" I do not love the sword for its sharpness, nor the arrow for its swiftness, nor the warrior for his glory. I love only that which they defend. " - Faramir

@master_samwise

11 ай бұрын

Faramir is another incredible character. His portrayal in the movies is unfortunate.

@clarahudson8283

11 ай бұрын

Beautiful

@snubblebubble4937

10 ай бұрын

Faramir is the character who Tolkien described as being the most like himself. It is very sad how they portrayed him in the movies, but his arc in the book is phenomenal.

@aramir5061

10 ай бұрын

What a great character

@jeremysteed3527

10 ай бұрын

​@@snubblebubble4937I was gonna make this same comment.

Personally, the way I see it, the healthiest form of masculinity is knowing when to be Aragorn and when to be Sam Gamgee

@master_samwise

10 ай бұрын

I say: is it too much to ask for both? (Sam Gamgee video coming soon to a KZread near you... eventually)

@tj-co9go

9 ай бұрын

Sam Gamgee embodies what a good friend a should always be like - always willing to support you when you cannot do it yourself, even if you don't want it

@lightworker2956

9 ай бұрын

Yeah, excellent point. Sure Aragorn is great, but he's also superhuman (exceeding a human's lifespan and having healing powers). Aragorn is very handsome, he's the rightful king, people owe him service just because of him being the rightful king, he gets a magical sword handed to him and a beautiful elf woman loves him. In other words, real-life humans can never be Aragorn, because they don't have Aragorn's advantages. Yes I get that Aragorn has virtues that real-life humans can aspire to, but still, telling people "just be a superhuman rightful king with magical swords and beautiful elf wives" is going to sound to disenfranchised men like "... I can't possibly be that." Disenfranchised men already know that if they're highly successful then people will think they're great. Citing Aragorn doesn't dispel that perception. You might actually annoy disenfrachised men by citing Aragorn, because it might sound to them like a variant of "just be hyper-successful bro and then all your problems are solved." I know that's not the point, but that's what it can sound like. Meanwhile, as you say, Sam Gamgee is someone who an actual human could actually be. Yes I know he's a hobbit and not a human, yes I know he's on a supernatural quest, but he doesn't have supernatural advantages or magical swords or elf wives or rightful kingship. He's just a really good and steadfast dude. @master_samwise

@nopolitics8745

8 ай бұрын

@@lightworker2956 LEarning to be a servant and a leader at the same time is very essential. True humility

@nathanaelgajdos5317

8 ай бұрын

I would argue that Sam and Aragorn embody the same sort of masculinity and humility. The difference is that they were different people. They had different strengths, weaknesses, abilities, duties, and realms of influence. I believe that both Sam's and Aragorn's characters are such that if they had switched places, they probably would have acted similarly. This is just my opinion, so let me know if you disagree.

A quote from my grandfather. "A man knows he has truly grown into manhood when he ceases trying to PROVE that he is a man to those around him."

@simplewrites

4 ай бұрын

A wise man

@jeil5082

3 ай бұрын

reminds me of my late grandpa, he was the kindest and funniest man i knew as a kid.

@ShenLong33

2 ай бұрын

Wise man.

@nickcunningham6344

Ай бұрын

Your grandfather sounds like a wise man.

@tbneddy9216

19 күн бұрын

Fantastic quote 💯

Another often overlooked aspect of Aragorn's masculinity is how he is willing to show vulnerability. Yes he can knock some orc heads off, but he can also recite Elvish poetry, confide in the people he loves, and show genuine emotion at the loss of a friend.

@ignerisviivii8551

9 ай бұрын

It is not about how he is willing to show vulnerability, but to whom he is willing to show it, and when he is willing to show it. A man, a real man is stoic, in control of himself and his emotions. Thus, a man will show his emotions only to a select few, and only to a time he deems appropriate, and only to a certain degree, a degree from which he could remain composed, and in control of himself. Highlighting vulnerability is not the solution ; rather, highlight discernment is.

@TechnoSpectre3

9 ай бұрын

And pretend to eat a disgusting soup to make Eowyn happy on the trail.

@katieblake3023

9 ай бұрын

@@ignerisviivii8551 Extremely well said! Thank you for highlighting that important distinction.

@katieblake3023

9 ай бұрын

@@TechnoSpectre3 lol

@akashajones6079

9 ай бұрын

​@@ignerisviivii8551No. Men do not need to be stoic. Especially since so few are capable of being actually stoic and rather just become emotionless asshats.

So good. “True humility is not thinking less of yourself, but thinking of yourself less.”

@hebercluff1665

11 ай бұрын

Very true. I've thought, ever since I was young, that people who think of themselves as victims are just as prideful as those who think of themselves as great. The common factor is that they're both thinking of themselves. If you're always dwelling about how the world is about to get you, then you are still thinking of yourself, and you're making yourself out to be a hero with a tragic backstory. I've seen it way too often (mostly from a few relatives of mine) where people act as if they're better than others because they've suffered more. "Those people over there are just rich wussy's who've never had to do anything hard." That sounds a little prideful to me. What if the person you're masking fun of has gone through something horrible? Having money doesn't magically make you happy. Being rich also statically makes you more likely to commit suicide, so it's not all sunshine and rainbows (though life is still easier in some ways.) Anyway, it's just better if we avoid comparing ourselves to others. Thinking that your suffering makes you special is just as prideful as thinking that your blessings make you special.

@grantstratton2239

10 ай бұрын

Great definition. I also like the definition that "Humility is the courage to face your own weaknesses honestly".

@user-ej1oe2jl9h

10 ай бұрын

my friend these are wise words, and indeed it is so, humility isn't meant to be either; (a) a doormat for people to walk on, or (b) self-victimizing by claiming that you are nothing. which honestly, this is the a big misunderstanding of let's say for example humility in the bible or of kings and queens who were actually good people. people who didn't allow people to step on them, but didn't think of themselves. in other words, they weren't self-centered people. a beautiful lesson for us all. 😃😃😃

@Superduper666

10 ай бұрын

Quite a few TikTok people need to think this way

@KevinJohnson-cv2no

10 ай бұрын

You only think of things less when they decrease in importance or urgency. It's the same thing. Humility is for the insects.

" I don’t credit Disney for my high standards in men; I credit Tolkien "

@sourisvoleur4854

10 ай бұрын

Is that original with you, or did someone say that that you're quoting?

@forelithe3517

10 ай бұрын

@@sourisvoleur4854 anon.

@jilllogan1288

10 ай бұрын

I agree. As a middle aged woman I look to Aragorn to find the strength I need to do what I must without getting angry or too emotional but allow myself to feel what I do without feeling weak. For years I've had to rely on myself to get things done. Aragorn is my guide,strength and love and compaasion.

@arianewinter4266

9 ай бұрын

Someone made a post, about which grown men you would feel comfortable being stuck in an elevator with and honestly, it's pretty much every Tolkien character that is not grima, or another serven of saurons. Even denethor and saruman who are aholes have to much class as if they would feel like bothering you.... Tolkien wrote way before his time extreamly progressiv characters!!!

@blissseeker4719

6 ай бұрын

​@@arianewinter4266Tolkien is a Christian. Progressive ideology is regressive

I think as a woman, this is one of the reasons that, even though the series doesn't have very many female characters (though the present few ARE all strong characters), I've never had a problem with the lack of female characters. Its not a series about the male characters trying to be macho tuff guys and saving the day. The masculinity of most of the male characters is rooted in love, duty, and honor, which is something EVERYONE can admire and connect with, regardless of gender. To me, Aragorn is THE man, he embodies every ideal masculine trait in a healthy way. Knowing the life and backstory of Tolkien, being a young man who went to war alongside his friends and experienced immense grief over their loss, really puts his view of masculinity and heroism into perspective. Fantastic video, well worded and relevant to the two very conflicting viewpoints of masculinity being perpetuated today.

