Hello Fans of MIDDLE EARTH, NARNIA and the WIZARDING WORLD.
Here we can share Theories related to the 3 WORLDS created by J.R.R. Tolkien, C.S. Lewis and J.K. Rowling.
The Stories of these 3 worlds are so intertwined that discussing common aspects, similarities in characters and comparing the Lore would be a DELIGHTFUL Experience.
JOIN me to explore The Golden Trio of these All Time Favourite Series.
FUN FACT:
The Primary Part of the the 3 Series has 7 books each!
Пікірлер
GREAT VIDEOS! ✌️ I recommend you to read: 1. HIS DARK MATERIALS 2. FOUNDATION
Thank you for the suggestion
Yes, this is the message in the Chronicles of Narnia with the greatest relevance and gravity. Thank you!
Well done, but you should stop looking so good, I'm trying to focus on the theory.
Great video!
These theories are super interesting! Loved this video!
Don’t forget the bats!
Very well theorized. Just a suggestion - your videos will work really well in shorts and reel format with some HP background music and some AI generated art of characters you talking about just like Movie Flame channel. Looking forward to more such theories😊
I think petunia didn't want to know anything about wizards and witches or magic, cause of the jealousy of her sister
I had this notion that Petunia wasn't against magic (as she wanted to be a part of it) but had to internalise her feelings due to Vernon's strong beliefs. She may have been head over heels if Dudley was a wizard.
Yes I agree
Ok 1 the veal is probably where they study death (nick even says that they death in some form in the department of mystery’s) also if love is weaker then horcruxes that kinda undermines the hole series because the hole point is “love concurs all” and good wins over evil so the most evil thing in the series beating the most good thing in the series is kinda dumb. This is a topic though that would have a lot of depth maybe super carlen brothers could expand on this
May be you didn't watch the entire video as towards the end, I explain how Lily's love overpowered the Horcrux. Thanks for the comment though.
When you put it like that, it makes perfect sense
Thanks 😊
did Gollum not know it would make him invisible?
He did, as in his story it is mentioned that he would have fun being invisible when he was still a hobbit and play pranks on others. That is why he knew Bilbo had taken the ring and became invisible.
You deserve more subscribers, I hope the algorithm blesses you.
Thank you for the support. Kindly share the videos too
Thanks for the theories good day....
I really love all your Narnia theories! I just finished re-reading The Magician's Nephew and found myself wondering about this very thing. I also found myself wondering about the extent of the magic the apple would have had in our own world, as magic from other worlds seems unpredictable and in some cases, disappears entirely, such as in the case of Jadis. Perhaps a similar thing might have occurred with the apple? It may have healed Diggory's mother, and given her cruelty and despair, but would it have given her magic or immortality?
Love your channel Thank you for making all these videos! I've been really enjoying them :)
Thank you for the appreciation. Please share the videos too
I love the Chronicles of Narnia, but C. S. Lewis harbored racist viewpoints. He depicted the Calormen as an amalgamation of Middle Eastern and Islamic cultures who worshipped the equivalent of Satan. There's only one good Calorman named Emeth, and he doesn't even make it to Aslan's country!
I think Bard was the hero not in place of Bilbo but in place of the Master of the town. It was up to the people of Lake-Town to defend themselves against this foe that someone else awakened. It should have fallen on the Master's shoulders but he was a coward and he sucked. Bard, in contrast, was steadfast and brave and stepped up to save the people. So I think Bard's actions were intended to highlight the Master's inaction and wasn't really supposed to reflect on Bilbo. At this point in the book Bilbo has definitely come a long way from the guy who wanted to go back home to get a hanky, but having him kill a dragon I think would have been unrealistic. The way Tolkien had Bilbo discover Smaug's weakness, on the other hand, I think was more believable and also because Bilbo found the dragon's proverbial Achilles heel, it also served as a way to balance out the harm the Company did to the town by pissing off the dragon. The only part that bothers me is how Bard is able to understand the thrush. I know the book is full of mythical creatures and wizards and the like, but having a bird talk to some random guy with no explanation of how the guy can understand bird talk (in my opinion) is really asking a lot from the reader to just "go with it."
