What is the worst call you have ever seen?

@Go_oilers

Ай бұрын

Also hello

@lesevesel2898

Ай бұрын

Every goal called back against Tomas Holmstrom. The man would have had at least 25 more goals added to his career easily.

@benguin_

Ай бұрын

When Tom Wilson broke Zach Aston-Reese’s jaw, and got absolutely nothing for it.

@davidhowell1415

Ай бұрын

The worst call for all sports was the legalization of sports betting with tax incentives for states that allow it. If the government can make more money if the favored teams lose the money comes in. It’s 100% rigged for game 7 in mlb, nhl, nba, soon to be wnba. The nfl has been rigged for decades now

@linuspatterson544

Ай бұрын

(I am a ref) I was refereeing a youth hockey tournament that was in town. I was crossing the blue line following play to the net-when I made eye contact with Jonathan Marchessault who was standing on the other side of the glass. He had just won the Stanley Cup & Conn Smythe roughly 3 months before that, and I came to a sudden stop as I was starstruck. While I was distracted, a team scored and when I heard the noise of players I turned around and waved off the goal. Obviously, it was a clean goal which ended up being overturned. But moral of the story is; it is very easy to be distracted by NHLer’s.

They handed out the new rule books written in braille so the refs can finally read it

@izaksmith538

Ай бұрын

😂

@Nsdus5676

Ай бұрын

That’s great

@Fallout3131

Ай бұрын

LOL

@mikekennedy4661

Ай бұрын

Everyone….go home. Tyler just won the internet.

@jasperflare

Ай бұрын

They should make it a audio book so they can listen for once since there blind to some calls

The goalie interference calls have been mind boggling this playoff season. I don't think any one has a real clue as to how the refs are going to call them one way or the other. It seems like they just flip a coin and it is either confirmed or not.

@moody9442

Ай бұрын

the rule depends on the betting line and if the betman like the team

@thezachster1234

Ай бұрын

canes fans know. The regular season we challenged for GI multiple times with varying levels of certainty of the outcome of the call. We lost almost every single challenge whether it was for our goalie or us scoring. It felt like we could literally never get it right.

Man. It really pains me to say this... but as a canucks fan since the early 90s that experienced the 2011 playoff miracle run, and as a result had a long burning hatred for the bruins and marchand... That was some bullshit and the bruins got fucked hard here. These officials at EVERY level (refs, video judges, Bettman, DoPS) need to be held accountable. This is a SPORT. That has RULES that people are paid to ENFORCE. At least TRY to make your fans think things aren't biased and rigged. Starting to look like the damn WWE with refs missing super obvious infractions and guys diving from the softest shit and drawing a penalty for it. It's becoming way too much

@gkarenko9593

Ай бұрын

Why are you holding that dog hostage?

@meelosh92

Ай бұрын

Fellow Canucks fan and I feel the exact same. Been watching the series against Florida, and Boston is getting screwed. Becomes difficult to watch, just gets to be a bit much. Go Canucks Go!

@RDChanse

Ай бұрын

but how many times was marchand not held accountable. the oilers and vancouver if soucy got a game for his hyman 100% shouldve got one im not an oilers or canucks fan. but the nhl is so biased when it comes to incidents with star players. i kinda get it you take soucy out for a game it doesnt change the game that much but hyman out for a game and oilers lose a top point producer. either way same type of incident but hymans was 100% intentional to the face. but like what RTH said you call all of it or non of it. if they truly cared about player safety mcdavid wouldve got fined for his slash, zadorov with his fine, hyman would get a game+fine soucy a game+fine.

@Earthboundmike

Ай бұрын

@@RDChanse I'd prefer that actually... it doesn't exactly set a good example. Winning at all costs isn't something I like teaching kids.

@Earthboundmike

Ай бұрын

That being said Zadarov was also a suspension not a fine, lol.

Trouba just won a leadership award... lol

@dabootvv

Ай бұрын

yeah, leading with his elbow :DD

@carlofontanello2415

Ай бұрын

Some people just love hating on the Rangers, that’s fine. I’m sure I hate whatever losing team you like. 😂

That Sam Bennett goal is nuts like how is that not interference

@thebigpicture2032

Ай бұрын

That’s easily the most egregious non call I’ve ever seen for goaltender interference. Blatant cross check that clearly stops Swayman as he is moving to his right to make a great desperation save. Maybe he wouldn’t have made the save but he deserved the chance to try. From a Florida fan.