@liviasilva3333

7 ай бұрын

i agree wholeheartedly with this.

@Elamado97

7 ай бұрын

It reflects real life, men are the ones who often go to war while women stay back as support and lead the people at home which i think is a good take for the kind of story lotr is. He made up for the lack of female characters by using those traits on the male characters, i think that makes it more impactful because its not like he forced it on them, no, they naturally formed like that.

@DG-iw3yw

6 ай бұрын

Bet you didnt know around 50% of armed forces are women...Youve been reading too much nonsense. Past a certain point in history, women were pulling their weight, this whole idea that women dont go out and fight etc is cripplingly modern, and people cant help but repeat things they have heard, that sounds good to them...

@amicaaranearum

6 ай бұрын

“A time may come soon,” said he, “when none will return. Then there will be need of valor without renown, for none shall remember the deeds that are done in the last defense of your homes. Yet the deeds will not be less valiant because they are unpraised.” --Aragorn (to Éowyn)

@minecraftfox4384

6 ай бұрын

@@DG-iw3yw Nothing you've said is factual.

When Aragorn holds Boromir's hand and weeps for his death, that was what proved to me that he deserves to become King. A true king is one who knows the weight of every life that is in his care. He has a golden heart and hands that seek to mend a broken world.

@elessartelcontar9415

3 ай бұрын

And he had to go through hell, decades in the wilderness fighting unbelievable evil at impossible odds with no home. Always at high risk and the enemy hunting him. He deserves the big win he finally got.

@Machoman50ta

20 күн бұрын

Rick grimes going to play Aaron in the lotr movie 😅

We all need to thank Tolkien for pushing the best virtues possible into young men and women. Aragorn is incredible but so is Eowyn.

@master_samwise

10 ай бұрын

Eowyn is an incredible example of courage and (in the book) provides a beautiful example of learning patience and trust. I wish the movie had had more time to spend with her and Faramir in the Houses of Healing.

@Hero_Of_Old

10 ай бұрын

​@@master_samwiseyep, the houses of healing is essential for Eowyns arc.

@arty_nattie

10 ай бұрын

@@master_samwise Do you have a video about her? I wanna see the other side of the coin.

@kyledabearsfan

10 ай бұрын

The key to both is patience and understanding.

@bullgravy6906

10 ай бұрын

She was done perfectly. Her fight against the Witchking wasn’t really a fight at all, she stood her ground but was terrified, laughably overmatched, and was a second away from being crushed like the comparative bug she was, but she was saved by Merry before delivering the final blow. It was glorious for all of that, and would’ve sucked horribly if she just flatout beat this character that made brushed aside Gandalf like a minor inconvenience

As a young man, I've always looked at Aragorn as one of the best references in popular culture for what true masculinity looks like, excellent video!

@master_samwise

11 ай бұрын

He’s one of the best! LotR is full of incredible examples, but each in his own way.

@christophergillette7167

10 ай бұрын

If you’re gonna take a role-model from fiction, this is an excellent choice. For me, I actually got a very similar vibe from Gregor the Overlander. He’s just a kid, but deep down he’s so similar. He *will* do what needs to be done, and protect those in need, and no danger or suffering can push him from that course.

@AlfaLyr

10 ай бұрын

Excellent choice

@painunending4610

10 ай бұрын

You've fallen for the old system my friend. By defining something as 'true masculinity' you are still upholding the idea of a 'real man' which is harmful Hopefully one day we can work out of this and leave the old systems behind. I understand why people cling to them, they're comfortable and the chaos is not, but still it can be depressing

@legendarymarston9174

10 ай бұрын

​@@painunending4610What do you consider the best option?

"For even the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.”

"Your strength is not for yourself, it's for others." Words to live by.

@theone-tg4ey

10 ай бұрын

yeah, I hate me, but id die for the ones I love

@joesplace2960

9 ай бұрын

Gonna steal that and make my new motto.

@Elamado97

7 ай бұрын

​@@theone-tg4eycan you truly love others if you have never even loved yourself?

@censoredbybigbrother1175

2 ай бұрын

Depends on the other... for my brothers... yes. For some hostile invaders...they can have hot lead.

@jelmervd2l

2 ай бұрын

@@Elamado97I don't know, but why couldn't you love another without loving yourself?

"For Frodo" Those two words embody everything about doing the right thing for those you care for.

@HiHi-lt1cb

10 ай бұрын

"You bow to no one"

@vincentcleaver1925

10 ай бұрын

And he says it quietly, too

@gellister

10 ай бұрын

I also think it says a lot about how your focus is where you make a difference. He doesn't say "For Middle-Earth!" because Aragorn doesn't love Middle-Earth, he loves his friends like Frodo and he fights to protect them which in turn helps save the world. I think with that, the fellowship in general, and especially Samwise, Tolkien is saying "Save your friends and you help save the world, give your strength to your companions because that is what truly matters and you help them carry their burdens which in turn helps the world.".

@BabyXiuhcoatl

10 ай бұрын

​@@vincentcleaver1925With tears in eyes.

@shmerelize

8 ай бұрын

FRODO LIVES!

I feel like people mistake toxic behaviors as masculine behaviors. Toxic behaviors are toxic regardless of gender. Masculinity isn't about being aggressive, angry, or beating your chest like how most people portray "toxic" masculinity, but standing up for what's right, holding true to your values and beliefs, standing up for the defenseless, and doing your duty along with other upstanding traits.

@Justday216

11 ай бұрын

Summary: having integrity

@Vexreal_

11 ай бұрын

factual toxic masculinity is a very real thing that stems from a misunderstanding of what it means to be masculine.

@Justday216

11 ай бұрын

@@Vexreal_ it's either one extreme or the another real masculinity it's from the middle it's like having two swords one swords is the destroyer the violent the rage the war like sword you have then the other sword is the protector the provider the carer too others who can't protect themselves so real masculinity is having the mindfulness to know what sword to use in that situation

@master_samwise

11 ай бұрын

Well said. Toxic masculinity isn't masculinity at all. It's just being an asshat.

@andrew9371

11 ай бұрын

​@@Justday216yes integrity is the most masculine of traits

When I was still a child, I loved Aragorn for how *cool* he was. Now that I’m in my 30’s, I love him for how *good* he was. There’s nothing wrong with a good ol’ power fantasy now and then. But I find it quite helpful to remember, from time to time, that the King of Kings was a healer and the son of a carpenter.

@juanmiguelfrissatessa1950

9 ай бұрын

Amén to that❤.

@barbarahansen626

8 ай бұрын

Amen.

@SusieQ3

8 ай бұрын

Amen ❤

@eatprayhop680

8 ай бұрын

Amen

@dizzyheads

8 ай бұрын

I'm really hoping they don't try to bring him up again and ruin his character

I love your definition of humility. Miyamoto Musashi said something along similar lines: "Think lightly of yourself and deeply of the world"

@JoshGlastra

5 ай бұрын

I have this same quote inscribed on my Leatherman, great one!

-I never thought I would see eye to eye with a christian... -How about eye to eye with a fellow human trying to make sense of life? -Aye, I could do that.

I just wanted to say, as a young woman, I love seeing this kind of content. I wish more men my age had the maturity and strength to aspire to true masculinity like this! I think true femininity is of a very similar nature; both sexes should pursue that which is good, loving, and to the benefit of others. We may just go about it in slightly different ways, due to our strengths and abilities. Thank you again very much! 😊🥰

@master_samwise

11 ай бұрын

Absolutely!

