I'd 100% watch a couple videos about the reforms that Phil talked about at the end of this vid. Always open to learning more about history, even if it is politically based.

@WildGoose1129

Жыл бұрын

I agree. All forms of history are based on or influenced by politics in one form or another.

@ilRosewood

Жыл бұрын

Same. If he makes it - I’ll watch it.

@BrendanMillerExplains

Жыл бұрын

"even" if it is politically based... It's the best history!

@Garbimba1900

Жыл бұрын

Agree

Yes, more videos like this! It's so fascinating to see these inflection points in history that can seem so benign.

I, for one, would love to watch your take on Deng’s policies & reforms - easy to get lost in the political squabble when talking about this guy, hard to pin down my opinion of the guy

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

Yeah it'd be tricky to figure out how to balance it but probably worth learning.

@notreally2227

Жыл бұрын

@@PhilEdwardsInc I think you should dig even further，there have been too much historical myths and cliches piled above Deng's era. Ironically,the conversion to capitalism even started far before the end of GPCR zh.m.wikipedia.org/zh-hans/%E5%9B%9B%E4%B8%89%E6%96%B9%E6%A1%88

To me your strength lies with your eclecticness; when I click on a Phil Edwards video all I really know for sure is that it's either going to be good or it's going to be great. That said, if you make a mini series about each of Deng's major reforms I'll definitely watch it.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

haha thanks and noted!

Deng probably wasn’t the most influential figure for the 20th century, he came into power too late for the arbitrary limits of 1900-2000. However what can’t be argued is that he more than any other has had a bigger impact on shaping the 21st century. Quite sad how few people are aware of Chinese history in general with other figures such as Zhou Enlai and Zhao Ziyang also overlooked. Another really interesting video could be when China’s president Jiang Zemin debated with Bill Clinton on live Chinese TV about political topics like human rights. The same thing happening with XI and Biden would just be unimaginable.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

wow i hadn’t heard about that debate. sounds like the kitchen debate, 90s edition. i’m gonna add that to my list.

@xp8969

Жыл бұрын

You should look up what arbitrary means 😂

I dig the Tom Scott look man! 👍. Great video as usual!

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

haha need to slightly brighten the red.

Your videos are such a good presentation of events that leave room for thought and not strong political statement that seem to take away from the viewer the power to think. Thankyou!

A video about the reforms Deng brought would be awesome. He has changed a lot of lives around the world, not just in China.

@yaoliang1580

Ай бұрын

China's phenomenal progress in a very short period of time has not only improved the livelihood of hundreds of millions of Chinese but also brought great benefits to so many countries around the world as China is now the largest export destination for many of their products

Ahh if only more of life's problems could be solved by going to the rodeo... Thanks for the great vid as always!

You have a real talent to pick (and portray so intriguingly) the historic markers that are only glimpses at the time, but their impact shines for decades

As a history buff this is one of those moments that you simply have trouble accepting as something that actually happened. Its just far too ridiculous but it exemplifies the saying that "Truth is stranger than fiction"

Denis in France, I'm amazed at the news report archive you've found. I'm also very interested about the Cold War and the end of that Era, so your idea about exploring the way China changed and thru what reforms is absolutely my cup of Yunnan tea!

Great video, Deng Xiaoping is indeed one of the most important figures of the last century. Changing the life of so many, getting the PRC recognized, building up a collapsed country and reform it to prevent one man rule. In the west he's mostly know for his biggest mistake. I highly recommend: Deng Xiaoping and the Transformation of China, by Ezra Vogel.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

Ran into this book but didn’t read it - I’ll put it on my list.

@sparqqling

Жыл бұрын

@@PhilEdwardsInc I'm not a reader, but highly recommend this book. About his early days in France, the rise of the party, his purges, his love for croissants and the reforms. The book is written well and based on a lot of research and interviews. Anyone who wants to understand current China should read it, Deng is the master behind the rise of China.

@sushilover5367

Жыл бұрын

his biggest mistake? lol most chinese would deem his prevention of a color revolution in 89 the 2nd largest accomplishment of his life.

Really love how you kept using “went to the rodeo” as a larger metaphor in the video. Really tied it all together. Good work!

I remember that. I suspect the lack of a crowd may be due to it becoming a more private event for security purposes.

