As an engineer this discussion at granular level on bleeding edge battery work just so interesting thanks Munro and Associates and Zeta Energy these deep dive specifics are genius insights.

@nononsenseBennett

Жыл бұрын

I'm very intrigued by the growth of these tubes. I hope to see more on this technology

@tarstarkusz

Жыл бұрын

No. This was long on promises, long on fluff and very exceptionally short on actual data or even a sample battery.

@mattbutler8880

Жыл бұрын

This is alchemy

@rwyo83

Жыл бұрын

another scam

@danielene7904

Жыл бұрын

He is retired, this is what he loves doing 😉

This is a proper conversation where everyone listens to and understands one another. Thank you for a clear and concise video.

the regularity and uniformity of those nanotubes is kind of mind blowing

@nononsenseBennett

Жыл бұрын

Reminds me of the filaments of asbestos. Could this be a health hazard in handling when recycling?

@karenrobertsdottir4101

Жыл бұрын

It's a nice science experiment, but it's always hard to believe that CVT can get the throughput for something that needs to be as cheap as battery electrodes. That said, they are dealing with quite short CNTs, so 30 seconds isn't terrible, and if they go to even smaller coating thicknesses (lower energy density, higher power)... maybe? :) The other issue I'd *really* want to know more is their cathode chemistry. As a general rule, all the methods I've seen to alter the cathode chemistry to prevent the polysulfide shuttle problem dramatically reduce the energy density.

@dantebarnes8187

Жыл бұрын

@@nononsenseBennett interesting insight, recyclability is vastly important I would think.

@geoffgeoff3333

Жыл бұрын

​@No Nonsense Bennett only 5% of asbestos was crystalline (cannot be easily expelled from body by cilia&mucus) - the majority was 95% amorphous and easily removed. The hysteria over asbestos was initially ginned-up by the Trial Liars and their well-paid so-called expert witnesses from the lower echelons of their graduating class. As always, once the hysteria gets going, it's impossible to stop. Analogous to bank runs on o/w solvent banks, planetary global warming hysteria even though we know other planets in solar system also warming, shipyard workers getting lung cancer while insulating hulls and smoking 2 packs/day, EMF cancer claims when HV Line workers have no increased cancer rate than genpop, etc., etc., ad nauseum.

@Mathis218337

Жыл бұрын

@@nononsenseBennett just don't inhale it lol

Very impressed with your work Sandy. it’s great that you continue to contribute to the world of engineering even though you could probably afford to retire. you obviously are well respected in the community. Thank you.

@DEtchells

Жыл бұрын

Hah, I’m sure there’s no “probably” about Sandy’s ability to retire if he wanted to 😁

@johnjaeger4804

Жыл бұрын

@@DEtchells no doubt but he obviously loves his work. too bad most people can’t do that

@myjizzureye

Жыл бұрын

@@johnjaeger4804 I love your father and there is no "probably" about his ability to push back.

The future will appreciate all the interviews with the many battery startup teams

After Tesla bought Maxwell and took what they wanted, they didn't disolve the rest. They sold it back to the VP of sales. It goes by Ucap Power now.

@Gareebaa84

Жыл бұрын

What’s interesting is that they have really failed to implement the gains of that technology i.e. battery day. They have only really implemented a couple of the bunch of innovations i.e. 4680 form factor, tab-less and battery frame. They are struggling to scale the dry coating tech which is key to reducing complexity, cost and waste and I think there was 1 or 2 other things they have yet to deliver on. Hopefully they will get there, but I think they are some time off by the fact they are asking for suppliers for generic 4680 cells.

@marknevar8234

Жыл бұрын

@@Gareebaa84 Perhaps you missed the Investor Day comment where they confirmed dry battery anode and electrode problems were solved at scale.

@Gareebaa84

Жыл бұрын

@@marknevar8234 indeed I did. Thanks. Still skeptical, why order 4680 from other suppliers if after 2yrs investment in scaling up they don't have the capacity yet?

