You make a good point about the bezel inserts. I happen to like aluminum bezels more than ceramic bezels, unless it's matte ceramic. So I'll always prefer the "worse" aluminum bezels just as we all prefer "worse" mechanical timekeepers lol!

@thewatchidiot

Жыл бұрын

loooool thats right mechanical watches are worse tome keepers indeed! Same here i tend to prefer aluminum bezels but thats only because i dont like the look of matte black dials (basically dark gray dials) paired with a deep black and shiny ceramic bezel. This combo is way too common and I'm not at all a fan. And plus its fun trying to bleach aluminum bezel to ghost them 😁

@typebflieger

Жыл бұрын

Couldn’t agree more. I find shiny ceramic far too blingy and distracting as it picks up so much glare. A matte aluminum bezel makes the dial pop a lot more.

King Turtle all the way, for the day/date function alone.

This is precisely why I watch your channel. Unvarnished assessments. Well done!

Congrats on the 10k milestone! You've become one of my favorite watch youtubers! If I won the Citizen, I'd put it on a nice black rubber strap for some more sporty versatility!

Congratulations on the 10K !!!Great comparison of the two!!! I’d definitely be stumped on which to keep, but leaning to the King Turtle on value. Also kinda like the slightly larger size, and would remove the cyclops to clean up the look a bit. As for the Citizen, I’d either put it on a NATO, or search out one of their metal bracelets that has the nifty extension built in. Keep up the great work, looking forward to seeing more 👍👍👍

I think you made the choice with the slim turtle. Looks great! If I had the Citizen, I’d put one of the new bracelets Marc at Long Island recently released for the pro divers. Congratulations on 10k! Love your content!

Thaks for that great comparison. I'm toying with ordering a Slim Turtle and this video was really informative.

I love Citizen watches, and the one you are giving away is absolutely beautiful. Happy with whatever strap it comes on if lucky enough to win it. Glad I found your channel !

Great video as always! I would have to go with the king turtle as I have been wanting one for quite awhile. As far as the Citizen goes, I think a blue rubber strap like the one in the video would be sweet! Great content!!

For me, it’s the slim turtle (although you can pull both off) all day. The color combo and that “traffic light” seconds hand are just too cool.

congratulation on the passing the 10k mark. i already owned a few 44mm seiko dive watches and i think the slim turtle is a great alternative. for the citizen, as a bracelet guy i would love it on a bracelet but any any dive watch would feel nice to wear with a FKM strap.

Good comparison, Slim turtle for me, thanks for highlighting this model, had no idea till now it existed, gone a bit cold on Seiko lately but this might change my mind..... Subscribed!

The king turtle has so much going on. I don’t have any issue with the wide bracelet only narrowing to 20mm - I like ‘‘em chunky.

Great review! I just ordered the slim turtle. What gray textile strap are you using in this video?

Both watches could coexist in a collection as you’ve mentioned - the King T would do for me but that’s just my personal preference, both awesome watches. Congrats on the 10k and I’d put the Citizen on one of my Helm Komodo rubber straps 👍

Congrats on the 10k milestone, as for the citizen i’m happy with the blue rubber strap on it

Beautiful watch. The factory strap works for me. Thanks for the channel content

Congrats again on 10K! The Citizen would probably wind up on one of my FKM straps. Like the stock one, but really enjoy the FKMs I have on my larger divers.

@thewatchidiot

Жыл бұрын

And thank you once again! an FKM strap would work very nicely on this one and it would probably be unbelievably comfortable! (also i sent you an email just now😁)

Very generous of you. I would love that Citizen on a sail cloth strap.

I think the promaster looks great on the strap it comes on! Both featured watches look great! Awesome channel!

@thewatchidiot

Жыл бұрын

Agreed! i still wear my black dial promaster on the factory strap although i had to mold it with boiling water lol! I wish this new version still had the no deco table but I know i'm in the minority there. Thanks for your support!

Enjoy your reviews, 10k is just the start! If I won I’d put an uncle Seiko GL831 rubber strap on, which always brings out that vintage diver feel of a watch.

Nice video WI, It’s a tough choice but I’d pick the turtle because of the dial. The pro master I’d try it on a leather tanned strap since I ain’t going diving with it. Keep up the good work

I think aluminum bezels look much better than ceramic, and scratches, although I try to avoid them, add patina to a watch which I really appreciate.

@thewatchidiot

Жыл бұрын

lol I'm the same, i want my keepers to have more scratches but despite my best efforts i subconsciously keep babying them!

