Пікірлер

• 
  @keyelschienn6679Күн бұрын

  They're both olympic bound now.

• 
  @liamneels8197Күн бұрын

  This is perfect and stands against the test of time! Rewatching now in time for Paris. Thank you so much for investing your time into making all these videos! (Currently binging your channel 🤓)

• 
  @FlipFlyTumble12 сағат бұрын

  Thank you so much!!! :)

• 
  @ds-lx5je7 күн бұрын

  Great video! Would you by any chance analyze Shang Chunsong’s floor routine from the 2016 Olympics (AA Final) everyone says it’s very underscored and it might be interesting to look at. Great content!

• 
  @jenniferli729510 күн бұрын

  Since the majority of athletes are not doing the ring leap correctly, shouldn't the difficulty rewarded be increased?

• 
  @user-cy2nt5kc1e10 күн бұрын

  for me this is still my favorite vault from her! The distance!

• 
  @alfy80mc20 күн бұрын

  Effortless!! ✨✨✨

• 
  @EsterBresolin-th5qq24 күн бұрын

  Its is actually 0.3 for bent knees i think

• 
  @DoitfortheAnthem25 күн бұрын

  Animation used is helpful .

• 
  @preludetak25 күн бұрын

  Urazova got deductions?

• 
  @ZuranthiumАй бұрын

  Her front aerial shouldn't be deducted for bent knee, it's near impossible to do a full split on that and not bend the knee a little to prepare for the landing, unless you want an injury. No deduction for arms on the straddle jump, they aren't overly bent or ungainly. The two "adjustment" deductions shouldn't be here, that was moving choreography, notice the arms. The .3 balance you gave should be seen as .1 balance and then .1 adjustment separately. She has sufficient side choreo, there's clearly a series of traveling steps with varied upper body movement throughout. This video shows how the code can be misused and one of the reasons why there is so much E-score bunching. It's sad when a routine like this is denied from even getting high 8's on execution.

• 
  @ilaria.acquaroliАй бұрын

  actually kaylia never gets it credited

• 
  @corystajduharАй бұрын

  Here's the best double layout I've ever seen. It's from Trinity Thomas. Form is perfection and she floats so high in the air. kzread.info/dash/bejne/c66HqZWLqbPYeMo.html

• 
  @marjunmarcelocristobal2678Ай бұрын

  The other Asian Gymnastic crazy countries like Korea,Taiwan are keenly watching.

• 
  @antmfan231995Ай бұрын

  Honestly not bad in terms of deductions considering this routine was 11 minutes long

• 
  @corystajduhar2 ай бұрын

  That was even higher than I remembered.

• 
  @mrparts3 ай бұрын

  Too subjective . None of these examples show a clear objective threshold of when the half turn stars. These fake “half turn” releases should be worth the same as the original element.

• 
  @poshbo3 ай бұрын

  This becomes highly subjective. They should just make it so that if you catch in cross grip it will not be credited; you must catch in full reverse grip to have it credited

• 
  @cocoroni10313 ай бұрын

  I hope Kaylia this year can turn like Ellie so she will get 0.2 bonus

• 
  @tyuxhen73023 ай бұрын

  Kaylia nemour Algeria 🇩🇿

• 
  @volodymyrdolia65443 ай бұрын

  On that slow motion only the girl in red seems legit to me. All the second girl initiated for the slight arm movements necessary for the mixed grip catch.

• 
  @quitted72763 ай бұрын

  I have a question, can a skill be downgraded AND receive execution deductions? What causes a skill to get downgraded? Like a switch ring jump with the back foot only reaching shoulder height. If this jump is downgraded to a switch leap, will that impact the execution score?

• 
  @michaelwilson85913 ай бұрын

  The only problem I have with this is that the deductions were then what they were. You can't really say it's worse execution or take off because it means she would probably have a whole different routine. Don't tell me Shawn would have happily taken 6 tenths in artistry deductions without changing things.

• 
  @FlipFlyTumble3 ай бұрын

  We all know that. The video is simply to educate others about the deductions in the current code.

• 
  @zk93394 ай бұрын

  Achievement unlocked: Collect all possible execution deductions in a single vault.

