Very interesting, but far too brief. If you had gone on for an hour, I would listen with full attention.
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vk5 күн бұрын
Thanks for your comment. I wish I could do a few longer ones, but the render times would give my computer a hernia. We'll see though. :)
@SuperZekethefreak20 күн бұрын
With a single word, Tom had the power to overturn an entire continent or send the oceans washing over it in a massive deluge. In fact, it was Tom who destroyed Numenor with a single word, and later when the hobbits (then called hob-goblins) fled to the north-east, Tom would destroy these lands west of Eriador too. Only Iluvatar had that power, and Tom would then be his Avatar. We need to be mindful that Sauron was a minor character, just a Maia like Gandalf and his fellow wizards, and like the Balrogs. Sauron served Morgoth, formerly called Melkor, who was banished to the abyss but later escaped. And after he escaped, why didn't he appear in LOTR and other stories? Because Iluvatar sent his avatar Tom Bombadil to entrap him in a tree called Old Man Willow, who was said to be "imprisoned", and not of the race of Ents. In fact, OMW had a tremendous dark power to "corrupt" the world around him to a vast extent from his location, and he is credited with corrupting the Ents. Tom lived in a small valley close to the Withywindle river which he occasionally boated down to visit the hobbits. Many of the creatures in his valley were very old and magical, with talking animals and plants. Here he stayed to guard over OMW as his jailer, until one day OMW would be released from his "chains" and return to the world undoubtedly as Morgoth, who would gather all of the old evil to him once again for one final apocalyptic battle called the Dagor Dagorath with numerous Balrogs, Dragons, massive Spiders, Trolls, Orcs and such. Occasionally, Gandalf or some other important figure visits Tom for advice concerning the future wars, so he knew the future and was willing to guide the protagonists to the correct course of action. At this times, Gandfalf et alia spent long periods of time under Tom's tutelage, which shows us the authority matrix of Maia to Iluvatar's avatar. As for his relationship to Tolkien, Tom was a doll his son enjoyed as a boy. Some claim Tolkien identified with Faramir, but in so very many interviews and letters, Tolkien was 100% clear that he most identified with the hobbits, and with Sam Gamgee most of all. There are just so very many quotes of him saying this.
@Zomfoo22 күн бұрын
Why is his head so big in the AI thumbnail art? Where is his feathered hat?
@kennethhenderson9000Ай бұрын
Although they are pleasing to look at, too many of the illustrations show mountainous backgrounds not found in The Shire. Yes there are hilly areas in The Shire, but these are not alpine crags. Think about the terrain of England. Tolkien's love of rural England is the inspiration for his Shire.
@robertbrown3413Ай бұрын
AI makes mistakes
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vkАй бұрын
I'm afraid my location high up in the Rocky Mountains has influenced my instincts about what constitutes a mountain versus a hill. But you make a good point. I promise that in the next one I won't make mountains out of molehills. :)
@glynlewis1492Ай бұрын
All ‘c’s are pronounced ‘k’ in Tolkien.
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vkАй бұрын
Thanks for the tip.
@locker1325Ай бұрын
Very nice discourse on the geography of the shire along with the cultural importance of each area. There is much I didn't know.
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vkАй бұрын
Thanks. Glad you enjoyed it.
@andreaharwood-jones7503Ай бұрын
Love it.
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vkАй бұрын
Thank you! More to come. 😀
@Tennesseepipin1791Ай бұрын
A good video 👍. I could so totally see JRR adding himself into his book or at least the ideas he believed in.😅
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vkАй бұрын
Thanks. Appreciate your input. 😃
@OrgrukАй бұрын
Michel, pronounce Mikel
@ktiemz2 ай бұрын
r u a a i?
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vk2 ай бұрын
Sorry, not sure what the question is. But I appreciate your input.
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vk2 ай бұрын
Wait, I think I just got it. Am I an AI? No. I do use AI generators. Photoshop, Audacity and other software to make these.
@Hemond12 ай бұрын
Perhaps ktiemz means "Are You An Artificial Intellegence?"@@TolkienTapestry-cq5vk
@coffeegator60332 ай бұрын
I think it's JRRT's parents. They both died when he was young and for some reason I just see him framing them in a tiny piece of heaven together somewhere living out the lives they wanted to live.
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vk2 ай бұрын
Interesting idea... hadn't considered that.
@Eudaimonist2 ай бұрын
Absolutely not a self-insert. Tolkien has commented on which character is most like him in LOTR. His answer is... Faramir. Please, let this speculation die. It is a pure ink blot interpretation with nothing to back it up. I do appreciate the Socratic refutation of the other speculations, though.
@qarljohnson49712 ай бұрын
Tolkien often changed his mind and held multiple takes on his creations. Like all good artists do. Eudaimonist is being a stultified naysayer, sans any consciousness of the possibilities of other 's unconsciousness.
@Eudaimonist2 ай бұрын
@@qarljohnson4971 Shut up, troll.
@Eudaimonist2 ай бұрын
@@qarljohnson4971 I gave an argument in favor of my position. You gave nonsense. Saying that Tolkien changed his mind does not defend the thesis of the video.
@charlessoukup11114 ай бұрын
Always wondered about BombaDIL, like, ElenDIL...the Numenorian suffix....
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vk4 ай бұрын
A good point.
@PipsKay4324 ай бұрын
Yes, I do very much think that Tom Bombadil could very well be the Professor himself putting himself in the storyline
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vk4 ай бұрын
It does answer all the questions. And thanks for your comment.
