Пікірлер

• 
  @AnthonyKleanz11 күн бұрын

  I go to Brooklyn frequently but mainly stay in Long Island and use FSD there. It seems to do better in city conditions compared to backroads. You give me a bit more confidence to use it more lol

• 
  @AnthonyKleanz11 күн бұрын

  Ima have to let my 2018 model 3 take me everywhere lol I mostly use it in Long Island but I guess I can try Brooklyn.

• 
  @DerekDavis21324 күн бұрын

  NYC to Prospect Park: 6 miles. A short easy drive in the daytime. Give FSD a *challenging* drive, and watch its knees buckle.

• 
  @babouin197724 күн бұрын

  FSD is impressive

• 
  @DerekDavis21324 күн бұрын

  Not that impressive: After *four* *years* in beta, FSD still fails at things that any high school kid could handle: potholes and broken glass in the road road signs: DO NOT ENTER and ROAD CLOSED parking structures speed bumps (often fails to slow down) Police and Ambulance with sirens on The list goes *on* *and* *on* .

• 
  @babouin197724 күн бұрын

  @@DerekDavis213 ok

• 
  @DerekDavis21324 күн бұрын

  @@babouin1977 Hey, we need to keep it real. FSD is just a simpleminded Level 2 assistant.

• 
  @DerekDavis21327 күн бұрын

  '2 weird interventions' on a *short* *easy* *daytime* *drive* . FSD continues to disappoint .

• 
  @margaretesulzberger297328 күн бұрын

  Best New York FSD Test-Videos are from you with your old Tesla. I’m always surprised, how little traffic there is in New York, compared to European Cities. Many other Tester seem to be overstrained already by the imagination of city traffic. You are quite relaxed and attentive. Have you tried out differences between the 3 driving modes - formerly “Chill,” “Average,” “Assertive“ - with the new FSD supervised? Think I missed some of your latest videos, although I’m following you.

• 
  @BerlinBK266228 күн бұрын

  i think the playback speed is a little off, it's a little quicker?

• 
  @uptownsfinest200628 күн бұрын

  Great vid. Can you take it across some of the major Manhattan streets, like 23rd, 34, across Central Park, and some upper Manhattan ones like Columbia U to LGA airport, W 145 to Home Depot in Bronx, W 181 and Cabrini to Pelham Parkway and White Plains Road?.

• 
  @eastmanwebb5477Ай бұрын

  Very helpful video. Thanks. Could you test on a route that includes "Bus Only" lanes.

• 
  @YinLawnАй бұрын

  When I look at these videos, I was mainly looking for disengagement due to safty. If it was disengaged due to don't want to be honked, then these type of disengagements are not preventing FSD ready to be robotaxi. 6:30 and 11:11, for example, are situations where should be disengaged...BUT not for safety reason. If robo taxi does those, it is okay. Just continue to improve in the future.

• 
  @YinLawnАй бұрын

  11:11, wow.

• 
  @TyvanTVАй бұрын

  Hands down the best FSD video on KZread. Boy you put it to the test and it passed with flying colors. Btw are you in X?

• 
  @BenSchippersАй бұрын

  2018 Model S

• 
  @TyvanTVАй бұрын

  @@BenSchippers ok nice

• 
  @scubapcАй бұрын

  I would be impressed if FSD could drive down 8th Ave near 60th St on a weekend. That should be the driving test that grants NYC driver's licenses.

• 
  @CaseyJamesOrrАй бұрын

  Dude, the moment you said "lets go on assertiven" I was like, there's no way thats NOT assertive. I would have never gone through those gaps, no less that fast. Why i I personally would never drive through NYC myself.

• 
  @bradwatson7324Ай бұрын

  Impressive!!!

• 
  @BerlinBK26622 ай бұрын

  what happened to the camera position 😂😂it almost blocked the whole rendering

• 
  @DerekDavis2132 ай бұрын

  4:20 Ambulance with lights on, FSD doesn't seem to notice 5:35 18 mph over a speed bump. FSD did not slow down at all 10:58 FSD turns right, but does not signal to other drivers 11:08 FSD gets stuck behind a cement truck. Not good FSD still is blind to potholes, broken glass in the street, or a pool of water in the street (after a rain).

• 
  @goochbootch3466Ай бұрын

  stuck. lol

• 
  @AGENT47istАй бұрын

  Shut up troll

• 
  @DerekDavis213Ай бұрын

  @@goochbootch3466 A human driver does not get stuck. 😄

• 
  @CyberCPAOH2 ай бұрын

  Solid

• 
  @DerekDavis213Ай бұрын

  Yes, Solidly flawed .

• 
  @razzarelli19882 ай бұрын

  Absolutely fantastic drive. So my Model Y was on 2024.8.4, and yesterday I received an update and it only updated to 2024.8.9! So frustrating. Not sure why it gave me that update instead of the latest 2024.14.7 with FSD 12.3.6.

