Why Religion Is Bad For You
►►Ask Rabbi Manis Friedman Your Questions In His Private VIP Community: go.itsgoodtoknow.org/vip-memb...
Click Here To Get Access To Weekly Conversations! itsgoodtoknow.org/join-the-co...
We Need Your Help!
To support the work of Rabbi Manis Friedman, please visit- itsgoodtoknow.org/donate/
To join the online community and for weekly live webinars, please visit- itsgoodtoknow.org/join-the-co...
To book a private session with Rabbi Friedman, please visit- itsgoodtoknow.org/coaching/
For information on upcoming events and to join the email list please visit- itsgoodtoknow.org/
Follow Rabbi Manis Friedman:
Facebook: / manisfriedman
Twitter: / manisfriedman
Linkedin: / rabbifriedman
Instagram: / rabbimanisfried. .
About Rabbi Manis Friedman:
Rabbi Manis Friedman is a world-renowned author, counselor, lecturer and philosopher who uses ancient wisdom and modern wit to captivate audiences around the world. For event bookings, please call our office at 800-656-5669 or email us at office@itsgoodtoknow.org
Пікірлер: 879
I love his quote “Don’t get religious, get Godly.”
God has directed me to your teachings! I prayed as a Christian to be shown the TRUTH & to grow Thank you Rabbi
@liviaides1445
4 жыл бұрын
YAH bless you, rabbi Friedman and keep you safe in every vway! SHALOM! Todà rabah!❣💙🕎
@missfeliss3628
2 жыл бұрын
Yes I am converting to be a Jew ...christianity is made up I think!
I'm a Christian & I have never heard the Word explaind so well I Salute u Sir
I’m so glad their is a rabbi like you we can listen and watch online. When practical wisdom comes from you and people can use it and live happily with the knowledge.
@kevinkingston6488
4 жыл бұрын
I agree well said....
@this-is-my-voice
4 жыл бұрын
Practical wisdom from the man whose son is an abuser and says spooky things like grown men are attracted to 13 year old girls, rape is not so bad it's more the effect of it...etc. Of course the title of this video is a lie to trap people into religion...
@KaraGhounKhan
4 жыл бұрын
You don't need "their is" when "there is" does the job. Cheers.
@protocolsoftheeldersofchic1215
4 жыл бұрын
The guy in the vid is part of an extremist sect that wants to destroy christianity by turning them into noahides.
@dzidkab7189
3 жыл бұрын
I'm sorry it's not THEIR, it is THERE. It's time to learn a difference. It's basic English grammar. And I'm polish.
Thankyou Rabbi for this shiur. This really helped me change the way in which I serve Hashem. I didn't realize how much I was trying to be religious, like the book 'How to be the most religious person in the world.' I was too busy with trying to look it on the outside whilst neglecting the true service for Hashem from my heart. Saying autonomous and empty prayers and actions. No wonder I was looking outside of myself for approval from others. Now I can serve Hashem with kavanah and my own path has begun to unfold before me. Thankyou for being true and real in your shiurim. I went straight to my heart. I got something new from all that I've listened to so far.
I don’t really know what teaching I follow. All I know is this man here speaks the truth.
@Tia7890
3 жыл бұрын
Same! ❤️🌺🌸
@elishevamayer2138
2 жыл бұрын
This is my Rabbi
"Religion was invented when the first con man met the first fool"~Mark Twain
@kvasudevan7575
4 жыл бұрын
this process repeated again and again even nowadays
@kvasudevan7575
4 жыл бұрын
renewal of religion also have had the same aspects
@ollie6389
4 жыл бұрын
Keep on playing those thoughs & keys until you find the Truth. God Speed
@factmachine1860
4 жыл бұрын
mark Twain probably in gehinom right now
@missswann4234
4 жыл бұрын
Tom Riviere and who is mark twain? ;)
I’m a Muslim and I really enjoyed that and I needed it
@khairyusuf1659
4 жыл бұрын
Worship One Creator not his Creations Qur'an is Enlightenment Guidance Criterion for Humanity for the Success of both the World's Please Read Understand Practice Preach Devine Law's Dreams R unlimited but Life is Limited Tc of Right Knowledge True Faith Islam Well-wisher @ Peace
@khairyusuf1659
4 жыл бұрын
@David ben Mesecke Fear Almighty Allah Alone Abraham & Ismail built Kaaba in Mecca Without Devine Guidance Humanity can't Understand the Devine Law's & Plan's & Purpose of Life Qur'an is Enlightenment Guidance Criterion for Believers please Read Understand Practice Preach to Humanity for Success of both the World's Follow the Prophet's Mohammed for a Meaningful Life Well-wisher @ Peace
@christophersurnname9967
4 жыл бұрын
You’re not a good Muslim then. Infidels must bow down to Allah or die. Is this not correct?
