🌎 Get a Exclusive NordVPN deal here ➼ nordvpn.com/mentournow It's completely risk-free with Nord's 30-day money-back guarantee! ✌

@Vmaxfodder

6 ай бұрын

The world is also experiencing never before seen narcissism!

@flagmichael

6 ай бұрын

@@Vmaxfodder ?

@nerysghemor5781

6 ай бұрын

A funny thing you can do with a VPN: if you like foreign languages you can get KZread and other places to serve you ads in that language. It also helps if you hate political ads in your own country. I’m in the US and I do NOT want to see those. 😂

@robainscough

6 ай бұрын

Fox News got sued and lost for $787 million for false information provided to viewers ... funny that you showed Fox News "making drama".

@thecomedypilot5894

6 ай бұрын

Mentour, stop acting like the US is the only country with issues and the EU is flawless. Do some real reporting for once.

What we're seeing in the States, is decades of well-meaning policies that on the surface seemed to raise standards for safety, but in reality, only mask the deeper institutional and systemic problems now coming back to bite us. Examples include the 1500 hr rule, age limit in hiring ATC, raising the retirement age for pilots from 60 to 65, and etc. In short, "standards" have been raised, but quality-of-life for people who work in aviation have not.

@Harrier42861

6 ай бұрын

I agree that the first two are a problem, but I'm a bit confused why you're including the increased age limit for pilots from 60 to 65 - we really need to reckon with the fact that 60-65 is now an age where good health is the norm, rather than the exception - not in the same way as your prime years, but good health regardless.

@Lime61318

6 ай бұрын

What do you mean age limit for ATC? Excuse my ignorance.

@MentourNow

6 ай бұрын

Good points

@leighbellouny3904

6 ай бұрын

@@Lime61318you have to start training before you turn 30, or you’re disqualified, and there’s an extremely low forced retirement age

@jaws666

6 ай бұрын

​@@MentourNowintresting news and very informitave as usual...thank you again for yet another fantastic video,sir.👍👍👍👍

The first thing that strikes me about the Boston incident is "yes we are ready" is not "we are cleared for take-off" so to me that's a break down in communication equally shared between the PIC for using potentially misleading words and the F/O for not asking for clarification. A lot of similarities with the Tenerife disaster. Happens all the time in the railway industry where I work

@kellyalvarado6533

6 ай бұрын

imprecise language is a factor in sooooooo many industries/situations 😮😢

@RalphEllis

6 ай бұрын

It is due to diversity hires. Which have been happening for ten years now. Would you sign off a substandard pilot? Knowing you will be sacked if you don’t - the answer is obvious. Of course you would. R

@johnstreet797

6 ай бұрын

makes me miss Kennedy Steve alot

@KaladinVegapunk

2 ай бұрын

It's just kind of funny how angry dumb people can't just be mad about real things they have to invent some, forced diversity, flat earth, anti vax, great replacement, all completely whackadoodle and delusional but people get so riled up

Corporate pilot here retired 15 years ago. One thing I liked about European airports was the taxiway lighting system that would put a red bar at a runway intersection until you were cleared to enter or cross the runway. I don't know if they are doing that in the US but it is a good system to help prevent runway incursions. Human beings' performance is reduced by fatigue, distraction, task overloads, lack of information, lack of training or lack of experience and external stress caused by non-work-related factors, or just flying with someone who is not a good crew fit with you, so somewhere in there is the problem. Sometimes I think two well trained, wide awake but low experience pilots just might do better than one inexperienced pilot flying with a self-proclaimed admiral of the air, or two admirals of the air trying to out do each other. Ok, I'm rambling!

@ThroneOfBhaal

6 ай бұрын

Haha 'Admiral of the Air' is a perfect title for some people 😆 Are you sure there is space for me in this cockpit, your ego is taking up most of it. 😆

@bbgun061

6 ай бұрын

Major airports in the USA have that system.

@patriciaramsey5294

6 ай бұрын

But you speak the truth.

@rscott2247

6 ай бұрын

Please ramble more.....

@johnstreet797

6 ай бұрын

maybe, but what you are saying sounds true, and besides Ramblers were good cars

Training an ATC here in Europe takes 2.5 to 3 years from a "random guy from the street" (who passed 4-level interview process where roughly 1 in 100 applicants is chosen) up until a fully trained, licensed and independently working controller. And the success rate in the training is roughly 50 %. Even a controller with previous experience from a different area has to train for at least half a year for the specific sector they are going to control. At least you are not paying for the training yourself (unlike CPL / ATPL). Still, any hope of rapidly filling vacant contoller position is a castle in the sky.

@DontUputThatEvilOnMe

6 ай бұрын

It’s about half the time in the US. But can be longer depends how long the on the job training period last to get approved for all the ATC positions at your assigned facility. The interview and selection process is still very tough in the US. It has multiple tests physical and mental tests and some interviews. The exceptance rate is very similar.

@joshh2705

6 ай бұрын

@@DontUputThatEvilOnMe depending on the facility that you are training at, 2.5-3 years from off the street to fully certified is actually about the same in the US. Obviously some facilities can get you there faster if they are slower or have less overall stuff to learn.

@DontUputThatEvilOnMe

6 ай бұрын

@@joshh2705 cool thanks.

@RalphEllis

6 ай бұрын

It is due to diversity hires. Which have been happening for ten years now. Would you sign off a substandard pilot? Knowing you will be sacked if you don’t - the answer is obvious. Of course you would. R

@RAVIOLIdS

6 ай бұрын

What are you waffling about? Me and my bro did the opposition in January and almost complete with the Atc license we already got our destinations too

Something you dont mention is there are a HUGE amount of incidents with 15,000+ hour pilots - it seems like they get overconfident with their skill until they encounter something they haven't before.

@MentourNow

6 ай бұрын

I’ve found THAT to be far more risky than letting younger people fly.

@51WCDodge

6 ай бұрын

@@MentourNow Any health & saftey can tell you that complaceny is a killer. Ages bettween 45 and 65 in UK are the dangerous years.

@benhart16

6 ай бұрын

I don’t think they are saying age and experience is inherently dangerous, but that hubris is. One on the issues with pilots that I’ve been hearing is they fly so much on autopilot, they get out of practice manually flying. I think the solution is instead of assuming seasoned pilots have sharp skills, verify this regularly in simulator checks where they have to practice emergency procedures. If they pass with flying colors, great, if not then you know where there’s an issue that needs attention.

@mycosys

6 ай бұрын

Not selling anything, @@ZERO-911, i'm just a mechatronic engineer making an observation based on hundreds of incident reports. If you want to discuss operational policy you are better of taking it up with the check pilot with decades of experience above. I'm sure he can sell you something cool, too. But as a general rule - safety comes form observation - not rash assumption and prejudice, and complacency is the biggest killer.

@mycosys

6 ай бұрын

Its not even just hubris, @@benhart16 - totally different field bur the day you stop thinking a metal lathe is about to k!ll you is probably the day you should quit.

The worse thing about ATC shortages is that they were told in 2020 by ATC associations and unions they needed to keep training new controllers or face staffing issues that would last as much as 10 years to get out of.

@gaylealleluia8392

6 ай бұрын

Union thugs

@uzijn

6 ай бұрын

But covid!

@liam3284

5 ай бұрын

But Covid was a good example of being reactive and demand driven. Few flights during COVID, so we won't hire ATC. The after COVID, instead of restricting flights until ATC capacity can increase to handle it, they allow as many flights as airlines want and overwork the existing ATC.

