Everyone talks about reservation nobody talks about getting rid of caste. Caste system is poison.

@vasu7858

5 жыл бұрын

Caste today is just a second name

@hareeshscifi13

5 жыл бұрын

Caste will go with both reservation and awarness.

@souvikbiswas1757

5 жыл бұрын

@@hareeshscifi13 reservation will go with removing of caste ..I think best way to get rid off reservation is if so called higher cast people helps the lower casts to achieving the main stream of society.

@hareeshscifi13

5 жыл бұрын

But that would just be blindly helping the dalits. Affirmative action provides them a ground to work hard and achieve their goals and not be uplifted by pouring favors back to them after thousands of years of oppression.

@souvikbiswas1757

5 жыл бұрын

@@hareeshscifi13 bro observe the current situation of govt jobs ..cut off marks in almost govt job is nearly equal in both obc and general category . Sc development is also happening very fast .Nearly 20%scs are getting job in general category . Don't worry bro reservation will automatically go with this rapid progression. This change just happened within 50 years of freedom .. Don't you think it is big achievement ? It will surely go in next generation.

Reservation can be a solution for limited time only. What we need is "Caste Free India"

@gamingsingh4004

6 жыл бұрын

Dinesh Nim and how u do achieve that ? ...by reservation .

@nitintripathi5410

6 жыл бұрын

Caste Free India is a distant dream to be realised as of now and probably un-achievable entirely. What seems possible and acceptable by masses is If a member of a family avails reservation (either job/education) the next generation of the family should be barred from reservations.

@gamingsingh4004

6 жыл бұрын

Nitin Tripathi u really need to learn the difference between social backwardness and economical backwardness and on what bases reservation is given and why .. u mate clearly have no idea about any of this all u know what u heard on TV ... Want to learn facts stop watching TV and read newspapers like 'the hindu'

@nitintripathi5410

6 жыл бұрын

@gaming singh With all due respect I wish to point you to a different direction rather than what you already feel is correct, Both are different (Social and Economic backwardness), however in most of cases one who is socially backward is also economically backward. what the current reservation is doing "Helping the one economically" My point being "You can't eradicate social backwardness by proving limitless economic opportunities" Govt can't change social mindset so can't alter social backwardness Then why provide limitless economic help Economic help should be capped and limited.

@dineshnim

6 жыл бұрын

@ Gaming Singh - Surely not by reservation. People should understand they their own growth is dependent on this. Any country with social division as we have in Indian cannot grow. No one asked ever which caste Albert Einstein belong to. But if he would have been in India then most searches on Google would have been - albert einstein caste

The caste problem lies in backward regions of every state. Untouchability is still practised. The Thakurs and Brahmin and even Vaishya community of eastern UP and Bihar (what I've seen) are against reservations but at same time they are not ready to accept equality.

@rc7211

4 жыл бұрын

Not only in backward regions, the caste system is quite present in the urban areas also. Just look at marriage ads, or just look at the castes of the people doing the most undignified jobs in society such as cleaning your sewers, you'll see the caste system at work. Just look at poverty and landlessness statistics, even in urban areas, you'll be the caste system. And so much more. So the caste system is not only 'untouchability', it is a much broader and complex structural reality.

@subhrovkdasgupta6651

4 жыл бұрын

But whats stopping the, from competing fairly with the general category??

@bhauri

4 жыл бұрын

please keep reservation to UP and Bihar. in my place there is not such thing. but still we have reservation.

@Enjoyment...530

4 жыл бұрын

And moreover they dont want let obc as well as sc and st come in main stream like at top post in govt service ...

@ibps794

4 жыл бұрын

@@Enjoyment...530 who doesn't want ??? Who are they?? Do they hold authority to do so??? This country is run by articles mentioned in the Constitution. Wo please don't use fallacy to prove your points

we start a 400m race, one guy has a sack in his feet that bound him, the other can run freely; after a little time, when the guy with sack is at 100m, while the other 300m, we open the sack & tell him - now you are equal, go & compete.

@DurgeshYadav-rc6ox

3 жыл бұрын

Exactly...

@nimratk

2 жыл бұрын

Best example

@justintime0167

2 жыл бұрын

How about we elaborate on that race? The guy with the sack is built/heathy enough to carry that bag( having privilege and less financial problems) while the guy who can run freely has an amputated leg,( financial problems ), the audience continuously bashing him for "unequal" competition ( cd) and when he wins the race the other guy with the sack gets the job because his surname was Sharma , Dubey,etc ( the reservation that no one talks about ).

@AyushSharma-pk2ic

Жыл бұрын

@@justintime0167 agreed

@AyushSharma-pk2ic

Жыл бұрын

That is valid In starting......now I've seen so many Dalits who are richer than generals.....your point is totally irrelevant in current generation

Root cause of the problem starts when someone uses word - "Upper Caste" that makes selected people superior irrespective of whether they deserve this or not. There are people feel proud of it. For reference many people use their caste on cars as symbolic representation of their superiority. And note, this is not politically driven but public driven. The day people start feeling proud on what they have achieved instead of which caste they belong to ... things will start changing and it many take one more generation.

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

Most of the reserved students end up dropping out. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit.

@vinjed

2 жыл бұрын

Lol. Instead Upper Castes are also clamoring for Reservations. Social changes never comes from laws. Else racism would be gone from US after 1965 Civil Laws.

@stallonegodinho6296

2 жыл бұрын

@Ash Hegde Did u even read my comment 😂? Read and understand before making false accusations on others.

