As an Iranian with some reasonable knowledge about the Iranian religion, I am really impressed with the depth of correct knowledge this gentleman has about the case. I really enjoyed this great scholarly lecture, thanks.

Every Christmastime I have wondered this for more than 20 years. Thank you for finally answering my question.

I’m really impressed with this Pastor. He is actually honest about the birth of Jesus. He’s not trying to dance around the historical evidence.

@thetruthexperiment

Жыл бұрын

I don’t think preachers lie very much. They just aren’t very smart. I’m sure they lie to their wives sometimes.

@Kid_Ikaris

Жыл бұрын

​@@thetruthexperiment Would you agree though that it's more gullibility than stupidity?

@albusai

9 ай бұрын

​@@thetruthexperiment😅😅 you know them all

@ahmedmahmud4238

6 ай бұрын

These are theories. The factual reports say other wise. The theories are second guessing what history has reported. Believing a theory does not make one honest, unless you know as a fact that the theory is true. Which you dont. In other words your mistaking theories with historical facts.

@stephrichards4611

6 ай бұрын

I don't know if he's a pastor?

Thank you so much for these incredibly thorough and well-researched lectures. I’ve gotten more out of these than any traditional sermon. I feel so grateful for finding these-and right near me in Toronto, too. You are providing an antidote to fundamentalism that is so needed in today’s society. I cannot thank you enough for sharing your historical knowledge with us for free on KZread.

@kenramirez5782

2 жыл бұрын

Jesus the Christ was born on3AD September 11 you can check it out on KZread Dr. Michael Heiser What do the magi and the dead sea scrolls have in common another interesting thing to look at would be the evidence of the shroud of Turin

@nataliewantscookies

10 ай бұрын

Ditto ❤

@carlyabush

10 ай бұрын

@@nataliewantscookies I forgot I left this comment but this reply brought me back to this channel. I'm going to listen to some more lectures this weekend. Thank you, Natalie!

@albusai

9 ай бұрын

You talk as if being fundamental is a bad thing 😅😅 struggling to be like Jesus is never a bad thing 😅😅

@carlyabush

9 ай бұрын

@@albusai Of course it isn’t. But anyone who claims to be a follower of Jesus should understand the historical and sociological context that informed the New Testament.

This is a thoroughly intelligent, informative, humorous, candid and most entertaining lecture. Thank you.

@stephrichards4611

6 ай бұрын

I found it a waste of time

It is of particularly interesting that they called Magi. The Magi are what the Zorastians, the ancient religion of Persia, called their priests.

@artdanks4846

5 ай бұрын

Exactly right!

@Csio12

2 ай бұрын

ZOROASTRIAN

I want to move to Toronto from California just to be able to attend these lectures.

Absolutely enjoyed it, thankyou!

This is enlightening and done with a kind heart and open mind. What a great communication in today’s cynical world.

@chancehonotapu4380

2 жыл бұрын

this guy is wrong on all areas concerning the 4 Gospels, which are writing by 4 different people, with 4 different point of views? its not like, Jesus commanded his disciples to take out pen and paper and write as he speaks, but lessons through his Words... And Witnessing Miracles through his Works. (The Ministry of Jesus) Redemption for the Gentiles comes from the Blood, And we were given Grace by Faith in the redeemer with is Christ Jesus its more clear through Pauls Ministry which is still Ministring Today know as the Church Age...

@leesnyder9144

2 жыл бұрын

@@chancehonotapu4380 interesting

This was excellent. Great teacher!

@kenramirez5782

2 жыл бұрын

Check out Dr. Michael Heizer on KZread what do the magi and the squirrels have in common and another interesting KZread The shroud of Turin

I really like your words and your teaching thanks and I think is so true

Amazing!

I noticed that the text do not tell how many Magi came it just said Magi came but it did not say three

You are my go to nightly watch. I love all your lectures and have learned so much!! I love it!

@centre-place

Ай бұрын

Glad you like them!

Well done. I've been listening for quite some time to John lectures. It's mostly he who speaks and never has to refer to open texts in order to recite. Well educated. Knows his history combined with theology. Have to admit, I enjoy the lack of ads. I can fall asleep listening without needing to skip ads. A nice bonus

Super presentation. Enlightening.

These videos really bring out the crazies in the comments.

@bassinc3039

2 жыл бұрын

And here we are.

@nosuchthing8

2 жыл бұрын

Not so bad

@jojojacques810

Жыл бұрын

Crazy or awakened 😝

@kenlarson944

Жыл бұрын

You don't have to be crazy to watch youtube, but it helps

you must be a fantastic paster - love all your vids

Very good presentation. Congratulation.

Malekyoir could be mix of Hebrew and Persian; Melekh (King in Hebrew) and Yar( friend in Persian) . Keep in mind Shahyar is an actual Persian name that has been popular in Iran since Sassanid era

If when my son was born, wise men/hermits/princes turned up bearing rare gifts, I would remember it. But Mary tells her son to stop wasting time in the synagogue, and no-one in Nazareth seems to point to the adolescent Jesus and say " hey, that's the dude that those wise men visited." And did the family flee to Egypt, or stay in Bethlehem; can't be both.

@cindyb8504

6 ай бұрын

that’s because our Lord was not born in California

Sir you are a Great historian and a Good man

It's so funny to read so many comments that all think they know better than any other contemporary scholar could possibly know the events that happened over 2000 years ago. While we come up with all the various ways we think of the Magi, how can ANY OF US say or ant as if we KNOW what was what after +2000 years. Just enjoy learning someone else's view about the matter, no matter how different tp you'r own view, celebrate (or discount) the Magi as you set fit, and be within and enveloped by the Heart of our God of Light. Let one another have the views that are theirs, honor their ability to establish those for themselves, and enjoy your own views and what they mean to you. Knowing that you cannot know is more powerful than claiming you know all. And will help keep you humble as we're all should be.

we don't know the one true, pure, perfect, unadulterated truth - only what people wrote down and didn't destroy thru time

@dukadarodear2176

2 жыл бұрын

@lost No, you don't know the truth because there's no truth to know. It's ALL myth and legend. In fact it's more likely than not that Jesus, the "Christ" never existed as a real person. Grow up and do a bit more objective research.