@gaylealleluia8392

5 ай бұрын

@@liam3284 some quit because they didn’t want to take the injection. Therefore, there was a problem for the airlines

@OregonBacon

4 ай бұрын

@@gaylealleluia8392 I think that was rescinded after they quit... thank the current administration for both poor funding for ATC as well as being reactive rather than proactive. Mentor should be testifying in Congress.. he's got a perspective and pulse on what should be the focus here right now.

I would add that the newer "line up and wait" clearance has the same number of syllables as "cleared for takeoff" and the additional similar tonalities of "wait" and "take". There was absolutely nothing wrong with "taxi into position and hold". It was clear, concise and completely different sounding than a takeoff clearance. This change for the sake of change did the flying industry no favors and in my mind actually made things less safe.

@adamdriver1016

6 ай бұрын

respectfully disagree. you cannot get clearer than 'line up and wait'. 'position and hold' is too ambiguous.

@davebaton8879

6 ай бұрын

'Line up and wait' is standard ICAO phraseology while 'taxi into position and hold' is not. It is as simple as that. If 'line up and wait' and 'cleared for take-off' is really easy to mistake we would be seeing incidents like these regularly outside the United States.

@bwalker4194

6 ай бұрын

@@davebaton8879 Perhaps you are a bit too young and/or inexperienced to know why this happened, so let me refresh you. 30 years ago Europe had a distinct problem with America dictating international avaition phraseology. They then inculcated something new to show their relevance: and the net result was “line up and wait”. The distinctive error of their ways plagues us to this day.

@bwalker4194

6 ай бұрын

@@adamdriver1016 No disrespect taken, but you are obviously not a serious pilot nor an air traffic controller.

@adamdriver1016

6 ай бұрын

@@bwalker4194 15'000 hours on the Airbus. Hold a TRE rating. That serious enough for you darling?

another factor that we should keep in mind is that before 2020, there were 10 incidents a year and we heard about 2, while now, there are 20 a year and we hear about all 20. so yes, the number of near misses has doubled, and that is cause for concern, but the amount of media attention has multiplied by five, and we need to remind ourselves that the number of incidents has only doubled.

@MentourNow

6 ай бұрын

Exactly, and I did make this point in the video.

@kenbrown2808

6 ай бұрын

@@MentourNow ah, I missed it, then.

@elbuggo

6 ай бұрын

I think you pulled those numbers out of your own butt.

@kurger100

6 ай бұрын

lowering of standard in USA is not a conspiracy theory, no matter how much this guy try to downplay it, perhaps for political reasons (Perhaps he is, as many Europeans are, led to believe by the media that anyone right of Kamala Harris in US is a far-right-extremist-little-Hitler )… Every cooperation in US has a large chunk of its investments determined by Diversity-Equity-Inclusion scores , all of which are in essence metrics to see how much less straight white men they are hiring.. And racial quotas that discriminate against white males are still in effect in the federal sector , (I'm not a white man, so I have no dog in this fight, but its a fact) Yes, all pilots and ATCs has to pass exams, but there's a difference between barely passing and being well versed, experienced and good at a career... Think of good lawyers and lawyers who has barely cleared their bar exam. when you deliberately make your hiring pool smaller (most DEI metrics demand at least 50% women and racial/ sexual minorities be hired to lucrative federal positions in USA, while out of the total applicants only a minority would be such individuals ), the statistical likelihood of having to select sub standard workers among them increase...

Props to the Learjet 60 captain for giving what seems to be an honest answer, "In my head we were cleared to take off, the only thing I can think of is that it was cold, I was not completely well and had a stuffed nose," That doesn't sound like an excuse, which many people might be prone to give when they're put in the hot spot for causing a dangerous situation.

@haqvor

6 ай бұрын

Incidents often have a long chain of small annoyances or mistakes that by themselves seems insignificant but all add up to a higher stress level that cause a big mistake. I'm not surprised at all that it can start with a stuffed nose. There have been tests that shows that driving with a cold have the same effects as driving while drunk, in regards to general awareness, ability to make correct decisions and also slower reaction times. Pair that with a bit of expectation bias and you have a recipe for a serious accident.

@damlatorun6756

6 ай бұрын

@@haqvorwith a stuffed nose you’re irritated and probably get less oxygen, and that’s gonna have a bad effect without a doubt

@robgrey6183

6 ай бұрын

Sounds like an excuse to me: "Yeah I know I didn't do my job but my nose was stuffy. Not my fault..."

@getyoursupervisor8519

6 ай бұрын

​@@robgrey6183 ah, Mr. Faultless joins in.

@cristianstoica4544

6 ай бұрын

The expectations are higher. That explanation was publicly deemed as a poor excuse by at least one peer. So either you are fit for flying or you find a sound reason for what you do

I worked at an FBO in the late 80's refueling 727/737 aircraft for USAir at one of their hubs. What I don't understand with pilots is, how you have a runway incursion when crossing a runway. We had it drilled into us that when crossing a runway (in our fueling trucks), we a) had to get ground tower permission, but then b) ALWAYS looked both ways up and down the runway to be sure there were no aircraft on the runway, on short final, etc. Just like you're taught when crossing the street as a child... look both ways.

@alexlowe2054

6 ай бұрын

Unfortunately, at least 3 of the mentioned incidents involve a plane approaching from behind or above, which gives pilots zero visibility.

@HenryLoenwind

6 ай бұрын

Don't forget that the runway is the natural habitat for airplanes while it is getting even near it is an exception for fuel trucks.

@Jeff-dv9jl

6 ай бұрын

@@alexlowe2054 From neither a pilot nor a controller: Is there any work going on to let pilots "see through" the airplane in all directions? I realize that collision avoidance systems are what is designed to surveil the surrounding skies, for aircraft that have those systems. A third person would be needed to monitor the 360-degree surveillance as I am imagining it. (I wish they never stopped having a third professional on the flight deck in the first place, but this for other reasons - not to watch for other aircraft - and I realize that at present there is a shortage of pilots.) I know I'm like a little kid asking weird questions.

@bbgun061

6 ай бұрын

​​@@Jeff-dv9jlnot really. I think the F-35 has something like that. The pilot wears AR goggles which display camera views below and behind the airplane. But that's an expensive system for a military aircraft.

@Jeff-dv9jl

6 ай бұрын

@@bbgun061 Got it - thanks for replying.

As someone from the US, “what is going on in the US” is something I ask myself every day 😅

I LOVE my local air traffic controllers. I fly in and out of a very busy area of the East Coast, and our guys handle a massive workload of airline, GA, cargo and military operations so smoothly that I'm often amazed. I've called in and been told that I am sixth in line to land and somehow, they keep us all sorted. On top of all of that, they are eminently friendly and courteous. I love those guys!

@MikeyCanuck123

6 ай бұрын

Sounds like the rest of the industry should take some lessons from your guys and gals.

@Dn1sdr

6 ай бұрын

Must be atlanta approach.

I’m a student pilot in the US right now and just the other day I was taking off doing a touch and go and I had a small business jet was go around and ended up about 100’ over my right shoulder as I was climbing out. There may be a pilot shortage but there is a huge Air Traffic Controller shortage here and worse most all of them have never flown a plane themselves as thus are less equipped to understand the needs and requirements of piloting an aircraft. They do a hard job and I thank them for it but from what I can tell there needs to be more of them

@paulis7319

6 ай бұрын

Welcome to the whimsically whacky world of aviation! Us pilots have been commenting about non-pilot ATC for decades. The best way to help that issue is to schedule a trip to the tower and meet the controllers face to face. That helps us as pilots have a better understanding of how and why they do what they do, and they can learn from us to streamline their job as well.

6 ай бұрын

ATCO in other countries are not tipically private pilots. This was mostly a US thing and there is no numbers to say it's an advantage. You also have Pilots on frequency doing crazy stuff you would say a pilot would never do. It's just not a factor in this.