@vimalkanta1542

2 жыл бұрын

@Ash Hegde chutiye tum log khud bhi mehnat kar liya karo

India will get reserved, Foreign will get deserved :)

Even after being a doctor my mom faced discrimination from people who work under her and if reservations will be over what do u think the people who r in power r so moral that they will not discriminate against st sc obc

@manidipamandal3422

4 жыл бұрын

Absolutely right!! Same problem always happen in my family...

@babypujitha

2 жыл бұрын

So true

I think reservations are legalized form of caste discrimination on a large scale authorized by government of india. If a son of poor cattle grazer gets reservations due to lack of resources then it is understood but if a son of an IAS gets reservations only because their caste is considered lower in SOME PARTS OF THE SOCIETY is not acceptable. Reservations is a concept of past. Now it need to be modified, what I come to conclusion is that reservations should not be for so called lower castes but for those who are below poverty line and hardly have any resources to achieve, what they want.

@gamingsnake3881

Жыл бұрын

Cry more

Very Nice thought. I have never seen any such type of convincing presentation on need of caste based reservation in India. Thank Yogendra sir...i am your great fan since childhood.

The way Yogendra Sir speaks is so soothing. I can keep listening to him for hours. In this Talk, he also explains the difference between 'formal equality' and 'substantive equality'. I agree, "Equal treatment doesn't mean same treatment". Looking forward to read 'Theory of Justice' by John Rawls.

@puneetbhandari1039

3 жыл бұрын

He is urban naxal and urban naxals erode u up in the same way, it's their modus oprandi!

Thank you sir for ths elaboration. Equality Everytime cannot mean treating equally

@shashanksingh7948

6 жыл бұрын

Priyashree Patil right

@pp7390

4 жыл бұрын

@@MBasu-km8by i think you forgot, but reservation was for upper caste only till now (i mean pretty recently) your father or grandfather must have used it.

@RAZONEbe_sep_aiii_0819

4 жыл бұрын

@@MBasu-km8by you lack of wisdom is outstanding.

@dhruvavikas1632

3 жыл бұрын

@@RAZONEbe_sep_aiii_0819 u lack brain

@pawankatiyar1557

3 жыл бұрын

@@MBasu-km8by you are just talking about seeing the ones taking extra advantage from the reservation but just take a look at rural depressed class population with no excess of basic facilities which are far more than the people getting extra advantage in population..now think the person from depressed class who doesn't even treated equally in school cause of its caste have only one option to study to make his life better ,and from the level he is competiting is far behind the generals and if he is getting reservation as a push it is not wrong..so reservation should not be abolished but certain modifications are necessary to prevent the exploitation... It's easy to sit in an AC room of metropolitan cities and make decisions on the one who are in the slums lacking basic needs but its hard to live like them with humiliation which they get with their birth

even my opinion was changed after going through caste census report of government of India

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

Reservation can't solve it. Most reserved students end up dropping out Universities. The result is that we have less Dalits without degrees. Same Dalits could have gotten degrees in less prestigious universities.

@anaghag4925

3 жыл бұрын

But why does that happen?

@amongussus4

2 жыл бұрын

@@stallonegodinho6296 even in govt jobs dalit are less

@stallonegodinho6296

2 жыл бұрын

@@amongussus4 That's becoz a lot of them can't qualify the exams for government jobs even after lowering their minimum passing scores

@amongussus4

2 жыл бұрын

@@stallonegodinho6296 true

Loved the part of fine tuning of reservation.and the conclusion regarding what should the real question be..end of caste inequality not end of reservation..if the former happens the latter will automatically follow.Thank you yogendra sir.

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

Most of the reserved students end up dropping out. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit. Same Dalits would be getting degrees in less prestigious colleges. The inequality is not becoz of caste discrimination. It's that certain groups are over achievers.

3 жыл бұрын

@@stallonegodinho6296 you can't provide any proof for your claims lol

“Inter-generational benefits to be restricted”: Mr Yadav, there is an adage that says “charity begins at home” and also as the Mahatma put it: “Be the change you want to see in the world”. To this end, you must immediately stop sending your son to school, and stop teaching him the many things about the world, that a father would teach his son, and also stop him from reading all books and stop him from the internet, so that intergenerational benefits that you received from your father and grandfather will NOT be passed on to your son and his son, and the “social pipe-dream” that you want to achieve can start with your family.

Made for poor people of SC ,St and obc coummities but benefits are enjoying by rich people of thes coummnities....

@joshdhiwa

3 жыл бұрын

Though they become rich they will not be able to marry poor girl or guy who belong to upper caste.

@shivammudgal1181

3 жыл бұрын

@@joshdhiwa if they don't have self respect, after earning money and power they are comparing themselves with poor upper caste, than what system can do more

I don't want to air my views on reservation here, since social media tends to be a bad forum for policy discussions. That apart, this was one of the most rational discussion on reservation I've ever come across.

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

Most of the reserved students end up dropping out. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit.

1. The very concept of reservation underlines one's social background and caste 2. Poverty and deprivation of resources are even there in those families which do not enjoy the benefits of reservation. 3. The idea driving reservation today is "divide and rule" , as it has been breeding hatred and discrimination among different castes and ethnicities which is a perfect environment for caste-driven political parties to thrive in. 4. No one seems to be focusing on a person's economic conditions to decide his/her chances to avail reservation 5. Equal opportunities do not imply lowering down selection parameters for a particular section of society and compromising the quality of fresh recruits for a job / course

@gamingsingh4004

6 жыл бұрын

k r u clearly have no idea what is difference between social and economical backwardness and on what bases reservation is given and why it's given ..

@kr1192

6 жыл бұрын

gaming singh do enlighten me 'Sir'

@gamingsingh4004

6 жыл бұрын

k r why shell I waste my time on enlightening you ? ... U got internet, use Google or go read a book or something .. dafuq!!