Would 100% watch and share good videos about china's economic policy history

@mikewong6815

Ай бұрын

I would too.. enjoyed the whole presentation.

yo the videos on deng reforms would rock, definity would watch them

Phil, wonderful content as always. It would be interesting to see the chronological steps of this event to modern day China, and maybe a follow up with China’s future plans of modernization (market domination).

You have good taste in topics! I enjoy the eclectic nature of the mix

Awesome video, love the editing style

I was one of the peple who didn't know about Deng but learnt a lot in this video, thanks Phil. It's also insighful to see a glimpse at these moments in history with the context of the world today.

I like how you did it, but another good title that would have played on both terms could be: "When China went to the rodeo: Deng's Big Trip".

This was great. I'd seen some photos of Deng in a cowboy hat and never knew much about the trip's context. I'd watch a series on the changes Deng pushed through in China (curious how straight history will work with your/Vox style). I'd actually be more interested in a short piece on the change in US spelling of Chinese names and words that came with the normalization of relations. Added pinyin to the already existing hodgepodge of Taiwanese and various non-standardized Cantonese and Mandarin spellings

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

Yeah that’s not a bad idea.

It's always nice when you upload :) thanks.

I love your videos. One of my top 3 favorite channels. How do you come up with the topics?

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

thanks! i must admit I saw it on this Twitter account: mobile.twitter.com/ampol_moment?lang=en

Absolutely fascinating!! Thank you for the info! Given your previous releases, at this point I just trust your judgement regarding what topics would be interesting enough for future videos.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

Ha that makes one of us!

@nvrndingsmmr

Жыл бұрын

@@PhilEdwardsInc Lol!!

things are quite different now and then. At that time Taiwan was control by a millitary dictatorship who clearly claimed the whole China and even Mongolia as their lawful territories,and therefore they never ended the openly civil war condition with PRC. Also,more than 60% of taiwanese population considering themselves as Chinese at that time.

MORE! I'm definitely all for more China-inspired videos! This one is truly a gem.

Tom Scott seems older than normally.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

hey he's got some grey too.

I am an American who lived in China. Deng established a city called Shenzhen. It is an amazing city and there is a giant billboard/poster with Deng's face praising his accomplishments of opening China.

Thanks for the video and commentary!

Good video. More of these please. Would love to see your reform videos too.

It's a good day when Phil posts. Once again the master of excavating the obscure... Probably secret sauce but would be curious about how you pick and research topics. Great seeing your personal channel grow.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Vam! Based on your last video, I think my methods a bit like yours - whatever interests me or, in some cases, if i’m stuck in a hotel room!

@VAM_Physics_and_Engineering

Жыл бұрын

@@PhilEdwardsInc thanks Phil

Some serious country singer was hurt when you thought it wasn't serious enough 🤣

Very interesting video! Especially jaw-dropping to me was that the NYT changed the spelling of Deng's name because in Germany, we have two ways of spelling the name Mao Zedong (the other way is Mao Tse-Tung). And now I wonder if we did the same thing as the NYT did, though I think you can choose between these two names. Anyway, gotta look up that NYT article if I find it :D

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

Here's the link! timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1979/02/04/112846600.html?pageNumber=10

@squado_6119

Жыл бұрын

@@PhilEdwardsInc Thank you =)

Superb video Phil! Thank you!

So informative! Thank you man.

Would definitely welcome more content on this topic. A couple of quick observations and annecdotes. Chinese leadership got lucky but were also very smart. Over thirty years ago I printed a UK government trade council publication. It was around the time western companies were beginning to offshore, and also we were being told Asia was about to become a huge consumer market. What was very obvious was that the Chinese government was focused on building it's manufacturing capacity and infrastructure. Every issue was full of stories about Chinese buying machine tools, or building major infrastructure: They were strategically building the China of today, with western governments actively competing to help them. What was very obvious is that they were not buying consumer goods from the west but they were taking on manufacturing them. Twenty years later I had a government job working in policy. Again I came across Chinese trade and industrial policy. This time it was government deals promoting tech transfer, the Chinese were doing deals to buy up key technology in clean tech amongst other areas. As before they were operating strategically to build up their industrial capabilities. None of this is new, the Soviets famously took a similar route before the cold-war, and other countries have done the same. But what marks China out is the intelligence they have deployed building their economy, from the annecdotes above to strategically investing in raw materials, and investments in developing countries. Meanwhile in the Anglosphere we have followed a different political and economic approach, the free market approaches of Reagan and Thatcher. Time will tell which was the most effective.