@vbscript2

6 ай бұрын

@@paulis7319 Both trips for pilots to the tower and also the reverse - ATCOs jump seating in airliners - would definitely be helpful. The latter used to happen, but, from what I understand, this has also be a casualty of the ATC shortage, at least in the short term.

@Robbedem

6 ай бұрын

I'm surprised they don't shut airspace down if there aren't enough traffic controllers. I thought that was the norm.

@John_Hudson_922

6 ай бұрын

about 15 years ago as many people were looking for work, I and many others tried hard to get into the ATC world. We studied, traveled and did the tests, and got great results - only to not be selected. The government had their chance and they couldn't anticipate that they'd need more than the bare minimum staffing levels. Huge mistake.

NYC traffic controllers speaking fast can lead to misunderstanding. This is especially true when they are speaking to pilots who have only a minimal command of English and who are struggling to understand controllers with a New York accent. However, have you heard the arguments these controllers sometimes get into with pilots? That wastes time and is even scarier.

@SteamCrane

6 ай бұрын

NYC attitude is often a problem. What, you gotta problem wit dat?

@liam3284

5 ай бұрын

Another problem with talking fast is radio channels are rarely clear, and are band limited, so some components of speech will be missing.

@jstephens2758

5 ай бұрын

@@liam3284 Agreed!

The FAA shut down ATC training during covid with no plan. Training instructors had hours reduced and or put on furlough. And when everything ramped back up there wasnt enough training capcity to make up the shortfall causing staff shortage. Same is true of pilots. Serious fatigue issues are starting to become dangerous and days away from becoming deadly.

@alexlowe2054

6 ай бұрын

This. Shutting down training for a short time at the start of the pandemic was understandable. But completely shutting down training for 2 years is unforgivable. Schools and businesses figured out how to keep functioning in a fully remote environment. The airline industry should have worked to at least keep some sort of remote online-only training running. Even if it didn't 100% qualify people, continuing some sort of remote-only training would allow the industry to pay their training staff and be prepared to resume training after the pandemic. Instead, the airline industry stopped paying their workers, which meant many people moved to different job. The entire industry lost the capacity to train new personnel because they lost their training staff and all the people who were in the training programs. It was a catastrophic failure, and we're seeing the effects now. It'll take years to undo the damage, and the industry will need to offer better pay and benefits to attract people after this loss of trust.

@gaylealleluia8392

6 ай бұрын

FAuci…. & Dirty Dems Done Dirt Cheap.

@xeldinn86

6 ай бұрын

Shutting down the country did more harm than good.

I’ll say this from jump seating weekly the past few months.. there’s not enough ATC controllers. Multiple airports ATC would vector us in, and tell us to defend to the run way, only to forget us. Pilots had to call them and tell them hey, I’m at 2000ft or whatever and then they’d clear us to land. Separation was also another issue. Seems things are always seconds away from disaster. There needs to be more controllers, more runways at many airports and more time between flights

@amazer747

6 ай бұрын

That's where the early landing clearances are dangerous. They forget you're coming and have been cleared.

@denverbraughler3948

6 ай бұрын

“xxxx, yyyy tower. Continue visual approach runway nnn. Report two mile final.” “Two mile final, runway nnn. xxxx.” “xxxx, cleared to land runway nnn.” This dialogue isn’t a problem. But “hey, I’m at 2000’” isn’t so useful.

@denverbraughler3948

6 ай бұрын

@@amazer747 : Yes. It’s much better that controllers forget to clear you than to clear you then forget you and clear another aircraft. A landing clearance shouldn’t be issued so early that it could be forgotten by the controller or the pilot. Pilots often forget too.

@paulis7319

6 ай бұрын

He got to that part near the end of the video, stating there's currently a ~20% shortage. You're right, there are a lot of improvements that the aviation industry needs, but the FAA is driven by money rather than facts.

Loved the way to took a multifactorial approach to a complicated problem. Retired ATC and I strongly agree with your analysis. One (main) problem is our Congress and funding allocation. This leads the FAA without adequate funding to shoot for the 80% level and predictably hitting 70%.

It's not just the pilots that are the issue, it's ATC.

@benchoflemons398

6 ай бұрын

FAA, the government has a monopoly with no demand to improve.

@uclajd

6 ай бұрын

And guess what the hiring practices are of the federal government.

@deans178

6 ай бұрын

Privatize ATC like Europe & Canada did. Take our ridiculous self grandizing polititians and inept government out of the picture!! Our current "government" thinks "bigger government" and "more government" is the better solution.

@deans178

6 ай бұрын

That's exactly what the video said! You must not have watched it!

@MattyEngland

6 ай бұрын

@@deans178 I commented before he got to that part, sorry if that hurt your fefes

Covid did a number on the US in different fields. It caused a percentage of more experienced people who were also getting closer to ending their time in those stressful jobs to go ahead and retire from that work, and that went along with the big drop in demand. Two years later the amount of people on the job wasn't nearly enough. Something like this EVEN THOUGH you could say is foreseen is STILL hard to deal with when you have a sizeable amount of people leave a specific career. All of these jobs require very attentive people, who are also well educated and good communicators, so the different companies/agencies losing a significant amount of people like this caused real harm. So, through all the cutbacks the companies/agencies needed to do because of the dropoff of the flying public along with people leaving those fields I'm not surprised. When I need to fly to Asia, I'm still going to fly. I have faith in the airline industry that things work correctly WAY more times than they don't and I face MUCH more danger getting in my car when so many people can't even stay in their own lanes because they're looking at a smartphone instead of the road.

@Brian-kl1zu

6 ай бұрын

"Safe and effective." "Sudden Runway Incursion Syndrome." Nothing to see here folks. Move along, and get your boosters.

‘Just general aviation’. Ouch! We’re pilots too!

I know more adults over the age of 30 who want to go into ATC than I know people who want to become pilots at all, but the age cut-off to start ATC blocks all of them.

@Blacktopcowboy

6 ай бұрын

I feel that. I got my dispatch license because i was months past the cut off age.

@Flyingbison86

6 ай бұрын

Changing the age limit wouldn't do anything anyways, there's plenty of worthy applicants every time a bid goes out. The FAA can't get them through the academy efficiently enough.

@shrimpflea

6 ай бұрын

60% of all new ATC quit or don't make the grade within a year.

@Flyingbison86

6 ай бұрын

@@shrimpflea this is untrue. I'd say maybe 1/3 don't make it at the academy, but that's the point of the academy.. you can't screen for this job via a simple aptitude test. Retention is pretty good, few people quit unless they are sent to one of the facilities with multiple year training backlogs, there aren't many like this. As for success rates, even where I work, one of the most difficult to certify at in the NAS, the people who can't hack it are retained and sent to easier facilities where they almost always are successful. Hiring older individuals won't correct this anyways, age has nothing to do with ability and we have plenty of applicants. The cutoff age is due to the forced retirement age, which believe me, shouldn't be touched.

Lots of controllers have retired over the last 15 years, I’m one of them. I am one of the few that flew corporate while a controller and I still fly now. Covid hit and traffic dropped it training continued so many newer controllers were not used to the volume of traffic that was present pre-covid. I fly into the NY area, mostly KFRG and KTEB and it’s fun but requires precision and clear communications. Make me wonder if that intensity makes folks pay closer attention than other less dense places. It’s not a one issue problem but many a faceted problem. I devour accident and incident reports and this channel to stay aware of the pitfalls in aviation. I’m single pilot IFR in complex twin piston and turboprop aircraft and try my best to be thorough, use check lists, and minimize risk. Love your videos, keep them coming. (I agreed the US 1,500 ATP standard now is BS).