@solarion9802

Ай бұрын

...and Bennett had ZERO business being in that game because he sucker punched Marchand the prior game causing a concussion. Now that the reverse angle has mysteriously been made available a day late...everyone can clearly see just how filthy that hit was and it was very plainly a suspension due to intent to injure. Not a Bruins or Panthers fan btw, but I'm struggling to understand the rules in this series when it seems like the rules don't apply to Sam Bennett.

@robjohnson3454

Ай бұрын

It was that’s the problem

I can never get over the dancing scrum between Boston and Florida lmao

@jason-hy8ci

Ай бұрын

Both teams afraid of getting that Infamous, Game Losing/ Winning "Stupid"....... EXTRA PENALTY.....Dun, Dun, DAAA!!!! 😲 Absolutely ridiculous behavior because of the ridiculous "Instigator" penalty. IMAGINE..... the NHL wants to be taken "Seriously" yet they have a Rule that mentally and physically handicaps Players and the course of the Game SO MUCH that you get images like that. Just Ridiculous. NHL deserves Everything............. it doesn't get. $$$

@Slayer_7666

Ай бұрын

Brazeau for the Bruins, didn’t see the number for the Panther, so. I personally wasn’t watching the game, so. This one is a mystery to me…but with all the hatred boiling over. It’s funny and nice to see such nonsense happening.

@jonrobles1468

Ай бұрын

They were auditioning for Dancing With The Stars.

I'm a Ranger's fan. If Truba had connected on that hit it would have been the trifecta of suspendable offenses. Elbow to the head. Leaving his feet. Intent to injure. I seriously doubt he would have played another playoff game this season, no matter how far they go.

Would it not make sense to keep the officiating the same through the regular season and playoffs? Then you should know what will and won't be called.

@RobTalksHockey

Ай бұрын

That makes too much sense

@donaldmcronald3543

Ай бұрын

As a leafs fan, please this lol seems like the NHL is trying to please the casuals in the regular season and then the playoffs going back to what the die-hards have loved for ever. And in the end everyone is confused about where the line is

@GlassJ0e

Ай бұрын

I might stay up past my bedtime to watch a regular season game if playoff rules went year round.

@Fallout3131

Ай бұрын

@@GlassJ0esame 😂

@dabootvv

Ай бұрын

@@RobTalksHockey thing is that playoffs get wayyy more emotional and if you'd call everything it would be 4v4 or 3v4 "all the time" :D

"Worst case Ontario" - Thank you for slapping us with my favorite Rickyism

The worst call I have ever seen was the 2017 Stanley Cup Finals Game 6 between the Penguins and Predators. After a shot on net by the preds, the ref blew the whistle because he thought Matt Murray had the puck but the puck was sitting in the crease. A Preds player banged the puck in and the refs waved off the goal because he had blown his whistle. As the pens fan I could not believe that they disallowed that goal

@ericrubin1719

Ай бұрын

It was Colton Sissons that scored. Yes , that is the worst call I ever saw \ heard.

The last 3 games at Boston have been decided by refs. First was the goalie interference on Boston when he literally was held over the shoulder by the D. next was the bennet cross check without goalie interference . Last night was the not goalie interference cause it was Florida’s player who actually lifted bobs stick. It’s a disaster

The worst call I’ve ever seen is one I remember vividly from the 1st playoff series between Tampa and Florida. The refs had been atrocious all series, but one call took the cake. Bolts player gets clipped and goes down, everyone knows a Bolts PP is coming, even the Panthers player goes and sits down in the box. Then out of nowhere, and without explanation, the ref makes the Panther leave the box and puts the guy he ran over in instead. Most bewildering thing I’ve ever seen

Sorry Rob, this dude spamming is the reason oilers fans get the bad rep, we’re not all that bad.

@Go_oilers

Ай бұрын

As fellow oilers fans I shall understand you I’ll start deleting

@Justthatguy1998

Ай бұрын

Lies don’t listen, they are all this bad if not worse

@dalriada

Ай бұрын

Most of us are just dudes who like hockey. Sorry some bad apples are hassling you.