@HOWBAZARY

2 жыл бұрын

The Heavens declare the glory of God. The Heavens being the Sun, Moon and the Stars. The Mazzaroth is a literal road map.

@kpwillson

10 ай бұрын

​@@dukadarodear2176historians generally support the idea that Jesus was a historical figure who did exist.

The tribe Mug (Mag), the priests of Zoroastrianism, came from Media (modern day Azerbaijan,) were proficient in many fields, such as astrology, medicine, spell, metallurgy . There are many toponyms related to Mugs still exist in Azerbaijan. In the book of Enoch the fallen angel Azazel thought people who lived in this area to all those things (spell, magic, metallurgy, crafts and so on)

@alibala4506

3 жыл бұрын

and the dreams interpretation

@Hermesborugerdian

2 жыл бұрын

Yes, however due the name of this Iranian median tribe, all Zoroastrians priests started being referred as Mogh (Magi in Persian) in all of Persia

@mehryaarvid

2 жыл бұрын

The moogooei tribe of Bakhtiari people are their descendants, in their folklores and everyday believes you see the trace of old believes. Mogu were a tribe

@HOWBAZARY

2 жыл бұрын

The Book of Enoch is ridiculous and not Biblical at all.

@alinajafi4644

2 жыл бұрын

@@Hermesborugerdian Yes ..... they were belonged to the "Dayre-Mogan" or club of Maggies.

After 1:15 :14 long video I did not understand who the Magi were. So who were the Magi?

@hulamei3117

Жыл бұрын

There were no magi. It's a story.

What a brilliant lecture!

A small point that sometimes gets lost in discussions - if the Persians had won their wars with the Greeks (Thermopylae, Marathon, etc) they would have overrrun Europe and Zoroastrianism would have spread throughout the continent as the state religion (Zoroastrian cults such as Mithraism were already popular with the Romans). Christianity would have probably never taken hold, certainly not to the extent it did, and Zoroastrianism would have been the major religion today instead of the almost-extinct status it has today. That's how history works - sometimes all it takes is a battle or two for humanity to change and go off in different directions.

@artdanks4846

5 ай бұрын

Very true, that this is how history works. And fortunately, God is the author of that history.

@budsurtees4224

5 ай бұрын

@@artdanks4846 "God" has nothing to do with this. Stop spewing mythological rubbish.

Can they write questions down to ask at the end so we can keep going

Thanks a lot for explanations scientifically

@ImJustOnePerson1

2 жыл бұрын

@lost why did you even watch this?

@HOWBAZARY

2 жыл бұрын

@@ImJustOnePerson1 Know your enemy.

@ImJustOnePerson1

2 жыл бұрын

@@HOWBAZARY The speaker not trying to hurt you. Okay, take a deep breath. It's going to be alright. You can be religious and he can try to explain it scientifically, you can coexist. It's okay.

@alinajafi4644

2 жыл бұрын

@@HOWBAZARY Enemy? Why is that ?

I hope you do a talk on the Bahai Faith and it's views and beliefs. Baha'u'llah talks about Zoroaster quite a bit. Lately I've started thinking Zoroaster was the beginning of the Magi.

@hime273

6 ай бұрын

Ahhh yes, Bahai: the Illuminati Religion.

@artdanks4846

5 ай бұрын

I used to be a Baha'i, and yes, we were taught that the Magi were Zoroastrian priests, that were following a Zoroastrian prophecy when they followed the star to find the Christ Child. I've never found any historical evidence to support that theory. But in a way it might make some sense. The Persian Empire had conquered the Babylonian Empire, where the Jews had been held captive for 70 years. The Persians released the Jews from captivity, allowing them to return to Israel. They were also monotheistic, being Zoroastrian. Many of the Jews chose to stay, so it's conceivable that the Persians could have been influenced by their religious beliefs. It may very well be that they understood enough of the Hebrew Prophecies about the coming of Messiah, to then follow the Star to where the Christ was.

So i guess Herod couldn't see the star? Thank You for this! Great work!

@jaredb9523

2 жыл бұрын

It's talkimg about space ship or plane just as primitives on islands would explain a plane. A star over the city.

@jaredb9523

2 жыл бұрын

@lost so if Jesus died and came back to life with eternal life where is he..? And where did he go? And how did he get there ? Jus vanished? If u say he died I can see how his spirit could travel somewhere but never during his life was he ever capable of teleportation why would he be able to after ? If he left it would have to be in some sort of vehicle unless we telling Santa stories..

@HOWBAZARY

2 жыл бұрын

@seeker No, it was a literal star. The Magi studied the Mazzaroth/Zodiac. Astronomy not Astrology.

@judithsmith9582

2 жыл бұрын

Herod was not an astronomer.

@christianpatriot7439

2 жыл бұрын

He could have seen the star, but not recognize its significance. His astrologers could have seen it, realized what it meant, but were too afraid of Herod to explain it to him.

Matthew's claim that the messiah was prophesied to be from Nazareth is a midrashic extrapolation from Isaiah 11:1 , "shoot from Jesse." "Branch" or "shoot" is "nitser". If you put in other vowels and semi-vowel performatives to NZR you can force out the "Nazareth" interpretation.

Hi John. Listened on this morning Wed. Aug. 2nd. Who Was Mary? Very interesting , Amazing how little there is on her. Liked very much. Thank you. Kathy from Ft. Collins, Coo. Congregation

Wonderful explanation of the contradictory nativity stories.

Greetings from Kaspar!

this is good

Good lecture, but if they were from different countries, why would they not go home?

Excellent lecture as always.

Brilliant video, thanks! Myrrh is the main ingredient in Chrysm, the holy oil used in anointing. It's still used in the UK to anoint new monarchs in the coronation ceremony, this part was considered too holy to be filmed in the 1952 coronation of Queen Elizabeth so it is was screened off. In a literal sense our monarchs are "Christs".

