Why are political scandals and corruption in Singapore so rare?
A series of political scandals has rocked Singapore in recent weeks, from corruption probes to inappropriate relationships among politicians. These challenges have affected the ruling party as well as the largest opposition party.
It started in May when two ministers were investigated for potential abuse of power and conflict of interests when renting government-owned colonial-era bungalows in a posh housing area along Ridout Road.
The duo was eventually cleared of wrongdoing in a probe led by Singapore’s anti-graft agency.
Shortly after the Ridout saga, Singapore Transport Minister S Iswaran and hotel tycoon Ong Beng Seng - known for bringing Formula One races to the city-state - were arrested as part of a corruption probe.
The dust from both events had barely settled when members from both the ruling People’s Action Party and the opposition Workers’ Party resigned over “inappropriate relationships.”
Felix Tan, a political analyst in Singapore, explained the brouhaha over the recent scandals: ”[Singapore is] almost a perfect exemplar for all countries to be.
“And when something like this happens, (it shows that) we’re not that perfect. We have built up that reputation. People expect us to keep up with that,” he added.
Watch the video to find out why corruption and political scandals are rare in Singapore, and what it means for the country.
#CNBC #Singapore #Politics #Corruption
-----
Subscribe: cnb.cx/2wuoARM
CNBC International TV: cnb.cx/2NGytpz
LinkedIn: / cnbc-international
TikTok: / cnbci
Facebook: / cnbcinternational
Instagram: / cnbcinternational
Threads: www.threads.net/@cnbcinternat...
Twitter: / cnbci
Пікірлер: 188
There was corruption cases in Singapore in 1979 on the NTUC Chief minister stole money (but he ran to Thailand for 46 years) and 1986 the Minister of National Development accept millions of bribes from developers.. but he commit suicide before he can go to court. there were others that opposition accused them but could not get enough evidence to prove
@vishnuyadav6508
10 ай бұрын
Llaapy
@MrBoliao98
10 ай бұрын
So what, now we got corruption investigation, the fellow gets 8.5k
@princesssupernova5300
10 ай бұрын
he commited suicide on deathrow, literally got death penalty
@jameslim3850
10 ай бұрын
suicide then no need to investigate his case already@@princesssupernova5300
@longiusaescius2537
9 ай бұрын
@princesssupernova5300 British?
You should possibly make an episode about the opposite topic. Why xx nation has so much corruption 😅
@ickysnowman
11 ай бұрын
America should be a could subject
@rangodenalo6185
11 ай бұрын
@@ickysnowmanYour mom could be the best one
@albertpangtzekaan5456
11 ай бұрын
Yes 👏 well said. @faisalmohamed3569.
@fullmetaltheorist
10 ай бұрын
@@rangodenalo6185That's crazy bro I saw your mom at the club. She was the best pole dancer.
@uwet.8826
10 ай бұрын
@@ickysnowmanyou are kidding right? How could the US has corruption problems since it simply legalised them before they become problems. Lobbying comes to my mind immediately.
No one can talk about this since government criticism is a criminal offense. Double standards indeed.
@Bella-wp7wz
5 ай бұрын
Hahaha true
@taipangwong356
2 ай бұрын
Thank you gor speaking the truth
@bell-xk5dd
Ай бұрын
Nonsense..
@matthewpeloso2172
12 күн бұрын
Agree. You have to tell people the government ti's clean or you will get in trouble and the Lee family will bankrupt your for defamation or some other frivolous claim. It doesn't matter if what you are saying is true.
Because its easier to control small population of 5m people living in a small city state.
@exelrode
10 ай бұрын
especially when you don't have free media and people can't openly criticise government or protest their reactions and there is just one party that's been in power since country got created so there is bound to be cases of misuse of power and corruption because the system of checks and balances wont work
@fullmetaltheorist
10 ай бұрын
I dunno man. Germany us doing pretty well too. It comes down to political structure and punishing corruption.
@harukrentz435
9 ай бұрын
@@fullmetaltheorist it took 20 years for germany to build an airport. Where did all the money go?
@fullmetaltheorist
9 ай бұрын
@@harukrentz435 I don't know. I'm not a German. I'm just saying that from looking at Africa it's fair to say corruption can ruin a country. The funds meant for building infrastructure are just stolen in africa and nothing gets built.
