well and living in the Delta Quadrant discovered and rescued from Stasis from the crew of Voyager and Captain Janeway

@nx9100

4 жыл бұрын

Omg! The 37's was such a great episode!

@Seschal

4 жыл бұрын

❤❤❤❤❤❤

@bernieweber4663

3 жыл бұрын

She could be alive at 110 years old. People have loved to 129.

currently living here in marshall islands. this is freakingly cool.

@keiramooney1017

7 жыл бұрын

maeson R omg

@deepseadirt1

7 жыл бұрын

yeah, oh really...she'd be over 120 years old. ;)

@Amariellah

7 жыл бұрын

maeson R have you met anyone their that can confirm she died in Saipan or that school taught the kids about her being captured

@jerrymartin1675

4 жыл бұрын

@@deepseadirt1 ĺ

@ivonneroman3878

4 жыл бұрын

I’m late ash are you still living there? That dope

There's a theory saying she crashed on an island of coconut crabs and was eaten alive which is why we can't find her.

@bernieweber4663

3 жыл бұрын

No way. Those crabs would have been eaten. She probably died and then the franz might have done away with the body.

I love mysteries....

@gerrynightingale9045

7 жыл бұрын

"I don't know why they call it "Hamburger-Helper"....it's goo-oood all by itself!"

@gerrynightingale9045

7 жыл бұрын

"How do you want your bun? Light or dark?"

@rossviles3332

7 жыл бұрын

RealTomato Ketchup,Eddie? She'll be fine on the roof. It's not like it's going to rain or anything.

@psychiccowboy6058

6 жыл бұрын

Unknown Hacker the woman's got jet black hair did she dye her hair on the island and all those ships they're old Merchant ships maybe she came on one of them to visit this is stupid.

@rattekiman9954

6 жыл бұрын

Unknown Hacker Same

Listeners on Howland Island heard Earhart's voice on the radio. It was a strong signal. Her plane got near Howland.

Real news, not like the usual good job.

@rome368

7 жыл бұрын

Grant Hill it is real because it fits your narrative right. Just like the man in the white house claimed that every american would be insured, LIE. Secondly Mexico would pay for a wall, LIE. smdh, ignorance is bliss. Fake news until it is something you agree with? Facts are Facts like hey guess what Chrisopther Columbus didn't discover America it was already inhabited, how can you discover an inhabitated land? Besides the Vikings came here before Christopher Genocide Columbus. FACTS, look it up

@Daneelro

7 жыл бұрын

Now that we know that this news was about as real as anything out of Trump's mouth, will you think about why you're so easily duped?

@samjam2376

7 жыл бұрын

Report has already been discredited. But lets see how it plays out.

@samjam2376

7 жыл бұрын

so when is news fake? when reporters don't do any real research on their own and parrot another so called reliable news! source.

@JTScott1988

4 жыл бұрын

Real news has been reported consistently on every news source but Fox.

the problem with this is the photo was previously published in 1935 two years before Earhart went missing

Do some research this photo was taken years before she disappeared

@bankrupt4l

4 жыл бұрын

HOW DO YOU KNOW????

@bankrupt4l

4 жыл бұрын

No

This photo was found in a Japanese publication out in 1935, two years before she disappeared. This is not Earhat & Noonan.

"leaves no doubt..." no doubt means we know for sure. How do we know "for sure" looking at this picture. GTFO of here.

@Beloved20223

4 жыл бұрын

nepatriots77 😂

military don't want you to know, would you believe if they say the photo is published 2 years before?

Interesting how all these "experts" can convince people and as it turns out the photo was taken two years before the flight in 1935.

@kaitlynholman6046

6 жыл бұрын

and how would u know that

@brianmachado4533

5 жыл бұрын

How do you know that?