• 
  @Vicki__xx4 ай бұрын

  So what would she score averagely with today’s scorings? Would she be good enough to medal in 2024?

• 
  @ilaria.acquaroli4 ай бұрын

  x0.6 artistry is taking count of the steps without choreo?

• 
  @enricos.49934 ай бұрын

  that punch front... is it tucked or piked? shouldn't this be deducted?

• 
  @plantsforlife11204 ай бұрын

  GORGEOUS GYMNAST!!!!!!!!!

• 
  @plantsforlife11204 ай бұрын

  It is just AMAZING how nit picky the scoring still is considering today’s gymnastics has become so much more acrobatic and not artistic based. Scoring needs to be revamped or another sport category all together needs to be made to acknowledge these changes.

• 
  @776alpha677beta4 ай бұрын

  Old video but awesome editing! People choose to see perfection watching Nastia perform because her look. She was super skinny and super white. So people ranted about those “lines” and failed to recognize all that lacked. She still was top at her time flaws and all though. She was just way overhyped compared to many others that had their time in spotlight and were much cleaner in form. She was sometimes quite sloppy but finished and the comments were insane about how perfect it was. Gymnast less thin & less white will not blind people with love of those features and they will get way more deductions now and then

• 
  @junglesuperstar92704 ай бұрын

  You sound so racist . It is insane .

• 
  @Bxyxox4 ай бұрын

  @@junglesuperstar9270not a single lie was told. Nastias execution was subpar

• 
  @user-cy2nt5kc1e13 күн бұрын

  ​@@junglesuperstar9270 gurl be fr

• 
  @jodywilley27744 ай бұрын

  Clearly, these judges were never in gymnastics. I mean a deduction for a flexed foot? Try landing a skilled while your foot is pointed. I think you would break something or worse. She sas and always be one of my favorite gymnasts. SO MUCH POWER IN HER SKILLS!

• 
  @JoseDeJesusSanVicente-wg4hf4 ай бұрын

  PLEASE COULD YOU MAKE A COMPARISON VIDEO ACCORDING TO COP 2022-2024 OF THE ALL ARROUND ROUTINES OF NASTIA, GABBY, SIMON AND SUNISA TO SEE WHAT POSITION EACH ONE IS LEFT

• 
  @JoseDeJesusSanVicente-wg4hf4 ай бұрын

  PLEASE COULD YOU MAKE A COMPARISON VIDEO ACCORDING TO COP 2022-2024 OF THE ALL ARROUND ROUTINES OF NASTIA, GABBY, SIMON AND SUNISA TO SEE WHAT POSITION EACH ONE IS LEFT

• 
  @ae29484 ай бұрын

  I never knew "insufficient tuck" was a deduction. I've seen it dozens of times in the last ten years, but the announcers never mention it.

• 
  @jodavitow3 ай бұрын

  Announcers never mention 90% of the actual deductions judges would take. Specially the NBC ones, those are usually the worst ones.

• 
  @tjexplorer4 ай бұрын

  Wow, so looking at the 2023 World Championship event scores, that would put her between 6th and 7th place today. I know very little about gymnastics. Is that right? If so, are gymnasts today executing that much better today?

• 
  @FlipFlyTumble4 ай бұрын

  the reason for the low score is mainly that obviously this routine was not constructed for today's code especially artistry. plus, in 2008 they needed more skills (10 counting instead of 8) so more room for deductions. i think standards of execution are definitely much higher today but gymnasts like shawn would probably have been able to adapt to the code if they were competing today

• 
  @freddycooks4 ай бұрын

  Thanks for taking the time to do this.. I was hoping to see the difference on D-score between codes, but I see now the title does say "E-score"...

• 
  @alexi87414 ай бұрын

  Mother is back

• 
  @FlipFlyTumble4 ай бұрын

  😂

• 
  @Bxyxox4 ай бұрын

  I love these videos so much, so interesting to see how the COP has evolved

• 
  @andrewhumphrey74294 ай бұрын

  What would the D-score be?