I don't always learn new things in your videos. I did learn something in this one-- keep it up!

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

haha i’ll take it!

Very much here for China politics history content!

Yup this is just amazing content man. Subscribed!

I'd love to learn more about this!

I want to hear about Deng's reforms.

I’m shocked you didn’t say “Enhance” at 0:07

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

dang it. next time.

Love the clip of the reporter, I feel like reporter would be put on suspension if he/she expressed such contempt for an event today.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

I agree!

Yes! Please! Videos about the reforms!

would love to see the video on Teng's Reforms

I hope you cover his cronies possible comeback if pooh bear messes up.. Also, loving the videos, and despite my old thoughts, the background in your basement works... Gives a "I'm working late burning midnight oil learning this stuff to explain to everyone" vibe!

Really liked this video!

I can rarely stand the Vox medium headshot-to-clip cut style, but this is really well done

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

this comment was an emotional roller coaster for me, but it ended up ok

@parsnipproductions8875

Жыл бұрын

@@PhilEdwardsInc I’m sorry Phil - that reads backhanded, I like your style. These subjects are well within the scope of a short/medium length KZread video, and this one takes an interesting perspective. Few in the west talk about China with any nuance, so far as to even know who Deng Xiapoing is. I also see a good amount of care applied when communicating the certainty of claims made on this channel which … well … is sometimes well done in my opinion by some of your contemporaries

I wish you would cover the racist narrative with which western media covers anything China related. Al Jazeera did a pretty good mini doc on how biased our media narrative is and how everything related to China is always covered through a lens of politics even when it’s not politically related.

I am into this series

Your content is wonderful

Cold war era US international politics always make for interesting videos. Always learn new things on this channel!

Just had to pause the video. That song isn’t “Rodeo,” it’s “Beef, it’s what’s for dinner,” from those old commercials LOL

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

They are indeed one and the same. (Though somebody told me fancy people pronounce it "Ro-day-oh" in the dance world, which I did not do).

I love your stuff! Please Do more rising china history!

I absolutely adore Texas reporters repeatedly and uncritically pronouncing the Chinese leader's name "dung"

As a Chinese American, it was interesting to learn more about Deng Xiaopeng!

big fan of this vid very interesting and a good job at keeping bias out of the topic

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

thanks, i do try to keep it pretty down the middle!

Yes, more videos on the reforms, please!

More Chinese history! Def interested

That reporter is so Texan.

Love this video I didn’t even know about this and I’m a Texan

What a great video idea

Yes to more Deng Xiaoping videos!

Algorithmic punch (I visited China in 2004, and some of the malls where playing American country music, a popular trend at the time, and I wonder if it was at all related to this rodeo. also yes the reforms would be a subject of interest.)

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

I ran into this article while researching but didn't get far into it. Seems interesting though. www.theatlantic.com/culture/archive/2021/05/what-john-denver-means-some-asian-immigrants/618784/

@TK-_-GZ

Жыл бұрын

@@PhilEdwardsInc appreciate the effort as always.

Hey just wanted to let you know, I love your videos and always look forward to new ones. But for whatever reason KZreads algorithm never served up this video in two days of active Youtubing, despite being subscribed and having watched all of your videos all the way through. Only reason I know this video was released was because of the story you posted. Not sure if this is useful, but thought I’d throw it out there.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

Dang it you're the second person to say this! Thanks for the heads up.

"Black cat, white cat; what do I care, as long as it catches mice?" ---Deng

Another seemingly boring topic that became captivating once you got your hands on it. Great job. Phil, could you put all your videos on a playlist? That way we can watch them at random.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

I have a history videos playlist already if that helps!

this was the exact moment where we witnessed "the fall of america and its values" and the moment of hypocricy

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

Just ignorance on my part, but I didn't realize how explicit the "you can have Taiwan" was.

@praveenjain262

Жыл бұрын

@@PhilEdwardsInc hi phil appreciate your work, my comment was in context of america's support to democracy and suddenly they got tilted towards china an absolute dictatorship.. that was just another hypocricy on part on USA beside bewildering taiwan..

My parents came from rural town and met in one of the few early Hong Kong money invested factory in Shenzhen. This place is where Deng assigned as one of the special econ zone. So when the western media today talking China in this spooky , smoky way. We the millennials can’t really relate. I always wonder what are they talking about. What we have today is great thanks to Deng . We even have the name “Deng yeye” for his legacy in Shenzhen, Yeye means Grandpa, like he’s the founding father of the modern China.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

thanks for sharing that!

