Xi Jinping didn’t wish Modi. Chinese people say he isn’t invincible, chatter about Rahul
"Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s third term has become a reality, albeit with a coalition government. However, this is unlikely to cause significant changes in India’s foreign policy. S Jaishankar has retained his position as External Affairs Minister, signalling continuity, particularly in India’s relations with China" writes Sana Hashmi in her column.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our KZread Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Пікірлер: 248
Nobody cares if ping pong wished or not
@ChandranPrema123
25 күн бұрын
People who voted do care Traitors
@arunfernandes827
24 күн бұрын
How about Ding Dong??
@WizKid-ny2yq
23 күн бұрын
Not ping pong.. its Winnie the Pooh
@wilson2009yao
19 күн бұрын
Why do Indians want Xi's wish? Xi is not China's PM. His wish is for President Murmu. China's PM already wished PM Modi for his 3rd term.
China wanted Rahul to win. Xi is disappointed that now he has to face tough Modi
@GurkiratXSingh
25 күн бұрын
Tough Modi? The same "Tough Modi" who has NOT been able to say "CHINA HAS ENCROACHED INDIAN LAND IN LADAKH" since May 2020. That "Tough Modi" 😂
@rajx7120
25 күн бұрын
@@GurkiratXSinghChina has not encroaached any land. It prevented patrolling access in some parts of no-man's land. There is a technical difference.
@arunsar7893
25 күн бұрын
@@GurkiratXSingh Abe ch*t*ye .. toh Rahul kya khud bandook leke ladne chala jata kya border pe??
@pagan-540
25 күн бұрын
@@GurkiratXSinghIt is always better do some study in this matter ,if you are Indian. For China's influencers in India ,of course , the matter is different.
@anuragc1565
25 күн бұрын
We should refrain from making baseless accusations and arguments. Neither China has "encroached any area in Ladakh" wrt to Galwan clash of 2020 nor did "China want Rahul Gandhi to win". In geopolitics adversaries and friends alike keep an eye on elections of important countries and the possibility of change of guards therein because that is going to influence their own foreign policy. Adversaries look for an improvement in relation while friends watch out for any deterioration in relation. Besides, there is something called as optics in geopolitics. XI not congratulating modi or Modi not inviting Pakistan is optics meant to send a message to other party that relations are not normal. SO, its futile to delve into fancy stories and conspiracy theories
Not wishing Modi simply means China feels intimated , and India is in right path
@subasthapa4839
3 күн бұрын
😂
Just because Modi doesn't have absolute majority doesn't mean, there will not be anti-China feeling. BJP's allies are equally patriotic and nationalist.
@importantsomeone153
22 күн бұрын
by not taking actions against anti indian elements inside india modi have made india banana republic any indian media can take money from china and do propaganda against india and indian gov is afriad to take actions such people modi just have to make one mistake then radical left will destroy india from within
@adolft_official
22 күн бұрын
anti china fEeLiNg with 100 B USD trade deficit with china and gifting depsang plains to china in 2020? Rabid bhaktard...
Xi is not happy with Modi but then the feeling is mutual
@wilson2009yao
19 күн бұрын
Xi is not China's PM. His wish is for President Murmu. China's PM already wished PM Modi.
China is trying to normalise it's aggression on the border, it wants an India open to chinese goods while it ignores Chinese aggression on the border. The fact that CCP thinks Rahul Gandhi is much better for it's purposes should be a worry for Congress and the strategic community in the left.
@zzgreyhat3886
25 күн бұрын
but after 2020, india imports from china skyrocket.
@rajx7120
25 күн бұрын
Worry for Congress? Strategic community on the left? These things don't exist. They were too happy striking MoUs with CCP.
