I misread that as "What Are The 11 MEGATRONS Of The United States?"

@Idk-ys7rt

2 ай бұрын

That would be a video from Alternate History Hub's second channel, wrong channel 😂

@IRosamelia

2 ай бұрын

That would have been way cooler 🤖🤖🤖🤖🤖🤖🤖🤖🤖🤖🤖🤖

@Idk-ys7rt

2 ай бұрын

@@IRosamelia That's 12.

@IRosamelia

2 ай бұрын

@@Idk-ys7rt Thanks for pointing that out Rainman 😅

@nickfernandez7358

2 ай бұрын

It's nice to know that I'm not the only one

Very minor correction: Alabama never claimed the Florida panhandle, but the people there did want to separate from Florida and join Alabama. By US law, however, Alabama would have to pay Florida for the land, and they were not interested in putting forth the funds to do so. The movement eventually fell off.

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Thanks for the clarification!

@pureteddybear_

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge Anytime!

@liamcollins9183

2 ай бұрын

It would also change the political outcomes in Florida quite drastically. The panhandle heavily skews Republican, so if it joined Alabama, it would probably take one or two house seats and Electoral College votes woth it, but whats left would be easier for Democrats to win in state level and Presidential elections.

@davidkane4300

2 ай бұрын

The Florida panhandle is also informally called "South Alabama" because of the similar culture... It really ruffles some peoples' feathers, however.

@pumpkiespoon8524

2 ай бұрын

@@davidkane4300 as a Alabamian it belongs to us

Most of these are a real stretch. There are pretty large stretches of rural areas between some of these cities.

@davidkane4300

2 ай бұрын

Yeah, like there's a zero percent chance someone lives in Albuquerque and commutes daily to Denver... Unless they fly, which would still take hours of commute time.

@danfsteeple

2 ай бұрын

Yes. I would not include Norfolk, Virginia in the Northeast. It’s 4 hours from Washington, DC

@asantehardin1035

2 ай бұрын

True. OKC Metro is 3 hrs away from DFW. He did mention is was strange...but that's too far.

@Juanesai0210

Ай бұрын

@@davidkane4300it’s megaregions not metropolitan areas. There can be rural and desolate stretches in between dense areas that still share socioeconomic ties to each other so much so, they get incorporated into the megaregion

@cjmhall

Ай бұрын

@@asantehardin1035 OKC is closer to DFW than Houston is. There are a lot of people in Dallas with close ties to OKC, so it makes sense to include it in the megaregion.

It's a REAL stretch to include Kansas City (and to a lesser extent St. Louis) part of the "Great Lakes" megaregion. They're reasonably large cities with their own metropolitan areas, but they do not even touch each other, let alone join with Chicago's. At Interstate highway speeds, there's conservatively at least three hours of pretty much open farmland in the middle of Missouri interrupted only by Columbia (which isn't much of an interruption).

@davidkane4300

2 ай бұрын

I didn't see KC included in the Great Lakes region (it was just circled as a metropolis in the US), but I agree St. Louis should not be included... Like you said, other than interstates that connect it to Chicago, it's hours upon hours of farmland and tiny cities in between. The culture isn't even really the same... I'd say it's closer to a south central Mississippi valley megalopolis to include Memphis.

@asmeroe764

2 ай бұрын

I think it is saying the great lake area having STL, has to with infrastructure, there is a lot of truck and rail to and from STL to the great lake area. But just suburban sprawls, no way is half of Illinois, Indiana, and Ohio directly apart of this area.

@jljordan1

2 ай бұрын

Kansas City, Lawrence, Topeka, and Junction City/Ft Riley/Manhattan could be its own region honestly

@JayYoung-ro3vu

2 ай бұрын

True. You don't hear either city claim to be Great Lakes. St. Louis tends to have a more southern connection (my aunt's cooking is 'southern' and not 'northern' though she hails from there). Both 'Kansas' cities are part of the Great Plains. They will tell you so.

@JayYoung-ro3vu

2 ай бұрын

​@asmeroe764 I can agree with it though the 'apart' should be 'a part'. 😉

Bro made Piedmont sound way fancier than how we say it

@davidkane4300

2 ай бұрын

Yeah, it's peed-mont like you're peeing lol.

