Пікірлер

• 
  @edwinjusto57399 күн бұрын

  Man it takes alot to make a despicable character suddenly somewhat likable, this was masterful metatron had been up until this point a pos and like that 1 episode is all it took to make him somewhat good

• 
  @Bigeasy18615 күн бұрын

  Gabriel also stood up for humanity when he spoke to lucifer.

• 
  @Tauya18 күн бұрын

  Josh!!!!!!!!!!!! 🌼❤️

• 
  @mayfelias461228 күн бұрын

  Still can't believe that Billy Miller is gone 😢😢.

• 
  @havinfunfallin9458Ай бұрын

  Atheism in a nutshell of if god isn’t real/if he has abandoned everything then we are what he says because we never give up. But god does…

• 
  @MechaKnuckles2 ай бұрын

  Great analysis. Crazy that this video comes out, and then mere days later is Backslide, one of the most blatantly religious songs the boys have released in a while.

• 
  @moonshimmer93412 ай бұрын

  Awesome video! (Funny too lol) Thank you for sharing

• 
  @reylui02502 ай бұрын

  does anyone have the lyrics trasncribed? My native language its no english. Thank you so much

• 
  @adamcahill19292 ай бұрын

  Lua, you always put in so much work creating great thoughtful videos. Thank you. |-/

• 
  @poptivist2 ай бұрын

  <3

• 
  @alecrosema48852 ай бұрын

  Love how you referenced all the old songs and it’s crazy to see how consistent Tyler has been with many of his metaphors throughout all his works

• 
  @alecrosema48852 ай бұрын

  Thank you for the open ended explanation. 🙏🏻 I do think, that given Tyler’s faith, the journey to Sun ultimately will lead to the Son. His open minded stance however means that the ending will be intended for everyone to connect with, and I’m very excited for it

• 
  @semilovelyheathen41562 ай бұрын

  Excuse us while we sing to the sky ❤my daughter and I got matching tattoos of these lyrics

• 
  @DropsofJuniper772 ай бұрын

  Loved it Lua ❤

• 
  @makeitwithalex44832 ай бұрын

  Thanks for putting this video together and all the research you have done - I really enjoyed it

• 
  @Ponce172 ай бұрын

  As someone that considers themselves Christian. This makes me very happy, it's nice to see someone put their religious beliefs into their music. Even though he's not extremely vocal about it, it's cool. I wasn't raised in a home where my mom beat us and forced her view of Christianity on us or used Christianity as a way to justify hateful comments. She would take us to church and tell us that we will have our own path with Him and it's our choice to make.

• 
  @sunasday2 ай бұрын

  this is a really well edited & executed vid! I hope u get way more views 4 this <3

• 
  @RyanJohnson-vm5rz2 ай бұрын

  I don't what's more impressive, the fact that Tyler Joseph made up this beautiful madness or the fact that you are spotting it all. Both are gifts. I hope he's seen your videos.

• 
  @poptivist2 ай бұрын

  🥺💝

• 
  @ac-ow3du2 ай бұрын

  great vid! keep it up

• 
  @RyanJohnson-vm5rz2 ай бұрын

  I've watched so many videos about what people think is going on in Tyler's lyrics. This may be the most well thought out, thought provoking explanation of some of those things. Well done.

• 
  @poptivist2 ай бұрын

  that is so cool to hear. i really worked on this. if you're interested, the video i'm most proud of and probably put the most weeks into was one called "christmas saves the year: darkest timeline" which predates the outside and its ritual aspects. from someone so well-read, so to speak, i'd be interested in your thoughts. (you do have to scroll past about 70 concert uploads lmao)

• 
  @RyanJohnson-vm5rz2 ай бұрын

  @@poptivist I'll check it out for sure

• 
  @loonofmoons2 ай бұрын

  Furthering a bit i just thought about in drown the lines "I walk to you, rain falls from you. Can you wash me? Can you drown me?" In literature, water/washing of a person signifies baptism/renewal/rebirth pretty much everywhere you can read. So, pairing that with your interpretation of the sky being God could deepen those lines to Tyler literally asking God to reform him, or make him better, or to basically take him and make some sort of Tyler 2.0 that is maybe less sad. OR, going with the line of "Can you drown me?" Tyler is asking God to just completely, and maybe even violently, get rid of him/remove him from the very earth/ground (ground and earth in particular because, well, they are not the sky, and could even be called the exact opposite of the sky. I'm not very religious, so this next part can be read with a grain of salt, but one notable biblical figure that also follows a similar line of thinking to that is Judas. Judas is controversial in some sects of Christianity, but going by the Catholic interpretation (or at least what I understand of it), our betraying homeboy here is stuck in hell completely frozen/paralyzed. However, if you think about Judas in terms of character analysis, rather than biblical teaching, you'll have to consider the extremely close, brotherly relationship he had with Jesus. Judas betrayed Jesus, yes, but then regretted it to the point of suicide, and is then relegated to an eternity in hell, which is torture. This guy hated himself so much, despised himself and the action he took, that one could argue he outright *refuses* to move, choosing instead to root himself to some corner of hell in an effort to forcibly not exist anymore. Anyways, I kind of started yapping, but I felt like some of this brain vomit would be interesting to consider.

