Tweet at us @live_munro and follow us on Instagram @munrolive

You can tell when Sandy is really excited about something he's evaluating by how focused he becomes, how quickly he talks, etc. He's like a kid in a candy store when he gets to see clever design and engineering that takes him by surprise. Love it.

@batchint

3 жыл бұрын

guessing not many people go to the candy store with news.... and stuff...

@hagestad

3 жыл бұрын

is he unaware that Ford and VW are doing electric cars together?

@patreekotime4578

3 жыл бұрын

@@hagestad Are you unaware that applies only to commercial vehicles and has nothing to do with this or the iD4?

@abraxastulammo9940

3 жыл бұрын

@@patreekotime4578 Isn't Ford buying 600000 MEB from VW?

These videos are so valuable in seeing the details most of us never look at.

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks, Glad you enjoy them!

I don't know diddly squat about vehicle engineering but I get all excited when Sandy gets all excited about this stuff! :D

Listen to sandy and you will win as an automobile company... plain and simple.

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Great Point.

@MrZakius

3 жыл бұрын

True, but it's not only that. We can all learn the core concepts of his logic and apply to our fields of work or pretty much anywhere in life. These are simple truths: 1) always look into the essence of things, don't dwell too much into the details without knowing the real purpose of what it's all about; 2) Always consider cost vs benefit; 3) Don't half-ass things, always go for the best result possible, don't be lazy; 4) Love what you're doing.

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks KaziusG.

@mjcamp01

3 жыл бұрын

@@MunroLive I'd like to suggest that you try not to abbreviate during the videos, I'm sure you have lots of non engineers watching who may not know what PM or SPR are

@calholli

3 жыл бұрын

@@mjcamp01 PM is "post meridiem" (after noon), and SPR is "special purpose rifle" (typically an 18" AR15 designed for DMR use. -(designated marksman rifle). see, its quite simple

Great to see Ford finally put out a good product. All hopes are not lost. I’m impressed!!

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Us too!

@Scholzey

3 жыл бұрын

@@MunroLive Will be interesting to see how much you think it cost to make. Are these impressive things cost effective, or an expensive attempt to keep up with tesla?

@rogerstarkey5390

3 жыл бұрын

@@Scholzey For the last "X" years, Sandy had been saying "use castings instead of welding". Maybe someone DID listen?

@concinnus

3 жыл бұрын

@@Scholzey These parts are cost-effective. It's battery cost where Tesla will eat everyone's lunch.

@turbostixxx

3 жыл бұрын

Need to fix software issues.

Sandy's comments on VW's lower control arm/strut front suspension "Not so good, found on cheaper cars". Sandy's comments on Ford's same set up "Not dramatic, but really well done"

"Let's take a look at another little doodad that is kind of impressive" I almost spit out my coffee!!!

"im gonna talk to the rear-end, and im real excited about that" - gotta love Sandy's dirty talk

@elektrotehnik94

3 жыл бұрын

lol

@bradcavanagh3092

3 жыл бұрын

But with no tailpipe it can't be dirty talk!

Mach-E shaping up to be a potential legitimate competitor to Tesla! FINALLY! THIS IS GOOD FOR ALL INVOLVED, INCLUDING TESLA!!!

@4literv6

3 жыл бұрын

Agreed, it was telling that team Edison was run a lot like a startup from the beginning. They did not answer to the normal mucky mucks in fomoco. Reading about team Edison really shows how they got the mach e to where they did vs where Ford was on evs. Also Ford leased tesla model 3s for all the engineer's to benchmark the mach e against. Since the model y wasn't yet available. 🤔

@teslascoop2177

3 жыл бұрын

Unfortunately Motors are not built by Ford.. So don't hold your breath just yet

@4literv6

3 жыл бұрын

@@teslascoop2177 indeed, haha built by Bosch along with the inverters, incidently bosch just commited to further investment in ice tech for another 20+year's. 😂

@GA-wq8xq

3 жыл бұрын

Well designed, better built than Tesla’s with better, nearer service. Should be a hit.

@4literv6

3 жыл бұрын

@@excelrobot quite incorrectly to. I'm a former multiple Ford owner. And can say very few local dealers have anyone who knows anything about bevs. And trying to find a dealership who actually has more than one bev certified tech on duty? When currently barely over half of all Ford dealers even are certified to service their own electric vehicle's? Good luck with that!

