So, a criminal act was committed by the tribd. This caused reprisal raids, caused the killing which took place over 10 weeks. Not what i call a massacre, since it wasn't a single event. Call it a genocide, which it was in some ways, but it was one b r ouhht on by their own actions. Besides the three killed how many were wounded or injured, i noticed that wasn't mentioned. Were there none, unlikely since it was violent enough that thred were killed. It is interedting how only the sympathetic parts of some history are covered. I also suspect that there is a great deal more to the run up to the events mentioned, probably showing both sides in a bad light. The past is past and shouldn't be used for political or social gains today by people who were never part of those events.

Those who died and those who perpetrated it have all gone and weren't done by today's people Commemorate these horrid events but don't nurture them a a grievance to live by

@privateprivate3767

8 ай бұрын

every story I've heard of white on aboriginal violence is always retaliation or self defense every story I hear of aboriginal on white violence is unprovoked even recently with the unprovoked digeree doo attack against a white football fan who was supporting aboriginals can anyone give me an example of unprovoked violence against aboriginals in Australian history?

Would have been pretty scary back in the day to be worried about getting killed and eaten

@kimbo99

8 ай бұрын

YES Locked in the Stone Age was an ugly distressing place to be. Lucky they were rescued by British civilisation. Some gratitude is due. Where is their gratitude ceremony ? Their gratitude dance ?

@perentee77

7 күн бұрын

Yep, aboriginals were cannibals who were even known for eating their own children. Why don't we here more about that rather then glorifying a very barbaric group of people.

Yes very sad to see Aboriginal people in chains just like it was very sad to see Australian people in chains but we don't seem to see many photos of them do we .

@waitpu4817

9 ай бұрын

Well that's the point to all of this, it should be something to identify with not separate, what about all those orphans sent from England to Australia & used as slaves, the same people responsible for that stolen generation are the same as those that did it to them & it should be understood to be addressing as that, not an us & them thing, because they have always employed someone else to do it to another, they don't dirty their hand with such things, it's always a divide & conquer tactic, stop getting sucked in to it.

@waitpu4817

9 ай бұрын

@@James-kv6kb I think you need to read my comment again, wasn't that kind of what I said & what really needs to be addressed, it seems like your reply should have been, (" I don't get sucked into it & we need to acknowledge that to stop getting used against each other?")

@James-kv6kb

9 ай бұрын

@@waitpu4817 yes I do apologise you just had a bit too much detail sorry

@waitpu4817

9 ай бұрын

@@James-kv6kb Thanks, no problem it's easy to miss small details & misinterpret, I've done the same.

@guymoschella4066

8 ай бұрын

Well said James Go to Port Arthur it's an eerie place at night .

The "word of mouth" that I heard, was that the tribe from Wickham wiped out the Karratha tribe, and claimed their tribal land. Its amazing how history appears to change to suit a new, and more desirable, narrative.

No explanation of odd phrase "flying foam"

@C-Here

9 ай бұрын

I was wondering about that too!! 🤷

@zen4men

Ай бұрын

As the sea can produce flying foam, it crosses my mind that maybe this people obtained much of their food from the sea? Lived very much on the beach? /

@Danoz_die_wreckt

Күн бұрын

It’s a the name of a nautical passage in the area that was itself named after the ship Flyingfoam.

150 years ago, and to the north in Cambodia PolPot managed to kill 1 million people in 1978-80 only 40 years ago. Why even mention this at all, every country on the planet can offer up a massacre of some description. Do you know it was Ernie Dingo who introduced the smoking ceremony in 1978, prior to that it didn't exist!

@geoffbrown1518

8 ай бұрын

I think you'll find Ernie Dingo introduced the "Welcome to Country", prior to the mid 1970's it didn't exist.

@MrZlathan3

6 ай бұрын

Oh okay. So I won't mention that the Nixon/Henry Kissinger secret bombing campaign killed hundreds of thousands of Cambodians set the stage for the ravages of the Khmer Rouge.