@laurenloertscher1319

11 ай бұрын

Same, friend. Same.

@spencerjensen1993

11 ай бұрын

I completely agree. Young men need to know how to be masculine. As a young man, I wish there were also content of a similar nature showing young women how to be feminine.

@aidanjanemcintosh6919

10 ай бұрын

This is stupid, but I also kinda admired your choice of word 'more men'. If it was me I'd definitely use 'most'. Such humility👏

@elyssacorbaley8133

10 ай бұрын

@@spencerjensen1993 There are a lot of great examples of true and pure femininity! I personally feel that many females in Tolkien's work fit that description. However, the one I am the most appreciative of, and familiar with, is women of the Bible. If you ever want incredible accounts about feminine yet strong women, you could read the book of Esther, the story of Abigail and David (before he was King of Israel,) the judge Deborah, and so many more! Sorry for the long long reply, but I really do love the topic of giving people excellent examples to look up to. 😊

Viggo Mortensen absolutely nailed the portrayal of Aragorn, which really helped bring the character to life for the films. I also really liked and appreciated the character of Sam. He was strong, loyal, and confident in his gentle masculinity too. And Sean Austin did an equally great job portraying Sam.

I think two additional points to add are that 1. He is not intimidated by or threatened by the women in Lord of the Rings. He trusts and relies on Arwen to get Frodo to Rivendel despite the ringwraiths hunting them. He also has no problem with Eowyn wanting to go into battle despite her father and brother insisting that she should not go. 2. At the end in Return of the King when Aragorn is crowned King, he bows to the hobbits and says "You bow to no one, showing that while he is the king, he does not consider himself to be above them, but that he regard them as equals. All in all so many good things to say about Aragorn.

@colleenross8752

9 ай бұрын

Theoden is Eowyn's uncle, not father

@ungeimpfterrusslandtroll7155

5 ай бұрын

Eowyn didn't act selfless, she acted selfish as she didn't listen, there is no way around it. Eowyn is not a good example for women in general at least in that regard and she also can't cook. What she did, other woman should not follow. Just imagine every girl being that rebellious. Theoden and Eomer also weren't threatened or intimated by her. Aragorn is different and i don't think that he had no problem with her joining the battle, he just didn't interfere but he would not have allowed it either if he was in her uncle's position that's for sure. I fully disagree with our assessment and i also doubt that's what Tolkien tried to convey.

@nickeysalvato8024

4 ай бұрын

​@@ungeimpfterrusslandtroll7155eowyn is absolutely a hero and someone for women to aspire to be. she was fully trained and competent in combat. her choice to toss away her dictated role as a woman to fight (in what they thought was a completely hopeless battle, basically a suicide mission for honor) is anything but selfish. bringing up her cooking? really? and in the comments of a video about how authentic masculinity never seeks to punch down, but to uplift others? come on man

@ungeimpfterrusslandtroll7155

4 ай бұрын

@@nickeysalvato8024No, and i would say the same about a man who acts the same. She didn't listen to her father figure and in extension military superior. She had no consideration for why they told her that, all she had in her head was what she wanted to do. No man would get away with this and she only does because she is a woman and it's seen as a positive because of modern feminist politics.

@nicechock

4 ай бұрын

its basically the story of Joseph from the Bible when he becomes the ruler of Egypt.

This puts his relationship with Arwen in a great perspective and helps explain why that relationship is so important. He is fighting for her, not for himself.

@nayrtnartsipacify

10 ай бұрын

He was a numenorean king he was fighting for everyone. Arwen was a half elf like her dad. Thats why she could choose a mortal life. She would stil live a very long time but she would die.

@s.e.e455

10 ай бұрын

I would argue by saying he was fighting for *everything* that matters, and I think that included his own life. You can care for and prioritize the needs of others and still care about yourself, too. Being selfless doesn’t mean you don’t value your own life and identity. “Humility is not thinking less of one’s self, but thinking of one’s self less.”

@Elamado97

7 ай бұрын

I always thought he was fighting for the greatest good, all his decisions came from his love for goodwill, he became the king for that very reason.

@johnrockyryan

6 ай бұрын

​@@s.e.e455 very well said he was fighting for her, himself and middle earth

@swvolleyball9137

3 ай бұрын

I agree. He was still reluctant about stepping towards his destiny until Elrond informed him of Arwen’s peril. While he was fighting for middle earth, I think Arwen was the push he needed to embrace his greater purpose.

Having a credit card father, as in, he just paid the bills but was never there emotionally or as a role model of masculinity, I had to take it upon myself to choose what ideal of masculinity I'd adopt for my life. Growing up surrounding myself with RPG and epic stories, the hero and caretaker archetypes really ressonated with me, and I can't really think of better examples than the likes of Aragorn and Uncle Iroh. They show that by walking the middle path one can achieve great things. They are sensible, yet they are not cowards. They dislike violence, but they have the strength to defeat the ones who try to hurt them or the ones they love. They are the rock of those around them, but they are still capable of sharing their feelings and empathazing with others. They can and DO kill, but they would much rather tend the ill and cure. Their strength of character really shows when they have the option of wrongdoing, of becoming corrupt, of becoming usurpers, but they don't. Being weak is not a virtue. They will walk the long path, they will take no shortcuts and they will never betray themselves. By doing that, staying true to their ideals of honor and duty, they become a true beacon of virtue to those around them, natural leaders, which is definitely something admirable and that all men who would one day like to be fathers should aspire to be.

@TheParez

10 ай бұрын

Well said, thank you

@jedimike7622

10 ай бұрын

Uncle Iroh really is one of the only other characters I can think of that matches the peak of true masculinity that Aragorn portrays. They're both such good role models.

@user-ck4xl1cs1o

10 ай бұрын

​@@jedimike7622In a way, I even think Uncle Iroh is a better (or rather more relatable) role model. As much as I love and adore Aragorn, his character sometimes gets close to Mary Sue territory. Sure, he has self doubt and doesn't always know where to go, but he ultimately always makes the right choice and excels at what he does. Iroh on the other hand is, as far as we know, a (former) member of a warmongering family who invaded an innocent country. It required extreme loss and emotional struggle to lead him onto the right path. He sees his own history mirrored in Zuko and wants to share the wisdom he received from a very similar experience. I think overcoming your own convictions and finding the right path is a much more real and relatable struggle than knowing the right path all along and "just" overcoming the adversities on the way. (Not wanting to downplay Aragorn's achievements, just highlighting the differences between the characters.)

@jedimike7622

10 ай бұрын

@@user-ck4xl1cs1o you have a fair point, and I would agree with you. Aragorn is more of an ideal, but Iroh feels more like a real person that we can relate to.

@painunending4610

10 ай бұрын

It's amazing to me the mental gymnastics people will do to cling on to the old way if thinking instead of seeking true liberation

As a father of two sons, this is one of the hardest things to teach them. Helping them to learn to be strong not so they can be bullies but to fight off the bullies from the kids the bullies pick on. Helping them to learn to be successful not so they can be successful, but so they can provide for the family, for the church (or other institutions), etc..

At Aragorn's coronation, when he says to the hobbits, "you bow to no one", was the best line in the whole story. At true example of humility and respect.

Aragorn as a character has been an inspiration to me my whole life. Refusal to concede with no certainty of victory, no matter how bleak is a constant reminder to never give up until dead. Never considered it a masculine/feminine trait just a a human one. Same vibes from Ripley and many other female heroes.

@master_samwise

10 ай бұрын

That's the beauty of virtue - men and women should both strive for each and every one. How we express them tends to differ, but the fact that we DO express them should not.