@patreekotime4578

Жыл бұрын

@@Gareebaa84 About the only thing they had failed to deliver on was price, and now prices are coming down as well. The big miss from battery day seems to be the $25k car... now theyd rather sell a $25k robot to take peoples jobs.

@Gareebaa84

Жыл бұрын

@@patreekotime4578 I think you agree price was intentional. There's no reason to reduce price given the demand. U saw them experiment with that price lever recently and now they are sold out again

I'm not convinced they have eliminated the dendrite issue. Looking forward to hearing more about this company. Thank you Munro live for putting this together.

@w8stral

Жыл бұрын

Dendrites will ALWAYS happen due to dissimilar materials etc, the Q, is how fast they grow before another failure happens.

@Georgewilliamherbert

Жыл бұрын

@@w8stral Their explanation about swelling resistance seems credible given the CNT forest-swelling should fill in the gaps not “out”. The cathode sulphur migration mitigation seems credible. But dendrites ... they suggest it’s not a problem but will need to show in details why.

@w8stral

Жыл бұрын

@@Georgewilliamherbert No, they did not say dendrites are not a problem just that their design severely hinders dendrite formation rate. True, they did not use the word rate, but that is the simple truth for any dissimilar material.

@gregbailey45

Жыл бұрын

I think it's about the nanotubes having oodles of space around them to soak up the Lithium.

@phillyphil1513

Жыл бұрын

re: "I'm not convinced they have eliminated the dendrite issue." exactly those who are astute/paying attention will recognize how they are not the first to claim to have resolved this issue. in fact those in the chat who aren't "baby young to the world" will recall how we heard all this same HYPE and CONJECTURE in regards to Super Conductivity back 30+ years ago (ref: circa 1992) yeah "Pepperidge Farm Remembers". now I know it's hard to believe but the 4 men speaking in video are not REMOTELY the only people with decades of Engineering experience across a variety of sectors. no, for example the Auto Industry alone employs over 10 Million people annually, so that roughly leaves another 99,999,996 talented and experienced people you haven't heard from. in fact I just flew back from Salt Lake City having spent a week with 24 others including myself.

pls more of this.. so good . learned so much

I just love these informed conversations around the table. Especially as I've got to the point in the last year or so where at least 90% of the info is staying in my brain, and the understanding isn't so temporary any more. So, for me, this was a truly great episode. Can't wait for the next one. And by the way, they can be as long as you like.

@bui340

Жыл бұрын

What's the secret of your currently well working brain?

@ramblerandy2397

Жыл бұрын

@@bui340I wish there was a secret. But it's just repeated exposure to this kind of stuff.

@myuzu_

Жыл бұрын

@@bui340 His neurons have achieved peak gradient descent

Reassuring to see a bit behind the scenes regarding battery technology development. Thank you for bringing this complex topic down to earth. Your guests were superb communicators given the obvious knowledge they possess.

Very impressive presentation 👍

I hope this tech pulls through. It would be so awesome to smackdown any remaining problems with EVs (minus charging)

@w8stral

Жыл бұрын

Well, when someone invents a moving mass produced lithographic machine this battery tech can become possible, until then, this is a pipe dream.

@DEtchells

Жыл бұрын

Actually, that should be “… other than charging and the total inability of our grid to supply the required energy” (Maybe that’s what you meant by “charging” though.)

@briandbeaudin9166

Жыл бұрын

​​@@DEtchells ... and the complete inability of our current infrastructure to provide the dozen-or-so supply constrained raw materials at the rates needed (10× or more) to convert an appreciable percentage of the global automotive industry to EV's. Not to mention the massive recycling facilities that would have to be constructed as well. ☹

@DEtchells

Жыл бұрын

@@briandbeaudin9166 Yeah, all that too. It's an even bigger issue than the grid, but either is a showstopper on its own. It's just incomprehensible to me that the "green" forces are shutting down reliable energy production at the same time they're investing billions (many hundreds of them, probably trillions globally) in trying to force an impossible changeover to solar and wind. (And it's clearly not about saving the environment, as any rational person who cared about CO2 would realize that third/fourth-generation nuclear is literally the only non-CO2-emitting way to provide stable baseline generating capacity.) Our energy policies, hundreds of billions dollars of expenditures and the resulting impacts on global health and peace are literally and entirely based on fantasies 😖

