She’s totally right. When it comes to mascaras, pencils, lipsticks - the drugstore makes pretty good products. Foundation and powder - always high end

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

It is incredible...

@resyahusaini6641

Жыл бұрын

yup, my cheap eyebrows, pencil liner, and eyeshadow its good. but foundation is terible....

@agustinad1447

Жыл бұрын

I can never bring myself to term to buy a high end mascara😂

@snakeplissken5743

Жыл бұрын

For me mascara is important too

@javayna2353

Жыл бұрын

I bought an expensive Lancôme serum mascara at Sephoras and the tube is basically empty with only a few dry clumps in it that fell like dust under my eyes leaving me with nothing on the lashes and dirty looking face.

Saving money is EVERYTHING right now.

She’s the only content creator who can talk fast without sounding annoying

Marlena could you do a similar video about makeup brushes? i.e. which brushes we should splurge or save on?

@LilyB-vz8lq

10 ай бұрын

I haven’t tried Elf yet, but the reviews are good and price is very affordable.

"Blunt" + Brand developer + experience with chemists and labs = Trustworth. Thank you, Marlena!! 💛

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

Amazing. Really helpful and good.

@eveyluvvs

Жыл бұрын

Exactly! Marlena has the best insight!

It is rare to hear influencers acknowledge or discuss where products are made. It is something I am very cognizant of, and it informs my purchasing decisions, so it is refreshing to hear about it here . This is another reason why I loved your brand.

@MarlenaStell

Жыл бұрын

Many luxury items are made in Italy and some in USA. Mid level in USA and less expensive in China and Taiwan. Korea is taking off with their K Beauty and surpassing USA almost for some beauty items. Canada has a couple labs too and they're mid to luxury level. Poland also does great work- would say mid level.

@lanaatkins3872

Жыл бұрын

I think it's because many influencers are not as aware as we would like to believe they are, and if they get to the level of them having their own brand then they've started doing content to preserve their income - not be completely upfront anymore, but that is just what I have witnessed from different influencers over the years and my opinion could definitely be debated.

@BlingyBea

Жыл бұрын

Tarababyz always says where each product is made, love that she does that.

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

So fascinating and informative...

@35rrfd92

Жыл бұрын

The best mascara does not smudge und does not crumble at the beginning.

Best best best drugstore items I’ve found: Maybelline Fit Me Matte & Poreless (dewy version if you are dry), wet N wild breakup-proof eyeliner, L’Oréal lash paradise mascara, Milani Luminoso blush, coty aurspun powder, Essence Shine Shine Shine lipgloss, arches and halos eyebrow pomade, and ELF putty primer to fit your skin needs. I only pay big money on eyeshadow.

@DreaRahming

4 ай бұрын

Yes that's my list right there

PREACH girl! THIS is the kind of content we need now. I just listened to your podcast on The Sesh and even though Makeup Geek is no longer I’m still excited to see what’s in store for the future. I love that you stay humble and classy where so many others in your position haven’t. Keep doing the best 👊🩷

@luzlopez776

Жыл бұрын

She's very thorough and detailed

@kristagallitelli

Жыл бұрын

I just saw your comment right after I made mine and we said the exact same thing. Also saw her on The Sesh. This woman is the real deal. Fastest I’ve ever hit subscribe lol

Marlena, this video series is everything we need, especially right now! Here are a few interesting ideas to educate us on: 1) how a formula's ingredients are chosen (binders, moisture, thickeners, preservatives, etc) 2) how to tell what products may share manufacturers/be private labeled or the differences between in-house, ODM, OEM etc 3) how can you tell if a disappointing product is intentionally what the brand wanted (so just preference) vs actually being poor quality? Can't wait to see what 2023 has in store for you 🥰

@maureentakach3065

Жыл бұрын

Yes! This series is great!

@Thechanterramarie

Жыл бұрын

Yesss!! We need this to be a video series!

@sg-qu5mh

Жыл бұрын

I’m curious to hear your thoughts on colourpop’s “fast makeup” practices and other brands that are releasing new things every week.

