*Which other megaregions should I cover next? China or India?*

@NamesGryphon

Ай бұрын

India would be neat

@ghost21501

Ай бұрын

I feel like China and Southeast Asia are mostly unknown in the West. Would be cool to see.

@muhammadhamzazafar6903

Ай бұрын

you can cover both india and the northeast Pakistan region of Punjab as well as maybe some areas of Bangladesh such as Dhaka

@biggussdickuss5184

Ай бұрын

China

@baileyfellers5465

Ай бұрын

Please do both! I love learning more about how the world is becoming more interconnected through urban development. Although I think China would be more interesting to start off with

If all roads lead to Rome, at least 3 Megaregions lead to Italy.

@togerboy5396

Ай бұрын

I was just going to comment about this, it’s so cool to see how northern Italy is the crossroads of the three most important megaregions. It’s probably because of infrastructure out of Italy during the Roman Empire and HRE.

@miliba

Ай бұрын

@@togerboy5396 If you play on the Mediterranean map of Civ 6 and spawn on Italy, you'll wanna secure Northern Italy asap

@publicminx

Ай бұрын

they actually lead to Northern Italy to be exact. The gravitation moved within Italy already at Rome time from Rome to cities like Ravenna, later under the Germanic Frankish Empire it became further empowered and after the split of the Frankish Empire it was kind of a (with huge autonomy) part of the Holy Roman Empire which coninued the empowerment of quasi independent cities who created maritime trade empires which were connected (via land and rivers like the Rhein/Rhine throughout Germany) with the other maritime trade empire (the Hanseatic league with Luebeck/Germany as de facto capital) which made Northern Italy as kind of a hub to other more southern regions and on the other side with the other side of the Holy Roman Empire - the Green Banana. And Germany is basically in the dominant center in Europe, as being part or between most Mega regions (Blue Banana, Green Banana, the Norrdinc String, Gulf of Finnland) ...

@Bayard1503

Ай бұрын

Or leave from Italy...

@rspirit

27 күн бұрын

All roads lead to Milan!

As someone who lives near Helsinki, the reality is that Finns never have been traveling to St Petersburg and prefer a 100 times more Tallinn and Stockholm. Since Estonias independence our traveling has mainly only been there and no Finns really ever have been to Russia, eventhough St Petersburg area has more people than Finland as a whole.

@BostonElton

Ай бұрын

as someone who lives in Stockholm i prefer Helsinki over like every other city

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Thanks for the inside view! It does seem odd to include Saint Petersburg along with Helsinki and Talinn. From a geographic point of view, sure - they're all in the Gulf of Finland, but as a continuous urban area it doesn't make much sense.

@xaverlustig3581

Ай бұрын

In an ideal world, St Petersburg and Helsinki would be in close contact though.

@heh9392

Ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge Yea alot and alot of forest in between the cities of the shoreline and only Helsinki and St Petersburg are the only million person cities on the gulf.

@coyotelong4349

Ай бұрын

The political divide between dictatorial Soviet Union/Putinist Russia and freedom-loving Finland over the decades has had a lot to do with that, no doubt

Do more megareigon and belt videos, they are very interesting

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

I agree! Will do :)

@nettcologne9186

Ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge... and don't forget the "German belt" when discussing the belts in the USA. thx

@gregoryturk1275

Ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledgedon’t forget the taiheiyo belt

@gregoryturk1275

Ай бұрын

Japan

Keep cooking bro

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

👨‍🍳

@Eroscty

Ай бұрын

​​@General.Knowledge the Atlantic axis should be called the Atlantic Iberia

@chandrasarmah8255

Ай бұрын

And you wash the dishes 😉🍽️

@interycreeper1152

Ай бұрын

​@@chandrasarmah8255 We'll worry about the dishes. He worries about cooking.

@jonathan9431

Ай бұрын

​@@General.KnowledgeGirona is pronounced like G in English, not Jirona, its a Catalan City and in Catalan the g is pronunced like in English

Do one for Asian Megalopolis like the Pearl River Delta or the Taiheiyo Belt

@sir_dreadlord_on_blitz7042

Ай бұрын

Yes!