@JayYoung-ro3vu

2 ай бұрын

True! It sounded "so French".🤣

@JayYoung-ro3vu

2 ай бұрын

​@davidkane4300 Yes. Two others are 'Spokane ( the e is silent and Raleigh is raw lee not rall lee. It's akin to we "ugly Americans calling Paris(pearis) Par is or Lisbon Lizbohn ( again, "so French"). 😆 Now, sometimes, like in Ohio, Lisbon is pronounced Lizbun (an Appalachian influenced pronunciation. Overall, he does well. ❤👍

@anthonyhall4427

2 ай бұрын

I know right 😅😅

@DR-gc5lm

2 ай бұрын

Fayetteville as well…😂

As a Coloradoan, not once would I have considered anything in New Mexico part of the Front Range.

@davidkane4300

2 ай бұрын

It's not. The Front Range as a noun is Cheyenne-Pueblo, with the former tossed in to also include Fort Collins. The "front range" (not a noun) of the Rockies describes everything on the eastern side from northern Alaska through Canada to around Juarez. Albuquerque/Santa Fe sit in the Rockies, so they don't count.

@tomasmondragon883

2 ай бұрын

Yeah, not until passenger rail gets built to connect Denver and Albuquerque. Until then, Pueblo and Albuquerque can fight about chile. There is a shared culture, but Las Vegas, Raton, and Trinidad are too small to justify connecting the two regions into a megalopolis. Might as well include El Paso and Las Cruces if your definition of megalopolis is that loose.

@lkj974

2 ай бұрын

The Sandias are part of the Rockies, so yeah. But as far as being an interconnected urban area, that's laughable. It's a full days drive to reach Denver from Albuquerque. And they are pretty different culturally too, although they might seem similar to someone from the east coast.

@denver0102

Ай бұрын

Same. I thought that the front range urban corridor is Cheyenne to Pueblo…

@daltonmiller5590

Ай бұрын

For real. The map in the video is kinda dogshit. All these megalopolises are real, but none of them are as big as the video portrays them to be.

It would be cool if you continued this with other major countries like Brazil, China, India, Russia, Germany, Nigeria and others.

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Great idea!

@Jesus_saves77786

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledgeplease do that man I would definitely watch!

@omargoalzz

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge Canada has very interesting ones as they overlap with the U.S. in about 2 and other Megaregions would have cities in USA probably (I already know which ones would have cities in the USA and cities that overlap)

@greasher926

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge In the case of Russia, it’s hard to find data in in English since metro areas/agglomerations are not officially tracked. But there is a Russian wiki page on it, which can be easily translated using a web browser translator extension. ru.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Агломерации_России

@Booz2010

2 ай бұрын

Never Say NEVER 😎 Justin Bieber

As an ex long haul trucker back in the early 2000's we would do whatever it took to not use I-95 going up into the northeastern areas. We would try our best to go up that way by using I-81 and then cut over to whatever area we were going to. The times I took 95 straight down through all those major cities was a complete time killer.

@Demopans5990

2 ай бұрын

Pretty sure truckers still prefer to drop off their cargo at warehouses/transfer stations over dealing with horrendous city traffic

@jk-jl2lo

Ай бұрын

i just drove a stretch of 95 for spring break (from nj, staying in va) and the dc and nyc traffic is seriously killer. i've spent 30-40 min in a stretch of 2-3 miles on the turnpike up near the newark airport and that wasn't even a week day rush hour.

@blahdblah0007

5 күн бұрын

I-95 is still horrific 25 years later. But, for example, if you want to go from Newport News / Richmond / Norfolk to DC… just take the train. You’ll spend less time if you drive in I-95 traffic but it’s usually about 45-60 minutes more and you don’t have to pay attention constantly (or even at all 😴 🍺 :)

@Demopans5990

4 күн бұрын

@@blahdblah0007 And even if you do drive, you're spending another 30 min looking for parking, before giving up and parking either in a $3/hr garage, or 3 blocks away

Representing the Piedmont-Atlantic here, I can definitely vouch for our infrastructure not being prepared for the rapid growth we're seeing. Our cities are vibrant, but our roads are congested!

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Hopefully with growth, authorities will be forced to invest in them.

@matthewsalmon2013

4 күн бұрын

Because NCDOT owns all the roads and can't seem to understand how rail and bus might solve all their problems. The reason you can live in Delaware and commute 100 miles to Washington (as Biden says he did for years as a senator), is Amtrak. Greensboro/Triad can't figure out it's economic fit, but more frequent train service could make it a bedroom community for households working in Charlotte and Raleigh-Durham or likewise with Greenville, SC for Charlotte and Atlanta.