This has happened on every continent bar Antarctica . Sadly it is history and can never be changed . This doesn’t mean that your children and the generations to come are to be made to feel guilty for what happened then. Learn from bad history but don’t let it destroy the good that has been done. Raciest revenge will destroy this country not unit.

@waitpu4817

9 ай бұрын

You sound like John Howard going on about the guilt industry, why does acknowledging the facts of the past implicate guilt except on those that have inherited a gross benefit by past atrocities & who implied guilt on you or Howard, seems to me you are the beneficiary of past atrocities & carry guilt or you wouldn't need to even bring it up, who says or said children and the generations to come should feel guilty?

@christenedoering7720

9 ай бұрын

​@@waitpu4817Well if your saying we're benificerys you are slapping guilt on people you weren't here either was I as for John Howard he was correct in saying he will not apologise for something others did rightly so.

@waitpu4817

9 ай бұрын

@@christenedoering7720 When are people going to realize that conspiracy's don't exist the government & related agencies never cover up anything & are always 100% honest & transparent, politicians never act out of self interest, swayed, influenced or act for fraternities they frequent, big money corporations or companies they have investments in & are only motivated by their love of the people for the nations they represent.

@kimbo99

9 ай бұрын

@@waitpu4817 Faulty reasoning. Modern civilisation arriving clashes with simpler societies. It is of no benefit to the arriving civilisation. It exists and will continue regardless of a few massacres. So there are no beneficiaries of past massacres. Aboriginal Senator Jacinta Price said Colonialism brought civilisation rescuing the natives from the stone age. And wallpu here you are typing on a computer made available to you by civilisation. Try adding a drop of gratitude to your reasoning

@waitpu4817

9 ай бұрын

@@kimbo99 Gratitude for bullshit politics & media lies serving big money interest & judaic agenda, what a dumb suck you are.

Well done Ernie. The journey to reconciliation is to acknowledge wrongs. Not blame or shame anyone. These are winning words. This historical event relies on word of mouth passed down through generations. My comment does not diminish the oral history. However, if your commentary included the recorded history, and the punishment if any put upon the settlers. This would add substantially to this piece of history. For true reconciliation, both sides of an account needed to be told. The validity of this account is not being challenged, knowing the history of colonial Australia should not destroy or separate people today. Australia is an egalitarian society. We need to keep moving forward. Only a true reading of history based on fact and not urban propagated anti-British colonialism will satisfy both side of the reconciliation process. Today, we are approaching the referendum vote. I am voting "no' Not because I have no feelings for the history that is ugly by any standards, but because the 'Voice' will divide and enshrine a racist divide into the constitution. Australian history is not all aboriginal history any more than it is settler history. The activist will polarise the conversation for one side or the other. We need the middle ground where a fair and factual history is presented. In my view, the vote will go down, but good will come to the marginalised aboriginal people who have been held back by corporate aboriginal organisations that benefit from the plight of the marginalised. I believe that Jacinta Price is the rising star for advancement of aboriginal participation in modern Australia.

@kimbo99

9 ай бұрын

Aboriginal Cannibalism & Infanticide was common kzread.info/dash/bejne/nZxswbdpYdrdp9o.htmlsi=-ONMuQ4yMqVxCbgJ

@guymoschella4066

8 ай бұрын

Ernie started the smoke BS and welcome to country there wasn't any anything before that he made it up . I don't need to be welcomed in my own country .

@abrogard142

8 ай бұрын

but it is not 'to acknowledge wrongs' in practical effect. to acknowledge wrong would be to pronounce on the situation in that time and place. in practice here in the 21st C the practical effect is pressure contemporaries to assume the guilt for the wrong and make reparation. It is a con. An irrationality and a con. It arises from primitivism. I mean: it is primitive in logic and effect.

Ernie were you not convicted for bashing your partner Domestic Violence ?

soon as the racist hate-filled ernie appeared, I knew it would be a distorted rant. turned it off the moment I clocked his big head

@zen4men

Ай бұрын

Knowing nothing further of Ernie ( am in England ), I was impressed by his high standard of communication in English - better than many Australians! - calm presentation of his story, and LACK of apparent anger. Is Ernie not a prime example of how the original people can thrive when in contact with mainstream Australian culture? So while some have lost by contact, others have gained - rather like all people do, when facing difficult choices. /

@perentee77

7 күн бұрын

There no truth they were the original people. That's a myth to justify the aboriginal industrial complex.