@khairyusuf1659
4 жыл бұрын
@@christophersurnname9967 In the Age of information technology, Ignorance is a Choice of Right & wrong Mind'based Spirituality & Man made Law's Capitalism Secularism & Blind faith will Deviate from Purpose of Life & destroy your Life & Faith My friend , God will decide who is Good & Evil Don't be a Devil's advocate Be kind to yourself & Understand Purpose of Life Read Scriptures Qur'an is Word of God Guidance for Mankind Massenger R blessings for humans Worship One Creator not his Creations Tc of Right Knowledge True Faith Islam Well-wisher @ Peace
@khairyusuf1659
4 жыл бұрын
@@christophersurnname9967 Don't judge a Religion by it's follower's & Media & word of mouth , Blind faith will not benefit you in both the World's Better to go to the sources of Scriptures Qur'an Word of God Worship One Creator not his Creations Understand God & Your Relationship Tc of Right Knowledge True Faith Monotheism Well-wisher @ Peace
I’m Polish catholic… there’s a lot of tension between our nations and religions…years of European history … what a smart person!!!!! I love his lectures! Greetings from Detroit!
@mariekatherine5238
Жыл бұрын
Eastern Rite (Byzantine) here. There’s also conflict from the prejudices of long ago, but the new generations don’t have that, not in the US.
Long life to this amazing brilliant man! There’s no one like him, ever! Please don’t stop doing these videos, I so enjoy listening to you, you inspire me.
I love this man. You see this kids? This is what wisdom looks like.
Rabbi you are intelligent beyond imagination, and this is mind blowing period. The truth all step of the way, by the way I am a Sheik (Muslim)
That was a great speech. Insightful, funny, articulate - i've really enjoyd it. Greetngs from a Greek Orthodox Christian from Athens/Greece. Shalom , Rabbi Friedman and thank you :)
@protocolsoftheeldersofchic1215
4 жыл бұрын
He wanys to destroy christanity he is a chabad rabbi
@protocolsoftheeldersofchic1215
4 жыл бұрын
@@ReverbRevival519 my comment stands.
sometimes these so called needs that i have really blinded me and caused me many griefs. but from now on i will trust the Lord more than I did before. Thank you Rabbi Mannis.
I'm not Jewish but I love this Rabbi, so full of wisdom and humour.
@jackdavidsen6074
4 жыл бұрын
@Le Ed -- Ny reply may not be the best, but allow me to give it a try: Reality is circular, it is not square, but viewing it as such is a very widespread misunderstanding which we have lived with since,... well, the dawn of religion. Rabbi Friedman does give very fine answers on his way around the circle of living, of grace, loving, and of square lens problems. And in my view, he does it wonderfully.
@Claude_van
4 жыл бұрын
@Le Ed The scientists simply fulfilled God‘s need to create new things in this world.
@hexagramz5115
4 жыл бұрын
Yeah, made me laugh couple times
I love your ideas Rabbi Friedman, my mind and heart is overwhelmed with humour and happiness right now, thank you.
I have never heard anything about being needed by God before in my life. Thank dear Sir.
@benjaminben6200
Жыл бұрын
Nice comment sir. I thank you.
I like this man. So glad I found him here. My Rabbi is like him, that's why I keep going back.
@factmachine1860
4 жыл бұрын
Rabbi manis friedman doesnt mention any torah sources for the things he says
@factmachine1860
4 жыл бұрын
@daniel דניאל Ok But he needs sources for saying hell isnt that bad, When In fact its 60 times Hotter Than Fire On The first Level! By cooling people off Yeah They might, Yeah It might temporarily relive there worry, But When They die They will suffer tremendously Unfortunately. I hope They repent
@vixendoe2545
3 жыл бұрын
@@factmachine1860 Rabbi Singer has also said that hell is not a permanent thing, only for the most evil of people.