• 
  @deivisbinho4 ай бұрын

  Same doubt

• 
  @thiagomelo74254 ай бұрын

  6.1/5.9 i think

• 
  @ansonpang4 ай бұрын

  I think the pike jump at 2:01 doesn't reach horizontal so that's a deduction right? The Back Pike also seems to have leg sep/bent knees

• 
  @FlipFlyTumble4 ай бұрын

  the only technical specification for pike jumps in the code is that hips have to be <90º

• 
  @tadg20034 ай бұрын

  In this era, routines like Shawn with most acro skills are almost none deduction prone unlike the Nastia like routines with dance elements

• 
  @cocoroni10314 ай бұрын

  Yes, but acro skills (E or higher) are generally more risky, and many gymnasts pause for those huge acro skills. Shawn is very dynamic and has a great flow.

• 
  @Dianette974 ай бұрын

  I am happy to see this channel posting again ❤ One sugestion : I would like to see more videos about routines from 2023 world championship. Thank you! Keep on posting! 🤗

• 
  @FlipFlyTumble4 ай бұрын

  Thank you so much I’m actually working on a bunch of content from 2023 worlds so stay tuned 😃

• 
  @andreag36154 ай бұрын

  That roll on the shoulders doesn't count for close to the beam choreo?

• 
  @cocoroni10314 ай бұрын

  It counts but she only has one. She needs two choreos or one more low beam element (e.g. wolf turn).

• 
  @colesmith75094 ай бұрын

  I’m so proud of you for taking the leg separation deduction on her layout combo 😭 everyone for years has said it’s perfect and I’ve always been shocked

• 
  @cocoroni10314 ай бұрын

  Her layout is so good, and it's so true that she has zero deduction. One advantage of her routine is that she doesn't have any connection deductions.

• 
  @darklight10304 ай бұрын

  Wonderful quality content. I've always loved the echo of the beam sounds in this broadcast haha

• 
  @KaiOpaka4 ай бұрын

  Honestly if someone could isolate that stuff and loop it, I'd love an ambient gymnastics noise video.

• 
  @sharifuddinsalleh71194 ай бұрын

  I'm TIRED of this kind of videos. Everyone knows how the rules and regulations of artistic gymnastics have evolved!!!! There's NO REASON WHATSOEVER to pin point what previous GREAT GYMNAST would have scored under the present system. Such comparison is STUPID, UNFAIR AND UTTERLY DISRESPECTING of previous champions.

• 
  @airballoonzmacaroons5624 ай бұрын

  Mans got a degree in yapping

• 
  @cocoroni10314 ай бұрын

  It doesn't disrespect the gymnast. Many gymnasts would've changed their routines under the new code. But the video is about how the recent judging apply to all routines, including those in the past. It is helpful because it's easier to know which routine doesn't adapt to the code.

• 
  @colesmith75094 ай бұрын

  This is so dramatic. No one is criticizing Shawn in this video. Youre the only one that took this as a jab at Shawn

• 
  @mariusa.58634 ай бұрын

  I didn’t take it that way either but I can’t blame someone who does. The "result" is basically "Look, she’d score way worse nowadays". And that can be seen as unfair. I don’t really see the point of a video like that, btw. Of course she’ll score worse since her routine was designed for another CoP. Anything else would be pure coincidence. I found it interesting to see what gets deducted exactly, that was helpful. But I don’t get why an old routine was used for that.

• 
  @ansonpang4 ай бұрын

  @@mariusa.5863 It's an opportunity to see how the COP has evolved over time. 7.6 is not the worst E score if she changes up some of the artistry. Also, she will be doing less skills since the 2006-2008 COP requires them to do 10 skills but now most people do 7 skills and count like a B skill so with adjustments and better work on the landing, she can score a 8.2 or above and is competitive with the current routines e.g. Simone, Shilese, Zhou Yaqin

• 
  @airballoonzmacaroons5624 ай бұрын

  LET'S GOOOOOOOOO NEW VID

• 
  @MademoiselleNuna4 ай бұрын

  Such a thorough analysis! Thank you for the high quality content 🥰

• 
  @FlipFlyTumble4 ай бұрын

  Thanks for watching!

• 
  @paulohenriquecolussi93894 ай бұрын

  love it!! you're amazing

• 
  @FlipFlyTumble4 ай бұрын

  Thank you so much!!

• 
  @mrdsn1894 ай бұрын

  Thank you Emily