It looks like everyone in the comments section thinks this is a perpetual motion machine, not just a demonstration of the strength of earth's magnetic field
@magneticpropulsion25073 күн бұрын
Someone a while ago was like aha I can see the battery 😊
@ecomensstudios71693 күн бұрын
Pretty intresing. gonna say never thought that the earths magnetic field was this strong.maybe some torque measurements? looking foward for more experiments! :D
@magneticpropulsion25073 күн бұрын
Did measurements a long time ago. At one of the spacers that hold the two discs together the force when held 90° away from north for these magnets is close to 2 Gram Force.
@KD-bk7gd3 күн бұрын
Imagine letting this bad boy rip in a vacuum with no wind resistance.
@magneticpropulsion25073 күн бұрын
The swivel bearing is where all the friction is. Perhaps when I get it to run very smoothly it can have a pinpoint bearing on the bottom axle to reduce the load on the swivel. That can reduce friction. Anyway, it can go faster as is with some tweaks.
@jammerzz5 күн бұрын
and i subbed. let's get you monetized.
@jammerzz5 күн бұрын
have no idea what im looking at but congrats on your achievement.
@magneticpropulsion25075 күн бұрын
It's a permanent magnet stator less motor. The magnets point to Earth's north because that's what magnets do. Then a small electric motor turns the magnets so they aren't pointing north. When the magnets turn north they bring the armature around with them. And so on...
@jammerzz5 күн бұрын
@@magneticpropulsion2507 does this output any power?
@magneticpropulsion25075 күн бұрын
It outputs less power than it intakes. There's that pesky law of thermodynamics. But seriously it illustrates that the geomagnetic field is thousands of times more powerful than we were all taught. Also it turns without any reactions. For example the motor in an electric screwdriver pushes against your hand as it drives the screw. Were this motor somehow made that powerful it would not push back.
@jammerzz4 күн бұрын
@@magneticpropulsion2507 hmmm, interesting. thanks for explaining it fellow scientist.
@krtekcyberpunker15 күн бұрын
Ten mini repráček z druhé strany rádia bych autorovi nacpal do řiťky.
7 mins of everyone's life that will never be recovered.....
@magneticpropulsion2507Ай бұрын
Thanks for watching the video and commenting. You're entitled to your opinion. Would you like to elaborate?
@icebluscorpionАй бұрын
That's not auto of balance that's an excentirc shaft setup. You will never get it in balance by adding weight in that configuration. You have to learn to make centric holes first man 😂. Your real need to know the difference between excentirc setting and weight distribution
@magneticpropulsion2507Ай бұрын
Thanks for watching and commenting on the video. The holes that support the upper and lower axles are pretty well lined up. Why do you think they're not?
@icebluscorpionАй бұрын
Do you see the wobble on the round tray where the magnets lay? Either the hole is skewed or the rods /Axes are bend. Someting is definitely off center. A wrong weight distribution has no wobble in two axes simultaneously. You know when a wheel is straight with no wobble then you do balance the wheel with weights but a bend bicycle wheel needs to be retentioned the rays? How are they called in English? In Germany they are called Speichen I have out it in the translater and it spits garbage 😅.
@icebluscorpionАй бұрын
There is definitely a noticeable wobble in your construction as if something has to match play or skewed or excentric aligned, something like that. 🤔
@icebluscorpionАй бұрын
I see it now! It is the mount under the magnets. The holder looks off center and it lacks a constrain on top of the circle like magnet tray on top
@icebluscorpionАй бұрын
Also... I looked up your channel. Very interesting thoughts. I subscribed your channel now I'm eager to see more of your projects.
@MINIGEAR100Ай бұрын
Can you make a tutorial on this?
@furiousgamingwithkittens122427 күн бұрын
yes please make a tutorial
@MINIGEAR100Ай бұрын
Can you make a tutorial on this
@magneticpropulsion2507Ай бұрын
Thank you for watching and commenting on the video. There are no plans presently to make a tutorial.
@janplexyАй бұрын
Pro tip: flux is your friend, clean that iron tip.