My Great Great Grandma was one of the orphans left from this massacre, she was taken south by one of the whites, hence the beginning of my white Ancestry

@James-kv6kb

10 ай бұрын

Apparently South Australia was the only place where there was only two massacres where the rest of the country had 400 so at least we were doing something right

@debbie3630

8 ай бұрын

So sorry to hear about your great great grandma, very sad 😢

Where are the bones? Hmmm. The story is probably a little different than Ernie says. The black husband most likely loaned his wife to the policeman as prostituting their wives was a common practice across Australia. What sometimes happened though was the black women preferred the company of the White man and did not want to return to the harsh life with her tribal husband. Or else she might have stayed too long and this angered the husband. Alternatively, the husband demanded more payment for his wife and the policeman refused. However, just like when black men attacked another group of black people, often to steal women or in a revenge attack, and killed a number of them, those attacked would at a later date call together relatives from around the countryside and then go out and murder a number of those accused of the initial attack. I'd like to see the, 'transcripts of early pioneers' mentioned here. Word of mouth from 150 years ago cannot be taken as accurate by any stretch.

@timfirth977

7 ай бұрын

Bloody hell, you're a sick racist piece of work aren't you? What research and study did you undertake here? I bet, on a winner hear I reckon, that you are just spewing your racist sick fantasies, and that was the extent of it!

@MrZlathan3

6 ай бұрын

"Most likely?" So you're just going to make up your own scenario that just happens to degrade the tribesmen as much as possible while absolving the white British convicts.

every story I've heard of white on aboriginal violence is always retaliation or self defense every story I hear of aboriginal on white violence is unprovoked even recently with the unprovoked digeree doo attack against a white football fan who was supporting aboriginals can anyone give me an example of unprovoked violence against aboriginals in Australian history?

@rheel6747

7 ай бұрын

I think you may be waiting quite some time for any examples

@MrZlathan3

6 ай бұрын

So let me get this straight. You're saying that over 140 years of Australian history, the 270 frontier massacres and the mass poisonings; the driving of children over cliffs; the state-sanctioned and organized programs to eradicate the First Nations people were all instigated by the First Nation people on this innocent British colony of convicts. OoooKay.

The Inventor of welcome to country 😂

@guymoschella4066

8 ай бұрын

Was E Dingo's baby

These guys are from India not too long ago, they were NOT the first people here, they committed Genocide on the previous first nations people. Who knows if the people they genocided were even the first peoples. Your government approved books lie about so much of our history, but it takes a brave person to look up information against their own bias. Especially Academics who are the most "scared to offend" people to ever walk the earth.

@waitpu4817

9 ай бұрын

How do you know if those in India didn't come from Australia?

@kimbo99

9 ай бұрын

My Indian wife walks down the main street of aboriginal Redfern, Sydney and they call out Hey there SISTER !

@privateprivate3767

8 ай бұрын

the archeological remains of 'Mungo man' prove aboriginals were not the first Australians every story I've heard of white on aboriginal violence is always retaliation or self defense every story I hear of aboriginal on white violence is unprovoked even recently with the unprovoked digeree doo attack against a white football fan who was supporting aboriginals can anyone give me an example of unprovoked violence against aboriginals in Australian history?

@chaffcutter58.

8 ай бұрын

So true,

@kimbo99

8 ай бұрын

@@waitpu4817 because oddly there is no evidence AUST Aboriginals ever made boats. And Indian cultures did produce boats

Gunpowder better than a spir and thay founded out the hard way

If you look into the history of this place. This was mild. There was a lot of things ongoing. Like dashing babies against trees,rocks, tossing them off cliffs and such. Man can be way worse than what you may think.

@perentee77

7 күн бұрын

How about the aboriginal tribes that ate their own babies?