@marlongaribay9414

2 күн бұрын

As someone who drived to atlanta frequently, the road work will never end :)

I'm excited for the Portugal megaregion video! I'm a long time subscriber an I know you're Portuguese so I'm excited to finally see a Portugal video

@filiperosa7496

2 ай бұрын

Portugal only have 2 cities

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Should be out next week! Or at least sometime in March.

I've been to all of and lived in 3 of these regions throughout my life. It's kinda cool seeing this laid out like this, because you can totally tell you're in most of these regions while traveling through them on the interstate. The exceptions to this are Cascadia, Front range, and parts of The Great Lakes. It's interesting that I technically grew up in the Great Lakes area, but only because I live in between Chicago and St. Louis. That area is mostly farmland, very very rural.

@matthewsalmon2013

4 күн бұрын

Right? STL is part of an older Mississippi River economic corridor. Cheap oil broke that link and cities like Cincinnati, Louisville, and especially Memphis, Parkersburg and Wheeling are either in decline or somewhat adopted by another region.

Most of these are a stretch. It's like Amsterdam, Paris, Madrid and Berlin being in the same megaregion. You're just pointing out big cities. The North East actually makes sense because a lot of it's actually urban and we're not connecting cities through 200kms of farmland.

A notable thing about the North East Megalopolis is that it pretty much is one continuously developed megaregion. You can drive from DC to Boston and always be somewhere with buildings

@neox9369

Ай бұрын

No, lol at you people who weren’t born or raised in that area speaking on this off of KZread commentary. Being From DC myself, driving to NY is not straight buildings without a bit of rural and green space, that’s silly.

@matthewsalmon2013

4 күн бұрын

The Wash-NY stretch yes, but NE is not so built up.

Not to be picky, but there was either a mis-speak or misinformation put in the Cascadia region. It was said between the Pacific Ocean and the Rocky Mountains but it's between the Pacific Ocean and the Cascades. Other than that this video was really informative. I used to live in the Front Range, Texas Triangle, SoCal, Northeast, and Great Lakes mega regions and I found these little snapshot views of them were very thorough and informative. Great work

@ARabidPie

2 ай бұрын

Also mispronounced Spokane in that part. It's: spoke-anne not spoke-aine.

@davidkane4300

2 ай бұрын

Yes, I was going to mention this... It's all West of the Cascades except for the Spokane/Coeur d'Alene metro (which almost everyone mispronounces, like Boise, which he got right), which is only loosely the same culture as Cascadia. Besides those, it's very rural and very conservative East of the Cascades.

@matthewdovidas4213

2 ай бұрын

@@ARabidPie yeah I saw that after I was busy typing my comment and didn't hear the mispronunciations. My buddy used to live in Sunnyside, WA so Eastern WA/ID pronunciations I'm familiar with from him. He also mispronounced Piedmont by using the French pronunciation which is fair considering he's European, but t would be the same as calling Amarillo, TX with the Spanish pronunciation, it's like a cardinal sin to the locals there so it's just funny to look at how others worldwide pronounce a lot of weird quirky towns and places.

@bunk_foss

2 ай бұрын

​@@ARabidPieI left a comment on that.

@markw999

2 ай бұрын

I dunno, half my neighborhood here in N. Idaho are Portland refugees it seems. Culturally (not so much politically on this side of the border though) we are shifting toward a more Cascadia type culture. Spokane is probably getting more liberal, N. Idaho more conservative in the process. We were always kind of linked to the Seattle/Portland nexus anyway as Spokane just isn't that big of a city and doesn't have the diverse economy the bigger cities did. When I was a kid (80s), everybody wanted to go to the coast (many did). Now they're boomeranging right back. I'd even say the same of the Tri-Cities/Wenatchee/Ellensburg which are getting some influx of Seattle/Portland folks too.

The Cascadia megaregion is discontiguous by design. In order to prevent urban sprawl Oregon and Washington both have really strict urban growth management laws, and housing boundries that are hardly ever expanded. The zoning laws mean about 98% of new development gets funneled into already existing urban areas. So cities in Cascadia tend much more towards growing in density over growing in size. Seattle has barely physically expanded in over 30 years because of it.

@SMATF5

4 күн бұрын

That's really interesting. I'm from Southern California, and for the year or so that I lived near Seattle, I noticed how dense the city itself was, but with much more sparse suburbs than I was accustomed to (e.g. north Orange County or the San Gabriel Valley).

