Yonaguni is fascinating in that the two consonants "w" and "y" have undergone fortition: w shifted to b, and y shifted to z and then d. Eg: - 野菜 is "yasai" in Japanese, cognate with Mandarin yěcài. In Yonaguni, it is "dasai" - The name of the island: 与那国 (Yonaguni) is "Dunan" - 山 is "yama" in Japanese and "dama" in Yonaguni.

@MonibaKoliSMB

27 күн бұрын

Intriguing 😊

@hieudo4460

26 күн бұрын

Sorry what are you talking about, how could [w] be fortify into [b], also [y] is not even a consonant and [w] is a semi vowel, do you care to elaborate? I am not sure what phones phonemes you’re referring about since you use quotation marks I’d assume it’s phonemes you’re on about? Idk about your phonetic representation if that makes sense, ta.

@msruag

23 күн бұрын

@@hieudo4460 isn't it obv that they meant y as [j] or [ʝ]? 💀japanese romaji uses y for [j] so the elaboration is there, wikipedia says yonaguni originally had [ʝ] which fortified into [d], and semivowels can also be fortified as has happened in gaelic

It sounds a little bit like Japanese, but it is a completely different language.

@dan74695

23 күн бұрын

Well, it is related.

@porothashawarma2339

18 күн бұрын

As an Indian it sounds very strangely similar to some the languages in north eastern India .

@user-zn7uh5rj1j

17 күн бұрын

It uses the same alphabet as japanese!Even the kanji, but the reading is different from Japanese kanji

This channel is amazing Even language that we never know its hereee

Just based on the numbers alone it definitely shares roots with other japonic languages but it's easily one of the most isolated and removed from mainland japanese

Although I am partly Asian myself and know the "mainstream" Asian languages, the Yonaguni language has a positive kind of mystery, which is indescribably beautiful, like the background melody choice of yours, dear Andy. And thanks to the speaker. Arigatougozaimashita❣️😍❤️

@tsuneyoshi779

28 күн бұрын

✋😭

@goulven05

28 күн бұрын

That’s really nice to hear, yeah it’s a beautiful language

@RoseRoseRoseRoseRoseRose

28 күн бұрын

@@goulven05 Nice to read you again❣️

@goulven05

27 күн бұрын

@@RoseRoseRoseRoseRoseRose Thank you 🫡

@matthewsiregar

26 күн бұрын

What kind of asian?

Thank you from🇯🇵

Sounds a lot like Austronesian😮

@LSJ1998

19 күн бұрын

Might just be the speaker's accent. I hear an Indonesian accent from both the speaker and the presenter

@porothashawarma2339

18 күн бұрын

Yes !

It doesn't sound like Japanese at all and yet its clearly related if you compare the words, and I don't just mean the numbers.

This sounds like a mix of Minnan and Austronesian language

It is so cool how native speakers for these obscure languages (with 400 speakers) lend their voices to make these videos!

Nife debiru for making us learn more about the different Ryukuyu languages, this is precious, thank you! Much love to Ryukyu from this Brazilian!

@parsifal2299

28 күн бұрын

Diz a lenda que o jiu-jitsu Brasileiro veio desse mesmo povo que migraram para o interior e fundaram os dojos

@joalexsg9741

28 күн бұрын

@@parsifal2299 É possível, mas soube que na verdade há tantas dialetos das línguas Ryukyu que são na verdade ininteligíveis entre si, podendo ser chamados de línguas independentes mesmo. Há alguns vídeos mostrando isso. Realmente, pelo que me disseram, a maioria dos nossos descendentes japoneses veio de Okinawa (ou das demais ilhas do reino de Ryukyu, não sei dizer ao certo). Nossos descendentes deveriam fundar uma organização pra preservar estas línguas preciosas, ao invés de se promover o Nihongo como se fosse a única língua do Japão! Aproveito pra mencionar o povo Ainu, pois muitos ainda não sabem de sua existência, outra cultura muito interessante e bem mais antiga do país.

Sounds like Nihonggo-Austronesian.

Beautiful language.

Please video about Proto-Ryukyuan language: the ancestor of Yonaguni.

Bitter sweet as we learn about new languages we learn they are disapearing.

It's... almost like japanise but with a bit of something else, something unique.

wow! this is a very cool language!

Nice

Next can you do bouton japanese?

Some of the numbers and other words remind me of Tungusic languages such as Manchu .

Sounds more like an Austronesian language than Japanese

under 1 day gang

love you guys from manchuria ! I'm a huge fan of japanese culture. bi nihon gurun be buyembi ！

@iLolek10

14 күн бұрын

Witam. Czy mówisz językiem Mandżurskim? Jeśli tak, czy jest on podobny do języka Mongolskiego?

@fiyangga.yanggiri-hala

14 күн бұрын

​@iLolek10 sorry, what language is this ? I can't understand what you wrote.

@iLolek10

14 күн бұрын

@@fiyangga.yanggiri-hala As you wrote You are from Manchuria. Province on north-east China. My question is if you speak manchurian language? If yes, can you see any similarities with mongolian language? Or maybe with korean language?

@fiyangga.yanggiri-hala

14 күн бұрын

@@iLolek10 yah, we have a lot of similarities in both languages. for example, how are you in mongolian sain bai nuu ? . in manchu sain no or saiyun ? and a lot of other words. but I'm not a native speaker of monglian, so I have no idea how many similarities are in two languages

@iLolek10

14 күн бұрын

@@fiyangga.yanggiri-hala Thank you very much. It is not easy to meet anyone who speak manchurian for me. I was traveling in Mongolia when I was young. Living with mongolian family for more than a month. Then we go togerter to China, Beijing. Staying on borthere city Erlian. for two weeks. So I have listenning mongolian language everyday. Even learned some of it, just from listennin. Would you take a part as a volunteer in one of Andy's video. If he decide to make comparison Manchurian and Mongolian?