Phil, YT is up to shenanigans again. I'm subbed and notifications on. I check both the bell notifications and go into the menu > subscriptions tab several times a day. No mention of a new video drop from you. Luckily, I'm a fan of the recommended videos under the "Home" tab and spotted your mug there. My conjecture is that the Notifications tab is no longer a strict list of newly published content. As we know, all social media is now driven by algorithm. Most began with a simple list of what was published in reverse chronological order. But whether FB, Insta, Twitter, etc., the average user only views the platform xx minutes per day. Once a user has more than xx friends or feeds or subscriptions, they will not have enough time to browse the entire list of what was published since their last visit. So everything is driven by algorithm now. The algorithms are deeply held secrets but we know they measure things like engagement, which is why for instance the amount of negativity and conflict has soared. Post a cute photo of a puppy, if a user has 1,000 followers, 100 may be shown the photo by algorithm, and 10 may click "like" or leave a comment or share. Instead post a controversial post, say of a puppy that has been mistreated, 100 will be shown the photo, but then many more feel compelled to engage. The algorithm then pushes the content into more and more feeds, until it runs out of followers. In rare occasions if content is really hot, the platform will push it into random users' feeds and thus a viral post is born. The point being, on most platforms it's actually no longer possible for a user to see an accurate reverse chronological list of ALL the accounts they are following. Facebook, for instance, deliberately hid that option under further and further menu layers in the app until they finally removed it completely. At the end of the day, we are not paying customers of any of these services. We lived in that utopia, once, at 2400 baud and monthly subscriptions. Now, ad buying corporations are the customers, we are merely aggregate eyeball data. And the only thing these companies care about is in increasing Engagement and Watch Time, and they do that by only showing us the content their algorithms have decided will lead us to watch and engage more. The dirty secret is that the social media companies don't need to be necessarily nefarious or evil. They're simply competing for our eyeballs, against all of traditional media, and each other. And days at the beach and the 1100 unanswered emails in our inbox and the laundry that needs to be folded and the sunset, right outside. If any one of these companies surrendered their race to the ultimate algorithm, they'll just be pushed aside like good old Tom from MySpace. Just another part of late stage capitalism, it's a race to the bottom and in the end, no one is responsible or accountable. There's a video idea for you ... life by algorithm. Is this the future? Banks are using algorithms to determine credit. Is location destiny? A town in Florida is literally going all "Minority Report" and using "predictive" software to harass those who it has deemed more likely to commit crimes in the future. Netflix and other streaming services only show us content their algorithm has deemed likely to be viewed. It no longer matters if your videos are thoughtful and well made. It no longer matters if they're brilliant, or funny, or entertaining. It only matters if an opaque algorithm that not even its creators can fully understand has deemed your videos worthy of notice to those who have asked to be notified. So if you've noticed your stats going down or wonky, this is why. At first, KZread stopped including all new videos under the "bell" icon, which is why I got into the habit of manually looking under the "subscriptions" tab a couple times a day. They've now removed that as well, so there's truly no way to see if new videos have been published. The sad thing is, I don't know that there are any solutions. There are email lists and push notification services you can use, but then those open another level of non-content creation and annoyance. There's always that one person who decides they no longer want to be notified and rather than unsubscribing, marks the email or text as spam. Which than again hurts the entire effort. I have nothing positive to suggest. Welcome to algorithmic Hell.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

Haha hello from algorithmic hell!! I choose to hope blips like these are just bugs, because I occasionally notice it as a KZread subscriber too. It does seem wise to diversify at some point, but for now I’ll likely stay yoked to Yt. Could be worse - could be Facebook!

At the time Ling-Chieh Kung, Madame Chiang's nephew was CEO of Westland Oil in Houston. I think that's why Deng wanted to come to the Houston area. Westland Oil went bankrupt in the eighties because Kung spent a giant amount of money making a nuclear bunker the size of a small town north of Houston. It even had a prison and a courtroom. Kung really really planned for his Mad Max future.

Deng Xiaoping was the greatest statesman China has had in 300 years. God rest his soul.