@urnewbestfriend8235
3 жыл бұрын
@@factmachine1860 so you know that how? Have you been there?? Didn’t think so
@yonarivkakimelman
3 жыл бұрын
Not bringing sources - this is simply his unique style of speaking. I have had the pleasure of learning from texts with him and I can attest that he’s actually a very well-versed Torah scholar (he even served as one of the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s redactors) but his aim here is not to inundate with sources but rather to distill the essence of the mystical teachings of Torah - and deliver in a delightful and palatable way that anyone can receive. After a while listening to him, you may be inspired to study the sources in Chabad chassidic teachings yourself!
Very wise words, I am a Jew and I am glad someone who can confirm what I believe all along!
@patkearney9320
11 ай бұрын
I’m Irish and I’ve always loved the and envied in a kind way Jewish folk a decent way of life and wisdom all around you. Us the other peoples are so confused and messed up truly your the chosen people for sure remember this my friend regard’s from Ireland.
I don’t know what I would do without you,Rabbi. Thank you so much for sharing your wisdom to this guilt ridden Christian.
@sretnazvijezda400
4 жыл бұрын
@Höher wertiger I dont know Where is her heart
So brilliantly explained ...actually if we stop being religious...focus only on what God needs from us...Thanks Rabbi..for the eye opener....I hope all religious leaders listen to you....
Kindness is Religion .... Thank you Rabbi 🙏
@francisfischer7620
8 ай бұрын
It's the only religion I believe in.
Those videos are priceless , and thank you is an understatement . Am so grateful .. ❤️ ❤️ 🙏🏾 🙏🏾 ❤️
I've been watching the rabbi every night now God bless him
Sitting alone listening to Rabbi Made me laugh out loud to myself . I like this man a lot !
Thank you Rabbi. My son said that and I said it back *I didn't ask to be born either* Just love your knowledge.
Thank you Rabbi Freidman. You speech is enlightening and entertaining. You have encouraged me to understand the Kabbala and how to answer questions and comments without producing anger.
Just when I thought I was hell bound... I stumbled on this guy🙏 for me...
Only after leaving religion was I shown my true purpose. I stumbled over the simplicity of it. Serve others. Religion serves self. Religious people need their egos fed.
Rabbi Friedman sharing 'The Greatest Law Never Writen'
Love it! 💖🌹 Religion doesn't bring joy and love to my life, relationship with my Creator and my loved ones does!
@SH-yy1qe
4 жыл бұрын
@Mohamud Ahmed I agree . But theirs a millions diffrent views about what god wants lol
An absolute eye opener !!! Thanks from Holland.
Me encanta su sentido del humor!!! Soy su fan #1 saludos desde Tampico, Tamaulipas Estimado Rabbino🌹
I'm not Jewish but I love this guys words of Wisdom.
@GameDevAraz
2 жыл бұрын
Should be Jewish.
@elishevamayer2138
2 жыл бұрын
Thank you, this is my Rabbi
Wow! I feel like I'm in school with a great teacher!
Sir, I just discovered you yesterday, & I am so glad/great ful, that I did.
Wow as an atheist that was some powerful words
There is a difference between law: you ought! And grace through love: I want. Ought vs. Want. Law or Grace. Justice or. Mercy. Justice means I must go to prison. Mercy means I forgive you. I need mercy and grace otherwise I get law and justice.
@annturi5826
4 жыл бұрын
Hello Ted Bates. Your comment intrigues me. I agree with the basic premise. I just wonder if "grace and mercy" can exist without "law and justice". For example: if someone likes to do harm to others, like killing people, how long should we show "grace and mercy" before we use "law and justice"? This is an issue I have struggled with for quite some time. What is your opinion on this? Many thanks for your reply in advance. Most kind regards
@hcharton5722
4 жыл бұрын
@@annturi5826 We condemn the sin, but we always love the sinner. We do this because every soul is a part of our soul and a part of the Yehovah. Yehovah is One. We are a part of Yehovah. We are all One. If your right hand cut your left hand, would you amputate your left? No, because it is a part of you.
