... It seems like he's saying if you give McCarthy a perfect situation he can succeed, but that's true for most of the guys at the top of the draft.

@TyroneBiggums789

2 ай бұрын

Analysts are all saying this now in part because it gives them a cop out to not look bad. Basically praise every QB prospect but say they’ll only succeed in a great situation, if they flop then you can just blame the situation and team, therefore you never have to be wrong. It’s lame…

@alsutton5667

2 ай бұрын

As you can see he’s not being honest he’s a lil salty🤣🤣🤣

@jdc9023

2 ай бұрын

No way. QB is the hardest position to predict for NFL success. When you're talking about a "sky is the limit" guy, we're talking a Brady, Rodgers, Mahomes, Allen type. Situation is big, but it won't make a Josh Rosen or Blake Bortles "elite."

@DerekGuy-pd8kq

2 ай бұрын

a perfect situation? You mean if he knows what the defense is gonn do before he snaps the ball? As if he stole their signs?

@sbs8128

2 ай бұрын

@@DerekGuy-pd8kqyou’re a clueless bozo. Stay in your basement

"If he has a great oline, a top back and pro bowl recievers, he could be good"!

@Braceman

2 ай бұрын

duh.....any quaterback would be lolol

@rj6110

2 ай бұрын

Brock purdy moment

@diddyfaplord

2 ай бұрын

Not to mention a top tier defense!

@bearwalsh6414

2 ай бұрын

aka jalen hurts

@fullofmuscledownunde

2 ай бұрын

So basically what Jayden Daniels had in college

Vikings are the spot for JJ: sit for a year behind Darnold. I'vs watched every one of JJ's games at Michigan. His performance on 3rd and long is special. Has a knack for making the right play at the right time. Universally loved by his teammates and coaches (except for Cade 'McNamara). High character dude who loves football. He's Kirk Cousins with a better arm and better athleticism.

@4TDsInOneGame

2 ай бұрын

Agreed…it’s JJs intangibles that I think have elevated his draft stock greatly recently.

@joshlewis575

2 ай бұрын

As a Michigander and lions fan it scares me to think of him with the vikings. KOC cam draw it up with the best of em. Oh and they have the best reciever in the league. NFC north is gonna be the toughest division in the league next year

@Kskol-ld7cq

2 ай бұрын

He's a winner period. Hopefully the Vikings get him at 4

The farther JJ slides in the draft, the better his chance of going to a good situation.

@michaelbettisworth8938

2 ай бұрын

True story

@user-ks3ol3lw3b

2 ай бұрын

Most teams with a good situation for a rookie QB already have a QB, and won't draft one in the first 2-3 rounds.

@DreamConundrum

2 ай бұрын

@@user-ks3ol3lw3b He doesn’t need “most” teams to draft him. One team will draft him. I doubt he will slide that far but he might do well sitting behind Goff in Detroit for a season.

@bigfootwalker5399

2 ай бұрын

and he will ruin that team!

@bigfootwalker5399

2 ай бұрын

​@@DreamConundrumin Detroit JJ can learn to bite kneecaps 🤣

I disagree with that blanket statement "with the right team" To me JJ is a guy you want to draft if you have the wrong team. He's pretty good all around, selfless, heard he's a good leader, I feel like he's the type of player who'd be a safe pick because of his versatility.

That could be said of almost every nfl prospect

@stevejonesll1399

2 ай бұрын

Right

@jla3562

2 ай бұрын

I was looking for this comment damn shame 😂 if I had a million I would be in the perfect situation

@fullofmuscledownunde

2 ай бұрын

Yeah but JJ I think is going to surpass what people say of him. I think he’s a gunslinger that was taught to game manage

@ronaldpetersen255

2 ай бұрын

Not true at all

@user-rv2dp6nd4k

2 ай бұрын

Which is a scared away with saying he needs a system that is going to make him successful, which is also a Speedway of saying that he’s not going to change the team

I absolutely love the annual Draft, but it also makes me want it to be September already so I can watch and hear Herbie talk CFB every Saturday 🏈.

He's going to be a solid starter

This was an excellent April Fool’s joke.

Go Blue!

