I hope you liked that video! Ignore the snow in the background! This video totally didn't take 3 months to make!

@ogmghb1797

11 ай бұрын

I LOVE CARCENTRIC INFRASTRUCTURE!!!

@esgee3829

11 ай бұрын

@@ogmghb1797 i know me too. helps sell my yellow "SLOW" signs you put on your street. nobody outside america buys them from me tho:/

@Thelearninglouge

11 ай бұрын

Did it

@theX24968Z

11 ай бұрын

One thing you should know about the rise in suburbs is that it has a lot to do with the beginnings of the cold war and moving everything out of cities they could in fear of cities becoming targets for nukes. this was known as "defense via dispersion"

@fuyuminekimaya7571

11 ай бұрын

now try it in the netherlands

As someone from Ottawa, when you said Ottawa was your test city my heart sank on your behalf. No one deserves Ottawa public transit.

@PhaythGaming

11 ай бұрын

Nor how spread out it is as a walker.

@Liddell2675

11 ай бұрын

Agreed….

@shiaraspittall979

11 ай бұрын

I clicked on the video because I saw what looked like the LRT and had to see how much they struggled

@Mir-gw6kj

11 ай бұрын

@@PhaythGaming 15 minutes by car, 1 hour 15 minutes on foot, at least in the suburbs where I'm from 😂

@PhaythGaming

11 ай бұрын

@@Mir-gw6kj same lmao. I can get to work in 5 minutes by car, 20 minutes by bus, 45 on foot ahaha

Finally more pro walkability content. This is the most important crisis in American society. Obesity? Cars. Climate change? Cars. Social isolation and corporate consolidation? Cars.

@MC-wh3xm

11 ай бұрын

Lol yes, having the freedom of movement means isolation. Go ride on an NYC subway and you can have a Michael Jackson impersonator push you onto the tracks.

@Purplesquigglystripe

11 ай бұрын

Even economic and racial inequality can be linked to car dependency

@whoisthatkidd2212

11 ай бұрын

also the housing crisis is fundamentally being driven by car dependency as parking lots and roadways chew up so much of the public space that it becomes difficult to build more houses and the amount of housing that is within a short distance of jobs and amenities is very limited because of exclusionary zoning.

@Miles26545

11 ай бұрын

@@MC-wh3xmyou can just ride a bike in nyc, and they only show the crazy cars, nobody uploads the normal ones

@MC-wh3xm

11 ай бұрын

​@@Purplesquigglystripe my first car cost me 600 dollars. You people are beyond parody.

It just occurred to me: when the city's trains or buses break down, the city has to pay for those repairs. When a private citizen's car breaks down, that citizen has to pay for it. The costs being pushed onto consumers instead of cities may be why so few cities stick with public transportation. (or at least another contributing factor)

@cordeliaface

8 ай бұрын

Not to mention, when a city has to pay for it, it comes from tax dollars. People don't want to pay for that out of their taxes, they'd rather pay for it out of their own pocket, for...whatever reason ("I don't use public transit, so why am I paying for it?" "I can afford car repairs, everyone else should, too," etc.) On a similar note - how often does the average consumer replace their car vs. how often does the average city replace public transit vehicles? I remember thinking touch screens were terrible based on my experience in retail stores who install touch screens and never go back to update the infrastructure, so the touch screen eventually becomes borderline unusable, but since it's still usable, it's still there. Meanwhile, I get a new smart phone every 3-5 years, so I don't have problems with that particular touch screen.

@Avenlane

8 ай бұрын

@Reishadowen: Absolutely correct and I agree 100%

@damienbaca3806

8 ай бұрын

Sure but the way cities, public transport, and really all places in NA are designed, most people wouldn't ride public transit even if it cost nothing. And since cars are mandatory in NA, any cost of public transport is on top of paying for a car that you decided not to use.

@hfjnvnlucas

7 ай бұрын

I mean, the city still has to somewhat take care of the highways, even when parts of the system are maintained by private companies. Seems highly unlikely that the money saved from not repairing citizen's cars would outweigh the money coming from ticket revenue and on-station commerce. Plus wouldn't the ticket fares take that into account already?

@chaosXP3RT

7 ай бұрын

It's for the same reason that Home Owner Associations exist. The city doesn't have to pay for repairs, the HOA does

One thing I value about being able to take the train to work rather than driving, is that driving can be stressful, and requires focus. Whereas on the train I can read or play on my phone until my stop.

@valdir7426

6 ай бұрын

yes; that is a very good reason. driving is a bigger mental load than work (for me); I'd rather chill in the subway than being honked for failing to move one nanosecond after the light got to green.

@Another_AR

Ай бұрын

yes you point out

@jacobharris5894

Ай бұрын

Exactly. When I went to ASU it was about a 15 minute drive from my house or a 40 minute drive by bus. If I wasn’t in a hurry or rushing I usually didn’t care how slow it was because I could study or zone out for 40 minutes. It still would have been nice if it was faster and more reliable though.

@commandantkevin

29 күн бұрын

For me it is the other way arround. In the netherlands trains and metro's are delayed fairly often or dont stick to their schedule. The defects and delays arent always listed on their website. The metro rides in 10 minute intervals the train in 30 minutes. Meaning that i get delayed 10 minutes at the minimum if the track has a defect it can rise to half an hour. In my experience people in the netherlands are more lenient when coming to late because of a traffic jam because those are fairly consistent here they usually cause a 5 to 15 minute delay. When coming half an hour to late because of pt they say "should have planned better". Only reason why i use it is because the government made it free for students (you do built up a debt but it gets removed if you get your diploma within 10 years otherwise you get to pay) and it is hell to find parking spots in rotterdam.

@commandantkevin

29 күн бұрын

Just to clarify, pt is more stresfull for me because i cant depend on it to get me on time. I can read or play on my phone but that would end it up draining my phone to much. I usually study a bit in the metro but most of the time I dont have anything to do in the metro as i ride it for 2 hours a day.

I can always get behind more public transit content! 🎉

@fairyflossgurlz

11 ай бұрын

Reece, love your channel! was surprised to see you on here!

@yeeterofannoyingpeople4003

11 ай бұрын

There’s no way

@yeeterofannoyingpeople4003

11 ай бұрын

They must have the noti bell on

@SebastianD334

11 ай бұрын

Glad to see your cameo in here!

@JerkWarlord

11 ай бұрын

YOU'RE HERE! I WAS GONNA SAY THEY SHOULD COLLAB WITH RMTRANSIT. I'm actually gonna watch the video now haha brb

One thing not mentioned in this video is the "last mile" problem with public transit. Even if you have a reliable, fast train, if you live more than a mile from the station, it can be a pain to get to the station. A 20 minute walk at either end of a transit commute adds a lot of time onto a journey. That's why density around transit stations is super important

@JaccoSW

10 ай бұрын

True but it's also why virtually any train station in the netherlands has bicycles you can rent. It will easily change that 1 hour walk into 20 mins or even less by bike.

@MisakaMikotoDesu

10 ай бұрын

That's why busses exist. In Europe you just wait at a stop and get one to the station every 5-10 minutes.

@uis246

10 ай бұрын

That is what bus for. Altenatively you can bring something like e-scooter with you.

@sunglassesemojis

10 ай бұрын

@@MisakaMikotoDesu Unfortunately for most people in US, even living in a mid sized or large city, the bus stop (if a bus even exists at all) may be a long walk away and only comes every 30 or 40 minutes. You're considered lucky if you're on a route with 20 minute frequencies. Busses are so inconvenient and frequently cancelled or late that in my city they are only used by people with no other options. Not because they are a convenient or fast way to get around.

@codybaker1150

10 ай бұрын

I love trains. Like as a hobby. I wish we had better public transit in the US, I do. But I live in a rural, low population area. There is no bus coming to take me to a train. Ever. And in the terrain I live in bikes are near impossible to ride. Unfortunately, I would have to use my car to get to a train or bus. And by then I'm already in my car that I am still paying for, so I might as well take it all the way. It's the same issue with China's "trains to nowhere" that they keep paying for with taxpayer dollars so they don't have to admit they were a really misguided idea.

I remember planning to go to the beach with my friends and thinking "I wonder if we could take a train near there". I looked it up and it woulda taken 7 hours compared to an hour drive.

@Thezors

4 ай бұрын

This. My commute to work by car is 45 minutes one way, if I took the train, it would be 2 hours and 15 minutes one way. I also live in northern NJ in the United States where most of our public transit is directed to NYC. There are times you have to make a stop in NYC to go back into other parts of NJ. It’s very time consuming.

@ethanjohnson2849

3 ай бұрын

You live in New York?

@RockR277

3 ай бұрын

@@ethanjohnson2849 California

@BreadFred3

Ай бұрын

I take the bus for quick visits among a major road or on a long trip. Might take me 15-20-30 minutes more to get there but it saves me gas and wear-n-tear on my car.

@hopegate9620

Ай бұрын

Interesting! I live in France, where public transportation is well developed, so it's almost always faster to take a combination of trams/the subway/trains/buses. Particularly in a city I used to live in (Montpellier), since the local government there is actively trying to make driving harder so that people take public transportation instead (which is completely free for residents).

In North America, a lot of people think that using cars is the only option Outside of North America, using car is like the last option

@junovzla

2 ай бұрын

I live in Venezuela and public transit here is fucking terrible, but nonetheless it's soooo much better than taking a private car (mostly because of the prices, but I'm sure if our country was in a better place economically cars would be a terrible idea). In my 19 years of life I've only amounted to like less than a week total of driving in a private car (never in the driver's seat of course), everything important is within walking distance, and if it isn't you can take a bus, some cities even have metro trains.

@solumi413

2 ай бұрын

It's a culture shock to realize that everything is very far away in American cities and that you're going to need a car. when in other cities in the world you can walk to certain places where you find essential things.

@MichaelRay380

2 ай бұрын

I'm a 19 year old American, I've owned a car for 4 years that I have exclusively used for transport anywhere, including for groceries, for that entire time. I was considering taking the train to the US capital, which is 200 miles away, but it is 3 times as expensive as driving due to how our government runs its public railways and the cost of tickets. Buses here are also more expensive than driving the equivalent distance in a car and you'd be lucky if they actually get you close to your destination at all unless you live and work in the city center and go nowhere else.@@junovzla

@TheMcgeeOG

29 күн бұрын

i mean crime happens more around public transportation

@justaloserrr

28 күн бұрын

Yeah, plus in our south Asia we have CNG, Auto, Rickshaw. Those are our best public transit

So many American cities would just fail the walking test because highways literally block off paths. It’s also notable that places that have reliable public transport are also the most walkable, so it’s always a choice between one mode (driving) and multiple modes (walking, biking, trains, buses, subways)

@philnik777

11 ай бұрын

I don't think it's necessarily a choice between the two. It's just that when you have proper public transport, it leads to fewer people using cars, which results in less space being required by roads, which in turn leads to denser cities which are easier to walk/bike/etc. This leads to fewer people using public transport for everything, reducing the load on it, which again makes it possible to build denser cities. You can still have cars and you need roads for emergency services anyways.

@BlueBeeMCMLXI

11 ай бұрын

do highways literally block off paths, or do highways block off paths?

@kingmaf3677

11 ай бұрын

thats what i was thinking the entire time, if you drive you cant really do anything else its just cars and maybe a bit of walking. but all other forms of transit work together, you can bike walk and use public transit together. improving one usually improves the others aswell or atlesast it doesnt cause problems, but supporting cars always supresses other forms of transit.

@truedarklander

11 ай бұрын

​@@philnik777 I mean the choice is in how you plan the city. Money that doesn't go to transit and instead to highways is a choice being made here

@elenakalliste

11 ай бұрын

@@philnik777 it’s a big picture city planning choice that is the difference between NYC and Dallas. People will do whatever is most convenient, but there are places where walking is not a reasonable choice and there are places where public transport simply doesn’t exist in any meaningful at that eliminates the need to have a car.