2 upcoming video suggestions 1. Cities that lost their peak populations in history regardless of abandoned/destroyed status by either natural disasters, war, and urban decay. 2. How do Lebanon and Armenia compare?

I thoroughly enjoyed this video. Great job! Thank you!😊😊

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Thanks Jamie!

Its always a nice day when you drop videos, abraços mano, bom conteúdo

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Obrigado!

@Booz2010

2 ай бұрын

Muito Obg 💯

Living in Albuquerque, I think it’s a stretch to include it into the Denver region. There is about a 3 hour stretch of mostly wilderness between Santa Fe and Pueblo, CO.

With as liberal as you are applying some areas in these Mega Regions, I am surprised you didn't include Juneau in your "Pacific Northwest" Mega Region

Nice video keep up the good work

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Thanks!

Amazing intro. idk when it was added but its amazing

The Wasatch Front in Utah, connecting the cities of Salt Lake City, Ogden, and Provo, is one of the fastest-growing metro areas in the U.S. There are even plans to build new locales for MLB and NHL expansion teams.

@davidkane4300

2 ай бұрын

It is, and, interestingly enough, this is the second time this week I've heard/read articles (by different authors) that referred to the Wasatch Front as part of the Front Range (as a proper noun, which is the Cheyenne-Pueblo region, not including Albuquerque since that's in the Rockies, not at the base).

@zyoninkiro

2 ай бұрын

​@@davidkane4300 Culturally and transportation wise, the Wasatch Front is pretty much it's own region and not connected to the Front Range. If anything, the Wasatch Front and Eastern Idaho from the UT/ID border up through the upper Snake River valley have more in common for a variety of reasons. Basically it would follow I-15 to the Idaho Fialls MSA and US-20 through the Rexburg area as well as US-91 through Logan and into Idaho.

@davidkane4300

2 ай бұрын

@@zyoninkiro yeah, they're floating the idea of building high speed rail between SLC and Boise. If it truly was a high speed rail non-stop or with only a couple of short stops in Twin Falls and maybe Ogden, then people could reasonably commute between the two. When I was stationed in Mountain Home, Idaho, many civilians on base lived in the Boise area and took the Commuteride vanpools. They'd arrive at the van around 4am, then nap or relax in the van for the hour+ long drive (they'd rotate drivers so it was fair). So it would be reasonable for someone to get to the train and spend the couple of hours sleeping or working on the train. Of course, this would be more geared towards salaried office workers or management than hourly blue collar since they could count it as part of their work day.

@longestvideoever

2 ай бұрын

I find stadium buildings really annoying. Why should we cut funding for food stamps and add taxes to people too poor to afford their $80 ticket prices to fund their own private business ventures?

@thomasrinschler6783

11 күн бұрын

Well, you got that NHL team a lot faster than expected!

I love your videos! Great job! ❤

First, I'd like to say thank you for another great video that helps me understand more about US. I wasn’t aware such “mega-regions” exist there. I think you may consider another video covering various “belts” that exist in US - Bible Belt, Rust Belt, etc.

Abbotsford (and also Chilliwack are also in Canada. If you ignore international boundaries, Bellingham is closer to Vancouver than Seattle.

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Is there much of an open border there or not so much?

@brandongorte4746

2 ай бұрын

@@General.KnowledgeFor US and Canadian citizens, it's a fairly easy crossing. You stop at the incoming customs only to hand them your passport/passport card/enhanced drivers license (in states and provinces that provide them). You declare if you have any agricultural products, guns, and the like; they ask you a few questions about where you're going; and that's about it. Sometimes they'll do a secondary, but it's not as common. The trip can be made easier with a NEXUS card, if you cross often. At each crossing, there is no outgoing customs - the Canadians exchange their information with the US and vice versa.

@drewsteps

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge Define "open" border. It's open, but everyone must past through customs each direction. It's very time consuming and frustrating.

@stevejohnson3357

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge very open. And during lockdown, people could go to the Peace Park to meet up and not cross either border.

@cobra-chicken

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge I hold a Nexus card and can usually get across the border within 5 minutes. Canadians can get a TN visa to work in the US as long as you have a US job offer and I heard there are people who commute across the border to get to work every day. There are no fences at the border. There are houses on 0 Ave with backyards opening up to the other side. It's probably the closest you can get to open border short of a Schegen area arrangement.

I like this video! good idea!

