Thanks Josh for explaining why you raise the chamfering tool. A lot of non-machinists now know.

It's little things like this that make you realize that the learning for a machinists never ends.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

I am learning everyday. You will never know it all.

@phlodel

3 ай бұрын

I've known a number of good machinists. One of the better ones used to say, "You've got to make a truckload of scrap before you're a machinist."

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

@@phlodel I've probably made 5-7 semi loads, and I am still learning. Never give up learning.

I actually learned this when I was an apprentice in the Max Planck Institute many years ago! It makes instant sense if you think about the geometry of the layout. It was good to see it explained so clearly. Thanks very much.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

I find it amazing how many people do not realize this simple concept. It is simple tool geometry.

@marctrossbach6560

3 ай бұрын

I have been by the max Planck institute!!

@BruceBoschek

3 ай бұрын

@@marctrossbach6560 There are many. I was in Tübingen.

You are effectively changing the angle between the tool and the surface being cut. Also helps with the back relief angle to not touch the internal cut.

I notice it too, but since I'm not a machinist, I assumed it was for better clearance. It is nice you take your time to explain. Regards!

I saw the video on Saturday, ask myself what you were doing, then I realized you were compensating for the internal clearances, and it all made sense. I am not a machinist, but try to learn whatever I can. You explanation was helpful and clear.

Excellent. I've seen a lot of people use a small boring bar or even an internal threading tool for inside chamfers. I guess it's what works for you is the best way. Thank you.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

Those tools are set above center. It's the same concept, just that I don't change the tool.

I have a chamfering tool set up just as you have, used it for years now. I always ground extra relief on the one side for the extra clearance needed. Your trick there is like magic. I will start using it. Thanks for the tip, Ken

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

Glad you like it. I used to grind the tools, but I got lazy and started just lifting to get above center.

@madmodder123

3 ай бұрын

@@TopperMachineLLCWork smart, not hard :)

I was wondering about that as well. I love learning stuff!

Coz I ain’t a machinist in anyway shape or form, i just went on the info and principle of keeping the tooling on centre. But always had a sneaky thought on raising the tool for internal stuff just that little bit. Hmm I might have a play around with this. Awesome and thank you!

Morning, I also wondered why the change for internal but did not ask in my reply. Being a self taught hobbyist, I assumed you had good reason and thought I would try it at some point. Thanks for the feedback to all of us.

Thanks for the video. You are a good teacher.

When I studied Turning at Technical College circa 1977, we were taught that the internal tools had to be above center exactly for the reasons you explained. With one addition, the softer the material, the higher above center the tool had to be offset, with cast aluminium and brass requiring the biggest offset. Thank you for your time explaining these quirks.

Been machining for 45 years , always grind tool to suit the job at center hieght.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

I used to do this also, but this is faster. Nothing wrong with grinding to suit the needs, I just like instant gratification. I am young after all. LOL

You’re dead right and that was well explained 👍👍👍👍

useful little tip ...or big tip depending on the size of your lathe .. thanks Josh

Josh, Great hint.....def gonna try it when I get a chance....I dont use cemented carbide hardly at all.....indexable or micro 100 stuff mostly as my parts I work on are usually small....and follow up a chamfer almost always with a quick touch of emery and a cratex polish...overcast and +44 rt now ....grass and lawn are peeking out....driveway down to stone.....YAAAAAYYYYY.... Great instructional vid for the masses...... Don

@TopperMachineLLC

4 ай бұрын

We had 62° here today. Absolutely beautiful.

Thank you Josh!

Very clear Josh, thank you so much for posting this.

Learned something this morning, Thank You

I did not know that. (Johnny Carson). Love that Lion BTW.

Makes perfect senses, Thank you.👍

I didn’t actually pick up on this first time I watched the bushing video - so went back and watched it again. Thanks for the explanation and demo - I’m going to go and experiment with this. I sometimes end up with a burr when chamfering and I bet this fixes it. 👍

@TopperMachineLLC

4 ай бұрын

It most likely will.

@StuartsShed

4 ай бұрын

It did. Result! 👍

Yeahhhh I was wondering about that ! Thank you so much for the explanation !