The hate in the comments is hilarious. A very naturally talented, hard working, dedicated, smart and let’s not forget winning QB coached by an ex college and NFL quarterback who also happens to be a great college and NFL coach. Yeah I don’t see him standing a chance 😂

@DerekGuy-pd8kq

2 ай бұрын

you forgot" who cheated"

@JohnAC4

2 ай бұрын

@@DerekGuy-pd8kqwah wah, little cry baby can’t get over something everybody does in college, wah wah keep crying about it

@Crzysquirrel124thst

2 ай бұрын

You know a QB prospect is white when they are described as "hard-working, dedicated, smart, and a winner." Zach Wilson, Sam Darnold, Josh Rosen, etc., were all talked about the same way. When your coach doesn't trust you against Big 10 defenses, why would any coach trust you against an NFL defense?

@bv7441

2 ай бұрын

@@JohnAC4 - Didn’t you know that programs like Bama, Georgia, OSU, etc are as pure as the driven snow and would never bend any rules in order to gain an advantage? 😂😂😂

@DerekGuy-pd8kq

2 ай бұрын

@@JohnAC4 LOL-the EVERYONE DOES IT EXCUSE. Which isnt even true.

can't you say that about anyone? Purdy wouldn't be doing what hes doing if he was on the bears or cardinals

Bo Nix and Jayden Daniels both beat Justin Herbert their Freshman years

No other QB in college that’s a first rounder this year ran a pro style progression read system. All the others, one read, and then your option is launch it deep or take off running.

@KamuiCage

2 ай бұрын

That Pro style bs has been played out for a while i remember them saying it about Josh Rosen and other Qb. It doesn't mean you're going to be good in the NFL times have changed and the NFL has noticed it

@adamkoehler5747

2 ай бұрын

@@KamuiCagetrue. NFL coaches have started drafting for talent and adapting their system to fit the QB.

@rayontita1912

2 ай бұрын

Apart from the fact that that’s a lie (every offense has progressions and now the NFL runs so much college stuff that the lines are blurred), the fact of running a “pro style offense” in college doesn’t mean much. Every Iowa QB runs a pro style offense (Under centre, progressions, checks etc). How many of them worked out? Most of the top QB’s in the NFL ran a spread or an air raid in college and still learned NFL offenses.

Game changers: Maye and Williams, Mobile with throwing upside: Daniels, Penix, High end game manager: McCarthy, low end game manager: Nix

"Need an offensive line that can win the line of scrimmage" So definitely not the Vikings

JJ Mccarthy goes #1. How cool would that be.

@PaceFootball

2 ай бұрын

Not very

@KamuiCage

2 ай бұрын

Bears fans would riot, Commanders fans would celebrate

@farriskhan2352

2 ай бұрын

​@@KamuiCageBecause media experts told Bears fans that a different guy should be #1, and this would not fit that narrative?

@KamuiCage

2 ай бұрын

@@farriskhan2352 No because they watch football and know that Williams has been the #1 ranked QB for 3 years for a reason. The media tried to push the Trubisky and Daniel Jones hype but the fans knew those guys were not good Qbs because we actual watch football games not just highlights or only listen to draft coverage after the season ends. The fans in Chicago and NY hated those picks when it happened even though most boards had Trubisky #1 in 2017 and some had Jones very high in 2019

@farriskhan2352

2 ай бұрын

@@KamuiCage So you are saying that "fan buzz" is more important than GM expertise?

“With the right team” my grandma could be epic. 😂

@whatvrrdude

2 ай бұрын

nah ur grandma would get knocked tf out on any team playa

When have the college football analysts, jeremy klatt also, ever been write about college qbs?

Kirk having his seatbelt buckled up in a parked car is low key hilarious

Jj will be great hope he goes to the right place mannn

Only time will tell....................

@buckhorncortez

2 ай бұрын

That is so insightful...did you think that up all by yourself...?

@JohnMyers-yk3hq

2 ай бұрын

yep@@buckhorncortez

Everyone has slept on this kid...Mark my words he will do great in the NFL.

@KamuiCage

2 ай бұрын

People say this every year about their teams Qb or favorite player. I remember a guy saying this about Paxton Lynch

@TheJakekeller22

2 ай бұрын

@@KamuiCagelynch didn’t play against any good teams and didn’t win a natty as well as the best winning percentage in college football history.