@FranzBieberkopf
23 күн бұрын
Yawn. All Indian governments from Nehru onwards have tried to portray the opposition of being anti-national and pro-the enemy of the day. As in 1948, so in 2024
This is absolute bad behaviour not to greet leader of 642 million voters ❗️ Unacceptable rudeness
Heaven have not fallen Xi mentor and Guru for IND alliance Xi wanted khats khat implemented by pappu and Drain our resources And expected IND alliance govt to destabilize india IND alliance and xi dreams went awry Disappointed and new tool kit in league with Congress MoU
He his jealous bcz Modi wins in a dynamic, vibrant and against an opposition who are clever with votebank politics in name of secularism.
Rahul Gandhi must be so elated. China ka PM ban jaye jaake. Kyunki India mein he will never be PM without showcasing his body of work (which he has none). Pm's post is not the paternal right of anyone.
We Indians need no non-serious wish from Xi. Better call a spade a spade.
Taiwan has publicly declared Arunachal Pardesh is part of China.
@rajx7120
22 күн бұрын
So? Recently, India also renamed places in Tibet. These are mindgames.
Her religion
Indian voters must observe this that neither pakistan nor China want Modi to win, both want Rahul Gandhi to win.
Only India can fix China and China knows it, matter of a time, India knows it has to do it for the world and the world knows they need to pay us dollars for protection
@abhishekjha8645
24 күн бұрын
🤣bhai kya phookte ho? Humko bhi chahiye.. Aisa nasha humko bhi hona!
@mangalapalliv
23 күн бұрын
Yippee..... one more bhakt
@akhandbharat9940
23 күн бұрын
@@mangalapalliv yippee one more Aloo to gold follower
Doctor Madam . Why India- China Bilateral Annual Trade is 125 billion dollars loaded heavily in favour of China ? Disturbing trends . Can you please throw some lights on this troubling issue . Jai Hind !
Thank you Sana for an excellent summary of Chinese media portrayal of India and the recently concluded elections as well as for your opinion about the status of India China relationship. The relationship between the countries is bound to be negative because of host of issues, some of them highlighted in this report…..👍👍
Some lesson to learn for Indians.
We need more young analysts in India on Chinese studies. Keep it up.
hi Indian minority population is bigger than whole western Europe. print media should also study how Indian minority treat majority.
Americans don't need to look for aliens in space just look for the Chinese they are nothing short of Aliens 😂
@arunfernandes827
24 күн бұрын
It’s seems that you should follow Arnab intellectually you will Find a fit
@ar_p6567
21 күн бұрын
@@arunfernandes827 I'll 😆
J Jali hui hay Xi ki. That’s why he did not congratulate.
Print please continue this series. Print own sectiom for the china development. Appreciated
There is no competition, China is way ahead. There cities are much more developed. I saw she is a postdoc fellow but then I question if she has been to China to see how much it is developed. If yes , then one would know they are much ahead of us overall in almost everything. Also don’t forget how much we are dependent on them which is reflecting in imports vs export ratio. Such a biased opinion. Kindly explain how India will compete when in literal sense we are so much behind.
@abhishekjha8645
24 күн бұрын
My friend, you talk sense. There's no space for logic and sense on social media. But for those who understand logic and have sense, one does not need to look too deep to understand the chasm between China and India. GDP: China $28 Tn, India ~$5 Tn.
@abhi4biotech
24 күн бұрын
@@abhishekjha8645 People from social science and arts tend to be less empirical and communication is there key skill to make it convincing. It is the nature of their studies and education not that it is bad thing. I guess Sana should focus on developing methodology to see beyond the exchange of the diplomats. I should add, I am not the expert but simple looking into development, innovation and how much they are investing in R & D already gives a sense if we are competing or just way behind trying to mimic what we can, as usual.
@mangalapalliv
23 күн бұрын
The latest issue of The Economist published a 11 page article with data on how China is beating US and EU in all applied research...... India is a civilization in decay with no idea of how to regenerate itself... Just look at the number of children leaving India for studies abroad which is nothing but a proxy for better opportunities, desire for overall well being and how they see their future in India....