I would love to see a version of this with the Mega Regions of Europe. I also think it would be cool if you did a video on the currently forming Gigaopolis.

I love in the greater Denver metro area, so I'm always happy to see a mention of us!

Thank you for making the Casacdia video

@nickmiller5685

2 ай бұрын

I never thought the day would come. I’m so happy

This episode is very very very interesting.

Great video.

Providence, Rhode Island is an absolutely beautiful city with so much history.

I'm from Piedmont Megaregion (Memphis, TN) Lived in Northern Cali Megaregion (Oakland, CA) Currently living in The Texas Triangle (Houston, TX)

@beezythaking4008

Ай бұрын

dam you been livin in the hood lol

@matthewsalmon2013

4 күн бұрын

Memphis is from an old Mississippi River economic corridor, only distantly connected to the Southeast Piedmont Atlantic region. It's probably equally (dis)connected to the Great Lakes (via STL) and Gulf Coast regions.

Born and raised in the Florida Megalopolis🤙🏻🌴

Yoooo... thanks for the shout out to Lake Tahoe!

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Top 5 Lakes

I had this map printed out and posted on my wall growing up 🤘

A.I. regurgitation of the landmark book, "The Nine Nations of North America". Transcribed at 2x to sound like the small print from a radio adv.

Seems about right. I was born and raised in the SoCal region Traversing both north and south. Moved to the Piedmont Region, and planning to move to the Texas Triangle region.

What was with the random music track that started playing when talking about the Texas Triangle?

@VelocityZap

2 ай бұрын

I know right!? lol

@rayyfire5738

2 ай бұрын

what do you mean? it’s the texas triangle theme song everyone knows it

@SMATF5

4 күн бұрын

...I kinda liked it

I grew up in the NYC Metro area, it’s really packed. Chaos!! But it’s home.

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Nice! NY is my number one destination if I am to visit the US. Maybe it's a cliché I've been sold my mass media but I still think it's worth it.

@Lisbonese

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge you’ll love it, there’s also a large Portuguese community there, I’m Portuguese like you but grew up there. Been in Portugal now for 4 years. NYC is a great experience for sure.

@sean668

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge Make sure you leave Manhattan. Please please please leave Manhattan. So many tourists make the mistake of staying in this tiny little bubble and miss out on so much. Travel to Astoria, Jackson Heights, Williamsburg, Cold Spring! There's so much to see here

@RandomRabbit007

2 ай бұрын

I've been in NYC (Queens) for 2 years now (in my 30s). Born and raised in California but here for my wife's career, I gotta say NY is fun to visit for like 2 weeks but I wouldn't recommend anyone live here. It's just WAY too many people. It creates a constant anxiety/aggression in people because the daily tasks/chores of life get WAY harder to get done when you're competing with an insane amount of people who also need to go grocery shopping, to the laundry, to the doctor, to work, etc. Human-life (and decency) have little to no value here. People are not kind, they don't make small talk, they're not "chill" like in California, they're all in an extreme rush. I can imagine a Native NewYorker is born with a sense of dread when it comes to being able to afford a life here all the while living in shoe-boxes with banged-up/scratched cars. A NY minute is like 10 seconds somewhere else lol. I have never seen more asshole drivers in my life (and I have driven in 3rd world countries that have over a billion people and I drove in California my whole life lol). Sure the food is great and Manhattan is fun when the weather is nice (which is like 2-3 weeks out of the whole damn year LOL) but after a while a skyscraper is just a skyscraper, and there is little to no natural beauty. I say NYC is great if you're in your 20s and your parents are rich lol, otherwise it's just too fuckin much in every way imaginable. Don't get me started on the morning/evening commutes. It's just no way to live. My wife and I can't wait to move back to California in 2025. We got what we needed and we wont stay a day longer but I could see myself visiting for a week in the spring (I would never come to NYC in the winter after experiencing it for the past 2 years). Whats the point of living somewhere cool if it sucks to be outside either because of extreme cold, wind, rain, heat, humidity? Fuck me. The typical touristy spots can be cool initially but after seeing it once, what then? People dont really "hangout" here. Life requires constant WORK. Gotta make that $$$ just to be able to survive. The rat-race is REAL. The speed-cameras on the road are such bullshit too. How are you gonna make it 25 mph EVERYWHERE? Atleast in California we still have 35mph, 45mph everywhere and a real COP has to give you a ticket, not some damn heartless camera. Sorry for venting, I'm done now lol. @@General.Knowledge

@Demopans5990

2 ай бұрын

@harmansg The 25mph limit is based on the fact that in NYC, pedestrians are everywhere, and traffic laws are more like traffic suggestions. It is one of the few cities to ban right on reds after all. Even if the city raised the limit to 40, no one is going to be reaching it anyways, especially in Manhattan and Brooklyn. Wfh would make NYC an infinitely better place to live. Less cars == less cars with shorted horns.