@annturi5826
4 жыл бұрын
Thank you @@hcharton5722 for your valuable reply; it is highly appreciated. Most kind regards
@hcharton5722
4 жыл бұрын
@ellenfrancis67 thank you dear friend, I think the best answer I can give is that grace and mercy make law and justice possible- and vice versa. They temper each other. In fact, law and justice without grace and mercy cannot really exist. It is just that we show mercy. I am both spirit and human. To protect my humanness I do have to draw boundaries. To nurture my spirit, I must forgive. It is through grace that we can forgive. I pray that like our Loving Source, I am slow to anger, and quick to forgive. Many Blessings.
@dt6822
4 жыл бұрын
One is the father, the other is the mother. And the Syrian is the other. Syrian-XM. LOL
This was amazing. Thank you. Blessings to you!
Thank you rabbi!! שלום
THIS IS SO VERY STOICAL. GRATEFULLY INDIFFERENT. THE GOOD MEANS LIVING WELL. LIFE FOR MAN IS AN ART.
My mother with her wickedness she turned to religion..what happened next was living with a complete covert narcissistic woman who would stand infront of church and donate millions, show off in church while never eating with us,never doing anything with us..i hated gospel,hated church, hated all that relates becaudr to me it is evil.
Thank you Rabbi for the words of wisdom.
I don't have any religion but i love God more than everything. We have to praise only the one who created heaven and earth no one else. I love and respect anybody who loves Him this is why I respect you rabbi. You are funny and smart
I'm a Christian but I agree , religion is man controlling other men and usually ends up with man receiving glory instead of our creator.
Amazing stuff . I love to hear this man speak .
my dad always said dont be religious, be jewish. judaism is not a religion. i never understood what he meant back then.
@lawrencetendler2342
4 жыл бұрын
Judaism should be, is meant to be ,above Religion ,which is what many of us forget.
This man gives off Carlin vibes, i like it.
@cockatooinsunglasses7492
4 жыл бұрын
We found a Jewish George Carlin.
@funDAYsmiling
4 жыл бұрын
killertaco97 Carlin is too confrontational though. I’m not even sure what qualifies Carlin other than his being famous for being a contrarian. Jewish Rabbis on the other hand are ALWAYS very well educated and experienced.
@funDAYsmiling
4 жыл бұрын
“was confrontational...”. ^ I agree that this rabbi has the “opened up ... come at me” posture which helps.
@protocolsoftheeldersofchic1215
4 жыл бұрын
George Carlin knew about their subversive and deceptive ways.
@CrazyHorseInvincible
3 жыл бұрын
Except Carlin didn't change the definition of "religion" for the purpose of special pleading.
Manis means sweet in my language. When I hear his name it puts smile in my face
@leab2039
4 жыл бұрын
Neptune Joo what language?
@user-po6hy4wq5w
4 жыл бұрын
@@leab2039 malay
@florahavard456
4 жыл бұрын
Neptune you should be praying and get from under his teaching.and run as fast as you can from this man.
@neptunejoo
4 жыл бұрын
@@florahavard456 i know :) but i am still intrigued
@benharyo
4 жыл бұрын
Same in mine.. 😀
I'm much more motivated to do for others, to encourage them, to advice them to succeed, to bring the best out of them. I do it joyfully, but sometimes I think that maybe I don't do enough for myself. I sometimes wish that I was more selfish or more ambitious when it came to me. I'm very critical of this. Interesting view point. Although I'm not so sure that it's not more of a burden to know that we must serve God. lol Thank you, I enjoyed listening to your sermon. BTW I'm a Christian.
Yep Yep ! Great Video Rabbi Friedman ! I rather be needed than needy then my right side of my heart is working in harmony with the creator thank you !
I'm Christian and I actually binge watch anything I can find of Rabbi Friedman. It's always eye opening. I'm doubting some aspects of Christian beliefs though.
@elmalanmalan2175
2 жыл бұрын
Same here
I enjoyed this so much. Strong message. Please keep spreading your message
Am a jew and am a new subscriber am glad to hear this🙏🙏🙏
God bless you, Rabbi! I really appreciate your insightful program. I concur completely with you: religion seeks self-gain for its practioner. Spirituality seeks to surrender self to GOD. To ask for HIS assistance in loving HIM, with all of our heart , mind, and soul, so that HIS WILL, and not our own, is done.