@blissseeker4719

6 ай бұрын

Wasn't Ripley a character that was originally designed around a man?

@skyfalldeadpool1633

3 ай бұрын

Aragorn, Xena the warrior princess are my favorite screen characters. One is male the other is female but both have the good traits that are admirable

True confidence is humble and calm. That's what my dad taught me and what I strive for. That's what masculinity means to me.

@stevem2323

8 ай бұрын

Protect the ones who can't.

One of the many things I appreciate about Aragorn is that besides fighting / battle skills, healing, physically practical stuff, is that he also has social intelligence and empathy. (Sadly, I personally can only go off the movies) He knows when not to jump into a fight, or when to hold Gimli/Legolas back from attacking. He defers to Theoden's command when in Rohan. He lets Eowyn down gently but honestly. All around good dude.

@rakino4418

9 ай бұрын

There's no time like the present to start reafing the books. You can even find some great audiobooks online. Andy Serkis (the performer of Gollum) has an INCREDIBLE audiobook reading of LotR.

@Elamado97

7 ай бұрын

he sounds too good to be true but i guess when you have lived 80years among humans and are still young you learn these things

@rakino4418

7 ай бұрын

@@Elamado97 he grew up in Rivendell for a good bit. That's generally a good influence.

@emmaphilo4049

5 ай бұрын

​@@Elamado97exactly Tolkien gave his characters the gift of long life. Indeed imagine at 80 having the knowledge + a body still young, It would be amazing!!! It can take so much time to learn wisdom!

@jeshurunhazelton7789

3 ай бұрын

​@@Elamado97who lived eighty years

The one thing i always praised the LOTR trilogies for was their constant reminder to men that it is ok to cry. We see almost all the main male characters, from the humble hobbits, to the mighty kings like Theoden and Aragorn, cry because things are hard and hardship has befallen them. It then shows that this moment is not weakness, but a necessary part of healing. After Theoden mourns the death of his son, be allows himself to be ready to return to protecting his people, rather than keeping it inside and letting the grief consume him.

@Sh0n0

4 ай бұрын

Eh i think showing weakness isnt good especially as a man. Real men don’t cry

@milusan326

4 ай бұрын

@Sh0n0 And let the pain consume yourself slowly from the inside is a good idea?

@Sh0n0

4 ай бұрын

@@milusan326 real men dont get bothered by the pain

@DannyChen712

3 ай бұрын

@@Sh0n0 thats a really stupid take from someone who probably doesn't have anyone they are responsible for. Easy to act tough when things are easy. Acting and being are two different things.

@Sh0n0

3 ай бұрын

@@DannyChen712 yeah man exactly my point, listen to that whiny tirade you just put, real men shut up and get on with it, its double important if you have others your responsible for, you have to show them you are strong

I am an Asian woman, and I just love the entire fellowship so much. Sam is my favorite; he is not perfect, but is just the best! All of the fellowship really display a vulnerable, AND strong masculinity. One thing I do like about the movies over the books is how they made Aragon a bit conflicted at the beginning about leadership, because it shows his humility and that he does not take leadership and power for granted. I love that Boromir made no excuses and was honest about his "failings". Gimli is an open book about his emotions and feelings, and I feel like he gives the best hugs. As for Faramir, I really wished that they kept the Extended Edition scenes with Boromir, as it shows that he was not so much "tempted" but just showed a love for his brother and father. (They also cut the line where Sam praises his quality!) I also love the female characters as well. Arwen making such a brave choice, Galadriel overcoming temptation, Eowyn fighting for Middle-Earth. I am a new subscriber, thank you for your video essays!

@MarvinHartmann452

9 ай бұрын

I agree with you. I think Sam is the best, and most modest and important character. And Boromir represent all sides, good and bad of passion.

@leighjordine4031

9 ай бұрын

Sam is the real hero he carried frodo even though he wasn't destined to carry the ring himself. He sort of did if not for Sam frodo would of been taken by the ring.

@therealstaples1160

9 ай бұрын

I really love that Arwen, in the book, is holding back the light of Mordor with her will. Thus the even star is failing.

@tomorbataar5922

9 ай бұрын

@@leighjordine4031 Very true, but Frodo was actually taken by the ring in the end. If not for Gollum taking the ring from Frodo they would've been lost, the ring's evil ended up being its own undoing.

@Notme195

8 ай бұрын

Honestly the main thing I never liked about the movie was how the made him terrified of his own destiny. He never comes across as arrogant in the books, the time has come for him to face his destiny and he is willing to try his best. In the movies he never really feels like a leader untill he stops whining about how he doesn't want to be king.

“It is possible to commit no mistakes and still lose. That is not weakness, that is life.” - Jean-Luc Picard Beautiful.

@destructionman1

9 ай бұрын

"I shitted yesterday." - me

@Wonkess_Chonkess

8 ай бұрын

I was performing hand to gland combat yesterday while looking at some juicy bbw pictures. -me

@destructionman1

8 ай бұрын

@@Wonkess_Chonkess Beautiful 🥲

@Wonkess_Chonkess

8 ай бұрын

@@destructionman1 That's not a joke bdw

"Strength makes one fit for service, not to rule" The Way of Kings - Brandon Sanderson

@master_samwise

10 ай бұрын

I don't remember that quote but that has to be one of Dalinar's, right?

@iamkrohn

10 ай бұрын

@@master_samwise it's from the in universe book itself

Aragorn's works of healing within Minas Tirith don't truly revolve around the healing of physical wounds. Instead, his presence there is to, essentially, mend their souls. To be less poetic, Tolkien's using this part of the story to make an allegory for PTSD; he isn't just supposed to be their nurse, but moreso something of a therapist. As a symbolic element, Aragorn, the king, represents hope in a hopeless time.

@Dawnrunner42

9 ай бұрын

But also as the literal political monarch, that can never be forgotten

Aragorn is a symbol of servant leadership. Servant leadership requires the virtues of both humility and courage. And so, the servant leader works for the greater good, not for the retention of power nor any selfish desire for wealth at the expense of the poor. Real men defend the weak. They do not bully the weak. One could say that Denethor is an example of "toxic masculinity" because his lust for power and his pride overcomes his capacity to care for those he leads. He abandons the people of Gondor whom he is supposed to serve and protect. You, Master Samwise have articulated well the qualities of good men.

@ViktoriaMagrey

7 ай бұрын

I've always aspired to be a servant leader. That is true leadership to me.

I love this! For months I’ve been thinking that Aragorn is a good example of true masculinity, because not only is he a brave warrior, but he’s also gentle and not afraid to show that he can also be vulnerable. Nowadays many young men aspire to become the typical macho man that fights in bars, races cars like a maniac, and thinks that simple acts of kindness such as hugging a friend are a sign of weakness. People should really follow Aragorn’s example of masculinity.

This reminds me of the old Star Trek episode ("The Enemy Within," I believe). Kirk is split into two different halves. One is overly aggressive, scheming, and quick to anger. The other is too nice, weak, and meek. We learn that they cannot survive by themselves. Each half of the man needs the other. This is a lesson we should learn today. Yes, I'm old. Yes, I'm a geek. No, I don't care.

I literally grew my hair out to be like this guy when I was a teenager, I looked up to him, I wanted to be brave like him and protect the weak and honestly this movie and books shaped my life and made me who I am

@reedbender1179

9 ай бұрын

well done..👍...greetings from Gandalf, formerly the grey, now literally the white ! 🤫 😂

Thank you, I needed this today. Ever since my depression I focus on myself too much. I wish I knew what Aragon's example looks like in our modern world, but this content helps me refocus at least.