@danielloh1174
8 ай бұрын
ask yourself why Singapore rated as Top 5 the most uncorrupt country in the world?? .. there a country had smaller population & land compare with Singapore such as Turkmenistan or Monaco, population only 40K but had higher corruption rate according higher corruption index compare with Singapore, singapore was develop under very low foundation with zero resources. the late LKW able to turn Singapore into a strategic location, which made it an ideal hub for international trade and commerce, its not miracle fell from heaven
Corruption PERCEPTION Index is based on Perception and number of recorded cases right?😅
@taipangwong356
2 ай бұрын
Yes, if they are all suppressed from limelight, fewer will the known
How the Press is structured is different from that of other countries. In most countries, the Press performs investigative journalism. This is not how the Singapore Press is designed.
@duruisakaguchi1840
10 ай бұрын
Because is a democratic society the press mirrors politics maybe just that there's not so much "scandal" to report.b. Let's just have sustained development
@Thekidisalright
10 ай бұрын
Or maybe, there is nothing much to investigate since the government is clean.
@ErenYega747
9 ай бұрын
Ya and the press investigates so well that they found "weapons of mass destruction", a helpful find for the world, helped a lot of people, convinced a lot of people to do great things. Bravo!
@cooper1819
7 ай бұрын
Yes, and obviously the Press is not very effective at this, not having right authority and expertise, could hardly find themselves. Just place of whistleblower, Press just use as political vehicle.
@taipangwong356
2 ай бұрын
Your view is insightful.
It's important to have institutional checks due to the failings of men. Singapore is never immune from failures. We need checks and balances...
@scp_sixtynine4203
9 ай бұрын
Countries with checks and balances: corruption scandal every day (see US 2016 to 2020, UK 2015 to present) Country without checks and balances: Why does Singapore have so few corruption cases
This is a story about control.
@Thekidisalright
10 ай бұрын
Ya, that’s what those who are political illiterate and have zero understanding about Singapore would say. It’s common
If it was not so rare then Singapore would not be so wealthy as it has become. Same for the other countries that has become wealthy (without plentiful natural resources).
@eavyeavy2864
10 ай бұрын
Europe
@emadaseeri6227
10 ай бұрын
True, it’s cliche to say, but nice guys finish last
@exelrode
10 ай бұрын
Maybe there would be more cases of corruption that are swept under the rug because of tight media control that govt has and citizens can't just protest easily like in some other countries.
@matthewpeloso2172
4 ай бұрын
Singapore wealth is largely based on a opaque financial sector which serves is a primary place to launder money.
Correction. Singapore Prime Minister salary is capped at 2.2mil annually and not 2.2mil annually. 2.2mil includes bonus. Not every year the Prime Minister will get maximum bonus. As for Ministers their salary is likewise capped at 1.1mil annually. Same, it is depending on bonus to get 1.1mil annually.
@chaotiongsai
10 ай бұрын
No! You lie. It’s 2.2 million. Not capped at 2.2 million
@gracelim2336
10 ай бұрын
Its only half of CEO of Top Bank..
@Jack-hy2ki
9 ай бұрын
@@chaotiongsai from Google "The Salary of Singapore’s Prime Minister The benchmark salary of the prime minister of Singapore is $2,200,000 per year (including bonuses). This is twice that of an entry-level minister."
@pangswan2907
9 ай бұрын
Whatever who gets how high their salaries. Is none of our matter but really matter to them. When looking of everything's around us they are very much different too, for instance tresses'height ,buildings' height, that goes to human's pay.
@matthewpeloso2172
12 күн бұрын
This is why SG go has his wife running Temasek. So they can get more money on top of the low salaries. Same with ministers - routinely taking bribes and kick backs for the local projects run. That gives extra income on top of the salaries.
Only shows up when it can't be hidden.
@Jack-hy2ki
11 ай бұрын
Can't be hidden? U must be talking about Leon Perera and Nicole seah. Other cases all announced by the ruling party.
I envied Singapore so much, corruptions in Indonesia are so rampant, they disgusted me
@jennylee1802
10 ай бұрын
Please don't envy Singapore. Singapore is more like China.
@chaotiongsai
10 ай бұрын
@@jennylee1802True on the Authoritarianism part but China is way poorer with 99 percent of Chinese living the standard of living of Ethiopians.