@KamuiCage

2 ай бұрын

@@TheJakekeller22 I was just using Lynch as an example but i hear this every season for the past 20 years about a fans favorite Qb . ,Aj McCarron, Greg McCelroy, Stetson Bennett, Bliane Gabbert, Jake Locker, everyone believes the guy from their school is slept on and is a winner , a leader and going to be a great Qb. Winning percentage and Nattys are team accomplishments Stetson won 2 , Mac Jones won a title while throwing 41 Tds and 4 ints

I heard another analyst say something like "JJ is basically a B+ at everything, and a couple of A- traits" I'm a Commanders fan, and at #2 overall, I want a chance for an A. Give me Maye/Daniels...Whoever the team has the plan in place to make us contend again.

kirk needs to take the invisiline out or gus johnson is rubbing off on him

He better pray NE doesn’t draft him!

Maxx Crosby 2024 DPOY - Herbie

After seeing what Brock Purdy did with the 49ers a lot of team might go back to the traditional route with goin for accurate qb now only the team that have good linemen n good wrs yk what I mean lol

I’m a huge Michigan fan, I think McCarthy will be an excellent NFL QB. But I DON’T think he should be a top 5 pick in all honesty. None of those teams are set up to develop this kid. He needs a little bit of time to work on layered throws but beyond that he has so many of the traits guys mention in elite quarterbacks.

McCarthy perfect spiral tho wow

Can't believe we're in an age where someone can do an interview in their freaking car.

@benmecha01

2 ай бұрын

it’s honestly preferred

Go Blue

Not going to lie I feel like dude can turn into a version of Tom Brady….cause he’s willing to do and win how watever is required that game…yes he got carried with the running game but also wen he need to do his job more times then not he did it….i truly think wen it’s all set and down he will be looked at differently then wat he’s looked at now in a good way

clearly, the higher a player is drafted, the worse the team he's going to - unless some team trades up big time. and there are some teams who draft high over a number of years and their players just don't pan out and everyone concludes that the player was a bust. but herbstreit also made a point that most fans just don't get about leadership - which can't be quantified - but does matter. mccarthy has that "it" factor in that regard.

Situation is almost thr most important factor for rookie QB's we all know this lol, If you can find a guy that can drag dysfunction through mud thats what you are really after

JJ behind Stafford in LA would be fine with me

They say this every year smh

Imagine if these guys had to bet their pension money on their predictions. There would be no predictions. You may as well pick names out of a hat. A few weeks ago, Maye was a lock for #2, and McCarthy was somewhere down around the start of the 2nd round. Since then, no games have been played, and the draft has turned upside down. Just like every year.

@stevejonesll1399

2 ай бұрын

Nobody knows, so they just pretend like they do, because they get paid to. It's insane that Brock Purdy, the last picked dude in the draft has been in the last two years playoffs, and won a few. Nobody has any clue, because anything can happen, the only reason they pay these guys, is because stupid people exist and they believe everything they are told

Herbie is god’s gift to us all for football analysis

I'm a Buckeye fan, but i don't hate McCarthy. Great college player, not sure if he's going to be a great NFL player? The QB position is a crap shoot usually in the Pros.

So Michigan should draft him

So basically like any guy drafted?

He’s such a viking

The hype? Why harbough ties? Do you think harbough would have had hime throw for 250+ more than 3 times last year if he's the real deal? No, huge run game, huge defense, he's a Flaco or Eli at best, get a ring in "the right situation".

There is way too much smoke with this kid. Like... Could y'all stop hyping him up? People are setting him up for failure.

What QB wouldn't succeed if you stacked the team and made him hand the ball off mostly like in Michigan.

JJ is modern day Tim Tebow😂 bro really said film doesn’t matter because he’s a winner😂😂😂

@bv7441

2 ай бұрын

Dude… Tebow couldn’t throw the ball. JJ can make pretty much every throw and has solid arm strength. Have you watched football before?