Interesting. As I sit here in rural MI. I never thought of this region as so large, but it makes sense

The Wasatch Front area might be considered the Front Range, but it's growing rapidly too. I love things like this video, combine that with cultures in the area and that'd be beautiful

It's nice to see the Great lakes region booming again, for decades the coasts lead, now the heartland is finally getting the attention it needed.

As a Northeastern US resident I have thoughts. While you didn’t touch on the Montreal area I did notice that it included Plattsburgh NY, at the same time Plattsburgh is in the Burlington VT orbit as well. It faces challenges to be considered part of both, Lake Champlain is one challenge, it’s $15-30 ferry ride to get to Burlington which means careful thought should be undertaken. The international border is another, more artificial but significant challenge, while easy to cross for recreational purposes, there are barriers to living in one country and working in the other.

I grew up in the Southern California mega region (Orange & Riverside Counties) and still have family there. I have also (briefly) lived in the Gulf Coast mega region (Biloxi, MS) when I was in the military, also was (briefly) in the Texas Triangle (Dallas). I lived in the Front Range (Denver area and Colorado Springs) for about 25 years, Cascadia (Portland) for a couple of years, and I now live on the outskirts of the Northern California mega region (Reno, NV-about an hour and a half from Sacramento and three hours from San Francisco-over the mountains). My wife grew up in Boston and Southern NH-the Northeast region, so I’m familiar with most of these. However, I have never been to the Great Lakes (except for airports) or the Florida Region at all…

If you make a comparison between the megalopolises of the USA and those of Europe you can see how densely populated the European ones are, for example Benelux would be a Megalopolis between 3 countries, some say that the Netherlands is like a giant city, also the Rhine-Ruhn

@Marquipuchi

2 ай бұрын

European regions arent sprawling though. In the US suburbs connect to eachother and the land is continuously inhabited, while in Europe villages are dotted around but inbetween those and cities it is just farmland. I noticed this many times when taking the train in the Netherlands and Spain.

@Booz2010

2 ай бұрын

Megalopolises of 🇨🇳 Shanghai, Shenzhen, &Guangdong 👀

I have lived in three of these mega regions: northeast, Southern California, and currently live in Piedmont Atlantic (Northern Alabama). It will be interesting to see how these regions grow and influence American economy and politics in the future.

We have one megalopolis forming in Morocco ,stretching from tangiers in the north to casablanca the economic capital of the country , this maybe even include marakesh and agadir in the south . Including more than 75% of the country gdp and 50% of the population but less than 10% of the area

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

It's interesting how it's a pretty common phenomenon throughout the world. Really shows how we have a tendency to concentrate population and industries/services together.

@zakariaalami1491

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge yep exactly also the attractivennes of oceans and seas due to globalization make these megalopolis almost always adjacent to maritime spaces unfortuntly to the expense of non coastal cities like my own FEZ .

@TracyII77

2 ай бұрын

@@zakariaalami1491 Good insight. Even without the trade aspect, mankind has sought to live near water since the beginning of history. The Arizona Sun Belt mentioned in this video, despite being mostly desert, follows the water system in that region. This includes large underground aquifers. I suspect that one can trace the underground water systems in the Sahara by the location of the cities and settlements there.

@zakariaalami1491

2 ай бұрын

@@TracyII77 yes of course the ancient civilizations all created around big rivers , nile , mesopotamia , indus valley , yellow river etc

I live in the overlap of the Gulf Coast and Texas Triangle regions. Gotta say there are some very not urban regions once you get past Sabine River. Two of the five longest bridges in the US are on I-10 between Houston and Baton Rouge. I've been through there when the Atchafalaya basin was at full flood. It's truly land fit only for Cajuns and US army jungle training.

The Cascadia region extends along the west Canadian coast and into Alaska and is considered almost a separate climate region as the difference in temperature from its northern point to its southern point is ~10 degrees most of the year. The Pacific Northwest is different and hosts the states of Idaho, Oregon, and Washington.