@user-yq2hv1ix8j
22 күн бұрын
It is you who are in dark.. Do you think that's all there's to it?? Sometimes, people fails that geopolitics is NOT JUST SOME EMPIRICAL VALUES OR TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCEMENTS. As you said if that were the case ,then the xi ping pong would have never laid down a red carpet for a nobody like muizzu and never would have welcomed him so warm heartedly and promised to protect Maldives " national integrity " (as if this is not enough😂😂). He never even gave such respect to A.blinken. Let's not forget the amount of spies in Indian Ocean and the China rattled by Modi's greetings to TAIWANESE PM.. DO YOU THINK THESE ARE ALL SOME CHILDISH GAMES??😂😂 And it doesn't matter where one is! Coz one the higher u r the more painfully you fall😂😂
@user-yq2hv1ix8j
22 күн бұрын
@@abhi4biotech sadly your arrogance and prejudice against arts is really something that's blinding you
Woman, aren't you educated? You are born in India and he is your PM too. Haven't you seen US television channels say President Biden or President Trump regardless of their affiliation... Show some respect.
@hawkingdawking4572
25 күн бұрын
Modi is the leader of Hindus.
@Kim-ej2xm
25 күн бұрын
Why should she respect him when he is supporting Rapists ?
@nagarajpn9279
25 күн бұрын
Wtf? Don’t you have any other point to make?
@learnstocks7181
25 күн бұрын
What respect 😂😂😂 dumb bakths like you thinks we don't even call him with name? He is a public servant you idiot... Meh... These dumb bakths are total fools😂😂😂
@Appe_m
25 күн бұрын
Is Chowkidar Modi okay? Hari om
Modiji❤, china 👻
Woman is not one-sided herself after she accused China of being that ?? Lol
I dont understand these print journalists...ye log kaun hai kaha se athe hai...
@s-qc9ns
25 күн бұрын
Inke pass Paisa nhi hai iss liye kisi ko bhi utha lete hai.
Great analysis. ThePrint’s #EyeonChina and #GoToPakistan are some of the most underrated yet highly valuable offerings coming from this esteemed media organisation.
Thanks for the series!
Yeah why not we also seek Pakistan's opinion or if possible also ask the UK, wait why don't we let them choose who India PM would be?
Why is she just saying modi modi.... He's PM. Modi. Say it every time till he have the majority or till the end of his tenure. Have some respect for the person who hold the post.
@JohnnyRotten-uf6xw
25 күн бұрын
He's a public servant. What respect?
@AdiChintalapati
25 күн бұрын
Look at her name. Isn’t it obvious
@ashamsaud4737
25 күн бұрын
@@AdiChintalapati Look at your name. Isn't it obvious. Just look at the names who will lynch me for this. Isnt it obvious yet
@RivanJD
25 күн бұрын
Name tells everything.
@heirapparent3433
25 күн бұрын
Why? Is there a law against doing so?
Pl address PM Modi and not disrespectfully. All u told are not ,PM Modi making.
I watch your analysis on Taiwan talks too …Good decluttering you do mam
Is Modi your padosi or chacha? If you’re referring to Narendra Modi, you can’t call him just Modi..he is Prime Minister Modi. Have some basic sense to respect elected leaders. I think more than China you’re not happy with PM Modi’s winning.
@rajx7120
25 күн бұрын
She did not say President Xi also. Stop spamming.
@BollywoodBabuOfficial
25 күн бұрын
@@rajx7120 I don’t care if she says it for Xi or not but she should have President Xi . This is basics man and she’s a journalist, if some random layman said this on streets it is not an issue because they don’t know but she is a journalist.
@user-st2do8oo4i
25 күн бұрын
@@BollywoodBabuOfficial No its not basics. You can call anyone anything. You can abuse the Modi, use the most worse cuss words you can ever use, still its nothing. Why you treat him like some god or very fined individual. He is just appointed as PM of India by people, and those people can say whatever they want to him. And journalist are also people
@rallabhandiprabhakar4750
25 күн бұрын
This is ridiculous and one sided . You and some others may be over obedient or overawed devotee but many of us are not . That doesn’t mean we disrespect NM Why can’t we call NM as Modi . Many people call M.K. Gandhi as Gandhi and some call him Mahatma Gandhi . Just because Mahatma prefix is not used , one shouldn’t imagine MKG is being disrespected You must discard displaying such fossilised thinking in public .