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

@@gamingsingh4004 Most of the reserved students end up dropping out. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit.

A wonderful solution to create equal opportunity though very complex for execution but can be done by efficient lawmaking.

What a simple and calm speech about sensitive matter, he just calmly destroyed hypocracy lying in the matter with figures!! brilliant sir!!

what a wonderful lecture. thank you for enlightening us.

Very Well said: In place of asking when Reservation will abolish, we must ask when this Caste Discrimination and Inequality will eliminate. Its a bitter hate of General category to mock & criticize the Reserved Category.

@virtualmaza513

4 жыл бұрын

Are you in your senses? Even in SC ST reservations should be given to poor people not rich. I'm not against it it's ok to have OBC, SC and ST reserved but only for those who are underprivileged not for all.

@abhishekdhamgunde3237

4 жыл бұрын

How do you dicide if it's eliminated or not

@megumin6095

4 жыл бұрын

@Peter Griffin 100s of years of caste system rooted in indian history and you think a little help to the underprivileged who were left to do the lowest of jobs to survive awfully does more bad than good? Your privileged and entitled upbringing is the part of the problem, not the system you want to abolish sir

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

@@megumin6095 most of those who go to university by reserved category end up dropping out. Ur just wasting seats. And backward people end up without degrees. They could have gotten a degree in a less prestigious college without reservation.

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

Most of caste discrimination takes place in poor places in UP and Bihar. So why not let these people become rich instead of keeping them poor

Superbly and gently explained... Great 👍🏻

Excellent!!!

Great explantion of Rawl's theory of justice...!

I can see everyone is clapping on their own distraction

Myself r belong to so called upper cast .. due cast system in Hinduism many people converting to othet religion , so much cast discrimination , .. i agree with mr Yogendra said ....

@nivedithasenthil2411

3 жыл бұрын

Finally someone from upper caste has made this statement .. happy realisation ... Hope u understand why reservations r required and it is not the reason for casteism ( which has existed for the past 2000 years, in the absence of any affirmative reservation policies)

i wish i had a teacher like YY at every stage of my life....the guy is pure gem!!!

@manishjhamaster

4 жыл бұрын

He wrote Ncert Books.

@sandeepupadhyay813

3 жыл бұрын

Chutiya leftest hai ye..iski sweet baatoon pe mat jaoo

@DurgeshYadav-rc6ox

3 жыл бұрын

@@sandeepupadhyay813 And what's wrong in being a leftist...???. My Ghosh... the ideology of the youth of this country is misplaced big time

Such a nice and ibtelligent person.

I swear to god if i became doctor my fees will be also reserved but priorities will be opposite

Can anyone tell why only new castes are being added to beneficiaries of reservations , and those castes who have cornered all benefits of reservations are not being removed from getting reservations?

John Rawls veil of ignorance example perfectly fits here...love it👍👍

@akashsingh-mp4nr

2 жыл бұрын

Does it fit in practical??

Janm se nhi..Karm se h maanav ka maan..Yahi h mere jeevan ka sangraam.. These beautiful words by Suryaputra Karn is what nation needs to think upon

@ripanmondal1

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah, so promote Intercaste marriage.

Thanks for the talk. It was Helpful.

Never seen such rational views on reservations.

A very cogent argument is presented here. Govt & political parties should also consider the truth value of it.

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

Most of the reserved students end up dropping out. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit. Same Dalits would get degrees in less prestigious colleges.

salute to u sir👏👏🙏🙏🙏

Caste reservation is need until jati bhed bhav remaining in a village of India and needs to increase reservation percentage where still people are thinking I am upper caste. Who thinks upper or lower caste both are gulam of Spanish and Portuguese culture by English Raj. VM

@ashirwadsharma4555

6 жыл бұрын

rahul yadav Ji so acc to your argument to eradicate castism reservation is necessary so why obc people don't marry the sc or st .And st marries with sc to eradicate the castism .see in your village that is it happening ?? Is Yadav marries with sc or st or even in other obc cast ???

@ripanmondal1

5 жыл бұрын

@@ashirwadsharma4555 Intercaste marriages are increasing because of reservation.

@pareshkumar9094

5 жыл бұрын

@@ashirwadsharma4555 Yes that is happening Intercaste marriages are happening but only between sc, st and obc But not in general category

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

@@ripanmondal1 There are no reservations in marriages . So ur argument is vague that inter caste marriages are increasing becoz of reservation.

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

@@pareshkumar9094 Most of the reserved students end up dropping out. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit.

Great, I just replied someone asking for clarification about his data and got a mouthful of abuses (because I am not from his caste). There goes unity!!!

@vkumar2657

4 жыл бұрын

Is he from upper caste ?

@osculocentric

4 жыл бұрын

I had found a few of his papers, unfortunately people have hatred towards anyone speaking rationally. I am SC.

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

@@osculocentric Most of the reserved students end up dropping out. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit. Same Dalits would be getting degrees in less prestigious colleges. Dalit passout in universities is less as a result!

@akashsingh-mp4nr

2 жыл бұрын

@@stallonegodinho6296 har jagah haga hai same reply tune...itna effort caste abolish karne ko karta toh reservation ki zaroorat na parti

Those who fight to remove reservations for the deprived are basically fighting for the same size of roti without even thinking of increasing the size of the roti. Instead the fight should be for drastic reduction of corruption in the country. Its the corruption at top that is reducing the size of roti.

What Nepotism Done With Sushat is Castism Doing With Bahujans Since From Thousands Of Years . Reservation Is Just Representative In Gov. Sector . In Private Sector There Is Still Caste Discrimination Prasent. A Particular Business Is Done By Particular Caste And Nobody From Other Caste Can Startup In Their Businesses .