@mrbluesky5830

2 жыл бұрын

So presumably chrysm or chrism, is etymologially related to Christ. Both related to Greek words for anointing and anointed (of the monarch at the coronation). Which could be an alternative theory why Myrrh was one of the three gifts, rather than that given in the video about anointing the dead.

@yakamen

2 жыл бұрын

Is the office of king or queen not the head of the Anglican church? Because that makes sense to me.

@mrbluesky5830

2 жыл бұрын

@@yakamen yes, head of the Anglican church (also "defender of the faith" the title ironically given to Henry VIII by the Pope), and head of state.

@TorianTammas

6 ай бұрын

​@@yakamenKings and high priests in judaism were both annointed with oil. So all jewish kings and high priests were christs.

Last phrase was truer than anything said in church

@thetruthexperiment

Жыл бұрын

He’s in church.

Most people don't know but there was a fourth wise man He is not talked about much because he brought a fruitcake.

@lisaholloway5069

6 ай бұрын

😂

@janeeden919

6 ай бұрын

I would have taken a Madeira cake - cheap, but a crowd pleaser

Is this lecture in Australia? Would love to talk this speaker

@mandylynnalbert-nerud1235

2 жыл бұрын

Magi reminds me or my mind connects to the arpad dynasty. BC AD time seem to have been recorded by arc rulers of the time year lord

People quite frequently today report seeing ufos, whatever they are, and they would have been seeing them frequently in ancient times. And only a ufo would fit the scenario of being able to be followed, not a star. And also the scenario that ufos are explained away as stars or something so as not to be called crazy.

@rickmcentee9204

5 ай бұрын

Oh thank God I'm not the only one who thinks this...! 🏆

1:06 :00 minor point but I think the Chinese have historically (and even now to an extent) make you go back to your family's hometown for certain government things. I think it is called hukou

@Dhsu4321

Жыл бұрын

Hukou is a modern invented system and not being implemented in ancient China.

@TorianTammas

6 ай бұрын

The romans did not. By the was Jesus is born under the hewish king Herod in one story and under Roman rule in the other story. Neither can be true as there is a ten year minimum gap.

i think i know why leaps of faith are so important now.

@yakamen

2 жыл бұрын

I think it was St. Augustine himself who said a leap of faith was required to overcome the intellect. That wasn't meant insultingly. After all, he was a brilliant guy, and just needed a way to connect with God.

@hulamei3117

Жыл бұрын

Very lengthy leaps required

Matthew's quotes about Nazareth and Nazarene is hotly debated, and there are many other sources that defend and make sense of this position. We should not expect the lecturer to know everything about the full mystery of God, or to lay out every single position in such a short space of time. Don't take everything he says as 'gospel' but do your own research. This has been great for me as his challenges to my belief made me search for the truth, and my faith is not swayed. Many church fathers were aware of some of the discrepancies but they were not swayed ultimately.

Clearly you are a Loki variant

@yiannimil1

2 жыл бұрын

que loki?

@omarandangelaanderson6490

2 жыл бұрын

@@yiannimil1 iioooooooooooooiiiiooiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiooiiiiiiiiiiiooiiiooiiooiiiioo lol lol n

@CrrrashnnBurrrn

2 жыл бұрын

Nailed it

@d.m.hubble2591

2 жыл бұрын

Clearly

@brianarnold4819

2 жыл бұрын

@@yiannimil1 the devil.

I'm playing this and he says epiphany was yesterday , thats correct , two years ago and today

Indeed there is definitely a reform during this time...particularly away from animal/human sacrifice

@annepreciado4157

2 жыл бұрын

Plus a move away from several gods to monotheism

@annepreciado4157

2 жыл бұрын

Thanx for the info, btw😊

Huge omission, It was the Persian, Zoroastrian Empire that liberated the Jews from Babylonian conquest, slavery. Osmosis of Zoroastrian ideas into The Old Testament was not a result of casual encounters with neighboring religions.

@thegardener8972

2 жыл бұрын

There were numerous decentralized copies of the writings of Moses way before the Persians ever liberated the Israelites. They were the only monotheistic religions at the time and that’s why King Cyrus allowed them to return.

@jant4741

2 жыл бұрын

@@thegardener8972 Zoroastrianism forbid slavery is why liberated. Never read your theory before. Close to a 1000 years before liberated, Egyptian Pharaoh Akhenaton was already monotheistic. Believe he was contemporary of Moses, possibly step brothers. Zoroastrianism predates both of them. Mosaic law, how much was penned by Moses is debated by scholars, and Moses certainly did not author the entire Old Testament.

@andrewsuryali8540

Жыл бұрын

The Jews in Babylon were not slaves. Ezekiel's story makes that clear. Their lower classes were resettled as farmers along the river. Many of their elites served the royal court of Babylon as elites too. The Babylonians even let the House of David set themselves up as exilarchs, a position they kept well into medieval times. When Zerubabbel, born and raised as a noble in cosmopolitan Babylon, was sent off to rebuild Jerusalem he probably wasn't too happy about it.

Interesting that Isaiah 60 actually talks specifically of people from the islands, then mentions Sheba, Kedar, Tarshish of people going to Jerusalem. Isaiah talks quite a bit of these isles of the East. Not sure if scholars just want to ignore this or really don't think of it.

@25centsworth

2 жыл бұрын

Strong's H339 - 'iy It means an habitable land, distinguishable from the sea or a river.

@robertvidal3935

2 жыл бұрын

@@25centsworth The reference to “ships” would distinguish it from a land locked land like Kansas, would you agree?

@25centsworth

2 жыл бұрын

@@robertvidal3935 If you are referring to Isa 60:9, 'the ships of Tarshish', I think it's safe to assume that the city of Tarshish, wherever it was located, was a port city west of Jerusalem.

@robertvidal3935

2 жыл бұрын

@@25centsworth Isaiah 24:25 “East”, “islands of the sea”.