Some more things to consider: 1. Another option: bikes with safe infrastructure! Just look towards the Netherlands for inspiration. 2. When you're driving in a car, you can only drive (and maybe listen to music). On a train, you can write on a computer, read a book, read textbooks, watch videos, etc. Imagine if you could be on trains for 2 hours rather than in your car driving!

@shishlinsv

11 ай бұрын

If you are Canadian, you should look at Finland's bike infrastructure. Climate does (not) matter!

@netfelixmusic

11 ай бұрын

Average dutch person trying to flex their public transit system.

@anubizz3

11 ай бұрын

Another Netherlands worshiper...... You aware Netherlands have 588 car per 1000 people? And Singapore and Hong Kong have 140 and 100? You want to lessen car dependancy but chooses to follow the country that fail to do so..... TOD and public transport always the answer... Please if you want to follow Netherlands at least they the best country for biking in Europe? Ups no it's Denmark...... 😂 So they fail on reducing their car dependancy aside from downtown core, fail to build excellent public transport, and even fail to become the best cyclist country.... In flat tiny country with 3 of their big city next to each other...... What a country to follow. 😂

@meretoi

11 ай бұрын

As soon as they said they were going to Ottawa I laughed and texted all my friends... THEN THEY SAID IT WAS THE DAY THAT BIDEN WAS IN TOWN AND I ROFLMAO

@laurabowles

11 ай бұрын

Bikes may be great for some people but they don't work for the disabled. It also still forces you to be out in the elements.

As someone from Hong Kong, one of the world’s most densely populated cities and home to one of the greatest public transit systems in the world, this video taught me A LOT. So thank you for enlightening me! It’s very true that trust in the system is important for the success of public transit. If a system is not reliable, nobody will take it to get to where they want to go. It’s importance and impacts are clearly reflected in Hong Kong, because the trains here (the most popular mode of public transit available) arrive at stations punctually 99.99% of the time, and if it isn’t, the corporation pays a huge fine. That’s how you ensure accountability and reliability. Everyone knows the metro is reliable, and thus they like taking it.

@defaultnano

Ай бұрын

we love the mtr here 😍😍

The problem with this is that they were all pretty popular locations to travel to but didn't account for where people actually live. I live on the edge of Ottawa and what is a 20-30 minute commute by car to downtown becomes an hour as soon as you introduce a connection into the transit trip.

@Alby_Torino

2 ай бұрын

This is just because the way North American cities are built. I live in a 4800 people village south of Turin, northwestern Italy and to get in the exact center of Turin I need 25 minutes by train and 50 minutes by car. And Yes There's a train station in a 4800 people tiny village.

@junovzla

2 ай бұрын

Yeah that's just because North American cities are horribly designed.

As an American, the lack of public transit options is dismaying to me. It was never really something I thought about until I was trying to find a way to visit my grandparents without a car. I finally found a rail connection, and it really impressed me. The train was so much cheaper, comfortable, and convenient compared to taking a plane, only at the expense of time it took to reach my destination. A total overhaul of our transit system is absolutely necessary.

@GTAVictor9128

11 ай бұрын

As someone who has been living in Ireland for over 10 years, I recently had a short trip to Reus, Tarragona Barcelona, and Madrid. Coming from Ireland that has completely dysfunctional trains, the frequency of regional trains felt like luxury. In the city, it was the first time in my life riding the metro. Missed one? No worries, the next one will be in 3 minutes. And to go from Barcelona to Madrid, it was also the first time in my life riding a high speed train. The journey from Barcelona to Madrid was ~600 km and it took ~2 hrs at an average speed of just under 300 km/h. Then when I returned to Ireland, it took me 2 hrs 30 minutes to travel a distance of ~200 km by bus. Now you see why even a simple regional train felt like such luxury to me.

@stevefl7175

11 ай бұрын

As an American, it's nice having a good public transit (I grew up in NY), but even there you sometimes wanted a car unless you lived in Manhattan and didn't leave the city much. Of course, the train is cheaper because it's subsidized. In cities, it's often subsidized by the cars (like NY, where the Transit Authority gets a lot of money from bridge and road tolls which are for more then needed to maintain them). I'm curious though what train you took that is much cheaper then a plane, as Amtrak can be quite expensive.

@bobbirdsong6825

11 ай бұрын

@@stevefl7175 just a small correction, usually car infrastructure is much more expensive in terms of maintenance and due to the number of cars people drive in this country we also federally subsidize cars far more than any other form of transportation. additionally places that don't have good transit and walkability usually suffer from insolvency as things are too sparse and the land use is too inefficient for businesses to pay enough taxes for small towns to keep up with the maintenance of car infrastructure that was likely paid for by the federal government decades ago when no one was thinking about who would be repairing all the potholes and side streets in the future.

@stevefl7175

11 ай бұрын

@@bobbirdsong6825 most of the maintenance needed on roads isn’t because of cars. It’s because of trucks. Trucks cause far more wear and tear on roads then cars do. This is how most goods are shipped outside of long distances. The second part is the weather, particularly the freezing and thawing cycle which cracks the roads and caused potholes. Small towns generally don’t have public transit anyway. You need a certain density to make Publix transit work. Sure there may be a bus that runs down the main route but that’s about it. Name one Publix transportation that pays for itself with its fares. It’s zero, none of them do. Heck in some places it’s free. The entire Publix transit in some places are subsidized. For cars, the federal gas tax pays for some of it. In large cities tolls, taxes and fees pay for a portion of it. Public transit is only for the commuter, while roads are vital for commercial goods to be moved around as well.

@bobbirdsong6825

11 ай бұрын

@@stevefl7175 Of course public transit doesn't pay for itself, it's a public service. If anything the ideal transit service is free, as access to transportation is the most important factor in income mobility. And I'm not just saying that keeping highways up is expensive. Those need to be there. It's all of the sidestreets and parking lots that make modern suburbia a sea of asphalt that's expensive, because like you said, it deteriorates with weather. Meanwhile when I was living in Japan I could get to downtown Tokyo in an hour for less than $7. I don't think you can travel 50 kilometers that fast and cheap anywhere in the US using transit. And Japan has truck reliant goods shipping too! Go figure.

The great thing about public transit is you can condition the new generation, at an early age, to have a taste of freedom without having to rely of their parents to go around the city. As you start in early age, you will tend to be more supportive of projects to improve infrastructure and innovation.

@CvnDqnrU

11 ай бұрын

"you can condition the new generation, at an early age, to have a taste of freedom "

@am_Nein

11 ай бұрын

​@@CvnDqnrUthat's what they said.

@blahalujza

11 ай бұрын

Exactly. My eldest is 11, and he's absolutely empowered by the fact that he can get to places on his own.

@gudeandi

11 ай бұрын

I kinda disagree. I grew up in an area in germany that had pretty good public transport. Even now living in a bigger city with a even better and more dense public transport area i prefer taking the electric car. Because I'm way more flexible, can reach more specific points and have a way higher comfort (i'm looking at you Bus 6 in a hot summer). So my friends and I always had a good public transport system around us but still after all that years... i wouldn't take if. It's even more expensive (in my case).

@benas_st

11 ай бұрын

@@gudeandi Right but you're an adult, they were talking about kids being able to just go places, without needing a license or car or anything. Just a ticket:)

I think one piece that would enhance the race between the 3 of you and the comparison between modes of transport is biking as the "active" transport. I bike for commuting and groceries, and I also drive. On occasion biking is way faster than driving because traffic isn't a problem, and I retain a lot of the freedom of walking (can stop at a cafe out of the blue) and parking is barely a problem. It's my favorite mode of transport.

@solangecossette1374

4 ай бұрын

Another advantage of bikimg or taking active tramsport, is that you can discount part of that time as exercise you should be doing on a daily basis to keep healthy. Not-just-bikes did a great video called "the gym of life" that examined this. For exampke - say your bike commute to work is 45 minutes - whereas by car, it is 15. At first, one might think "hey, that quite ridiculous, I wil just drive to save time". And you wpuld be right... However, if you take your bike, you have essentially done 1 hour and 30 minutes of daily exercise. If you drive, you now have to make up that lost exercise time somewhere in your daily schedule. The argument becomes even stronger the closer the two times meet. After I get home from biking to work, I can just plop down and play "Dave the Diver" without qorrying about my daily exercise quota. Users of publix transit systems can experience something similar - if the stops are within reasonable walking distances. Walking is good for you, and they equally xan plop down and attempt another Hades run at 32 heat.

@zage932

4 ай бұрын

Haha one piece 😄

@avobananaa

2 ай бұрын

hmm. id love to bike more often but im just worried about mine getting stolen or something haha

While I was in Japan, korea, Curitiba and Mozambique, public transit was great; in SF, NY and other high-crime areas, you're routinely met with unruly behavior, unsanitary conditions, drug use, robberies and fights. The social element has always been the strongest detractor for public transportation for me and others who have to worry about their immediate safety.

@briansmith48

8 ай бұрын

Exactly 👍 💯

@Toribell1928

7 ай бұрын

Yeah I live in Japan now and use public transit but when I lived in the US every time I talked about using public transport literally everyone around me protested. There was so much crime on them, it wasn’t worth it.

@user-nj5st3ho9t

7 ай бұрын

Yeah, if you live in Tokyo, you do not need car at all. I do not use public transportation in United States, but I used the public transportation in Houston recently, and it was not bad when I moved from downtown to airport.

@vulcanfeline

7 ай бұрын

i went to visit some friends in toronto 30+ yrs ago and just took for subway. they were gobsmacked that i would dare to go "down there"

@mehp_

7 ай бұрын

i agree! i live in the suburbs of my city but i've not once considered using public transportation when visiting downtown because i'd feel very unsafe! safety and comfort are very big when it comes to the mutual trust needed for successful public transport

"Just because there's a place I CAN walk, doesn't mean it's walkable" THIS SO MUCH!!! Also the fear of getting hit by a car, I've literally walked somewhere, waited like 5 minutes for a car to actually pull out of a driveway, and the moment they finally decide to move? I WAS LITERALLY RIGHT IN FRONT OF THEIR BUMPER!

@iminacult1636

11 ай бұрын

Same! I've been almost hit by parked cars that go in reverse. I'm like dude, aren't you supposed to pay attention to everything?

@nox6687

11 ай бұрын

If the car was an SUV, they literally may not have been able to see you. SUVs have a big frontal blind spot that blocks the view directly in front of the car.

@railroadforest30

11 ай бұрын

Same

@KB-ke3fi

11 ай бұрын

Try getting hit by a train. That happens a lot.

@chaotickreg7024

11 ай бұрын

​@@KB-ke3fiTry getting hit by a car. It happens next to trains a lot.

The thing about public transit is that the more of it you have, the better it is. If the network is denser, you can go alternate routes. If the network is used, frequency of vehicles increases... You should be at the point where getting to the stop means at most five minutes of a pleasant walk (because more trams, less cars), then a short wait for a tram and then a short walk to the destination... In other words, it's effective at scale, whereas cars are the exact opposite.

@perfectallycromulent

11 ай бұрын

whether a walk is pleasant or not depends on the weather. even 30 seconds in pouring rain will make wet for a long time, and cities like Chicago get to 100 degrees in the summer and down to less than 0 in the winter.

@QualityGarbage

11 ай бұрын

@@perfectallycromulent And yet the Chicagoans continue to use it,,, The train is not a bad place to be, even if it's raining, snowing or 90 degrees out. Many of the stops are heated in the winters, and it's still better than sitting in traffic or driving in hazardous conditions with everyone else (also, umbrellas and coats are a thing. People are used to weather existing, and not everyone owns a garage. (The Dibs system is proof of that))

@beactivebehappy9894

11 ай бұрын

@@QualityGarbage yes a lot of benefits for some minor inconveniences. People in the US act so privileged that even rain makes them feel humbled

@paulcarter476

11 ай бұрын

Betcha they enforce open drug use on trains. Come to Seattle and experience local drug users and rabble rousers on just about every ride!

@churblefurbles

11 ай бұрын

People are free to move to live in a pod, talk is cheap on progressive channels, revealed preferences say otherwise.