• 
  @williamrogers12192 ай бұрын

  The fact that you are driving a 2018 Model S with Hardware 3 and have the same FSD capabilities as a new model, illustrates the value of Tesla and buying used Teslas where the new owner can enable this functionality for $99 per month. No automobile manufacturer provides this type of over-the-air upgrade to existing vehicles.

• 
  @DerekDavis2132 ай бұрын

  Over the air updates are wonderful, but FSD is still just a simple Level 2 assistant. Level 5 Full Autonomy is a long ways off.

• 
  @AGENT47istАй бұрын

  @@DerekDavis213 The classic troll hating SpaceX or Tesla in every comment. Shut up mofo

• 
  @markl38932 ай бұрын

  Ben Schippers - FSD is no longer beta software. It is now FSD (Supervised) V12.3.6 Please don't call it beta!

• 
  @BenSchippers2 ай бұрын

  Trust me, it's Beta. I build software for a living. There's a diff between marketing and engineering speak. It's good but it's Beta..:)

• 
  @yesno9592Ай бұрын

  @BenSchippers It's to remind people that they still need to pay attention while they use the system. 'Beta' sounds a lot like 'better' that might make people too confident in the product, that is still going to be in a beta stage until level 5. Not everyone is familiar with software engineering jargon... bit unfair to them. 😕

• 
  @Aku6Soku1Zan2 ай бұрын

  Tesla got so many things right with FSD 12 it's unbelievable.

• 
  @DerekDavis2132 ай бұрын

  And many things wrong too. There's a long list of common everyday things on the road that a human can easily handle, but FSD is clueless. A long road ahead, for FSD.

• 
  @AGENT47istАй бұрын

  @@DerekDavis213 Shut up troll

• 
  @ken-mb5cp2 ай бұрын

  Dude you’re the FSD Master in my book. Move over Omar.

• 
  @BenSchippers2 ай бұрын

  hah. Love Omar..:)

• 
  @ken-mb5cp2 ай бұрын

  @@BenSchippers Let’s see Omar drive FSD in NYC. NFW!

• 
  @ken-mb5cp2 ай бұрын

  @@BenSchippers I use it in Jersey but it scares me so I disengage a lot.

• 
  @ken-mb5cp2 ай бұрын

  Deez nutz.

• 
  @diymadness23302 ай бұрын

  I can hear that Tesla build quality with every bump you hit in your model S. Sad cause that is exactly how my old one sounded.

• 
  @paulrybarczyk50132 ай бұрын

  I love how your video starts under the historic Williamsburg Bridge. I'm sure its builders never imagined self-driving cars under their bridge 120 years later. Great video ... thanks! 🙂

• 
  @DaKrawnik2 ай бұрын

  FSD v0.12.3.6 Fixed.

• 
  @kingsworld89032 ай бұрын

  why does ur tesla look old

• 
  @kingsworld89032 ай бұрын

  looks better than the new ones in my opinion

• 
  @KC-uw6phАй бұрын

  Amazing thing is the older models can utilize FSD without any hiccups that’s because they future proofed all the cars with hardwares.

• 
  @mthuhn2 ай бұрын

  Just to let you know when you're on the highway it is still on version 11 not a version 12 that will come on version 12.5

• 
  @bradstewart70072 ай бұрын

  That is not a fun drive. The FDR is so narrow, and in heavy traffic it’s stressful to stop and start. FSD looks life-changing already for commuters who drive.

• 
  @DerekDavis2132 ай бұрын

  A very easy drive, all freeways. Maybe next time, something more challenging for FSD? How about Manhattan?

• 
  @Astros-dz4bx2 ай бұрын

  Hey bro, any chance you can drive around the Astoria area?

• 
  @BenSchippers2 ай бұрын

  Sure, will try next week.

• 
  @warrenlee3932 ай бұрын

  can you make a video driving through the downtown. I wanna see how it handles many cyclists, cars and people. thanks. subscribe you.

• 
  @DerekDavis2132 ай бұрын

  Other KZread creators have made videos of FSD 12.3.6 in NYC, and there are many *human* *interventions* required.

• 
  @BenSchippers2 ай бұрын

  @@DerekDavis213 Not my experience

• 
  @BenSchippers2 ай бұрын

  I'm putting one up shortly

• 
  @DerekDavis2132 ай бұрын

  @@BenSchippers So you are ready to lean back in the car and close your eyes? You trust FSD to drive in NYC all by itself?

• 
  @KC-uw6phАй бұрын

  @@DerekDavis213was that what he said? You still have to supervise it. But if you’ve seen videos it does very well around humans, maybe a bit too safe at times but better safe than dead. With the rate of improvement we could all probably lean back and relax by the end of next year latest

• 
  @babouin19772 ай бұрын

  what do you use for your camera mount?