@shellshockedgerman3947
10 ай бұрын
Indonesia would also have that rare case of corruption if it was a one-party state with restricted press. Be lucky that Indonesia's press is strong enough to report on corruption of the government.
May be LKY need to come back and give all one tight slap what is politically sensitivity in public service.
@GeeWhizzzz
11 ай бұрын
LKY reserved corruption for himself and his approved clique / circle. There was no social media back then. It was easier keep things hidden from the masses. He controlled the courts, judges, media, all agencies. His playbook is still in circulation.
@FunYouLeh
11 ай бұрын
He has Teh Cheamg Wan under his belt too.
@franciscody9622
11 ай бұрын
@@FunYouLeh Where did he got the poison to kill himself? Any views?
@FunYouLeh
11 ай бұрын
@@franciscody9622 Econ mini mart at Fark Chu Ave 7
@pangswan2907
9 ай бұрын
@@franciscody9622 我認死者因李光耀知道他真正有贪污的贪污局 CPIB 局长及他的成员呈上铁证逃达李光耀以及及当时总统的最终的切定 DOUBLE CONFIRM, 走頭無路,才自殺。可能死者贪的太大数目,贪的太久,以为人在做,人和天都不知道,事过太久,我们对死者有一些憐悯心❤,別在写了。
Where got rare? Quite exciting now! In any case, nobody knows when a new case is going to blow!
@Thekidisalright
10 ай бұрын
Now I understand why LKY said those who speak Singlish are losers.
To Know what We Don't know is Key. We don't know what we are not told. We don't know what we don't know. We don't know what is not known. Luckily we have State Media to keep us informed🤭
Iswaran should resign and face legal consequences
I discovered former LEE KUAN YEW had a stunning story on corruption. A famous Chinese lady interviewer asked how Singapore can make zero Anti Corruption in the country. His reply goes like this: during his office he spotted a promising officer. He promoted him Minister in charge in National Development Board. As time passed, Mr Lee received a tip from CPIB that the Officer involved into two pieces land conversion. He command CPIB to carry a firm and a decisive investigation. ......
@charliegabs
7 ай бұрын
Was he executed?
The glee in Felix Tan's demeanour is infectious. It is like throwing a rain of daggers in a Zhang YiMou epic Kungfu movie.
We are only human .. some more than others
Remain strong??? No faith in PAP… there’s no accountability and transparency at all
@1:07 -- fact check, the sexual misconducts didnt involve ministers - one was the speaker and the rest are members of parliament --
Self delusional treatment of corruption, fingerpoint neighbours
Where did you find this " political analyst"? Key reason for Singapore success in anti-corruption is " The burden of proof to rebut the presumption lies with the person." The PCA (Law) provides for a presumption where any gratification given or received by a person in the employment of the Government or of a public body is deemed corrupt. So the person must proof himself innocent. Unlikely other countries where investigators have to find the "corrupted act". So the government official just have to wear an expensive watch to be "guilty of corruption", and for him to proof source of funds.
@cooper1819
5 ай бұрын
@@DisinfoWatch Yes, I would agree with the Misuse of Drug Act, from Section 17 to 22 - "If a person possesses anything containing a controlled drug, it will be presumed that he or she possesses the drug. The individual must prove that he or she was unaware that the substance was ins his or her possession." Guilty until proven innocent. So this creates the responsibility on the individual instead of law enforcers.
It's because they enforce their laws regardless of status.
money launderer
Does lack of free press, basic freedoms and openness and transparency in the public sector have anything to do with it. What do you think? Quite sure LKY "nip-in-the- bud policy" had something to do with. He was always clear and decisive.
@franciscody9622
10 ай бұрын
@surinamesurname Don't think so the declining support for PAP indicates Singaporeans want change.
that is treason
because.. they hide it so well?
@matthewpeloso2172
4 ай бұрын
If you research you will see a lot of the money laundering scams do surface but most is hidden. There is a lot more of that going on that any report of legitimate business! Even the successful companies from SG are paying bribes to win concessions outside of SG (as well as at home).
Should report to president only… PM have party affiliation
Ask a tunnel engineer?
Errrr.... No Political Hanky Panky in Singapore..... please 😢😅😂
You call it a (Ridout) saga. I call it a hoo-ha.
@franciscody9622
11 ай бұрын
After the next GE we can put a proper label on it.