@danvaccariello439

6 ай бұрын

Is it true that beginning in 2012 the FAA started hiring ATC's based on a "personality test"? There are rumors that the personality test was to weed out white people and exclusively hire black people.

@kimchristensen3727

6 ай бұрын

The 1500 hour rule hasn’t changed anything at all or made life more difficult for new pilots. It is just a really tired excuse by young pilots. Major airlines didn’t hire 200 hour pilots before the rule. “Time building” has always been a thing. The only thing new is increased demand for pilots and a more impatient younger generation.

@bwalsberg

6 ай бұрын

@@kimchristensen3727…..this is so true. I had 2,300 hrs before my first 121 regional. 4,200 at my first mainline. The new breed expects to hit mainline at 1,500……and the sad thing is that they are getting it!!!!! (With all light aircraft experience)

After listening to this ATC clips available on the web from these incidents, my imo about the causes is: 1. US aviation relays on to much VFR. If they used more IFR and fixed flight path (especially STAR, SID and standard Go Around) much of these close calls would be prevented bc everybody follows pre planed flight path in and out of these busy airports/ airspace's. Just look to London, UK where everybody follow the same path/ fixes and everybody knows exactly where they should go and what altitude. You never hear about near misses like you hear in etc NYC. Both of the every busy airspace's with lot of airports. 2. ATC standards. From that I hear on these tapes US seems to use every much nonstandard international ATC protocol and phraseology which could confuse pilots (especially foreign which may not be so good in English). It would also help for ATC to speak slower and shorter instead of fast and long clearances. 3. As other has mention it may also come with poorer training of both pilots and ATC controllers.

There was a recent collision in HOU Hobby airport where a corporate jet departed without a clearance and clipped a landing citation jet. No one was hurt.

I love the way you analyse stuff effectively; looking not at the surface causes but also the deep roots of a problem. This is the only channel where this happens with any reliability and I absolutely LOVE it. Keep doing what you do - it's very much appreciated.

@kurger100

6 ай бұрын

lowering of standard in USA is not a conspiracy theory, no matter how much this guy try to downplay it, perhaps for political reasons (Perhaps he, as many Europeans are led to believe that everyone right of Kamala Harris in US are a far right extremist little Hitler as the media has made you believe )… Every cooperation in US has a large chunk of its investments determined by Diversity-Equity-Inclusion scores , all of which are in essence metrics to see how much less straight white men they are hiring.. And racial quotas that discriminate against white males are still in effect in the federal sector , (I'm not a white man, so I have no dog in this fight, but its a fact) Yes, all pilots and ATCs has to pass exams, but there's a difference between barely passing and being well versed, experienced and good at a career... Think of good lawyers and lawyers who has barely cleared their bar exam. when you deliberately make your hiring pool smaller (most DEI metrics demand at least 50% women and racial/ sexual minorities be hired to lucrative federal positions in USA, while out of the total applicants only a minority would be such individuals ), the statistical likelihood of having to select sub standard workers among them increase...

@stonelaughter

6 ай бұрын

@@kurger100 The actual fuck are you talking about?

@Naomibabe457

6 ай бұрын

It is how all investigations into aviation happen

As well as the point to point model, don’t forget that Europe has trains! That takes a chunk out of the domestic aviation market that simply doesn’t exist in the US. Birmingham and Manchester to London used to be busy air routes , for example, and now… not.

I just read that there's a maximum age at time of hire of 31 for ATCs. That doesn't help with filling the vacant seats.

You probably have seen the latest Runway incursion here in the U.S. the actually ended in a collision between 2 business jets a LUAW that took off without clearance.

@haqvor

6 ай бұрын

Juan at the blancolirio channel had a video about the initial report on that just a day or two ago. A Hawker took off without clearance and clipped a good part of the horizontal stab of a landing Citation.

@wb6anp

6 ай бұрын

Yes and in the audio it sounds like the Hawker pilot tries to blame the controller.

@haqvor

6 ай бұрын

@@wb6anp Confirmation bias is a very powerful thing. I don't think that the Hawker pilot purposefully took off without a clearance. He was probably completely convinced that he got the clearance and just followed the instructions he had been given. That should of course never happen but apparently it does, so for me it highlights a situation that needs better margins that either eliminates the situation or that the procedures should be changed that allows for reasonable mistakes that doesn't get any serious consequences.

Wow. Excellent, thoughtful video. This brought a lot of ideas together in one place. I love hearing the opinion of someone close to the action. The brief recaps of some recent incidents was a good addition.

@kurger100

6 ай бұрын

lowering of standard in USA is not a conspiracy theory, no matter how much this guy try to downplay it, perhaps for political reasons (Perhaps he, as many Europeans are led to believe that everyone right of Kamala Harris in US are a far right extremist little Hitler as the media has made you believe )… Every cooperation in US has a large chunk of its investments determined by Diversity-Equity-Inclusion scores and racial quotas that discriminate against white males are still in effect in the federal sector , all of which are in essence metrics to see how much less straight white men they are hiring.. (I'm not a white man, so I have no dog in this fight, but its a fact) Yes, all pilots and ATCs has to pass exams, but there's a difference between barely passing and being well versed, experienced and good at a career... Think of good lawyers and lawyers who has barely cleared their bar exam. when you deliberately make your hiring pool smaller (most DEI metrics demand at least 50% women and racial/ sexual minorities be hired to lucrative federal positions in USA, while out of the total applicants only a minority would be such individuals ), the statistical likelihood of having to select sub standard workers among them increase...

There was a close call at LaGuardia on Thursday.

Not only runway incursions but lining up for landing on the wrong parallel runway or taxiway - just happened with AA at JFK recently. Victor had the ATC on that.

@vbscript2

6 ай бұрын

Just to clarify, though, it was a biz jet, not AA, that lined up on the wrong runway. AA was where they were supposed to be.

@ajg617

6 ай бұрын

@@vbscript2 True but it was also a biz jet that took off without clearance at Logan forcing JetBlue to go around and another at Houston Hobby resulting in a collision with another biz jet. Point being you can't preclude mistakes by the smaller types impacting a commercial at larger hub airports. One reason why I still can't understand why KMHT was totally abandoned by Delta (as were some 20 other feeders) and others. It used to relieve some of the pressure from Logan but the fares are astronomical.

@vbscript2

6 ай бұрын

@@ajg617 Oh, yes, it's still very important and impacts the airlines. Not trying to dismiss its importance at all. As for major airlines pulling out of smaller airports, they've all been doing that and it's mostly for two reasons: the pilot shortage (they need those pilots to be flying bigger aircraft) and ATC shortage (the FAA has requested airlines to reduce flight counts in some regions due to the lack of sufficient controllers available, with the Northeast being one of those.) United and American have been doing the same thing. A lot of small airports have seen reduced or eliminated service over the last 3 years. Having small airports with a few RJ services around doesn't really noticeably decrease required flight counts at big airports like Logan. Instead, it just creates more work for the TRACON and ARTCC. It might slightly reduce passenger count at Logan, but quite unlikely to be enough to matter, especially with Logan being a hub for Delta.

In my opinion situation awareness matters more than the flight hours

@kickedinthecalfbyacow7549

6 ай бұрын

There is a correlation between experience and situational awareness

@justkittensbeingkittens5892

6 ай бұрын

Yes, but how do you measure that. Flight hours are a consistent standard you can measure

@Rblazer

6 ай бұрын

I think the “quality” of hours is much more important. I’d rather fly with a 700 hour King Air driver compared to a 1500 hour instructor. These instructors don’t know shit but think they do, that’s the main issue IMO

@chrisstaples182

6 ай бұрын

​@@Rblazeryeah instructor hours count for nothing in my book. Basically have 200 hours

@Rblazer

6 ай бұрын

@@chrisstaples182 yep agreed with you

A very well thought out analysis when it would have been easy for you to just slam the system. It’s refreshing to see there are still people like yourself capable of making balanced, intelligent arguments. Breeze flies to my hometown and I didn’t even know they flew ERJ’s. I’ve only ever seen the A220’s. Good stuff!