@sg-qu5mh

Жыл бұрын

Loved this video and this content from you! It’s so helpful!

@dvorahmariscal7963

Жыл бұрын

Loved this! I worked with a cosmetic manufacturer here in So California and people would be surprised at the many, many brands that are produced in the same facility. Keep videos like this coming and happy to see you again. It has been a bit since I have seen you. Have a great weekend.

Mascara, blushes, and lipsticks. Honestly, everything has an inexpensive counterpart that will work. With that being said, I swear by Nars Sheer Glow, but I received the most compliments when I wore Fit Me dewy, by both men and women.

@BrookeAmber007

Жыл бұрын

I love fit me dewy and smooth!!

@NickaLah

Жыл бұрын

I have sensitive eyes specifically when it comes to mascara, and high end does make a difference, unfortunately. I tried some of Tati's recommendations for drugstore options and hated them 😓 I already have long eyelashes, so they should've worked. I actually think Stila's Magnum XXX is highly underrated and doesn't deserve the poor review on ULTA.

@fatanaolomi

Жыл бұрын

I’ve worn fit me since it came out in 2010 and I would get sooo many compliments

@INTELLIGENCE_Revolution

Жыл бұрын

I am a double wear fan. BUT I’ve recently tried a fit me Matt and poreless - I LOVE it. The colour match is better. And it stays almost as well !!!

@annlatham

Жыл бұрын

fit me is a go to for me and I have been using it for years!

love that she gets straight to the point.

I'm so tired of wasting money. I just found you and immediately subscribed. Thank you

Hot take, just being honest: almost no high end makeup products I've tried are truly worth the money for me. Are some of them noticeably better than their cheaper counterparts? Yes. But does that difference add enough value to my life to be worth the extra expense? No. That's just me though, and I understand that others have different makeup needs, standards, and care more about luxurious packaging than I do.

@user-cv7iv4kq6z

Жыл бұрын

What about high end eyeshadows though? I find they’re easier to blend ..

@LynneConnolly

Жыл бұрын

@@user-cv7iv4kq6z not always. I hated the Natasha Denona palette I got. Disappointing. But Beauty Bay delivers for me. I won't normally go above, say, Huda Beauty prices, because after that, the quality doesn't noticeably improve.

@ellienyah

Жыл бұрын

@@user-cv7iv4kq6zi find expensive eyeshadows to be among the least worth it (since colourpop and elf are already so good). Like sure the high end one might be better, but is it $40 better? Nah. Spend it on nice skincare instead!

@theladynextdoor313

Жыл бұрын

Agreed. Almost all high end cosmetics aren’t really worth it. Unless for just wanting very specific fancier packaging, the formulas are not superior.

@theprousteffect9717

10 ай бұрын

​@@theladynextdoor313Like yeah, high end products will contain better quality ingredients much of the time, but I don't find it makes a noticeable difference in the results.

Indie eyeshadows are also a good option for mid tier or affordable pricing. Some of the formulas knock luxury brands out of the water.

@SlackSlackSlackSlack

Жыл бұрын

Can you recommend good matte eyeshadow? Thks

@MarlenaStell

Жыл бұрын

SO true!!

@virginiaanndavidson178

Жыл бұрын

Hellllls yeh! Indie ftw ❤

@vivianebernardon9954

Жыл бұрын

I love Iby beauty, their formula is amazing, really good

@julissax5142

Жыл бұрын

Alamar cosmetics eyeshadows are sooo good

Lash Princess had me shooketh. 7 dollars and one of the BEST mascaras I've used.

Okay this video is a GAME CHANGER! It's not often that I watch a KZread video and get all brand new information that I haven't heard somewhere else, but this was packed full of so much helpful, new information. Thank you for making this!

Girl, I'm going to need a tutorial on that eye look!! It's so gorgeous!!! And thank you so much for your honesty. I had already came to most of these same conclusions but it's nice to hear it from someone with actual experience with makeup formulation

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

Love in the future...

