Another problem in Dunki is that you see SRK not Hardy, while in other RH movies you see the characters Munna Bhai, Rancho, PK, Sanju and not Sanjay Dutt, Aamir Khan or Ranbir Kapoor.

@rehansuhaib

Ай бұрын

It's not the problem it's just that srk persona is so big that every character he plays we see him as srk and not the character anymore.

@mrluciferlucerna

Ай бұрын

@@rehansuhaib I don't think that is it, SRK can mold himself into any character he's given, he's done that multiple times and successfully so SRK told in an interview that he used to send Hirani clips of him speaking dialogues in different ways, and I think Hirani just chose the wrong method this time

@abhijeetdeshpande150

Ай бұрын

​@rehansuhaib thats an excuse bcos recently i was watching chennai express he was rahul who found himself in trouble surrounded by gangster and langauage problem . I didnt see any charm of srk there onlg rahul who is in trouble

@user-ev4lo5yf9p

Ай бұрын

That's what i've been meaning to say

@user-ev4lo5yf9p

Ай бұрын

@@rehansuhaib Excuse me sir but do you see The Iron man persona in RDJ in Oppenheimer It's a shitty persona if you can't live and act every character in your films

CAN'T BELIEVE HIRANI MADE A ONE TIME WATCH MOVIE

@macksequeira4233

Ай бұрын

Adhiktar 2 baar dekhi jaa sakti hai, overall achhi hai. 3.5/5 👍

@lareveur6094

Ай бұрын

Kudos to those who watched it once

@macksequeira4233

Ай бұрын

@@lareveur6094 bhag Salaar ke 14, tu wahi dekh Prabhas aur Prashant Neel ki tatti

@Deep2RUN

Ай бұрын

not even one time

@pi.log10

Ай бұрын

*Main Reason - No VIDHU VINOD CHOPRA*

One of the worst thing in the movie was srk justfying illegal immigrants in that cringe court scene

@Anonymous-bf5fk

Ай бұрын

True.

@premprasun1516

Ай бұрын

20 minutes v nhi dekh paya main

@parkar09sanil

Ай бұрын

Also the last msg...in end credits....

@Vor567tez

Ай бұрын

I think the topic itself was flawed. Illegal immigrants is a vicisious system that is totally illegal. But unlike previous leads of Hirani movies where the leads are challenging the corrupt system ,SRK is unintentionally justifying the system. (That's also why Sanju didn't resonant much.) Gangubai tackles this tricky situation better. It maintains the delicate balance b/w romanticization vs reality. We do sympathize with her but also became cautious of awful condition the system propose.

@rajeebdas1724

Ай бұрын

'Hardy justifying '... Not srk.

After watching Dunki ALTERNATE Story and Dunki could be PK sequel segment, I bow before you. Purey 50 minute vasool ho gaye. 💯💯💯

@elvissteve7415

Ай бұрын

Yup. That was good stuff!👌❤

@satyanarayantibrewal4513

21 күн бұрын

Wahi! Bhai soch ke itna maja aaraha hai to banta to ask lag jata Baki srk bhi haga to hai movie mai

@prashil3k594

18 күн бұрын

Bande ne Ra One Fixed me hi khud ko prove kar diya tha.

@elvissteve7415

18 күн бұрын

@@prashil3k594 acha. Will watch that one 👍

Manu red flag part was way more funnier than whole movie.

I always felt that Vidhu Vinod Chopra was the hit factor in Hirani's films.

@Andrewtate200

25 күн бұрын

Not really.. It was amir khan actually.. He have director mindset.

@meinhunerd

18 күн бұрын

Sanju , Munna Bhai​@@Andrewtate200

@RBNrocks

5 күн бұрын

Exactly. 12th Fail was released at the same time and did wonders

@meinhunerd

5 күн бұрын

@@RBNrocks July mein aayi thi

Main reason is Vidu vinod Chopra, this is first time they both have not worked together and vvc created 12th fail and hirani Dunki. Difference is clear who was creative in both of them

@Akhil_923

Ай бұрын

Bollywood is mediocre industry

@SatisFire6677

Ай бұрын

yeah exactly...now its time to praise writters more than directors

@macksequeira4233

Ай бұрын

Oh really?? What about SHIKARA, MISSION KASHMIR, PARINEETA, EKLAVYA and THE BROKEN HORSES - these were below avg films and without Raju Hirani. DUNKI is far better than these.