I hate to admit this but my brother in law, a man with military fighter jet experience, who transitioned into commercial flying has been a check pilot for many years. He retired earlier this year before he planned to. His main reason for it was pressure from the airline he worked for to “ease up” on his evaluation of new pilots. I live in Germany but he lives in the states.

@SteamCrane

6 ай бұрын

Ouch!

It's getting to the point that line up and wait is going to have to be eliminated. If it gets much worse airports will have to put gates up like those at a train crossing!

@after_midnight9592

6 ай бұрын

Retractable bollards, like we have on many city streets.

@outermarker5801

6 ай бұрын

And people STILL end up on train tracks 😵‍💫

@kimchristensen3727

6 ай бұрын

Have you seen American drivers at train crossings?

@andrewlorenzo6611

6 ай бұрын

LUAW is not allowed at many airports in the US.

Petter keeps talking about Czech airmen, what about Polish or Spanish Airmen?

@flagmichael

6 ай бұрын

Groan!

One thing they need to change ASAP in the US is giving a landing clearance when there is other traffic on the runway!! Or phrases such as “Number 2, cleared to land”. Cleared to land should simply mean you are actually cleared to land now!!

@danhamilton2676

6 ай бұрын

Your suggestion isn’t addressing a safety issue. There is no safety issue when controllers issue landing clearances to multiple aircraft.

@smaze1782

6 ай бұрын

Also, issuing a landing clearance along with something like, “where are you parking” so the pilots at times don’t even read back the landing clearance.

@iahflyr4690

6 ай бұрын

You are 100% correct. Never did I refuse and landing clearance when told number X when flying nor did any pilot refuse a landing clearance when told number x that I used working in the Tower. It is very safe.@@danhamilton2676

@squeecy9965

6 ай бұрын

Hard disagree. This allows controllers to plan ahead instead of waiting until the aircraft is 100ft off the ground to assign a landing clearance. Just because you are cleared to land doesn't mean things can't change into a go-around instruction. Also, if I remember correctly, not all airports are able to do this, depending on what type of equipment they have in the cab.

@Flapsupnolights

6 ай бұрын

Totally they put the onus on the pilot. Whereas most other places in the world you can’t get a clearance to land on a runway that isn’t clear 😂😂 such a stupid way of doing things.

I doubt if it’s recruitment. Many of the pilots screwing up are very experienced. I think it’s a mixture of things. Taking things for granted, short staff in the control tower, more flights. Etc.

You hit close to home with this episode. I live in Sarasota (SRQ) where we went from about 1 million annually passengers before the pandemic to more than 4.3 million projected for 2023. We were served by 6 airline to 8 locations, dominated by Delta with spoke service to basically to Atlanta. The growth started with Allegiant which served over 20 secondary and small market airports. Then Southwest returned after canceling service to SRQ when they bought Air Trans (they are now the #1 airline at SRQ). We are now served by 11 airlines including all the new style airlines like Allegiant, Breeze, Avelo, Frontier and Sun Country with service to 54 destinations. Of course with this growth has come growing pains. Our 13 gate terminal space has maxed out with 5 new surface gates to be finish at the end of 2024 (Allegiant is taking all 5 gates). We also had a similar near miss in February 2023 with an Air Canada A321 cleared to take off while an American 737 flight was cleared to land on the same runway. This episode really targeted SRQ, covering all our local issues to a tee.

@TravisStewart42

6 ай бұрын

I'm not so clued into the industry, but wow, that is a huge increase in a very short time period. I didn't realize demands were increasing that much. Also will look up the incident you mentioned. I'm in Canada but somehow didn't hear about this March incident.

@Jrh-rp7np

3 ай бұрын

Dude I flew into Sarasota the other week and couldn’t believe how busy it was.. when the last time I flew out of there in 2008 it was like no mans land.. I also flew out of smaller Punta Gorda airport recently which Allegiant flys out of and it was stunning how busy that little airport was the line just to get in took me awhile and then the airport was absolutely packed.. and this airport doesn’t even have a gates ,, you walk out and onto steps and then into the Plane..Also, I’ve noticed there aren’t as many direct flights for whatever reason so you now have way more connecting flights all over the place

Petter, I'd rather listen to you rant than anyone else's "facts". I'd consider you calling something "bullshit" to be something I'm taking seriously. Positive attiude, brother.

@MentourNow

6 ай бұрын

Thank you

@chrisstaples182

6 ай бұрын

​@@MentourNowplease read my comment.

@kurger100

6 ай бұрын

lowering of standard in USA is not a conspiracy theory, no matter how much this guy try to downplay it, perhaps for political reasons (Perhaps he, as many Europeans are led to believe that everyone right of Kamala Harris in US are a far right extremist little Hitler as the media has made you believe )… Every cooperation in US has a large chunk of its investments determined by Diversity-Equity-Inclusion scores and racial quotas that discriminate against white males are still in effect in the federal sector , all of which are in essence metrics to see how much less straight white men they are hiring.. (I'm not a white man, so I have no dog in this fight, but its a fact) Yes, all pilots and ATCs has to pass exams, but there's a difference between barely passing and being well versed, experienced and good at a career... Think of good lawyers and lawyers who has barely cleared their bar exam. when you deliberately make your hiring pool smaller (most DEI metrics demand at least 50% women and racial/ sexual minorities be hired to lucrative federal positions in USA, while out of the total applicants only a minority would be such individuals ), the statistical likelihood of having to select sub standard workers among them increase...

"…The gatekeeper role is far too important for that." Those are nice ideals, but one's ideals can quickly dissolve under corporate pressure or fear of losing one's job. "If I don't follow these metrics closely, I'll lose my job and my ability to provide for my family."

One thing that I've noticed listening to ATC/Pilot communication is the change of terminology used now compared to when I started flying over 50 years ago. When I got my Commercial and Dispatcher License, "Position and Hold" was used instead of "Line up and Wait." "Position and Hold" sounds more like a command while "Line up and Wait" sounds like a request. "Hold" would probably stick in your mind better when the frequency is busy.

@xeldinn86

6 ай бұрын

What about 'line up and hold'?

@MaxEPR

6 ай бұрын

@@xeldinn86 "Line" is also used by Ground Control like in, "Get in line behind the Company passing you now and follow to the gate."

FAA requirements are ludicrous which has left a large lack of controllers. Same with pilots. Ever been treated for depression? Nope, you're done. It's nuts.

You see this is almost all U.S. industries where profit and stock prices are the most important thing, as well. 1: They hire specialists to improve their efficiency and save money. 2: The "Experts" tell them that their largest expenditure after new construction ( or planes in this case ) is payroll. So they "trim" payroll or decide to not hire replacements for what they see as non-critical roles. 3: ATC personnel are seen as basically glorified customer service by management. So they have to take extra shifts or wear more hats as it were. Note that the U.S. average is about 35K a year - they are paid like customer service as well. The FAA could easily hire more but they are obviously seen as non-critical by management if they are being overworked and under-paid like that. 4: Rather than lower the number of flights at an airport due to low staffing, they pack in every last flight that they can anyways as profit is everything. Which leads to understaffed, over-worked, and doing more than their original job entailed ATC people making mistakes as flights take off and land every minute, all day long. You never see airports or airlines cancel flights due to staffing issues, barring a complete lack of personnel for some reason. Understaffed that day means just doing more work. As anyone who has watched planes coming in at a major airport knows, there is an endless queue of planes landing all day long and ATC people are basically a call center at that point - juggling customers as quickly as possible. Way too many planes way too close to each other. 5: They do the same with pilots as well, pushing them a little more and and little more and oh, just this once, a little more, which results in more late and early flights when they might not be as awake/having problems staying fully alert.