• 
  @poptivist2 ай бұрын

  🫨 just unlocked some intense jesus lore i did not know about (thank you for watching <3)

• 
  @ezekielcoronado7002 ай бұрын

  ​@@poptivistI would like to add a couple things to what you said. One of the most famous bible stories is Noah. We're God flood the whole earth because everyone was so evil and so much innocent blood being spilled that the blood in the ground literally shooted for justice. Second I would like to point to ancient Jewish cosmology. And in ancient cosmology the pre creation state, or rather pre ordered state, it's was just the waters and God. But the God created heavens and earth and set the waters apart. And waters in ancient cosmology represented decreation, or rather chaos. And this was usually personified by serpents or sea serpents. Anyways sorry for rambling

• 
  @tigerlewis73702 ай бұрын

  You have so many fresh perspectives that make so much sense, I get so much out of your videos. I really appreciate how deep you go into the Christian metaphors even though you aren't religious yourself, it takes alot of self awareness and curiousity to do that, I respect it alot.

• 
  @poptivist2 ай бұрын

  thank you so much my friend. 🫡❤️‍🔥

• 
  @owalterluan2 ай бұрын

  Great video

• 
  @loganmontague1172 ай бұрын

  “East is up”…

• 
  @makaijensen9312 ай бұрын

  Your voice is so soothing and your ideas and visuals are both beautiful and well-articulated. Love it. Stay classy Wisconsin

• 
  @poptivist2 ай бұрын

  thank you so much :']

• 
  @abidonaghy2 ай бұрын

  honestly Tylerrs writing with regards to religious text and the trauma that can be sustained from being raised in that environment speaks so closely to me. I know what he's trying to say but there's no hope in any lifetime i could explain it, but i see it ripple out through all his art. its beautiful and other words that fail me right now. I'm glad the algorithm brought me this video, its somewhat validated what i've been feeling!

• 
  @MNCLIQUEMOM2 ай бұрын

  LUA!!! Wonderful video and I appreciate all your knowledge and work here! @abidonaghy with all respect to your opinion, I can 99.9% guarantee you that Tyler was not traumatized from being raised in a family of faith. It’s my opinion that Tyler does write about wanting to be able to have proof God exists, looking for a concrete source of spiritual strength. He questions - which everyone on this earth has probably pondered at one point and he yearns to know God is real, especially when he needs God at vulnerable moments. In the end I know that Tyler’s entire family is a family of faith, and here I can assume Tyler also lives in the faith that God or Him or a higher being exists. Of course I am not in Tyler’s mind, and I am speculating based on what I know about his family and in-laws and Jenna’s siblings. Personally I feel “Trees” lyrics literally state Tyler searching for God - I also consider “Trees” a final blessing from Tyler for every person in earshot, and this is why he ends every show with “Trees”. That’s my hypothesis. I feel Tyler is spreading love and not for any certain religion, but love and safety and peace to all. Tyler is a minister in certain ways and his live shows are like church to me! Every one can define what art -lyrics- means to each individual. Everyone has their own belief in a higher power and that relationship is personal. Tyler questions everything. Especially when we suffer from mental health issues - faith doesn’t seem to be enough to take the pain away. I’m sorry this is long-winded and I probably went off course, but the main point I wanted to make is that I very much DOUBT Tyler was ever TRAUMATIZED by being raised in a strong faithful Christian home.

• 
  @Arthiurito2 ай бұрын

  I don't onow if it really relates to the video. But I think i just realized something about mulberry street. He says "we are pushing sideways, keep sidewalk unde your feet". Like he is telling to people to move out of the middle of the street and back to the sidewalk just like the next semester music video. As a way of saying that the things you use to keep your bliss help you get out of this suicidal state and back to the sidewalk to keep going. I don't know if it makes sense, but I like this interpretation

• 
  @VanetaRogers12 ай бұрын

  Love this video. I agree with you on almost everything!! You are so smart to figure all this out and I’m so glad you shared it. I do want to say, however, that I think you are missing one thing….I think some of the lyrics you cited to say that Tyler wants to die are actually a Christian thing - and not about suicide. In Christianity, you are supposed to die to self. That’s what baptism is - you kill your old self and are born again in Christ. So although I don’t know that everything you referenced is referring to a Christian death (you’re probably right about a few referring to a desire for literal death), I’m pretty sure many of them are - especially the one in Holding On To You (you can take my life, you can take my soul). It’s like how, in Trees, he sings “I can feel your breath, I can feel my death, I want to know you…” - he’s not talking about his body dying; he’s talking about his spiritual death and being taken over by the Holy Spirit (God). He wants God to take his life, take his soul, but not his body. At least, that’s what I think. But only Tyler knows!