@mariog7213

Жыл бұрын

Patina is the worst

@elihollingsworth6852

5 ай бұрын

Bezel scratches look like garbage, as do dial scratches.

@NexDim.

5 ай бұрын

I’m also hoping the newer bezels eventually fade too

Digging the Slim Turtle. Good choice. Honestly, that stock Citizen strap looks pretty sweet!

Congrats on 10k. I recently purchased a king turtle manta ray and it’s stunning I also have the SPB151 Willard and yes the turtle is better value for money, but the Willard has an X-Factor. I got the turtle from a private seller on Chrono24, it came with a nato but’s it 20mm😂. It would look well on the Citizen. P.S. I’m also following you on WatchCrunch.

Great video as always. As far as Seiko's go I'd pick the King Turtle. The slim one looks cool and the proportions are spot on but I don't like the date window. When it comes to Promaster I'd like to try it on Uncle Seiko velcro or US rubber cause Citizen rubber straps are pretty usually pretty stiff, at least the ones I've tried so far were.

Thanks for this mate, great comparison between these turtle models. As for the giveaway, I would pair the pro master with a grey nato strap to match that grey-blue dial!

Looks great as is with the factory strap! thank and great channel

Lets go with the factory strap for the Citizen. The slim turtle is on my list! Love the bracelet.😊

Nice comparison, thank you. What do you think of comparing the slim turtle with one of the 42mm Willards? When I got my Willard it took all the wrist time from my turtle. 😁

the bracelet of my Turtle srp773 came off because the pin that holds the links together came out, my watchmaker said that there is a risk that it could happen again due to the way the bracelet is made. Is there any solution for this problem? I really care about this watch and I want to wear it on a bracelet. Great video 👏

Great vid! I think you just sold me on the slim turtle (as I’m even wearing my king turtle with removed cyclops👌🏼). I’d put an isofrane rubber on the Promaster, but I do love the oem strap with iconic n.d. chart.

Great vid and both stunning watches. My choice of strap for the citizen Promaster would be an orange isofrane style strap, that would really set it off a treat! Thank you. :)

Great video and congrats on the 10k! Would go for the slim turtle, I like the case and brushing much more + I'm not a fan of a date cyclopse. The Citizen would go on a FKM rubber strap!

Strapcode hexacode is the one I like the most of aftermarket bracelets. Waiting for my king turtle now and will buy that bracelet to try in the nearest future. For the citizen strap, I’d go with nato.

Hey @thewatchidiot! Where do you order your seikos? I’m having a difficult time finding the turtles anywhere online! Love your page btw, awesome content!

I have the 313, I love it, my only complaint is that it runs slow. Haven’t gotten around to regulating it. Definitely need to try out a “true” Turtle. The Citizen I would probably put on a MN strap! Great video!

Great video and congrats on a 10k subs... Regarding Citizen, it would have to be either steel or rubber bracelet, no third option 😂😂😂 I know strapcode have some great bracelets for Seiko, maybe something similar!😉

Congratulations on the 10,000! I would put the watch on a Prometheus Design Werx grey NATO strap with its titanium hardware.

Congratulations for the 10k. I would much prefer the slim turtle because of my slim wrist and the much nicer bracelet. As for the citizen watch , I would find a much nicer rubber/fkm strap.

Great review !!!

great review =) For the strap choice on the promaster, I would go with a nato.

Great video! I saw the white dial seiko recently and its a lovely looking watch. As for the citizen, i would be super boring and pair it with a grey nato lol. I don't own a blue dial in my collection so perhaps this would be a new obsession if i liked it.

I’d go with a nato.. followed on watch crunch.. great video! Cheers

I would swap Citizen strap for my retro waffle style rubber strap. Great video as usual by the way!

My first actual dive watch was the King Turtle in green and I was still debating whether or not to keep it and/or get a Slim Turtle. Now I now that I need both, you can never have too many Seikos after all! I'd put my newly acquired original blue Tropic strap on the Citizen! Would be a perfect match and who doesn't love a vanilla scent when looking at your wrist? Lol

@TheEasyRail

Жыл бұрын

Always keep the first one. It's the special one. Afterwards they are just number unless bought for occasion

My next dive watch needs to be a black dial with a “tool watch” vibe. I have a few divers but my black dial I have is the oris aquis 400 caliber. I love it but it’s very polished (once again I love that too). I definitely try to match my watches to my outfit a lot of times and sometimes the polished surfaces don’t go as well as an all brushed surface. Got my eyes on the spb143!