@bigdog4173

5 жыл бұрын

Robert Lockwood No the photo us one of several,not very good but sufficient proof for ONI that she WAS there..ONI gad intercepred radio messages that seemed to confirm her capture..this was additional proof for them..Claims that tge photo was previously published are a debunking effort,US us still sticking to cover story of ocean crash landing ..whole matter very embarrassing to US government..wait til 2037 when files including other photos should be released

@JENDALL714

4 жыл бұрын

@JebaydenSmith The pier wasn't built in 1935, the photo that the book came from was from a later edition.

@joebittman5039

4 жыл бұрын

How do we know that files released in 2037will be complete,altered,accurate or falsified.?Who is in charge of these files now?Where are they and who is protecting them?What does anyone know about them?Just asking

Brings back memories of “Unsolved Mysteries”. The music used to freak me out! But yes I do feel that she was shot down and died in some pow camp

@ilikepigeons6101

4 жыл бұрын

OMG I WATCHED THAT TOO

"I believe it proves" and "I think it leaves no doubt" Thinking and believing are not proof.

I Worked With Amelia's Sister, Muriel...Too Bad This Information Didn't Come Out Before Muriel Passed Away...!!!! We Had Many Discussions And Theories About What Happened To Amelia...!!!! It Broke Her Heart Not To Know What Actually Happened...!!!! 😢 Hopefully, They Are Together Now Up There...!!!! 💔💔

I believe this! The Japanese were suspicious of her! They thought she was a spy! That was her second flight! My grandpa was related to Amelia Earhart! My grandmother knew about her, even before she became famous aviator. She knew that Amelia Earhart, wanted to become a pilot. Gone but ,not forgotten! The legacy lives on!

@bigdog4173

5 жыл бұрын

Minnie Earhart Yes she was blackmailed into spying,and got caught..this accidental flyover trick has been used before and since,such as KAL 007,over the USSR,and MH17 over Ukraine..

@DirtyDan-jj9xv

Жыл бұрын

That's crazy , I really believe this is true ! The Japanese got her thinking she's a spy just like the people who had the top secret picture said , "she was a spy don't talk about it"

Too bad that photo was taken in 1935 and she was lost back in 1937 😐

@essdevine1717

4 жыл бұрын

Somebody had to tell them 😁

@JaneDoe-si7ht

4 жыл бұрын

If you'll notice the woman they claim is Amelia, the hair is too dark. Amelia's was lighter.

@siahmackay9083

4 жыл бұрын

@@JaneDoe-si7ht it's a black and white photo bro

@JaneDoe-si7ht

4 жыл бұрын

@@siahmackay9083 There's lots of photos of Amelia in black and white. Her hair isn't that dark in any of them. Even in photos on this video.

@JaneDoe-si7ht

4 жыл бұрын

@@siahmackay9083 Not a "bro".

Its convenient that files are always missing with these stories, did a dog eat them or something.

@yadingus5652

7 жыл бұрын

Mr Banana the papers accidentally walked themselves to a shredder

@bigdog4173

5 жыл бұрын

Shawn Sheehan Wait til 2037 files should be released then..

157-337 (LOP) was one of the last things Amelia said over the radio, there are two 157-337 (compass and true heading) which one was she referring to? There are also two 67 degrees ( compass and true heading) and both are located north of Howland Island, 67 degrees true heading (sunrise) is 11 degrees north of Howland and 67 degree compass heading (76.54 degree true heading) is approximately 1.5 degrees north of Howland. So which 67 degrees is the 157-337 LOP based on?

I seen this when it first came out 3 years ago.

@bigbangomeganova8411

4 жыл бұрын

Nice

@younghotwheelstrack6627

4 жыл бұрын

Haha

Too bad this is a photo published in book in Japan in 1935, two years before Amelia and Fred went missing on July 2, 1937. 😳😔🤪

@chiasanzes9770

3 жыл бұрын

Have You done the re-search yourself or are you just another brainwashed American.

Just reminded how much I do NOT miss Matt Lauer!

If it was them, then why aren't they being guarded by the Japanese? They are just sitting and standing there like the other folk on the dock.