@tracef195

Жыл бұрын

Most educated person on KZread. That is also very honest and humble

@RzucajacaWazonami

Жыл бұрын

To

@sabafai

Жыл бұрын

Thats what I was about to say here.her eye make up is just wow

So glad to have you back! You are so informative and down to earth!

Your honesty is so refreshing. It's very exciting to see your developments, thank you for your authenticity

I'm so glad you mentioned Viseart. I love that most of their palettes have removable pans that can be replaced individually.

Hey Marlena! It's great to see and hear from you! This video was great and so helpful. Thank you and please keep them coming!! Glad to have you back!!

Thank you so much for these tips. Glad that after all you’ve been through your still doing KZread. I’ve been watching you from the get go. Love you Marlena!!!😊

Thank you so much for this series!! Love all your wisdom and experience when you explain your opinions!

Marlena you are such an amazing educator! Natural teacher. I have been watching all your recent videos and I have to say these types are fabulous! So helpful!

Absolutely loved this video! It was so fascinating hearing your perspective from manufacturing and knowing the other side of the industry. Would love to see more videos like this!

Marlena thank you for the truth. You should write a book about how to shop smart. Also if you decide to go back into product development, can you make clean makeup line.

These videos are so much more helpful than any other makeup related videos on the internet anywhere. This is all straight to the point precise information that you really do need to know.

Hi Marlena, I loved this video! Your obvious knowledge and passion for the creation of make-up is inspiring. I think this is one of the most informative beauty videos I've seen on KZread and it was very easy and fun to watch. Please make more of these type of videos Marlena as I am sure I am not the only one who needs help deciding which items we should spend more on and why. Thank you for all you do for us consumers.😊

Love this series and the fact that you aren't afraid to tell the truth!

I am glad you made this video! Thank you, Marlena! This product and formulation information is so helpful/valuable.

YESSSSSS!!! This is the kind of REAL content beauty on KZread needs!!! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

Loved this!

LOVE this series and love your honesty and ability to lift other brands up. You are the very first beauty guru I started watching years ago!! THE GOAT ❤️❤️ No one compairs.

Marlena, I love this series. Thank you for your honest input.

Omggg i love this video so much.... . Please make more video on this topic which setting spray to buy, concealer, baking powder etc....

OG youtubber always giving us the real tea!! This video was so informative Ty for your professional insight!

100% agree on the mascara situation. The type of wand makes the difference. I got rid of almost all of my makeup collection and now have curated quality items I use often. So much happier. Thanks for sharing! Yes, more in this series please. 🥰🥰

@aneesa4252

Жыл бұрын

would you mind sharing some of your favourites? :)

@MarlenaStell

Жыл бұрын

Same! I cut out my collection and only keep things that I love and use often :)

@amylewis7563

Жыл бұрын

Essence Lash Princess, Maybelline Sky High, Benefit Bad Gal Bang, Loreal Telescopic.

@fnma21

Жыл бұрын

@Amy Lewis Maybelline Sky High is great! My eyelashes are short and straight and this mascara works magic on them.

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

Brighten your smile with love...

You're the best Marlena. I value your opinion and first hand knowledge of process and manufacturing. Thank you for sharing what others would not.

Thank you so much, Marlena !! I've followed you for years and years and I truly trust you. 🌹

Wow, I’ve always thought this about splurging on foundations but saving on mascaras!! Thank you Marlena for helping us so much!! I love your heart in everything you do. I can tell you actually care!!

Marlena..this...video... WAS AMAZING. I'm recently getting back into makeup and have felt so lost, overwhelmed, and skeptical. This video was so concise, on point, and fair without making me want to give up on makeup all together. Thank you for this amazing content. I wish I had got to try some of your products but I have no doubt you will create another incredible brand in the future

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

I love your face...

Love, love this educational series. Keep them coming!!

Wow! LOVE THIS INFO 🙏 Please share more of the behind the making of makeup 💄

love your videos....thank you SO much for great advice!!

Marlena, you are the BEST! Thank you for sharing these tips for cosmetics, especially as a woman in the business. 😊 We all adore you 🥰💗💖

L'Oréal Voluminous always runs on me! Literally the only mascara I've used that's ever done that on me!

