Пікірлер

• 
  @personnelente8 күн бұрын

  Aside from massacring the French names, not a bad video.

• 
  @PortmanRd9 күн бұрын

  Two years later, and the English would be bang it again. But this time amongst themselves. Obviously got bored. 😅

• 
  @scottleary846810 күн бұрын

  I love your realistic animations and also your depictions of the surrounding terrain.

• 
  @henryvagincourt450210 күн бұрын

  You cannot de-string a crossbow, like a longbow, they work in a totally different way.

• 
  @sasanachmor13 күн бұрын

  Liberated? Silly and inaccurate phrase as Normandy and Aquitaine were ancestral lands of the Plantagenets for hundreds of years. You are applying the modern concept of nationalism incorrectly to a period of time centuries before it was developed. The Bordelaise feared the French conquest at the time.

• 
  @PatrickButler-pp4hh12 күн бұрын

  You lost. And 571 years after the event, I suggest you get over it. And for the record in the many battles between French and English, the French won more battles than the English. Look it up.

• 
  @sasanachmor11 күн бұрын

  @PatrickButler-pp4hh I didn't fight in it, so I didn't lose. I am also "over it". I don't need to look it up because I have already read multiple history books, wiki-boy. If you read what I said, it was a comment on the misapplication of modern thought and terminology to a time period where that didn't apply. If your podcasts and tiktok history have taught you any big words, that's an "anachronism". A "no-no" (term on your level) for history.

• 
  @PatrickButler-pp4hh11 күн бұрын

  @@sasanachmor Oh dear. Your petulant (another big word) reply says it all about you. Ar do rothar anois a stór.......

• 
  @sasanachmor11 күн бұрын

  @PatrickButler-pp4hh If I was too aggressive and personal in my response, I apologise. I had a bad stomach ache this morning when I replied, which explains but doesn't excuse my rudeness.

• 
  @PatrickButler-pp4hh11 күн бұрын

  @@sasanachmor Apologies are a rarity in these exchanges, where ego often plays a very subjective role, so I respect you for that. Hand on heart I also am a keen student of history, but I am acutely aware that, as they say, "History is written by the victors". As a proud Irish European my greatest wish is that our great continent will finally stop decimating itself every generation or so. But sadly, some have been at war for so long that it is by now in their DNA. Slán leat...Guten Tag......bonne journée.....e buona giornata a te.

• 
  @christianguiraud762514 күн бұрын

  Too many mistakes. Good effort anyway.

• 
  @destroyer068516 күн бұрын

  This is the English method: hey didille let's go up the middle

• 
  @GGdeTOURS3716 күн бұрын

  TY to have the courage to also speak about some English lost battles! This is rare from the English historians and I respect you very much for that! Guillaume - City of Tours - France

• 
  @sasanachmor13 күн бұрын

  There is loads of content online created by English historians about English defeats if that's your fetish. Redcoat History has a video "5 worst defeats of the Victorian era." He has videos that cover defeats in the American Revolution, Indian Mutiny, Boer War, Zulu War, etc. The English don't celebrate or romanticise defeats like celtic nations do, but they don't conceal them either.

• 
  @PatrickButler-pp4hh11 күн бұрын

  @@sasanachmor "The English don't celebrate or romanticise defeats like celtic nations do, but they don't conceal them either". No ?......What about Dunkirk, while you sneer at France for surrendering in what was a hopeless situation. France had already seen 200,000 + dead while you lost a total of 400,000 in 6 years.

• 
  @sasanachmor11 күн бұрын

  @@PatrickButler-pp4hh Dunkirk is celebrated as the victory of the everyday little people who banded together to pull something out of the jaws of complete defeat. They celebrate the little boats, not the soldiers who fought and died at Dunkirk, because they lost. Victoria Crosses aren't even given out in losing actions, despite how brave anyone was. Arnhem was different because the soldiers were put in a situation that they never could have won. The soldiers who died in the failures at Crete, Singapore and Hong Kong are never given a second thought. Respectfully, the Welsh, Irish and Scottish have historically celebrated and written songs about Culloden, the Battle of the Boyne, Wolfe Tone, Bonnie Prince Charlie and Owen Glendower but I can't think of any think of any English equivalents. If an English general dies in an unsuccessful action, they are unsung and it's considered that they did the only decent thing by dying so they didn't have to be court martialled and executed. After the Battle of Fontenoy the King's own brother was court-martialled and it was only the proof of his personal bravery that kept him from execution. The French are more level-headed and don't write their inglorious dead out of history. That's not a criticism, that's just an observation on cultural difference. We only have a lot of history recorded because the French had a cultural difference in recording history. We only have lots of songs, poems and literature because the Celtic peoples of Great Britain and Ireland have a cultural difference in artistic subjects. Is Éireannach í mo bhean chéile. Tá meas agam ar Éirinn.

• 
  @pinkysuspegasus16 күн бұрын

  Awesome video, as always. Is there a way to support your work? Buy me a coffe, Patreon or anything else? Also, just a quick question/suggestion: During the visualisation of the first english attack (app 5:00 - 6:33), don't you think that the french cannonade would have somehow disrupted the formation of the attacker, which should hence look a bit more rugged/distorted, than it does in the video?

• 
  @battlesin3d7016 күн бұрын

  Hi. I've enabled the "sponsor" feature on my channel. You're probably right about breaking formation, I'll try to use that in the next video. Thanks!

• 
  @PaulinAsia_16 күн бұрын

  Thank you for the video. I never heard of the Battle of Castillon. Such a defeat for the English.