@satyam6811

3 жыл бұрын

Government has initiatives like DICCI for Young Dalit entrepreneurs to provide them with low interest loans you can Watch Guru Prakash a Dalit professor of Patna University a highly Intellectual among the hate mongers

@ajaylokare5384

3 жыл бұрын

@@MBasu-km8by are you insane or what ? Do i have to give references from manu Smriti ?

@satyam6811

3 жыл бұрын

Everyone is free to do startups and there is no reservation market share over there the only thing matters is quality whether you are Dalit or a not a Dalit it never matter even a dalit can excel in any way like you must be knowing about Artist Vijay mahar and There are many and nowadays even government are initiating businesses among Dalits through DICCI and other innovative measure

The problem woth reservations based on economic background is that it may unite the population by finally demolishing the caste structure in the truest sense. Without dividing it will be very difficult ro loot the citizens of this country. Ideally the 3 basic minimums that a country like India should have been able to deliver to the last citizen in the line, by now are:- 1. Nobody sleeps hungry. 2. Every poor person has a safe shelter to spend a night. 3. Every citizen has equal access to the best possible medicare and medicines free of cost. These are the basic human rights of each citizen in great countries. Great countries where people care for each other regardless of one's caste, creed, region or religions. 🙏 🙏

@muralimahadevb.s6352

5 жыл бұрын

Do u have any idea of how to achieve that, imagine ur the prime minister

"A beggar's hand is a bottomless basket," sums up the reservation system in India.

I want to add one more thing ... We learn from our family, its like having financial education for guys coming from business family similarily that urge to grow comes from family i think. Most of the youngster from lower class family are not growing up with an attitude to grow , its changing but very slowly and if u want to know if there is any discrimination .. there is only one way u have to be born into one of those classes.

Reservation should not be eliminated rather it needs to be reviewed

@vkumar2657

4 жыл бұрын

And caste should be eliminated asap

@apurbaghosh807

4 жыл бұрын

Why bhai??

@RK-iq7il

4 жыл бұрын

@@MBasu-km8by Absolutely right... reservation is a law. and it can be amended as n when required..just need a little effort...but cast system is something which can't be abolished at your will. It is like persona that cannot be changed easily. So efforts should be made to abolish cast system n reservation will be put to end in no time.

@megumin6095

4 жыл бұрын

@@MBasu-km8by caste system is rooted in the indian society. 60 years since it was abolished, the obvious disparity can be seen to this day. The protests to the obc inclusions more than speaks volumes. To say you want the reservations to be gone to abolish casteism, you're obviously very blind sided by the entitled and privileged upbringing you had. You're blaming reservations for the divides when history of our nation treating certain sections of communities bad for centuries leading to the present day divides, doesnt account up to anything?

@megumin6095

4 жыл бұрын

@@MBasu-km8by "low education for continuing casteism" do you believe underprivileged communities will be able to get proper exposure to education without reservations? Do you not consider upper caste people who has a headstart in life have the capability to take all the seats? See here is why I'm saying you are blinded by privilege. Privilege is when you think something isnt a problem because it's not a problem to you personally.

Reservation has only downgraded the society by offering jobs to less deserving candidates. We should help backward classes by offering free and high level of education and vocational training therefore preparing then to get any jobs based on qualifications not based on reservations. Reservations is not sustainable models and can’t last longer.

@shashanksingh7948

6 жыл бұрын

gowildamit 70 saal tum general ne desh ko chalaya hai aur barbaad kar diya....if there is someone undeserving then it is you general

@abhishekd1475

5 жыл бұрын

less deserving? then what about the admissions based on donations? are they deserving ?do u weigh their abilities based on the amount that they are giving to get a seat?

@akashsingh-mp4nr

2 жыл бұрын

Bsdk khule me nahi haga kar aise....🤮🤮

Thanks for this talk sir

I always show you are wearing our gamusa, thank you sir. I feel proud. I m from Assam.

@deba7739

3 жыл бұрын

That's identity of traditional poor

koi Jaat or Cast Unchi nhi aur Nichi nhi..Bas Insaan aur Karm hi uski Quality hai,Pehchan hai...SURNAME ko Apna Fake Superiority NA bnaye...Jai Hind.

@aashayhadke7979

3 жыл бұрын

🙏🙏

For all the people crying about about how Brahmins have dominated society for 1000's of years and commited atrocities on lower castes , riddle me this. I am neither brahmin not hindu,yet I too suffer at the hands of the curse known as reservation. Pray, tell me what have I done to deserve such a cruel fate?

@ripanmondal1

5 жыл бұрын

Don't cry. You too a reserved candidate if you are not a Hindu. Get your caste certificate and apply for reserved seats.

Very nice explanations.

I just want an answer..please read till the last line.. There were 4 students preparing for iit in Patna..3 were from upper caste and 1 from lower caste, they were sharing the same room, eating together without any discrimination...all 4 of them have almost equal family background and financial condition.. 1 from lower caste student is little less intelligent in comparison to other so other 3 help that one student..1 year is completed and results is out..3 from upper caste score around 100 but they didn't qualified for iit but one from lower caste scores 60 marks and get admission in iit.. Now my question is- Isn't it a case of discrimination on the basis of caste?? If it is case then can we complain or take action against this kind of discrimination? Is this is not a loss to our country when we get a better engineer then why we are having a less qualified and less Intelligent engineer??

In most descent countries, reservations/affirmative action are instituted to protect the minorities, not the majority. Only in India, we get to see the majority voting to reserve privileges for themselves at the expense of the 20% minority. Whatever you call it, this is discrimination, Indian style. Yogendra has convinced himself that this is right. He is also minimising the amount of reservation by pointing to 7% of jobs, but what about education? More than half of the seats are reserved.