You gotta love an engineer who is passionate about engineering.

I love watching Sandy geek out!

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks!

Somebody got his Birthday Present :-) Never saw Sandy that happy and excited! So Ford build a really good electric car, who would have thought that?!

I'm not surprised, and pleasantly pleased with Sandy's finding. You could tell Ford was greatly inspired by Tesla to make this car. I'm glad to see some creative fresh thinking design from Ford , and learn it's more than a marketing effort.. Thanks Sandy Congratulations Ford

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Couldn't agree more!

@calholli

3 жыл бұрын

They did a great job, but calling it a Mustang really set it into a world where it could never succeed; absolutely set it up for failure. If it was simply called the "Mach-E" and not mustang, so many more people would be taking it seriously; but instead now its known as the "Mocked-E'

@carholic-sz3qv

3 жыл бұрын

Uhm nope ford was not inspired by tesla, castings have existed in cars for decades now, maybe sandy should teardown a mercedes sclass or audi A8...

@samesch85

3 жыл бұрын

@@calholli is that why you can’t find one in stock and have to wait 6 months to get one if you order today?

@calholli

3 жыл бұрын

@@samesch85 No... that's because they only build 12 of them per week.

I've not seen Mr Munro as excited for a while, glad he is looking forward to drive and teardown

This is the first time after a while I see Sandy so excited

Sandy’s excitement can’t be replicated. This man is doing exactly what he should be doing. I love it.

I bet that Ford management wasn’t paying much attention to this “unimportant” EV project so the designers and engineers were finally able to do something more innovative by Fords standards

@4literv6

3 жыл бұрын

Lookup team Edison for fun. They ran it like a startup totally separate from the usual higher ups reporting only to Darren Palmer. They also leased tesla model 3s for the engineer's to benchmark the mach e against. 🤔

@morrisg

3 жыл бұрын

@@4literv6 Looks like that paid off for Ford! Hooray!

@bluetoad2668

3 жыл бұрын

Probably would have paid more attention if they expected to have to to make them in high volumes. As is I bet this is seen as a sideline for PR purposes and heavily subsidised by other vehicle sales and the tax rebate.

@crhu319

3 жыл бұрын

And now all the execs are seeing positive reviews and they'll have to do it this way from now on. On every line.

I just love watching Sandy talk and shoot straight from the hip! I hope today's business leaders are listening, learning and getting away from farming out the work to the lowest bidder!!! My father was a Sears repairman in the 50's - 70's and everything then was built to last. Today the fancy expensive plastic laundry machines would break if my walker bumped into it. We need to hear from more people like him who can help design things made to last!!!

Great job Mach E team!

Well this does it. Cancelled my ID4 reservation. Will buy a Mach-E and a Tesla Model Y, selling my two gas cars.

Why Sandy is really happy. 6:00 - Beer holder in the castings.

@elektrotehnik94

3 жыл бұрын

It's gonna become a meme, isn't it? xD I love internet

This type of excitement is what keeps Sandy young!

Why the simple McPherson type of front suspension is good idea in Mustang Mach-E but in ID.4 evaluation it wasn't??

@adrianguggisberg3656

3 жыл бұрын

Because Ford managed to come up with something that isn't a live axle.

You have to either use the correct settings on your camera or get better lighting. Sandy putting a handheld torch right next to something, completely blowing out the contrast and making it impossible to see what he is talking about aint working.

So the Mustang is looking better-engineered than the ID4 so far. THAT is a surprise for me. Thanks, Sandy! These are great insights.

Commenting for the algorithm. It’s great to see Ford thinking outside of their typical box on this one. Keep it up! Thank you Sandy for making these videos. You’re enlightening the masses.

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

More to come!

"I'm so impressed...we may buy this...and tear it apart...." LOL

These videos are so great to watch while eating :D

“I’m gonna talk to the rear end of the car” That sounds like an interesting conversation 😏

It’s amazing how much design goes into being crash worthy. It’s something you never even think of

Love this excitement because it shows that he doesn't just hold to being excited about Tesla.. Glad to see ford making forward thinking changes. Just wish they could apply more to software as well.

I love watching Sandy geek out over this kind of stuff! Thank you for the education. I appreciate you not only pointing out the what, but the why as well.

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

You are so welcome!

Congratulations Ford! It's about time!