@25centsworth

2 жыл бұрын

@@robertvidal3935 There is no Isa 24:25. And, 'islands of the sea' is in Isa 11:11. Read it again. There is no 'east' mentioned relative to it.

A Blessed Christmas Day to Everyone!!! 🙏 “And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us, and we beheld His glory, the glory as of the only begotten of the Father, full of grace and truth.” -John 1:14 “Thanks be to God for His indescribable gift!” -2 Corinthians 9:18 “He’s the King of the Jews He’s the King of Israel He’s the King of Righteousness He’s the King of the Ages He’s the King of Heaven He’s the King of Glory He’s the King of Kings and He is the Lord of Lords Do you know Him? He’s the wellspring of wisdom He’s the doorway of deliverance He’s the pathway of peace He’s the roadway of righteousness He’s the highway of holiness He’s the gateway of glory He’s the master of the mighty He’s the captain of the conquerors He’s the head of the heroes He’s the leader of the legislators He’s the overseer of the overcomers He’s the governor of governors He’s the prince of princes He’s the King of Kings And He’s the Lord of Lords That’s my King Do you know Him?” His Name is Yeshua… Jesus! If you do not know the LORD, please do not wait another moment... “Behold, now is the accepted time; behold, now is the day of salvation.” -2 Corinthians 6:2 None of us knows how long we have on this earth. The only opportunity we are guaranteed to have is right now... A: Admit you have Sinned
 “For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.” -Romans 3:23 “For the wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord.” -Romans 6:23 “If we confess our sins, He is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.” -1 John 1:9 It is tough to admit that we are wrong. Even before God, we feel we are basically good, and we would like to think we are never as bad as some... we are ALL sinners and can never be good enough to earn our own way to heaven. Jesus spoke to the scribes and Pharisees saying, “Serpents, brood of vipers! How can you escape the condemnation of hell?” -Matthew 23:33 They believed that faithfully following rituals and traditions would get them into heaven. We are all like those scribes and Pharisees when we believe we can save ourselves by good works or following religious rituals and traditions. That path takes us to one place only... hell! Please listen, there is a way... The ONLY WAY... B: Believe in Jesus our Savior 
 “For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life. For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved.” -John 3:16 -17 “So they said, “Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and you will be saved, you and your household.” -Acts 16:31 “And this is His commandment: that we should believe on the Name of His Son Jesus Christ and love one another, as He gave us commandment.” -1 John 3:23 “For by grace you have been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves; it is the gift of God, not of works, lest anyone should boast.” -Ephesians 2:8 -9 Salvation is not complicated. Jesus said, “Assuredly, I say to you, whoever does not receive the kingdom of God as a little child will by no means enter it.” - Mark 10:15 A child simply puts their trust (faith) in their parents protective arms. Likewise, we entrust our life to Jesus our Savior, believing on Him and His finished work on the cross. The Apostle Paul defined the message of the Gospel (good news) like this- “...that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, and that He was buried, and that He rose again the third day according to the Scriptures,” - 1 Corinthians 15:3 -4 Jesus, the perfect, sinless lamb, the Son of God, laid down His life and took the death penalty meant for us, dying in our place (read Isaiah 53:6 ). He paid the debt we could not pay and redeemed us (bought us back) from the power of sin and death. (read John 1:29 / Galatians 3:13 / Romans 3:25 ) C: Confess Jesus is Lord and Savior “...that if you confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus and believe in your heart that God has raised Him from the dead, you will be saved. For with the heart one believes unto righteousness, and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation.” -Romans 10:9 -10 “The LORD is not slack concerning His promise, as some count slackness, but is longsuffering toward us, not willing that any should perish but that all should come to repentance.” -2 Peter 3:9 God fulfilled His promise, sending His one and only Son to die in our place. He has offered us the most precious gift-salvation, the forgiveness of sin, eternal life with Him in heaven. BUT…we must receive that gift. We must confess our sins (read 1 John 1:9 ) and proclaim our faith (belief) in the death, burial and resurrection of God’s only begotten son, our Savior Jesus. Confessing with our mouth requires an outward, public action, not a secret, hidden, timid faith. The Apostle Paul boldly proclaimed his faith so that others could hear and be saved. God’s plan of salvation is freely offered to everyone. If you are not familiar with prayer, it is simply talking to God openly and honestly. Remember, the Bible says we are saved by grace through faith. God sees our heart. We are not saved by simply saying some special words in a formal prayer. We are saved when we reach out by faith, admit our sin, repenting from believing our actions save us to belief in Jesus and His sacrifice for us, confessing Him as our Lord and Savior. Saving faith produces a forever changed life. The Bible is God’s message to us. It’s readily available even online. Please read it. Your death penalty has been paid- you have been pardoned... The choice is yours to accept it or not. We’re all headed to one of two places - heaven or hell. Will you please accept the LORD’s gift of love today? “Likewise, I say to you, there is joy in the presence of the angels of God over one sinner who repents.” - Luke 15:10

@autumn5852

Жыл бұрын

Speak fir yourself because we don’t all find it difficult to admit we’re wrong and we don’t all think we’re good and we (not all of us) definitely don’t think we’re better than others 🤔 are you a narcissist? - Because otherwise why do you find it hard to admit when you’re wrong and why would you ever think you’re better than somebody else? 🤔 it sounds like you’ve definitely got some kind of mental health problem.

Gustav Fechner developed an Avestic Christianity. He wrote a book called the Little Book of Life After Death. He is considered to be a pioneer in psychology and also inspired one of the greatest mathematicians in human history Bernard Riemann.

Great historical lecture and demeanor Sir!

I thought this was about Magi...where exactly from and the purpose!