@shantanusapru
25 күн бұрын
@BollywoodBabuOfficial: Aao andh-bhakt, padhaaro!🤣🤣🤣
Print is in india but the ink is from china
India is doing well if China is irritated by Modi 😂
Indian always be overconfident of their country, but in fact, for Chinese, nobody cares about who is Modi😮
Ping pong can go and play ping pong.......
have some respect--- What Modi Modi, atleast PM Modi or Modiji
@sashanksriram29
25 күн бұрын
Hes a freaking human being not god shut up
@Kushagra.j
25 күн бұрын
@@user-st2do8oo4i this is what your mother screams at Night 😂
@shantanusapru
25 күн бұрын
@amodernindian1358: Aao andh-bhakt, padhaaro!🤣🤣🤣🤣
@amodernindian1358
24 күн бұрын
@@shantanusapru ITS NOT ABT aNDBAKHT, ITS ABT RESPECT, AAPKE GHAR MEIN SHAYAD NAHI SIKHAI HOGI
@shantanusapru
24 күн бұрын
@@amodernindian1358 NAHI SIKHAYA HAI! RESPECT IS EARNED; FREE MEIN MAIN NAHI DETA!
Why do you want Xi Jinping's wish? Xi Jinping is China's president, not PM. His wish is for India's president Murmu. China's PM Li Qiang already sent PM Modi to wish his 3rd term.
Xi is disappointed with Modi's win. More 5 year wait to take over ladhak by invoking aggreement with congress party.
Excellent presentation
Modi Modi Modi, get some education. He is your PM, its PM Modi. This is what happens when you have degree but not proper education.
what’s this one point O and two point O??? simply say first term second term
Shekhar Gupta (PRINT) has fallen out of favour with the Modi establishment
This little young girl trying to teach geophysics anf india china relations. India and china had been at loggerhead dince long time resulting in 1962 war and dokhlam, 1967 fight. Therefore, ehst so big deal about xi not wishing pm modi. Does it matter so much? IN addition, recently india is moving towards TAIWAN.
Ping ping we dont worry 😂
first of you have manner to host .be civilized ,now he is PM by the people .why you speaking modi modi
Modijee is the prime Minister of India. So if chona acts big do a simple thing. Stop all imports from China. Indan customers have clout of 10 magnitude. Make china feel the pinch
Misinformation video, Sekhar Ji, I respect your journalism, kindly don't give your platform to persons with partiality with some ideologies. I want The Print to be itself as a benchmark to be a centrist and not leaning to any Left or Right.
@sps6
25 күн бұрын
All our journalism colleges are churning out Marxist stooges
Good analysis that substantially declutters this topic. Good job!
Wow, look who is analysing and advising how democracy should be. Those people who always been communist. If XI jing ping is real leader than make china democratic, Arrange india like election and try to win in that. We were behind, not weak. We also know that apart from Indian political parties, many countries had spent huge in indian lock sabha elections. I would simply say you have trusted wrong people and your money is wasted.
Give respect to pm ..hes not ur security guard
Modi never invincible or godman
PaaPOO Rani as PM of Bharat would be a black day in the history of Bharat !
India should realise China sees them as a small spec in the grand spectrum of things. China is way ahead in every field, it’s embarrassing how obsessed India is about comparing themselves with China and what they think about them😅
@venkataramanasrivatsasa6470
25 күн бұрын
But Global Times opines differently. If you're a spec, you won't indulge in propaganda in your mouth piece. Leaders of democracies are always at disadvantage vis a vis autocratic regimes.
@FloraFauna321
25 күн бұрын
Winnie the Pooh's bot sighted.... Always trying to demean their rivals. India is no longer part of that group. You can do what you like with Pakistan but not India. So go suck up to Xi
@abhishekjha8645
24 күн бұрын
India is more comparable to Pakistan than it is to China. Even Bangladesh is ahead of India in economic terms.
