One problem: If Qui-Gon lives, Dooku doesn't join the Sith. Qui-Gons death was the catalyst for that.

@vampricyoda

8 ай бұрын

Not really. Palpatine already had his claws into him as seen in Tales of the Jedi. The deletion of Kamino all happened DURING Episode 1. Qui-Gon's survival means Dooku might have been easier to turn back to the light. But his fall started well before Qui-Gon's death/

@passioneexodite5796

7 ай бұрын

@@vampricyodatrue, however the final push was Qui-Gon’s death.

@jimmyboy131

7 ай бұрын

Qui-Gon's death was important to his turning against the Jedi but he was already on his way out the door, so to speak. If QG had lived he would have tried to bring him with him, though QG wouldn't have followed him into the Sith order.

@ChibaMitsurugi19792

3 ай бұрын

@@jimmyboy131I agree. And maybe he could have prevented Dooku from leaving like when he stopped Dooku from that killing that chubba face senator Dagonet on whatever the planet was called. That was in the 3rd episode of Tales of the Jedi.

My favorite things about Qui-Gon Jinn is that he understood the true meaning of attachments despite what the Jedi Code says and that he did not follow the ways of the Jedi Council but instead he followed the will of the force.

Obi-Wan - "Don't do anything rash!" *proceeds to jump out a window after the droid*

I got three words for this: What. A. Story. This is genuinely incredible, bro, a timeline of Qui-Gon living and becoming a father to Anakin never and Anakin being the Jedi he meant to be, and Obi-Wan being the brother Anakin needs and being the Jedi family what it meant to be. What I found this AU more enjoyable is having Maul redeemed. For there are youtube channels with Maul being brought to the light side, but they are not impactful on what you did with Maul for the journey, and his character arc made him grow as a better person. I would love to see a sequel to this where Maul becomes a grey force user, Anakin leads the Jedi away from politics, and Mother Talzin pulls a Reva move on Maul similar to what Reva tries to do with Vader from the Kenboi Series. Anyway, this is a great story, my friend; keep up the fantastic work, and may the force be with you!

@BanthaStew

11 ай бұрын

Thanks Benjamin, I really appreciate the kind words. I'm glad you enjoyed it so much. Honestly, with the response this video is getting, I might do a part two and if so, I like your idea a lot. May the force be with you too.

@TheKieran112233

10 ай бұрын

@@BanthaStewplease do a part 2, I am hooked!

one thing abt mace vs sidious, sidious did not hold back at all, Mace defeated him fair and square

What if Mother Talzin was Sidious’s apprentice.

@BanthaStew

11 ай бұрын

That would be cool

@ericfrontczak8016

10 ай бұрын

She's weak

@beentheredonethat5908

9 ай бұрын

​@@ericfrontczak8016What lmfao? Palpatine wanted her as his apprentice. With a mix of dark sister magic, her dark side connections, she woukd have been a powerful apprentice. He didn't pick her because she was so powerful and he didn't understand her magic , which was an issue for him, he feared it. He choose her child because of her ability, ive never heard such a ridiculous claim!

Idea: what if Anakin killed obi wan on mustafar. Love this fan fiction

@BanthaStew

11 ай бұрын

Thank you and cool idea

This feels like their be a part 2

@BanthaStew

11 ай бұрын

🤷‍♂️ maybe, we’ll see

Anakin trained by qui gon would probably sense palpatine was a sith, in fact palpatine and plague’s feared qui gon training Anakin.

I love this, an AU where Qui lives long enough to die of old age . I adore Qui gon and his boys and even like maul in this.

@BanthaStew

11 ай бұрын

Glad you enjoyed

The biggest mistake the Jedi Order made was not making Mace Windu Anakin's mentor and trainer 😅

@krismikewill

9 ай бұрын

I agree. If he's "The Chosen One," why is a new knight training him?

SW Idea: What If Maul was a Jedi

@BanthaStew

11 ай бұрын

That’s a good one

@skyscrapermadness_0904

11 ай бұрын

Most definitely 👍

This is honestly really good. And that’s not me looking at it through the lens of “man, I wish”, but I find that it flows well and is really intricately thought out. You rewrote the events of the Star Wars universe, and left very few loopholes (if any). Great work, man.

@BanthaStew

11 ай бұрын

Thanks Cody, I’m glad you enjoyed it.

Interesting way to leave this off, with the witches still alive and able to plot out revenge.

I love this alternative idea.

@BanthaStew

11 ай бұрын

Thank you, it was fun to make

What if the Jedi actually realize that the genetic model for the Republic Clone Army was standing with the Separatist movement on Geonosis...

Yellow lightsaber blade is the colour of the Jedi Sentinel. Qui-Gon is a Jedi Consular and you don't change your Jedi class once it's established. His blade would stay green.

I always wished Qui-Gon had survived. It was a bum deal from Lucas that he died, and I'm still convinced he should have defeated Maul.

Liam Neeson and the fact that no one really gave a shite about "Trainspotting" over there. Qui Gon jinn when he was cut down by Maul everyone was like "NOOOOOOOOO!" "Sob sob"...

What if anakin was declined training by the Jedi order and following that obi wan left the order and took anakin to train him on mandalore

What if Lord Kazeem joined Darth Bane?

"Max level Jedi rizz" lmao Anakin's got _nothing_ on Obi-wan's and Qui-gon's god-level jedi rizz

the thing is by the time the 5s stroy happens not only did he already take out his inhibotor chip but the night sister were also whiped out

What if the jedi never discover Anakin due to never having their hyperdrive malfunction over Tattoine?