• 
  @VanetaRogers12 ай бұрын

  Also, I have subscribed!!

• 
  @blueJadeistyping2 ай бұрын

  KZread just randomly recommended me your video and I don't regert it at all. Great analysis! Nice comment about Clancy, a protagonist, still relying on death to spread his message. Never thought of this before.

• 
  @poptivist2 ай бұрын

  thanks for your response :)

• 
  @BiboBidhon2 ай бұрын

  Always coming to your channel to get the right perspective.. at least i can say the closest

• 
  @alextheartsyastronaut2 ай бұрын

  you just gave me a thought and now i gotta share it cuz ouchie. you mentioned even the suicides go to heaven and that lead to this- what if trees is about the ring of violence specifically violence against the self, in dante's inferno, because the people who have committed suicide are slowly becoming trees?

• 
  @alextheartsyastronaut2 ай бұрын

  the sound you mention as "that thing is alive and well around" 16:26 reminds me of a car that's struggling to turn over. like it wants to start so bad but it's too cold

• 
  @nadyavishnyakova82973 ай бұрын

  this was such a thorough analysis, wow. thank you for the video, it opened my eyes to some things regarding the lore. |-/

• 
  @RyderOverash3 ай бұрын

  0:02 Guns For Hands 2:14 Slowtown 7:10 Kitchen Sink 12:13 Anathema 16:01 Ruby 23:21 Ode To Sleep 25:19 Trees

• 
  @martybernshow70233 ай бұрын

  So Tyler being turned to a bobby would be a visual for compensating yes?

• 
  @poptivist2 ай бұрын

  *squint* bobby?

• 
  @martybernshow70232 ай бұрын

  @@poptivistbobble head

• 
  @xoparker3 ай бұрын

  I’ve been missing this. Thank you for uploading ♥️♥️♥️

• 
  @Yandhi23 ай бұрын

  Now that I’ve seen ‘Next Semester’ I associate the cyan/blue color with the lights of the car. Any emotion or lyrics that has some association with that moment has the color blue. Reclaim cyan, reclaim that moment. Idk.

• 
  @alfonsok713 ай бұрын

  This show is what started it all for me ❤❤❤

• 
  @yourfriendlyinternetmeatshield3 ай бұрын

  Thank you. First video of yours ive seen, just sorta stumbled here doing my own thing and needed to know exactly what the bishops were for my own reasons.

• 
  @C-SD3 ай бұрын

  Copyright jail. 😂

• 
  @AaronMeade-gj9pl3 ай бұрын

  0:53 this is why i prefefer the angels to the ones in hazbin hotel metareon talks like a human turned angel whos seen lifetomes of people come and die the ones in hazvin hotel just look stoned and look like swimsuit models

• 
  @C-SD4 ай бұрын

  Wait, we never saw trash turn pink. I love how he was like "I run for a while" in interviews, and people picked on him.

• 
  @poptivist4 ай бұрын

  i'm not sure if trash CAN turn pink, being the pinker-of-things

• 
  @ffann1004 ай бұрын

  This season was really good and Curtis is one of the reasons why

• 
  @mdogg0944 ай бұрын

  Thank you for this video. Every album cycle has hit at a different time in my life. This brings me back to being in college and driving for hours to see this tour live. It’s really impressive you cobbled this together!

• 
  @poptivist4 ай бұрын

  thanks very much :']

• 
  @jaredsmith39004 ай бұрын

  settings>accessibility>displays&text>invert colors

• 
  @jaredsmith39004 ай бұрын

  pink is the green color from trees

• 
  @jaredsmith39004 ай бұрын

  Watch everything you did on your iPhone w/ inverted colors.

• 
  @detgoat4 ай бұрын

  is this same color in ned's cup?? plus same dark blue shirt since hds video seemed to start cycle

• 
  @navigating_my_head4 ай бұрын

  This. Is. So. Good. Amazing actually. You’ve put this together so well, coupling what you’re saying with sounds, lyrics and interviews; that’s a lot of work you’ve put in. Thanks so much for this. 👍

• 
  @MuscularMayhem4 ай бұрын

  Lua, If I hadn't met you in person I'd start to believe you were Josh leaking all of Tyler's secrets. 😂 You have the best content! Much love, KT 💜 PS: When is my PURPLE era?!?

• 
  @detgoat4 ай бұрын

  can confirm she's real person that's really the best on colors, and many other topics

• 
  @poptivist4 ай бұрын

  JUSTICE FOR PURPLE

• 
  @airdrummer554 ай бұрын

  I love the way you made this.

• 
  @poptivist4 ай бұрын

  thanks!