I cannot believe how incredibly well-produced and well-paced this video is - Sabrina is so clever and funny! The method used to demonstrate the various pros and cons with each transport mode was genuinely enlightening and fun to watch. It also had the perfect amount of history and background context. Thank you for putting the time and effort to make such an outstanding piece of work, from a public transport fanatic in Aotearoa New Zealand :)

Having spent all of my life living in small towns or small "cities," where the closest thing you'll find to public transit is a very limited bus schedule, this whole video was such an alien concept to me. Like I'm learning about a new culture. 😆

@mgailp

5 ай бұрын

Same here. My town and it's neighbor just got a grant and started their public bus route about 6 years ago. (I use the singular in a literal manner - each town has one bus and a single route with one shared stop at the hospital so you can change between them.) Being legaly blind, I will never drive again, but said bus route's closest stop is almost a mile from my home and there is no sidewalk between here and there. I desperately wish public transport was an option, as I have to inconvenience friends to get anywhere.

@scorinth

4 ай бұрын

Some time ago, my dad described to me the streetcars of Des Moines, Iowa. _Des Moines._ DES MOINES HAD FUNCTIONING STREETCARS UNTIL THE '50s!

@stingrae919

3 ай бұрын

Me too. The town I live in used to have a train running through it and to the big city that’s like 30 miles away for decades until they closed it when cars became really popular. Now I have to drive my car for a stupid amount of time everyday because the only public transportation that comes in is at a bus stop a 40 minute walk from my house where the bus comes maybe 4 times a day. And I live in a fairly big town too (a population of like 5000)

I love how Sabrina went through all the same stages and realizations about how awful our transit system is in Ottawa. I was giggling the entire time.

@christophkallab2540

11 ай бұрын

Hey, I'm an Austrian watching this video and your transit system is shockingly confusing I'm not even surprised that no one's using it when it's basically "take a guess and if you're wrong you messed up good" In Europe it is a lot more streamlined - Google Maps always tells you where to go and screens all over the stations (and ticket stations where you buy your ticket) tell you where to go If you don't want to look up you can even download specific apps (in Austria it's the "ÖBB" app) that not only tell you the place but also the exact spot you have to stand at - you can also buy tickets through the app and that's not even going into the prices - a daily pass is 11 bucks?! that's nuts - one daily pass in Austria is like 4-5 Also - there are A LOT of choices - so if you don't want to go by train just take the bus or vice versa - or if you miss one it isn't going to take long for the next to arrive/take an alternative

@katiemutschler6040

10 ай бұрын

I just got a job and they asked me if I could into Orleans and I said "I would prefer not to because I don't have a car" and they told me that people bus in all the time. HOW Anyways I was born in regina and the transit in Ottawa is better. I was shocked to see it ran on Sundays and past 8pm Also Google maps will give me such obscure paths with 5 transfers and then all of a sudden I realize I can just reduce transfers to walk 10 minutes by taking away 2 stops at the end. But still. Way better than Regina

Something that so many people forget when it comes to transport is that no single form of transport is one-size-fits all because they all serve different types of journeys. An infrastructure system isn't just trains or buses or planes or cars or public footpaths but the *collection* of all methods of transport. When people find it easy to get around, it's not because the trains or buses are good but because all the different forms of infrastructure work to complement each other. That's what's missing in most American cities.

@impishDullahan

11 ай бұрын

This is what I miss about European transit systems (my experience is mostly Belgian, mind): stations are hubs for both trains and busses/trams, which effectively turns nearly all bus/tram lines into collectors for the trains. Meanwhile, in my experience in North America, you often need a car to get to the train stations where they exist to begin with, at which point you might as well keep on driving.

@foul-fortune-feline

11 ай бұрын

Generally less cars means more everything good and less everything bad is the thing

@felidae1975

11 ай бұрын

And nit forget the bike. You can ride a Train with it. Sometomes with an extra Ticket. You are nearly as flexible as by walking and most of the time as fast as a car in the city.

@nicholasdean3467

11 ай бұрын

To bad most North American cities are way to sprawling for public transit. No point of a bus or train if you have to walk/drive over an hour away. With every single person having an acre of land.

@41052

11 ай бұрын

@@felidae1975please I just want to bike/scooter everywhere but the bike lanes 😭

I LOVE cars and driving!! Having said that, when I lived in Washington DC in the 1990’s, I learned that their public transportation system is THE way to go! This experience was bolstered when I later visited London, England and used their integrated system. I will enjoy driving till the day I die, but will always choose public transit when the options are available….

@crishnaholmes7730

5 ай бұрын

Are you still in America

@TeganCantEven

5 ай бұрын

I found my people 🤣

I grew up in Milan, which has the most developed public transportation in Italy (a lot of lines that except for sunday you usually wait for max 10 minutes), and honestly even when car or walking (italy is a very walkable country) are an option I always preferred to use public transportation, because I get to read or listen to music or watch stuff or even studying, which is something I can't do walking or driving. Plus, in Milan everyone is used to taking public transportation and because of that you learn how to get around since you're a child (cause maybe you're going somewhere with your parents) and that also allows you to learn very quickly how to use public transportation even in other cities! so yeah i'm just sayin that to me the north america issue is that people are just not used to it and don't even think of it as an option, while it's actually a pretty great solution

One of the best things about public transit for me is the ability to take advantage of transit time. You can’t get anything done while you’re walking or driving, but you can totally finish that one late assignment on a long bus route or train ride. It just makes me feel more productive and even if I don’t work it allows me time to just wake up or otherwise relax without having to think too much

@timkom2289

10 ай бұрын

You dont even have to be really productive. Even just reading news or playing sudoku is still much better use of time than being fully focused on road.

@bonumonu5534

9 ай бұрын

Literally. More time being brain dead for me every day!

@willis7404

9 ай бұрын

So true, I’ve read so much more since taking public transit for my work commute.

@lourainevillalon3852

9 ай бұрын

true, i always commute with (e-jeepneys), they're like minibuses. my travel time is actually 1 hour and 30 minutes up to 2 hours and they are airconditioned. And if you're lucky you can choose to sit on the good seat (i prefer to be near steel handles for support). i mostly use my transit time for catching up for reviewers and tutorials whenever our exams are near. it's also really good for the brain when you can be able to process incoming information while on a busy platform (commuters come and go from point to point). I also take that transit time to good use to sleep whenever i'm pulling off all nighters. it's a real game changer for all types of passengers and mostly students. it's cheap, it's reliable, and it doesn't take too much of your energy (all you have to do is walk between stops)

@vogeline_

9 ай бұрын

walking is a great exercise though

I'm in the U.S. Army & i was stationed in Camp Humphreys South Korea, & the Public transit(Trains,buses) were excellent they were on time & clean, also i went to Japan,Thailand & Malaysia & had the same experience. I thought multiple times " why America doesn't invest in their public Transit like this?"

@sexychobit86

11 ай бұрын

Lived in South Korea as well. The public transit is the bees knees!

@Alex-ug9wx

11 ай бұрын

Honestly? They probably can’t afford it. Between intervening in pointless wars and bringing “freedom” to other countries and paying their politicians a shitload, they probably can’t afford it. A good portion of Americans will tell you they can though… because ‘murica better and richer than Europe or Asia… It’s honestly frightening just HOW many things the US could do better by JUST following what their other allies do. I suppose it’s a Fahrenheit-Celsius situation though, in the fact that they just wanna be different.

@seanthe100

11 ай бұрын

Maybe to maintain a dynamic economy, the economy of SK is pathetic it's the same for all the public transit countries

@Nevir202

11 ай бұрын

Kinda a silly comparison to make. Ya, public transport in Japan is great IF you are staying only in the cities or moving between them. Anywhere else? You're gonna have to take a car anyway. Most of the US isn't urban centers, so...

@jintsuubest9331

11 ай бұрын

@@Nevir202 US couldn't even manage city transit or inter city transit. Most people in US work in city but their only option is to drive 90minutes t their work place every day.

Public transport is a lot more appealing when it goes to places you actually want to go. In the US, you end up getting only a couple lives that don't cover the cities they serve very well and stations tend to be in either in slums or massive parking lots with nowhere you want to go nearby. Option 2 is that the stations are in boutique neighborhoods that most people couldn't afford anyways.

Watching your videos lifts my mood so much, thank you. I'd still argue there is an uncomfortable thing about driving - the psychological stress of being on the road. Other drivers creating unexpected situations, traffic jams, trying to squeeze the car into the line every time you can and not to break the rules at the same time... I personally think it's a big problem.

Coming from the Netherlands and now living in Stockholm I can confidently say that public transport is at its best when its frequent. Even when busses or subways aren't on time, it doesn't really matter if you know another is going to be there within 5 to 10 minutes. Most of the time when I choose to take public transport I don't even check departure times because of this. Combine this with walkability and good bicycle infrastructure and you don't need a car. There are times when cars are simply more convenient (e.g. when going to more remote places), but being able to choose not to have a car, and not being limited by that choice, is adding to my quality of life. Side point: I visited South Korea last year and it felt like they perfected public transport. I didn't speak Korean, and never got lost due to how standardized the design of the infrastructure is (at least in the subways). Hell, I never even took the wrong exit - something that does still happen to me here in Stockholm after living here for over two years.

@Greenhoody176

11 ай бұрын

Was in South Korea last month and I have opposit opinion. You never now, on some lines, on which metro station you will end up, because metro lines have forks and it isn't marked for foreigners in any way if train is gonna turn left or right. Yu have only information about next station not the end station. Every second day, i had to use uber because train turned left on the fork instead of right.

@perrondenais684

10 ай бұрын

Great point, frequency and understandability allow you to make a transit trip happen on a whim and with no planning. Being able to do so without planning is key to staying competitive with driving and walking

@SaplinGuy

10 ай бұрын

While living in and travelling in Japan, one thing I LOVED about the subway stations was that the exits were numbered! So when using Google Maps to go somewhere, it would tell me to go to the station, take this and this line, then get out from exit 4, and I wouldn't have to cross any intersections! Also very convenient when meeting up with friends, to meet at that station's exit X

@uis246

10 ай бұрын

I think for going to remote places trains are more convenient.

@uis246

10 ай бұрын

​@@SaplinGuySame for Moscow. Exits are numbered.

Earlier this year, I (a Brit, who lives near London, does not drive and is very used to getting public transport) was in Dallas, and I wanted to use public transit the best I could. This resulted in a lot of giving up in frustration and ordering a Lyft instead, but my favourite was when I was trying to get back to the airport to go home, triple-checked the bus route, waited at the bus stop for 10 mins... and watched the bus I was supposed to take drive right past me at about 40MPH, two lanes over, with clearly zero intention of stopping. America pls ;___;

@kb_100

11 ай бұрын

Travelling in the US is really shocking. You're forced to rent a car otherwise you're completely stranded. Luckily I only travel there for work so I don't have to pay those expenses myself.

@oogabooga517

11 ай бұрын

You try to cross the street here and get flattened by a Ford F-150 😭

@giselleo5976

11 ай бұрын

Oof come to the California bay area next time!! Much better public transit than Texas and prettier than New York City

@m4rcyonstation93

11 ай бұрын

@@kb_100god i love freedom amirite

@FalconFlurry

11 ай бұрын

The bus driver was like: "Ew, a passenger?? I don't wanna pull over, I'll just pretend that's not my route" lol

I love you guys so much. As a budding urban planner, this video was great. Love the team too

KZread's been recommending me this video ever since it premiered and I finally watched it. It was delightful!

Lmao, as an Ottawa public transit user who regularly had two hour commutes, I CACKLED throughout the entire public transit section. Our system is truly hell and breaks more often than it runs.

@vigilantcosmicpenguin8721

11 ай бұрын

After watching the video I feel so sorry for you.

@LJ.613

10 ай бұрын

That just isnt true. Its had some very high profile breakdowns, but its runtime is still well over 90%. Hardly good enough still

@SolidSt8Dj

10 ай бұрын

The busses are shit but the train is legitimately excellent. A few high profile issues pales in contrast to the 99.9% of uptime the train has

I'm an Ottawa native and I revel in your suffering from our absolutely terrible transit and walkability.