@johnfitzgerald8879Ай бұрын
The system is then modelled by one larger weight on the left side which has twice the weight of an individual ball. The left two can be simply substituted for that one larger ball. What is happening is that the left balls velocity at impact is half that of the ball on the right. The momentum being conserved and P=mv then the left balls being 2m, then it's velocity V is P=MV or P=2mV or V=P/2m. Now do the same with the kinetic energy of K.E.=(1/2)mv^2 and the fact that at the top of the swing, the kinetic energy goes to zero as the potential energy becomes P.E.= = mgh, when g is the gravitational constant and h is the height it reaches. Using m and M=2m as well as h and H for the right and left balls, the final heights can be calculated. The summary is that conservation of energy and momentum, being conserved, are expressed as different initial velocities and heights for the beginning and ends of swings of the respective balls. The modelling that allows the aforementioned to be true is based on the assumption of perfectly elastic collisions. The issue with Newton's Pendulum or Newton's Cradle is in the marginal inelasticity and why it settles on the mass on each end being equivalent rather than one ball causing three on the other side to swing. Elastic collisions result in perfect transfer of momentum and energy between the two colliding objects. Perfectly inelastic collisions result in the two masses combing into a single body. Between these two extremes, there is energy loss in the vibrations. Even the two tapped balls has energy loss as the tape vibrates and stretches. Without a deep dive into how this energy loss varies, my best sense of it is that the reason that one ball bounces one, two balls bounce two, and so on is that energy conservation is absolute. The balance of energy between the two sides is such that it must also account for a balance of energy losses through the system. On closer examination, it is clear that, in fact, the pair of balls separate slightly, the balls at the bottom swing a bit, and all through the system there is a sum of small losses. The system as a whole finds that balance and markedly tends towards bouncing equal balls on both side unless forced to, in which case that imbalance is absorbed by variation in the internal heat generated.
@johntrainor7851Ай бұрын
So on one level the tape makes the collision inelastic and kinetic energy is not conserved but if you look carefully it is the same as if the two taped together balls were just one ball with twice the mass. But I guess what I am getting at here is that mass is defined in terms of force and force in terms of mass which is circular. In ordinary experience it doesn't matter because we might define force as a push or a pull and we have a built in intuition about it. But if your going to base a science on such a circular definition you really aught to do better. To put it another way you might ask just what is energy? Because if the balls in the middle don't move and energy is defined in terms of motion then how on Earth is energy transferred from one ball to another without moving it? Just some food for thought.
@magneticpropulsion2507Ай бұрын
There's a video on "The Action Lab" channel that says it's a shock wave that makes the number of balls that fly off equal to the number that impact the opposite end.
@johnfitzgerald8879Ай бұрын
@@magneticpropulsion2507 Right. And that shockwave dissipates as it goes. The tape changes the nature of that shock wave as well.
@sunnierfish1952Ай бұрын
Idk how but you motivated me to learn ASL
@Ukey__19Ай бұрын
Can you paint it?
@magneticpropulsion2507Ай бұрын
You can use water proof paints on the balloons around the inside sphere.
@FoxPaws-zn7zh2 ай бұрын
Just bought this and I can't get the screen working, any advice?
@mgtsmartladyАй бұрын
Same issue , four red zero display with no frequency reading. Radio works great, though.
@magneticpropulsion2507Ай бұрын
@@mgtsmartlady Look at the schematic to see the pins from the IC that go to the LED display or one pin for the tuner to the IC then check them for bad solder connections..
@mgtsmartladyАй бұрын
@magneticpropulsion2507 Removed the covers , batt holder , speaker adhesives and rechecked solder joints and all ok. Had another look at the U3 , 16 pin chip solder joints that looked ok but freshen them up. On power up channel frequencies worked. Thanks for your suggestions , must say surprised by sound quality. I have got the bug now waiting for electronic components tester kit to arrive.
@wildwildwestfan_69-kj9sp2 ай бұрын
cool!
@Mr._Bellic2 ай бұрын
0:01 This sounded like a timed explosive.
@austinferri38452 ай бұрын
I dont think thats a compass. wheres the North south east and west man
@janthran2 ай бұрын
this experiment is really unclear, it doesn't look to me like it's doing what you're saying it's doing.
@magneticpropulsion25072 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching and commenting. I appreciate your criticism and admit that it's a very informal experiment. I'd be happy if others will do a more strict test of what the video is claiming. By releasing the boat by hand there is a lot of variation in each trial. Any suggestions as to make a stricter study on the hypothesis is welcome or a reference to a study as well.
@janthran2 ай бұрын
@@magneticpropulsion2507 it looks to me like you let it go while the top side is closer to the magnet but i honestly can't follow what it is that you're trying to do anyway. neo magnets don't have fields that large so the one sitting in that room shouldn't affect the one on the boat at all
@magneticpropulsion25072 ай бұрын
The stack of neo magnets tacked to the floor are 3/4 inch by 1/4 inch n52 and are very strong even at several feet away especially on other magnets. The observation is both that the north end moves faster and the effect of the magnet on another magnet in making it turn is very much more than the attraction end to end. Thank you for your interest.