I'm so glad I stumbled across your page! You're the only person I will watch for beauty tutorials!! Thank you for sharing your wisdom. ❤

Thank you. You are so right especially with the eye shadows and foundations. I enjoy your videos

Love! Love! Love! I settled in to my bath and hit play. Great content. I was sad it was only 12 minutes. I was definitely wanting more!

Marlena, this is an amazing video! Thank you so much for your honesty and transparency.

Hi Marlins!!! I missed watching your videos!!! You are one of the few real ones!! ❤

Thankyou for sharing so much information about saving and splurging on make up. So helpful. 😮

I love this series so much. thank you for sharing your knowledge and expertise on makeup.

Thank you for sharing this amazing info with us. Cannot wait to see what future launches you have. Makeup geek was the best quality eyeshadow hands down, not to mention no talc. This sensitive skin girl needs more Marlena creations

Marlena I have followed you from day one. I love Makeup geek shadows so much. These new videos that you are educating us with are outstanding. Thank you sincerely.

Fabulous content, there's sooo much on makeup all over social media, very few of those videos add value....yours is among those few useful ones

Edit: June 2, 2023 Marc Jacobs Beauty is coming back! Not sure when, but sounds like a rebrand 😊 You mentioned the Marc Jacobs eyeliner and I am sooo sad that the makeup line no longer exists. The highliner was my #1 favorite eyeliner because it stayed put and didn't transfer to my contact lenses by the end of the day. 😢

@chersilveira8944

Жыл бұрын

I know!! THEY were so GOOD! I miss those Highliner pencils.

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

They are sooo interesting...

@kjalight

Жыл бұрын

That formula is still my favorite I have ever tried. I’ve used many price points and none of them had the same longevity and wearability.

@Future-zx9ts

Жыл бұрын

I. Know. 😩I still have a few that I’m using bc they are in good condition, but I’m dreading the day I run out. I’ve found some pretty good ones (most at the drugstore), but still haven’t found a true Highliner dupe.

@AmeriTerry

Жыл бұрын

I know - I'm very careful with my Marc Jacobs eyebrow pencil. I only got 1 refill- the gel is still going. Not sure why the brand couldn't stay a float. What's funny is Tom Ford has makeup but never see any of his stuff advertise.

Thanks for doing this & for your honesty & for looking out for us. I rarely, rarely ever buy hi-end of any product. I appreciate you being here with us !

@MarlenaStell

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much Lena!! That's my mom's name - love it :)

Love love love this video and I so happy to hear the push for quality eyeshadow. I don’t feel so guilty now! My eyelids are super sensitive and I love high quality. Thank you for the awesome video content!!

Great advice. Thank you

Love the series! Keep ‘‘em coming 😊

Fabulous advice and insight! Thank you ❤😊

Loved this! Please do more 💗🥰🥰💗💗🫶🏽

This was so interesting!! Thanks for sharing, I'll love to see more videos like this one.

Love your honesty . The only brand that has my exact color match foundation is Tarte . Hasn’t failed me .

This is tremendously helpful thank you! I love how you're using your knowledge to educate others. God bless you and may you succeed in everything you do!

This was brilliant! Thank you! Yes please on the more like this. Loved hearing more about the manufacturing

Loved the video lol forward to any series

I love your energy Marlena!

I love your videos! I appreciate that you take the time to tell us, the consumer, the truth. Your reviews and opinions matter more because you have years of direct experience in the makeup industry. Thank you!

@MarlenaStell

Жыл бұрын

No problem! Thanks so much Heidi!! xoxo

You've got the info. from all the different angles we wanna know, thank you so much!

Absolutely loved the video! ❤

I love your videos ,and your honesty, I love your eyeshadows. I have 6 of your pallets and 3 blushes, and your brushes are awesome too!❤

I love this type of content. Thanks for sharing. 👍🏼

Nothing beats Wet and Wild Photo Focus foundation , Ive tried all the high end always go back to Wet and Wild. Im 61

@SaystheTruth3

4 ай бұрын

Yes! Totally 💯 agree!