@milkbag682

11 ай бұрын

Another ottawa native here, and I was SO surprised to see ottawa and line q specifically mentioned. Personally I love it, and moved from orleans to old ottawa south. We still have some good neighbourhoods yet.

@RealGrouchy

11 ай бұрын

Me too, especially since I ride a bike! 😂 BTW, excellent brief summary of Ottawa's LRT failures.

@RedLuigiE

11 ай бұрын

Lol was looking for this comment. Also an Ottawa resident, born and raised. Kinda depressing, honestly.

@Dexter037S4

11 ай бұрын

Ottawa may suck, but like, it is one of the best in North America. such a low bar to clear.

I love his struggle. In Austria we have a app that lets us enter your destination and it just spits out every line you have to use and when it drives. It's awesome honestly, public transport here is just awesome in comparison....

@matthewstarkie4254

24 күн бұрын

I can do that in Finland just with Google maps. It's pretty fast at noticing delays and things too. My only issue with it is that it prioritises route time, rather than ease. Personally, I'd rather add 10 mins to my journey if it means I can take one bus over two.

I really liked the second half of this video. One thing I tend to dislike about a lot of content around public transit is they never really talk about the benefits of cars which makes them sound very tone deaf. I think contrasting the benefits and negatives of the three modes of transportation is really insightful. It allows you to step back and really understand why people like cars even though public transit seems to only have benefits. Now we just gotta pray that Edmonton's LRT system is completed in a reasonable time frame :')

@stealth3122

7 ай бұрын

@@chase-warwick I'm currently a student at the UofA and I my bus ride is like an hour cause the LRT line is still expanding to the west end.

As a french guy, I can't imagine not taking the subway or train to get to my job, it's literally faster than my car...

@Anti-Taxxer

11 ай бұрын

As an American, I couldn't care less what you think.

@alistarcortez4310

11 ай бұрын

@@Anti-Taxxercopeeee lmaooo

@mori1bund

11 ай бұрын

@@Anti-Taxxer you don't have to tell us that you're American. The rest of your comment makes that very clear... ^^

@LaZarusXtnct

11 ай бұрын

Because your roads are fked

@LaZarusXtnct

11 ай бұрын

​@@mori1bund *Laughs in WW2 hero

I live in Oslo, Norway - and here we have the absolute *best* public transit. We have the metro (subway) that goes practically everywhere, and buses that goes everywhere else and we also have trams in the inner city if neither the bus nor the metro takes you where you want to go. Then we have ferries that can take you to the islands outside of Oslo, and all of this fantastic transportation is included in a card you can buy either for a day, a week, a month or a year. And if you need to go outside of Oslo, the trains goes all the time and basically everywhere (and if the train doesn't go where you want to end up, take the train to the closest town and then you can *always* take a bus or a ferry to the spot you want to go). It's FANTASTIC! I truly don't see any reason at all to have a car when you live in this city. I get it if you live far out in the countryside or in the northern parts of Norway, but otherwise... No, a car isn't necessary _(I say this as a single woman without children, a car could of course be _*_very_*_ helpful if you have a family, but you could absolutely live without it)._

@rosemastinwood1606

11 ай бұрын

I loved the transit in Oslo! I also found the addition of e-bike rental options around the city awesome, it meant that if I wasn’t going far I could just hop on a bike too :) I would love to move back to Oslo!

@tbrown5657

11 ай бұрын

Suuure, rub it in, why don't you 😭😭😭

@TheDuzx

11 ай бұрын

Even if you ever needed a car like one day a week you could just rent it for those days and it would be cheaper than owning one all year. Cars are expensive.

@boldoberan

11 ай бұрын

Would be cool to see a part two of this. But in... let's say Oslo

@7club795

11 ай бұрын

I'm originally from America, my first real exposure to public transportation was when I moved to Norway. It was earth-shattering that I could just find accessible, reliable public transportation practically everywhere all the time. It spoiled me, and now no other transit I've used has lived up to it.

I’m so late but I would love to see you do this video again and explore somewhere like Taiwan’s public transport! I’m biased because I did a study abroad there but their transport system, coming from the US at least, was such a refreshing change of pace. It felt like now where was unreachable at any point from anywhere and was such a nice feeling and made exploring so much easier and fulfilling! This isn’t going into the environment of their public transport and the timeliness+professionalism from their public transport workers!

I used to live in a major city with mediocre public transport, and I appreciated the ability to go some places without driving. I now live in the middle of nowhere (10 minutes outside of a tiny town) and public transit isn't on the cards around here, but I deeply understand why it should be a deal elsewhere.

@crishnaholmes7730

5 ай бұрын

Which major city

@EloquentTroll

5 ай бұрын

@@crishnaholmes7730 St Louis

As someone who took public transportation for 12 years the #1 biggest problem with public transportation in the US is travel time. It took me 2 1/2 hours to get to work by bus which was a 12 minute drive away. I am absolutely not joking. To get to work I would walk to the bus stop which was 10 minutes away, get there 5 minutes early so I don't miss the bus! 20 minutes in the wrong direction to the transfer station. Wait at the transfer station for 20 minutes for the bus I need to arrive. Take the bus for half an hour up to another town. Get off the bus, cross the street and wait 15 minutes for the next bus. Take that bus for 20 minutes to work. Get off and walk for 15 minutes. All because I didn't own a car. This is ludicrous. Public transportation is not a solution when we build our cities against the idea.

@ianhomerpura8937

11 ай бұрын

What the hell. Those frequencies are insanely bad, especially for a country that is a member of the G7. Many developing countries do not have wait times that long. Buses and trains arrive every 10 minutes, sometimes every 3 minutes during rush hour.

@ReineGalena

11 ай бұрын

I feel you, public transportation is practically non existent where I live. It would take me 3 hours for a 30 minute trip so I'd have to stay on campus all day because it wasn't practical to go back and forth between classes.

@I.____.....__...__

11 ай бұрын

@@ReineGalena When I was in uni, I lived close enough to campus that I'd go home even if I had a one-hour break between classes, it was close, but I'd usually have a few minutes between arriving and having to get back to the bus-stop (it was a ~30-min bus ride). (I just checked Google Maps and apparently it's just a 15-minute bike-ride. 😲 I could have biked there and back the whole time I was in uni. Hell, it's just a one-hour walk. 🤦)

@ambientdiscord

11 ай бұрын

essentially same for me. I work in Boston and i got an apartment which is exactly 7 minutes walking from a commuter rail stop. The rail takes 1 hour to get to the subway. Another 10 minutes to my stop and 5 minute walk. This doesn't count waiting around for the trains and making sure to get there early so you don't miss them. The commuter rail comes once per hour during peak hours or once per 2 hours in non-peak hours. At BEST the trip is 1 hr 30 min. Driving it's easily 45 minutes because i stagger my workday to be offset from rush hour. If i try to arrive to work at 8AM it can usually take an entire extra hour driving due to traffic. I used to take the rail in and do work on the train but because so many people started working from home after covid, i am allowed to park at work any day i want now. The story i always tell people is that one day i got so sick of the absurd delays that the train can cause so i just stopped. I was at work and needed 5 more minutes to finish something. If i stay the 5 minutes it saves a full day of production time due to the way something works. However if i stay the 5 minutes i can't make my commuter rail train. I decided to stay the 5 minutes which meant i would miss my train so i went to my office and just decided to sit around for 1.5 hrs to kill time before the next train would come. Because i had to wait the 5 minutes i could not catch the 7:30 train so i waited in my office to catch the 9PM train. I leave with plenty of time to spare and get on the subway and wait. And wait and wait and wait. The conductor keeps telling us we will move shortly. After about 30 minutes they finally come on and tell us that there is an electrical issue at south station & instead of letting the trains move around on our end of the line the pause all trains that could pass through south station. Because i had gotten on so early, i could have easily done the 20-30 minute walk to the commuter rail station but they never fking communicate what the problem is or how long you will sit there on the tracks. Eventually we move and i get to the commuter rail station. I thought i i were lucky the train there might also be late but nope because that train is based out of north station so that one left on time. I missed the 7:30 train because i had to spend another 5 minutes at work. I missed the 9PM train because of an issue on the subway. Now the next train comes at 11PM and this is the LAST train of the day. I think about going back to work so i can wait the 2 hours in my office but after the last issue i am not going to risk missing the last train so now i have to sit there watching rats fighting on the track until 11. Luckily that train comes and i get to my stop at 12:15. The reliability is awful. If it were just 1 train it would be 1 thing but the issue is that you need to make multiple jumps and each of those lag of the journey has some percent chance of having a delay. If any of those trains goes down for any reason, you are suddenly caught in hours long waits trying to get back in on the next cycle. I do work in a chemistry lab and sometimes i need to get in for a time sensitive procedure or i need to get to a meeting at a certain time. Public transit is just so untenable because there are zero personal benefits EXCEPT that i can get the ticket reimbursed where they will not pay for my gas. It just isn't worth my sanity though to have nights where i should have gotten home and making dinner by 8 only to get stuck in a loop of delays where i can't get home till 1.

@sinzones3909

11 ай бұрын

another thing is just. bad timing too. the previous place i lived i’d take a bus to the grocery store. that bus came once every 3 hours. had somewhere to be but missed your bus by A Minute? bad luck! wait another 3 hours :)

it's always fun to play "ohhhhh so THIS is what Sabrina was tweeting about" when AIP releases a new video

I don't know if you count this as time use or not, but public transportation also allows you to have your hands free and to do whatever else you want to do 😁 That's adding to its main strength, though, not improving a weakness 🤷‍♀️ Love your videos, by the way, the whole train of thought leading to the answers with all hypothesis explained is really entertaining 😁

@muchluck7981

8 ай бұрын

I mean... Sure you have free time to do whatever you want but unless you are using public transport to do work, you are mainly doing idle stuff. Sure your hands would be free so you can use your phone which is a great boost but if you are not using it for work, you are using your phone for other stuff.

@mslinguisteak

8 ай бұрын

@@muchluck7981 Working isn't always related to your official job ;)

@sam4330

Ай бұрын

@@muchluck7981 I've spent plenty of time on public transit reading great books or just chilling while listening to music. Driving sounds so stressful in comparison.

@muchluck7981

Ай бұрын

@@sam4330 having done both, Public transport while relaxing is it's own set of worms. you can do your own thing in the public transit but if they are not well maintained or worse, they can make you feel more unsafe if you are not using them. A car at least gives you peace of mind knowing that it's going to be left the same way you found it so it's up to you to make sure it's well maintained and cleaned. public transit is up to the city planners and depending on budget, some may receive more atttention over others

@sam4330

Ай бұрын

​@@muchluck7981 I suppose the downside to that is that when the car actually needs maintenance, you're the one who has to make sure it gets it, and you also have to know enough to make judgments about whether something needs fixing or not. But I have only lived in places where public transit is very well maintained in terms of safety so maybe it's hard for me to understand. I did use to live in a very rural area though, where the roads were small and winding and NOT well maintained. There were bus accidents way too often in the winter, and I definitely get people who refused to take those bus rides, even though the busses themselves were well maintained. Personally, I think it contributed to me deciding not to get a drivers license, because I just don't want to deal with the anxiety of potentially being the one to cause a car accident. Very silly, but we all like to make our choices based on what feels more comfortable, lol.

I once got hit by three bus cancelations in a row for an hourly bus service and I still love public transport because that was the only place in the city I couldn't get on a train.

I remember a big debacle when the American ambassador* made a comment about how people in my country must be poor because not everyone owns a car. But a substantial part of us simply find biking and public transport both cheaper, healthier and more convenient because the systems to support those styles of transportation are robust, and I think the only thing that gets in the way of similar adoption in America and Canada is the lack of solid infrastructure. Many cities have been built to be straight up hostile towards any form of transportation other than cars. *former

@russellgeisthardt9828

11 ай бұрын

“A developed country is not a place where the poor have cars. It's where the rich use public transportation.” ― Gustavo Petro

@sirsurnamethefirstofhisnam7986

11 ай бұрын

Which country was this?