@bestamerica2 ай бұрын
hi M P... ' here is my LED kit... kzread.info/dash/bejne/mah6m7ptk8jQm6w.html
@bestamerica2 ай бұрын
hi M P... ' here is my LED kit... kzread.info/dash/bejne/mah6m7ptk8jQm6w.html
@andrewmcmurray62362 ай бұрын
You could probably alot more rpm with some decent bearings
@Bossmodegoat2 ай бұрын
Sick beat
@emberpoptartkittenz60402 ай бұрын
im loving it and very cool that it swims around the water on it's own 😊
@emberpoptartkittenz60402 ай бұрын
very nice man! i love this idea 💡😀 have you heard of a liberty engine project?
@wildwildwestfan_69-kj9sp2 ай бұрын
that's not what this is. this is powered by AA batteries. perpetual motion is impossible because it breaks conservation of energy.
@zinofilms43372 ай бұрын
Very impressive 👏🏻
@dragon908152 ай бұрын
So how did you get them point north without rotating?
@DJDome1232 ай бұрын
The earths natural magnetic field and you hold them in place temporarely until the rest accelerates ,i guess. Edit:The magnets also probably have more mass then the rest of the assemby.
@magneticpropulsion25072 ай бұрын
The magnets are a powerful compass. The torque on a compass is an exponential power or more greater than the attraction force insofar as they are related.
@videos400582 ай бұрын
fields:)) that is ufo tech?:)
@bestamerica2 ай бұрын
' my 81 LED kit is finish and beautifully color LED plus all 81 LEDs lights stays on without flashers
@erwinresearch92242 ай бұрын
great approach, please keep going on
@magneticpropulsion25072 ай бұрын
That's the plan!
@Wahinies3 ай бұрын
I wish i had seen this before ordering 603 to replace what is now obviously an 805 xD. Thank you for sharing
@therliss3 ай бұрын
Wow , thx. I buy this on aliexpress , thx for your review.
@kreepyits-o77613 ай бұрын
Min didn't come with instructions 👎🏼and i notice the resistors are two different types on the color around them didn't know what color resistors goes on the inside or outside the board
@user-ks5jc6yz4r3 ай бұрын
I never received the printed instructions. Any idea where to get that from?
@knowledge_power12153 ай бұрын
Just add weight to magner
@knowledge_power12153 ай бұрын
Attach some weight to magnets so they becaome more stabile
@knowledge_power12153 ай бұрын
Try to use normal motor free rotatible to stop counter rotation of magnet
@magneticpropulsion25073 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching and commenting on the video. Will consider your suggestion in a future iteration if such a motor and gearbox can be found already available.
@corinneoladuti16334 ай бұрын
Did it just stop? I thought it was not meant to stop at all 😅
@magneticpropulsion25074 ай бұрын
It pauses for a second during each revolution as the turning magnet catches up to the sphere. It's still going after 7 months. Appreciate you watching and commenting on the video short.
@Salute3884 ай бұрын
Thanks for sharing
@donaldfields14794 ай бұрын
*Promo SM*
@bestamerica4 ай бұрын
' how can all 81 LEDs stays lights on... no move X / Y
@bestamerica4 ай бұрын
' coool nice LED kit... can change different color LED lights on the kit or not
@laidman20074 ай бұрын
This was actually very good. The KZread public didn't give you the love you deserved.
Пікірлер
It looks like everyone in the comments section thinks this is a perpetual motion machine, not just a demonstration of the strength of earth's magnetic field
Someone a while ago was like aha I can see the battery 😊
Pretty intresing. gonna say never thought that the earths magnetic field was this strong.maybe some torque measurements? looking foward for more experiments! :D
Did measurements a long time ago. At one of the spacers that hold the two discs together the force when held 90° away from north for these magnets is close to 2 Gram Force.
Imagine letting this bad boy rip in a vacuum with no wind resistance.
The swivel bearing is where all the friction is. Perhaps when I get it to run very smoothly it can have a pinpoint bearing on the bottom axle to reduce the load on the swivel. That can reduce friction. Anyway, it can go faster as is with some tweaks.
and i subbed. let's get you monetized.
have no idea what im looking at but congrats on your achievement.