The three kings lived in Iran for years preaching to people . There toms are still near to kashan’s city

The flaw in historical investigation is that it is never settled. All assumptions are arrived at on the review of scantily available evidence. Should more evidence be uncovered that potentially affects the previous assumption. So on and so forth. It is a far more sober approach to take the experts viewpoints with a grain of salt. It is never in their place to be entirely sure as their line of work doesn't allow that. Rather it promotes enquiry and inquisition more than delivering final answers. Experts are prone to bias. Why would Josephus, who lived later, be a more credible source of the historicity of Jesus than his eye witnesses? Is it because he was a historian, and therefore credible, or that he wasn't a Christian? Luke was a Greek doctor who lived in the time of Jesus. Is his account not weightier than Josephus's who has no other corroborating contemporary?

@taylorjensen2787

2 жыл бұрын

The gossiple of Luke is from a Greek doctor?

Thank you for your presentations very very informative. In the case Balthazar, Balthassar what were the identifying features to distinguish "Arabs from "Africans" if possible?. Why would Western projection of ethnicity have anything to do with it?

The Persians were a branch off of the Corded Ware culture. Apocalypse is also found among the Germanic branch of the Corded Ware, etc.

It's a form of syncronism that this Video is increse in numbers of views

Myrrh was actually a well known contraceptive at the time. So they brought money, perfume, and contraceptives...lol

@hulamei3117

Жыл бұрын

Lol

The most interesting description, In my opinion, of the three wise men is in the novel BEN HUR by Lew Wallace. They are described as hermits, one from Egypt, another from Greece and the third from India, who each had an epiphany which led them to Bethlehem guided by a star...

@bobbybrooks4826

2 жыл бұрын

Book publishing is no different than newspapers magazines radio and TV... Total squat controlled garbage

@bobbybrooks4826

2 жыл бұрын

Interesting as in insane?

@budsurtees4224

11 ай бұрын

Rubbish. Please stop gaining your knowledge from historical novels and movies.

@TorianTammas

6 ай бұрын

We are living on a rotating planet. So the idea to follow a star to a village shows that people have no idea of orientation. In reality magoi are persian priests who read the stars as messages from the gods. So if a great king is born under a certain star conjunction they exoect it to hapoen again under the same conjunction dozens of years later. Tgey were a kinf of astrologers with a firm base in the belief that the will of persuan gods is shown in the stars.

🔥 Zoroastrians priests honoring Jesus at his birth makes perfect sense. 🕎Judaism teaches that there is NO Devil and what appears to be evil, is actually G-d concealing Himself. Jesus put himself in opposition to Judaism with his Devil theology. But the 🔥Zoroastrians advocated him.

Myrrh is a gum-resin extracted from a number of small, thorny tree species of the genus Comephorid. Myrrh resin has been used throughout history as a perfume, incense and medicine. Myrrh mixed with posca or wine was common across ancient cultures, for general pleasure, and as an analgesic. Not necessarily for embalming.

Historians associate Caspar with King Gondophares (AD 21 - c. AD 47) mentioned in the Acts of Thomas. Thus One of the magi may have been a delegate of the same Indo Parthian king

who is the speaker ?

They was the size men the occultist from ancient time's magician means wise man a man who understands nature laws and occult law's. It's that simple.

@Peter-ci1zw

2 жыл бұрын

Unfortunately so was your sentence

@Jacob-sb3su

2 жыл бұрын

Learn how to type

@jjbentley9

2 жыл бұрын

@@Jacob-sb3su it's called automatic correction and sending it too soon. But thanks grammar police.

@lewisham

2 жыл бұрын

Or you know, Zoroastrian priests.

@jjbentley9

2 жыл бұрын

@@lewisham that's the same thing as a wise man. Yes lol it gos through out all cultures through out Time.

The prophets would be called mediums or chandeliers at this time. Was the Bible written through automatic writing or just from the prophets experiences?

I think this a misunderstanding of Persian policy. Even after 200 years of rule in Bablyon, chaldean religion was still thriving there. Same with Canaanite religion and egyptian religion. U really don't get an empire with a policy of religious exclusivity until the time of the roman Constantine 500 years later.

According to ihe Bible how many of the magi were there?

The professor sounds like he's still in his twenties

@grlpeterson

2 жыл бұрын

Going into 60s.

Bethlehem was a mere village back then. There's no reason to expect Josephus or any other writer to mention the murder of a few dozen, at most, children, especially if Herod did not publicize why he ordered it.

@ivermectin7928

2 жыл бұрын

Derp derp derp. Fictional stories by fiction writers.

@kaloarepo288

2 жыл бұрын

The story of Herod murdering children actually refers to the fact that Herod actually murdered his own sons (by princess Mariamne)because he feared that they and their Jewish mother were plotting to overthrow him.Herod himself was not Jewish but his wife was -of the Jewish royal dynasty of the Hasmonaeans so Herod's sons,having a Jewish mother,would have been more entitled to the throne than Herod himself.

@fantasia55

2 жыл бұрын

@@kaloarepo288 Herod murdering his own sons shows that he would not have hesitated to kill a few dozen peasant children.

@marietteestabrook4098

5 ай бұрын

Killing his own kids would have been newsworthy by Josephus. Nobody liked Herod.

King is a spiritual title, the highest state of consciousness, as Yeshua was also called a king. It derives from the crown or aura that emanates from the head of the enlightened, art depicts this aura as a halo.

@JohnBrown722so

2 жыл бұрын

Oh also the Maya knew about it it's almost like how the Statue of Liberty is depicted with you could actually see almost like I guess horns or rays beaming off one's head connected to a spiritually enlightened beings.

@kilowhiskeyalpha6078

2 жыл бұрын

@@JohnBrown722so Yes it is the crown and also the origin of unicorn, the spikes are known as horns and the Greek word for horn is Cornus. People who are thought to be divine are also depicted with horns like Moses or Alexander the Great.

@kilowhiskeyalpha6078

2 жыл бұрын

@@JohnBrown722so Yes it is depicting the crown of an enlightened being. The spikes or rays are called horns and the origin of the word unicorn the Greek word for horn is Cornus. Revered persons who are believed divine are also depicted with horns for the same reason people such as Moses or Alexander the Great.