@piotrczubryt11113 ай бұрын
It was obvious to me, since I read biography of Tolkien. Still it leaves a question what status Tolkien imagined for his alter-ego. I guess of Maia who entered Arda before it was fully formed and marred.
@user-mb1hg4qu9f4 ай бұрын
👍👍
@TolkienTapestry-cq5vk4 ай бұрын
Thank you!
@pissedoffhobbit9744 ай бұрын
I very much enjoy most things Tolkien. I saw this and thought I’d give it a look. Very nice take on old Tom.
Пікірлер
Very interesting, but far too brief. If you had gone on for an hour, I would listen with full attention.
Thanks for your comment. I wish I could do a few longer ones, but the render times would give my computer a hernia. We'll see though. :)
With a single word, Tom had the power to overturn an entire continent or send the oceans washing over it in a massive deluge. In fact, it was Tom who destroyed Numenor with a single word, and later when the hobbits (then called hob-goblins) fled to the north-east, Tom would destroy these lands west of Eriador too. Only Iluvatar had that power, and Tom would then be his Avatar. We need to be mindful that Sauron was a minor character, just a Maia like Gandalf and his fellow wizards, and like the Balrogs. Sauron served Morgoth, formerly called Melkor, who was banished to the abyss but later escaped. And after he escaped, why didn't he appear in LOTR and other stories? Because Iluvatar sent his avatar Tom Bombadil to entrap him in a tree called Old Man Willow, who was said to be "imprisoned", and not of the race of Ents. In fact, OMW had a tremendous dark power to "corrupt" the world around him to a vast extent from his location, and he is credited with corrupting the Ents. Tom lived in a small valley close to the Withywindle river which he occasionally boated down to visit the hobbits. Many of the creatures in his valley were very old and magical, with talking animals and plants. Here he stayed to guard over OMW as his jailer, until one day OMW would be released from his "chains" and return to the world undoubtedly as Morgoth, who would gather all of the old evil to him once again for one final apocalyptic battle called the Dagor Dagorath with numerous Balrogs, Dragons, massive Spiders, Trolls, Orcs and such. Occasionally, Gandalf or some other important figure visits Tom for advice concerning the future wars, so he knew the future and was willing to guide the protagonists to the correct course of action. At this times, Gandfalf et alia spent long periods of time under Tom's tutelage, which shows us the authority matrix of Maia to Iluvatar's avatar. As for his relationship to Tolkien, Tom was a doll his son enjoyed as a boy. Some claim Tolkien identified with Faramir, but in so very many interviews and letters, Tolkien was 100% clear that he most identified with the hobbits, and with Sam Gamgee most of all. There are just so very many quotes of him saying this.
Why is his head so big in the AI thumbnail art? Where is his feathered hat?
Although they are pleasing to look at, too many of the illustrations show mountainous backgrounds not found in The Shire. Yes there are hilly areas in The Shire, but these are not alpine crags. Think about the terrain of England. Tolkien's love of rural England is the inspiration for his Shire.
AI makes mistakes
I'm afraid my location high up in the Rocky Mountains has influenced my instincts about what constitutes a mountain versus a hill. But you make a good point. I promise that in the next one I won't make mountains out of molehills. :)
All ‘c’s are pronounced ‘k’ in Tolkien.
Thanks for the tip.
Very nice discourse on the geography of the shire along with the cultural importance of each area. There is much I didn't know.
Thanks. Glad you enjoyed it.
Love it.
Thank you! More to come. 😀
A good video 👍. I could so totally see JRR adding himself into his book or at least the ideas he believed in.😅
Thanks. Appreciate your input. 😃
Michel, pronounce Mikel
r u a a i?
Sorry, not sure what the question is. But I appreciate your input.
Wait, I think I just got it. Am I an AI? No. I do use AI generators. Photoshop, Audacity and other software to make these.
Perhaps ktiemz means "Are You An Artificial Intellegence?"@@TolkienTapestry-cq5vk
I think it's JRRT's parents. They both died when he was young and for some reason I just see him framing them in a tiny piece of heaven together somewhere living out the lives they wanted to live.
Interesting idea... hadn't considered that.
Absolutely not a self-insert. Tolkien has commented on which character is most like him in LOTR. His answer is... Faramir. Please, let this speculation die. It is a pure ink blot interpretation with nothing to back it up. I do appreciate the Socratic refutation of the other speculations, though.
Tolkien often changed his mind and held multiple takes on his creations. Like all good artists do. Eudaimonist is being a stultified naysayer, sans any consciousness of the possibilities of other 's unconsciousness.
@@qarljohnson4971 Shut up, troll.
@@qarljohnson4971 I gave an argument in favor of my position. You gave nonsense. Saying that Tolkien changed his mind does not defend the thesis of the video.
Always wondered about BombaDIL, like, ElenDIL...the Numenorian suffix....
A good point.
Yes, I do very much think that Tom Bombadil could very well be the Professor himself putting himself in the storyline
It does answer all the questions. And thanks for your comment.
It was obvious to me, since I read biography of Tolkien. Still it leaves a question what status Tolkien imagined for his alter-ego. I guess of Maia who entered Arda before it was fully formed and marred.
👍👍
Thank you!
I very much enjoy most things Tolkien. I saw this and thought I’d give it a look. Very nice take on old Tom.
Glad you enjoyed it