At the five and 15 minute mark they were two advertisements for Christianity... Maimonides maintains if you pray to anything other than the Creator, the almighty God, you are effectively idol worshipping and you will never be saved, most Christians don't realize this. This is very fundamental for them to achieve the afterlife
It is truly happening that according to God there are people who consider themselves to be wise but are fools before the sight of God
Too good. He is superb. Makes things simple and explains.
I’m a christian It help me a lot to learn more about God from Rabbi friedman
@protocolsoftheeldersofchic1215
4 жыл бұрын
Under the noahide law christianity is considered idol worship and the punishment is beheading, did you know that?
@goldengun9970
2 жыл бұрын
@@protocolsoftheeldersofchic1215 Jews and muslims tigether tell christians they are idol worshipers. Who are you? Someone who only learnt this yesterday?
Thank You! This is most insightful and liberating ever!
dobro istinito rečeno, nepotrebni verski ratovi i takmičenja služeći sebi svojoj telesnosti-
reminds me of the verse in the holy quran "inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji3oon" which translates as "to god we belong and to him we shall return" and we are encouraged by proohet muhammad 1400 years ago to recite and remember this verse when life overwhelms us or tragedy afflicts us.
@mr.mikaeel6264
4 жыл бұрын
نفسي يؤلم استماع هذه رجل
I am muslim too.. very enjoy this speech, so deep, meaningful, and we all here to serve our One God.
@Claude_van
4 жыл бұрын
@yusie rizal Man is created in the image of God not to be a slave of God but a partner. That’s Judaism.
@gondala
4 жыл бұрын
@@Claude_van probably thats the culture since only jews have experience to be "close" enough to feel God's existance compared to islamic history.
@ISREALYAHWEH3INONE
4 жыл бұрын
@@gondala jew are the chosen one to spread the word and law of God God of all Hebrew prophets God of isreal yweh Not God of Quran and Allah We dont believe in same God
@protocolsoftheeldersofchic1215
4 жыл бұрын
Judaism is a supramacist ideology, look into the talmud and the noahide laws. Its psychopathic
@gondala
4 жыл бұрын
@@ISREALYAHWEH3INONE you may not believe the same God, but God of muhammad clearly mention that our God is the same, the God of moses which speak to moses in the valley of tuwa or uwa whether you believe it or not. :D
Thank you so much. I thought I was going to have to go this alone.
@mahmoudali6605
3 жыл бұрын
If your thinking it, there is likely a great amount of people thinking it too.
The most beautiful verse in the whole scripture is Revelation 18:4 Come out of her My people. Out of the bondage of Babylon (meaning confusion). Free from manmade doctrine. No religion, but revelation and relation. To enter into peace in the heart of the Father. I am the way, the truth and the life ✝️ Religion always pushes redemption to a future event, and keeps us in separation from God. Whereas in His Spirit, we can have life and love abundantly, here and now! Amen and yes!
I luv you Rabbi..we can always count on you to brighten our life.💞☃️
May God bless you, Rabbi: you are a blessing to many.
That’s deep and makes so much sense now!! I’ve never thought about Gods needs and not my needs☺️not needy but needed!!!
...SO true and close to us we do not even realize its importance; amazing and beautiful teaching.!
I enjoyed the lecture, regards all the way from middle east, with love 🌹🙏🏼.
Wow. I'm so grateful for finding this
Sh'koiach, Rav! Great wisdom and deep understanding on the actual meaning of Judaism.
You should, I should, we should. All we do is should all over ourselves. As a sufferer of chronic pain I especially like this guys message!!!
Shalom. Great message!
Thank you Rabbi Friedman! Once again you melt away our deepest problems in a few short minutes with humor and truth giving all of us, no matter who we are and what we are going through, the clarity to move forward at whichever place we are in life. May Hashem bless you and your family with a Chasiva V’Chasima Tova with abundant good and long healthy life b’gashmius u’bruchnius in a revealed good way always! Much gratitude from one of your students 😊
This Rabbi says the same thing as I, a born again Christian. Complement to the like minded man.
What a kind and gentle teacher. Thank you.
Blessings in plenty. Shalom.
God says if you love me, you will keep my commendments. when we are in the presence of His Love than we are truly happy and that s also our strength.