@SlapStyleAnims

Ай бұрын

Yeah!

@suryakumarsharna3074

Ай бұрын

Defo

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Yes! On my list

@crazydog1750

Ай бұрын

The Pearl River Delta is insane to looks at metrics for.

"Some people call it the pickle too, apparently." Am I the only one who bursted out laughing? 😂

@QuahogFlashback

Ай бұрын

yes

@aldrichdomingo7240

Ай бұрын

yeah. 😅

@rizkyadiyanto7922

Ай бұрын

yeah its bit of a pickle.

@dns9995

23 күн бұрын

because they love pickled stuff in that region? :D ever had pickled cheese?

Regarding the Scandinavian string, it is worth mentioning that it is centered around the narrow inlet to the Baltic Sea. Historically, this area was of great importance for controlling the regional trade routes. The German part of this region was the core of the medieval Hanseatic League, the Danish and south Swedish part controls the actual choke point, and Gothenburg was the centre for all Atlantic trade from Sweden. I believe this is why Stockholm is left out, it has come about in a different context than the rest of the region.

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Very interesting! Great point. Just as you mentioned the core of the Hanseatic League, it would be interesting to see how far back each of these urban concentrations goes, and what the initial cause for that concentration to begin was.

@Mischnikvideos

Ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge ...and St. Petersburg delivered the goods from Siberia. The two areas belong together.

@boek2777

Ай бұрын

I believe that the climate and topography are more important. I don't know much about Germany but Denmark and southern Sweden are without resources that can be used in heavy industry (coal, iron ore, Uranium..) BUT have some of the most fertile land in existence (the area around Eslöv is the most fertile area in the world). I know this because I'm old enough to remember the discussions in the 1980's, when Eslöv started growing into that land. When the Öresundsbridge (some Swenglish;) was planned, it was seen as a great benefit to the local food industry. Denmark produce more than three times the food that is consumed in the country while the Swedish climate makes it so that it's a wast of money to produce food in the northern parts of the country. The exceptions are foodstuffs that like cold (reindeer meat and some berries) that can be sold for a price that nobody would pay unless it was so hard and expensive to get. Some discussions between Denmark and Sweden happened. Sweden opposed The Danish suggestion of the name 'Greater Copenhagen' but did finely agree that the Swedish municipalities of Malmö and Helsingborg should be included in that term. This hence made the three harbors, three food producing centers and three information centers join forces under one slogan.

@Mischnikvideos

Ай бұрын

@@boek2777 In return, the Danes receive wood from Sweden. What is arable land for the Danes is forests for the Swedes. Most Swedes live in the south and climatically they are in the same region. Today, agriculture is only a small part of the economy in both countries. Other sectors of the economy are more important and can generate the money that others want for food. Buying is then cheaper than making it yourself.

@MrMakabar

Ай бұрын

The German part also sits at the choke point. Not the natural one, but thanks to a number of canals it is possible to avoid the Danish straits, by going through Germany. Currently the most important of these connections is the Kiel Canal, which connects Kiel with the end of the Elbe. Before that other canals have been built in the region going back to the first summit-level canal in Europe the Stecknitz Canal, which made Lübeck such an important city in the region. So in a way the northern German cities also sit on the Baltic - North Sea choke point.

We should definitely differentiate between megaregions and megalopolises. I'd call the blue banana (including Paris) a megaregion with a few megalopolises inside it: greater London, greater Paris, Rheinland, Amsterdam/Rotterdam, Milano The green belt is definitely no megalopolis, though one could call Vienna-Bratislava such.

@BostonElton

Ай бұрын

i definitely agree

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Agreed!