@uclajd

6 ай бұрын

Because communist countries are so much more safe and efficient, LOL. Go fly on Cuba's airline and get back to me, comrade.

@benchoflemons398

6 ай бұрын

Then why does the us not have privatized airports and privatized ATC like Europe where these issues aren’t happening?

@plektosgaming

6 ай бұрын

@@benchoflemons398 Good question. My guess is that many decades ago it was like that and the government found that a lot of mistakes were being made. This government controlled system works well until budget cuts and 20 year old salary tables are repeatedly not updated. Most ATC are making $15-$20 an hour, and in many states like California and New York, just a couple of dollars an hour more than minimum wage. It's one to the worst paid government jobs in the U.S. when you compare the training, duties, and stress.

@br4nd0nh347

6 ай бұрын

Thanks for saying this. This is rampant not only in the airline industry but everywhere. You and Gail Peterson said what we're really thinking about this situation.

@plektosgaming

6 ай бұрын

@@nty3929 Note that "25 to 50 an hour" in Government-speak means that that's the pay range for that pay grade based on time spent AT that pay grade. Meaning that you start at 25 an hour, no haggling, no options, 100% of the time, at year 0. Then you slowly work up to the highest range after .. not making this up.. 20 years. This is what I meant and thought was understood. Government wages are horrendous unless you are one of the lucky few who has been there for 20+ years in a position. For new people, the starting wages of 17-25 an hour is the reality, depending on the state. They have to put in many years to get to the top of their pay grade and for people entering NOW, it's not going to keep up with inflation versus other options. (plus what person under 25/this current generation wants to have the same govt job for 20 years?) So they have a hard time attracting young workers. Older workers like myself see little value as we get 0 credit for other government positions. So a lateral move is not an option.

Not just near misses. In October there was a high speed collision at HOU between 2 business jets.

It’s called hub-and-spoke. This operating model in the US refers to a system of air transportation in which local airports offer flights to a central airport where international or long-distance flights are available. Each airline has their own “hub” airports. For example United Airline’s largest hub is Denver International Airport. And its second largest hub is Chicago O'Hare. Other hubs include Newark (NYC region) and Denver and Washington

I would argue that in some cases the 1500 hour rule LOWERS the quality of new commercial pilots. They become fixated on doing anything they can to get hours, rather than quality flying.

@elbuggo

6 ай бұрын

Experience is no substitute for old fashioned lQ, unfortunately.

Another excellent topic. Here’s a suggestion for another video: the increasing numbers of GPS jamming and more recently GPS spoofing events encountered in eastern EU and Middle East due to the spreading of the current conflict zones. The current fleet of aircraft is barely equipped to face/detect such type of threat (as military equipment are more advanced and readily available) and I personally experienced a couple of concerning events (Map Shifts, loss of GPS capabilities, spurious GPWS warning in cruise, etc…). Worth an investigation to raise public concern IMHO

@Skullair313

4 ай бұрын

Is the position data in an airplane computer not interconnected / checked with the the IMU data?

"Industry inspected itself and industry is fine"

I enjoy how MentorPilot has such a good, professional, and yet easily understandable approach to speaking about the airline industry. One question I have after seeing this video is what is MentorPilot’s take on what happened to the Air Traffic Controllers (ATC) beginning on August 5, 1981 that affected the airline industry when Reagan fired the 11,359 air-traffic controllers who had not returned to work after Reagan broke up the ATC union. For the record, Regan also declared a lifetime ban on the rehiring of the strikers by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). One would assume that this had to have had an affect on safety at that time in the airline industry. But, to what extent. And how if in any way does this compare with what is currently happening with the hiring and appropriate training for ATC hires? When I was in the Air Force, many years ago I used to have a friend who worked in the Denver Stapleton ATC tower. I visited him there once. That is a very challenging job to do as you have so much responsibility for so many lives and you cannot afford to make any mistakes. Ever since then I have had the greatest respect for those working in ATC.

@kurger100

6 ай бұрын

lowering of standard in USA is not a conspiracy theory, no matter how much this guy try to downplay it, perhaps for political reasons (Perhaps he, as many Europeans are led to believe that everyone right of Kamala Harris in US are a far right extremist little Hitler as the media has made you believe )… Every cooperation in US has a large chunk of its investments determined by Diversity-Equity-Inclusion scores , all of which are in essence metrics to see how much less straight white men they are hiring.. And racial quotas that discriminate against white males are still in effect in the federal sector , (I'm not a white man, so I have no dog in this fight, but its a fact) Yes, all pilots and ATCs has to pass exams, but there's a difference between barely passing and being well versed, experienced and good at a career... Think of good lawyers and lawyers who has barely cleared their bar exam. when you deliberately make your hiring pool smaller (most DEI metrics demand at least 50% women and racial/ sexual minorities be hired to lucrative federal positions in USA, while out of the total applicants only a minority would be such individuals ), the statistical likelihood of having to select sub standard workers among them increase...

Thanks for the very interesting video, Petter. Just a minor comment: WestJet is a full service airline serving almost every Canadian province, much of the US and also some European cities. It isn’t a leisure airline.

The other day I was doing touch and gos at Tucson international and the tower controller sounded like he was gonna fall asleep at any second. The good news is a new controller came in after around 20 minutes.

Best aviation channel I love learning about aviation I could watch and listen to you for hours you explain things so well and make it easy for everyone to understand thank you so much for all your amazing work ! Sending love from Quebec City Canada ! ❤️✈️

Great video again! And truly detailed! However, I would like to mention that these new strategies also have to do with huge economic rules: slot values, less airport taxation for carriers, less congested airports (which means on-time arrivals and departures), less complicated ruling for the passenger regarding loyalty programmes, access to lounges, etc, passengers satisfaction with the carrier (with repeating experiences), less crowded queues at the security check, and many more (I do not wish to extend myself).

The "cancel if its not profitable" also is a good way to have poor customer relations - I know a few people who have sworn to never take some of these small airlines or avoid some airports because they got stranded for days of cancellation the one return flight a day and had to finally rent a car to drive back over a few days. If you can't depend on your flight happening you can't risk taking the flight.

@charisma-hornum-fries

5 ай бұрын

That would be difficult near the arctic circle and in countries like Greenland. -We just accept that weather conditions are the bosses of any flight. If I'm to translate to the bigger picture the climate change events will be the bosses of everywhere. We all have to adapt to that reality and get used to interferences and that flights are canceled and rebooked.

I can imagine that a different way of communicating some messages might be a real big benefit. Right now, essentially there's a hard limit on the amount of instructions that can be transferred in a sector, since only one person can be communicating at the same time. It would be interesting to see what it'd be like if some communications (for instance heading, altitude and change frequency) could be communicated through text.

@magrathean0

6 ай бұрын

Perhaps a telemetry type duplication of critical instructions like landing/ takeoff clearance and runway numbers.

It’s refreshing to hear some cursing come from you. Strong language is indeed necessary sometimes

2:30 - nancy bradshaw (united) was almost 100hrs into OEI (almost 3x the average) and managed to destroy the crown of a 767 on a clear calm day. They had many previous failures in heavies and check ride.

I recall being told there's a cut off age for HIRE at as an ATC when I thought about becoming one in my mid 20s and was told the clock was ticking. It's just like with many police forces and fire departments around the US where they cut off age of hiring in the late 20s.

ATC talking like auctioneers or horse race commentators! You nailed it, Mentour 😊.