This deserves so many more views how does it only have 300 what

@BanthaStew

11 ай бұрын

Just came out today 🤷‍♂️ we’ll see how it does throughout the week. Glad you enjoyed it

@krismikewill

9 ай бұрын

16k as of 23 July 2023.

The youngling saver 9000 lol

I loved this video, folks! Well done. I think that it might be your best one yet!

Your writings are fire keep going man much respect 🔥

bro your intros are great, not to mention your editing in general, for a relatively new channel its nice to see, great story keep up the great work

@BanthaStew

10 ай бұрын

I appreciate that, thanks!

This starts off wrong immediately. It's because of the dark side the maul is able to keep fighting, knowingly slowing qui-gon down at the same time luring him into a small space where his form of lightsaber stance limits his attacks. Palpatine wouldn't be afraid of maul ratting because he never told maul anything.

Bro this is genuinely a great story I would rather have this as a movie or tub series then anything Disney has made

@BanthaStew

10 ай бұрын

Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it

You mean, what if he were stabbed by a light saber, under Disney? He'd have shrugged it off - obviously. I'm reminded of General Woundwart from Watership Down - "Light saber's aren't dangerous!"

Great video bantha!

@BanthaStew

11 ай бұрын

Thanks!

@GeekSavant80x

6 ай бұрын

​@@BanthaStew like a bantha

What if Qui-Gon was the Jedi Grand Master ?

What if Cal Kestis was trained by Qui Gon Jinn?

Good video man

This is a Great Video ❤❤❤❤🥰🥰🥰🥰👌👌👌👌🤯🤯🤯🤯👍👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏🙏 Can't wait for Full Video 2nd Part.

What if Yoda was a Hot Dog instead of a gremlin?

Of course being played by Liam Neason helps.

If he survived sidous would obviously like something else up to have him killed cause Qui gon was a big threat to his Grand plan as well as Obi wan, he didn’t see Obi wan as much of a threat but if you think abt it he killed Maul, killed grievous, Crippled Anakin

So disappointed in Maul for betraying Asajj and Savage

Obi-wan was a better teacher. Qui-gon did not have time for two. It would have been a darker timeline in which Qui-gon had more trouble constraining Anakin than Obi-wan. He was an old man at the point where Anakin turned passably adult.

@Matt-yg8ub

6 ай бұрын

Obi Wan was already grown…..nothing remained but to take the trials. A six month overlap would not have been difficult for Qui to juggle. Qui Gon was very much a better choice to train Anakin. His mannerisms and experience made him far more of a father figure and less of a cocky big-brother and that’s precisely what Anakin needed….someone to confide his struggled to rather than a brother to complete against. If Anakin had confided to Qui-gon that the force was giving him visions of his mother dying ……he would have packed up and flown to Tatooine that afternoon….not told him that dreams pass in time. If Anakin told Qui-gon he was afraid to loose someone…..he would have asked him who and why……not pulled a little green goblin version of Elsa and told him to “let it go”. Anakin’s young adult angst was never dealt with because every time he tried to seek help…the stodgy bastards brushed him off with empty platitudes and Jedi wisdom instead of acting like friends and helping him.

What if cad bane killed kenobi in the box arc

Is there a what if vid talking about if anakin lead the siege of mandalore like mail wanted and he got to talk to him

Question to anybody out there… Why didn’t Luke’s NJO ever use Myrkyr as a sort of “dark-Jedi prison?” Vornskers hunt Jedi, the ysalimiri disrupt the force…seems like the perfect prison planet for “dark-siders” Edit: sorry, just getting back into legends, only ever read Thrawn tridge and NJO so far

A cool story and very enjoyable. The changes I'd like is to see are anakin and padme getting together around 5 years after palpatine's death. Thus luke and leia skywalker are born. What the jedi Council do about it is anyone's guess. I'd like to see a period of deep reflection and contemplation on attachment amongst other things. Also going deeper into the jedi archives than is usual for standard operating procedure. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

What if the droid army dint attack and start the war?

If you want to suggest What Ifs, chat with fellow Star Wars fans and keep up to date with the Bantha Stew community, make sure to join the Bantha Stew Discord Server 👉 discord.gg/se3Xdnc 👈

What if revan trained anakin like if revan was frozen in time and woke around phantom menace

Kenobi would not need tries he helped destroy a Sith.

Great story! But if i'm poking holes, why did Qui-Gon not see Dooku one last time. Could he not try to redeem his master?

This would have been a great movie if Lucas never introduced Luke and Lia

What if Grievous escaped Utapau for Mustafar and then Anakin tried to kill Grievous and the other separatists and then Grievous and Obi-wan team up to fight Anakin on Mustafar?

Good video

@BanthaStew

11 ай бұрын

Thanks

What if anakin killed suidion in attack of the clone

Oh come on !!!! Obi-Wan was a total dog , he absolutely would have tried with a little hottie like Padme . There is no way that he wouldn't want to play " hide the gundark " with her .

im starting to think this man is not real, his humor is too dad jokey 🤔

What if Qui Gon trained Luke

What if obi died instead of qui gon

I wish Ahsoka had been included

It’s great, but I would like Luke and Leia to have been born. Luke is stronger than Anakin. No if ands, or but’s. What if Qui-Gon taught Luke?

Oooo what if qui gon survived should be goooood *maul kills ventress* ehh this is crap 😂

what if ankin was born female

@PugnaciousProductions

11 ай бұрын

Luke and Leia wouldn't be born, but really nothing.

@cecilarthurton3795

11 ай бұрын

@@PugnaciousProductions if anikin was female Luke and Lisa will still be born when Anika gets pregnant by the force

He didn’t Survive, Darth Maul took care of That!!!