@master_samwise

11 ай бұрын

So glad I could help however little I can!

@eelchiong6709

10 ай бұрын

I know how you feel, for I have been depressed these past 22 yrs. There will come a time when you will feel nothing at all and just go on living in auto mode. There will be many, many instances when the idea of ending it once and for all will enter your mind. I was barely able to resist it only because of my bestfriend, and the promise I gave him never to repeat it no matter how tempting, so yes, I did attempted it once. The solution to this is the acceptance that what depressed you will never again be yours. To move on. To cling to the comfort of family and friends. But not for me. Because I wouldn't let go. I have a strong will, and it is this strength that allows me to go on without letting go due to stubbornness. As a Psych major, I know better but... So I urge you to move on. Take joy in every little blessing that comes your way, don't be like me. You are not that strong. Or have my capacity to absorb pain.

I also really like boromir he made mistakes and paid the price but his mistakes were never due to desire or selfish reasons infact quite the opposite he was just desperate to save his people and his nation from the forces of evil and it was his death that allowed aragorn to accept his position as king

@OkenWS

5 ай бұрын

Yes, I think it was clear from even his short screen time (can't speak for the books) it was clear he would have been as great a Prince of Gondor as his brother.

@devildante9

5 ай бұрын

@@OkenWS On the book he has quite more lines, almost always when there's a decision to make (like going through Moria, or when the Fellowship almost froze to death but survived thanks to Boromir pestering them to bring firewood), and he almost always antagonistic to Gandalf and Aragorn, but he always is the voice of reason (from a logical perspective, the Quest was like the worst possible choice, it's all about Faith). The way he talks is also super smart and never overstates his authority, he isn't Captain General of the whole army of Gondor for nothing. In short, he is shown to be a rational, polite, strong, humble and level headed leader, which is why the scene when he looses his marbles hits even harder.

I think one other thing that should be said about masculinity is that crying does not make a guy weak or feminine. We're human. Sometimes stress and hardship gets to be too much, and a guy beating himself up because he allowed himself to feel human emotions to the point of crying only serves to create the behavior of toxic masculinity, that is to say having such a skewed idea of what masculinity is that it causes you to harm yourself and others. Crying over EVERYTHING is certainly not healthy, but again, moderation and balance, the middle ground as has been mentioned in the video, is what us guys should strive for.

This is why I love Tolkien's works. He truly understood perfect masculinity. To all men and boys of all ages, be the lover, protector, and builder we all can be, build up, love, and protect this society as never before. God bless you all.

@namethis658

9 ай бұрын

Nah, he was an idealist who found recluse in his own ivory tower of imagination, a pretty pathetic sight, really. And I do not want to be a builder or protector, I want to do whatever the shit I want because this is what I want.

@lukefriesenhahn8186

9 ай бұрын

@@namethis658 What an awful comment. Did you not watch the video, or research Tolkien at all?

@namethis658

9 ай бұрын

@@lukefriesenhahn8186 yes, I watched it, and what exactly do you disagree with? That JRRT was an idealist (despite living through the horrors of war)? Or what?

What an awesome video! As a teacher I often find myself having to challenge these ideas that the boys I teach take as gospel. I do not envy them having to grow up in this age, but I hope I can help them on the road to being a man.

@master_samwise

11 ай бұрын

Good on you!

@namethis658

9 ай бұрын

Ideas like what?

@sjins1poolboy698

9 ай бұрын

@@namethis658 the ones being referred to throughout the video. i.e. unauthentic masculinity. Unfortunately propagated by a plethora of online influences.

@namethis658

9 ай бұрын

@@sjins1poolboy698 well, I believe that the concept of masculinity or femininity as such should be abandoned, you should instead think of yourself as an individual and not try to fit into enforced roles.

@sjins1poolboy698

9 ай бұрын

​@@namethis658 its not about enforcing roles. Teaching our boys that its okay to look down on woman or that woman are their possessions is wrong just as telling a boy he should be ashamed to be a male because of the disgusting things men have done throughout history. Masculinity and femininity are not dictation that men work and women stay at home (have they been used to perpetuate this? Certainly have. Does that mean that's what they? Certainly doesn't). Teaching a boy that he should be respectful, caring, kind, brave, considerate, and vulnerable doesn't take away from him being his own self. It enables him to be his own self but do it in a way that builds up those people around him in his life. Does that mean I think girls shouldn't learn to be respectful, caring, kind, brave, considerate, and vulnerable? Nope. Do men and women go about in the same way? Nope. Does that mean they're being oppressed from being who they truly are? Nope. Abolishing masculinity and femininity just gets rid of the road map for our kids, they have the whole world at their finger tips like no other generation ever has, constantly being told to be who they want to be. Most of them end up feeling lost and end up desperately clinging to the loudest voice that makes sense to them. But hey that's how I feel and I don't know anything about you beyond the opinion you've shared. I'm sure you have good reason to feel the way you do about femininity and masculinity but I hope maybe you can hear why I think they have value for the young people I teach. 🙂

Funny thing is: many, if not all, those qualities do not only describe ideal masculinity but also ideal femininity to some degree. It is almost like gender/sex doesn't matter that much when it comes down to be a 'self-fulfilled' or 'ideal' person.

@abrahamliebsch3385

10 ай бұрын

That's true. The values and duties are the same. It's how they manifest adn express themselves that is different. This is the lesson that Eowyn learns through experience.

@EvelinaNinudottir

10 ай бұрын

I think there are two ways to approach terms like femininity and masculinity. One of them is the way you describe it - basically where they refer to overall positive traits that we refer to as masculinity or femininity depending on the gender of the person who inhibits them. The second way is to tear the words from gender all together, and simply brand certain qualities one or the other. For example, compassion could be deemed a feminine trait and fairness masculine, but obviously both men and women ideally should encompass both of these traits, thus in a way creating an ideal state where the masculine and feminine is balanced in every individual. I think either understanding is interesting :)

@Lyendith

10 ай бұрын

Yep, that’s why I find it hard, if not futile to define what is or isn’t "true" masculinity/femininity. I guess some of it is related to physical differences like muscular strength or sexual organs, but those don’t matter _that_ much in the grand scheme of things − unless one wants to exclude physically weak men or women who can’t bear children as "not real men/women".

@jack1701e

10 ай бұрын

Pretty much, we're all humans after all, we all want the same things and go through the same worries and hardships. There are differences of course but we all just want to be happy.

@JOHN----DOE

10 ай бұрын

@@jack1701e But the point of this video is that happiness is ONLY achievable through living for OTHERS, not the crappy modern ideal of "self-realization."

Aragorn is a prime example of great traits that can be found in men: courage, loyalty, focus, intelligence, leadership and empathy, He's the leader you would willingly walk into any battle with.

@BabyXiuhcoatl

10 ай бұрын

Exactly. Equally due to the fact that Aragorn is the type of leader who would walk into battle with you.