@SleepyFen

11 ай бұрын

@@sirsurnamethefirstofhisnam7986 The country is Denmark. The ambassador in question is Carla Sands. She was pretty much publicly ridiculed for her insanely narrowminded commentary.

@actual_nonsense

11 ай бұрын

man I wish I could get back every sent I spend on cars, car maintenance, insurance, fuel, tires, storage, and parking. I could probably buy a bus pass for everyone in my town with the money.

@grammarnazi12

11 ай бұрын

​@@actual_nonsense this. I'm sure there are plenty of people in north America who genuinely love their cars, but for me owning a car has always been a necessary evil - like some outrageously expensive pet that no one actually wants around 😅

Sabrina is always the one in the group who is inadvertently chosen to do the extreme challenges... that long walk! applaud the resilience! 👏

@qwertyTRiG

11 ай бұрын

It's fully her own fault, though, which is why we love her!

@justinwhite2725

11 ай бұрын

Because she is the one that comes up with the scenario and her doing the hardest part makes it easier for her friends to buy in.

@tacocravr

11 ай бұрын

Not to throw shade but it definitely feels like Sabrina cares more about this channel than anyone else, they're who I think about when I think about this channel, the best videos star them, you get the point.

@gayatriunni549

11 ай бұрын

@@tacocravryeah fr like don’t get me wrong, i love melissa and taha, but sabrina’s videos are the ones that truly feel like answer in progress

@NotASummoner

11 ай бұрын

I find it worrying that walking for a couple hours is considered an extreme challenge... I get how it's not a good experience with the roads but the actual walking part really shouldn't be an issue.

Damn your storytelling and editing have gotten so good!!

Great video, from beginning to end. Absolutely hilarious when you all share your arrival times, hahaha. More group challenges!

I live in the USA and just got back from a 2.5 week trip to Japan (where we used nothing but public transit). The public transit was amazing and I wish we had more around us so we could use it. As she said, when it works it works.

@Anon54387

10 ай бұрын

When it works it works is a mindless tautology. One can just as easily say when it doesn't work it doesn't work. It's like these people saying it is what it is. What is that? It is what it is. See how we are no further along than we were at the start?

@SteveGoldberg-he5ur

10 ай бұрын

Women in trains get groped and molested there, also it's packed like a tuna can. IT's stupid to use trains instead of drive, if I used there I'd drive everywhere instead of being in a place with potential molestors and creeps of all genders.

@Pepe-dq2ib

10 ай бұрын

Japan also doesn't get reports of subway violent attacks on the hourly basis.

@aa4a-a4

10 ай бұрын

@@Pepe-dq2ib school shootings aren't a reason to not have schools

@Pepe-dq2ib

10 ай бұрын

@@aa4a-a4 school shootings dont happen multiple times a day and my parents took us out of inner city schools long ago.

One disadvantage if you move around with your car is, that you have to take it everywhere you go. When I move through Hamburg, Germany, I often decide from case to case. Some examples: - I walk 30 minutes to visit a friends house, but when I go back it's dark and I'm tired, so I wait 10 minutes for the next Bus and it drives me home. - In the morning I used the train to work, but in the afternoon the sun is shining and I'm feeling good, so I rent a bicycle and ride home. - As team event at work we decided to walk 20 min to a restaurant in the evening. If I would have a car, I had to drive there alone or walk 20 min back afterwards, but now I can just hop into the next train. - I had dates, where we decided to do a walk through the city and we ended up on a different spot where we started. With a car I would have to walk back to it, now I could just take the next train. - Sometimes to discover a city I walk around, get out 2 stations earlier, etc. With a car If I park it 20 min away, I have to walk that distance on the way back. The flexibility with public transport that wherever I go in this city, whether I drink alcohol or not, how tiered I am, I can always just walk a few minutes to the next station and drive home with it, is something a car can not provide, currently. Well, the city needs to have decent public transport for that.

@yiyang4445

11 ай бұрын

Totally agree, same in Shanghai! I hate driving and bringing my car with me everywhere when I lived in the US

@AdamGaffney96

11 ай бұрын

Absolutely agree with this! And oftentimes if you took the car initially but want to go somewhere else, that results in you not doing the walk back, and instead just take the car everywhere instead. Using the car at ANY step basically encourages you to use the car for EVERY step, whereas as you said, with public transport you can decide to just take a different mode of transport.

11 ай бұрын

This is why car sharing services are such a great idea. (and bike and scooter sharing ones too). Gives you a lot of the benefits, without the drawback of lugging around the car/bike/scooter.

@99Plastics

11 ай бұрын

Enjoy huffing farts daily.

@pumpkinhill4570

11 ай бұрын

Absolutely. I do this all the time in Japan. You go to a shopping district by train, walk through it, then get another train one or two stations away from where you started. You don’t have to constantly double back on yourself just to get back to your car.

I just love your style of these videos!

I'm planning on moving to Canada from Europe, where everything is on time and any public transport is more affordable than even a taxi, and this is scaring me Wonderful video, though, and thank you for your commitment, Sabrina!!

As a resident of Ottawa and frequent public transit user who recently wrote a research paper on the LRT fiasco in Ottawa (which is SO MUCH WORSE than this video could possibly convey)....I CACKLED when I realized you guys were coming here of all places to test out the use of public transit. I do think that you overlooked something really important, which is that for many people, "shelter" isn't a hotel in a high-density area, it's a house or apartment in an area that's not at all well serviced by public transit (particularly here in Ottawa). That can either make your commute especially miserable or even borderline impossible, OR it can severely limit where you're able to live. I'm absolutely SHOCKED that public transit ended up being OVER AN HOUR FASTER than going by car. There's no way that's the case for the average person on the average day, not in this city, anyway. I do think you're right, though, that transit is worth the investment, and overall this was a fantastic video. Awesome job, and kudos for doing this in the snow and slush.

@mmacmartin

11 ай бұрын

well, their targets were basically on the LRT, so that had to help the result...

@joshhsoj1902

11 ай бұрын

@@mmacmartinyour comment sorta made me realize how passable the LRT is for "tourists" in Ottawa (unless you flew in, that’s a different story). Which I guess is something…

@stevefl7175

11 ай бұрын

I think the same thing, in that for a person living in a city, one of the nice things of a car if you have to go quite a distance is your home is an end point (or start point). Plus the comfort of not having to worry about rain or bad weather (for the most part). I would love to know what happened to the driver, who took 2 hours to get to the hospital. Ottawa is just not that big. From a map it looks like it was just 4-5km, in 2 hours? Call me skeptical. I grew up in NYC and it wouldn't take me that long to cross the city on a regular day and it's far larger. Choosing places on the public transit system, I give sort of a pass on, if the experiment was to try and see what it would be like for a place with a large transit system where most places are near a transit station. (Still, you do need to get from your house, to public transit, to location, and then back. Where car is a straight route). I'm trying to look at it as a test of being in the inner city and getting around within it.

@Dexter037S4

11 ай бұрын

@@joshhsoj1902 Soon enough even for flying in it'll be useful due to the Airport Spur.

@OntarioTrafficMan

11 ай бұрын

@@Dexter037S4 Yes but unfortunately the fact that you need to transfer twice to get downtown (Line 4 to South Keys, then Line 2 to Bayview, then Line 1 to downtown) will probably scare off many potential riders even though the transfers themselsves are actually quite easy.

The video overlooked one important thing. Cost. Sure public transit has issues but that's mostly self inflicted from the auto industry lobbying against good infrastructure for public transit. What most car owners can however relate to is the ridiculous cost to maintain cars, insurance, recalls, accidents. You could save so much money wasted on cars. So much for the freedom they were told cars would offer

@JohnSmith-qe6fb

10 ай бұрын

Devil's advocate here ( I think Public Transportation is great): What about the cost to expand rail systems? The light rail near me will cost over 1 Billion for just over 5 miles!

@Ghorda9

10 ай бұрын

@@JohnSmith-qe6fb expansions don't just go away after they're built, it's a one time cost.

@seantroy3172

10 ай бұрын

​@@JohnSmith-qe6fb Highway expansion projects for autos can be extremely expensive as well. The real cost winner is active transit, better walkability and bikeabilty. A billion dollar investment in a bike network would get you a world class, safe, protected bike/multiuse trail network. Plus for individuals the cost of walking is effectively 0 and biking is immensely cheaper than owning a car.

@JohnSmith-qe6fb

10 ай бұрын

@@seantroy3172 In a high density metro area I completely agree. Putting in infrastructure for EV, biking, and other forms of clean transportation, including busing would be a well worth the funding . We need to look at options for more rural areas as well.

@andrewmendez8322

10 ай бұрын

​@JohnSmith-qe6fb Public transit is expensive but to have a system where everyone has their own vehicle is even more expensive. If I'm not mistaken a large portion of funds go into maintenance of current road infrastructure alone.

Hey! I just found out about your channel because of this video! I think it's a great video! I just suscribed to get to know more about interesting stuff with your unique storytelling style!😁

i feel genuinely surry for Sabrina that she put ENORMOUS amount of effort in making this video. Like, this should get at least 30 million views because it's produced perfectly and so thoroughly

As a Dutch person, it's just really weird that bicycles aren't even mentioned in a video on transit (I watch Not Just Bikes though, so don't worry I get it). Bicycles are (I think) the best kind of transportation ever invented: they're space-efficient, they're simple to maintain and repair, easy to adapt for people with mobility issues or even light cargo transport, and best of all: even a simple 1-speed bike, while still being completely human-powered, can very easily go 4-5 times as fast as a person walking while using much less energy.

@svenjorgensenn8418

11 ай бұрын

Your country isn't even the size of my state. Bike from North Houston to South and tell me how you feel

@KF-zb6gi

11 ай бұрын

Seeing how the sidewalk isn't really walking-friendly, riding bicycle might be more dangerous since it would need to stay on the road with cars

@Kycilak

11 ай бұрын

@@svenjorgensenn8418 Well, the video is about the modes of transit in city. If they replaced walking with biking, I would consider it a more useful comparison.

@braydentoth8442

11 ай бұрын

Well for one thing bikes still aren’t adaptable to all disabilities. And I’m not talking about more advanced ones. Using me as an example only a helmet that perfectly protects the head in 100% of instances from concussion and damage or a bike that is 100% crash proof. So trains are actually more accessible in terms of many disabilities.

@ProfessordevilL

11 ай бұрын

@@svenjorgensenn8418 So sorry that you have to travel between states every single day. That must be painful.

Having just visited Paris, I think the biggest thing is at 18:25 "If I get off the bus, it's now like another 15 - 20 minutes before the next one." I experienced that trying to commute in Utah where the Frontrunner train would only come every 45 minutes. That means if you're 1 minute late leaving the house, you're now 45 minutes late for work. In a well-serviced city like Paris, that's 2 to 4 minutes, so you can absolutely hop on and hop off. Also, if the concept of making it to your train "on time" disappears because it's always a minute or two wait tops.

@IrvineTheHunter

10 ай бұрын

THIS ^ I take the bus, RN, but it really doesn't save me time on walking my 3/3-mile commute, because if I miss it I have to rush to work because the next bus is 30-60 minutes away.

@GalladofBales

10 ай бұрын

This! Frequency is freedom

I live in Lahore, Pakistan. It takes four to six hours of commuting to go back and forth from one corner of the city to another. Also the nearest bus station is one hour walk away from my home. So time is the biggest hurdle in my personal experience using public transport.

During the whole time, I was like: USE A BIKE, USE A BIKE, USE A BIKE... So much faster than walking, not a big deal to park, no public transport schedule. And you can even combine them: take your bike in the train or in your car (folding bike works really well too). And electric kick scooter can also help a lot with the last mile.

@MAL1GNANT

7 ай бұрын

Foldable electric bike on trains? Flawless combo.