@NicolaW72

6 ай бұрын

Indeed.

Breeze was always planning to have a fleet of a220s. The E-jets were a way to get the airline started prior to receiving new planes.

18,000hr bizjet pilot here. Instead of “line up and wait”, which I find a little loose, perhaps “line up and hold”. Seems more direct, like an order. In our cockpit, we only turn the landing lights on once takeoff clearance has been received. Currently flying a G650 and I have to say the line checklist is a little long, so there is a “hurried” atmosphere generated by the crew to get items done before power up. This creates a situation where the crew is involved in checklist items, Important, and ATC instructions, REALLY important, but there is a distraction going on. Cockpit duties, and ATC instructions. Juggling both balls so to speak. On another note, you mentioned that the landing Citation was given a clearance to land early on. This is a age old ATC thing in the USA. If memory serves me correctly, it is in place for the reason when radios were first installed there was a high rate of failure with them. So, ATC decided that as soon as an aircraft makes contact with the control tower, they will clear you to land in the event of a radio failure, lost comms. They did not want you wandering around the sky figuring out what your going to do. Instead, go straight in and land.

Flying as getting dangerous, it's a matter of time before a major disaster.

A good example is the Lufthansa A350 into SFO a few weeks ago. LH says their pilots aren’t allowed to do visuals at night and the controller purposefully put them into the hold until they were forced to divert to avoid a fuel emergency.

Just like many other industries the pressure to meet deadlines/ profit can affect good decision making. The difference in aviation is that the consequences can be catastrophic. Will the paying public accept a higher price ticket to reduce the number of flights to a safer level ? If there is a risk the plane I'm on might be side swiped by an incoming jet then I'd pay.

@gavrosd283

6 ай бұрын

I for one would. Commercial flying has become too mainstream. I’d happily fly less/pay more for higher safety standards. This may very well be the only way forward if they can’t recruit/train quality professionals quick enough.

That issue was kinda an odd one, let me explain, south west is known for taxi and go, they don’t wait once clearance is given. As this kinda became the norm in most airport they operate in. The problem is also the key word, as most controller would’ve probably gotten used to it, during high operation they might given clearance to southwest thinking that they would start take off roll immediately upon entering the runway but this was not the case in this incident. The pilot has the final say on when to start their take off roll and the controller played in to complacency, thus the human error strikes again.

This video really highlights the potential dangers of near collisions on the ground in aviation. It's concerning to see how the current system may contribute to these close calls and how different the EU and NA systems work to each other. I hope that the aviation sector gets some more ressources and attention from the US and the Govermentsectos. Thank you for shedding some light on this issue. Safety should always be a top priority in aviation!

Great video! For the San Diego Incident, that controller was working tower, ground and clearance at the same time. Also VASaviation has all of the audio for these and that could be a helpful place to analyze these accidents too.

I do not think that the 1500 hour rule for pilots is necessary. You want experience not time. Also I believe that the standard of ATC trying to push departures and arrivals closer and closer is getting out of hand. I mean it’s not all the controllers fault they’re trying to keep traffic flowing in a busy airport. The FAA needs to think over some rules. Love your vids man keep it up 👍

As an ATC in the UK it blows my mind to hear a tower controller in the US clearing multiple aircraft to land at once. Maybe it's my naivety of being an area controller not fully understanding the requirements of tower controllers but it seems to me that you should only "clear" an aircraft to land when it is actually CLEAR to land. I feel like this is a huge problem when you have 3 or 4 a/c on the ils on approach and all are cleared to land

@ClearedAsFiled

6 ай бұрын

You are soooo right...👍

Youve made me an aviation enthusiast. Watched every one of your videos. Really intersting and well explained. Thanks mate

As a training Captain I fully agree that we would not sign off on any pilot who doesn't perform to standard, even if we don't chose the new hires we do have a say if they get released into the line. There was yet another close call with a landing aircraft and another one taking off without clearance, this involved two business jets that actually did have a mid-air. Miraculously both landed safely. In my humble opinion the majority of these cases involved missed or misunderstood communications. This is the major factor that needs work and solutions.

Another brilliant video, with easy-to-understand explanations, presented with confidence and no click-bait. Truly excellent. Thank you.

Super interesting! Keep doing these interesting whole of industry commentaries 👏

I literally live 20 min from tweed and my parents are using Avelo next Feb!! So crazy to hear you talking about my neck of the woods!

Having flown heavy freighters all over the world I have noticed this issue with US controllers. They are enormously talented but I do find their rapid fire, cocky "Maverick-style" radio style to be at times confusing, arrogant and oft time condescending. This is especially to foreign crews who may get confused by rapid fire instructions and then complete comprehension breakdown when slang, and tongue lashing takes place. Btw, I'm an American pilot. Not once have I ever had an issue overseas with attitude. Oft times there may be an accent issue or unfamiliarity confusion but this was always handled professionally, calmly, in a conversational tone that did not require speed listening and writing skills. other issues in US, crossing runway arr/dep. Trying to squeeze in one more..., no standard taxi routes at many places and too much hand holding by controllers...use SIDS and STARS and only speak when a conflict exists.. would lead to a lot less talking over one another. These last couple months have been a real eye opener in regards to ATC. The SFO/Lufthansa incident was over the top.

Having both FAA and EASA licenses, EASA/CAA does it better 100%, especially ATC. Seems here in the States ATC have an authority complex and also need to learn standard ICAO phraseology. Had a controller on a 5am departure in HNL (nobody on frequency) speaking faster than Eminem's "Rap God", just to add to her "cool" factor I guess, a totally useless and unsafe practice we see too often in aviation today. Cool is flying your whole career without an accident/ incident, flying under the radar, and retiring alive.

@patrickeppler6438

6 ай бұрын

Absolutely, once stopped the B777F on a taxiway at JFK because the NY gnd controller was incomprehensible in his Brooklyn accent and mile a minute banter. When asked why I stopped I said I didn't catch is last instructions as they were so fast no one could understand if they weren't ready for the call and he didn't pause a second afterwards. I just figured he would eventually get back to me.

@kimchristensen3727

6 ай бұрын

Europeans like to think their airports are busy but look up the busiest airports by aircraft movements: 9 of the top 10 are in the USA. You have no idea how many more planes US controllers handle and how good they are at moving traffic.

You should check out People Express. One of the first airlines (which I financed as a startup) to offer "small regional airport" access to elsewhere on a transcontinental basis.

I always appreciate your in depth and calm videos like this, which provide important context to these incidents, and how the industry might address the causes.

Memories.... a story that horrified me in New Haven Like any other kid, I wanted to become a pilot but mom vehemently opposed the idea. So I saved up for my license, and finally had enough when I was a collage junior. Called and setup an orientation with a flight school at this very airport in New Haven. Paid my $20 gas fees and off we go. After take off, the instructor was explaining things and I listened as if I didn't already know. Then he asked if I wanted to try it. "SURE" I said. We were going south, so he asked me to turn the plane north to go back to the airport. For about 10 minutes, I was doing great and he just sat there looking at me smiling. Then he asked if I had done any flying before? "Yep, I've logged an hour plus in MS Flight Simulator on my IBM PCjr 😂". I couldn't make out the airport even though he was pointing at it. Then he took control and lined up with the runway to land. But when we were below 100 feet (I think), crosswind kicked the mosquito 30-50 feet away from the runway. He quickly lined up again, but below 50 feet gust did it again but not as far as the last time. He again lined up and continued his descent. That's when I asked in horror: are you still gonna land? A few seconds later he slams the plane onto the tarmac and says "yep, today is a nice day to fly!!! ". As soon as we got off, I hightailed it outta there and never looked back. Mom was right, it's a job for (people on a mission😄). Sorry Petter, but who in his right mind would want to do this every day, for a living! It's like a roller coaster ride, you enjoy doing it every once in a while but not every day.