@kyloren-cd8dk

2 ай бұрын

@@bv7441 lol it’s not a literal comparison, it’s a comparison between the prospects. Everything this guy said about JJ is the same stuff people said about Tebow. And no JJ cannot make every throw. Show me his deep ball from the opposite hash. I’ll save you the time. He attempted 3 all season. Show me his deep posts from the opposite hash off of play action. Again he never did it. JJ has no displayed a consistent ability to make nfl throws, or rather throws that we see every Sunday from top 10 qbs. Now maybe you’re right and he actually can make those throws, but we have no reason to believe he can. He just never did it at Michigan.

Anytime we needed to convert 3rd down I prayed we would hand the ball off to blake corum.

@maizeman90

2 ай бұрын

Even though McCarthy was one of the best, if not the best, 3rd down QBs in the country?

He’s gonna be a Bronco

The sky's the limit for anybody if the right team drafts them. This seems like one of those cliche sports takes that sounds good but really means nothing. Like a hockey post game interview

@eats4cheaps305

2 ай бұрын

It's really not. Plenty of 1st rounded have been created to a team built to make them succeed and they don't. What he's saying is, if the team is able to run the ball and protect the QB then this kid could start year 1 and be good.

With the way teams are treating QBs the past several years, I bet they All fail. Teams are looking for the one in a million like MaHomes which doesn’t happen but once in a generation. Talking about dual threat QBs, how many can be that way for more than a few years? NONE! Age sets in, they get slower, they take too many hits and they’re forced to be pocket passers which many can’t handle. Owners aren’t developing QBs the same way they used to and don’t understand why they can’t win a SB in year two without a veteran mentor.

JJ is the best QB in the draft. All QB needs support. If Tom Brady was drafted by the Lions, he would likely does not make it out of year 1 as a NFL QB.

Nix

no duh...with the right situation all players could be great...

With a team of genetically engineered supermen with futuristic cyborg implants I think McCarthy might find a way to lose.

@bv7441

2 ай бұрын

This makes no sense considering the kid has lost like 2 games since the beginning of HS…

@onliwankannoli

2 ай бұрын

@@bv7441 I did say “might.” His high school stats don’t mean anything, even great college QBs often don’t do well at the next level. We’ll see.

I don’t understand why people hate on JJ cus literally any qb can become elite nobody can predict the future. I personally think if the Vikings land him it’s the best fit for him cus he would have weapons around the board olus Kirk was holding the Vikings back.

@Ericrawnsley

2 ай бұрын

Nobody hates on him. Saying he's not good enough to be a franchise qb off of the talent he's shows in not hating... it's using logic. Out of all the qbs talked about being taken in the first he is undoubtedly the least skilled

@jona.scholt4362

2 ай бұрын

"Undoubtedly the least skilled" Is a roundabout way of saying, "I haven't watched JJ McCarthy very much"

@joedavon3290

2 ай бұрын

@@Ericrawnsley literally anyone can do better than kirk in Minnesota. Not to mention other teams who need a qb still just to add competition.

@BenCarmichael0

2 ай бұрын

The difference between jj and the other qbs is his iq. It's at the nfl level already because Jim Harbaugh had taught him like an ex qb turned coach. He made him understand the game and that's why he doesn't have crazy passing numbers, he literally was the coach on the field managing the game. His skills, he a 5 start recruit and the most accurate qb in the draft so it's on the coach to bring it all together. That's why it depends where he goes and the sky's the limit

@samariohoward6298

2 ай бұрын

​@@Ericrawnsleyleast skilled at what..

His arm is sub par at best he can run and extend plays that's it

@bv7441

2 ай бұрын

Says guy who clearly hasn’t watched him play…

He would be set if he went to the Rams but he'll go to the Vikings and have to play too early and be mid

It’s crazy Drake maye is a Top 3 prospect the other 3 guys who literally proven winners been on championship competing teams aren’t . Just funny to me .

he's a viking

@kpink915

Ай бұрын

This aged well

Did Herbstreit get dentures or something?

If the team has Connor Stallions it’s the perfect place for him to succeed

@jmillerMAGA

2 ай бұрын

Rent free in your head

McCarthy and Williams are the big QB busts this year.

@thestoty8676

2 ай бұрын

lol Williams a bust but not JJ. Not even close. JJ is going to kill it in the League

JJ is this year's Will Levis. Although I think he won't fall past Denver

What a nothing comment.