@valdir7426

6 ай бұрын

bike are hugely popular in european cities and I respect that but I must say even if use them sometimes (we've got a free service where you can rent them for very cheap) I'm not a fan. -in the winter it's super cold (and rain isn't great either) -people in cars are want to kill you when you're biking -other people on bikes are assholes as well; apparently if you don't ride at least at 50 km/h you're basically a tourist and everybody will ring you, people have places to be apparently (honestly when I drive I have the same experience; if you haven't started your car 1 nanosecond after a light becomes green people will honk you like you've try to murder them. it's nuts). so basically for me it's walking and taking the subway. I can walk for one hour sometimes if I feel like it.

@Machodave2020

6 ай бұрын

As an American while I'm not necessarily against this this isn't always practical. Like in my city, there are areas where biking is really really good, but areas where biking is a complete nightmare - guess who lives on the latter? I even live on a highway and the streets and sidewalks are crappy, so biking is out of the question. Walking, public transit, and driving in my case are clearly better.

I am a college student in Austin with no car and the public transportation here is truly miserable. Especially during the summer when the temperatures are in the 100s & the humidity is high & Google maps never tells me the right bus times. I always consider calling in to work whenever I miss the bus because waking half an hour in this heat is borderline dangerous.

@petterwiggen5833

10 ай бұрын

Howdy fellow Texan. Yeah public tansit ain't the greatest.

@davidelorreaga7494

10 ай бұрын

Austin could expand so much and handle its density with public transportation. I feel your pain

@MrMensa141

10 ай бұрын

Remember this problem when you vote for a democrat.

@nataliechavez1228

10 ай бұрын

@MrMensa141 are you joking? The Republican platform is against investing any effective amount of money into mass transit

@zachanikwano

10 ай бұрын

Borderline?? It IS dangerous!

CYCLING should have been included in your study. i've been living/working in riyadh for 7 years. riyadh is a car oriented city (as are most cities in the middle east). i have been living here car-free, just cycling everywhere i need to go. and it's so easy and convenient!

@DizzleDog

9 ай бұрын

Lol. You can capitalize it all you want. Americans aren’t gonna start riding bikes on a 10-20 mile commute on these dangerous roads. I’m sure it works for you in the Middle East but there’s nothing easy or practical about that in the US. We just drive and get there quickly in air conditioning while carrying all the supplies we need

@vakancy

9 ай бұрын

cute

@PoisonFlower765

9 ай бұрын

Bikes > Cars almost any day! These replies genuinely do not get it.

@PRH123

8 ай бұрын

​​​@@everydaytenor8862I have a family and ride my bike year round, to work and shops, down to -20 C... When I worked in Stockholm all my colleagues came to work on bikes in the winter... It's just a question of dressing right and equipping your bike...

@PRH123

8 ай бұрын

@@everydaytenor8862 it’s not as hard as you might think, the exercise keeps you warm…. And actually -10 and lower is better than say 0 C (32 F) because it’s dry, usually sunny, cleaner…. and living in a place where they keep the streets and sidewalks plowed helps too…

Thanks for the great video! It’s made me very thankful that my city has excellent public transport!

My city used to have a subway system, but it has long been shut down it was used by street artists up until a couple years ago when it was demolished.

I've had to move to a different city for a summer internship and couldn't take my car with me so I had to take public transportation. Honestly, I love it surprisingly. It has its downsides and being in America, it does suck in terms of connectivity and it is usually slower than driving. Still, being able to zone out, read a book, browse the internet, or whatever was a plus. I just wish we had a better public transportation system that is cheaper and faster. Definitely plan on using it more often when I get back to my own home city.

@sebastianr1204

11 ай бұрын

Living in Europe I hate taking public transport even when I lived in a big city during my studies. I hate to hate to have to rely on somebody else, no matter being the streetcar driver or the schedule. Most often I take my bicycle (for commuting, groceries and meeting people). When I don’t have the time to bike, I use the car.

@shadowtimez2452

11 ай бұрын

Living in a "big" Norwegian city, the public transport is amazing!!! Whereever I'm going I can count on the public transport system!

@victai163

11 ай бұрын

i looove reading on the bus!!

@pranaym3859

11 ай бұрын

​@Sebastian R I rarely used it in my home country too but in NA, you don't have any option rather than a car. Car will eat up your significant chunk of income. And forget about biking in NA if you want to live, you'll die soon in the world of cars It's way better to have multiple options even if you don't use it.

@kasswuit

11 ай бұрын

@@victai163 definitely better than staring at cars the whole time

I think one of the things you might have missed in the comparative analysis when saying that cars are the "natural choice": For many people, any stores for food etc. are quite a ways away, to the point it doesn't make sense to go more often in little batches - so instead you do big shopping trips every week. And to transport that much stuff? You need the car. Stuff like this is why a car is often a necessity in NA, after which the irrational mind kicks in like "If I already have a car why would I not use it to go work?" etc.

@alquinn8576

9 ай бұрын

yup, once you need a car regularly for 1 thing, it becomes the dominant option for many other things. the issue with mass transit being unfavorable in US/Can is deep and structural, so a few prestige projects are not going to fix all of that.

@dolex161

9 ай бұрын

awattO (meme for Ottawa) do be a Costco town... There's no other choice, Lob grocers are everywhere, but dang are they expensive. Shelter is stupid and starting at 500k, condo buildings bought out by blackrock or foreign money and renting out for 3k+ per month. Ottawa sucks...

@Adowrath

8 ай бұрын

@@happyguy2k Like the country I live in, Switzerland? It's great, I don't need a car, my Dad doesn't need one anymore either. I don't think I'll be getting a Driver's license anytime soon either.

@_aullik

8 ай бұрын

What you just said: If there aint good public transport you need a car and once you have a car you prefer it over bad public transport. Couple problems with that. First there is no need for stores to be built that far away from residential areas, in fact it used to be different in the US and is different all over the world. Second, if no one uses public transport, there is no investment in it and it gets worse so even less people will use it. Third: Cars are convenient up to a point. If you wanna go just get into your car and go. No timetables, not walking to a station just point A to point B. Its a luxury thing. At least in theory. But if everyone takes the car, you get congestion and everyone is slower and it becomes quite inconvenient. So if you improve public transport and the living space to the point where it is more convenient not to use a car, people will not use the car.

@Adowrath

8 ай бұрын

@@_aullikThat is in fact not what I said. What I said was, by the fact that general stores and such currently are not close to people's homes, even if public transport was better than it is, using it to shop that long distance away would be less efficient than by car due to the volume you can transport. I don't know how you construed my "this is another sad reason many people see a need to use cars" argument as some kind of defense of cars/attack on public transport.

OMG I love you guys! So much fun+knowledge

I love taking the train. I do it whenever I travel. It's relaxing. You can walk around. You can meet new people. The observation cars are the best. Please, take the 🚆!❤❤❤

I think what gets me is in countries with effective public transport these problems disappear almost. In Tokyo the trains are on time, clean, easy to navigate and widely used. When I visited it didn’t make sense to drive. Using the train fulfilled all your needs! It’s no longer a humbling experiences when it’s effective and everyone uses it. Then people are willing to take care of it and maintain it

@Rocketkid2121

10 ай бұрын

I would imagine the part about trains being clean and widely used in Japan has way more to do with much more respectable Culture. Good luck getting that to happen in US cities.

@Nottiy

10 ай бұрын

​@@Rocketkid2121there are lots of places that aren't Japan where public transport is widely used and clean. The US also has lots of social problems that if it received investment and resources, it wouldn't be a common issue and there would be less ppl having a mental health crisis in public or rough sleeping.

@fargsrgasdgerg492

10 ай бұрын

@@Nottiy Yes, the US is famously a very poor country with no resources🙄 Not every problem can be solved by money.

@fanboy50

10 ай бұрын

@@fargsrgasdgerg492 Oh, no one is saying the US doesn't have resources. The issue isn't that we don't have them. The issue is that our governments at almost all levels categorically refuse to use them (except in the most token, half-gesture amounts) for anything other than the military or cops. Now, one of our two main parties is certainly worse about this than the other, but this is absolutely a bipartisan problem. If our government(s) could ever be arm-twisted back into spending our abundant resources on things that actually benefit the public (adequate affordable housing, single-payer healthcare like literally every industrialized nation has, unemployment insurance, laws to keep wages in line with costs of living), we'd more than likely see these problems lessen or disappear. But our society has been totally eaten by capitalism, so things in the public interest don't get done without sufficient profit motive for private entities. You can hear it really illustratively when people talk about how the Postal Service in the US "loses money." In countries that are run with an eye to actually meeting the needs of the populace, things like public transit and postal service and healthcare simply "have costs" that are, for the most part, considered worthwhile for the service they provide to the public. There isn't an expectation that any of those things are going to generate a profit: any fees or costs assigned are simply there to offset some of the costs, with the understanding that the majority of it gets funded through taxation. Meanwhile, you will never once hear a politician here talk about how much money our military, by far the world's most-expensive, loses every year. It's all about priorities, and our country's priorities fucking suck.

@fargsrgasdgerg492

10 ай бұрын

@@fanboy50 You seem to be ill informed about how much USG actually spends. Whatever issue you think USG should spend more money on, I guarantee you the US spends more per capita then any other country (yes, this includes healthcare). Americas problems aren't caused by lack of funding, they are caused by gross incompetence and corruption at the systemic level. These aren't problems that can be solved by spending more money. You mentioned the US postal service. Did you actually bother looking at how other countries do it? I looked at Canada, France, Germany, the UK and Sweden. Of these countries, the postal service in France and Germany is entirely private (and is operating at a profit). Canada has a government run postal service that earns 144M$ a year with 8.2B$ in revenue. The other countries have a private postal service that is partially owned by the government. The Swedish postal company (which is also partially owned by Denemark) makes about 200m$ a year. The English Royal mail is the only one of those countries that loses money (losing about half a billion pounds a year). From looking at this, I don't think it is unreasonable to be be unhappy with the USPS for losing almost 10B$ a year. If other countries can make the post work, why can't the US?

OMG Reece !!! Yes please do more plugs like this and share your knowledge with the masses

I live in a small city in Italy (in Sardinia which is an island) and I spend a lot of time complaining about public transport, but watching this video I realized that our public transport (at least inside my city) is AMAZING. We have busses AND trains, I can get almost anywhere in the city and the suburban areas aren't connected too badly. On the other hand we often have delays and broken busses and route changes, but most of the lines have a 10 minute frequency and only the ones that go in the adjacent towns there's like maybe 30 minutes between each bus

As a European I'm always baffled when people from the US and Canada have to discover the magic of bus /train transportation for the first time

@JustinWashington-gf8zk

11 ай бұрын

Everything here is massively spread out, public transportation would be inefficient and would also run a deficit in most parts

@rafaeltorre1643

11 ай бұрын

Comparing a small country to an entire continent doesn’t compute.

@balazskiss9252

11 ай бұрын

Lol, you know that Europe is also a continent right and comparable to the contiguus US as Alaska is irrelevant here? Also the video is about urban public transport not intercity/interstate one so the US's size is irrelevant. And that in Europe there are also suburban transport which connect spread out cities as well. I mean London of all places is fairly sprawled out and comparable to US cities and yet it has a very usable transport system which enables people to not own a car in order to live their life.

@rafaeltorre1643

11 ай бұрын

@@balazskiss9252 I would think a man of confidence would explain the decision to compare transportation from your continent vs your individual country towards the US. Why is that? I can compare my family’s accomplishments vs an individual person but that wouldn’t say anything of value when it comes to comparison. Just makes me look better. But It doesn’t work. So it doesn’t mean anything of value. What does an entire continent of dozens of small countries you don’t live in, compare to a country that is an entire continent? Its not a logical comparison. You could compare any state or city in the US to your country and find no difference and maybe even a better transit system. But that doesn’t say anything if they are two completely different things. Instead of defending your decision you go straight to stating they are both continents. Yeah they are. Cool. I had steak for dinner. I have 3 degrees. But who cares. How does a bunch of countries compare to just one statistically? It adds no value.