@herzkine

2 жыл бұрын

@@kilowhiskeyalpha6078 correct me if i am wrong but thats a latin word, but incorrectness like this fits the General pseudo enlightened babble here.

@herzkine

2 жыл бұрын

King is also a word from the german language tree, and if there was some special concept beware how much gets lost in translation. Bit easy you put it here, it like the " word " in the which was Logos in greek , which already was translated and still had more the meaning of thought or concept. Same here with the word King, to apply it to a concept of the hebrew word is neglecting simple at Best.

For the first century Jews, was the 2nd Temple more a symbol of fear or of hope?

The Idumeans fully converted to Judaism🕎 in the generation before Herod, and were eventually absorbed into the Jewish people leaving no trace. They converted because the Jewish king Hyrcanus conquered them and ordered them to either leave the Land of Israel, or convert to Judaism. So they converted to Judaism🕎, but remained among themselves. Read Josephus' "Antiquities of the Jews," book XIII, chapter IX.

Astrologically it would be about by the positions of the stars at the time could have come to a conclusion that at a certain time or date someone like jesus that they were expecting would be born, by some sort of natal chart interpretation of the stars at that time.

He says that Satan didn't exist in the early Jewish religion, but I'm wondering, what about the Satan, or adversary in the book of Job?

since there was no star, I guess "wise" meant something way different back then... like screwed up on hashish

28:05 The Parthian Empire which ruled Persia at that time had no state reøigion. Zoroastrianism appeared to become a state religion by Sassanids.

The Magi saw the child in a house ... he was not a baby in a manager. The child was a year or two old. That’s why Herod slaughters all male children 2 and under. 💕🐝

@TheRobdarling

2 жыл бұрын

Too bad Herod never slaughtered the children... lies.

@STho205

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheRobdarling said who, Herod Antipas, Chiaphas, Herod the Great, the Bethlehem Phone Book.... Biden said there were no Americans left in Afganistan that wanted to leave....and that his soldiers didn't murder an aid worker and car of rescued children because they saw him on surveillance cameras fill plastic bottles with water thinking it was nitro. Not saying they did or didn't, but kings and generals... ordered the execution of young children throughout history.

@ivermectin7928

2 жыл бұрын

@@STho205 Dummy. Historical evidence shows Herod never slaughtered children. You trust a fictional book over actual historical evidence. That says a lot about your mentality

@STho205

2 жыл бұрын

@@ivermectin7928 we love you Herod. In a time of mass murder by various states, people killed in arenas for entertainment and Herod despised by his own people as being cozy with these mass murderers... Herod senior was just this misunderstood guy who never hurt a fly.

@marietteestabrook4098

5 ай бұрын

No way was there a star guiding them, then. Stars don’t stay in one place!

I’m curious why no one makes any connection between the ancient Phoenician “bee kings” priests to Ishtar/ Astarte/ Venus, known as the Essenes, the Gnostics, the Sophists (Sophia is “wisdom” in Greek) rhetoricians of Greece that caused the death of Socrates, could also be of the same group as the “wise men” or “ three kings”, and also the scribes, the lawyers, the sopherim, that Jesus accuses along with the Pharisees as false interpreters of the law, There were 3 sects of Jewish leadership in Jerusalem at the time of Jesus according to Josephus: The Sadducees The Pharisees And the Essenes I believe the Essenes were the perpetuators of the written law, but manipulated the understanding of it through ecumenical councils, that outwardly appeared righteous, but were inwardly greedy for wealth, power, and prestige.

Merci

Not only did Nazareth give the baby Jesus a town to call home but Nazareth also gave the world one of the greatest Rock groups of the late 1960's and into the 1970's.

We should read the same books sometimes.

Zoroaster was a Brahman and came from the Indus valley. Brahman was what the descends of Abraham were called this is confirmed in the last book written by Issac Newton. In the first chapter of Malichi it says everyone except the Jews are offering good sacrifices to the lord. Which means Zoroaster taught everyone about Mithra was more correct than the Jews not teaching about a coming Messiah.

"I'm herry happy that you all rerembered" - OK, thanks.

The oldest surviving manuscript (K1) of an Avestan language text is dated 1323 CE. There was certainly an ancient Persian religion that used some symbols and god names found in Zoroastrianism that goes back to darius or before. But I think we need to be carefully about the EXACT traditions and beliefs we apply to that ancient religion. Just because the 14th century avesta uses the same god names does NOT mean the none of the religious beliefs changed one iota between 1000BC to 1300AD. 2000 years is a long time. Or does the oft talked about "game of telephone" only apply to Christian texts?. It is possible Zoroastrianism borrowed material from Christianity and Judaism. Evidence for that would be the some of similarities found in the Avesta to the Christ story. Written copies of the Christ story PREDATE the copies of the avesta we have, so it is illogical (and a violation of the methods of modern historical scholarship to try to apply the influence in the opposite direction.

24:34 , The lady was asking a very good question about the remains being authentic when St. Helena procured them. One thing you have to know is that Helena being the mother of Roman Emperor hold a very good position of getting authentic items. For one thing, she would have her own team of experts who would investigate the actual claims that these artifacts are authentic. I would imagine when the Magi went back to east(Persia), their story of visiting Jerusalem and meeting the baby Jesus to give offering/homage would be something out of the blue for most Persians. I'm assuming these Magi were of upper class as they obviously were of scholar/priest/nobility, their death would put them in a well marked grave. Mind you, Christianity wasn't even a thing when these Magi died and it only took off after the death of Christ and the spread of Jesus's teaching by the Apostles to several hundred years. To a Persian, the grave of the Magi wouldn't have any meaning or significance. Frankly, the significance of the Magi would only be known to the most upper Christian scholar as Bible wasn't put together until the 5th century and not until 1500's the printing press was available to the masses.