@bigdog4173

5 жыл бұрын

Ylva Bjarnson Because on the beginning the Japanese were quite courteous..things changed after arrival at Saipan

@benpool4953

4 жыл бұрын

besides, theyre on an island, where they gonna go?

@hitoshisawa8479

4 жыл бұрын

good point

4°41'28"s-174°29'39"w zoom in on these coordinates

@clossigep007

4 жыл бұрын

.

Finally something actually related to history on the history channel

That photo was published in a Japanese magazine two years before Earhardt went missing, so it couldn't be her.

American humbug from "A team of investigators from History Channel". The photo was published in a Japanese tourist magazine in 1935. Two year before Amelia plunged into the Pacific ...

I read somewhere this photograph was taken before we were at war with Japan

@paganphil100

3 жыл бұрын

Chris Watters: Yes....its from a "travel guidebook" published in 1935.

The photo is from a Japanese book published in 1935, two years before Earhart even went missing.

@brianmachado4533

5 жыл бұрын

What book?

@bradthorne22

4 жыл бұрын

How do you know??

@mase2582

4 жыл бұрын

TehSpirit buzzfeed

@SPCLPONY

4 жыл бұрын

Why do people post comments like this and never answer questions? What book?

@mase2582

4 жыл бұрын

SPCLPONY THERES A BUZZFEED EPISODE

The photo was not her, and taken and in a book before she even left... Talk about fakenews.

there isnt enough detail in that photo to tell weather the people are Caucasian much less who they are.

@bigdog4173

5 жыл бұрын

Kevin Okey The photo is only one of several taken,it and others were sufficient confirmation that AE and FW were there..ONI had confirmed their capture via intercepting radio messages..US had few spies in area and this was best they could do under circumstances with 1930s tech..Supposedly person who took photo was also executed as a spy..AE and FW arent seen being guarded as Japanese were initially courteous things changed after arrival in Saipan..wait for files to be released in 2037

@recessivegenius6630

5 жыл бұрын

Big dog They were on an island. Where were they going to go?

@elizabethlinsay9193

4 жыл бұрын

Right you are.

@garryhall9519

4 жыл бұрын

whether.

@queerbrowngirl9293

4 жыл бұрын

i would love it to be true... but the "male caucasian" doesn't look white at all?? if theyre reaching on that then kinda ruins the whole story

Very insightful.

unfortunately this photograph has already been shown to have been taken around ten years too early for it to be Earhart. It existed in a japanese archive.

Just a question..... would a pair of “prisoners” especially ones deemed to be spys be allowed to casually sit on the edge of a dock pier? Un guarded and with no visible restraints? They would surely be chained/ cuffed and be under strict armed guard observation? Looks to much like a tourists holiday photo to me? Interesting though! Best wishes all

As soon as I heard "former FBI agent" I knew this claim is a lie.

Amazing 🙌

There is a video where a young girl who would sit in front of her radio with pad and pen (ready to write down songs she liked) that heard Amelia making a plea for help. That Noonan was hurt badly. She wrote down word for word what she heard coming from her radio. Noonan was out of his mind trying to grab the radio from her. An expert stated that it was possible with technical reasons why. So how could she be making a may day call hurt and then be sitting on a dock healthy?

@nelsonphilip4520

Жыл бұрын

You raise a good question. I think these investigators make a "good guess" or reasonable hypothesis as to the identity of the individuals in the photograph. If it's not Earhart & Noonan, who else could it be?

Photo already proven not to be Amelia and Fred...But, I still think that they met their demise at the hands of the Japanese.

No surprise, History Channel got it WRONG. This is a 1935 photo from a Japanese travel book.

Great investigation.

Great story. Pity someone found a book with that photo in taken 2 years before they disappeared!

In the mean time, IT is clear, that this same picture was made 1935. Earhart disappeared in 1937. On that picture cannot be Earhart! She did her trip years later.