My father is a man who, from my youngest years, has informed my ideal of the kind of man I want to be and the ideal of masculinity itself. Honour, self sacrifice, discipline and quiet confidence define him. He is not a fictional character, and so is not without his flaws. While he is very slow to anger, he tends to bottle up his emotions until he explodes in wrath. While not violent this tends to cause a fair amount of emotional pain when it happens. He is old and holds some views that are prejudiced because of his experiences. Having said that, this is a man who went hungry so that his wife and sons could eat when there was not enough food to go around. Even when food is plentiful, when there happens to be a dish he knows we're particularly fond of, this is a man who will needlessly even goes so far as to quietly forgo his own share so that there's more for the rest of us. It's so bad that I have to be vigilant and insist he take his due. He is someone who has worked long hours in multiple jobs to keep a roof over our heads and food on our tables with never a word of complaint. This is a man who, after being laid off in his sixties, cooked, cleaned and otherwise did more than his fair share of the work around the house to support those of us who were still working. He will endure hardship with stoicism, always has time to listen to his sons and wife, and has taught me to think critically and question authority. He has permitted his sons to make mistakes and learn from their experiences, provided those mistakes are not of a magnitude that would be life-altering. He has demonstrated through his actions the virtues of paternal love, patience and discipline. He has shared with us the music and media that has shaped him, shared the stories of his life and the lessons he learned, and has done his best to continue learning even as he has aged. He is someone who would lay down his own life without hesitation for someone under his care. He seeks to understand before judging, and I have ever been able to approach him as a friend first and father second. He is not perfect but embodies what I see as a masculine ideal very similar to Aragorn's. If I can be half the man my father is, I will be a man I can be proud of.

@caroleb707

4 ай бұрын

This is a beautiful tribute to your father.

@Someone-ro6ns

3 ай бұрын

Wow

@joesplace2960

2 ай бұрын

I wish you luck in your endeavor.

The natural progression of this is the channel's namesake. Here's hoping for another another version of this discussing ya boi Samwise Gamgee.

@master_samwise

11 ай бұрын

Oh you know that is coming... eventually

Adopting this in the modern day is a challenge worthy of the kind of men we are all trying to become, as shown in this video. It can be done. I recently got married and now my wife is moving in with me so we can start our life together. Before now I’ve always felt like I was biding my time and learning things so that I could serve in some capacity at some point in time. This video confirms for me that the time is now to use my skills and strength to better protect the family I hope to build, and nothing more. I took inspiration from GoW to put all this into a simple mantra to repeat to myself when I feel defeated or lethargic or hopeless/depressed. “Lo there do I see my wife. Lo there do I see my son. Lo there do I see my daughter. Lo there do they call to me.”

@ltchugacast131

11 ай бұрын

In the book Aragorn muses about how his moniker of Strider was originally given as an insult by an old fat man in Bree who liked to gossip endlessly. Aragorn considers briefly expressing displeasure but quickly finds he takes more comfort in knowing the man’s life is peaceful enough he can concern himself with gossip and debate about simple and meaningless things, and Aragorn is glad for him. He goes on to to say that a days march away or closer “were foes so terrible his heart would instantly be made like ice” that the man knew nothing of and thanks to Aragorn, he never would have to. He remains a silent figure wordlessly protecting the simple lives of those who know little of the true nature of the world and expects nothing in return. This also pairs well with the Hobbits thesis “In fact, it has been remarked by some that Hobbits' only real passion is for food. A rather unfair observation as we have also developed a keen interest in the brewing of ales and the smoking of pipeweed. But where our hearts truly lie is in peace and quiet and good tilled earth. For all Hobbits share a love of all things that grow. And yes, no doubt to others, our ways seem quaint. But today of all days, it is brought home to me it is no bad thing to celebrate a simple life.” Courage is not found in taking up a blade, nor in conquering a far away land. True courage is found in being brave enough to live a simple life. Many a great man placed themselves in hallowed halls by acting to preserve a simpler life lived in peace. It was the only because Frodo had so much to love about the Shire - from its rolling hills, and quaint homes, to its beautiful streams and bountiful gardens - that he was able to find the strength to make it so far. Today is 4th of July. The celebration of my nation’s founding. I have much to celebrate and I will do so shamelessly. I do this because when the days of bounty my family has been blessed with come to an end, it will be the things I celebrate today that drive me to fight for what is right and to protect and guide my family however I must. For today of all todays it has come home to me that it is no bad thing to celebrate a simple life.

@brworthington_

10 ай бұрын

@@ltchugacast131 this comment stuck with me, and I’m glad you said it. It goes deeper for me because I’m active duty military and planning on getting out in two years, which means others will have to carry the torch. All I want is to have that simple life to be proud of with my wife. As a kid I wanted to get a battle axe in my hand and start swinging, and now time and fate have made me a bit wiser and less arrogant. Simplicity and purity of existence is a good path to being less arrogant and more appreciative in general.

@namethis658

9 ай бұрын

>Adopting this in the modern day is a challenge worthy of the kind of men we are all trying to become/ Why? Why do you try to become like Aragorn? Aragorn is a fairy-tale hero, detached from reality. Following him will do you no good. Liberate yourself.

I love the fact that you tear down social media's projections of toxic masculinity. True Masculinity is not toxic, nor monsterous. Its a thing of beauty and as a millenial woman, I appretiate it when I see it around me, in my life. Your videos on this subject are great. Don't let people tear them down. Great job!!

we were not made for ourselves, but for eachother

In the anime, Demon Slayer, Rengoku - an incredible swordsman - is asked by his mother 'Do you know why it is, you were born with greater strength than others? It is so that you can protect the weak. Those who were born blessed with more bountiful gifts than others, are obligated to use those gifts for the sake of the world.' (English dub). Anime has amazing men, who hold true masculinity in them. Tanjiro, Rengoku, Aang, Iro. Thank you for your videos =]

@wholesome_masochist4113

10 ай бұрын

Do we count the butchery of Aang that occurs in LoK?

@petervizzini4006

10 ай бұрын

Much is asked of who much is given

@arturorosascastro9596

10 ай бұрын

Rengoku remind me of Aragorn, as well. I hope you can check that character someday, embody everything you say in this video

@audreyandremington5265

10 ай бұрын

Thorfinn too of course! Not too big a fan of demon slayer but you're right about the heroism themes. They're also in mha

@projectx7453

10 ай бұрын

I’ll like to add All Might to the list here

I grew up with Peter Jackson’s movies, and my dad generously educated me with what I always found to be a wonderful story. But now, I realize that the importance of works like LotR transcend the confines of the worlds they create. They create not just stories, but meaning and purpose for everyone who experiences them. Unlike most else in the world, a good story demands nothing in return but what little time we might otherwise squander. A good story will never betray you.

Aragorn always struck me as the embodiment of the Chinese proverb "It is better to be a warrior in a garden than a gardener in war". He is meek, but neither cowardly or ineffectual. Strong and wise, while neither being arrogant nor a bully. He has great capacity for a warrior's violence, and only uses such aggression against evil - to protect. If Theoden is the king you would gladly die for, then Aragon is the king you would live for.

“My friends, you bow to no one.” Tears, every time.

Very akin to Hector of Troy, the defender of his people, the professional soldier that takes moral ethic emphatic discipline as the foremost virtue,

@alexandarvoncarsteinzarovi3723

10 ай бұрын

Oh yes indeed very loving father with quilt

@namethis658

9 ай бұрын

How did Hector end up, remind me? ;D

@alexandarvoncarsteinzarovi3723

9 ай бұрын

@@namethis658 He died at the hands of Achilles in duel in retribution for the death of his cousin, Patrocles,

@namethis658

9 ай бұрын

@@alexandarvoncarsteinzarovi3723 so he was a loser.

This video gave me so much clarity and helped me sort through so much noise in my life. I’m on my 3rd time watching it. No joke. This amazing. Thank you.

@master_samwise

11 ай бұрын

I am glad I could help in any small way!

You are a highly intelligent well versed young man; A young man of high ideals, long missed and long needed. I thank God for young men like you- you have given me hope today. Subbed!

@master_samwise

10 ай бұрын

Wow, that is incredibly kind of you! Thanks!