Probably next, Iraqi Arabic and Persian?

Native speaker: 400 👀

Koryo-mar, please

First

@sot1susy-amogus

28 күн бұрын

No, ur 2nd I'm 1st

@leonardoschiavelli6478

28 күн бұрын

​@@sot1susy-amogusIf so, how did you REPLIED to? It's practically impossible for a REPLY to be the first comment ever in a video.

@Daavlavi

28 күн бұрын

​@@sot1susy-amogusYou deserve to be arrested

@sot1susy-amogus

28 күн бұрын

@@Daavlavi not me, I'm a good guy

I cognosize only underwater megality and figures dogu

Sounds like what my 10 year old self imagined Japanese to sound like

The name reminds me of bad bunny

Una noche más y copas de más Tú no me dejas en paz, de mi mente no te vas Aunque sé que no debo, ey Pensar en ti, bebé, pero cuando bebo Me viene tu nombre, tu cara, tu risa y tu pelo, ey Dime dónde tú está', que yo por ti cojo un vuelo Y a Yonaguni le llego Aunque sé que no debo, ey Pensar en ti, bebé, pero cuando bebo Me viene tu nombre, tu cara Tu risa y tu pelo, ey Dime dónde tú está', que yo por ti cojo un vuelo Y a Yonaguni le llego, ey No me busque' en Instagram Mami, búscame en casa Pa' que vea' lo que pasa, ey Si tú me pruebas te casa', ey Ese cabrón ni te abraza Y yo loco por tocarte Pero ni me atrevo a textearte Tú con cualquier outfit la parte' Mami, tú eres aparte Shorty tiene un culo bien grande, eh De-demasiao' grande Y yo lo tengo estudiao', ya mismo me gradúo Y en la cara me lo tatúo Vi que viste mi story y subiste una pa' mí Yo que me iba a dormir, ey En la disco habían mil Y yo bailando contigo en mi mente Aunque sé que no debo Pensar en ti, bebé, pero cuando bebo Me viene tu nombre, tu cara Tu risa y tu pelo, ey Dime dónde tú está', que yo por ti cojo un vuelo Y a Yonaguni le llego Si me das tu dirección, yo te mando mil carta' Si me das tu cuenta de banco, un millón de peso' To'a la noche arrodillao' a Dios le rezo Pa' que ante' 'e que se acabe el año tú me des un beso Y empezar el 2023 bien cabrón Contigo y un blunt Tú te ve' asesina con ese mahón Me matas sin un pistolón Y yo te compro un Banshee Gucci, Givenchy Un poodle, un frenchie El pasto, los munchie' Te canto un mariachi Me convierto en Itachi, eh Yeah-yeah-yeah-yeah Bad Bunny, baby, bebé Bad Bunny, baby, bebé 今日はセックスしたい でもあなたとだけ どこにいますか? どこにいますか? 今日はセックスしたい でもあなたとだけ どこにいますか? どこにいますか? Eh

BUDDHA BLESS THE YONAGUNI LANGUAGE 南無阿弥陀仏 🙏☸

Sound like it's not a Japonic Language🤔

@zach0gr

28 күн бұрын

I can say the same Though jap is user it doesn't sound this way

@rusticcloud3325

28 күн бұрын

The numbers sound like kun'yomi Japanese numbers tho

@YourCreepyUncle.

28 күн бұрын

Sound can be misleading. Look at the written language.

@shrekuwu259

27 күн бұрын

@@YourCreepyUncle.written language has nothing to do with relation. Persian uses Arabic script buts it’s not even related to Arabic. Finnish uses Latin script but it’s not even related to English.

@phambinhan17

27 күн бұрын

It is

AUstronesia

Can you please

I thought it's just Bad Bunny's song 😅

.ASIA bro

Sounds like an Austronesian trying to speak Nihongo 😅

How similar is this dialect to Chinese?

@ohkeydan6357

27 күн бұрын

Very different because it a different language and under different language family.

@citylidamj8898

27 күн бұрын

0 % similarity I would say😅

@xjmmjbnqfstjdijoj2044

23 күн бұрын

I think it is as close to Chinese as Arabic would be lol 😂 Don't get confused by the Chinese characters, those are used to represent meaning, not the sound (or the etymology) of words... For instance: 貴方 could 基本ally 書rite 英語ish like 之is and still 読ad it as 普通al 英語ish, with 絶対tely 無 中国se 影響 何soever (you could basically write English like this and still read it as normal English, with absolutely no Chinese influence whatsoever) That's basically how Japonic languages work for the most part

Sound like thai language.

So Yonaguni is a dialect of Ryukyuan (not Japanese) if anything. Ryukyuan is not Japanese, Ryukyus is not Japan it is another country.

@xjmmjbnqfstjdijoj2044

23 күн бұрын

Ryukyuan and Japanese, including their respective dialects, both come from a common ancestral language...just like Romance languages for instance

@sanneoi6323

22 күн бұрын

@@xjmmjbnqfstjdijoj2044 They are different languages. The fascist of Japanese government is lie. Ryukyuan people is their own nation, by rights a separate country. Ryukyuan split off from Japanese at Kofun Era.