@macksequeira4233

Ай бұрын

​@@SatisFire6677 Rajkumar Hirani is the writer of all of his films. VVC just loves taking credit as a creative consultant.

@somnathbanerjee_2922

Ай бұрын

@@SatisFire6677 Hirani Sir writes his own stories but problem this time is that, if u see writers of Dunki. One more writer is there that is Kanika Dhillon. She is member of Red Chillies I guess. SRK shouldn't have interfered in the writing part. I think, that's one of the problem.

The ending was so good when Manu ghosts Hardy, I literally watched it 7 times.

@prathmeshchougule6529

Ай бұрын

Abe saley💀😂

@Jagvir_Wariyah

5 күн бұрын

because raj hirani used to make films on real society problems with good logic whereas dunki was illogical for so many people as they shown dunki this story could have been better showing real stories but as we know doing dunki is like a second name of death for me and for many other people, so to make this movie entertaining they just skipped that part and they created too much roar ovet other things like not finding jobs or getting jobs but no respect or money and id proofs, living which they ve shown us but they never showed us with details , in the end they could give us some solutions of these kind of problems yeah they tried to solve when "srk doesnt accept that he is not fear from his own country "india" then they deport him but taaapse and other people with him stay there but that wasnt as much impactful as raj's other films like 3 idiots,pk where he had one agenda to solve the problem, like in 3 idiots it was "listen to your heart ,to parents also" whereas pk had "firki le raha koi,hum kon hote hain dunia chlane wale ", so these kind of agendas ...left us thinking about these problems . if we see in a buisness tactik this film was a commercial film nothing to do with reality of real dunki it is not inspiring like his other films and other reason could be vidhu vinod chopra who worked with hirani in films like 3 idiots,lage raho munna bhai ,munna mbbs and ecc... they dont work now idk why but vidhu chopra made 12th fail which is a masterpiece where rajhirani disappointed many of us!!

The title of this video is so accurate AF! like I was literally thinking the same exact question before sleeping every day (Ever since I witnessed the horrors of dunki in theatres).

@jonjafri1427

Ай бұрын

ok dunki wasn’t horror. It wasnt the best hirani movie nor the best srk movie, it wasnt as funny as it could’ve been but it wasnt a terrible movie still a one time watch but a decently good watch

@shivaansh.x

Ай бұрын

@@jonjafri1427 agreed!

@PrayasRahangdale

Ай бұрын

​@@jonjafri1427 dunki was a crap. Hirani's worst work. Wasn't even lukewarm funny, total torture.

@namastehindustan9879

Ай бұрын

​@@jonjafri1427nah, it was trash

@whotube88

Ай бұрын

Overreaction. It wasn’t his best, but wasn’t one of the worst movies you’ve ever seen either. It was a feel good movie. Not every movie has to evoke extreme emotions.

Partnership of both Vidhu Vinod and Rajkumar Hirani did the magic. In Dunki the magic was missing.

"Par hamara kya hai hum ladke toh fir bhi aisi Red Flag ke piche zuban latkate bhagenge" - by Cinemaan

Keep rocking man - and this video would reach Hirani for sure.... hopefully he ups his game and gets back to his OG form which made all of us worship his craft for years!

the most messed up i felt was when they didnt give enough pause during VICKY KAUSHAL death scene. i was shocked, itna build up and finally death ke baad character ko accha farewell bhi nahi diye. EMOTIONS kidhar hai?

@tanvitripathi3997

Ай бұрын

How?

@saumilshah555

Ай бұрын

Vicky wanted to go to London for a day, why was he giving ielts , would have gone on tourist visa 🤔🤔

@anubhavdhananjai2835

Ай бұрын

His Death scene was not given enough screen time. After effects of the death was not explained deeply... Emotional value kamm ho gayi ​@@tanvitripathi3997

@fighterWarKrrish

26 күн бұрын

​@@saumilshah555True

Bhai Priyadarshan Per Part 3 or S Shankar per video chahiye.