@willsimank7676

Ай бұрын

Ya you are. Worse than leaf fans

@people3865

Ай бұрын

​@@willsimank7676But, nobody can ever stop talking about us Leafs fans! 😂😂😂

I love how many times you put this Brazeau Kulikov thing. It's the one positive from this series so far.

@jason-hy8ci

Ай бұрын

I would if the "LEAGUE" would see it so they would finally realize how Stupid the "Instigator Rule" is.

@lime7494

Ай бұрын

@@jason-hy8ci what

If they called crosschecking by the book, Most of the game would be played 3 on 3.

@thetruthhurts6652

Ай бұрын

So be it

The non-call on McDavid for high-sticking/sword-fighting Hughes was pretty amusing.

First period, about 9 : 20 minutes in, Panthers and Bruins game 5. Bruins have the puck in the Panthers zone, and are sustaining pressure. McAvoy takes a shot from the Blue Line, Bobrovsky overplayed the puck and was WAY out of his crease, thinking he had it in his shirt/shoulder padding. But the puck was loose, and ended back to the Bruins. The Ref blew the play dead. Why? The puck wasn't frozen, and it had been clearly out by the dot where Lindholm was chasing it down. Bobrovsky didn't fall over in pain. Bobrovsky didn't lose his mask, or glove/blocker, etc. So why was the play blown dead? Why did the ref just skate over and check with Bobrovsky like he was hurt or something? Is this something that normally happens? A ref thinks a defending player in hurt, and blows the play dead while the other team has pressure in the offensive zone? Make it make sense.

Love you! Hate the Betting Ad!

@RobTalksHockey

Ай бұрын

Fair and respect. KZread ad rates have been crap, and your boy has a wedding this summer. I only accepted this offer because they allowed me to make segments on safe practices

@iannewman3641

Ай бұрын

It's ubiquitous at this point. Let our man get his bag. Just skip it like everybody else lol

@The_Punisher_969

Ай бұрын

I mean bro is covering hockey, where you're absolutely BOMBARDED with betting ads. Him placing one more betting ad in his video is not going to make the difference

@DAMNDANNY88

Ай бұрын

@@RobTalksHockeyGET THE BAG‼️‼️

this may be the only unbiased canucks fan on youtube. would say you just gained a sub but i’ve been subbed for a while already

And Trouba wins the Mark Messier Award haha

Those Habs Sens series were so good, you never could really predict how the series would go from year to year

@sharkycecil4991

Ай бұрын

And now both team suck 😢😢

Not only was the elbow super dangerous, but that skate was dangerously close to Necas' jugular

I was fully expecting to see a full-on Vancouver homer video. I was pleasantly surprised to see an unbiased take on the subject. Good job, Rob. Love your videos.

Thank you for putting clips of 2013-2014 habs the memories are amazing

@jason-hy8ci

Ай бұрын

I know, Right! 😁🤣

Quinn Hughes trying to bite Mcdavids stick was pretty bad

I haven't seen anything like the Jacob Trouba's go flying since Bobby Orr.😊

@kevinstull8552

Ай бұрын

At least with the Bobby Orr image, it's considered an iconic moment. For Trouba, it's more considered hilarious 😂.

Worst non call was game 6 bruins/blues finals where the blues player blatantly slew foots the bruins player in front of the ref. The bruins player is air born and lands on his back. Mostly both teams stopped playing bc they thought it was for sure a penalty. It wasn’t and because they stopped playing the blues player scores and made it 2-0. They tie the series at 3-3 and win the cup.

This FLA team reminds me so much of the early 2010’s MTL teams. There’s like a weird balance between diving and toughness that is so frustrating to play against

@jason-hy8ci

Ай бұрын

Either way you have to keep a bucket nearby when watching one of their games. 🤢🤢🤢.... 🤮

Loving the inflection on. W W E. sounds like a true fan

The bennett miss cal on goalie interference could be my pick for worst missed call this year, but going back a couple years when Montreal faced Las Vegas in the semifinals, Corey Perry took a stick to the face and was bleeding all over, no call, Nick Suzuki straight up getting punched in the face right in front of the refs and there was no call, that was most frustrating game I ever watched

It’s always been like this and that’s why the league is a joke. Mario Lemieux called it a bush league and he was right.