@mackycabangon8945

Ай бұрын

Yeah I felt the same way. For the Blue Banana the English Channel and Alps seperate England and Northern Italy respectively and it's weird to see them in the same megalopolis as Netherlands and western Germany for that reason, especially compared to American megalopolises which are divided by mountains (like the Appalachians for the Northeast Megalopolis)

@Questraptor

Ай бұрын

​@@mackycabangon8945 well, it is easier to cross the alps now I think to connect Northern Italy, and there is also the chunnel between England and France making them more connected, also the english channel isn't that wide

@jfrancobelge

Ай бұрын

The metropolitan area of Paris, and its 11 million inhabitants are actually south of the Blue Banana presented here.

The green banana has its ancient roots in Roman route to collect amber from the coast of the Baltic sea. The space between Sudets and Carpathian mountains on Polish/Czech border is called the "Moravian Gate" and has been the place that has seen multiple archaelogical cultures wander there for thousands years back.

@serebii666

Ай бұрын

Yep" The so called "Amber Road". It actually predates the Romans by a millennia as well. It dates from at least the 16th century BC, where amber was moved from Northern Europe to the Mediterranean area (e.g. the breast ornament of the Egyptian Pharaoh Tutankhamen (c. 1333-1324 bce) contains large Baltic amber beads). It was one of the main Bronze age trade routes over continental Europe.

the "blue banana" is made principaly by the Rhin (Rein/Rijn) river ! You didn't mentionned it. and then for the rest. This is general knowledge from my country ^^

@Pietervandebuurt

Ай бұрын

I was also surprised he didn't mention the Rhine river. Anyone with some basic understanding of Western Europe knows the Rhine has been really important for the development of Western Europe.

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

That's true! A pretty big miss from my end, sorry!

@nekhumonta

Ай бұрын

Only a small part of it though. Just the Netherlands and Germany

@publicminx

Ай бұрын

German: Rhein River

@D4BASCHT

Ай бұрын

It’s kinda Rhine-Po.

6:50 according to the map, it actually contains 5 countries. the fifth being moldova

I'm originally from Saint-Petersburg and I can confirm the ties were pretty strong between the city and the neighbouring countries before covid and war. It was cheaper, easier and quicker for us to go to Tallinn or Helsinki for a day or a weekend, rather than to Moscow. In summer ferries were running daily between the cities, in addition to trains, buses and planes. EU cities offered plane tickets for €9 to anywhere in Europe, which were not avaiable in Russia, so a number of buses would bring a bunch of people straight to a particular airport. Roughly 8000 people were disembarking in SPb daily from cruise ships, also with stops at Helsinki and Tallinn. In Finland the area next to the border crossings was packed with all kinds of shops and malls, where one could buy everything from a match to a sofa and thousands or people from Russia were doing there weekly shopping there due to price value and better quality of goods. Not to mention there are thousands of people whose relatives have lived for years in either of the neighbouring countries and they've used to travel constantly between the cities for family reunions, which is now a pain to do. I wish peace and friendship ties for everyone

Wait you did not include Rijeka, Koper and Trieste as important cities in Green Banana? Those are literaly closest ports to central Europe and are very important transport hubs

@qzg7857

Ай бұрын

He also didnt include biggest industrial region in Green banana Silesia. Which by itself is a megalopolis.

Instead of “Atlantic Axis” it would make more sense for it to be called “Atlantic Access”

outstanding video. glad to hear the portugal video went well :)

Keep the great work! I’ve been watching you since 2019!

I enjoy your educational videos that I would not otherwise know about (topics). I love how crisply and clearly you speak

Yes! Love the Megalopolis videos. They're truly fascinating.

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Thanks!