@kamartaj3010

6 жыл бұрын

OMBhanu yeah bcoz minority enjoyed privilege for thousands of year. Acquired wealth,power and position and left nothing for the majority post independence.

@OMBhanu

6 жыл бұрын

That was in the past...it has been 60 years since independence, three generations of dalits have received the benefit at the expense of the minorities, how long do you think this should go on?

@harshkumarf4379

6 жыл бұрын

it will go on till the every section of society gets its share according to its population ,,, you say that 50 percent seats are reserved but have you checked how many of the reserved seats are actually filled in these institution ,,,, the extremely low level of awareness among the lower castes is the only reason that the full benefits of reservation have not been realised ,,, but changes are visible ,,, the share of the sc st and obc in the govt jobs has increased ,,, despite being more than 60 percent of population they had less than 40 % represtation in the govt jobs and education syatem ,,,

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

@@kamartaj3010 Brahmins were actually landless. Check ur history.

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

@@harshkumarf4379 Most of the reserved students end up dropping out. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit. Same Dalits would have gotten degrees in less prestigious colleges

Reservation basically is a type of discrimination on the basis of caste to abolish caste system in the country 🙏 From many of the years , reservation system is been applied in the country but not even a fraction of might be get affected for abolishing caste system. No of the properly educated person does discrimination. Many of the society is been faced up by discrimination but not adopted the enquality measure to cure it. Reservation should be only on the basis of economical condition

logical arguments!!!!!!

That was a wonderful speech.

Brahmins are enjoying reservation in priestly wood job for more than five thousand years and still continuing

@rupeshgoel8236

5 жыл бұрын

F**k you.

@vishalrai2859

4 жыл бұрын

Uske lie v padhna padta h ved padh le ar ban ja

@abhaybisht7790

4 жыл бұрын

Chutiyeh generals matlab brahmin nhi hota.

@bolisettysrinivas7236

4 жыл бұрын

Why you didn't try sir

@vkumar2657

4 жыл бұрын

@@vishalrai2859 there are thousands of dalit have done PhD in sanskrit and read vedas .. When are you discussing it with your brahmin friends to appoint these guys as priest in temples .

kinda true though, imagine brahmins were going schools for 1000 of years and Dalits merely got chance in last 70 years, there was clearly no inter-cast marriages earlier that time, a particular cast (brahmins in this case) 1000 year ahead in the educational field, it will not be shocking if different casts would have developed different qualities. like brahmins are usually physically not that strong but mentally they are, likewise, there are many qualities craftsmanship to ironwork in which a particular cast has excel , but today education is mainly just focused on degrees and mental strength (which upper casts got evolutionary privilege) but if we focus on like of craftsmanship ( lower casts got evolutionally privilege). today gov is just trying to break this thing. you can give exceptions where lower cast people outshined, but there is a reason why we sill call them an exception.

@DurgeshYadav-rc6ox

3 жыл бұрын

evolutionary privilege it is mate!!!

@sandheep2270

3 жыл бұрын

@Nachiket Patil you are correct bro but it’s not only about education it’s also about their economic status. Because of the discrimination and suppression of lower caste people by higher caste the lower caste people remained POOR and uneducated. They were not given a chance to improve their economic status so through reservations they are getting a chance to get back on their feet and to come out from the poverty which was forced on them by rich higher caste people. So we should think all aspects not only one.

@sandheep2270

3 жыл бұрын

@Nachiket Patil yes I agree with what you are saying but we can’t come to a conclusion about this issue we can’t tell which is right and wrong for telling that we should know the full story which we can’t unfortunately.

@DurgeshYadav-rc6ox

3 жыл бұрын

@Nachiket Patil You know what... i agree to all of your points about the idealistic approach, but to be brutally honest they aren't much pragmatic ones. A damaged society will naturally lag behind from a normal one because of the law of averages and because of the nature of evolution. Human consciousness is the result of our surrounding environment and the greatest factor in making further progress of a society. Blame game provides little to no chance in making an actual progress, but it does address the root of the problem which is essential to understand in order to take the measures to establish a society where no one feels discriminated or oppressed. It's very important that people understand the reasons that why some group of people lag behind in social status and are looked down upon. The idealistic approach won't work here in practical world because of a lot of factors. The harsh truth is that people do discriminate based on caste , not only in villages but also in metro cities. You might say that not all people do, but then exceptions are everywhere and those exceptions will not be enough to alter the result of law of averages. You see, this feeling of inferiority or the feeling of being left behind only came as the result of discrimination and oppression done on people in past and that will vanish from the minds of people only in the form of evolution and can not be eradicated suddenly. A person born in high caste will never have this feeling of being left behind and that is why will never be able to actually comprehend it or empathise with it

Brilliant talk👏👏

in ancient india, when upper class hindus were given lot of privileges and dalits were denied education, denied to enter into temples, exploited heavily by brahmins and rajput nobody talked about equal rights. suddenly after independence when reservation were allowed for weaker section called dalits, suddenly everyone started shouting in the name of equality. what a hypocrisy. now u know how it feels like to be abandoned, forgotten and denied. (note: i m a hindu and not dalit, thus it is a candid opinion)

Most nonsensical Tedx Talk ever. Distrubution of out put of goods and services is the problem economics has not been able to solve. Basing his thoughts on Jhon Rawls book ," Amartya Sen" has also written a book called the 'idea of Justice' in which he has describe the distribution of a flute problem. There could be various perspectives. It goes as following: 1. Suppose, somebody manufactures a Flute (He would like to keep it even though he cannot play it as he would assert the ownership to the flute) 2. Someone who can play the flute would lay the claim on the flute as he would assert he can play the flute.(A utilitarian view) 3 .A person wanting to learn how to play the flute would assert that her wants to learn it and the person who already knows to play the flute would be no good candidate as he already knows to play the flute. Given such arguments its impossible to a make a choice, The only one, one can make is a Hosbsons Choice!! On the whole, the talk is just impromptu needs more finissee is actually incomplete and has different motivations. Quoting some great authors doesnt heed the sustantiation of the argument; it blurrs it. One must read the entire thing and them try to make sense and then make an elegant argument out ot it.