• 
  @alexbardoux729717 күн бұрын

  Congratulation for your excellent pronounciation of the french names, however hard it is ! (i sometimes miss). A sad story for lord Talbot and his son . The story of the one hundred years battles tells that attack is inferior to defense in this period.

• 
  @Misael.896618 күн бұрын

  Joan of Arc prophesied that the English would lose the war in France. very good video.

• 
  @Trebor7414 күн бұрын

  Joan of arc was a myth. Created during the Napoleonic period in order to give France an anti-english heroine.

• 
  @MarquisVincentBissetdeGramont18 күн бұрын

  Thank you for this video! We hear too little about French military victories! 🙂

• 
  @NeroPh.D19 күн бұрын

  nice video

• 
  @micahistory19 күн бұрын

  great video, i have never seen this battle animated before

• 
  @historybattles3D19 күн бұрын

  Only few of us know how much work this video requires... Great job!

• 
  @micahistory19 күн бұрын

  yo, one legend meets another

• 
  @battlesin3d7019 күн бұрын

  Thanks!

• 
  @battlesin3d7019 күн бұрын

  Sorry I accidentally deleted a comment

• 
  @dickthecat747019 күн бұрын

  Those borders at first looks like some one just scribbled on a map lol.

• 
  @PacoOtis23 күн бұрын

  Weak!

• 
  @alexbardoux729723 күн бұрын

  Did god send the deer ? I'm sure many soldier asked this question, on both sides, these with "Jehanne" and these against....I heard about an english general galloping to cacth his vanguard further north, and the soldiers believing he was fleeing increasing the panic. Are there any sources thereabout ?

• 
  @dylanwilliger26 күн бұрын

  1066 THE CONQUEROR CAME NEVER FORGET REMEMBER THE NAME 1066 THE SAXONS WERE SLAIN THE DAY THAT THE CONQUEROR CAME

• 
  @zurgesmiecal28 күн бұрын

  yeahh sure yt, only 5 comments🙄

• 
  @johnconnery1939Ай бұрын

  Great video. Bravo

• 
  @delinquentinparadiseАй бұрын

  Sick and tired of these American Commentary’s There are too many mispronounced words and it’s mostly Conjecture. It’s supposed to be History but this is a joke.

• 
  @mikeyb4610Ай бұрын

  I live 5 miles from Bosworth and the local Geography is nothing like that displayed in this video…it’s flat land with no prominent hills and definitely no valleys!…so this scenario would never had taken place…nice try though!…

• 
  @slartibartfast42Ай бұрын

  This would make a lot more sense if you mentioned the battle of Fulford, two miles south of York that took place a few days before. This explains why the viking army was split up and their armour was in their ships at Riccall. Three battles in a very short space of time , that had the weather been different could have taken place in a different order, with vastly different outcomes.

• 
  @annedejong1040Ай бұрын

  Superthanks

• 
  @GAM3RK1NG.Ай бұрын

  my ancestor through the male line, sir John ll de Lynyen served in this battle and the campaign, and even served until the army of lancaster returned home. he was also a felon (his wife supposedly did something illegal and he housed her apparently not knowing), and he would’ve been in prison and lost all his land, but henry grosmont himself personally testified in court of John’s good service in gascony that henry witnessed, and John was given a royal pardon with his house and allowed to return free man

• 
  @GAM3RK1NG.Ай бұрын

  wife not house

• 
  @dupplinmuir113Ай бұрын

  The real cause of the Hundred Years War was the French attempt to conquer England, in concert with their Scots jackals. Edward only declared his claim to the French throne after the war started.

• 
  @micahistoryАй бұрын

  really cool animation, can't believe how small this channel is

• 
  @battlesin3d70Ай бұрын

  thanks

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  They were pissed as farts they done well to hold on that long

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  50 minute battle

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  6 thousand Irish 9 .000 french and they bull horned the Irish and killed them all

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  Knowingly

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  French Vs Irish Harrold and his men were from Irish ancestry

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  The french bad Shields and blocked them as they matched up the hill

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  Harrods men had bow men they all had bows

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  God told them

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  Harrods was at the rear he was a coward he said and they had horses and were ready to ride off they knew they were going to die

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  There was no battle at Stamford bridge prior to this one

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  Harrold had archers

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  And they only lost as they were drunk they were throwing up in the battle field

• 
  @pegasus6724Ай бұрын

  They were all highly trained warriors just evil that's all

• 
  @yarp123123123123123Ай бұрын

  typical french.....

• 
  @adambane1719Ай бұрын

  I would have watched this except for the cheesey hard rock music that makes the viewing experience.... unbearable ! Lose the "music" bro.

• 
  @battlesin3d70Ай бұрын

  agree

• 
  @adambane1719Ай бұрын

  @@battlesin3d70 Nice one.... thanks !

• 
  @zurgesmiecalАй бұрын

  good times good times

• 
  @copferthatАй бұрын

  Never heard of this battle, which looks like a text book campaign. Perfidious Albion at it again.

• 
  @tibsky1396Ай бұрын

  Most were Occitan Gascons.

• 
  @zurgesmiecalАй бұрын

  @@tibsky1396 sneaky Frenchies never change

• 
  @tyrson4331Ай бұрын

  Great that you covered a lesser known battle. Didn’t know about this one

• 
  @richardpham4473Ай бұрын

  Love the content! Just think the thumbnail could be better

• 
  @battlesin3d70Ай бұрын

  agree

• 
  @kruchokluchokАй бұрын

  Значит у тебя еще и канал на англиском есть. Честно ооворя удивлен