0:14 what the hell was that? 😂

@snapmypickle

Ай бұрын

just having a little dance to blow off some steam

The embellishment calls have been the worst calls this postseason.

@maxcrss2845

Ай бұрын

Guy actually gets tripped, gets called for embellishment.

Whenever i think of bad calls the first thing that comes to mind is the Noel Acciari trip in 2019 finals

The other guy in the Tod Bertuzzi incident has his career completely ended as well.

Don't think I didn't recognize that slight trailer park boy reference Mr Lahey

@jonmendelson1104

Ай бұрын

I guess I wasn't listening close enough. I just finished a rewatch of TPB last week yet I have no clue what the reference was.

@Leonnoelmusic

Ай бұрын

@@jonmendelson1104 he said "worst case Ontario" instead of "worst case scenario" which is a rickyism ;)

@Leonnoelmusic

Ай бұрын

And my reference in rebuttal is a play on "don't think I haven't noticed those sly caveman references Lahey!"​@@jonmendelson1104

I was there for that 236 PIM game in Ottawa.. that game was probably the loudest that arena has ever been

Worst non call I have seen easily that Bennett goalie interference and a cross check at the same time not being called.

Nice vid

I was at that Ottawa-Montreal game in 2013. It was BEDLUM, best game i've seen

Thank you Sam Bennett. You the man!

as an oilers fan im well aware you're allowed to interfere with a goalie in the playoffs, even if you're actively holding the goalies pad.

10:19 Price putting his glove up like yo chill PK it’s good

This right here…. This right here… is the 50k views opening line! This right here!

@RobTalksHockey

Ай бұрын

Hahaha

While that elbow didn't connect, his foot did connect with his head when he fell back to earth. So he got away with attempting a dirty hit and it being an accident instead

If Trouba had landed that Misawa Elbow on Necas, Necas would have died.

also wasnt it during this 2013 playoff then Gryba gave a nasty head hit to Ellers ? and a 5 vs 5 line brawl

Hockey refs in general have lost control AHL playoffs going crazy too

Pettersson charging while stationary. Seen oilers fans say the rules say if you jump into the player. But key word is "Into" can't jump into a wall while stationary jumping

@RobTalksHockey

Ай бұрын

Yeah that one was bizarre. What I don’t get, is why call it for the first time in decades or at all in the playoffs

Cross checks in the back are different that cross checks to the butt.

@RobTalksHockey

Ай бұрын

Fair, but according to the rule book they’re the same. My point is, when every call is based on discretion it eventually becomes inconsistent

The play by play guy on that trouba missed hit... "going right through him," "oh hes going too..." just stops mid sentence when he notices the elbow like hes at a loss for words.

Notice how all the highlights of Kane getting benched by Zadarov were cut short right before he tries to slice Nikita’s throat with his skate?

@tyscam

Ай бұрын

Um, sure?

@crazysk8ta123

Ай бұрын

That’s the funniest take I’ve seen around

Bro, imma remember that goalie interference no call forever. But has anyone else noticed that the Panthers play a soccer team, embellishing everything x10, especially Bob!

They need to have video refs to call penalties on the ice at each zone of the ice. They have the tech for it. The reffing needs to be consistent.

I remember Perron trying to decapitate Kadri with a flying elbow, after Kadri scored on the St. Louis Blose in the 2022 play offs. Since the "attempt to injure" thing wasn't invoked then, it will never be.

to me the worst call so far was the sam bennett goal. bring a red is hard, playoff hockey is fast and sometimes you miss things, but when it gets sent to toronto and they still get it wrong!? and boston gets a penalty for the missed challenge!? that's a joke

I haven’t met an oilers fan that was both happy that Soucy got suspended, but also pissed that he got suspended for something so weak.