Seeing your hero falling , its hard to console yourself

@Andrewtate200

25 күн бұрын

Not hero.. Director Cuz srk already gave 2 blockbusters in single year..

Your perception for movies opened my eyes to see larger in depth picture what an actor or director wants to convey via particular scene..

I saw you uploaded a video. I made special time out, prepped for bed, charged my phone and watched ur video till end. Kudos man ! Cant wait when u actually get in the field and I see ur work.

Accept the harsh fact - Raju Hirani made his last good film in 2009.

@shellby2388

26 күн бұрын

Pk >>>>>>>>Raju All films

@ammarscut8804

23 күн бұрын

Pk bi fit thiii i think Sanju se garbar start hui

Finally you uploaded the video🎉🎉🎉

It feels like Hardy was written after SRK confirms to working with Hirani. SRK wanted to do film with Hirani and vice-versa.

another brilliant video, don’t mind the wait as long as you keep making such videos

I love the fact that you dive deep into each movie. From editing to writing, you analyze everything in a detailed manner. I believe that everyone who loves movies or wants to be a filmmaker should watch your movie and director analyses. There is so much to learn. Thank you very much ❤

Mujhe samajh nahi aata ke Aanand L Rai, Maneesh Sharama, Imtiaz Ali & Rajkumar Hirani ne SRK se pehle jitni movies ki thi wo saari Super-Hits. Saari movies SRK ke saath kyun moot deti hai ?

@Ekmevadwitiyam

4 сағат бұрын

Kyonki in sab ne apna rawness kho diya... SRK ko off beat films offer karke... SRK wanted to work with good directors but all of them experimented with him only.... The director who didn't experiment were Siddharth and Atlee...

@bluemoonbm3618

4 сағат бұрын

@@Ekmevadwitiyam very true

Kya gazab bande ho yaar! Kaise itna detailed video bana lete ho

Amazing work bhai . The level of detail and research is next level . Keep it up bhai 💯😀

Amazing Video Brother 🤗 Maza aagya 🔥 keep it up 👍

God level of analysis you have done man ... really appreciating.... May Raju Hirani too see this one today...

Was eager to know your perspective on the film!!

That "Manforce" and literally "ghost" thing caught me off-guard! Hilarious!

Marvellous bro! Simply Marvellous! 👏👏👏👏

wake up babe cinemaan just dropped a vid

@parththakkar6823

Ай бұрын

is this babe here in the room right now?

Loving your connect brother.. keep making videos more frequently and your in depth analysis.. 🎉

Bhai I genuinely love your ideas concepts and u actually will be a good film maker All the best ❤❤

Loved the video. Ek hi sittong me puro dekh daali. The best part was the two alternate stories you suggested. Also, can you do a similar analysis on the works of Shankar ? Maybe can be released to coincide with Indian 2 ?

I read a comment and then realized that this vid was approx. 50mins long .. your analysis was on point and very rightly articulated! 👍

So happy to see you back

Bhai, maine pichle 3/4 saal me itna lamba video wo bhi ek seating me pehli baar dekha hai. Isi se samajh jao aapka video kitna behtareen hai. Great work bhai.

Your alternate Dunki and PK story is so "Hirani" if i ever get to film making I'm making this movie myself and will give all it's credit to you. ❤

Dunki alternate story👌🙌💫 Good concept bro!

Ur amazing hope u get acknowledged for your work soon

Bhai i subscribed to your channel the moment you narrated the alternate Dunki story.. that would have been fascinating (& yes it could surely be PK 2)

Next level effort and content!

Great Research and ideologues ❤

Loved This Video!

Just want to appreciate you brother. Thank you for this long form content that you have been putting out on interesting topics. Finally someone is doing it for Indian films too. Your content is exceptional and inspires me. keep it up

In an Latest Interview Hirani said: It's Just I try New Things in the movie Like not same from my previous movies & it's Like Mai aab ek loop Mai Chuka huu And burden of Raju Hirani Cinema "Agar previous Movie Jaisa kuch banaya tho bolege yeh tho repeat Kar raha hai & Kuch Naya Tarike sai Banaya Tho Bolege Yeh Kya Bana diya Hame Aap ki purani movies Jaisa Magic Chaiye, I mean It's a loop" .