The comments, and inevitably 'highlighted reply', below answer the title question - it functions through fear and denial ...
IN SHORT IF YOU ARE IN POWER “YOUR WORD BECAME TRUTH. AND RIGHTEOUSNESS”.
Really?
Don't forget that those sweep under the thick rug.
It is not rare it is just that they cover up it so well.
@avay8726
10 ай бұрын
Wait ? Really ? I mean its singapore
Drug cartel launder money here
Not rare just well hidden and yet to be uncovered
We are still following LKY foundimg father even his President before have been replaced.
You send spy here?
Social division? Apa ini…
Because they handle it behind the closed doors
Maybe to ease sexual needs , vouchers to Geylang can be given to reduce Adultery cases?
Don't be dumb. The high salary is not only for anti-corruption. Who will work as ministers for peanuts?
@lyhs0219
10 ай бұрын
But salary even higher than USA president?
@yivunqp963
10 ай бұрын
@@lyhs0219then u get donald trump and biden as your PM and tell yourself that is the best your country can do.
@lyhs0219
10 ай бұрын
@@yivunqp963 in other countries they don't pay their ministers so much yet they don't get Biden as well
Because SG doesn't have media freedom, and the judiciary is not independent from the PAP ruling government. This means corruption is not reported to nor investigated with any rigour. In fact, if you do work in SG what you will find is that it is not what it presents itself as. It's quite corrupt.
Because singapore owns a big carpet?
One party… only
Conservative society and free market economy...
This didnt age well
Its not rare. Its just covered up
@MrBoliao98
10 ай бұрын
Mind you, we all can go reflect and see which MP stepdown quite early. Recently I found one but cannot anyhow say.
Because Singapore is so small, nobody can hide anything.
@truth4293
5 ай бұрын
Thats why they commit crimes overseas
What upheaval? What scandal? It's just flu and fever.
Sorry we vote
Small country lol and dictator😂 no democracy at all..
@zack.111
10 ай бұрын
Singapore has an election in every 5 years. So it is a democratic country.
Ban the face cover in singapore .law must be first not the islam. The Muslim did not respect the public. . Government in singapore should teach and ban
Any deviation from a clean and uncorruptible conduct that can tarnish little red dot's public services global reputation is dealt with quickly, harshly and decisively by founding father MrLKY.
There are but its well hidden
Who says there isn’t corruption 🤦🏻♂️
PM created a textbook on defamation laws. All oppositions in exile. Watch To Singapore, With Love. This is reality.
Oh sorry was I beening rude, boye for other parties and das kinder.
Singapore population is mainly Chinese (76.2% of the citizen population) according to the Singaporean census. China in a coat.
SINGAPORE is sliding downhill rapidly. Not long after Mr. Lee Kuan Yew's death, we watched the fall of the Lee KuanYew's family. Singaporeans are treated as 2nd or 3rd class citizens. Pofma is used to silence Singaporeans for speaking up. We are aware of scandals and corruptions but we are fearful of voicing out for fear of repercussions. Who will understand the immense pain and struggles that working class Singaporeans are enduring.
@BTjs321456
10 ай бұрын
Auntie Jenny, Singaporeans can speak our minds, but it does not mean anyone can start trumping-up groundless accusations, spewing slanderous remarks & expect to get away scott-free like how that attention grabbing Mr Amos who was subsequently convicted in USA for Pedophile-related charges. Pofma applies to foreigners as well, not only Singaporeans, its just that Pofma can only cover press & media under Singapore's jurisdiction where Pofma applies. I disagree with your view that "Singapore is sliding downhill rapidly" put next to "Not long after Mr. Lee Kuan Yew's death" suggesting an attempt to portray Singapore before LKY's death as being better. There appears to be epidemic scale of self-victimization delusion amongst people who enjoys lamenting that Singaporeans are 2nd or 3rd class citizens, who next give excuses of being "fearful of voicing out for fear of repercussions", in case you don't know, there is such a thing as anonymous reporting & creating new profiles/social media accounts that can be easily deleted & other more complicated masking methods to mask & hide your iP address & remain completely anonymous for you to share your accounts of scandals & corruptions, fear-free. Nobody can truly claim to totally understand anyone else "immense pain & struggles" as nobody else can truly become you, but every human being is capable of empathizing with another fellow human being pain & struggles. I wonder if your work life is really as miserable as you describe it to be? or is this not simply a hyperbolic expression of your desire to ascribe responsibility for the current plight in your life(a result of your own choices in life) unto someone or something else?(in this case the ruling Singapore government) Instead of looking outside for the change you desire in your life which you alone is responsiible for & capable of making the appropriate & necessary changes to change your life(whether you hail from working class or managerial, executives, business-owners etc. elite classes). Unless you change your mind, nobody else can convince you that you are not as powerless over your own life as you portray it to be, but you had unfortunately chosen to turn over the responsibility, failures & (also unwittingly) chances for success in your life out from your own grasp unto your imagined oppressive external entity which exist in your mind & allows you an "easy way out" to continue leading your painful struggling life. You will never be free of pains & struggles in your life if you continue to harbor the thoughts of an Aunt Agony, don't become like Mr Amos.