@crazydog1750

Ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge Also, I'd love to see you do a video about bicoastal countries, and how there are some countries that are tricoastal or quadricoastal (Spain is six-coasted). The ones I can think of are: Bicoastal: Mexico, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, Panama, Colombia, Angola, Senegal, Egypt, Croatia, Turkiye, Germany, Malaysia (peninsula portion), Ukraine (when Crimea is considered Russian), UAE, Israel, Thailand, North Korea, Oman, Indonesia (on the island of Timor), Brunei, and Timor Leste. Tricoastal: Canada (because of Point Roberts), France (because of Monaco), and Malaysia (Borneo portion). Quadricoastal: United States, Russia (when Crimea is considered Ukrainian), and Morocco. Pentacoastal: Russia (when Crimea is considered Russian) Sexcoastal: Spain (Portugal and Gibraltar interrupt its main coast, and then it has several exclaves on the Moroccan coast and since technically Africa and Europe are in the same landmass it counts). I’m probably forgetting some. But, making up words like “pentacoastal” was fun, and this kind of video seems like something you'd make. It's an idea I've had floating around in my head for a long time but just never did it. Feel free to disregard this comment altogether, lol.

been watching you since 50k, im proud of you having 800k now but you deserve way more. good luck 🎉

Great video as always.

You helped me immensely with a worldbuilding hobby project with this one. Thank you. Btw I really like the art style of your videos

Europe has 746.4 million people.

@o_s-24

Ай бұрын

He probably said the eu population

@Margot4454

Ай бұрын

@@o_s-24 sooo .... excluding UK

@o_s-24

Ай бұрын

@@Margot4454 yes, and also, russia and ukraine. And some smaller countries too

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Correct! My mistake, I went for the EU population.

@schs1977

Ай бұрын

Population of the Americans (North, Central, and South America) is 1.06 billion. China and India, as a comparison, are both over 1 billion each but in a more concise area.

Very good! As usual... 😉

I liked your video. As always

Tu és o GOAT meu, a representar Portugal no KZread internacional, muitos parabéns e votos de sucesso

I love your content!!!!!!!😍

The string map on the thumbnail is super odd.. I live in an area that was shown on the thumbnail map between Gothenburg and Stockholm and we are not much connected to those cities except by rail. Roads out here arent good yet we're in a "megalopis" ? I think the one where you just show the west coast of Sweden is much more accurate and then if you want to connect Stockholm to it you should map out the E4 highway because the E20 sucks where I live. Great video! ^^

Great video

Good shit brother

Good stuff

You sound sick bro. It is ok to not upload when sick, but I love the videos anyway.

ganda video como smp mano, like the video guys

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Obrigado!

Love you man.

Great vid

The Blue Banana is the former US/NATO anti-Soviet military area. I lived in Ulm, Stuttgart and Zweibrucken (near Kaiserslautern) in the 70s and 80s. Great place to live.

@xaverlustig3581

Ай бұрын

NATO is much larger than the blue banana.

@MoempfLP

Ай бұрын

No, the blue banana has been existing for centuries.

@ibnenkigalileo9256

Ай бұрын

NATO? Yurk

You forgot to mention that the green banana is basically the successor of the ancient Amber road. But besides that, good video 👍

Tasty topic :)

It really is fascinating. You look at a country or region and your gut reaction is the people are spread across it evenly, but it's really further from the truth.

Ja gostei do video acerca do atlantic axis e adorei este!

The pearl river delta in china with cities like guangzhou, shenzen, and hong kong, ect is in my opinion the closest to being a true megalopolis where all the cities urban areas touch without any real gaps in between. And since its all in one country theres no border between the cities except between hong kong, macau and mainland china but its really easy to travel between.

I live in the North of Italy, I think we're blessed with easy access to so many different languages & cultures (Latin, Germanic, Slavic branches + the Mediterranean Sea). No city in Europe has easy access to the Alps, the sea, the lakes, the plains, and vineyards like Milan does. There's lots of culture (Bologna, the oldest university; Padua and its university, where Elena Cornaro Piscopia became the woman in the world to be awarded a PhD, in 1678; Venice, Turin, Verona), industry and infrastructure, whether you want to travel by car (Como laghi is the oldest highway ever built), train, plane, cruise or boats. All of this with the Italian lifestyle/gastronomy/wines/weather. We are really, really lucky to live here.

@Misterjingle

Ай бұрын

I would say that Torino, Venezia, Verona in Italy and Nice, Marseille, Lyon in France have also the same access to the Alps, the sea, vineyards, lakes etc. Barcelona and its region have also it all, with the Pyrenees instead of the Alps.