@vidhishajani6524

29 күн бұрын

Correct bro. But still being and SRK fan I believe Dunki was not able to reach that milestone but still it is not that bad it is very good and I am damn sure that King Khan and Raju Hirani will collab again and make a masterpiece.

I think hirani want to do some experiments on audience taste that will the audience enjoy this type of movies . After people don't like it so for sure hirani make his films like his older films in future .

@Akhil_923

Ай бұрын

Why bollywood dont explore different gener ?

@lelouch7315

Ай бұрын

Because they don't work as audience always reject revolutionary or unique films that is trying to do something new. ​@@Akhil_923

@koolaiddudeawesome9850

Ай бұрын

@@Akhil_923Because audiences won’t see it

@killlernoob1842

Ай бұрын

Ye in bade bade directors ko saare experiments sirf SRK ke saath hi kyu karne he 😭🙏

@rajaditya5542

Ай бұрын

@@killlernoob1842 facts bro 😭

Wow Bro!!! what an Explanation!!

Raju Hirani's humour had already taken a dip in sanju. Like the sequence where he goes to ask for liquor from his gf's father looked like HouseFul type comedy scene . p.s I wrote this comment before reaching that poin in vidoe :p

Great Video! Ab ye bhi batado ki agle 3 mahine kis video ka wait krna hai. My suggestion is that Amar Singh Chamkila deserves a video.

Intro is sooo good bro. I totally relate. Went FDFS and this expresses me too so well 🤣

Bhai aapke sare shorts aur ye puri video dekhane ke bad ek hi cheej kehna chahta hu, "aap genius ho"👌👌👌👍

47:53 Agree... Except the "make me cry" part.... This scene was truly beautiful....

Mast Edit ❤❤❤

Broooo your version was soooo good ❤❤

Cinemaan sir, please make more videos.. Let me rephrase that, please make videos with more frequency. This is the first video of yours that I saw, and I am already a huge admirer of your analysis.

Bhai itni research kahan se kar lete ho bhai. I am fond of watching movies and would also love making one , maybe in future. These video essays are like Lectures on improving your Filmaking Skills. I want to Thank You for making these videos so entertaining for all of us. Really wish to be such a great Film Analyzer (if that word exists) like YOU!!!

What a detailed video 😂😂

Absence of Vinod Chopra in this film may also be another cause

You deserve all respect for Dunki alternate story and PK could be dunki! KUDOS

I thought I was alone to feel about missing old charm in RH's movie...thanks @Cinamaan bhai to admit it & elaborate it to audience

Brilliant analysis, excellent alternate story ideas, I only hope Hirani himself notices this video

@Andrewtate200

25 күн бұрын

Dono ideas op hai.. Pk ka sequal karke bohot kuch kar skthe the toh socho agar Amir SRK and Ranbir ek saath Aajathe aur yeh falthu ke extra actors remove kardethe toh bohot better hojathi movie.

What a video man hats off.

We want a full 3 part series for dunki's alternate story !!!!

I don,t know how many of you agree.. but mannu death scene is literally very 70s 80s era type (hero's mother death scene)... "jaha uski Maa ekdm se bolte bolte mar jati h aur uske bad hero bolta hai "Ae maaa kuch bol na maa" Jiske bad usko pata chlata hai maa mar gyi to upar dekhkar echo me chillata hai MAA ...... Bus shahrukh ka upar dekhkar mannu chillana reh gya ........I don,t like this scene😂 But ghar wapsi wale scenes are good..

@Akhil_923

Ай бұрын

70s ki masala movies bahut better hoti thi deewaar,zanjeer

@tanvitripathi3997

Ай бұрын

True man, as cancer se koi itna sudden thodi na marta hai, ki baitha or marr gya, na wo koi itni budhiya thi jiski sudden cardiac arrest se death ho gayi.

@indianfan1029

Ай бұрын

The truth is, it didn't even matter 1% whether she lived or died. Koi sympathy hi nahi thi us character ke sath, right from the start. Like Chinki in Munnabhai or Jhanvi in Lage raho.