@thewatchidiot

Жыл бұрын

oh man an aquis has been on my list for years now! The caliber 400 variants are awesome and makes it much more tempting but it does have a lot of polish for sure. The SPB143 would be a perfect companion piece it can play the tool watch role and it can be dressed up easily. Not to mention that it can actually be worn with straps lol! As great as the aquis bracelet is, not being able to swap straps as easily has been a pretty big minus point for me, although not as big now

10K, nice job Sir ! As far as the type of strap for the Promaster, l would have to go with a StrapsCo Waffle. They just suit the watch so well and are great on wrist. Luck to all and thanks for the opportunity to win.

Great comparison. I would Try it on a tropics Rubber strap.

Great comparison video. Would you consider the 313 a permanent member of the collection?

@thewatchidiot

Жыл бұрын

Glad you enjoyed the video! and as far as the 313 being a full on keeper, it sure is looking like that will be the case! The bracelet looks so good and its the only white dial black bezel combo that i actually like so i think its carved in a permanent spot

Great video. I would put a steel jubilee on the Promaster diver from Marc at Long Island watch. Cheers😊

Great video! I’d pair it with the Blushark Pajama 👍🏻

Love the Slim Turtle and the white dial, great bracelet too, really suits it. For the Citizen I would stick to factory strap to begin with, too often I have bought a strap for a watch before the watch even arrives!. Lately I tend to try it on the strap the manufacturer designed for it and then if it has some shortcoming I can't get over I will change it.

Love the Slim Turtle! Just picked up a black land tortoise and I love the slim cushion design 😊. I would pair the pro diver with a navy blue seatbelt nato strap! Single pass for slimness haha

Great Video! I would prefer the King Turtle, without cyclops... but the padi or save the oceans

Awsome video!!! I would keep the factory strap!!!

I like both and I have a King Turtle....and love it. This more expensive version is nice. If it were 100 bucks more I'd buy it. It doesn't seem special enough or enough of a step up for almost double the price.

I've been eyeing this citizen for over a year now and it'd be pretty sweet if I won it. I think it looks gorgeous on its stock strap.

I don't understand how can you return watches just like that? I have heard people returning watches after trying/wearing them, and I wonder what should the store do with those returned watches? Sell them to somebody else as "new"? Or throw them away? Not a nice thing to do. Go to the store, try it on and then decide to purchase or not. How can you return items after you use them. Maybe I am missing the point, if so, somebody please explain. Thanks!

The original 6309 Turtle had a rounded case shape. As much as I want to like the SRP777 (owned one) and the King Turtle, the elongated and bigger case ruins its looks. It seems that seiko took parts of its inspiration for the modern Turtles from the 6105-8000. You can see it when you place the watches side by side. I think you made a good choice keeping the Slim Turtle.

Slim turtle is more elegant and clasy. Silicone soft strap for the Citizen. Great video...keep it going.

Great video as always!! I’d definitely put the Citizen on a Nato or MN style strap, its a tool watch and wants to be used and abused!

Awesome news on the 10K….. stock strap on the Citizen would do me fine

I have a silver/grey nato with a blue stripe that would look phenomenal on that promaster!!

Nice comparison! I think I’d just wear it on the supplied strap.

That slim turtle is gorgeous and like you, I think the bracelet is a big reason for that.

What about the upgrade in the movements?

LOVE the Citizens but never had a Seiko!

I would for sure rock the Promaster on a simple grey nato 👍🏼

Great review. Pro master would have to be on a Navy blue with orange stripe NATO. 💙🧡

The slim turtle really looks gorgeous on that bracelet. I’d put a blue silicon strap on the pro master

Why is the second hand lumed on the wrong side on the king T?

I’d put a black with white stripe paratrooper elastic strap from Cheapest Nato Strap. I love it on my other watches!

I would wear that Citizen on nice grey NATO....I think that combo would look AWESOME!!

@thewatchidiot

Жыл бұрын

cant go wrong with gray natos! i was sooooo tempted to try out my grey natos on it but i didnt want to potentially scratch it. man i wish it had drilled lugs!