@Hmpf_Argh

11 ай бұрын

@@JustinWashington-gf8zk Look at all u.s. american cities pre world war two, and your argument dissolves into thin air.

In my opinion when public transports are not too crowded, they're more comfortable than driving because you can do other things like watching series or reading whereas when driving you have to stay focused

@I.____.....__...__

11 ай бұрын

Indeed. Sabrina said there's not much about driving that's uncomfortable other than looking for a parking-spot, but that's just because she's not a driver, most drivers know how nerve-wracking it is to to drive, worrying about laws and cops, about other drivers, about pedestrians cyclists and animals, about the car itself, and so on. You can (usually) even watch videos while walking, but you can't do _anything_ while driving, not even look at the sights. 🤦

@LaZarusXtnct

11 ай бұрын

This is something somebody who cant afford a car says

@lil_eau

11 ай бұрын

@@LaZarusXtnct no i live in Paris and the Subway is faster than car, I use my bike tho that's even faster. Having a car in Paris is a nightmare

@Forgefaerie

11 ай бұрын

@@LaZarusXtnct I have a car, I drive daily. if i could reliably switch to public transport - I would do that in a freaking heartbeat. 2 hours driving is 2 hours lost AND far more exhausting (why 2 hours, because that's how long the round trip for my daily commute takes right now, and its not even slightly unusual number for USA commute). 2 hours in public transit are 2 hours spend studying, or reading or engaging in multitude of other portable hobbies. and before you say anything about listening to audiobooks while driving, maybe you are such an amazing multitasker that you can stay focused on the road AND the book, but I'm not. I can do one or the other, not both. drivers in my parts of USA are too damn insane.

@LaZarusXtnct

11 ай бұрын

@@Forgefaerie 2 hours on public transit is 2 hours of living like a homeless person. A 2 hour ride on a bus would be like 15 mins in a car. The bus wont take you through an Arbys drive through either.

I remember taking the public transit in Wisconsin in a moderate city for university. I was surprised by how empty it was yet the system was so simple, the only people who used it were old people and there was barely any to begin with. It took me around the entire city from top to bottom. Yea it was a hassle to wait but it was the only time i ever used a city bus until i went back to my hometown

Apart from walking, cycling is also a type of active transport, saving you time

I love public transit, mainly because I can't drive. The biggest drawback of public transit I notice, is scheduling. When walking or driving if you want to go somewhere you just go there. With transit you may want to go now but there isn't a bus now. The bus was 5 minutes ago or 25 minutes from now. Then you take your bus or train somewhere and you repeat that process. With transit there ends up being a lot of time spent not moving while the trip time just ticks up.

@emmy8526

11 ай бұрын

Anything less than every 15 minutes is hostile to riders. Because even with that schedule, if one bus is early and the next one late, which often happens, you’re standing there for 20-25 min. If a bus is skipped entirely (a bus broke down or a driver called in sick), you could be standing there for 30 minutes. So with a schedule that’s any less frequent, you’re looking at even longer wait times than that. I speak from experience! Time is money, unless you’re a person who takes public transport, in which case they’re happy to waste your time like it has no value.

@GTAVictor9128

11 ай бұрын

If you live in a city with a proper metro like Barcelona or Madrid, a metro arrives every 3 minutes, so as long as you know the route, you don't need to plan for time.

@I.____.....__...__

11 ай бұрын

… and then the transit commission changes the routes and schedules to allow the college-students who pay $100 for an unlimited year-long pass to be able to sleep in an extra few minutes before they get up for their afternoon class, while residents of the city who have to pay $100 every month have to now take one or two EXTRA buses to get to the grocery-store, wasting an extra 30-90 minutes, having to walk a lot more, and stand in the sun/snow/rain more. 😠

@KyrilPG

11 ай бұрын

​@@I.____.....__...__ One or two buses to go to the grocery store ??? You live in suburbia ? I can see my closest grocery store from my window. Having to take a bus to run basic errands is simply bonkers...

@geeceephd

11 ай бұрын

Scheduling in Toronto/GTA is the main reason why I drive. There's a train connecting the downtown core to my suburb. While the train itself beats the traffic, it arrives in 30 to 60 min intervals. And those intervals never match the additional public transportations' schedules required to arrive to the train station. The station is at the Southern point of the suburb, so you'll need a bus to get to and from the station. Anytime I'm coming back from Toronto, there is a minimum wait time of 20-30 minutes for a bus to take me North/home. The lack of synergy between all the modes of transports makes it so that the total time it takes ends up being slower than driving in traffic. It's truly a frustrating affair. Specially when you consider that often times the bus starting point is at it these stations. So it doesn't take a rocket scientist to schedule a bus departure time 5 minutes after the train arrives, instead of 5 minutes before it arrives (not exaggerating, the busses I need are all scheduled to depart 5-10 minutes before the train arrives!!).

I live in the Netherlands, and let me tell you... Public transit here in Europe is amazing, you can get anywhere by either bus, train, tram or metro. Here in mayor cities a lot of people don't even own cars since they decide to use the public transit system to get everywhere, it works pretty well for them.

@nickchapman3199

11 ай бұрын

I was just in Frankfurt and wasn't impressed. Driving is way better.

@fewkeyfewkey5414

11 ай бұрын

@@nickchapman3199 your in the wrong place 😅

@Pacjonek

11 ай бұрын

​​​​​@@nickchapman3199ve visited Berlin both by a car and using subway. The problem with the car in the center is that there is nowhere to park it, all the parking spaces are occupied making you drive for 1 hour looking for anything. Meteo is definitely faster and cheaper. Overall, Germany is a country that is still quite car-friendly but you can also live well here without the car at least in cities

@nickchapman3199

11 ай бұрын

@@Pacjonek I've driven coast to coast in the US multiple times and I've never been to a city that was harder to find parking in than Frankfurt. The Autobahn was pretty cool though

@sneakiestsnek3150

11 ай бұрын

yeah, in america we've been building around cars for a while so what public transit we have has to work around that instead of being itself a framework.

I don't normally comment on videos, but in this case I feel compelled to. I've just returned to NY after a month in Berlin, and after watching your brilliant, beautiful, artfully constructed video, I am left with a dull anger and visceral pain in my chest, as the truth really is "location, location, location" (well not really, just that some locations get it right, and others don't). It's kinda funny to see an MTA cameo here, as BVG / DB's work over in Deutschland really puts the NYC system to shame. For example, you can get from Berlin airport to the literal other side of the city for just under $4.50. In NYC, it costs a flat $8.25 to just *leave the airport by train* and make your way to the regular train system, at which point it costs *at least* $7.50 to get to Grand Central, then an additional $3-$20 (!!) to connect to wherever you're going next. Not to mention the system is not nearly as well-connected, with all the trains insisting on just running North/South for no reason. Maybe the real question is "why do North Americans hate Public Works?" We have the same problem with education, at least.

@thecoolannishatk.

8 ай бұрын

At least NYCs transit is better then most of the Americas

in Vienna (Austria) there are a lot of people (myself included) that don't even have a driving license (yet!) because public transportation is so good and reliable

The city I grew up in had a decent public transit system. Proximity to bus stops was a selling point for a lot of homes. My childhood home was about a block away from a bus stop and as a result, during summer vacations, my sister and I were able to go anywhere in the city we wanted to (provided that we let our parents know, ofc). Then, the city hired some contractors from Portland (Oregon) to come in and "improve" the bus system. They turned it into more of a park and ride system, pulling the bus stops out of neighborhoods and instead putting them near businesses and at park and ride places. In other words, they optimized it for people who already have cars, but find it problematic to park near their workplace. For everyone else, it was a giant middle finger. Now to get to the bus stop, I would have to walk much further and cross 2 very busy roads. That makes riding the bus so much more of a hassle and less safe (crossing those roads, even in a crosswalk, is dangerous because drivers just don't look for pedestrians...I've had my share of close calls where I've had to jump out of the way of idiots rolling right through the crosswalk against the light and then getting mad at me for daring to be in their path).

@hufficag

9 ай бұрын

Throw something at their car

I was doing an exchange semester at University of Waterloo back in 2020. Coming from The Netherlands it was so precious to see how proud they were of their single previously built LRT line 🥺 That said public buses get stuck in traffic which kinda defeats the purpose, so Waterloo get a D for that. Without a car I felt like a second class citizen taking public transport which NEVER happened to me in Europe.

@nathanbanks2354

8 ай бұрын

Lived in KW (Kitchener-Waterloo) for a couple years while they were still finishing the single LRT line. Biked most of the time, but it's definitely a car city. Now I'm in Montreal, which is 8 times bigger, thinking of the way I biked passed all the cars stuck in traffic earlier today...as well as how tough it was to pass everyone in the bike lane. I'm definitely jealous of cycling in the Netherlands.

@commuterjack

7 ай бұрын

By Waterloo I guess you mean the one in America and not the district in London? I got a bit confused until I saw the LRT 😂

@nathanbanks2354

7 ай бұрын

@@commuterjack I presume it's the one north of Kitchener, Ontario in Canada since it just got its LRT. The are often called KW or Kitchener-Waterloo since they act like one city. The LRT services both areas.

@KafeinBE

6 ай бұрын

@@commuterjack And here I was confusing it with actual Waterloo in Belgium (which, by nature of being a small town, has zero public transport beyond a couple of buses)

@PradedaCech

5 ай бұрын

I didn't know Belgium was so bad..

Love that I’m watching this the day after I just missed my train and had to wait 30 minutes longer for the next one when trains are usually ten minutes apart

As soneone going to Carleton university in Ottawa without a car, the whole train thing has been a total nightmare. Its still happening now and its really frustrating because there's a train thats supposed to go through Carleton that was dupposed to be done ages ago and they just recently pushed it to April next year.

I'm really surprised that even with all the turbulence, public transit was still WAY faster than the rest

@lonestarr1490

11 ай бұрын

I'm not surprised at all. It's another story in rural areas, of course, but in cities with proper infrastructure, you can't go significantly faster than by public transit or by bike (with neither one of the two being consistently faster than the other, except for maybe in the middle of the night).

@sanityisrelative

11 ай бұрын

​@@lonestarr1490yep. I just moved from the city proper to the burbs. In the city I could get from home to work in roughly the same amount of time, faster even if traffic is trash but the bus lanes are clear (transfers willing). But now it takes 30-45 minutes to drive and at least twice as long by bus. The issue is the local level transit near my house. The land of once-an-hour buses. Once I get to a transit center and can catch a commuter bus to the city everything is gravy.

@YoshiAsk

11 ай бұрын

Depends on where you live. In my city, which is small but definitely a city, the public transit is so lackluster that it's almost always slower to take the bus than to drive. The only concern here with driving is parking on the university campus, which is super expensive.

@lonestarr1490

11 ай бұрын

@@YoshiAsk That's why I said that the city should have "proper infrastructure". If busses get stuck in traffic, then that's not proper infrastructure, but deliberately designed to be garbage. Because people won't use it if it sucks, and when nobody's using it the city is justified to cut costs. Bicycle infrastructure is very often deliberately made to suck balls in pretty much the same way and for the very same reasons. They do their best to induce as little demand as possible so that when anyone asks them to build more they can just point out that nobody is using what's already there.

@bassetts1899

11 ай бұрын

In my city in the UK, a train takes 15 minutes maximum to cross the city, but it would take you at least 40 minutes to drive. The train can just go in a big straight line in a way that cars cannot

I'm so happy you are covering the absolutely terrible Otrain. It's been such a sham in my city and is why our last mayor didn't run in the last election

@VuLamDang

11 ай бұрын

and yet it still won. we need MORE TRAM!

@johnfeet3990

11 ай бұрын

I wish it wasn’t taking so long cuz if it was done I’d be using it like crazy

@sanityisrelative

11 ай бұрын

Is that really what is called. Because damn they even suck on a naming level.

@HANKTHEDANKEST

11 ай бұрын

@@sanityisrelative My friend, I assure you: the stupid name is but a glimpse into the shallow end of the raw, undiluted corruption and stupidity that has been the entire O-Train project. SNC-Lavalin is genuinely pure corruption with a light top-note of maple flavour.