@maguffintop2596

10 ай бұрын

@@master_samwise Meant every word 👍

Aragorn is the type of man I want to be, I want to be a protector a guardian someone who can carry the burden of others and be relied on and looked up to I want to be kind and gentle but strong and fierce when needed I want to be able to heal peoples injuries from physical to mental and help people grow into something better ill carry the burdens of my loved ones and be the knight they need I want to be someone my future family will be proud of I will make this happen

"both sides' viewpoints are overreactions to what they dislike about the opposing perspective" not even a minute in and you summed up something that's been rattling around in my mind for ages.

Ever since I listened to your Iroh video I thought I recognized a fellow Christian in the way you spoke & your worldview, & now hearing you mention a Biblical story I think confirms it. If you are a Christian then you should be proud that your faith shines through even when you're not talking directly about it. On the off chance you're not take it as a compliment, I admire the way you think/speak.

@knutolavbjrgaas1069

11 ай бұрын

I thought the same thing.

@master_samwise

10 ай бұрын

My apologies for the late response, but thank you and God bless you!

Aragorn is the peak of a man, if we can be 20% of what he is we would be great

"Greater Love hath no Man than this, that He should lay down His life for His friends" Great Video My Brother.

Thanks for this. Now is a time when we need the right stories. This was making me think of "A Hobbit, a Wardrobe, and the Great War."

I have very few complaints about the Peter Jackson films but one thing I do wish was the screen version had shown a lot more about aragorn the healer. Such a big part of his character in the books

@master_samwise

10 ай бұрын

I absolutely agree.

I love how Tolkien developed his male characters , the good ones. Not afraid of showing weakness and feelings, willing to help and protect their friends, at all costs. He was in a war, saw another one. My grandfather fought in WW1 too. The bonds born in the trenches can be strongest.

7:26 “It is not for ourselves alone, we are born.” Cicero

Such a great video. Over the past few years I have lost my masculinity for fears that I will offend others, but all that has done is fragmented my character. I confess, I did shed a good number of tears watching this. This message is so necessary. I only wish I knew how to get to that place.

@nicolasgaddathompson611

10 ай бұрын

This text you´ve just shared with us couldn´t be more masculine, Jeremia. You´ve been brave enough to be honest regarding your fears and limitations, and you recognise de value of Aragorn´s example of masculinity. Keep it up! And be honest with yourself. People will notice, and they will respect the attitude.

@amicaaranearum

6 ай бұрын

“If I pretend … If I pretend I didn’t do those things, it means that I can’t have grown to become someone else.” “Journey before destination,” Dalinar said. “It cannot be a journey if it doesn’t have a beginning.” “I will take responsibility for what I have done,” Dalinar whispered. “If I must fall, I will rise each time a better man.”

Splendid video, chap. I really enjoy how you handle the ever growing tide of machismo and misogyny in your videos, encouraging men and people of all genders to express themselves to their fullest, truly living up to their own ideals. Your Iroh video and this combine to make a masterful display of your own thoughts on what is to be a man, and be part of the human race. For the good of all, I hope your videos continue to succeed.

@master_samwise

11 ай бұрын

Thank you! Obviously this video is largely aimed at young men, which is what I am (kind of) and what most of my audience is. But I hope women also enjoy and can learn from these examples. Virtues, as I’ve noted before, are never to be exclusive to one gender. We should all strive for them in our unique ways.

@clarahudson8283

11 ай бұрын

It’s hard to find but it’s there!

Aragorn is someone who I aspire to be emotionally. I hate these so-called “Alpha Males” that people are seeing nowadays. I’d rather be strong enough to be gentle, and protect the people I know and love if the situation calls for it.

Most men don’t know how to be Strong and Gentle, But what a jewel when they are both. Every man or woman at some point in their live will be asked to do extraordinary things, or make hard choices. Even with the weight of the world on their shoulders. It’s is those who can rise above that are unique in every way.

Your videos are awesome! I personally am a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, and I often find that the themes and lessons from Middle Earth help me draw nearer unto God in my life, and help me want to be a better person. Your videos totally nail that on the head! They’re inspiring, interesting and engaging, and help me become a better person. Thanks for making them!

@toddjackson3136

11 ай бұрын

Watching this video I was actually thinking, "Oh I wish I could tell you about Captain Moroni, Teancum, Captain Heleman, the Stripling Warriors!"

@John_on_the_mountain

10 ай бұрын

Makes sense since Tolkien was a very devoted Catholic so his works have heavy Christian themes and morals.

@bullgravy6906

10 ай бұрын

Surely you’ve read Enders Game and/or Wheel of Time?

I don’t really have anything meaningful to say, other than that this is what I’ve been saying for a while now. (It’s debatable whether or not even that is meaningful to add.) Therefore, this comment is for the algorithm, because I want this video to blow up. This is what our culture is not hearing, but so desperately needs to hear.

@master_samwise

11 ай бұрын

I appreciate you!

I’m glad that he’s complex and yet still remain selfless and kind

This may be the best video I have ever seen on KZread. I will be sharing it with not only both of my sons, but also both of my daughters. This is the kind of man, the kind of person, that our world stands in such great need of. You have heartily earned my subscription for life!

@master_samwise

10 ай бұрын

That is incredibly high praise. Thank you!

@BabyXiuhcoatl

10 ай бұрын

"This story shall the good man teach his son." -Harry the King

The problem with both femininity and masculinity is that the positive traits don’t make you a man or woman, they make you a good human being. We simply split these traits up and say “you are a man, you should be X.” No, to be a complete and mature human being is the goal not to embody some definition.

@KittySnicker

10 ай бұрын

Exactly! Just be a good person

@lukeporras1288

10 ай бұрын

True, but in the Western canon, strength, valor, and fortitude were associated with manliness, not femininity.

@jack1701e

10 ай бұрын

@@KittySnicker This. Four simple words we should live by. Just be a good person, be kind, be sensible, do good by others and protect those who need it, guide those who need guidance, help when asked, the world would be so much better if we just had more good people in it.

@JamesWillmus

10 ай бұрын

@@lukeporras1288 And the perfect rebuke of Western Canon is Eowyn. She too has strength, valor, and fortitude. She has those traits in abundance. Yet she is undoubtedly a woman with many feminine traits as well. My point is, becoming a whole, balanced human being ought to be the goal of everyone, man or woman. One major mistake of western society is insisting that men and women conform to some ordained definition of their gender and never seek to leave that box. The result is multiple generations of unbalanced people who could never hope to reach their full potential as human beings.

@nerychristian

9 ай бұрын

True. Both men and women should strive to be virtuous people. We each have strengths and weaknesses. But if we work together, we can strengthen one another and protect each other from those who seek to destroy us.

"To protect those who can not protect themselves" I see what you did there. ;)

@master_samwise

10 ай бұрын

Journey before destination.

@bellabluesteinpatchin9439

5 ай бұрын

@@master_samwise I can't stop grinning :D

This was nicely said. More men need to understand this concept of masculinity. For humanity's sake.

I'm experiencing the story as set forth by the book the first time in years, and it's super powerful. The movie is a top-tier adaptation, but I love how the book can take the time to build and deepen the relationships with more drawn out conversations. I'm actually listening to it in audio form, read by Phil Dragash, featuring music, sound effects, and voices that sound much like the movie voices. Hearing the original story underlined by these additions make me feel like I'm right there, sitting next to Sam as he cradles Frodo in his arms the night before they reach the door in Mt. Doom. Really special stuff. This story is a masterpiece of inspiring characters that love each other, and it makes you wish you were there among them, fighting shoulder to shoulder, and smoking pipe-weed together at the end of a long day.