@adairjanney7109

Жыл бұрын

evs are not even possible even with new batteries you people are so blind we need 10x more copper, 10x more silver 100x more quartz for it to be even maybe feasible and it isnt and we just lost 40% of the worlds material in Russia and Ukraine for the Jews but even that statement will come off as hate to you, because you have no idea what is going on in the world or what reality is. Of course maybe I am deluded as well but I think I know the truth. Can one ever really know

Thanks Sandy for bringing Zeta to discuss their new EV battery. Look forward to hearing more design and performance details from an actual EV battery.

OMG! Such insights into material science. Thank You Team Sandy.

Nice promising tech. But Sandy's heart sank when he heard about 2027 availability!.

Great conversation. Tom in particular was very clear and to the point every time.

One of the best videos for new battery tech I've seen since Maxwell days

Thanks Sandy and Munro team.

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

Our pleasure!

@banme2784

Жыл бұрын

@@MunroLive these guys kinda seem like bs between the cnt in mass production and the lack of an actual dischargable cell to show you. This was a weird paid ad

Incredibly interesting discussion! And I'm a food marketing executive with no engineering or technical background. Munro Live is one of my top three go-to KZread channels PERIOD, regardless of content.

@renekeystone5571

Жыл бұрын

❤

Wow, this was incredible, huge thanks to Zeta and munroe. ♥️

I have seen so many "battery breakthrough" videos in the last few years. Forgive my pessimism but I'll believe it when I can go and buy it off the shelf.

Thank you for letting the guy talk uninterrupted!

THUMBS UP: thanks for having great audio.

AWESOME SHOW!

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

Thanks!

Love the continuing attempts to make much better batteries, but we’ve seen so many not pan out that proof is needed in order to believe any claims. Good luck to them and us!

Awesome presentation. Thanks for sharing this. 👍🏼

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for watching!

Yes that was very good, thank you.

I liked this conversation the most.

I want to believe... Just as I have wanted to believe the last dozen or so revolutionary battery technologies over the past couple of decades. Somehow it seems like there is always a bottomless chasm somewhere between the promise and actual production that these technologies inevitably plunge into.

The team from Zeta is incredibly sharp. Too polished for me to trust fully. But they had an answer for EVERYTHING. Impressive whether they're truthful or not. Time will tell.

Brilliant, really interesting, thanks 🙏.

Sandy - thank you for keeping me on the cutting edge.

THE WORLD IS READY & WAITING !!! ~

Very informative and interesting technology. ❤️

Boy oh boy with all your experience and contacts made over all the years you've been in this industry Sandy, you've really gotten yourself to the top of the cutting edge of today's technology. It's AMAZING how far some of the people you know have come with cells and chemistry, I really can't wait to see these guys get it out there and become the next default for cell production. Great work to all involved. It's hard, long hours, time consuming, but the payoff for society as a whole is incalculable. Fantastic and thanks for the little education on the dendrites and how nasty those little buggers are. I have a pack that won't charge, opened it up and the 3 18650 very high mAh but low amp batteries just will not hold a charge. I'm not opening them up, it's not that big of a deal, but I'm going to be I have dendritic loss here. Thanks again!

Very interesting topic, thanks!

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

Glad you enjoyed it!

Talkabout a deep dive into battery chemistry ... great content guys and please, keep it coming. :-)

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

Thanks! Will do!

@banme2784

Жыл бұрын

@@MunroLive tell these guys to show up with a working cell. If they don’t, which I have yet to see them show a single working cell, tell them to get lost.

@melissaschilling1138

Жыл бұрын

@@banme2784 Zeta's working cells have had validation from two different government labs!