It seems like this wasn't designed by the old guards and more-so by new blood. This is a fantastic sign.

@chuckm260

3 жыл бұрын

Or it was designed by the old guard but ("new" guard) management allowed it, as Sandy alluded to. ;-)

I hope American auto engineering rebirths its self. I do not accept that we have to continue to look up to foreign auto makers. I’m 63 and the Tesla is the first American car I’ve bought. This video is great news for Ford, it seems like they may be serious about their business. Hooray!

Nice to see ford having some decent engineers and designers step in and make it happen. Glad to see they took this ev this serious.

The honest to goodness fact that makes these videos so great is that Sandy is an engineer through and through, and his excitement over good engineering is palpable. Love this video!

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you!

8:35 Can't wait to hear what the rear end has to say.

Music to my ears. Well articulated mate!

It's the transition to full electrics that's the goal. If Ford can get someone to move up from a Mustang GT Premium (50K) into the AWD Premium Mach-E (56K), then it's a win.

Another fantastic video! Thank you for these

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Glad you enjoyed it!

Great Sandy, that was another great video, these are the best when you find good engineering... its good to see the complaints to the unsung engineer heroes when they get things right... few give them a thought or discount them when things are done well..mostly they only get to take the criticism when they get things wrong!!!

i never thought id have as much joy as I do hearing sandy shit on the ID.4

Those crash features are outstanding. Protects the motors and battery pack from anything but an absolute total.

Sandy the toolmaker gets excited about nice tool steel molds 😎

Great to see you excited about a new ev. Buy the one with the most tech in it. I’m looking forward to seeing it.

Sandy, this content is why I come here.

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Subscribe so you don't miss anything! ;)

Love so much your work guys! You open up a new world for me :D

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Yay! Thank you!

Excellent content guys. Keep them coming! 👌

I am impressed with the undercarriage of this car. I have owned several Ford products, but never seen this kind use of aluminum and castings and extrusions. I think Ford went all out on this one to make a statement about design and quality construction, in brakes and suspension and crash safety, on their first real electric platform.

@Tegneaufreak

3 жыл бұрын

LOL . The undercarriage is an ID4. Google it. MEB platform, made by VW.

@fields1

3 жыл бұрын

@@Tegneaufreak no it’s not. That’s a future product that’s using MEB. GOOGLE IT.

@fields1

3 жыл бұрын

I’m just surprised Sandy is not complaining about how expensive aluminum is compared to stamped steel…

@eddiegardner8232

3 жыл бұрын

It didn’t look at all like the ID4 undercarriage when Sandy had that one on the lift a few weeks ago. Not sure why you got that impression.

@fields1

3 жыл бұрын

@@eddiegardner8232 Yeah, I have no clue what @San is talking about. There are some similarities with overall suspension design, but obviously a lot is different. I did find it odd that Sandy seemed to criticize the ID.4 for using McPherson struts which Sandy said was “not a BMW quality suspension” [like the Tesla] because it used struts instead of double wishbone. I found the BMW quality part to be funny because the best handling BMWs including the 2-series, 3-series, 4-series as well as the X3, M3/M4, Z4, i3, i4, etc. all use front struts. Only 5-series and up sized BMWs use double wishbones up front. Struts are cheaper to fix and have fewer parts. For a car like an ID.4, struts are perfectly fine. I do think Sandy has a soft spot for the Mach-E because he’s from Detroit, he worked for Ford, and it wouldn’t surprise me if he personally knows people that worked on designing this product. He had a lot of critical things to say about ID.4 even claiming some of the lower control arms on the rear were shaped like they were because mistakes had been made, almost implying they had to retrofit some forgotten component.

The excitement makes me chuckle:)

Happy Sandy means a good car. I'm glad Ford have done a proper job!

@Tegneaufreak

3 жыл бұрын

MEB platform. Made by VW.

@esm7708

3 жыл бұрын

@@Tegneaufreak made by VW perfected by Ford it appears. Not something I'd expect to be writing ever.

As Sandy is excited, I'm looking forward to the next video! By the sound of it this is shaping up to be a good challenger to the Model Y.

That is one excited Sandy Munro.

Wow, the MachE going 3/3 so far under Sandy's microscope. Ford has to be ecstatic about this!