@master_samwise

9 ай бұрын

I will have to check out that audio adaptation. I originally listened to the books on tape by Rob Inglis (and just did again recently), and he is absolutely incredible, but I’d love to hear a more dramatized version. So glad you’re enjoying the book! It is my favorite of all time and I’m so glad there are people still discovering it after all these years.

In short: don't be strong for your own sake but for your loved ones' sakes

Truly, the entire story of "Lord of The Rings" is among the best that portrays what true masculinity is like and what it should be. I believe that this is not only seen in Aragorn, but even with the other male characters who have done what is right throughout the arcs. This leads me to ask if you could make a video mentioning the other men in this story who have also shown traits seen in true masculinity (Gandalf, Bilbo, Legolas, Boromir, Faramir, Eomer, Gimli, Theoden, Frodo, Samwise, Merry, Pippin, Elrond, etc.). Not requested, but I believe is worthy to be noted down as well. Overall, this is a wonderful analysis of Aragorn and how he truly does represent Masculinity at its peak. God bless you!

No wonder I've grown into a man that I'm proud of, Aragorn is the ideal I've followed since I was young.

@BluuAugustine

9 ай бұрын

He’s a Chad

Aragorn's character is the perfect example of masculinity.

@squealerpig8451

8 ай бұрын

And me

I tend to think that masculinity has two additional values. One being willing to act when others are passive or just try to ignore someone having an issue. The other is what I call "being a rock" to others who need someone to help them through a difficult emotional moment. I once had to help pull a dying dog that had been hit by a car off the road so it wasn't in the way of drivers and so the dog wouldn't get hit again. The people who had pulled over (who hit the dog) and got out of their cars just stood there, unsure of what to do in the situation. In another one a person at work who might have been having an allergic reaction to medication was panicking, so I had to help him get to the floor, call the paramedics, and try to help them calm down and cool down since he was burning up (all this while many people stood around and did very little to help) . After a few minute I was able to say hey, you are still conscious, still breathing, this is a great sign that you are doing ok. This really helped him calm down and was really back to normal by the time the paramedics got there. The other masculine trait of "being a rock" is hugging someone when they are crying. Trying to help them get through the difficult emotional moment that they are having so they can be happy again sooner. Also I like all the jabs at Andrew Tate since he is accused of committing human trafficking and other horrible crimes.

@luless666

11 ай бұрын

Accused but no evidence was provided. He is free now and you keep coping and take sides of the government and corporations who wanted to destroy a man thy cannot control. Top g is not perfect, but he doesn't deserve all bad things that happened to him for telling the truth and teaching men to think for themselves and not trust the Main streem

@ThillerKillerX

8 ай бұрын

Accused by the media

Let us do what is necessary, not what is written. And protect those who cannot protect themselves until they find the courage to do so. Thank you for this gem of a video. May everyone find a little bit of Aragorn in himself.

@master_samwise

10 ай бұрын

Glad you enjoyed it!

Extremely well said! Balanced masculinity is Aragorn! Let’s hope the men of our world wake up soon.

Samwise himself a great example of moral strength, caring, and dedication, not for his own good, but for that of his friends. Certainly not the strongest physically, but perhaps the most loyal and humble in the fellowship. My favorite character and a role model we should all look up to. Few among us can be an Aragorn, but nothing stops any of us from being Sam.

You hit the nail about real masculinity.

This was a brilliant video and i finished reading Lord of the Rings again this week, Tolkien was something else.

@master_samwise

11 ай бұрын

Always a good time to read some Tolkien!

I wish more men knew about and practiced Aragorn's example of masculinity. I know I'll try. Awesome video, Master Samwise!

Viggo perfectly encapsulated the virtues of not only Aragon, but of a great make archetype in all 3 films. It goes far deeper than what the average viewer would typically see.

One should not ignore Tolkien's Catholicism. The concept you discuss is straight out of Philippians: "Do nothing from selfish ambition or conceit, but in humility regard others as better than yourselves. Let each of you look not to your own interests, but to the interests of others. Let the same mind be in you that was in Christ Jesus, who, though he was in the form of God, did not regard equality with God as something to be exploited, but emptied himself, taking the form of a slave, being born in human likeness. And being found in human form, he humbled himself and became obedient to the point of death - even death on a cross." If Tolkien was not familiar with the writings of Julian of Norwich, his good friend C.S. Lewis certainly would have been. I love this part (Revelations of Divine Love, Chapter 59): "I it am (sic), the Might and Goodness of the Fatherhood; I it am, the Wisdom of the Motherhood; I it am, the Light and the Grace that is all blessed Love: I it am, the Unity: I am the sovereign Goodness of all manner of things. I am that maketh thee to love: I am that maketh thee to long: I it am, the endless fulfilling of all true desires." I love the concept that Fatherhood (masculinity) should be both mighty and good. We lost that somewhere along the way, thinking that Might must be self-serving.

Fantastic video. Aragorn has always been one of my favorite characters in any story. This sums up the reasons why I’ve always looked up to him as an example of what it means to be a man, a leader, and a friend.

Beautifully said. I’m glad a popular video is exposing these pop beliefs about masculinity for what they are, knee-jerk reactions to each other, when really the truth lies in the middle. We need more characters like Aragorn in film.

@Eilonwy95

4 ай бұрын

Spot on!!

One of if not the best video I have watched in the last several months. This hit home more than I expected

Great video! I think it aligns well with your deep dive on Azula. Her approach to life isn't too far from what some are espousing should be everyone's approach. I've noticed some young men find it hard to believe that they can see each other as brothers rather than competitors. I think it takes a bit of faith to start believing in the strength of brotherhood. Stories like the Lord of the Rings certainly help. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

I do want to point out that I think men often hunger for the freedom to be emotionally vulnerable and still respected.

I often think this everyday and the fact I see a video titled this is amazing.

Aside from my late dad, Aragorn has always been my role model and whom I aspired the be since I first read the books at 10. several years before the movies came out. And when they did, the movie Aragorn was everything I hoped he would be. Didn't look back since. In several years I will be the age Viggo was when playing Aragorn. I can just hope I will be at least comparable in character to his greatness. Then I could say it was a life well spent despite all the setbacks.

In both books and movie I’ve always found Théoden as the stereotypical, classical “male” character, in terms of heroical bravery, rudeness etc. The exact same for Boromir and Éomer (the book’s Éomer, movies have overshadowed him for Théoden and sometimes Théoden for Aragorn). Aragorn is a bit different … he is plastic: he grows, becomes more confident but always for the good of his people. He is human, cries more than expected for a male warrior, shows doubt but at the end overcomes it. Beren (in several poems as The Lay of Beren and Lúthien, which are often more detailed than The Silmarillion or Lost Tales), seems a mixture of “rude” and “sweet” masculinity instead.

@hoked2194

10 ай бұрын

Aragorn is meant to be an unattainable archetype anyways. He's a super human raised by the literal angels of god, he's just a symbol of the "ideal man".

@lordoftherings999

10 ай бұрын

@@hoked2194Yes 👍🏻👍🏻 he has some little Maia-blood in his veins through the descendance of Malian

Aragorn is brave, reliable and righteous; the pillars of masculinity.

I really appreciate your writing and analysis. You're right, masculinity is having the strength to protect your loved ones and is displayed so elegantly in Aragorn's character

In a world of Andrew Tates, be an Aragorn.

@madsea6719

6 ай бұрын

Tate isnt a bad example to be. He has his bad points but in the latest year hes become religious and spiritual, you can learn a lot from him. Bad examples are modern rappers, criminals, gang leaders and so on.

@KevinS-bz6xt

22 күн бұрын

What lol Tait is a 💩. He's a criminal.