@johnnyc.31

Ай бұрын

Oil fan here. I felt Soucy should have had a fine only, and Zadorov deserved the suspension. The hard crosscheck from behind (after the game ended) was gutless and caused the other hits from Soucy & Hyman - who also should’ve been fined. And yes, McDavid should’ve had a double minor for his high stick on Hughes (regardless that it was unintentional) because he drew blood. Refs miss calls sometimes and that was a strange miss, but not uncommon. Also Trouba absolutely needs some fines / suspensions for his reckless attempts to injure before he actually succeeds.

@safejewel2072

Ай бұрын

@@johnnyc.31 100% perfect take

IMO, the Jamie Benn Goalie interference call was total dogwater. Both TNT and the Refs have made it abundantly clear that they want the Avs to win the series

@tdfmtig

Ай бұрын

Every penalty against Dallas has been soft hooking/holding calls.

@TheFamousUnderground

Ай бұрын

Yet Dallas is still up 3-1 so they seem to be defying the odds…

IMO, the goaltender interreference rule needs to be re written to make it clear what is and isnt goalie interference because under they way its currently written noone actually knows what goaltender interference is

The worst call I've ever seen was probably the Makar's "on-side" goal vs the Oilers 2 yrs ago. Hot take, I know. Let me explain: The offside rule has always been consistently interpreted such that control of the puck mattered, not contact with it. This is because it's not feasible for a linesman to base their decision on contact at live game speed. Thus, the offside rule is now applied differently at game speed than in video reviews, which makes consistency categorically impossible. Additionally, the sudden mid-game decision to change the applied interpretation of the rule such that having control no longer falls within the scope/definition of "attempting to gain control" set the precedent that refs can randomly change the interpretation any rule whenever they please, despite the existance an established and accepted interpretation. Basically, they can now make up rules in the middle of a game and that's fine as long as someone texts Elliott Friedman explaining exactly how to twist the words to fit the new narrative. Lastly, it wasn't another missed call or inevitable mistake that happens at game speed. Those are easier to forgive. This was a calculated decision made upon video review. They took the time to watch the slow mo and talk it over before throwing away decades of established precedent.

The KZreadr ToughCall did a few videos on the Bennett goal no goal. It seems the NHL may have accidentally gotten the call correct by saying it’s a good goal. They pointed out that the rule book has a rule about goalie interference when it is a “rebound oprritunity”. I forget the exact wording but basically it says if the goal is scored off a rebound then there basically can’t be goalie interference. I can’t stand the nhl rule book and the leagues refusal to edit it.

I thought the Marchand hit was a reverse check, Marchand was going directly toward the puck carrier, Bennet saw him coming and braced for the hit, just so happens it led to a reverse hit. Also, the rules talk about protecting players, not rats

Tom Wilson period

Playoffs - too many penalties are called as it is.

i feel like a way to fix the officiating is by having everything be able to be challenged. the onpy reason why the bennet goal stood was because the refs couldnt call a penalty off the review. if teams are able to challenge offside, why not habe them challenge soft penalties that may alter a game or missed calls that have a direct afect to the game

SUGGESTION: enable coach’s challenges at all points of the game. At any stoppage, the coach can challenge any play he feels should/should not have been called

@Fallout3131

Ай бұрын

No way, way to many stops. Coach’s would call every single possible infraction all game to give their team the best chance to win, I see that going horribly.

Mate, we have VAR in football and the calls are still s*it. Video refs don't solve anything, there's still plenty of grey area and interpretation. I'd suggest taking it for what it is, moaning about bad ref calls is part of the game. I don't mind bad calls, but I want safe calls. A player throwing elbows out like that is totally not acceptable. Neither is a high stick drawing blood. The soft cross check penalty on the oilers is harsh.

2:23 Trouba is such a clown and the fact he's still allowed to play in the league and is even a captain speaks volumes to how the nhl treats its big market teams. Absolutely ridiculous.

I've seen harder cross checks than that go uncalled, like that one time a forward cross checked a defender six times. SIX. TIMES. And was credited with a goal but the refs call Nurse for cross checking on a play like that? Like I hear people say "yes, it's a penalty. But how can you justify calling that when you let this similar play that should have also been called a penalty go?"

@Taubogason.40

Ай бұрын

I'll never understand on what criteria refs call cross checks. Ofc not every contact is called, would end in 100+ PIM every game just by cross checks lol

It's been bad the past 2 seasons. It's just highlighted because it's the playoffs. The wings have gotten a huge portion of it this season.