@pkcowzah3369

3 жыл бұрын

In case you dont realize, which i am sure is the case, your opening words "Most Non-sensical Tedx talk ever" smack so strongly of grandiosity, that its best not to bother with whatever you might have to say. There is no Hobsons choice there.

@manjinder2186

3 жыл бұрын

Suppose there are two persons one knows how to play the flute but doesn't have it while other person owns the flute only because his or her father owed it for the same reason. Then, who should own the flute?

Reservation has failed. Instead of taking everyone down, we should be focusing on providing high quality schools for all children. Currently, public schools in India are awful about which these intellectuals do not address.

@manishmahore1575

6 жыл бұрын

We should try "separate electorate" instead of reservation

@gamingsingh4004

6 жыл бұрын

manish mahore u talking about 'communal award' of Ramsay MacDonald.. u can't implement it now, Gandhi made sure of it. But yes it could've been a better option than reservation. Reservation is a slow process, it works but it's little slow when the population is this huge. In cities we can see the improvement but social backwardness is very real in rural area all that different water sources, separate glass, separate Temples etc what we hear Happened in past all is very real in villages and majority (68%) of indians still live in rural area. So we r still very far away from our goal.

@manishmahore1575

6 жыл бұрын

gaming singh communal award exactly had 3 major objectives 1- separate electorate 2- right of double vote for SC ST 3- separate settlement (most important) Would be implemented surely we got our goal. Second one reservation is not a matter seat in such areas it means representation of every class in every aspect or dimension.. but it failed because intellectual class of our country become selfish and mean... So we should try at least second option of separate electorate and settlement as well

@gamingsingh4004

6 жыл бұрын

manish mahore but communal award can't be implemented now. Mk Gandhi made sure that communal award dies when he forced Dr. Ambedkar to sign poona pact. So talking about it now is waste of time .. Reservations main goal is to brigde the gap between SC/St and rest of the Indian by forcing them to study (at school and college level) together, by working together. Making sure a fixed number of SC will be at all levels so ppl get used to seeing a SC/ST on all those places. Ppl often don't see it this way all they see is SC ST getting job or seats in colleges, which is wrong, reservation in case of SC/St is give because of social backwardness, their economy status is not relavent.

@manishmahore1575

6 жыл бұрын

gaming singh reservation has been in force since 70 year but there is no upliftment as the prediction was.. Bcoz SC ST can never be uplifted while with the general category for ex. Rats and cats are being taken in same room then rats are always be live in fear they were always be oppressed.. So we should imply the force of separation basically the separation of power political power.. they need their own representative, leader, bussismen, journalists, their own power.. Everything can be possible

it should be based on economic status according to what you said about a child born on 28 th floor of building with helipad and a child born in slum.

Such an educating presentation!

RATION CARD -APL BPL GOVT JOB: CASTE POLITICIANS:CASTE POLITICS CONSTITUTION: INDIA SECULAR COUNTRY

Really, YY is hypnotising...his tone, voice, and language.....wow!!!

Superb speexh sir

It's very simple, Caste-based Reservation will never end because Caste-based Discrimination will never end, Caste-based Discrimination will never end because Caste System (Upper Caste/Lower Caste) will never end... Caste System will never end because the so called Upper Castes will never in their wildest imaginations allow and approve of marriage with Lower Caste...

Reservation is outcome of Hinduism uppercaste Karma. Karma is a boomerang.

@breastmilkgaming

6 жыл бұрын

PATRAGO Remember that was colonial era . !

@s3narasi

6 жыл бұрын

whose boomerang is poverty and corruption reservation lovers boomerang.

@AmitKumar-un9mx

6 жыл бұрын

No Chutiya it's not.. its the fear of riot and vote bank due to which it's still exist. Even Sir Ambedkar introduced it for limited time only. Now it's time to remove it from the roots because it's again creating the differences between castes.

@menonvyshak428

6 жыл бұрын

Karma .... is it.... i wud ask u to remember ur words Once dis wil happen ...1000s of sc st all low caste heads ripped n blood shed all over .This is how its going to end . So remove all caste system n reservations bcoz i dont want lord mountbattens words to come into reality .👹

Though all countries adopting affirmative actions despite 5%general class oppose the policy....yogendra yadav ji you rocks😅😅always

there is a difference between equality and justice...unforunatly only few people understand this...

There should be reservation, but there should be regular amendments. Like creamy layer should be excluded. Those who have already taken the advantages should not take again. And it should be increased beyond a certain point.

We need to demolish caste system first ...

Reservation is for equal representation. Reservation has nothing to do with money.

@noice8674

5 жыл бұрын

then why dont you earn representation through hard work? why depend on reservation?

@vkumar2657

4 жыл бұрын

@@noice8674 How are you going to help manual scavengers to get representation in institutes like AIIMS ..?? Tell me the alternative please

@noice8674

4 жыл бұрын

@@vkumar2657 Govt schools provide free education to everyone. Study hard and crack the entrance exam. You will get into AIIMS without reservation

@theawkwardcurrypot9556

4 жыл бұрын

@@noice8674 Do they all have the sane social situations and statuses.