@mlmielke

11 ай бұрын

The only thing wrong with it was how it was launched through the east segment without a full network. Launch issues are normal, but not the way it was launched. It is a reliable system. The bus system never was, but frequency lied to you making it appear that it was.

As someone who will never be able to drive, due to vision issues. I struggle to get around the city in Australia where I live. I have heard so many horror stories about travelling around cities from friends I have with similar issues, but by far the worst places are in the US and Canada due to the lack of decent infrastructure but also the massive amounts of cars. I only realise how lucky I am that I can travel across my city in just over an hour rather than not being able to get across the city at all.

20 years ago, here in Utah, I remember taking a bus as a teen to our local amusement park so my parents wouldn't have to take me. What normally was a 30-45 minute drive took TWO HOURS one way. Things have improved in the last 20 years, but there's still a lot of work to be done. Now, though, as a disabled person with an Accessible parking pass, public transit just isn't feasible anymore because it requires a certain amount of walking that my body just can't handle. I rented a mobility scooter when we went to Disneyland, which was really nice, but taking the shuttle presented its own unique challenges (I have yet to try it in my hometown, so I don't have a comparison yet). So you make a fair point in that a LOT depends on the infrastructure and design.

I think this excellent video is missing one fundamental point, which is the role that land use plays on transportation modes. You touched on it a bit, but walking, biking and public transit only make sense when your city is densely built and populated. Train stations need to be surrounded by businesses and housing, not parking lots. That's the only way to have a sustainable ridership

@ianhomerpura8937

11 ай бұрын

THIS. This is exactly why even at the height of the COVID lockdowns, the transit networks in Japan, Hong Kong, and Singapore remained insanely profitable. When they plan new communities, new transit networks and extensions are ALWAYS included in the masterplan. Plus, the lands around railway stations are destinations in their own right - schools, malls, hotels, conference centers, connection to local bus and subway networks - everything within walking distance

I'm Dutch, and when I go to visit another city, I _always_ take the train. I don't even need to check if one's available because they're so frequent. But a major reason I'll always prefer trains over cars is because cars are so stressful. I don't think I could stand driving from one province to the next at night, tired out of my mind, while bright lights and loud cars are whizzing by at 120km/h. With trains, the only thing you have to pay attention to is when you're at your destination so you don't miss it - and when that's your train's final stop, even that is not really an issue.

@ceruleanstone

10 ай бұрын

Some people find driving relaxing or fun, though. Or both, especially on intercity road trips. I don't know if this applies in your case, but for many, gaining driving experience goes a long way to reducing the stress of driving. When I was a new driver, I found driving in downtown Toronto really stressful. But after a few years it was a piece of cake. Driving long distances at night when you're tired really sucks though--and can be very dangerous--so I avoid it whenever possible.

@MrSolLeks

10 ай бұрын

@@ceruleanstone i'm an outside sales rep for a company, I drive 75 to 100 miles a day. it's just normal for me around the Chicago suburbs and into parts of the city. I honestly can't fathom being stressed from driving at this point lol. I also love the flexibility a car has, do you need to get 2 weeks of food? easy. Do you need to transport any decent amount of equipment for your hobby? easy. There is no way I could go to the rifle range, or airsoft field on public transit, too much gear to carry easily and it all takes up a good bit of space.

@lsfornells

10 ай бұрын

@@ceruleanstoneSo why are you promoting cars on the streets again? People who like cars or driving them can always go to a circuit or participate in auto events

@lsfornells

10 ай бұрын

@@MrSolLeksYou obviously never experienced proper public transport. As I never experienced or seen a “rifle” or know exactly what its purpose is.

@ceruleanstone

10 ай бұрын

@@lsfornells The point of my comment was to illustrate just how wide the range of human experiences around driving can be, and that the way we experience it can change over time in response to the things we learn (or unlearn). Even if you're aggressively anti-car, this would be something you need to understand in order to effect the changes you want to see. Personally, I would rather have a wide range of transportation options available, including driving when I need to or when it's more convenient. And I'm fortunate to live somewhere that's highly walkable, and is pretty good for cycling, transit, and driving too. You might prefer to live in a car-free neighbourhood, which I could understand. Different people want different things.

It’s so nice being at a college in a city with actual public transit that works. My hometown was walkable, but some things were just impossible without a car, and when you got out to the urban sprawl suburbs? Forget about it

SAFETY is another factor worth considering. I love walking places and miss when I used to live in a really walkable city. Where I am now, there are places I go frequently that are close enough to my home in theory for me to walk to. There are sidewalks and crosswalks. But I don't feel physically safe being out alone walking down the street so I drive and park instead, reducing my stranger danger exposure to the shorter walk from my car to the building. And as Sabrina pointed out, when there are no sidewalks or when sidewalks are too close to traffic, that's also a HUGE safety concern. Additionally, I avoid public transit after dark bc of stranger danger. Which means if I'm ever out late, I have to take my car.

@Machodave2020

6 ай бұрын

That's actually the same problem that I have in Philly as well. In theory, I can get almost anywhere with SEPTA and walking but: 1). The area of the city I live in is terribly served at a local level as all of the buses are either county/suburban or crosstown routes. 2). Crime in Philly is so bad that you gotta always be on your toes even in broad daylight. 3). (This is mostly a Northeast problem) because there aren't really that many local routes, even though you can technically take a bus and walk, you might end up walking for a very long time - which is perfectly fine if you like walking, aren't carrying anything heavy, and the weather is on your side but this isn't always the case. And in some areas of the city, cycling isn't practical because it isn't always safe enough to do so (even with a bike lane). Edit: Unless you live in Center City, University City, or specific parts of South or West, you're going to deal with some or all of the problems mentioned.

@crishnaholmes7730

5 ай бұрын

@@Machodave2020do you like Philly overall

@Machodave2020

5 ай бұрын

@@crishnaholmes7730 yes because firstly, I'm from here - born and raised - so there's that. Second, the city still has some upsides to it (I.E, there's stuff to do here). Third, even with the problems, SEPTA serves the city okay - when it works, it works; at least it's better than Ottawa. Fourth, SEPTA is actually working on stuff to make transportation better - still won't be the best, but it will be way better. Lastly, in some areas of the city, it's pretty walkable and you can still cycle places. If you move to Philly, I suggest you get a car, a SEPTA Key (you can use your phone and debit card for SEPTA now, but the SEPTA Key gives you perks, so getting one is worth it), and use both - drive in areas where transit is shit, use SEPTA where transit is good.

@crishnaholmes7730

5 ай бұрын

@@Machodave2020 ok

As someone who lived in downtown Ottawa for six years I am CACKLING at everyone’s efforts to successfully navigate the city. I’ve never lived in another place that seems to REJECT NAVIGATION like Ottawa 😂😂😂 Also you should have done this challenge in the -30 C winter to really get the local experience 🥶

@RayWasAlreadyTaken

11 ай бұрын

right?! as a dutchy I was thinking, oh they're gonna go here cuz we have all types of navigation that's quality.. then like wait.. what, this city is.. special?

@niall_sanderson

11 ай бұрын

@@RayWasAlreadyTakenAs a lifelong Ottawa resident, “special” really is the best way to describe a lot of the nonsense that happens here

@mlmielke

11 ай бұрын

Ottawa isn't a grid city... that's already a major huge difference when trying to compare to any other major transit focused city.

@myrealusername2193

11 ай бұрын

@@mlmielkeI would still argue with that, it’s more like a bunch of grids in random spots and randomly rotated

@itsgonnabeokai

11 ай бұрын

​@@mlmielke most European cities aren't grid at all but public transport works great

I take public transport everywhere and everyone around me seems shocked when they realise that I actually like it - I really hope I can make it through life without ever needing to own a car.

@jasminelambert3753

11 ай бұрын

I don’t live in a city right now with good public transport, but I’m planning on moving somewhere that does next year. Every time I go on a trip to a larger city with public transport I always appreciate it and use it. Apple and google maps generally are really good at helping with the public transit navigation and I’ve always had pretty positive experiences any time and place I’ve used it. I don’t like driving and I’m hoping I can get rid of my car and solely rely on public transport when I move!

This rules, keep it coming 😍

Even when travel time seems to be shorter, there is not considered the travel time to public transit and the waiting time, especially when you get out of one ride and wait for the next. Often times it would not even make sense for me to leave work early because I am not even abled to get home.

As a European, I can say, that when you are not traveling huge distances, public transit easily wins the freedom contest. It runs - at least where I live - 24/7, so I can use it to go home even after a long party. If something comes up and plans change I don't have to worry about where I left my car, I can just use a different line instead. It is so convinient.

@THESLlCK

11 ай бұрын

As an American, it’s an impractical solution for most of the US landmass. It’s only viable in major cities, which are all unbelievably corrupt, and yet not at all efficient as a result. At least bribery gets things done in Europe.

@SSingh-nr8qz

11 ай бұрын

Take the state of Texas and overlay it over Europe and you will see the problem with your idea.

@maxresdefault_

11 ай бұрын

Someone tell England this, please

@danilooliveira6580

11 ай бұрын

yes, same here, sometimes, specially if you are going somewhere alone or with a friend, and not taking family, kids or old people, taking public transport is just SO much more convenient, its cheaper, you don't need to worry about finding a parking spot, you avoid the stress of driving, depending on the time or the lane you can even take a nap.

@ramppappia

11 ай бұрын

as an Eurpoean, I can say that only works if it isn't badly managed. hi from Rome still better than the usa's situation

Here in Norway the buses are pretty reliable, but the thing I love the most about it is the people you meet! Sometimes I meet multiple old friends on just a fifteen minute trip. Then I can have a little chat with them about how it's going and where they're going. It feels so great to have left the house to meet some friends and meet an extra friend unexpectedly on the way there. Public transport just brings people closer.

@bishop51807

11 ай бұрын

Really? I thought Scandinavians had a reputation for keeping themselves? Or is that the Swedish and or the Finns...help a brother out.

@danieldaniels7571

11 ай бұрын

When I ride public transit I mostly just encounter really dirty homeless people and low income working class people dreaming of the day they get ahead enough to buy a car.

@StijnDeWitt

11 ай бұрын

The problem with public transit is that it ONLY functions with STOLEN money. I understand you are going to deny that TAXATION EQUALS THEFT. Most people do. But there is no way around it. The government is taking my money, without my permission, under threat of violence. If ANY other party would do that, it would be called theft or robbery, but somehow, when the government is doing it, it is somehow okay and we call it tax instead... It's NOT ok. It's theft! The government is stealing my money and then spending it on something you want. Which makes you support it stealing my money. Which makes it impossible for me to resist it because there are so many like you that support government's ability to steal from its citizens. I like trains, but ignoring the fact that all of them are paid for with stolen money is too much for me. We will never be free as long as we permit government to structurally and methodically steal our money and call that taxation. And without taxes, public transport can not exist. It is wholly reliant on stolen money.

@ivarl5972

11 ай бұрын

@@bishop51807Just us Finns mate. The Norweigan's story about meeting lots of people on public transit sounds like a fairy tale to me...

@Richmondthefish

11 ай бұрын

Difference is in Norway people are civilized(Like say Japan)

I’m in the Orlando area. Driving to/from work takes about 25 minutes. The best transit option would take at least 3 to 4 hours and would involve walking or biking about four to five miles to the nearest bus stop. To just bike the entire way is estimated to take about 1.75 hours, fyi.

For me, in Albany Ga, public transit can be pretty problematic in and of itself. To add to that, where I live is technically just outside of the city limits, so the nearest bus stop is a forty minute walk from my house. Finally, I would say that I greatly enjoy driving. There's just something about it that improves my mood and eases my otherwise overburdened mind. It's soothing.

@DarkHarlequin

8 ай бұрын

I mean yeah if there's no public transit where you are public transit sucks 😅 Part of the Us public transit doom spiral. Public transit gets underfunded, it sucks or simply doesn't go where you are, you tak the car (cause you pretty much have to)... public transit gets even less funds cause 'everybody drives anyways'