@carlomontecarlo7881

Ай бұрын

@Misterjingle Lyon is landlocked and further away from the sea, though... Marseille doesn't have a thriving economy, and the other cities are small compared to Milan, minus Barcelona (which doesn't have easy access to the lakes, or easy international connections by road / railway like Milan does)

@Misterjingle

Ай бұрын

@@carlomontecarlo7881 Well, Lyon is not that landlocked, just 1h30 by train to the med. 2h from Paris. Marseille doesn’t have the economy of Milan, but Milan doesn’t have the sun of Marseille :) And Barcelona have lakes in the Pyrenees. Not as big as Lake como but still. I’m just saying that there are several nice places in Europe. I know how Italians need like Americans to be the best at everything, I just like nuances :)

@carlomontecarlo7881

Ай бұрын

@Misterjingle Well, you're projecting - I didn't say Milan or the North of Italy are the best, I said we're really lucky, which is different. So your anti-Italian bias is uncalled for. Lyon is 2 hrs away by train from Marseille (the Med vs 50 mins for the Milan-Genoa corridor, which is nearing completion), and - unlike Milan - both cities are not ranked as Alpha cities by GAwK or the EIU (even Barcelona isn't, to be fair). As for Barcelona, the Pyrenees are 350 km away from the city vs. Milan being 185 km away from the Alps. I also would like to know which lakes in the Pyrenees are as big as Lake Garda, Lake Como, Lake Maggiore. Lastly, you sure have to drive more to reach Central-Eastern Europe from Lyon/Marseille/Barcelona than Milan. So I stand by my comment ;)

@Misterjingle

Ай бұрын

@@carlomontecarlo7881 « anti-Italian » bro, please, calm down… It’s like I hurt your ego ! I love all my European fellows. But you have to admit sometimes it’s hard to talk with Italians, it’s like Americans or Turks, too much pride involved. However, you said « no place like Milan » which means = we are the best. It’s just semantic. I feel like you need to convince yourself. I just wanted to make some nuances. Been to Milan, It was ok but far from being the best place to work/live. I’d rather chose Roma, Barcelona or the south of France. Better quality of life with everything you mentioned : weather, food, slow living, sea, mountains, etc etc.

The basis of the blue banana is hard coal, which stretches from England to Germany. This was the basis for the large industrial centers with heavy industry. In addition, the Rhine is the largest transport/trade route in Europe.

Yeah! US belt video would be awesome

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Nice! It's on my list

nice video . Also make a video on Megaregions of India

🌎👍❤ We ❤ this channel.

Super

Parts of the Czech Republic, Austria, and all of Liechtenstein, are part of the blue banana as well. This includes the Austrian city of Innsbruck. Due to urbanization, the Blue Banana has become larger in size, branching outwards in a star shape. Despite this, the Blue Banana still remains the core of the conurbation. Although the Blue Banana may not have the same formation it had decades ago, it still holds Europe’s largest gathering of people, industry, money, and economic power.

@Apollorion

Ай бұрын

That's what you get when connecting the Rhine to the Thames.

Muito bons os teus videos

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Obrigado!

When you was talking about The Green Banana, you forgot mention, that in this area is located so-called Silesian Metropolis (with its main city, Katowice), which is the biggest metropolis in Central Europe

Love your channel. Have you done a video on the battle of Aljubarrota? Saudacoes Lusitanas.

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Not yet! I haven't really done videos dedicated to many specific historical events. Especially since there's so many other channels that focus on individual battles and do a terrific job. It's a good idea, though!

The blue and gold bananas are also connectes by the Rhone Valley, linking Zurich to Montpellier, in a long continuous megalopolis. And the golden banana should continue south into italy, at least until Naples.

Not sure if you could include areas of post-industrial decline in England and Wales - now replaced by London, Birmingham and Manchester for service industry.