How about when they just blew the play dead because Bobby left the crease in game 5?

6:32 bros says here’s the absurd part and ad started playing

@RobTalksHockey

Ай бұрын

Hahaha

I don't know if you're just Stirring the Pot, BUT....... this years Playoffs are Not Even Close to having the MOST FIGHTS of ANY Playoff Series.

Top rope Trouba 😂😂😂

When does coaching factor in? Especially for a player with a history. Does someone have to be karate kicked with a skate blade and bleed out before a change is made?

@The104th_Wolf_Pack

Ай бұрын

It doesn't matter. The mentality now is get Lord Stanley no matter what. Think of The Hawks from The Mighty Ducks. You are witnessing that mentality now in the NHL... WIN WIN WIN.

You whiffed on the fact that Trouba's skate connected horribly with the back of NECA'S head. Trouba is a goon

Lol'd at the ballroom dancing. That's the only type of dancing I like

Non call…Adam Foote getting his face smacked into the boards from behind by Redwings. Face was cut and no call. 95-96 timeframe I believe

The one where the player was cross checked into the goalie and was reviewed and not deemed goalie interference. That play in the bruins panthers game makes my brain hurt it’s so bad. If that’s not goalie interference then wtf is!?!?!

The crosscheck suspensions were too short and not enough players got suspended.

0:40 was an injury causing hit 💀

Officials are above the law.

Nurse crosscheck must be called a penalty even in game 7 OT

The rules have to be changed so there is no more confusion

The cut down on fighting plus the addition of the third man in rule has led to a MASSIVE Increase in severe injuries and concussions in hockey. Used to police itself within enforcers. Guys who would put you on your arse If you screw with a star player or if you went over the line and did something you shouldn’t have. You’ve been bruised and bloodied. So you would not do the same bad thing twice. But players didn’t want to cost their team when given majors for third man in rule. So all those enforcers scumbags like Marchand Could take cheap shots, high flying elbows etc Repercussion. He wouldn’t have lasted a year in the 80s playing the way he does

You didn't even include some notable misses, there were quite a few in the Colorado/Stars series, the highstick on Hyman that was missed or the Vancouver player throwing the puck out of the zone.

The officiating is just so bad. I wanna watch hockey god fucking damnit.

In my opinion an elbow to the body ain’t shit when they allow players to crouch down and block shots💀

If the NFL can do it and help "push" certain teams deeper into the playoffs, why can't the NHL?

the petterson hit

The irony is how Rangers fans have been chanting Potvin's name for 5 years over a clean hit yet Trouba literally knocked Sid out of the postseason and cost the Pens a series they lead 3-1 and up 2-0 in that game 5. Trouba is a dirtbag.

The worst call I've ever seen so far in my life was when Chara punched Gardiner in the face and somehow Gardiner got a penalty for that

@jason-hy8ci

Ай бұрын

He was asking for it.☝️ 🤭

why the intro longer than the actual video 😭

@RobTalksHockey

Ай бұрын

hahaha, it's all encompassing

@templit-4322

Ай бұрын

@@RobTalksHockey I know I’m just messing buddy, have a good one

As a fan of this game for many decades now, this isn't anything new.

this absolutely nails it

Every time a goalie is screened the fans want it called interference?!?

Game changing calls should be reviewed. That doesn't mean everything will be perfect but it would help. The Oilers would have felt the difference if McDAvid had received a game misconduct and deserved at least a game suspension.

@johnnyc.31

Ай бұрын

How did McDavid deserve a suspension for what was clearly unintentional? These biased takes prevent the league from taking criticism seriously. Good grief.

@Greenbottleblue81

Ай бұрын

@@johnnyc.31 Unintentional? Lol. He saw Hughes coming right before he raised his stick with the blade of the stick moving forward clearly in the path of his face. The puck was on the ice with his teammate and no contact forced him to raise the blade up.

I don't know how Bennett's goal was allowed

Honestly, this playoffs has been some bullshit.... especially the missed goaltender interference in the bruins game.... one goal could mean everything, and if that goal doesn't happen, then guess what the match likely goes to over time and overtime is fair to all