It's a permanent magnet stator less motor. The magnets point to Earth's north because that's what magnets do. Then a small electric motor turns the magnets so they aren't pointing north. When the magnets turn north they bring the armature around with them. And so on...
@@magneticpropulsion2507 does this output any power?
It outputs less power than it intakes. There's that pesky law of thermodynamics. But seriously it illustrates that the geomagnetic field is thousands of times more powerful than we were all taught. Also it turns without any reactions. For example the motor in an electric screwdriver pushes against your hand as it drives the screw. Were this motor somehow made that powerful it would not push back.
@@magneticpropulsion2507 hmmm, interesting. thanks for explaining it fellow scientist.
Ten mini repráček z druhé strany rádia bych autorovi nacpal do řiťky.
©️©️©️©️©️©️©️©️©️©️©️©️©️#copyright sorry but yep😢 the wideo might be going down
7 mins of everyone's life that will never be recovered.....
Thanks for watching the video and commenting. You're entitled to your opinion. Would you like to elaborate?
That's not auto of balance that's an excentirc shaft setup. You will never get it in balance by adding weight in that configuration. You have to learn to make centric holes first man 😂. Your real need to know the difference between excentirc setting and weight distribution
Thanks for watching and commenting on the video. The holes that support the upper and lower axles are pretty well lined up. Why do you think they're not?
Do you see the wobble on the round tray where the magnets lay? Either the hole is skewed or the rods /Axes are bend. Someting is definitely off center. A wrong weight distribution has no wobble in two axes simultaneously. You know when a wheel is straight with no wobble then you do balance the wheel with weights but a bend bicycle wheel needs to be retentioned the rays? How are they called in English? In Germany they are called Speichen I have out it in the translater and it spits garbage 😅.
There is definitely a noticeable wobble in your construction as if something has to match play or skewed or excentric aligned, something like that. 🤔
I see it now! It is the mount under the magnets. The holder looks off center and it lacks a constrain on top of the circle like magnet tray on top
Also... I looked up your channel. Very interesting thoughts. I subscribed your channel now I'm eager to see more of your projects.
Can you make a tutorial on this?
yes please make a tutorial
Can you make a tutorial on this
Thank you for watching and commenting on the video. There are no plans presently to make a tutorial.
Pro tip: flux is your friend, clean that iron tip.
The system is then modelled by one larger weight on the left side which has twice the weight of an individual ball. The left two can be simply substituted for that one larger ball. What is happening is that the left balls velocity at impact is half that of the ball on the right. The momentum being conserved and P=mv then the left balls being 2m, then it's velocity V is P=MV or P=2mV or V=P/2m. Now do the same with the kinetic energy of K.E.=(1/2)mv^2 and the fact that at the top of the swing, the kinetic energy goes to zero as the potential energy becomes P.E.= = mgh, when g is the gravitational constant and h is the height it reaches. Using m and M=2m as well as h and H for the right and left balls, the final heights can be calculated. The summary is that conservation of energy and momentum, being conserved, are expressed as different initial velocities and heights for the beginning and ends of swings of the respective balls. The modelling that allows the aforementioned to be true is based on the assumption of perfectly elastic collisions. The issue with Newton's Pendulum or Newton's Cradle is in the marginal inelasticity and why it settles on the mass on each end being equivalent rather than one ball causing three on the other side to swing. Elastic collisions result in perfect transfer of momentum and energy between the two colliding objects. Perfectly inelastic collisions result in the two masses combing into a single body. Between these two extremes, there is energy loss in the vibrations. Even the two tapped balls has energy loss as the tape vibrates and stretches. Without a deep dive into how this energy loss varies, my best sense of it is that the reason that one ball bounces one, two balls bounce two, and so on is that energy conservation is absolute. The balance of energy between the two sides is such that it must also account for a balance of energy losses through the system. On closer examination, it is clear that, in fact, the pair of balls separate slightly, the balls at the bottom swing a bit, and all through the system there is a sum of small losses. The system as a whole finds that balance and markedly tends towards bouncing equal balls on both side unless forced to, in which case that imbalance is absorbed by variation in the internal heat generated.
So on one level the tape makes the collision inelastic and kinetic energy is not conserved but if you look carefully it is the same as if the two taped together balls were just one ball with twice the mass. But I guess what I am getting at here is that mass is defined in terms of force and force in terms of mass which is circular. In ordinary experience it doesn't matter because we might define force as a push or a pull and we have a built in intuition about it. But if your going to base a science on such a circular definition you really aught to do better. To put it another way you might ask just what is energy? Because if the balls in the middle don't move and energy is defined in terms of motion then how on Earth is energy transferred from one ball to another without moving it? Just some food for thought.