What map is did you use here 9:42. Id love to see a full map showing all the other megalopolis and see where their commuters are from

Is there a source that tracts interactivity (like long car trip frequency) like one you briefly show (of the front range)?

I'm from the Northeast mega region.

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Does it really feel like one big city? Or is it just more of a map perception rather than a real life one?

@jimmymcinerney1950

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge I live in eastern Pennsylvania, one hour north of Philadelphia. My area is built up but as you get closer to Philadelphia it is very urban. My in-laws live in northern New Jersey (20 minutes outside New York City) and that feels like one continuous city.

@callmefleet

2 ай бұрын

@@General.Knowledge I'd say it is a lot like a really big NYC. You talked about how people work in one city despite living in another. That really feels like almost everyone. And it's not just jobs, so many hop into different town's schools too

@Demopans5990

2 ай бұрын

@callmefleet Not sure why would people drive 3 hours from Philly to NYC though. I can see it working out if they take the train and get work done there, but not driving. Never understood

@callmefleet

2 ай бұрын

@@Demopans5990 the only reason for going that far is a REALLY good job opportunity but there's more than 4 cities in these states

Nice video. I've lived my entire US life in three megatrons, northeast, great lakes, and northwest. Most of that in the northwest megatron (CA). Expensive but good amenities and jobs. Then there was that time in a German megatron but I'm not sure which one, I need to find your video on Europe. The northwest is really two megatrons, LA and the SF bay area, with hundreds of miles of highway connecting them to each other and the scattered cities in OR and WA. Having driven up there, there's a LOT of (beautiful) wilderness between SF, Portland, and Seattle, not sure I'd classify that as a megatron.

What I found fascinating was the map you created to create 50 new equal population states. That was very well thought out and I like a number of your original names. I live on the western fringe of the new Detroit state, but I wish you had a better name for that one.

I live in Chicago and can tell you that southern Illinois would drop us in a heartbeat even though they need us to pay for the majority of stuff the state needs.

@bmjv77

2 ай бұрын

And I grew up in downstate Illinois (as not everything south of I-80 is considered "southern" despite what Chicagoans say). Chicago relies on downstate to produce the goods that they rely on. When everyone continues to move out of the state because of the terrible policies of Cook county, and you're the only ones left to tax, you'll soon realize why you're dependent on downstate as well.

@davidkane4300

2 ай бұрын

Chicago already takes the majority of state funded programs and attention of the legislature. Look at East St. Louis... It's a literal American-style ghetto that Springfield largely ignores, even though it's consistently on top of the most dangerous cities list. Per Capita, it's more dangerous than the most dangerous countries (and, according to the FBI, the violent crime rate is nearly double [96/100] that of the south side of Chicago [49/100], both of which are far higher than the US average [22/100], although property crime is actually slightly less). I rode my $1000 Specialized bike through there to St. Louis since there's a pedestrian-crossable bridge over the Mississippi near the casino, and I kept getting stuck when trying to avoid the main road since the city/county/state dumped giant piles of dirt on city streets to block off depopulated areas (presumably in an attempt to mitigate crime), some of which I couldn't get past and would have to turn around. I ended up saying screw that and was going to try my luck on the main road, cutting through a church parking lot. Church must have just gotten out as they were all going to their cars and staring at me in bewilderment, probably thinking (1) crazy/dumb/brave white boy, and/or (2), must be a cop. Nothing happened to me, but I wouldn't use my one-off experience to say it's safe when statistics show otherwise.

@oktoberregeln

2 ай бұрын

@davidkane4300 yeah because the majority of the population lives in the city of Chicago or the surrounding area

@oktoberregeln

2 ай бұрын

@@davidkane4300 you guys really don't understand that my point is we need each other but yall actually think you'd be fine without us. Not true

@kevincousino2276

2 ай бұрын

If south illinois were a new state, would you stop selling food to chicago or something? ​@@oktoberregeln

6:12 would like to add. The Northern California region includes not Tahoe, but Reno Nevada as apart of this map. Which checks out perfectly. There’s been a massively growing EV/Tech industry there for the last 10 years.

Florida Megaregion in da house!!! 👍👍

Its like how Mexico City and their nearby cities (Toluca, Puebla, Querétaro, Pachuca) are now named Megalopolis and they share at least some stuff like twice per year checking you car or stuff related.