I'd like to hear more on the topic of china's post mao period... Have you seen china uncensored? It's an awesome KZread channel and covers lots of china related stuff Maybe you could do a like partnership or crossover video with them Phil... Now that's be kinda cool...

You know, this tour is very similar to the howdy modi tour that happened recently

Lookin' like Tom Scott's long lost American Daddy.... Nice video.

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

hey he's got grey hair too now!

All I knew about Deng Xiaoping going into this was that he was the guy in Hong Kong 97

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

This video has me really intrigued about this game.

I think a big lesson here is that He revolutionized China’s economy - essentially ending poverty - by opening up trade with the west. And right now, in our country we are seeing people on the right calling to grow our economy and at the same time to limit trade with foreign countries because some how they think that will help us. They don’t want to accept that we live in a global economy, and Deng knew this 50 years ago.

I remembered when i worked at Baker Hughes, and one of the old photos showed him touring a plant in Houston in 79. 7:42 where it shows in that clip of him looking at drill bits. It was pretty neat since i grew up in china during the 90s and remembered the mourning period for his death. Kinda nice to see normalizing relationship and the " honey moon" period during the 80s. Too bad China has gone backwards on US china relations now.

Paint me to see how few views this video has. Topics like this explain how we have arrived where we are today in geopolitics

I’m still not over the idea of it being a bad rodeo 😂 and some of the people being nonchalant. Dude said watching a movie on tv 😭

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

I chose not to linger on the clip of the cowgirl falling off her horse and needing medical attention. :|

I’d love to see your take on the reforms too! Especially since while it is very capitalist, it’s arguably not liberal - given how the government owns shares in almost every company, pays money directly to a lot of citizens from the taxes and share dividends of those interests, and still engages quite heavily in central planning for nationwide infrastructure and priorities. It’s interesting to me how he tried to balance the various interests, to leverage the scale of the state to bring the cost of Chinese manufacture so dang low, but also to attract private capital and deliberately create a millionaire and now billionaire class within a country which only really had old-time nobility before the various late-19th early-20th century struggles for power in the country. Many people point toward Sweden as an example of social-democracy as a governmental style, but it feels like Deng sought to create his own version of social-democracy, just coming at it from the communist side rather than the laissez-faire capitalist side, so it features central planning more heavily as part of its compromise.

super interesting

on the topic of videos about his reforms, idk about that. what i like about this channel it answers these silly yet interesting questions and diving deep in them. but thats just me

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

noted!

is your lens dirty?

@PhilEdwardsInc

Жыл бұрын

Seems likely.

It's not real history until someone writes an opera about it. And yes, more of this sort of thing please.

For those who r interested of learning the life journey of Deng, his biography by Ezra Vogel is a must read!

Interesting

he was a legend. Mao zedong built a new China, Deng xiaoping brought China to the world

Interesting event in history

As a Chinese, I would appreciate Deng for his economic reform and open up to the west, but criticize him for being soft and conservative, even resistant, at political reform, which generally somehow lead to Xi's dictatorship today

Wait a minute, you’re supposed to be wearing a pink Elvis jumpsuit for this presentation. I’m bummed. 🕺 ☹️

@dylanwho

Жыл бұрын

Came here to say the same thing! Total bait and switch :( WE DEMAND JUMPSUITS!!!!

Very interesting and I loved the southern college communist.

4:40 the US position on China and Taiwan is absolutely ingenious: The US recognizes that there's one China and Taiwan is a part of China, but it does *not* recognize Beijing as its capital. Think about it, the sentence at 4:40 can also be applied to Taipei being the head of all China.

@sparqqling

Жыл бұрын

That statement was carefully crafted. During the negotiations between Deng and the US to recognise the PRC instead of the ROC (Taiwan) there was a demand that US would not sell weapons anymore to Taiwan. The US agreed to suspend the weapons sales for one year. When Deng found out that is was only one year he was furious, but proceeded because the PRC needed the foreign investment.

Thanks to Deng, the universities in China were reopened after the Cultural Revolution, which allowed my parents and several aunts and uncles to get higher education. Also thanks to Deng, all those college educated family members left China following the crackdown in 1989 and eventually all of them came to the US.

More

Truly his first rodeo

okay but what is a rodeo ?

You didn't mention Deng's famous line. To get rich is glorious. I'm pretty sure he said that after visiting America. Let me know if you'd like help pronouncing Chinese names in the future. I have years of experience learning Chinese as a second language and think I could easily help you sound more professional.