@AvrahamSolomon
4 жыл бұрын
G-d Created us even knowing we would disobey Him, He has shown mercy to us and All our Generations before us. G-d Tell us if you Love Me Obey Me, well tell our children this as well. Disobedient children don't respect their Parents and don't love them, but if Kids Love this Parents then they Obey. Your Parents pay for yall your needs and then you are able to go on your own, G-d Never Stops Providing or we would all die. We should be doers not just hearers of His Laws, we are Blessed by His Laws as a Father has Laws for His Children and not others Children so this Means we our His.
@anthonygaydotcom
4 жыл бұрын
You've been brain washed well
@MrRainnes
4 жыл бұрын
Does this rabbi believe in the existence of hell. If yes, his next question would likely again be i didnt choose to be born so why this? In judaism is there the understanding of heaven and hell?
@schnitzelberry
4 жыл бұрын
@@MrRainnes We do believe in Hell, we call it "Gehinom". But we don't want to worry about that. We chose to focus more on Shamayim (Probably how you'd describe Heaven)
@arete7884
4 жыл бұрын
God didnt say shit, its human who interpret through their own frames and poison real wisdom, god is not a personality/character think of it as an infinite ocean
I really enjoy your lectures/talks.
The man does make sense. And his hat is awesome. Indy would be proud!
Rabbi Manis Friedman is really knowledgeable and he learned how to put his words what is even better, that fact makes him wise. He sees the world as I've always seen it. Since the first time I've known about him, I liked him. I've found and accepted myself through his speeches by Hashem's words.
The best jokes, if I may call them , are Jewish jokes! Your humour is intelligent. A traditional Catholic priest asks his Rabbi frien, "Rabbi, when will you ever taste a delicious pork?" The Rabbi casually responded, "Whenever your wife prepares one!"
I ❤️Manis Friedman, you are 1 in a million , your humor is outstanding and your motivation is so uplifting!
I love the surprise laughter from the back ground 😘😁
Religion teaches God don't need us, we need him. I quit being religious a few years ago. I've been a lot happier since, because I don't have to sin now to be happy.
I don't like to be needy. But to be needed is an unbearable pressure on me! And by G.D. ? I'll never be good enough 😢
Thank you, Rabbi Friedman.
Amazing! Thanks dear Rabbi!
"it used to work, it's not working" Impressive experimental observations.
So uplifting and so intelligent and so articulate...
Isaiah 45. Says, woe to those who say to their fathers: why did you made me and to their mather, why did you give birth to me?
@AvrahamSolomon
4 жыл бұрын
Asking this might be a rebellious question but we all ask why are we born, but when you reply as this Rabbi has replied you teach not just say it's wrong. You say I was not asked, my mother and father did not ask nor did Adam or Eve ask to be Created. Why are we here? Because G-d Wanted us here that's why so no one asked because no one was there too ask. Children ask a lot of questions and sometimes they ask questions we might not like but if we can turn that unwanted questions into a teaching moment that's a Gift a Gift to Teach and to Learn how to Teach so you are Blessed when your Child ask so you can Answer them.
@justaskmikey8581
3 жыл бұрын
I'm not a child an still ask,lol there is a purpose which I may not figure out, being from a 5 siblings me being last n 7yr diff from my nearest sib, I kinda was not wanted at least to me it seemed. My closest sib who I really think is my favorite of them all, well growing up wanted nothing to do with me n then they got older n moved on. I did make it up with them when I became an adult n lived near their family n a time with the family,lol. So was that a good thing? I think so! It can be a very hard time for kids an where they were in the family. First child, second child an so forth. I have done some readingvin the psychology of what this does depending on # birth order. It gave me understanding however late that it was when I found out about this. Anyway.. Thanks Rabbi - enjoy your wisdom & insight!!
I love his speach every time. He's funny and real.
Thank you for sharing your wisdom
I was closed off to Chabad thank you for opening my eyes.
@mrbond4960
4 жыл бұрын
Stay away from anything that says/goes against the Torah...
Thanks very much Rabbi!
I never met this Rabbi in person, but yet I can proudly say He is my teacher. Fine-tuning to the universal frequency and contributing to the eternal strings of music is what we were born for, We are energy so we have a frequency and all we need is to fit in harmoniously with our creator. Religion is a deviation from this simple reality, we don't need any religion. A common path that can define our role as a component of the universe is good enough.
I love it! Thank you Rabbi!
Loved this!
I found you today Rabbi thank you thank you thank you