@lucacadianalbert

Жыл бұрын

@@thewatchidiot yeah drilled lugs is something I wish more watches had. More of that and less quick release springbars

going to graduate from high school also going to turn 18 dont know what to choose between king turtle and the seiko 5 ssk gmt

I'll go for the King Turtle, just because of the sapphire crystal. And for the citizen, i'll keep it on the factory strap and go for a sailcloth from time to time to dress it up

A tropical rubber strap looks very good on my father's fugu, so that's probably my strap choice for that citizen promaster

thanks for the giveaway TWI! I would stick it on a textureless FKM sstrap

Thanks for the giveaway! I’m a sucker for a nato

I'd throw a green nato strap on the Citizen, I'm a sucker for a blue dial/green strap combo!

If I had the Citizen, I would put it on an Long Island bracelet. Marc recently announced his new bracelet for the watch.

I would wear it on that stock rubber strap! Never had a dive watch and that seems like the OG strap for them anyway.

The promaster looks great as is, I would probably put it in a blue nato tho

The date on the slim turtle really throws me off so it’s not for me, for the strap I’d get a navy sailcloth strap feel like that’s best. Keep up the content 🔥

Thanks for the video. I think that everyone who has a smaller wrist than you do needs to take a serious look at the Slim Turtle. I have 7.25" wrists, which are .25" smaller than yours, and it certainly will fit better. Actually, the maximum recommended watch case size for the 7.25" wrist is 43" as far as I have read. Besides: s Slim Turtle looks more elegant and sophisticated to me, while a King Turtle looks more bulky, sort of "red necky" to me. So one with the smaller wrists should consider these arguments, besides in the Slim Turtle Seiko used a better movement.

I've got the king turtle very happy with it. Would consider the slim turtle but for the price.stick with the factory strap on the citizen.

There really is a Seiko for everyone. Brilliant video. Have you looked at Christopher Ward watches? I'm seriously considering getting a C60. Cheers. BTW I'd wear the Citizen on a NATO.

@thewatchidiot

Жыл бұрын

Seiko's doing good things these days! Yeah I actually owned the C60 Sapphire Black! it was an absolutely incredible watch but i had to return it because i needed money to get my Black Bay 58 925. I really want to get another CW tho because they're on another level. Yeah the Promaster looks and feels great on natos, its a strap monster!

@barryvercueil2346

Жыл бұрын

@@thewatchidiot thank you for the reply. I really enjoyed your videos on The 925. Was a great journey. Keep up the awesome work. Cheers.

I prefer the slim turtle for many reasons the bracelet, the size and the pricepoint. Still love the both

I'd put the Citizen on a grey nato :-) I also look forward to seeing the slim turtle with a better movement in it in future editions otherwise I'd buy a vintage one.

I’d wear the Citizen pro master on a blushark nato :)

Slim turtle 😍 for the citizen factory strap please 😁

I like the factory strap.

Great video, Happy Thanksgiving…Factory strap on promaster

@thewatchidiot

Жыл бұрын

Thanks man and happy thanksgiving to you too! Yeah I love the factory strap on my black dial promaster so itll be great here too

Great review! I like the Slim Turtle better for a number of reasons and think you made the right choice! For the strap on the Citizen... I think I'd stick with the factory one or perhaps find a smooth version of the dark-blue rubber or maybe even a red rubber to set it off like crazy for weekends.

Waffle or tropic strap for the Citizen. Thanks!

I'm all about those smaller dimensions, regular turtle's are just on my limit so a dmaller option is great. As for the strap choice on the promaster, I would go with a blue sailcloth from Artem, a very robust combo.

Turtles are my favourite !

A great comparison TWI. I would have to agree with your conclusion to keep the slim turtle though. To me apart from the size it's just a little more readable at a glance. I'm not a huge fan of the candy bar date magnifier either even though. The slim turtle has the date at 4:30 it's so much more discreet yet functional and distracts less from the overall symmetry of the watch. Onto the colour scheme, well I love the Omega SM300M great white and the slim turtle looks like it should work just as well.

@thewatchidiot

Жыл бұрын

Thanks as always! And you're absolutely right about the slim turtle being more legible, i think it has to do with the simplicity vs the busier King turtle despite the king turtle having the more traditionally legible combo (black dial/white indices). The black dial Seamaster 300M has been on my radar to rebuy for ages now but now my experience with this slim turtle is making me consider the white dial Seamaster! (also i just sent you an email sorry about the delay!!)

@anthonystevens8683

Жыл бұрын

@@thewatchidiot I think the 300M looks great with either the black or white dial. I've not seen one but the new green dial allegedly looks great but I'll be sticking with the white.

I’ll keep it factory! On the strap that came with it and wear it all summer!

I would prefer the smaller one as well BUT I hate the date window. As for the giveaway watch, I'm partial to a good silicone strap.