I always like to imagine that Allison is making Phelan do these charmed reviews by gunpoint. Having a real Leo and Piper moment.

Fun fact: the girl in the phone booth was Ashley Tisdale

Alright, who brought my Prue back from the dog?

Can we talk about how Phoebe just blindly believes in Cole, but then when she witnesses him being magically manipulated into killing the witch, she just will not listen to reason? Or how Cole NEVER tells his supposed "best friend" about his father's soul being held captive? The writing is just so flaky and unintelligent and inconsistent.

You mean the episode isn’t about Prue becoming a dog with a bad CGI mouth when she talks? Aww man, talk about a missed “pawportunity” lol

I would have loved it if Prue and Piper had told Phoebe "You're not allowed to write in the book anymore" after seeing that horrendous entry.

The page on Cole’s human form always made me laugh. For a second there, I forgot that Phoebe’s suppose to be a 20-something woman and not a teenager/child. Not to mention the photo used lol.

Here's my new theory I just came up with: Phoebe never actually turned back from a banshee, hence everything she ever says and does from this point forward. 😆

I cannot believe I’m admitting this, but I once wrote a Charmed fan ficion under the pen name Prujo because of this episode. To my defense I as like 13/14. I don’t remember the details of the story, but I’m pretty sure it was a Prue/Cole story because I thought they way better chemistry.

The big arrows pointing to the human Cole photo are just hilarious. Like, DUH, yes Phoebe, we get it.

Allison reading off the line about cole liking jazz and fine wine is the best moment of the entire podcast series 😂

I am waiting for them to turn the page and read "Margoyle loves avocado toast and beat boxing."

The imagery of future witches trying to defeat Balthazar via tickles is fucking slaying me 😂

So did they ever tell Darryl he can stop looking for a dog?

This is why I miss Prue--she was a check on Phoebe's stupidity and defacing family heirlooms. It also sucked to lose Shannen since she wasn't afraid to criticize the show and took the initiative to take on more by directing despite the script's limitations (we can't blame her for French Stewart).

(rewatching the episode before watching the rewind) Oh my god, the investigator said about the guy who died in the beginning, "Yeah, his wife died a few months ago. Never did get over it."

I don't know why I care enough about this to correct it but 'blinking' is a specific type of teleportation that warlocks use, and it literally needs you to blink with your eyes - which is why they use flashbang-like potions in the episode they are fighting the warlocks to prevent them from escaping by blinking. What Cole uses is a type of demon teleportation referred to as 'shimmering' and is the most common type of teleportation amongst demons - although it seems to vary greatly in ability between demons regarding speed and distance you can cover, with Cole's shimmering allowing him to even time-travel at times.

Phoebe gets fanservice and Prue gets thrown under the bus. So business as usual.

That photo just screams: "I'm an actor, a singer, AND a living avatar of evil. I'm a triple-threat!"

Regarding the unorganized Book of Shadows: during the Nymphs just wanna have fun episode (which seems like a great candidate for a future podcast!) Paige makes an effort to categorize the book by colour coding it. To the dismay of Piper of course!