To qualify my opinion below I'll include a little bit of a personal backgrounder. I'm a retired career air carrier ATP. who was fortunate / unfortunate enough to be seconded to serve for several years as a 'Participant Investigator' on a Government led major air carrier accident investigation team. And although I'm no longer actively involved in the industry, I do continue to maintain an ever keen interest in everything related to aircraft operations. I subscribe to this channel because I appreciate the informed, fair & balanced perspective presented and especially the approach to analysis followed in all Mentour productions. However, a comment / attribution was made during the current discussion which was intended to place 'Check Airmen atop a high pedestal, which I believe is largely undeserved. While there have always been class acts within 'all' pilot ranks, in practice, like Line Pilots most Trainers / CP's are technically average at best and far too many of Trainer / CP's are appointed to fulfill some sort of quota, but will never have the ability and knowledge base to contribute much of anything positive towards the advancement of the Profession.

The FAA appears to be very out to lunch on a number of issues including pilot training, ATC workload/staffing/congestion and pilot mental health. I fly for a Canadian airline and it is definitely interesting seeing the differences in ATC procedures. You'll be cleared to land the instant you check in with Newark or Boston tower with an airplane on approach ahead of you and one just touching down. A couple hours later come back to Canada and the tower controller will not clear you to land until the preceding arrival has exited the runway or departing aircraft has lifted off.

Great research and superb presentation. Back when I was flying with the USAF, I made a point to visit a local ATC facility a couple of times and watch controllers. What an incredibly difficult and high stress environment even a local facility was -- 40 years ago! These people are dedicated and special, and not just anybody can do the job. Their minds have to have the rare capability to hold "the picture" of all the things going on. As someone earlier pointed out, only about 1 in 200 makes it through the process. I would love to see a Mentour Now presentation on ATC and on controllers (really two different-but-related topics), but it might take several installments. The way you put your presentations together, I believe the results would be fascinating.

Thanks for the analysis, very interesting. Of course in Europe and many other parts of the world, fast rail takes a good deal of pressure off the air toutes.

Waiting to hear your insights about the Japan tragedy

In high speed train there are relays of traffic signals in the cabin, there should be something equivalent for plane, a visible signal that confirm the controller clearance

Good analysis overall. I would also note that one of the things that has likely been slowing down properly filling the ranks of ATCOs in the U.S. recently has been an unfortunate trend of hiring (or trying to hire) unqualified leadership at the highest levels. The current U.S. Secretary of Transportation is a politician who previously had literally no experience in transportation beyond dealing with city streets as Mayor of the small-to-medium-sized town of South Bend, Indiana and has been using the job more as a platform for campaigning for future elected office rather than for actually managing the nation's transportation needs, including the FAA staff shortage. He's been quick to grand stand about any problem the airlines may have, but has barely addressed the problems his own organization is facing. Then, to make matters worse, someone with virtually no aviation experience (nearly his entire career was managing local transit in Denver and LA) was nominated to be Administrator of the FAA as a political favor because he worked on the current President's campaign. Even quite a few in his own party (which controls the Senate) thought he wasn't qualified and waited quite a long time to even begin confirmation hearings, which he ultimately failed. As a result, the FAA went quite a long time with no Senate-confirmed Administrator to run the agency, with lower-ranked agency official having to fill the roll on an extended interim basis.

@SteamCrane

6 ай бұрын

Painful, but factual.

ATC in the US is one of the least professional in the entire world. Cannot compare at all to UK or western europe other than france

Hotel-Victor-November!!! Love the convenience of the Avelo flights. Just picked up my wife and son last night. Probably not fun living in the neighborhood. And the short runway makes for rough landings. But it’s still my home airport-where I even logged a few takeoffs and landings a long time ago.

Earned my first job in aviation in Europe flying with LX. Now work for a major US carrier flying 737s since 2016. Both systems have their blind spots. 28 years in the industry and have seen a lot. Love your videos.

Great video as usual, fantastic analysis and critique of US Aviation. !!!! But once again I would have to acknowledge the cursed AI thumbnail...having it be photoshopped/human-made would be icing on the cake for what is an already great video

When corporations push DIE policies, they mean it

Wow, did not expect to hear you discuss my local airport in New Haven! Have only had good experiences with Avelo and Tweed New Haven airport thus far, however I have seen an increase in “Stop Tweed Expansion” signs of people who live in the immediate vicinity. Will be interesting to see how the airport develops as the airline business model changes in the coming years.

We need 'Check Policeman', 'Check Journalist' and more than anything 'Check Presidential Candidates'.

@ClearedAsFiled

6 ай бұрын

Good point...I agree with you 👍

The US ATC practice of clearing a landing aircraft and then clearing an aircraft to depart ahead of it on the same or intersecting runway is inexcusable. Do not make any apology for this unsafe procedure.

@bwalker4194

6 ай бұрын

I wholeheartedly agree! We old school controllers were taught to treat every clearance as if the radios would fail after that clearance.

A twin-engine Hawker H25B departed without permission from Runway 22 @HobbyAirport houston TX. at 4 PM Oct. 25 when it collided with a twin-engine Cessna C510 that was landing on Runway 13 Right.

Lack of ATC staff doesn't help.

Interesting. I was in that gate keeper role as a truck driver trainer. I was informed by my dispatcher that if I kept failing students I might lose my trainer status. I needed the money. I passed drivers who were technically okay but I had doubts about. One of them killed a person in a crosswalk. He had a green light. No charges. But I knew he wasn't very good with observation or reaction time. That's me. If I could do that I imagine others could too.

Always fascinating topics! You mentioned something (NY ATC speaking rapidly) that I've always wondered, the understandability of communications between pilots and ATC. I appreciate that ultimately, they learn how to communicate effectively with each other. But it seems nearly impossible to understand and in any stressful conditions, would be even more so. I'm not sure which is more unsettling between that and and bad penmanship on prescriptions. Kinda joking but not really...

@vbscript2

6 ай бұрын

Honestly, it's *typically* not a problem for most of the traffic (there is the occasional controller that's problematic to understand, but that's true pretty much everywhere.) The bigger problem (especially at airports like JFK) is when they try to talk like that to foreign pilots, especially those from some parts of Asia. Unfortunately, there is also a real problem with certain Asian airlines hiring pilots that realistically aren't anywhere near the level of English proficiency that ICAO requires them to have for international operations... and then they send these pilots to some of the most dense and complex airspace in the world, such as JFK. Most controllers there will automatically speak more slowly when communicating with those pilots, but sometimes they will still speak quickly and it will be difficult for the pilots who already don't have the required level of English proficiency to understand. I would also note that what you hear on LiveATC isn't necessarily representative of what the pilots are actually hearing. The planes and ATC facilities typically have an unobstructed line-of-sight to each other's antennas, especially when the aircraft is airborne. The LiveATC receivers are on the ground, though, so often have buildings or even the Earth in between them at ATC's transmit antennas, so their reception is often much worse than what the pilots have. While aviation radios are definitely not crystal clear (for lots of technical reasons,) they're much clearer than it might seems from listening to LiveATC recordings.

@Wintermute909

6 ай бұрын

​@@vbscript2that's a really good point about liveATC that I hadn't considered. Cheers!

@haqvor

6 ай бұрын

There are a very regulated vocabulary and phraseology that is used to minimize the risk of misunderstandings. Each clearance always uses the exact same phrases so everyone knows what to listen for and what to expect.

@I_Evo

6 ай бұрын

​@@haqvorYes, that's how it should be. But listening back to many of these incidents that's seemingly not always the case.