@user-yq2hv1ix8j
22 күн бұрын
😂😂😂 if that were the case the xi ping pong would have never laid down a red carpet for a nobody like muizzu and never would have welcomed him so warm heartedly and promised to protect Maldives " national integrity " (as if this is not enough😂😂). He never even gave such respect to A.blinken. Let's not forget the amount of spies in Indian Ocean and the China rattled by Modi's greetings to TAIWANESE PM.. DO YOU THINK THESE ARE ALL SOME CHILDISH GAMES??😂😂 And it doesn't matter where one is! Coz one the higher u r the more painfully you fall😂😂
印度人不会明白莫迪老仙的意思
Rahul should reposition himself regarding china otherwise this will be a major issue in next election
@TrendSuresh
23 күн бұрын
You care more about Rahul Vinci than your mother country
@sid8285
22 күн бұрын
Raul is too dumb and is not capable of any repositioning. He should remain in opposition till India becomes a 10 trillion dollar economy.
I don't think Modi also wished for China either!! So what is your point 😮😮😅😅😅😂😂
Well, India-China relations are not just due to Modi (whether 1.0, 2.0 or 3.0). They are also due to China. So, unless China changes/modifies/revises it stance(s) majorly, one shouldn't expect much change in India's stance(s) either...! What an idiotic video on a non-issue!
Yeh bhi Asuron ka channel hai
@hawkingdawking4572
25 күн бұрын
Then why do you watch it?
When everyone use the term 3.o, I remember Shankar who started this trend. When everybody named part 2 their sequal, he named 2.o
The fact is India and China are neighbours and will remain so forever. I feel it's essential to have a common ground between the two countries for mutual good. It's unwise to be a tool in the Western hands as a counter to China. The Western powers have their interests to protect and we can be quite expendable once those interests are met, as the case of Pakistan indicates. One must acknowledge how far ahead the Chinese have gone in the past few decades. Co-operation rather than confrontation will be the optimal decision for the two Asian giants.
@gauravshah89
25 күн бұрын
Tibet is our neighbor. Not china.
@AdiChintalapati
25 күн бұрын
Chinese have never been our neighbors. Please read history before commenting wrong things. Its the spinelessness of the great chacha that China is our neighbor now.
@vg6548
25 күн бұрын
India is not depending on the west for countering China. S. Jaishankar said it himself when asked about the same regd not supporting the west on Ukraine issue. They are surely helpful, but not to the extent that India can't do anything without them. Should we let China bulldoze us around to avoid confrontation? Its China that is starting the problem. So better preach them.
@FloraFauna321
25 күн бұрын
India should be guided by self interest rather than some easy or west power camp. The current policy is absolutely right . One cannot suck up to a hegemonic neighbour no matter how big it may be. Your views are archaic, misguided and foolhardy. Largely inspired by the Nehruvian era .... someone who handed over the UNSC seat to China
@Samdex92
24 күн бұрын
@@FloraFauna321 Buddy from the bitterness in your words and sticking to legacy issues, ask yourself who is archaic, foolhardy and misguided. Indian and Chinese economy used to be at par till a few decades back, long after the era of Neharuvian socialism. Chinese were quick to profit from shift in policies and reaping fruits of their demographic dividend. It was careful not to get distracted by antagonizing their neighbours. India with its base of youth (with more than two thirds of Indians under 35) can do much more if we get our priorities right. Confrontation with your neighbours isn't the smart way when it comes to growing your economy and collective well being of Indians. But if you wanna fall victim to pro-nationalism and "archaic" ideologies, that gonna result in a lost decade for India.
🤣🤣🤣
Sana , Where is your hijab
This woman neither understands China nor Geopolitics
@arunfernandes827
24 күн бұрын
Apparently you do 😂😂😂
@navinasimoes
24 күн бұрын
@@arunfernandes827 Definitely better than her
@varun2250
10 күн бұрын
@@navinasimoes Navina, please put out your own points on what you felt was wrong in this analysis by Sana. That would actually help all of us to approach this topic from different angles.