If you give this QB a great OLine, WRs, and RB he will be successful! Wow!!!

patriots trying to over draft this dud

Harbaugh didn’t trust him to throw the ball. That is a HUGE red flag

@thestoty8676

2 ай бұрын

Michigan was a run first team.

everyone but tom a clown in this

His comp is Zach Wilson.

Mac Jones 2.0

I swear I’d rather have bo nix or Michael penix if it means you don’t have to trade up for the 4th pick for someone who was originally projected a 3rd rd qb.

Alright Herbstreit, I’ll remember that and will be there when you’re wrong

JJ Vikings Perhaps 🤔

Not his fault but this dude might be the most overrated qb ever😭

What the actual hell is up with the sudden JJ McCarthy hype

I'm sorry, this guy will be a bust!

First baby

But unfortunately the right team would have to be the 1994 Dallas Cowboys

JJ McCarthy is AJ McCarron 2.0

If Bryce young had a stud O line and landed at the perfect.. I mean “right spot” he would’ve been rookie of the year. So yeah, you right herb. 😂😂😂😂

@eats4cheaps305

2 ай бұрын

CJ still would have locked that down

Please, not Minnesota

@joedavon3290

2 ай бұрын

you're dumb lol vikings need a qb and he's the most likely guy to fall to you vikings. Not to mention literally anyone can do better than kirklyn cousins.

@michaelmaas5544

2 ай бұрын

They’d be lucky to have him

JJ is a slightly better Zach Wilson, minus the milf hunting Wilson is the GOAT at that

JJ is garbage.

Imagine if you knew what the defense was doing your entire career… haha. Fraud

@glennpelton4887

2 ай бұрын

What? How is that possible? What' your proof? Even if what you're saying is true, we know for sure that Michigan didn't know what Michigan State, Purdue, Penn State, Maryland, Ohio State, Iowa, Alabama, and Washington were doing don't we. Every one of them bit the dust. Defenses can hide coverages. For example, against Illinois in 2022 the fighting Illini gave Michigan problems all game due to disguising their scheme until just before the snap. Still Blake Corum had just over 100 yards in the first half before going down with a season ending knee injury. It took a last-minute drive with the J.J. THE FRAUD making plays to lead the Michigan Wolverines to the win 19-17 on a field goal with 12 seconds left. So, please explain.

@bradleywright202

2 ай бұрын

@@glennpelton4887triggered much

@bv7441

2 ай бұрын

@@bradleywright202- So no explanation… That’s what we all expect out of you know-nothing coping clowns.

@Buffalorock902

2 ай бұрын

@@glennpelton4887 Proof? It’s fact and so many levels. Regarding the second half of 2023.. true they didn’t have all the info. However what they had was a winning culture (players buy in, coaches staying, recruits, money) all built on a false narrative. They were able to put this is motion for over 2 years by cheating. Had they followed the rules they would’ve had the same ups and downs and not had some of those desired outcomes. You can’t cheat for 2 + years , say you’re stopping and then get accolades for success by a group built fraudulently.

@Buffalorock902

2 ай бұрын

@@bv7441 what explanation do you want? The fact that your program cut your coaches salary in half in 2020? The fact that your school accepted suspension because they knew fighting this was not winnable? The fact that Stallions was on the sideline of others teams games and then immediately let go, along with the LB coach when all this started to come out? The fact that your qb admitted to this after the bama game? The fact that the ncaa has served up a ton of info to the school to prepare them for what’s coming? The fact that they openly purchased the tickets and kept records so thoroughly… I get it, you finally got what you want but none of it was earned by following the rules everyone else does. It’ll take a couple years but at some point all the fraudulent achievements will be erased.

People are going to look back in 5 years at this guy like wtf were we thinking like they look at trubisky being taken over mahomes. Michigan was dominant in every aspect of their team this guy was the least impressive. No touch on his throws finesse just guns it 100 mph on every throw.

these peole are on durgs.....JJ is terrible as a QB, look at his status compare to other QB.. He will be a bust for sure

Basically he saying average players that’s needs a lot of help he not a top 5 Qb

I see JJ being Mayfield 2.0 and that's not a compliment

JJ is a weaker Mac Jones or Sam Darnold. Will not make anything in the NFL. Drake Maye has a higher upside.