Great explanation thanks for sharing

Back in the early 1960 while at a technical college I was tort that. It was never explained to us, I suspect because it was not explained to them. Told to just do it. So thank you for your reading of why, it makes sense. Back in those days it was a case of 'do as you are told, not why.'

Excellent. Thank you for sharing ! 👋

Your tool height differences between ID cutting and OD cutting can be somewhat mitigated by leaving your OD tool height set and locked, but cutting in reverse, and on the opposite side of the ID for boring, chamfering, trepanning etc.

Josh, nicely presented! I appreciate and enjoy your channel

We have to raise up the chamfer tool or make aggressive clearance to avoid crashing the body of the tool

Raising the cutting tool slightly for internal turning is effectively adding positive rake to the cutting tool. Similar can be achieved by using a positive rake cutting tool on/at center. Note the cutting tooling this video is a brazed carbide zero rake tool. Negative rake tools do not really "cut". Negative rake turning tools remove metal by heating up the contact surface area/point to where the metal becomes soften (plastic) enough to be plowed away from the work. This is why negative rake tools work good when there is enough SFM, rigidity and power from the lathe. Negative rake tools are a LOT tougher, durable and able to remove metal-A-plenty compared to positive rake tools. It is also why negative rake tool don't produce a good surface finish with light cuts and due to the forces involved negative rake tools don't do well at small cuts at all. This is where positive rake tools work better, they are good at light cuts, can deliver a good surface finish, required a lot less power.. except the cutting edge is fragile. There is no ideal turning tool, just the best trade-off for a given need as much as the machine tool will allow coupled with the size of work involved.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

Thank you for this great explanation of Negative and Positive rake tooling.

Definitely works, I’ve done it often. I’ll add raising an OD tool slightly depending on the diameter and clearance angle can help with vibration on slender shafts. Use with caution and consideration.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

I have done that also, just don't recommend it for everyone.

@ellieprice363

3 ай бұрын

Resting a wooden hammer handle on top of a slender shaft while cutting reduces vibration and chatter. Only slight pressure if any is needed.

Great explanation. I like the concept of a short video which explains a detail of the longer one. Hope to see more of them.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

I plan to do this when it is feasible. Seems like it helps a lot.

That's a great tip, Josh. I'm going to try that next time I do an internal chamfer.

Thanks for the demo… I was one of the ones that asked!. The video demonstrates it very well!

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

Glad it was helpful!

Good tip..I do the same thing 👍👍

Experience is the best teacher. Not being a machinist I never even noticed you doing this but it makes a lot of sense when you explained it

Thanks

I did wonder why you did that and I did not think to ask. Thanks for explaining this so well

fantastic Josh, thank you so much for bringing this up and explaining, cheers, Paul from Florida

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

Glad you enjoyed it!

By setting the tool high, without resetting the center height nut, it allows a rapid switch to O.D. chamfer height. We do that all the time & I saw that You did that in the bushing video, it's the other 1/2 of Your trick & some might not have caught it.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

It is funny how many professionals don't do this, and are absolutely shocked that they didn't know it.

That’s a great chamfering tip. Never thought about the clearance issue. Great channel.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

Glad it was helpful!

I noticed that you were raising the tool for the internal chamfer on the last video and I was thinking that the tool post you are using makes it really easy to do that. Some older lathes don't have that type of tool post, so raising the tool for an internal chamfer is a lot more difficult, as it would involve packing under the tool. Modern conveniences sure help with simple things.

Nice.

~ I HAVE DONE uh TON OF BIG FACTORY MACHINE MACHINING ~ AND I WATCH THOSE CLOSE ON U/TUBE...AND I SEE... ~ AS THIS MAN USES HIS YEARS OF EXPERIENCE ~ APPLES IT, AS THAT IS WHAT MAKES HIM A PROFESSIONAL CRAFTSMAN !!! ~ WATCH HIM VERY CLOSE & LEARN...

I started doing it years ago working with brass. The geometry change affects how the tool deflects. At center or below any deflection causes the tool to cut into the part, above center and the geometry pulls the tool out of the part. On a worn or small machine, the deflection can cause digging in, chatter ect.