@noice8674

4 жыл бұрын

@@theawkwardcurrypot9556 If u have determination and willing to work hard u dont need any reservation to achieve in life. Reservation is just for the sake of appeasement

18 years of good formal school education is a strong tool to make the children of backward classes ready to access an equal footing. Yet we dont do much in those years. On a crippled based, we apply the cosmetic change of reservation. Consequence? Even in critical areas like medicine, we are trusting the lives and healths of public in the hands of candidates of SC ST OBC who were not competent enough to pursue a medicine career. Why their fundamental language , aptitude, and analytical skills were not given attention during school education ? If needed, why not give them free engineering or medical exam prep and then have them compete . SC ST in IITs, even after getting in at lower marks in JEE, struggle to clear the 4 years of btech. They mostly continue to score less. Reservation still didn't make them fit for job post IIT either. Give them reservation at DPS, at Rishi Valley, at Navoday. But not at higher education.

I don't want to say anything about reservation but caste based discrimination is real.And even educated upper caste people practice it .One can see in jobs (govt. and private sector) regarding promotion ,raise where no reservation is there, incompetent and wrong upper caste person are preferred over hardworking,sincere low caste person .

Very good explanation on such a complex topic. Thank you.

End asking about caste, caste surname and all form of discrimination and reservation.

Genuine question: 16:30 Why is that amongst the poor the pass percentage is higher in brahmins? Why is this statistic related to a lack of equal opportunity?

The problem with this graphical kind of analysis of opportunities is they only show a comparison between who is high and who is low among the communities and forget about about those who might be low in some higher ones and those who might be higher in some lower ones. But, the govt is for everyone, even for the weaker brahmins+ castes. But, your method is just eliminates these weaker people only because they are tagged with a brahmin+ tag. And, thinking according to our experiment, There's one thing common in weaker people in every community and thats (1) They don't have a proper understanding of things, so they need education. Education would help them know the world, morality, how to earn, etc. They'll learn the art of making money and raising their living standards. They need reservation for free education. (2) They're economically weak, that's why they're bullied by other people. Everyone whos economically weaker (even the upper caste weaker people) are bullied by other(even by rich lower caste people). The education of fairly making money would medicate this. While they're learning they need reservation for food, for health and other commodities along their learning period. The irony of this who system is we talk of removing the caste system and yet follow the caste certificates for our functions endlessly.

The demand of the time is to remove major anomaly in current reservation system in india especially SC/ST reservation. Over the period a segment among ST / SC category has become economically stronger then the rest and they are getting most of the reserved seat. There is need to think on following points to make it relevant and effective : Why son or daughter of economically sound dalit ( IAS / IPS officers) should get benefit of reservation? There should be provision of creamy layer in SC/ST reservation like it is there in OBC reservation. It will make reservation more acceptable and justified and remove grudge of most of the people who are out of reservation.

@santioned_sneh

4 жыл бұрын

How will you tackle untouchablilty then ?

@rahulvirmaan

4 жыл бұрын

@@MBasu-km8by We should make a caste free India, then reservation automatically phased out. Attack on the caste system and reservation will die out automatically because the reservation is based on caste itself.

@rahulvirmaan

4 жыл бұрын

Mohok Basu Yeah I know brother...that’s why we have to create an alternative social structure which can replace the caste structure but the new one should have social mobility. And can be changed according to the changing nature of society like our constitution is dynamic... not the rigid like caste.

@rahulvirmaan

4 жыл бұрын

Mohok Basu I know reservation keeps the caste structure alive... and now they are interlinked. So both have to be gone for once... that’s why I am proposing new social structure rather than going for old one.

@SB-vx2mr

4 жыл бұрын

@@MBasu-km8by he addressed everything in the video. He noted some points about fine tuning the reservation system. Watch the video properly, the current system is not good either.

49.5 % in govt sector ? Is it so small?

@dododododododod

3 жыл бұрын

for 76% of population maybe. reasonable.

I always wanted to hear someone sane make some points why he supports the reservation, because i had heard enough against it, and i am convinced against too. The stand 'for reservation' was very alien to me. I am very happy, i am surely not disappointed! Although there are a lot of loose ends in the talk, that i can see, this is a start of a good thought process and fact verification :)

I learnt this whole in My 1st semester... Political science honours 🙂

@RahulGNath

4 жыл бұрын

Can u share that materials for reference....😊

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

@@RahulGNath Most of the reserved students end up dropping out. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit. Same Dalits would be getting degrees in less prestigious colleges.

One of the most intellectual man in india... Yogendra yadav hats off✊ thanks for clearing this doubt from me.

Even after listening to this lectures some fools didn't understand why there is reservation........bhain ke aagey bin bajane jaisi baat hai ye....

@shashanksingh7948

6 жыл бұрын

Compassion Love bhai samjhte sab hain...par haraamzaadgi in general ke khoon mein hi hoti hai

@goofy3421

5 жыл бұрын

@@shashanksingh7948 tu bhi to general hai chutiye

@shashanksingh7948

5 жыл бұрын

@@goofy3421 tabhi to general logon ko acche se jaanta hoon...haramzade hote hain

@goofy3421

5 жыл бұрын

@@shashanksingh7948 fake name hai tera tu saala OBC hoga

# आरक्षण बहुत जरूरी है पर ऐसा नहीं जैसा अपने कहा - आरक्षण शिक्षा से ले कर नौकरी - जमीन - व्यापार - संगठन - पद - वितरण - ठेका - लाइसेंस और हर जगह जरूरी है और उसका प्रतिशत वैसा नहीं जैसा अपने कहा |||

Thank you Sir for a good attempt, though I have some disagreement, thanks to the entire team for the event

@arunvirsingh203

4 жыл бұрын

Would like to hear to your views brother.