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Some must have transitioned while remaining relevant though, no? I had the idea Manchester was previously an industrial secondary sector hub too.

@trystandavies7249

Ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge True - and other areas are slowly catching up (if you want to be optimistic!)

@JimmyJr630

Ай бұрын

@@trystandavies7249London seems to be in another world nowadays. The focus on the city from the government is honestly ridiculous. This might seem like a strange idea but I was thinking that since England doesn’t have its own capital within the Uk (Wales has Cardiff etc) I was thinking what if a new English Capital was set up in the middle of the country separate from the UK government like all the other capitals and away from London. This would force the English government to focus more on the north and midlands if the new capital was perhaps around derby/sheffield/nottingham in the centre of the country.

@trystandavies7249

Ай бұрын

@@JimmyJr630 Sounds like a good idea - definitely needs to be a focus away from London-Birmingham-Manchester even for their own sake and take the pressure off them. Should have built better infrastructure to the SW, NE and E of England, Wales and Scotland than waste all that money on HS2.

Nottingham?! Robin Hood and all that but come on Birmingham as the second largest City should have been included in the list… Interesting video though.👍🏻

@BostonElton

Ай бұрын

thats probably what he meant lol

@rubbishrabble

Ай бұрын

The point is to name both the main city and suburb. Zurich with the suburb of Basel. Munich with suburban Nuremberg. Nottingham is obviously the midlands. It actually reinforces the premise of the blue banana for middle class or blue collar. That may be why it went up to Northern England & Wales as a counter to Thatcher by the French.

9:11 the fact that we are referencing touchy topics in that exact time makes it even more touchy😅

Awesome. Now I can say I live in the ✨pickle ✨

Thought I lived outside a megaregion, but then the general pull me back in, with an addition

Damn, nice to see a Portuguese doing such a work. Excelente trabalho.

4:00 YES PLEASE I WANT THAT

did you use disco elysium music around the 5 minute mark or what is that? it sounds very familiar

It’s a pity you didn’t mention Silesian Metropoly in southern Poland, which is the most urbanised and most industrialised region of Poland. A great cluster of Katowice and smaller cities is bigger and more populated than any big city in Poland, even Warsaw.

@qzg7857

Ай бұрын

It was weird that he missed the biggest megalopolis of Green banana in a video about megalopolises

Makes sense to have England included as there is a frequent transit links between the island and the continent, so it's not all that separated, only issue I could see in its classification is the lack of freedom of movement

"Covering the entire countries of Andorra and Monaco" 4:30 Well, it would have been an impresive level of detail if only parts of these countries were included. 😉

@BostonElton

Ай бұрын

lmao

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Ahahah that's true.

You can do this for a lot of the larger countries. India, China, US, Indonesia, Pakistan, Brazil, etc... could be an entire series....

@rafaelportella2548

Ай бұрын

Agreed!

The blue banana is best explained by the Rhine river, which gives easy access to the North-Sea with all its trade. Why do you think Londen is placed in South East England? Because that is the closest region in England to the Rhine Delta in the Netherlands. It all has to do with trade.

I can add a piece of an argument to the center of "green banana" - it encompasses a large portion of the historic Silesia region that is (still) rich in coal and ores, and used to be heavily industrialized. Thus, it also contains the Upper-Silesian Metropolitan Area formed of many post-industrial cities around Katowice, Poland. I live here and (though I haven't gained much international perspective) in the context of Poland, the metropolitan area is still much more densly populated than other regions of the country (however still much less than Cracow or Warsaw).

This megalopolis series is epic. Also, I think megalopolis plural is the same plural as it is singular, like moose, but that’s just my guess

@JeeWeeD

Ай бұрын

It is megalopolēs in Latin, and I think we should just use that.

Yeah. A video about the bananas

By those measurments, the whole of Europe can be counted as a megapolis, since there isn't any serious, uninhabited territory between those megaregions, also the population of Europe is over 746 million.

Do economic regions: Ruhr, Randstad, Flemish diamant, etc.