@acupofwhitetea

11 ай бұрын

She is also a woman of power, since she is the mother of the Roman Emperor. If those "experts" denied her claims they would have gotten in trouble with her son and get punished. These experts also know that fact, so they most likely go along with whatever stuff St. Helena said to get good points with the family of the emperor or they are just as much of a religious zealot as St. Helena so they are already biased from the beginning. One thing to know about Roman/Greek literature is that sometimes the biographers have a tendency to add foreshadowing stuff even if it most likely didn't happen because it makes it sound more exciting, it's a literary trope like the Chekov's gun.

@polishherowitoldpilecki5521

10 ай бұрын

They were very likely Persian Zoroastrian priests, known as the magis/magos. Some Bibles record that they claimed that they were from the land of the sun possibly Iran/Persia. As Iran is known as the land of Sun and lion. Some bibles also claim that they were there to fulfill a prophecy given to them by their prophet. In Zoroastrianism, there is prophecy relating to a prophet called the saoshyant or Astvatereta Who according to their prophecy, was supposed save the world Unfortunately Zoroastrian sources and important documents were burned during the Islamic conquest of Iran. leaving us very few documented sources of Zoroastrians

@mgcocasal

6 ай бұрын

I'm sure they told her what she wanted to hear.

@TorianTammas

6 ай бұрын

@sangkang6294 It is very simple if their is a market for selling parts of spaceships thrn you can buy them. The same for parts if the christian story. We have 4 frenulums, had half a dozen full burial shrouds and a lot more. It ws a great market and the demand created new items every day.

Doesn't it say The Child greeted the Maji at the door? Not as an infant?

@marietteestabrook4098

5 ай бұрын

No way was there a star then.

In the History book of Herodotus, Astyages, the last king of the Medes, tells the Mags about a dream in which he had dreamed that his grandson Cyrus I, who was born from the marriage of his daughter Mandane to the Persian commander Cambyses, would dethrone him, and the Medes said that they were not Persians as follows: "The Maglar said: O king! We are also very interested in the preservation of your sovereignty; for otherwise your kingdom will pass from your nation to this son (Cyrus I) of Persia. In this case we, the Medes, will be enslaved, and since we are of different blood, We will never be taken into account by the Persians" (Source Herodotus, IV, 37) The Medes are Turkish nobles, definitely not Persians. Herodotus explained the differences (language, religion, clothing, culture, social behavior, morality) between the Medes and Persians in his book History. These definitions connected the Medes with Turkish culture. Persians are a nation that came from Northern India later. Maglar (Magos/Magus -> Magi) is one of the tribes that formed the Medes. From these come clergy, scholars and statesmen.

Magi r Chaldean from Babylon. Magi in Aramaic means astrologer. The east is always referencing Babylon not Persia.

@dannymack9636

2 жыл бұрын

They actually might have been instructed through the ages until Jesus was born by Daniel, it may have been one of the things Daniel had to seal up until the end days. Any how I agree they came from Babylon or Persia and Daniel's teachings or instructions has a lot to do with it. God bless you mate.

@Hermesborugerdian

2 жыл бұрын

The word went from Persian into Aramaic later, on however it strictly refers to Zoroastrian priests. Mogh was one of the many Iranian tribes who chose the priests which is why they gave their name to this entire class of people

@bass9351

2 жыл бұрын

@@Hermesborugerdian other way round Chaldeans were the teachers in that whole region after the empire fell persian ruled and they used persian instead of Aramaic

@Hermesborugerdian

2 жыл бұрын

@@bass9351 actually that’s not true, The Empire kept using Aramaic even under Persian rule, it’s just that the concept of Magi is a very Aryan concept that came from Persians, however I agree with you that astronomy was a Babylonian thing so the Association of astrology with the Persian Magis may had to do with Persians ruling over Babylon. However you must keep in mind that by the time Jesus is born the capital of Persia is Babylon and that’s the period that Chaldeans are declining and Babylon is known as a highly Jewish and Persian place.

@Hermesborugerdian

2 жыл бұрын

@Spolierman I’m pretty much agree with you, however keep on mind Persian province of Assurestan is basically Syria, while Mesopotamia was Ctesiphon with a high Persian and Jewish population by Sassanid era

There were a few herods in the bible. Herod the great, herod archelau, herod of antipas

Magus or magi is a magician or someone who practices magic, or anything seen as a mystery by the people which would include astrology or even astronomy at the time.

Strange that they are praised when they likely used astrology and divination to determine when and where they should go.

The Gospel of Luke tells us that when Christ was presented at the Temple in accordance to Mosaic Law, when He was 40 days old, Anna and Simeon were in the Temple waiting for him. If they had seen the Messiah, I don't see how they would have remained quiet about it. This would have alerted Herod. I say this happened after the Magi had already met Herod, and the news from Anna and Simeon would have made Herod realize that the Magi had left for home without reporting back to him as he had ordered them to do. So Christ was still an infant when the Magi visited Him.

@Idkjustyet

Жыл бұрын

I can’t find in the Bible what your talking about 😢

@autumn5852

Жыл бұрын

@@Idkjustyet Luke 2

@holyleague8286

Жыл бұрын

@@autumn5852 Luke 2: and ?

@ronjohnson4566

8 ай бұрын

Don't you think it's a little odd that a day after your god was born the guys from persia showed up to worship him. That's better than Mussolini keeping the trains on time.

@artdanks4846

5 ай бұрын

​@@ronjohnson4566 Actually, it was more like 2 years after Christ's birth when the Magi showed up.

Why would the 3 be found in Persia? Didn't they each go back to their own countries and die there?

Is that traditionally there are three gifts; the gold, frankincense and myrrh, potentially a theological allusion to the Trinity?