Bhai the biggest mistake is casting overactor srk in the film.

Apka idea bht jabarjast laga...👌

bro first time visited your video and my fkin lord bhai itni deep knowledge about movies...Hatt's of to you man

Welcome back ❤

Your alternate dunki story got me so hyped, i kept clapping. God if Hirani thought something like that for this movie, wud have been too interesting although it follow the template of Pk but still wud have been better than Dunki.

Hi buddy, big fan of your channel.. you're doing excellent job.. Can you please rank all the Raju Hirani's filmography..

because there was no Vidhu Vinod Chopra, he was the real brain behind his movies

A very well thought out video essay. I was really impressed by your version of the story 36:49. Subscribed!

Where is the slate of your upcoming videos?

Loved your detailed analysis..and one thing is - Your Video is much more funny than the entire Dunki Movie😂😂

Very clever font selection. Fonts are subtle ripp off of actual Movie font

your theory for improving dunki story seems very interesting , it can be a spiritual sequel of dunki. the kohinoor idea was awesome 🙌

ur analysis>>>

Intro was epic..perfect as per situation…ye wala mere saath bhi hua tha 😂

40:45 Man, I just want to add that the weird top-light on the actors' heads in that train shot was so fake and took me right out of the song and the montage. This movie really needed a lot of help. Brilliant video.

@cinemaanreal

Ай бұрын

Tbhi mai sochu why it looked so artificial. Great observation!

bohat mahnat ki larkay👏👏👏

100% True Opinion And The Antagonist Presentation As Compared To Previous Movies Was Just Soo Different !

The guy on 20:13 is a NSD 2010 passout btw. He is one of the guys that were in this acting workshop I did. He is thoroughly insightful, and is extremely knowledgable as a person

@virajbhambid2657

21 күн бұрын

But still people want won't watched him

Intro bahut funny hai bhai 😂😂 mazaa aagaya

The fact is that, Rajkumar Hirani has given masterpiece it's always hard to land another one. As you said there is internal conflict, between other movies because it comes from there experience and it goes on paper. I have heard many writers writing there own experience in serials or movies. That make that scene authentic. This case fits in this movie and even your decoding.

Recently discovered your channel and i love it.Saradin kam karne ke baad khane ke time dekne ke liye perfect content.

Amazing!! Can you also do an analysis on Nolan movies?

Coco ne Dil choo liya tha dost.

Bhai wo Kohinoor wali story bhot sahi hai kisi indian animation studio ke saath milkar direct kar lo indian anime bhi ban jayega aur aapka film debut bhi ^^

We want your videos on regional cinemas and your in depth review on particular movies released recently..

Very deep analysis 👋👋👋👋

Remember Anushka Sharma's mediocre love story portrayal in PK ? That's the vibe of Dunki as a whole.

Bhai tune mere dimaag mai camera lagaya hai kya, tumeri dimaag ki baate yaha kaise bol deta hai 🙂🙂❤️❤️

Bhai kya video tha maza aa gya 😂😂

Bhai Sanju mein Sr. Dutt ka editor ko sabak sikhane wala scene kaisa keh sakte hain aap, kya usme character apni baat ko action se nahi samjhata (Dutt Sahab writing Not Finished) ?

I noticed the same 'Raw emotion' thing in Sajjad Ali's play "Zard Patto Ka Ban" where they recreated a viral "watermelon seller" video in play using an actor. It was so wateredown

You know what was missing? BROMANCE! Even with the king of romance I felt nothing for Manu and Hardy's relationship at all. Would've been much better if the film followed to duo of Vicky's character and Hardy. Hirani and Joshi do the bond between two male characters very well, the dynamic between them is always THE or one of the highlights.

@asay27

24 күн бұрын

Oh yes exactly Munna - Circuit Rancho - Raju - Farhan Jaggu - PK

Keep it up look like I am taking my favorite teacher class .... Totally interesting ❤❤❤

Bro no one noticed but tumhari videos edit karne me bhi ek alag hi humour dikhta he

Another banger. Cinemaan never misses.