10:50 considering that there is the largest underwatertunnel in the world connecting uk with europe...

There's interesting conurbation here in central Montenegro and in the broader basin of the lake Skadar which is the biggest lake of the southeastern Europe. The capital of Montenegro, Podgorica is connected with Danilovgrad, Nikšić and with coastal port city of Bar in Montenegro, in zetska-bjelopavlićka plain and in Albania it's all further connected with city of Skadar in the same plain, coastal big city of Albania Duresh (Drač) and then with the Albanian capital Tirana. It's one of the most urban parts of southeastern Europe and visible from the space at night sky as a VERY long conurbation. It got some 400k people in Montenegro and 1,2 million in Albania. Aglomeration of 1,6 million people in total. Which is amazing for two smaller countries to achieve.

I love the video, however I did find an error!; The county of Viken in Norway no longer exists. It was disbanded on January 1st of 2024, this year, after it was decided the county lacked legitimacy during the Norwegian region unifications of 2020. The counties that are included in the Scandinavian String are now Akershus, Østfold and Oslo.

I think Scandinavian string should be until oslo meanwhile Stockholm part of gulf of finland cause it's just make more sense

8:51 guld of Finnland includes Stockholm in this picture.

@birgittae9046

Ай бұрын

Yes agree, but then Stockholm area is not mentioned in the specification and no Swedish flag? 🤔🇸🇪 Must have been forgotten…

😅 Ok I was expecting a whole different topic on this video 🍌.

Do you have a link to the "official" definitions of bananas regions?

I've always through it was kind of a coincidence that England matches up with the Blue Banana. I'm not sure England has much interconnectivity with the Rhineland compared to, say Paris.

Do one on American megalopolis

@TMandarinka

Ай бұрын

he did

@loafoffloof3420

Ай бұрын

he posted one about American megaregions about 4 weeks ago titled "What Are The 11 MEGAREGIONS Of The United States?"

I live in Constanța and I've never heard of the Golden Belt, I've never been to Odessa or Varna or Burgas. There isn't really much of a stable infrastructure, yes there are (crappy) roads but it doesn't feel like one big region. Other than that, great video!

I've been doing my own homework and I see the following megalopolises in the pre-Brexit EU: 1. Semiconnected Rhine megalopolis: 1.1. Lower Rhine (Belgium, South NL, NPDC in France, Nord Rhineland and Saar in Germany) 1.2. Middle Rhine (much of BW in Germany, Lorraine-Champagne and North Alsace in France) 1.3. Zurich area (mostly NE Switzerland but grabbing border areas of Germany and Austria) 2. Semiconnected England Megalopolis (most of England and also Cardiff area in Wales), can be split in two plus Cardiff and York outside of it): 2.1 London Megalopolis 2.2. Midlands Megalopolis 3. North Italy-Provence. This one should be definitely a distinct megalopolis: from the Rhone to at least Venice, from Ticino to Tuscany). 4. Oporto-Coimbra-Vigo (Lisbon is not part of that megalopolis) 5. Valencia-Murcia (separated from Barcelona Tarragona and Provence) 6. Barcelona-Tarragona 7. Rome-Naples 8. Krakow (extending southwards to West Slovakia and brorder areas of Moravia but not as far as Vienna, nor much less Slovenia, etc., it doesn't include Warsaw either, which is as isolated as Paris or Madrid as metropolis but not inside a megalopolis)

6:20 *Sad Trieste and Fiume noises*

The black sea one is severely underdeveloped. We need a motor way from istanbul-edirne-burgas-varna-constantsa-odessa

Well you have banana's & so why not the Atlantic axis as a 'cob' to keep the yellow plant vibe. 'Atlantic corncob' works.

South Africa also has a megalopolis in the Gauteng Province. Johannesburg including Soweto (6.5 million people), Pretoria (2.5 million people), East Rand (3.5 million people). The province of Gauteng alone has a population exceeding 15 million people (over 30% of South Africa's population) and has an area of 18 000 km².