Josh your videos are very informative you know your shit

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

I don't know about that. LOL I do the best I can to get the job done correctly.

Works for a wood lathe also.

Thanks for the tip :) did you ever get a chance to watch that reverse parting tool video?

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

I did, quite interesting. I would need a different tool holder though, mine runs up at and angle.

@jetegtmeier71

3 ай бұрын

@@TopperMachineLLC yea that would cause an issue, I think his logic is sound though

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

@@jetegtmeier71 I agree, the concept has great merit.

You either have a specific tool for every conceivable job or you adapt what you have. If lifting the tool stightly for clearance saves me buying a new tool unnecessarily I'm all for it. There are many occasions where clearance is an issue, mainly internal or when trepaning, so when i see you doing it, i dont even think it unusual.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

Exactly.

Thanks for explaining that. I never knew that it made any difference as long as the tool had clearance.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

I am actually surprised by how many didn't know this. Even seasoned veterans.

@ellieprice363

3 ай бұрын

@@TopperMachineLLC A round boring tool with a 45 degree face rotated slightly will also produce a sharper chamfer due to its positive side rake.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

@@ellieprice363 Yes it will, but that is a tool change. I am going for efficiency..

@ellieprice363

3 ай бұрын

@@TopperMachineLLC Understood. Don’t change tools unless absolutely necessary. Rotating boring bars slightly away from the cut works well if the tool is already inserted. Thanks for sharing so many time saving tricks with your viewers.

I have to do the same thing on My HF mini lathe.

I have been doing that for years particularly with a boing bar. There certainly are a lot of experts out there ready to call you down.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

If they really are experts, they will try it first and try to disprove me. Amateurs will whine and complain without testing.

@bobhudson6659

3 ай бұрын

Leave the "poor" keyboard warriors alone. They have nothing else to do. Retired machinist/mechanic.@@TopperMachineLLC

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

@@bobhudson6659 I have no time for the lazy and useless keyboard warriors. They need to move out of mommy's basement and get a life. Guys like you, on the other hand, I want to talk to and learn from!!!

Learning on the job, you will find this out soon or later..

Have had to do this with some boring bars also.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

Me too. It's all in the tool geometry and being just above center in the bore.

I knew when I seen that in the last video, people would wonder. Lol

Very leery of internal grip in a jaw chuck, especially with a long part. They just don't hold like external chucking. Be safe! I have most all my chamfer tools relieved for clearance, but lifting is an easy way that also works.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

That was for demonstration only.

If it feels good, do it! Even though it's not following "convention ".

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

But it is conventional knowledge. Inside tools.above center.

On average, how much are you moving it above centerline? I am going to try this today, but it was unclear on how much. 5 thou? 20 thou? I know it will depend on the board size, but there has to be a limit , right?

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

Depends on the bore, but I generally lift 1/16-1/8". Which I think I said in the video.

That piece of tubing in the lathe scared me. I thought you were going to cut on it. Would you machine that with that much hanging past the chuck?

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

Absolutely, I do it all the time.

@phlodel

3 ай бұрын

@@TopperMachineLLC I've done a fair amount of machine work, but I guess I don't have the experience to know the limits.

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

@@phlodel with experience, comes wisdom. Maybe what i do sometimes is dumb, but it works. Take your time, never rush. Something like this can go wrong quickly, so triple check your setup and be cautious.

I always had a chamfer tool in it's own holder with the ID side ground for clearance so that I didn't have to do that...

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

Sounds like an awful waste of time to change tools so much. Being a machinist is about efficiency.

@staffordduecker665

3 ай бұрын

@@TopperMachineLLC It's always on center and takes 5 seconds to change. Machinist with forty years experience...

i've been machining sense 1985 and you are WRONG if you would grind more of a relief on the cutting side of the tool it will cut great and the smaller the part the more important it is to be on center of the part

@TopperMachineLLC

3 ай бұрын

You are the winner! First person to tell me I am wrong! Guess what, I have been doing this for 25 years. It works. Don't like it, tough!

What in darn tarnation is going on here who turned on the CGI effects? Hello,😅

@anthonyrivers8395

3 ай бұрын

The best five minutes ever spent❤.