"The story has been passed down by ancestors of the survivors and transcripts of early pioneers who took part in murdering over one hundred men, women and children. " ~~ Pretty accurate figures for stone age people, most of whom could not count beyond 4. Take these massacres with a large grain of sand. Although blacks did massacre large numbers of their own at times.

@abrogard142

8 ай бұрын

that 'counting' point could have a special validity I think. never occurred to me before but it looks like a good point indeed. when talking of 'records' and accuracy.

Ernie Dingo you made a comment this is not meant to name shame or blame anybody you've always done a good job protecting the European

Lucky the chinese didn't land before the British, there would be no indigenous people left,think about that.

@user-vu1lb6qb3z

6 ай бұрын

Ok if that is where you stand.

Still love the traditional bling their wearing.

I think stopping and acknowledging is a nice thing to do and respectful to be able to connect, we are all spiritual beings and are one ❤

@perentee77

7 күн бұрын

Why is it only 1 side though? Can't they acknowledge all the good that Western civilisation bought them.

Sounds like aboriginal cultural " pay back " .

Is anyone going to remove the racist comments????

@perentee77

7 күн бұрын

Where's the racism? Facts don't care about your primitive feelings. Sometimes the truth hurts.

Ernie Dingo BS

Another great story from Ernie. Interesting comments from all the responders below. Split decisions on empathy and apathy. It will be an interesting vote in a few weeks.

FLYING FOAM ?

@Danoz_die_wreckt

Күн бұрын

The name of a waterway called Flying foam passage. You can see it in one of the shots. It in turn was named after a boat.

Acknowledge and Learn about the Past

👍🏾

I saw Quigley down under. I get it.

Stories like this are all over AUSTRALIA but AUSTRALIANS rarely if ever hear of them. This is the history of AUSTRALIA that is not taught to the children.

@James-kv6kb

10 ай бұрын

Ok no massacres in South Australia and this bulshit about them being a non-human being before 67 that's a lie because they were voting in South Australia in 1900 . Most of the culture that the mixture blood Aborigines are presenting is actually fake it never happened of course they won't tell you about the real culture only the pretend version

@privateprivate3767

8 ай бұрын

every story I've heard of white on aboriginal violence is always retaliation or self defense every story I hear of aboriginal on white violence is unprovoked even recently with the unprovoked digeree doo attack against a white football fan who was supporting aboriginals

@frasermiller-bz3qf

8 ай бұрын

It should not be taught as such but certainly included in history lessons, and based on as much fact as can be found.

@debbie3630

8 ай бұрын

i disagree, it takes a certain age of high school teenagers to maybe be able to process this kind of history or when they get older and more interested in history, this sort of trauma based history can have a negative effect on children’s psyche !!

@perentee77

7 күн бұрын

How about we teach the children the truth, not Chinese whispers. Also include the history of massacres that aboriginals committed against their own and also whites..

I’m shocked

Good Aussies are now working hard to give money to the aboriginals. But sad for the aboriginal victims

Dingo by name Dingo by nature Not to be trusted or believed

Move on , my ancestors were killed in Germany.

@UndetectedKiller-yi1dy

7 ай бұрын

the Jews got massive amounts of compensation

Ernies healing bs! What did he get paid for doing this dribble?

Could you explain the”good”that came after the Genocide?….Babylon style cities where crime and out of control drug problems are rife…

Has this been written ,or is it Chinese whisper , just asking

@colsmith7257

9 ай бұрын

Your not related to Alan by any chance?

@C-Here

9 ай бұрын

Aboriginal people hand their history down thru stories, not writing... U dismissing the native peoples version of what happened to them- is narrow to say the least ..

@rheel6747

7 ай бұрын

Way to embolden OP's claim by confirming that the Natives history is indeed passed down by them through Chinese Whispers 🤣@@C-Here

@C-Here

7 ай бұрын

@@rheel6747 Hardly...

@rheel6747

7 ай бұрын

No...exactly@@C-Here

Your history is not mine .. and there in Lys the problem...

The creepy White Settler Country Western music detracts badly from the narrative in the video.

Only learnt about this one this year at almost 30 years old. This needs to be taught in schools.