@kapytanhook

Жыл бұрын

Agreed, big talk seems easy for battery companies. Especially when it comes to cycle life and power density

@user-Dave67

Жыл бұрын

​@banme2784 I am with you on this, there's a lot of pipe dream here and everywhere. Before Munro starts interviewing companies and "Flannegans pipe dreams" Thay need to bring a batch of batteries say a 100 so that Munro can test them. Then sit down in have that interview and talk about the batteries. All of this may be a pipe dream.

Top tech discussion ,thanks Sandy

This is so great too watch engineers talk about upcoming technology. MIT's Technology Review on tape. I love it!

@dfinlen

Жыл бұрын

MIT doesn't do engineering.. All woke ass politics.. I stopped paying for the subscription.

@grzegorzkapica7930

Жыл бұрын

@@dfinlen Last time I read it was 12 years ago ;)

This is great to get a primer on this new technology. I'm hoping it can come to the automotive market sooner than 2028. I'd love to see my Rivian have the same range as my diesel Cayenne. Thanks Munroe for putting this together to help educate the masses. Another--Well Done!

👋 THANKS SANDY,TOM,TOM ,MICHAEL AND ALL THE MUNRO TEAM 🤗💚💚💚

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for watching!

@budgetaudiophilelife-long5461

Жыл бұрын

🤔 maybe something TESLA could use 🤷‍♂️💚💚💚

@billybobbob3003

Жыл бұрын

@@MunroLive huge difference between china and japan dipshits, japan wasnt our enemy after ww2...china is our current mother fucking enemy just like japan used to be pre ww2 you stupid fuck, plus tesla's charging network sucks i live in one of the most heavily populated area's of virginia and there is only one charging station in the entire city and it's @ the fucking mall lol what a joke electric vehicles are a fucking joke plus junkies cutting copper cable on charging stations and trading it in for cash for drugs you can run without catalytic converter by the way if junkie snatches that it doesnt make the vehicle inoperable unlike cutting copper cable from your power wheels charger they are heavier and wear tires faster shittier for offroad because high centered less open spots under the vehicle for rock or something to go in they wear down our roads more and we can hardly keep them maintained now muchless millions and millions of ev's the power grid cant handle millions and millions of ev's plugged in either they cant tow for shit they lose range just sitting in heat or cold unlike gasoline, charging times are dogshit they're a major fire hazzard you cant just fill them up with a can of electricity whats cheaper gas can/grabbing acouple gallons or thousand dollar portable battery pack that would take 60 hours to give it 2 % juice lol if you run out. they will be monetized pieces of shit the whole things terrible besides electric vehicles are out of date technology compared to ice vehicles, 1832 vs 1886, the design of electric vehicles trash also they are adding way too many things that are going to fail on them even somerthing as simple as charging port door or door handles its all one laughable joke besides all the stuff used to make batteries are finite resources just like gasoline and even more destructive to habitats. Besides they're a bitch to even tow the fuckers if you break down lol FUCK YOUR GODDAMN POWER WHEELS SOUND ABOUT RIGHT?

Quite a knowledge resource, this... Thank you.

Great stuff as usual. Love this channel. Could listen for 3 hours straight.

I love this stuff, Sandy and Team! Thank you!

I see some of my jets on display!!! Thanks for the discussion!

Informative discussion on aluminum sulphur. 2 Bit DaVinci did a video on the stabilization on cycling this chemistry. Ready for prime time!

This was awesome! Thank you Sandy for bringing the cutting edge technology to our attention.

Fascinating! I've just subscribed...

Good conversation and technology review. Thank you.

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

Glad you liked it!

Great battery tech, totally rocks!

Everyday again and again, we are always underway from a to better. Let it be better again and again.

They go on about the tabless design as if it was an Ultra Capacitor breakthrough but the truth is HF film capacitors have had similar construction with sprayed metal end terminations for many many years. It effectively parallels all the windings to lower inductance hence achieving better HF and and pulse current performance.

13:34 that equipment is so jank! I love it! (I'm a business owner in a niche field, a lot of the machines I use are ones I have had to design and build myself, they look very similar lol!)