This was freakin appreciated! Thanks so very much! Fast, to-the-point, helpful......the way all videos should be.

These videos are literally LIFE SAVING for my pockets! Thank you so much Marlena! Please keep these amazing videos coming!! 😍🙌🏻💞

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

I love your job.

Thank you for sharing your knowledge!! Appreciate it!

Loved this! Thank you Marlena.

I love these types oh videos! I really appreciate hearing about product development and product knowledge in general! ❤

Thanks for these honest videos!

I have been in full-blown arguments with people who swear the mascara formula is what makes or breaks the product when there is SO much information that is out there that says differently - so I am looking forward to the video you do with the correct lash brush to use for the type of lashes you have. Sticking around for awhile just because you said you'd be doing that one! :)

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

This video is extremely helpful...

@mediocrebankai3114

Жыл бұрын

I only look for the wands with bristle type brushes not the plastic! Always works better for me.

@Seraphine07F

Жыл бұрын

Complete rubbish. As long as it's a decent formula it's fine - the brush is the thing (& some kinds are better than others for certain ppl 🙏🇬🇧

@aggiaggi8306

10 ай бұрын

Maybeline mascara makes my eyes itchy , it’s because of fibres are poking my eyeballs and eye lenses. In midday I cant wait to remove it. Can someone recommend mascara that doesnt so that?

LOVED this video!! I trust your recommendations explicitly so this was a lot of fun!

Excellent, excellent video!! 50 yr old makeup geek here! I just discovered your content and I appreciate this type of content so much! I’m definitely into quality so what you say matters!

Marlena still such a beautiful soul. Definitely would love to have more in this series and you're absolutely right about Natasha Denona's 28 pan palettes. She originally was teaching color theory and offering those palettes for her students before she was more mainstream in 2016 and as demand grew, she rolled out the midi size. Learned that through Alicia Archer (formerly Kinkysweat). Any make-up history actually would be interesting to me of just how things have evolved from conceptualization to fruition and eventually the closing of Makeup Geek what has changed, what do you wish changed, what do hope to see change?

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

Love your teeth.

@Seoulsilouettes

Жыл бұрын

What are your thoughts on morphe Eyeshadows?

I’m so so excited for the mascara content ❤ and all your new videos

Love all the info! Thanks Marlena.

I miss Makeup Geek shadows!!! 😢 love you Marlena! I am an EL Doublewear fan (63 years) I use chanel mascara & will save the spoolie to use on the other mascaras I didn't like.

I love the videos you have been uploading 🥰 very informative

Just found your channel recently and I love how you go over all this stuff

Love your info and presentations. I love makeup and being a little older. It is nice to find a reliable source and still learning! Thanks

YES!!! I completely agree and I DO splurge on my foundations!!! All of my favourites are high end such as Nars, Shisedo, Kosas, Giorgio Armani, and Anastasia Beverly Hills! ❤M

As usual your video is informative and educational. You’re right about Makeup Geek eyeshadows, I have all of them and sure hope that you are back in business in the future. Thank you so much for still caring about your followers and members of the makeup community.

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

This was fascinating !!!

Excellent video. Thank you, Marlena!

I loved this video! I’ve been super into all the content you’ve been up loading, it’s so informative. If it’s ever an option, I would love to see a video for women who have skin that is 40+. I feel like what use to work for me 10 years ago can not anymore due to skin changes, fine lines, collagen loss etc. 💕

Loreal Voluminous is my favorite! 😍 I've been using it for years! Amazing product 💯

I'll say it quickly- fantastic series, I'd absolutely love to see more. Also, great video- knowledgeable, on point, honest. What more could we ask for?! 😘

@changeeyecolor3891

Жыл бұрын

Love is like the ocean...

Love it! Thanks for sharing.

Love your videos! You speak from experience and I love your honesty! you have saved people a lot of $$$ speaking about what to buy and what not to waste money on. Thank you so much!

Thank you so much Marlena ❤ love the video very informative