@stallonegodinho6296

4 жыл бұрын

@@arunvirsingh203 Most of the reserved students end up dropping out. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit. Same Dalits would be getting degrees in less prestigious colleges

Aap.jaat paat ka bhed bhaw mitao.......ye log khud reservations katam kar wa lenge

Caste based Reservation can never annihilate caste system @yogendra Sir...

@rigormortis6481

6 жыл бұрын

yes, but marrying brahmins to preserve your varna certainly will, right ? Right ?

@ripanmondal1

5 жыл бұрын

Tatasat Mishra, caste based reservation is a guaranteed way to annihilate caste system.

@akashsingh-mp4nr

2 жыл бұрын

@@rigormortis6481 bruhhh😂😂🔥🔥🔥💙

@akashsingh-mp4nr

2 жыл бұрын

@@rigormortis6481 see he didn't reply... these castiest MFS will write thesis on How reservations are sacrificing merits lawda lassan but they'll never take such steps as to abolish caste system,caste privilege or caste pride..

All points mentioned for fine tuning are very much required.because first' generation allready benefited and economically stroung to provide economic support to their children should not be given financial benefits. Instead that can go to other person of same cast.

Awesome

I am OK with equality of opportunity, not equality of outcome. I am OK with giving the lower class, right to free education, but not right to free jobs. You get college seats at lower or no cost at all, that too with lower marks. So study like everyone else and get a job. But instead, you don't use the college seat, you got for free, you don't work hard, and in the end you want a free government job too with your low grades. That is injustice towards the general category.

@parblisful

6 жыл бұрын

this injustice you have done for centuries towards them.

@animealpha4795

6 жыл бұрын

Partha Pratim Biswas lol, I'm pretty sure he isn't "centuries" old.

@ojasgulhane8524

6 жыл бұрын

You are absolutely correct regarding getting college seats and jobs at low marks, but these people are very few if you compared to other people of this (Sc St OBC) cast, maximum people of these cast are denied equal opportunity(as mentioned in video). AS Yadav ji said , the trouble of cast based reservation is that it is very rigid. These are very few people(compared to whole ) we see getting spoon feed with plethora of opportunities even though they had same upbringing as us and same quality of education , they are just extreme lucky and extremely few in number to be caught in loop hole of rigidity of cast based reservations.

@sanatkumar3136

6 жыл бұрын

rightly said reservation is instrument to pull the so called upper class downwards and replace them with less educated person...it is an act of hatred towards upper class...just in this reply section only i found that hatred ; u had ruled us 200years now i will rule over you..and this will go on.and i dont' care if new generation is different from old one..

@dudedude3335

6 жыл бұрын

Centuries of atrocities.. U people have no prblm.. ... But now just 60 years of reservation is itching you?.. High caste silver spoon fed fools like you can never understsnd the condition the lower castes live in....

Backward people must need reservation that give some potential to up in the social and financially ...

Well spoken.

Until reservations extend in Olympic, football, cricket world cups and others game reservation lovers will not satisfied. It would really pleased to see.

Professor Yadav you are too brave for your own good. You are still an idealistic activist not a politivian. What makes you think that your audience wants to know the truth you are telling.

@DurgeshYadav-rc6ox

3 жыл бұрын

Exactly my thoughts. This caste system is so deeply rooted in people's minds that they will always have prejudices for certain castes.

Reservations spread like epidemic ,every community demand for reservations .how could it possible ??

@theawkwardcurrypot9556

4 жыл бұрын

Intermarry,a lot.

Maybe the upper castes inherited riches from ancestors and are still enjoying it. That's what is meant by the racetrack example.

@anaghag4925

3 жыл бұрын

@@MBasu-km8by No, what we want is kind of editing the past and when the starting lines becomes fair cast reservations would be ended. Economic reservation is a different case.

@barathivaasan5876

3 жыл бұрын

@@MBasu-km8by think about this logically, a kid grows up in a household which has people with access to higher education and have had higher education for several generations. And another kid from a low caste whose ancestors were denied even the most basic level of education and were not allowed to learn. Do you think they would have the same level of knowledge and social dignity? I think you understand that the environment in which a child were raised determines over 70% of his or her personality and intelligence. The goal of reservation is to uplift people who have been denied education and basic humanity. It isn't just economical uplifting, it's about social uplifting. So that they are treated the same as someone from a higher caste.

All his points are valid but let's be real. NO political party will dare touch the reservations EVER. Hence, all the fne tuning that he mentioned can never be applied. There will be bloodshed. NO party will exclude some castes which have come out of poverty. And THAT is the problem.

@ripanmondal1

5 жыл бұрын

That's not a problem. You do not need to touch the reservation system.

For How long ? Actual time when introduced is 10 years only. Politians are prolonging for Votes. Preference based on income is Enough Now a Days.

3 жыл бұрын

As long as there is discrimination in society

@achyutsingh5298

3 жыл бұрын

Until the ratio of population reflects the ratio of occupation of higher education and teaching. Correct me if I'm wrong I'd like to learn more

@tejasambekar9316

3 жыл бұрын

Who told you that the reservation is only introduce for 10 years only ? As per the article 330 and 332 the political reservation is introduce for 10 years only not the education and employment reservation

@article1528

3 жыл бұрын

Who told for you watsup University of fb University 😂😂 those fights for reservation plz fight also for preparation to end for caste system sitting in ac room and sharing things in fb it's wont workable visit for Towns and tell to them we should stop this monoethics from today nly then reservation ends other wise it's waste of time commenting on social media

@notanikdey

3 жыл бұрын

System that oppressed for 1000s of years cannot be overturned in less than a hundred