Now we are talking! 👍😃

What exactly does a “Ford” suspension look like? I still see a strut like the VW used, not a double wishbone like the Tesla. I’m also surprised that the extensive use of aluminum isn’t being lambasted as too expensive vs. stamped steel. It is interesting that they chose to base their new GE1 platform on the existing C2 platform which underpins everything from the Focus to the Bronco Sport to the Escape, as opposed to doing a true 100% ground up EV platform.

Wow, love it when Sandy is excited about engineering! :)

I’m shocked that Sandy is this excited about a Ford. I can’t believe they out-engineered VW. Couldn’t be happier for the company.

@GA-wq8xq

3 жыл бұрын

Well has Sandy looked at the Taycan or other higher end models. I wouldn’t jump to conclusions based on one model

@abraxastulammo9940

3 жыл бұрын

@@GA-wq8xq Does Taycan even have a coax drivetrain?

Really impressive construction. Thanks for the review

Sandy gets excited about looking at a rear end. Don't we all!

Sandy doesn't pull any punches. He tells it like it is, and YES he is EXCITED because he is witnessing an innovative technology! Pay attention VW, GM, Mercedes, and others, you might actually learn something!

we love you so much, Sandy! keep up the good work, you are such a insightgul Sir!

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you so much!

liked this car since it was announced, great to know it also appears to be designed well!

I appreciate your videos Sandy and I would suggest that you turn down the flashlight and/or start using a wide laser pointer to direct attention, to improve the quality of your presentations.

kive it when Sandy gets excited over good engineering.

Another excellent video. Thanks

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

You're Welcome!

Awesome job Ford! Can’t wait to see the cost breakdown.

Many people gets excited about the rear end. Another interesting video. 🙏 thanks.

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks for watching!

Thank you!

That smooth bottom tray is beautiful. This was a feature that was once only available on sports cars and race cars. Now considered standard because of the battery cell shape. Slips thru the air now. Very nice.

Sandy. Thanks for your videos. I love the nerdiness :). Idea for future videos, you can show and discuss evolution of various components of cars from older time to newer times. Why things were changed and why it is better. :)

Pretty impressive. Thanks Sandy! Please tear this one down! Follow the innovation.

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

We plan to!

i am addicted to munro live

Great video. Sandy makes me want to buy a ford .... nah, suffered enough, but would like to see ford succeed. Fun to see sandy surprised and excited about engineering taking over accountants

@Wasabi9111

3 жыл бұрын

Tbh, I wasn’t considering the Mach e - was looking forward to the Ioniq 5. But after this video, Im going to test drive a Mach e.

its excellent to see Ford make massive engineering improvements. Thank you Sandy for sharing your knowledge. /cheers ScrapBongo

Buy it!!!!!! We want a Mach E tear down

"This doesn't look like a Ford underneath"... I suspected that all along when they made the "Mustang" into a 4 door sedan. It felt like they were taking someone else's skateboard and branding it a Mustang.

@MrWaththage

3 жыл бұрын

I was gonna leave the same comment here. Then saw yours.

@motofunk1

3 жыл бұрын

Curious if Sandy comes up with who did the engineering? If not Ford, who?

@rogerstarkey5390

3 жыл бұрын

@@motofunk1 Maybe Ford Germany?

@motofunk1

3 жыл бұрын

@@rogerstarkey5390 Good point.

@1943vermork

3 жыл бұрын

There are engineering firms that can design car for OEM. That could be the case here

Wow, Ford let the engineers design the new platform without having the accountants looking over their shoulders and vetoing everything new! Hooray! Clean sheet engineering leads to big advances in capability, crashworthiness, NVH, ease of assembly and on and on with a new EV targeted vehicle design. Congratulations Ford! Excited to see Munro's teardown of the new Mustang Mach E show us some of the secrets of what's looking to be an excellent design.

Love the excitement. And (sadly) good to know others like me, with amazing ideas get shot down too by ppl who don’t like change...

Thank you Sandy. Having just bought a Mustang Mach-e, I'll pleased to know you are finding superior engineering on the underside.

Another day another Munro

When you open the video and the first 2 frames is sandy with a big smile... you're in for something good :D

After Sandy completes praising the rear-end, let’s calculate the value of his advertising. I’ll bet it’s worth over $100K ! Ford would save money giving Sandy a free Mach e vs. running expensive and wasteful TV ads. Sandy has much more credibility than advertising.