This is so sad how her life ended all alone with no one knowing the truth !!! Only god knows now!!!! Rip Amelia gone to soon and so suddenly!!!

@happyscrappy370

4 жыл бұрын

Cyndi Gomez shhhh

The foto was officiële taken 3 years before she went missing!!!

This isn't new information. I saw a documentary where they showed this photo more than a year ago.

Except I thought after more investigations of that photo they found it was published in a Japanese journal/ newspaper before the date of earhart and Noonan dissapeared. I heard that somewhere.

Ask the Japanese?? Someone somewhere knows something- maybe info has been past down through the decades !!!

This picture appeared in a book in 1935, 2 years before Earhart's flight. Obviously it's not Earhart.

@VersatyleTV1

6 жыл бұрын

whats the name of the book?

@WeGoWalk

5 жыл бұрын

Sure, right, uh-huh. What book? You can’t just make a statement like that without backing it up. So, we discount your comment as totally false and without merit.

@Jen-X333

5 жыл бұрын

@@WeGoWalk read the news about it. The book was published in 1935. This is old news that was discovered to be bogus.

@brianmachado4533

5 жыл бұрын

What book?

@Jen-X333

5 жыл бұрын

@@brianmachado4533 all you have to do is Google. www.google.com/amp/s/relay.nationalgeographic.com/proxy/distribution/public/amp/2017/07/amelia-earhart-lost-photograph-discredited-spd

Finally there bringing this to light after all these years a true aviator a hero to many woman but to all pilots then and now and to her and Newnan's family thank you for making them courageous and sorry for the losses after so many years they can also see the light at the end of the tunnel for the truth and hopefully will know why it was kept a secret after so many years !! God Bless

Very compelling.

Well done! ✈✈✈✈✈

Wow!!

What a Twist!

It's not right the photo was taken two years before she got in that plane

if you squint real hard you can see oswald

Wow! Interesting !I'd like to know what really happened to her, she was related to my grandfather George Earhart he was from Kansas City! I remember my grandmother n my mother always speaking to me about Amelia wanting to become a pilot, I didn't really know who she was but my mom always said, grandmother told her , we 're related to Amelia Earhart, I had an aunt nicknamed Tootsie looked alot like Amelia Eahart! Grandpa's grandparents were from Bravia Germany emigrated to Kansas, the German last name was erhardt later changed to Earhart.

@adgamez1311

4 жыл бұрын

wow

All I can say is wow!

WOW!!!!

Why doesn't anyone talk to the Marshal Islands people to see if there are any old stories about anything like that?

@brandonsimmons1108

7 жыл бұрын

The locals do talk about two white people one being a "woman flyer, wearing pants) Most are dead or near death, but claim they remember so clearly because it was the first time they saw a white person. The marshall Islands even had a stamp made up. www.google.com/search?q=amelia+earhart+stamps&rlz=1C1CHZL_enUS688US688&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjz4bX4_P_UAhVLxYMKHbyZCygQ_AUICigB&biw=1920&bih=974#imgrc=oJ8HRmF5PJz7PM:

Yeah, that photo was taken two years before she went missing. It has been shown to be true.

Some one know something

She took off from Lae, Papua New Guinea enroute to Howland island, an uninhabited island between Australia and Hawaii

I read about this. This photo was taken before she dissapeared. The odds of her not getting lost are very high. She was trying to find a postage stamp..

@Jake-jh7bg

8 ай бұрын

No date on the photo try again

Debunked, picture was taken in 1935 from a Japanese tourist guide

Wow

This photo was taken in 1935 which was two years before Amelia's dissapearence

@brianmachado4533

5 жыл бұрын

where's your proof?

No, that picture was from 1935 tour brochure.Totally debunked.

🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄 "Experts" using gray blobs and arbitrary lines on a computer: "Look at all this proof!!"

Luuucy, you got some splannin to do.

I would love to hear more about her. How old was she

@paganphil100

3 жыл бұрын

Gail Jackson-Chapman: She was born in July 1897 so when she disappeared she would have been almost 40 years old.