@James-kv6kb

10 ай бұрын

It was a very big country and the massacres did not happen everywhere there was none in South Australia. But of course they keep pushing this genocide thing so people will feel sorry for the remaining quarter cast aboriginals and give them more money

@rowdy5697

9 ай бұрын

What version. This is not the official version written down at the time. This version is hearsay and should not be treated as fact.

@C-Here

9 ай бұрын

@@rowdy5697 Because the winners always write the facts right?? This is the Aboriginal version of facts- I'd be more inclined to believe them anyday- over the rulers...

@timfirth977

7 ай бұрын

@@rowdy5697 The official version would've been a whitewash of justifications for the murders.

@perentee77

7 күн бұрын

@C-Here what that's a very primitive way of looking at things. You'd rather believe Chinese whispers then what was written down at the time? Sounds like someone is letting their racism cloud their judgement.

White settlers here, there, everywhere... Why not tell it as it is. Brits...

Ernie, this is your best media work I have ever seen. Please keep this going. Our entire country needs to be educated about its real history, not the sanitised version that has been taught in schools. More please.

Reconciliation is s financial term Fpr what it's worth.Will not be accepting sorry apologies from environmental vandals

These stories should be taught in schools so the children of today and those that follow learn the truth and not the lies told by the racists, who make up their own truth.

@guymoschella4066

8 ай бұрын

They should also teach what happened in WW2 anda few other things so people can show respect to the people who dies so we can have freedom of speech and democracy. Thank goodness were not north korean

@perentee77

7 күн бұрын

No we should teach the truth in schools, not Chinese whispers. Don't let your racism cloud your judgement.

@richardbluett958

6 күн бұрын

@@perentee77 Are you saying that I am a racist for standing up for the first nations people, because if you are please learn a little more about how they were treated by our first settlers.

@perentee77

6 күн бұрын

If the shoe fits... it's clear your not standing up for the first immigrants (maybe) but instead using the topic to justify your racism

@perentee77

6 күн бұрын

Also I actually teach about aboriginal culture, have spent many years studying it, not just listening to the media and the education system propaganda. I spent 8 years as a tour guide around Ayers Rock (I will not call it uluru as I'm not aboriginal)

I'm over this nonsense. Shirt happens, we gonna pay tribute to the aboriginal groups that massacred other aboriginal groups? Of course not. It's always about stretching the truth to make 1 group look as bad and as evil as can be without honouring all the good that the group brought to the very primitive and sometimes downright barbaric tribes...

I remember conversing with a lawyer about his Aboriginal art work and Terra nullius. How the early explorers wrote about the aboriginal civilization that saved them. How it's all recorded in their journals, he agreed, it's the first thing we studied as students of Australian law. It's all based on a lie. Look at what they did at palm island, Sergeant Hurley, look at prter Dutton, groomed by the media. No one picks up when he commits perjury. I remember Ernie losing it with some Sydney DJ, kyle, abosulte tosser, hey hes what the market wants. Ernie is a decent bloke, down to earth, your ten times better than any deleb Ernie

It is time to sing out all song lines. We need to prepare for the new world

Its history, thats it, thats all, learn and move on, but tbh, with the worries the world has today, if ya going to think about something, think about ukraine, that relates to us more than this, we already know what we need to about colonial times, with respect its no longer relative, other than to try and make white fellas feel bad, i dont hold it against the natives that they were cannibals and in most cases hostile, aboriginals were killing and eating each other for a very long time, not all tribes, but most

@patriciadunmore9767

8 ай бұрын

Ukraine is a tool of the West, Russia did not start this conflict it started in 2014 when the US staged a coup in Ukraine. NATO set about training the Ukrainians to take down Russia and the the Russian speakers of the Donbas were systematically set upon right up until this day. Russia went to their defence. You have been fed a pack of lies.

@UndetectedKiller-yi1dy

7 ай бұрын

WW2 is history at a time when Europeans were killing each other so why does the world have to be constantly reminded every year with Memorial Day. Perhaps people should get over their war dead. People might be sick of hearing about it tbh