There's a video on "The Action Lab" channel that says it's a shock wave that makes the number of balls that fly off equal to the number that impact the opposite end.
@@magneticpropulsion2507 Right. And that shockwave dissipates as it goes. The tape changes the nature of that shock wave as well.
Idk how but you motivated me to learn ASL
Can you paint it?
You can use water proof paints on the balloons around the inside sphere.
Just bought this and I can't get the screen working, any advice?
Same issue , four red zero display with no frequency reading. Radio works great, though.
@@mgtsmartlady Look at the schematic to see the pins from the IC that go to the LED display or one pin for the tuner to the IC then check them for bad solder connections..
@magneticpropulsion2507 Removed the covers , batt holder , speaker adhesives and rechecked solder joints and all ok. Had another look at the U3 , 16 pin chip solder joints that looked ok but freshen them up. On power up channel frequencies worked. Thanks for your suggestions , must say surprised by sound quality. I have got the bug now waiting for electronic components tester kit to arrive.
cool!
0:01 This sounded like a timed explosive.
I dont think thats a compass. wheres the North south east and west man
this experiment is really unclear, it doesn't look to me like it's doing what you're saying it's doing.
Thanks for watching and commenting. I appreciate your criticism and admit that it's a very informal experiment. I'd be happy if others will do a more strict test of what the video is claiming. By releasing the boat by hand there is a lot of variation in each trial. Any suggestions as to make a stricter study on the hypothesis is welcome or a reference to a study as well.
@@magneticpropulsion2507 it looks to me like you let it go while the top side is closer to the magnet but i honestly can't follow what it is that you're trying to do anyway. neo magnets don't have fields that large so the one sitting in that room shouldn't affect the one on the boat at all
The stack of neo magnets tacked to the floor are 3/4 inch by 1/4 inch n52 and are very strong even at several feet away especially on other magnets. The observation is both that the north end moves faster and the effect of the magnet on another magnet in making it turn is very much more than the attraction end to end. Thank you for your interest.
hi M P... ' here is my LED kit... kzread.info/dash/bejne/mah6m7ptk8jQm6w.html
hi M P... ' here is my LED kit... kzread.info/dash/bejne/mah6m7ptk8jQm6w.html
You could probably alot more rpm with some decent bearings
Sick beat
im loving it and very cool that it swims around the water on it's own 😊
very nice man! i love this idea 💡😀 have you heard of a liberty engine project?
that's not what this is. this is powered by AA batteries. perpetual motion is impossible because it breaks conservation of energy.
Very impressive 👏🏻
So how did you get them point north without rotating?
The earths natural magnetic field and you hold them in place temporarely until the rest accelerates ,i guess. Edit:The magnets also probably have more mass then the rest of the assemby.
The magnets are a powerful compass. The torque on a compass is an exponential power or more greater than the attraction force insofar as they are related.
fields:)) that is ufo tech?:)
' my 81 LED kit is finish and beautifully color LED plus all 81 LEDs lights stays on without flashers
great approach, please keep going on
That's the plan!
I wish i had seen this before ordering 603 to replace what is now obviously an 805 xD. Thank you for sharing
Wow , thx. I buy this on aliexpress , thx for your review.
Min didn't come with instructions 👎🏼and i notice the resistors are two different types on the color around them didn't know what color resistors goes on the inside or outside the board
I never received the printed instructions. Any idea where to get that from?
Just add weight to magner
Attach some weight to magnets so they becaome more stabile
Try to use normal motor free rotatible to stop counter rotation of magnet
Thanks for watching and commenting on the video. Will consider your suggestion in a future iteration if such a motor and gearbox can be found already available.
Did it just stop? I thought it was not meant to stop at all 😅
It pauses for a second during each revolution as the turning magnet catches up to the sphere. It's still going after 7 months. Appreciate you watching and commenting on the video short.
Thanks for sharing
*Promo SM*
' how can all 81 LEDs stays lights on... no move X / Y
' coool nice LED kit... can change different color LED lights on the kit or not
This was actually very good. The KZread public didn't give you the love you deserved.
good work 👍
Merry Christmas, you are a genius
kzread.info/dash/bejne/h2GCq6tqgsfSk7Q.html
your number 1 subscriber!
Can this energy be harvested?
only by the reaper of souls
It's very great.