@navinasimoes
9 күн бұрын
@@varun2250 If you know how the system of Democratic centralism in a Communist Government works then you'd know.... A single person doesn't determine the fate of the system, it's the party and the National Congress that matters the most The President is the Head of the Military and the representative of the Government in the International affairs -Being the General Secretary, Xi is one of the high ranking members of the party, yet he has no contradictions with the average citizen of the country, but with the National Congress of the Party(The highest body of the Communist Party)
@varun2250
9 күн бұрын
@@navinasimoes What you described is how cpc behaved after mao. Shi jinping changed all that with his unilateral hold of the party like never before. Even mao didn't have such power and impulsive nature. In the past week alone, they jailed former Defence Minister and foreign minister who worked under shi for corruption. And these are not one off cases. Shi made cpc totally unpredictable which is one of the reasons why the economic downturn is gaining pace there. Show me any other cpc chairman who held more than two terms other than mao in such an unruly manner? Also under shi, politburo is as weak as it was under mao. This has everything to do with shi and nothing else.
Did india extend Invitation to Chinese president or primier to attend Modi's oath taking ceremony As per neighbour first policy and they didn't come Or the invitation wasn't sent?
@eshaba584
25 күн бұрын
Only south asian neighbours were invited😂😂.Have some knowledge before saying anything.
@pbkvijaykulkarni6404
25 күн бұрын
With China, just recall visit to sabarmati ashram and then to mahabalipuram in TN. What did india get in return ? So pl dont advocate China and Pak in Neighbor first policy
@user-fw1hj3vv2k
25 күн бұрын
Chinese president didn't accept the invitation i believe.
@emsworthcastle4849
25 күн бұрын
Like Pakistan, they only know how to backstab! At least we are not hypocrites!
@Arvindchauhan-qv6gd
25 күн бұрын
@@user-fw1hj3vv2kha ha how stupid you can be and your response proves that 😂😂😂😂
Despite BJP MP from Arunachal & Ladakh showing great concern about Chinese aggression, Modi denied it. That's how more than 20 Indian soldiers died.
It is very much a welcome gesture from Xi for saving the Democratic Tradition of India. Why should he congratulate an Undemocratic Government. China has helped in 1962 for saving the democracy of India by slacking the iron-like grip of Nehru to hold on to the post of PM for life. A mild jerk was very much necessary in 1962 to destroy the DemiGod like halo of Nehru. Hopefully, China will come to rescue our democracy if any urgency arises in future.
@rajx7120
25 күн бұрын
Lol! First, they should implement democracy in their own country.
@ajaypatra2863
25 күн бұрын
@@rajx7120 I agree with you my friend. But Chinese jerks in 1962 and 2020 have humbled our dictators. Otherwise any dissent in the atmosphere of fear and intimidation is practically impossible.
@mrseskasi
23 күн бұрын
The real dictator of India is in West Bengal not Modi. China will come to our aid??? What are you on ??? 😂 China blatantly claims Indian land as its own - what they will come to our aid. Damn the ccp are dictators to their own people. What a joke you have marooed.
Lol so many chini bots are here 🤡
This is a NDA-3 government not Modi-3. Andh bhakts don't know the difference
India: China, China,China,...... China: who cares.
@TheBasicsChannel
25 күн бұрын
Shi jin pig cares
@funlifestyle8001
25 күн бұрын
China:india, india, india..... India: 1 plate chowmein😂
@abhisen6745
25 күн бұрын
China cares for everything however small or big, its just not comes out to the world. majority of it is censored and happens in local scale in chinese language
@rajput2736
25 күн бұрын
Thats why whole time ...global times bark...okk...10 cent Chinese cyber army
@Arvindchauhan-qv6gd
25 күн бұрын
@@funlifestyle8001absolutely 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
M reporter anti india media channel
👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻
Indian always be overconfident of their country, but in fact, for Chinese, nobody cares about who is Modi😮