The Blue Banana isn't just huge, it's also really old. It's basically the heartlands of the Carolingian Empire, plus England. Low Countries, Rhine Valley, and Northern Italy have been an economic powerhouse since the entire Middle Ages. Not just on the European Scale, but globally. It's one of the economically most valuable plot of lands. And unsurprisingly has been a constant major conflict zone from 50 BCE to 1945 CE.

for the Blue Banana I think it should be more split Britain as a whole is and has historically been a different economic area to the rest of Europe especially again since Brexit. Though on the mainland a Rhine megaregion makes sense including mostly areas around the Rhine and it’s tributaries. It’s the closest we get to an actual megapolis in Europe. For Italy, the Northern Po valley it’s just its own region.

@nekhumonta

Ай бұрын

I think you underestimate the amount of trade that happened across the channel. Many countries traded for Flemish cloth, which was made from British wool mostly.

@hpvspeedmachine4183

Ай бұрын

you uderesitmate the trade across the Alps. Northern Po valley trades largely with Germany.

Lyon is usually seen as part of the Sunbelt/Golden banana

Strange that the business spot Stockholm/Eastern Sweden is neither included in the detailed map of the Gulf of Finland nor The Scandinavian string? Almost 40% of Sweden's population lives in that eastern region of central Sweden.🤔

Why isn't Florence and Rome considered part of the Golden Banana 🤔

@lavillenouvelle

Ай бұрын

They definitely should. They are more interconnected and more densely populated than the mediterranean coast of Spain.

With the exception of the Orange Banana its looks like all the Megalopolises overlap at some point. Making a Gigaopolis! Also could Belfast and Dublin be considered part of the Blue Banana?

In Poland the most populated region that has over 2 milion people and is also in the green banana is Upper Silesia with the main city of Katowice. It's not so known, because it's not one city, but a metropoly of many cities, and we just call it here Silesia. Fun fact: There are two languages there, polish which is the main language, and silesian which is some combination of polish with german words i guess

To these might be added the megaregion from Donetsk to Makhachkala. It is unusual in that it only contains smaller cities, with the other larger ones being Luhansk, Rostov, and Krasnodar.

as someone from Stuttgart I feel like another big megaregion is along the Danube river with Stuttgart at its western end including Cities like Ulm Augsburg, Munich, Salzburg, Linz, Vienna Bratislava and stretching to Budapest in Hungary.

huh interesting, apparently i live right on the edge of two of these

oh i life in the Blue Banana, nice....

Please do megaregions of India

@General.Knowledge

Ай бұрын

Okay!

Please do one for South America and one for east Asia

Megalopoli! (Sounds like a Kaiju movie title)

As Estonian, links between Tallinn and Helsinki are unquestionable: we ourselves referr to the two as Talsinki or Hellinna. However links with St Petersburg seem way overrated - especially in contrast with the same links with Stockholm (and Riga) - even more so under the current diplomatic relations. Most of the people in Finland and Baltic live at west rather than East, the connection, movement, and trade is with the Scandinavia, whereas there's multiple barriers with the Russia (even before the events and sanctions over the past couple of years). Don't believe it? Fly to Stockholm and take a road trip all the way to the Russian border...

@carleryk

Ай бұрын

The population of both Finland and Estonia mirror each other - over 50% of Finland's population lives in the South and over 50% of Estonia's population lives in the North. That is a very interesting and special phenomenon, pretty uncommon in the world.

@KohaAlbert

Ай бұрын

@@carleryk one is urbanization, second are marks from WW2 (sõrve and petseri were most populous rural regions at Estonia just before that). Thirdly for Estonia is USSR's period with full monopoly over economy, industry, and production, along with "iron curtain", "all roads to Moscow", population transfers, restrictions on movement, etc (which was opposite at Finland - people moving towards west and south), followed by Independence+ Schengen+EU people have been moving towards west and north (whereas barriers with Russia have only been gotten ever stiffer). Similar pattern with Estonia seems to occur at Latvia - people are mainly moving to the capital and coastal towns...