@gailjackson-chapman7085

3 жыл бұрын

@@paganphil100 thank for the information❤️

After the photo was first shown on American Media purporting to show Earhart & Noonan on a dock in the Jaluit Atoll in the Marshall Islands in 1937, a Japanese researcher began studying the photo & found the exact photo in a Japanese coffee table book listing the date of the photo as 1935, two years before they began their flight! What’s more, he determined that if the photo was indeed taken in 1937, the dock would have been crawling with Japanese Soldiers!

@timwheeler527

Жыл бұрын

The pier wasn't built until 1936. Truk wasn't built up until 1939. They picked them up off Gardner Island.

PS. AND THAT IS NO disrespect to THE LATE MS. Earhart!! may she "soon" RIP. 💚💚

thephotograph was taken at Jaluit Atoll in 1935 and published as part of the 111-page travelogue in 1936, how can ths photo of 1935 be evidence when Amelia's flight around the world did not start till 1937

Makes more sense. Very intriguing

That’s a photo that predates the loss of Earhart by a few years. This is nonsense.

I'm not convinced. There's just one very big question. If the Japanese thought that Amelia and Fred where spy's, where are the guards, why are they allowed to run around on the dock without those guards and why aren't they in hand cuffs or in restraints. I'm not going for the photo or this version of the story. Sorry, just me.

TIGHAR currently has the best leads on the Earhardt mystery. It looks like she ditched on an atoll off Nikumauroro Island and died there as a castaway.

@paganphil100

3 жыл бұрын

Stalicone: Yes....and radio transmissions from her were picked up for days after she disappeared. She wasn't sure where they were but she said they were on a reef near the wreck of a ship called Norwich City (which was wrecked at Nikumauroro Island, previously known as Gardner island). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SS_Norwich_City

Im hooked

pfff, photo was proven to be from 1935

@brianmachado4533

5 жыл бұрын

what book?

@bigdog4173

5 жыл бұрын

[D]arth No that was a debunking effort..photo is one of several..US is still sticking to cover story of ocean crashlanding. wait til 2037 when files released

@recessivegenius6630

5 жыл бұрын

It's a photo album held together with string. Jabor dock was built in 1936. There is no copyright saying 1935. The only thing that says 1935 is a librarian's stamp.

Best change those history books!

@shootseven6292

7 жыл бұрын

Not so fast. Chances are it isn't her.

@brandonsimmons1108

7 жыл бұрын

What chances? How many white "woman flyers" wearing pants were in that area around that time? Probably one.

@gavinreid8351

7 жыл бұрын

Brandon Simmons the seated figure looks too much like others in the picture. is it even a woman?

Wow,! This photo was found 2 years before she even took her flight..

@zettemueller3560

4 жыл бұрын

That’s what I was going to say. This photo was kicked out of the running for anything important when it was revealed it was out of a book from several years before she even started her flight-- so why WHY do we keep hearing about this???

@dollarbill6877

4 жыл бұрын

@@zettemueller3560 good question! After watching this video I found another. Some Peace's of her kind of plane was found near an island.. Tighar is name on the video and what he found.

PHOTO WAS LATER PROVEN TO HAVE BEEN TAKEN IN 1935, TWO YEARS PRIOR TO HER DISAPPEARANCE.

I was watching a documentary the other day that said the photo is a hoax.

I still believe she was captured by the Japanese but this photo was taken 2 years before she disappeared

Interesting. Apparently, this picture was published in 1935. The evidence she died on Gardner Island is compelling given the artifacts, etc.

This great story just got more interesting

History Channel Knew the photo was BS !

They said later this picture was from a vacation book. So where is this book?

LOL caption says "Les spent 150 years looking". Really? LMAO.

Awesome amazing beautiful people amazing beautiful places ❤

some one showed that picture several tears ago --old news

The never before photo that was seen by everyone and taken in 1935?