@jona.scholt4362

2 ай бұрын

"JJ is a weaker Mac Jones or Sam Darnold." You chose a strange way to say "I haven't watched JJ McCarthy very much"

@The_Real_ZC

2 ай бұрын

Wow brilliant take.

By the "right team"; he means a team that can illegally video the sidelines and steal signs in order for JJ to be successful

@samariohoward6298

2 ай бұрын

Its legal in nfl if u didnt know

@Smiththebat

2 ай бұрын

Oh my goooooddddd.

@DerekGuy-pd8kq

2 ай бұрын

@@samariohoward6298 “No video recording devices of any kind are permitted to be in use in the coaches' booth, on the field, or in the locker room during the game,”

5th round pick at best.

@michaelmaas5544

2 ай бұрын

😂 you obviously know nothing of the game

@PaulVisionLee

2 ай бұрын

@@michaelmaas5544 you prob thought Tebow should be drafted first round as well

@michaelmaas5544

2 ай бұрын

@@PaulVisionLee nope, called his bust as well as Manziels and the jury’s still out but I think Fields will be one too.

@PaulVisionLee

2 ай бұрын

@@michaelmaas5544 but you think JJ should be drafted first round?!?!

@michaelmaas5544

2 ай бұрын

@@PaulVisionLee he’s a lot closer to a 1st rounder than a 5th

stupid the sky is the limit with any quarterback, give me a break......JJ is terrible look at his numbers compare to everyone else. He will be a bust for sure

@andyfamas

2 ай бұрын

The fact you just look at the numbers shows why youre just a guy commenting on a youtube video and will never actually be in charge of drafting

@Braceman

2 ай бұрын

If you understand, football numbers is everything when it comes to the NFL. Obviously you don’t know anything about football.

@Matt-ps1jv

2 ай бұрын

So true, in-game context should be irrelevant. The fact that Michigan was a run first offense doesn’t matter.

@andyfamas

2 ай бұрын

@@Braceman lmao the most casual take I’ve ever heard.

This is hilarious. JJ isn't even as good as Zach Wilson.

@tm8916

2 ай бұрын

In which way lol?

@theflixcapacitor1372

2 ай бұрын

@@tm8916 exactly

@tm8916

2 ай бұрын

@@theflixcapacitor1372 astute analyzation! You a bot 🤣

@theflixcapacitor1372

2 ай бұрын

@@tm8916 unable to confirm or deny

Tainted Natty ... Stop jockin'. 🔨

@oldschoolg5661

2 ай бұрын

Butt hurt buckeye waaa waaa waaa, your natty was more tainted with Maurice Clarett 😂

Dudes 2024 Zach Wilson

Brother was not considered a good QB until they got caught in a scandal. Take that for what you want, JJ the next over valued QB.

McCarthy will bust 200000%

Biggest bust. Just gotta talk about him since he’s the only white QB “highly rated” in this draft

@geminiifilms6768

2 ай бұрын

lol cry more

@dezmondcrawford6813

2 ай бұрын

Drake maye?

@DANNYBUCKETS5333

2 ай бұрын

Drake maye

@deadeyedad8831

2 ай бұрын

lol at least do your homework…goofy 🤡

@theecharmingbilly

2 ай бұрын

Embarrassing op

He lost to TCU And his team was busted for sign stealing. NFL will be a rude awakening for him.

@stevendonanski2292

2 ай бұрын

What a chump take, he lost a shootout to tcu, the only game Michigan was without a rb. FYI everyone steals signs in the nfl. Really think reading zone or man helped him win that much 😂 ever hear of RPO.

@jonathan45732

2 ай бұрын

Tell me your joking 😂😂😂 every team “steals signs” in college that’s nothing knew…… no different then watching NFL film and seeing what plays a team calls from certain formations…… Your not an NFL scout and there’s a reason nobody in the NFL is gonna come knocking asking for your opinion.

@TheGloriousLeader

2 ай бұрын

And they beat Alabama and Washington after the alleged stealing was ended.

@jonathan45732

2 ай бұрын

@@stevendonanski2292 Exactly! Like the dude has to be trolling (it’s April 1st)

@billhicks808

2 ай бұрын

The potential to be able to steal signs is not quite the negative you seem to think it is.