That's right, Sandi is really excited to talk about the rear end 😂

As a former body structures engineer, I was geeking out with you Sandy. The hybrid cradle is nuts and looks to both enable motor drop and reducing high frequency motor NVH edit: "Furthermore, random noise and low-frequency firing orders are contrasted against tonal motor harmonics in the mid- and high frequency ranges. " cdn.ymaws.com/www.saimeche.org.za/resource/collection/BDB66635-3CA0-42B7-8354-83943412755B/2014_07_Bekker_-_FINAL,_2014,_30,_47-54.pdf So EV is quieter than ICE, but because it's quieter the high frequency motor harmonics are more noticeable when you're at the RPM to excite them.

@rkan2

3 жыл бұрын

I'd imagine any automotive electric motor to be quite quiet and smooth though..

@TennisGvy

3 жыл бұрын

@@rkan2 Mostly, but they still do have some problems. They have a common problem with stirring up vibroacoustics in the 3,000+ Hz range. I can find some references if you're interested

@Dimitri88888888

3 жыл бұрын

@@TennisGvy plz do

@TennisGvy

3 жыл бұрын

@@Dimitri88888888 "Furthermore, random noise and low-frequency firing orders are contrasted against tonal motor harmonics in the mid- and high frequency ranges. " cdn.ymaws.com/www.saimeche.org.za/resource/collection/BDB66635-3CA0-42B7-8354-83943412755B/2014_07_Bekker_-_FINAL,_2014,_30,_47-54.pdf So EV is quieter than ICE, but because it's quieter the high frequency motor harmonics are more noticeable when you're at the RPM to excite them.

@elektrotehnik94

3 жыл бұрын

@@TennisGvy please do, for sure, it sounds interesting... it's the EV aspect we never really hear about in detail, from anybody

As of May 2021 only about 26,000 Mach Es have arrived at dealerships and customers from its assembly plant in Mexico. Best of luck, Ford.

now if only I could afford this...probably the first and only crossover I would consider buying

I am glad Ford decided to do something special

God I love these videos. Now considering the MachE after my Model 3 in a few years.

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks Joe.

@Matzes

3 жыл бұрын

Re-evaluate in a few years. Both companies will continue to improve/evolve

@VoxelLoop

3 жыл бұрын

@@Matzes Regardless, it's great to see Ford put in a serious EV contender! I'm honestly surprised they did though. 😅 A lot of thought went into this vehicle and fresh thinking.

@Matzes

3 жыл бұрын

@@VoxelLoop sure thing. I would also like to know if and how much money they make on 1 EV sale

@VoxelLoop

3 жыл бұрын

@@Matzes Even with the cost savings, I imagine Tesla will be making more. Tesla has ramped up their cell production really well and is seeing the benefits of that in cost per KW. 🙂

I like the use of MacPherson struts in the front; low initial cost, reasonable geometry, and low cost of repair. Most owners won't know the difference between struts and an upper and lower control arm setup. They're not going to drive it like a race car around corners.

A good rear end is always exciting!

@rogerstarkey5390

3 жыл бұрын

Especially with concentric drive!

i-pace, Bolt and e-tron has coaxial, e-tron front only, i-pace both front and rear

Good content. Can't wait for a full teardown.

@MunroLive

3 жыл бұрын

Coming soon!

@elektrotehnik94

3 жыл бұрын

@@MunroLive WOOOOOHOOOOOOOOOOO! Song: kzread.info/dash/bejne/lXaKx7CKXdDak7w.html

Sandy is exited about the rear end.

As a german engineer i totally agree with Mr. Munro. (But i am not involved in cars..)

Great walkthrough and sounds like the car well build. What I am curious about though is that a lot of reviewers and buyers are complaining about the harsh and bouncy ride of the Mach-E. Now, granted this is a heavy SUV so some compromises are to be excepted, but for example the Id.4 that Sandy thought was poorly build and had a cheap suspension has a much better ride experience.

Quick means torque, trains have been using electric motors for many decades, we’re just now getting to experience electric torque, thanks for the good info Sandy keep it coming.

Good to hear & nice insights. If I may put my two cents in, the frame sub-frame (Al casting 5:49) construction is quite similar to the one in the Chevrolet Bolt EV to my eyes. Even the way they added the extension arms & overall layout all are reminiscent of Bolt EV.