@ironheart5830
10 ай бұрын
As far as I know White people are first class citizens in Singapore.
@space4495
9 ай бұрын
Singaporeans are the first class citizens in Singapore as they receive more benefits and opportunities.
@keithkoganeislife3144
Ай бұрын
@@ironheart5830how? Singapore is 75% Chinese, 13% Malay, and 9% Indian. There are White people in the country, but they are so small that they are such a tiny minority. The people that are in power are the Chinese, the people who own the businesses are Chinese, and the majority of the government is Chinese.
@ironheart5830
Ай бұрын
@@keithkoganeislife3144 why I don't see white people doing blue collar work in Singapore 🤔
The isawran case on obviously means we arent paying them enough! Inflation at work you know
CORRUPT EH ?
Every citizens was shock and stunt about the transactions at Ridout. But what we get is NO WRONG DOING FOUND. There no COI to show and the public is just outrageous few words to show. Those accuse minister is still trying to treaten those with those that brought the case to light. That is treacherous.
@ivancen5020
10 ай бұрын
lol, every citizen is shocked? one thing is for sure, you are bad at math and statistics ;-)
Because if they show it, it would be bad for their image. Don't forget that they using corruption in neighbour country to make themselves rich.
Singapore is the 5th country with least corruption?!! Seriously?! I didn’t know that and expected it to be 1st!! There might be something wrong with the ranking😅
@danielloh1174
8 ай бұрын
since 70' singapore remain top 10 the most uncorrupt country in the world by CPI, its not Singapore auditor, singapore are the benevolent successful dictatorship
@faridrezaei8180
8 ай бұрын
@@danielloh1174My questions is that what are the countries that are less corrupt that SG?
@danielloh1174
8 ай бұрын
u should go and check. there several global non bias news website statita, wisevoter. do not visit any Singapore government website or pro-pap blog podcast
@danielloh1174
8 ай бұрын
@@faridrezaei8180some people say Singapore more easier to govern because of low population. but look at Turkmenistan they had same amount of population but with high corruption index, Singapore was a country developed in low foundation without nature resources but Turkmenistan had one of the largest gas and oil reserves in the world and is one of the top ten cotton producers, unlike Singapore the economic potential of Turkmenistan has not benefited the population but the Government & their country leader. Singapore corruption control efforts are effective, an improvement from 95% in 2020. for me the were 3 most important factor that contribute to the low corruption rate in Singapore, political determination heavy punishment for corruption offences and zero tolorence
@dyeen
5 ай бұрын
@daniel (A dictatorship is a government or a social situation where one person makes all the rules and decisions without input from anyone else. ) However in Singapore the policies are voted by members of the parliament after debating it and there are more than one party in the parliament. So Singapore is not ruled by dictatorship.
puih vine
Philippines could never lmaoooo
This conversation is so dumb. It’s like they are convincing each other that our country is not that bad. It might be a rich country but continues to be oppressive and dictatorial. Try to utter these words may be.
Sounds like a damage control video
OMG!! Give me a break!! Don’t forget your close cousin HK!! Both have been given away for eating FISH only....
LGBT?
CHINESE SUPREMASSY
Rare because GREAT GOVERNMENT CERSORSHIP. SG is the dirtiest in SEA. With the best coverup 🤣
@Giles20
10 ай бұрын
Bro, Singpapore is the richest in Asia and its citizens have the highest living standard. I would sacrifice some "free media" anyday if my country can get to Singapore levels.