Facts, information, ground breaking stuff. Pleasure to watch. Thanks

It’s exciting to see such breakthrough technology. Best wishes for continued success, thank you!

Waiting for Jordan of the Limiting Factor to chime in!

Excellent, and very informative - thanks

Go Tom! Asking the tough questions!

I enjoyed the no-nonsense format with conversations around the boardroom table, a lot of experience in smart people in that room

@kapytanhook

Жыл бұрын

Funny, sounded like some nonsense without real data. They didn't even bring one along to show off. Many specs not mentioned. Its early days but surely if they are testing for thousands of Cycles and have some laying around on cupboards . Then they have time to make a few to give for independent verification and demo purposes. But ueah still pretty good in general

Thanks!

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

Thank you

It’s exciting to see such breakthrough technology. Best wishes and continued success, thank you

Michael: Come with me if you want to live. Sandy: I'll be back.

Really looking forward to this tech making it out to mainstream! Thank you Sandy!

Various KZread channels routinely spout "! battery breakthroughs"in their titles, nice to hear about one from a channel I trust

God I love these discussions! So glad to hear little christmas trees even exist at atomic levels.

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

🎄⚛️

@HydrogenFuelTechnologies

Жыл бұрын

​​@@MunroLive​ Congrats 👏 Munro and ASSociates, welcome to the Quantum Age... Same tech works with high dense storage of hydrogen too 😉 😜 👌 👍

Thank you for sharing! Very promising!

45 mins later and I'm convinced! Munro's low key style rocks but German Tom is inspirational!

Sound all nice and good, but if they are so far in their development, why didn't they show us a battery being used? Or had one with them?

This content is fantastic!

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

Glad you're enjoying it, Michael!

Love this new stuff talk, keep it up. Someday a breakthru battery will be here but the road to hell is littered with "the next big thing" battery ... hope this one gets there.

28:00 but big cell give you another big benefit: you can balance every chemical-unit, not a module of small cylindrivals. Also you have less conectors, easier packaging, simpler assembly, easier servicing and so on.

Good video again,tx Mr.Munro regarts from the Netherlands 😊😊

Fascinating discussion. I hope this technology succeeds.

Thoroughly enjoyable presentation and discussion! Not sure what stage this is in but if there are sales pitches going on, a huge leap would be to say "did you see that Leaf/Model 3/etc. we drove in on? We swapped the battery with our own technology and all of our team has them in their cars. So far we've driven hundreds of thousands of miles on them. This phone I have in my hand? I swapped it with our battery technology. I can get 5 days worth of life from this phone before recharging and we can drive 500 miles on a single charge. Oh, and charging the phone and car are only 30 minutes each. Here's an example of different form factors of the battery. Now here's the details on how we make it cost effective, safe, and reliable"

Very interesting video 😀👍

Would love to see those as my stationary storage cells :)

@gregbailey45

Жыл бұрын

Sounds to me like good chemistry for future 4680's!

If I were an engineering University I’d give credits for watching Munro Live.

@banme2784

Жыл бұрын

Good thing you’re not a university?

@BeingMe23

Жыл бұрын

MIT: 🤓👨‍🔬👨‍💻

@audience2

Жыл бұрын

Probably better than some critical liberal arts modules

@nononsenseBennett

Жыл бұрын

Where's my degree?

@drakeweibel6616

Жыл бұрын

​@@banme2784 cçcccç xccfcxcxcc

Keep the good work

The wrap up speaks to the reality that so many people who talk about "new battery discoveries" fail to understand: The time and effort that it takes to develop new battery technology is far more than just having a better chemistry. It is being able to create a better chemistry and structure that utilizes cheaper materials and operations, plus years of testing and validation at every level, and then finding out if the process can be done at scale. All while trying to keep investment flowing to recruit and retain talent in a business that may not be profitable for decades, while hoping you can get your product to market before being left behind and/or going bust. This is not work for the faint of heart.

this was fascinating, but as far as electric cars are concerned, there are performance specifications that matter. The discussion did mention vibration resistance and volume per kWh storage, but not weight or internal resistance of the batteries or temperature sensitivity. Without meeting those requirements also, you have a product that won't work in cars but may be useful in other applications.