• 
  @BenSchippers2 ай бұрын

  I'll try to find our for you.

• 
  @zhli42382 ай бұрын

  That drive was awesome. For title, maybe it should be “FSD 12.3.6 dealing with NYC morning madness”. I just realized that Tesla can see surroundings better than human drivers, because of 8 cameras and AI, essentially in rear views. This drive is all about super awareness.

• 
  @DerekDavis2132 ай бұрын

  FSD can certainly NOT see better than a human driver. FSD cannot see potholes or broken glass in the road. FSD cannot see a gate that raises and lowers. FSD will drive right thru it, if the human does not *intervene* . FSD cannot see ROAD CLOSED or DO NOT ENTER signs .

• 
  @Kaipiso2 ай бұрын

  Of course 8 cameras can see more than two eyes. You are mistaking seeing and recognizing what you are seeing. FSD can see better. Humans can reason better - so far. Humans often do not see stuff at all. So they cause millions of crashes each year. So even that great monkey mind cannot help it.

• 
  @RichardTaylor-TheWoodlands2 ай бұрын

  ​@@DerekDavis213 ... YET

• 
  @DerekDavis2132 ай бұрын

  @@RichardTaylor-TheWoodlands FSD is *years* behind schedule. Your 'YET' could be another 10 years.

• 
  @George2647g2 ай бұрын

  This is highway stack mostly (v11).. 12.4 will have full neural nets for highway as well (like it does city streets)..

• 
  @Aku6Soku1Zan2 ай бұрын

  12.5 not 12.4

• 
  @BenSchippers2 ай бұрын

  Nah, don't think on FDR. I suspect it's using 12.3.4 all the way here. Totally different from v11.

• 
  @razzarelli19882 ай бұрын

  ​@@BenSchippersbut Tesla mentioned that anything not on city streets is still V11

• 
  @FriedChairs2 ай бұрын

  @@BenSchippersYou aren’t showing the part of the screen but you can tell when auto speed switches to a set speed is when it has switched to v11 autopilot.

• 
  @Aku6Soku1Zan2 ай бұрын

  First for TESLA on Mars

• 
  @808GT2 ай бұрын

  A U turn, in NYC. Impressed.

• 
  @808GT2 ай бұрын

  Amazing. Please more heavy traffic madness.

• 
  @808GT2 ай бұрын

  Awesome video. Makes me very hopeful to see this on my 2017 MS with HW3 as well. Keep them coming because in these conditions, thats where it really shows. Please add when you need to nudge the accelerator or take over so its clear where it trips up. Maybe time stamp it or have an on screen counter.

• 
  @razzarelli19882 ай бұрын

  You really cant score it for what it did when merging onto the highway. Dont forget, highway is still running the 11.4.9 coded stack rather than the new neural net V12. So cant fault it yet.

• 
  @user-rr9fy4ie8w2 ай бұрын

  진정한 ai이네..미국인들아..이 좋은 기술 안 퍼뜨리고 뭐하냐. 중국이 다 쫓아오는데...기다려 주나?

• 
  @maximilianmander24712 ай бұрын

  6:30 ist an F inmy opinion..

• 
  @razzarelli19882 ай бұрын

  Keep in mind, the highway is still running 11.4.9

• 
  @Robert…Schrey2 ай бұрын

  9:18 !

• 
  @babouin19772 ай бұрын

  what mount are you using for your camera?

• 
  @zhli42382 ай бұрын

  Awesome ... an 82-year-old female driver would be freaked out by this course of driving. Now, FSD can robotaxi her.

• 
  @DerekDavis2132 ай бұрын

  If Ben presses the accelerator pedal even once, that is an intervention. That means that FSD cannot properly drive alone.

• 
  @BigBen6212 ай бұрын

  Is this your new obsession? That's absurd. "I did give it one acceleration tap just to move faster". It would have driven alone just fine-it would just have taken a few seconds more. In fact, that's what the vast majority of interventions are-just to speed things up a bit, which would be just fine without the intervention.

• 
  @ericgregori2 ай бұрын

  @@BigBen621@Big_Ben_from_La_Mesa This guy(Derek Davies) is spreading FSD FUD (of course, with zero evidence) on my channel as well.

• 
  @808GT2 ай бұрын

  @@BigBen621 Ignore the troll.

• 
  @BerlinBK26622 ай бұрын

  what a perfect FSD video, nice pace of commentary, interesting route. Hope you keep making more of these.

• 
  @yourjjrjjrjj2 ай бұрын

  It completely failed when someone else was doing this in manhattan. It's not ready yet.

• 
  @user-sx7er3ot3z2 ай бұрын

  인간의 이기심을 이길 수 있을까