@letsomethingshine

2 жыл бұрын

All three represent the focuses of religion. They can represent what religion is worth in metaphor. Gold is old and valuable, like religious truth. Frankinsense is beutifying and sense-appealing, like religious ritual. Myrrh is hard/bitter and effective, like religious work. Gold is an old king (should be yellow, lol). Libanos is a young white king. Myrrh is a mid-aged brown king. Yellow, White, and Brown. Truth. Beauty. Work. A story can highlight the point, but obviously a story can also confuse it. 1. Gold is a precious metal which is hardly a weapon (the worst weapon really), so it is used by priests/rich as decoration because it lasts does not tarnish and so the military men do not break down the religious icons etc during times of war (when weapon metals are needed). As such, gold "appeals toward supernatural/eternal reality (aka the world is violence but religion is lasting peace)" Gold is thus tested by fire (purity) and water (density), to reveal it's eternal truth. 2. Frankincense means "true/pure/best incense." But the Greek word used was "Libanos" which means "white" or "Lebanon" and indeed was the name of resin from Boswellia trees spice/incense pain-reliever from the Lebanon area. Such "Lebanese incense" would have been used in religion a lot, especially where people didn't shower and the homeless where allowed entrance. Take that for what you will. As such, white incense "appeals toward making things appealing" Frankincense/Libanos is thus used through burning it as sacrifice to attain something worth in the short-term. The incense was used in burnt sacrifices and obviously in cremations. 3. Myrrh is "bitter" brown colored resin from thorny trees. It could be made into oil used by religion to preserve things like in embalming the dead or oil-pickling (as opposed to vinegar pickling) of food. It could also be used as an incense. It is also a pain reliever. And was a main ingredient in Anointing oil (you anoint the sacrifices so they burn better, and you anoint the High Priest and the King so they "symbolize" that they are "sacrificing" by "serving the people as leaders" ). As such, brown oil "appeals towards making things that are perishable either perish better or last longer depending on the need."

@bass9351

2 жыл бұрын

Well said. Typical no 1 picks up on these specific things. GOD b with u

@luizverdecanna8023

2 жыл бұрын

It´s extremely complex, the anonymous author of Matthew wrote decades after Jesus death. Did he guess on behalf of Matthew that this narrative was the correct one. Nobody knew about Jesus when he was born then when he died they realized he was the Son of God, the author knowing that Matthew was a jew who followed the Hebrew Scripture tried to add the tradition into Jesus life. This also happened on Matthew 5:17 (“Do not think that I have come to abolish Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them.”) Jesus had nothing to do with the Laws he was a transgressor and total liberal, did not wash his hands before eating, did not accept tithe, embrace women, the leper, did not respect the Sabbath,, ate pork. INRI on the cross meaning "Jesus the King of Jews" romans put there because jews asked them to mock Jesus. Matthew pushed Jesus into the Old Testament, no wonder we call today the Religion "Judeo - Christian"

@dessiewatkins1006

2 жыл бұрын

It is more likely that the gold, frankincense, and mir were the required traditional gifts which dispossessed nobles offered to a foreign king as a way to gain peaceful assylum in that ruler's land. That is what stirred confusion over whether Herod's reign was truly appointed by God, since the Jews knew that Herod was appointed as King by authority of Rome, yet these noblemen did not offer him these gifts.

@STho205

2 жыл бұрын

@@luizverdecanna8023 Matthew is a symbolic code name. The gospels accepted into testament by later councils were not traditionally named. Read Isaiah and it associates the savior/deliverer... The reed that bends but does not break... With the three ritual elements. It is likely the medieval traditions of three wise men, instead of the unnumbered group in Matthew, were to symbolically cement the Trinity concept by symbolism. There were three gifts. Three sons of Adam Three sons of Noah to populate the cleansed by water Earth God, the Son of Man and The Comforter European scholarly leaders were also very tied to Socrates and Plato with the Earthly symbolism of the perfect unseen thing. Also the Plato assertion that all men were born evil through their original essence. Now go read the second book of The Republic about the fate of a essence pious man that appeared in the City.... And what happens to him. A little story/parable from 390bc.

I like the hypothesis that the man remembered as Jesus was actually Herod the Great's first-born son, Antipater II. Herod promised his kingdom to Antipater who perhaps told everyone what he planned to do as king, outraging the Judean hierarchy and threatening his father's reign. Perhaps Rome gave Herod the choice of having his son executed or losing his kingdom. The painful illness that drove Herod to commit suicide seems to be not being able to live with having made such a ghastly choice. This hypothesis makes the story of Jesus plausible. It explains why the story was momentous enough to remember, and why it was mythologized in such a way. It explains the authority Jesus had even as a child, and it provides a reasonable basis for the Davidic claim. It also explains the information gap in the life of Jesus between childhood and adulthood, (Antipater with his mother, Doris, were banished from Herod's court for most of his life).

@luisaarevalo3784

2 жыл бұрын

After watching this video, I wonder if Antipater was Herod's prophesized trophy as opposed to being his actual son. Perhaps he was (reluctantly) identified as an infant to Herod, by Costobar, husband of Salome, who may have been memorialized as John the Baptist.

@kamion53

2 жыл бұрын

Wasn't that a theme in Robert Graves novel King Jesus? I remember quite a bit of mumbojumbo that told you Antipater was the actual father of Jesus. Graves was a bit the Dan Brown of his day.

@luisaarevalo3784

2 жыл бұрын

@@kamion53 I'm not familiar with the novel except for seeing it listed on the Wikipedia page for Antipater II. The hypothesis I outlined is more or less my own.

@STho205

2 жыл бұрын

@@luisaarevalo3784 so you are Joseph Smith, hopefully you'll find the golden leaves buried near your home...just kidding. Mark (The gospel codenamed Mark) simply starts with Baptism as the ministry step 1 and ends with a ressurected departing Christ leaving instruction to all followers to get baptized and believe in God. That gospel does not go into Jesus' backstory, and seems the most basic and direct 1st century account.

@luisaarevalo3784

2 жыл бұрын

@@STho205 I don't need no stinking golden plates.

Sages would have studied & that would likely be in Alexandria Where the great library would have been & likely Organized from the area they would have been astronomers getting enlightment & attending symposiums at the great learning centers there as many great or learned men did or those in the fields of seeking enlightenment did so by being near the Great Library of Knowledges gathered in Alexandria as educated or enlightened learned men they could have rose to the statures named