I've seen several promissing presentations on Li-S architectures...all of them very exciting. Lyton is another Li-S cell start-up with an optimistic outlook. This is quite exciting...if the Li-S cell can deliver, the EV future is not only guaranteed, but will dramatically accelerate.

@gregbailey45

Жыл бұрын

Now, if someone could just debug Sodium Sulphur...

Thank you!

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

You bet!

Love his Eng, Methods. Good one. Thanks

Sandy, people thought that Tesla bought Maxwell for it's supercapasitors but the real gold was the dry cell technology. I have installed very many Maxwell ultracapacitors over the years.

This was really interesting. Thank you

My takeaway from this conversation is one major key point. These gentlemen stated that we want our product to stand on its own merits. You can explain in detail how great your product is. Many sales folks make long-winded pitches with charts and graphs geared towards convincing you to have faith in their product. In the end, the only real indication of quality and trust is the product itself. One other thing with all of these new battery technology game changers is generally they are barely worth looking at. They are vague about what the new is. How will it advance battery technology in the now? Is it real or setting in a lab results-oriented speculative? Will it take trillions of dollars and 100 years before it actually exists? We have all been misled by click bate videos bragging or promising the latest and greatest game-changing battery technology. 🔋

wow, great content, Thank You!

Sounds very promising. Innovation solves problems. We‘ll see how it performs and if they can get into mass production. Time will tell.

Military radio batteries were the A battery for the filament circuit and the B battery was 90volts and went through vibrators and ran the plates.

Where on the Periodic Table is Unobtainium? Must be really rare : ) Great show : )

So exciting to see pace of change in battery technology and what that means as a Planet using variable power technologies. This also needs to be done at huge scale so the ability of a process to do this really important!!

I really like their engineering/materials goals

Gold... Thank you for this PhD

@MunroLive

Жыл бұрын

🎓

Temperature sensitivity of Li - S cells has been the bane of Li - S technology prior to Zeta’s. I ran across an ECS paper from April 2022 which studied 19 AH pouch type Li - S cells which documented almost 3.3 times charge cycle capacity fade at 30 degrees C versus 10 degrees C. Zeta stated in the video that they address the gassing issue which is apparently related to elevated temperature capacity fade. Perhaps working temperature range has benefited as well? It would be interesting to hear more, as it is certainly relevant to automotive applications.

@wtmayhew

Жыл бұрын

I tried to post a link to the paper I cited, but it was auto-removed. Search for “Investigation of the Effect of Temperature on Lithium-Sulfur Cell Cycle Life Performance Using System Identification and X-Ray Tomograph”

@Sandy I had last year a 4 week vacation parking. And the Model 3 lost about 20% it was acceptable.

@FrunkensteinVonZipperneck

Жыл бұрын

But Sandy wants to know, "What was the Frunkin' parking cost?"

@christophmartin5381

Жыл бұрын

@@FrunkensteinVonZipperneck 120€

Thank you. I'd love to see a comparison to existing EV battery chemistries and examples, on that chart showing LFP, Tesla, and ideas. Add Tesla's cheapest type, Nissan leaf, and some others.

@WoutMertens

Жыл бұрын

There's a slide at 9:31

I wish heat data thermal management on their cells was addressed on charge and discharge.

Solid State is that, not moving forward but solid in it's state!

Around 16:30. It was only 5 or 7 years ago that copper nanotubes were experimental. Engineers and other scientists still were figuring it out. And, here is Zeta energy doing it in a small factory? workshop? And, rapidly and consistently. Sandy, I can see why you brought them on your show.

They panned LFP a bit at the end with the weight penalty issue. What wasn't discussed is LFP's ability to fully discharge/recharge for thousands of cycles. So while it is heavier, you are able to fully utilize the battery. Other batteries cannot be fully discharged without degredation (mostly negating their weight advantage). If this sulfur battery can also fully discharge/recharge and be lighter, this technology looks like it really has a chance.