I love your content. Would like to see you get more subs, I think making shorts would help get your channel seen more.
Thank you for the support and suggestion.
Nope , you are reaching out far.
Wow
This was really insightful! I really love listening to all your theories, you put so much thought into them!
This was really beautiful, I love all these theories, but most importantly, how closely they align with the books and the thoughts of the authors.
This was such a really interesting theory! The mystery of the dust and the rings has always baffled me, and I think this is one of the most interesting concepts I have heard yet!
Much appreciated.
I just discovered your channel and I absolutely love your videos
Thank you.
2nd view and 1st comment. Wish you good luck with the channel!
Did Tolkien and Lewis Create Similar worlds- Arda and Narnia? Please share your thoughts
PROFESSOR DUMBLEDORE...
impressive! must have taken ages to memorize all these.
Thank you for the appreciation
I would like to extend the challenge to all the harry potter fans and channels.
Excellent ideas! You are a genuine sage! I suppose it was irrelevant who exactly arrived in the new world. "A world that has not yet been created," as they think, which actually has no time going. Yet living persons arrived and they brought TIME into that world. They started to speak, interact and move. This provides sufficient reason to deduce that they began the timeline of the Narnian world. We know, of course, that it was Aslan who started this timeline too, by bringing them into that world. May Peace come to you!
Thanks for sharing your ideas.
Was the presence of Jadis essential for the creation of Narnia? Please share your opinion
the deplorable word has fascinated me for years. these are some really interesting questions! i wish we knew more about her and her sister
I agree. Jadis's story from Charn would be fascinating to read.
ez sub, I'm all about hearing LOTR theories
How FAIR was Dumbledore in keeping SNAPE as a teacher? Please share your opinion
I realised I mixed up the names! Harry and Neville were born at the end of July NOT Lily and Neville.
Do you have a list of Villains in the Chronicles of Narnia? please share your thoughts
Do you Agree that Beorn should have contributed in the WAR of the RING? Please share your opinions.
Do you Think Dumbledore urged the Sorting Hat to put Harry in Gryffindor House?
Do you agree that Dumbledore MEANT for the Weasleys to meet Harry at King's Cross station? Please share your opinions
Do you think Jadis' sister was in the Hall of Images in Charn? Please share your thoughts below
She must have been as she was the last Queen of Charn before Jadis spoke the deplorable word. Besides it was the Hall of Images, not real people sitting there except Jadis.
In my head canon, no--the deplorable word probably erased even the history of all things that were living at the time (aside from Jadis)--which would be extra disturbing
Tolkien was a genius in adding Riddles in Gollum's cave! Please share your thoughts about the theory below
Is it wise to trust Hagrid with something as important as this? Getting Harry ? Retrieving the philosopher's stone? Please share your opinions on this theory.
How Queer did you find the Hall of Images in Charn? Please share your thoughts below
How do you believe Glandring and Orcrist were Twin Swords? Please Share your thoughts below
Dumbledore's trust in Hagrid FAILS my Reasoning.. Perhaps Fantastic Beasts series holds the key. Please share your opinion on this.
Do you think it is SAFE to be in the wood between the worlds? Share your opinions below.
It's me again. I just had an idea for a theory. Because, I read Narnia books some time ago and I I'm not sure how time passes there in comparison to a real world. Between first and second part of the book in Narnia passed hundreads or thousands of years. I don't know how much time passes between second and third part, but I thought in the real world it was similar amount of time (between first and second part of the book and between second and third part). If that's so then why Caspian is still alive? Mabye I'm wrong, but can you explain me this?
Hello Yes it's true. Between 1st and 2nd parts 1 year passes in real world but 1300 years pass in Narnia. Between 2nd and 3rd part, again 1 year passes in real world but only 3 years pass in Narnia. Also, in Silver Chair again 1 year has passed since Eustace went to Narnia but 70 years have paased and King Caspian is an old man. I would love to make a theory on this. Thank you for the suggestion.
@@menwwtheories3002 Thank you ❤️
The theories you present are very interesting. I enjoy watching your videos and I want to motivate you to keep going. ❤️
Thank you so much!
How Gandalf was unable to read moon runes and interpret the origins of the elven swords? Please share your theories and opinions.