AI voice overs may save time, but it's lazy and it turns me off. Speak your own words.

@LydiaMoMydia

24 күн бұрын

it also just sounds atrocious

If this list was actually EVERY extinct language, the video would probably be longer than every KZread video in history and then some, and would require literal magic to put togetrher since only a small fraction of all languages that have gone extinct have left any records behind.

@nHans

26 күн бұрын

I can forgive him for not explicitly saying _"that we know of,"_ because that part is generally understood. By definition, we don't know about the "unknown unknowns," so we can't talk about them. Unfortunately, this video doesn't include some extinct languages that we do know of, such as the Harappan language of the Indus Valley Civilization. The bigger problem with this video is that it doesn't differentiate between "dead" and "extinct," and consequently, includes several dead languages among the truly extinct ones. This channel is just one of hundreds of copycats based on the "Every X explained in Y minutes" fad. I'm not very optimistic about its own survival.

@RobespierreThePoof

13 күн бұрын

Yes, this channel is really low quality content. It is just minimally animated videos of bog-standard encyclopedia entries read by a computer voice. I would guess that the KZreadr doesn't even have a degree.

You cannot call a language extinct simply because it evolved. Neither Greek nor Latin are extinct.

@hweiktomeyto

Ай бұрын

Latin is just dead so not extinct, since it has second language speakers and used in the Vatican, but yes, you can say a language is dead or extinct because it evolved.

@dimitriosvlissides5781

Ай бұрын

​@@hweiktomeytoaccording to your assumptions all the languagesare 3xtinct as all evolve Something not right in your assumptions

@hweiktomeyto

Ай бұрын

@@dimitriosvlissides5781 Mhm. If I ask a linguist what the status of Old English is, they would say extinct. Even dialects go extinct, so why can't stages of languages be extinct?

@dimitriosvlissides5781

28 күн бұрын

@@hweiktomeyto because "stage of alanguage is static "...for this period in mention .The evolving of the language is a continuum .... In greek language there still thousands of words that were used 2500 years ago

Coptic isn't extinct. It has 1 million speakers as the language of the Coptic Orthodox Church. There's a difference between a dead language and an extinct language. A dead language has no native speakers. An extinct language has no speakers at all. Same with Cornish. No native speakers, but it has speakers. Also Latin, which is the language of the Vatican.

@LearnRunes

26 күн бұрын

Are there any fluent speakers of Coptic?

@hweiktomeyto

26 күн бұрын

@@LearnRunes It's used daily in the Coptic church, so I would assume.

@hweiktomeyto

26 күн бұрын

@@LearnRunes Oh damn. I didn't notice that I'm subscribed to your channel. Hello. That explains the deja vu haha

@Ggdivhjkjl

26 күн бұрын

​@@hweiktomeytoSorry I've been quite this year. I'll be releasing more long videos in a month or so. If you're using the system, the contestants are almost perfect but the vowels need a bit of fixing. Still, if you practice with what's there you won't have to change much.

@hweiktomeyto

26 күн бұрын

@@Ggdivhjkjl Can't wait. Although I use my own orthography.

The Coptic Catholic Church also uses Coptic.

@LearnRunes

26 күн бұрын

What position does it take on the Coptic pronunciation reform dispute?

How come Old Prussian is missing ? Old Prussian was extinct around the 18th Century. It was a language related to modern days Lithuanian and Latvian. There are still documents (mainly liturgical documents) written in the language....

@RobespierreThePoof

13 күн бұрын

Because this KZreadr isn't actually knowlegeable in this subject at all.

The text around 2:45 is English written with Greek letters.

@Bepples

28 күн бұрын

"alia-mad toqeer abbas batti, pakistan is the world most famous country in the world first of all pakistan is the religious country in islamic point of view" Not sure where it comes from, sounds like broken english

*Harappan Language of the Indus Valley Civilization* should've made your list.

@LearnRunes

26 күн бұрын

Was it written?

@anthropos_94

26 күн бұрын

The Harappan languages unknown and unclassified.

@silverwolfmillennium8428

25 күн бұрын

@@LearnRunes Yea, it was

@LearnRunes

24 күн бұрын

@@silverwolfmillennium8428 Thanks for letting me know.

@abhinav4183

9 күн бұрын

Yes, and ashokan script too

5:06 "i have diarrhoea" bro what💀💀💀 Where did that fome from-

@calebbrown7025

29 күн бұрын

I don’t hear it

@Argenti_Lover

29 күн бұрын

@@calebbrown7025 he didn't say it if u read the text it says it there

I wonder what happened in 300 bc that made ancient greek extinct edit. lmao exactly after it says that it developed to byzantine greek (and then modern greek) so much for an extinct language

Btw koine Greek is being used everyday non stop in Greek Orthodox Church, and modern Greek is just the continuum of a living language, which evolved the last 3.500 years continuously spoken and written.

I have many problems wiþ ðis video such as: Old Dutch and Old Fraŋkish are ðe same and boþ Germanic, Burgundian was not spoken in ðe Duchy of Burgundy, but ðe early Kiŋdom of Burgundy, and it's East Germanic so not a Romance laŋuage or similer to Fraŋkish, Latin is Proto-Romance and as such if included you should have every widely exepted proto-language, (anoðer is you can raðer controversialy claim Dalmatian and Old Norse are not extiŋct), and finally whilest ðis is excusable he pronounced most laŋguage's names wroŋ, it's excusable but it hurts like hell.

Ancient Egyptian lasted for a long period, 3000 years , Coptic evolved from it during the Ptolemaic dynasty

Church Slavonic is still used sometimes in Orthodox Churches.

Why do you have images of runes in the Phoenician section?

isnt burgundian supposed to be an east germanic language, making them closer to gothic than old frankish?

why so fast? little bit slower it would be better ...

what is that english written with greek letters 😢

16:46, Correct it! What Tevfik Esenç, Who is this? This is the Georgian alphabet

Where is Ge’ez?

@daSrilankanCat

28 күн бұрын

Geez exists

to me an AI voice just removes all credibility that a video might have lmao

@jw-pd2fz

19 күн бұрын

That´s a good rule of thumb to have. Most likely they are just trying to get rich quick. Better to spend your time watch real academics who truly care about their subject.

@CaritasGothKaraoke

12 сағат бұрын

It might be OK if it were a _good_ AI voice. But then I wouldn’t know.

لماذا لا تذكر العرب والكنعانيون

@Norsean

29 күн бұрын

يمكن مايعرف

@g.quagmire7583

26 күн бұрын

There’s little correlation. There’s more correlation to canaanites to other middle eastern ethnicities

isn't scottish gaelic extinct?

@kutaykalender2321

17 күн бұрын

no

Hieroglyphs survive in England's pub names.

Cornish is not extinct

@scaacacsc

27 күн бұрын

it did go extinct in the 1700s but there were revival attempts later on. similar to what happened to hebrew.

@LearnRunes

26 күн бұрын

Manx is in that category of revived languages too.

Take that AI generated crap it shove it somewhere where the light doesn't shine.

holá

Ai. May you never find success 👎

Yeah... AI voice is a big turn-off. When it pronounces the same name three different ways in under a minute. Do your own work.