I grew up in and around Columbia, Missouri. Honestly I'd group Kansas City, St.Louis, Jefferson City to the Lake of the Ozarks through to Springfield and Bentonville, Arkansas. even Memphis and Nashville too.

Good video! I live in the Texas Triangle and what you mention about its dynamic nature is true. I have seen a definite frustration with the state government among many urban centers, and even their suburbs, although it hasn't fully coalesced into a more left-leaning political bloc as yet. I suspect it will over the next few years and its politics will demand a more sympathetic state government respecting the needs of a highly urban area. I also wouldn't be surprised if the Texas Triangle and perhaps the western component of the Gulf Coast Megaregion (especially Greater Houston and points southwest to Matamoros, MX) will come to definite the state and its social , economic, and political identities.

You get better everything

As others have noted this is a very broad definition of each megaregion. Nonetheless, very impressive maps. Where precisely are boundaries being drawn? County lines? Census districts? Zip Code Areas? This could be a map of the high speed rail corridors, which makes total sense. Where did the original come from? Curious why no link was provided?

You forgot the Oklahoma part of the Texas Triangle & the Salt Lake cities in your County's Map.

@thedeadlysquidward1641

2 ай бұрын

And he also did not mention the salt lake area of the Front Range

@Rich-MarsEco

2 ай бұрын

@@thedeadlysquidward1641 that in my comment. I edited that in immediately. Not 17 minutes later lol

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

That is true! My mistake

@davidkane4300

2 ай бұрын

The Salt Lake City metro isn't part of the Front Range... that name as a noun is associated with the Cheyenne-Pueblo corridor (as opposed to "front range" that could describe any area sitting at the base of a mountain range, including the SLC metro, which has it's own proper noun: Wasatch Front). The Front Range (noun) includes Cheyenne (and, as a stretch, Casper), but not Santa Fe/Albuquerque (as both of these are high elevation metros within the southern Rockies). Technically, if you're talking about the Rocky Mountains front range (geographically, not as a noun), it stretches from basically the North Slope of Alaska to around Juarez in Mexico where it diffuses into the Sierra Occidental region. There's just no land-based direct infrastructure (other than state/county roads) connecting El Paso directly north to the proper noun Front Range, or I'd say it should be included as well if we're taking liberties. There's a zero percent chance someone lives in Albuquerque and commutes daily to Pueblo (the southern most point of the Front Range, noun), for example, as it would take 5h30m to drive in the best possible conditions.

Interesting video, and no hate. Okies don’t consider OKC and Tulsa part of the Texas triangle, we we don’t have a ton of interaction with them

As many commenters have noted, most of these regions are a literal and figurative stretch to consider as continuous urban regions. As one example among many, if you go just a little bit south of Corpus Christi, there's a whole lot of nothing to drive through. If you drive from San Diego or Los Angeles to Las Vegas, you drive for hours through long stretches of unpopulated areas.

obrigado senor, greetings from Texas

I've lived my entire life in the Great Lakes Megalopolis, but I have to say, there are also some rather empty regions here, too. Not much at all between Lansing and Grand Rapids, and the same goes for Brighton, MI and Lansing, as well as areas along the I-94 corridor. A lot of Indiana is pretty empty as well, unless you include all the corn. I also saw a whole lot of nothing on most of the trip from Port Huron, MI to Toronto.

@MarsJenkar

2 ай бұрын

It doesn't help that the region has arguably peaked in its importance. The alternative name for this region is "the Rust Belt".

@jnmsks6052

2 ай бұрын

@@MarsJenkar The areas I've mentioned have never been developed. It's simply farmland and has been for decades at least. My point is that a very large portion of what is being called a "Megalopolis" is highly rural. Sure, there have been a lot of factory closures and urban decay in many cities in this region of the country. I've also seen a lot of repurposing of old plants and land in more suburban areas for higher-tech industries.

Android Netrunner had megacities the names were basically the cities at the endpoints. You had San-San (San Francisco to San Diego) Bo-wash (Boston to Washington) You even had ones that crossed international borders like Van-Port (Vancouver, B.C. to Portland, Oregon)

Interesting theory. Alabama has NEVER claimed Florida's panhandle. The MAIN reason why it lacks in connectivity are natural barriers in topography and conservation of lands by the State of Florida. Starting at the northern most point of Tampa's metro area, you find protected lands that run concurrent to the coastline up from Crystal River through the Big Bend, into the panhandle region taking a break at Tate Hell's Wildlife Management area and State Forest, Apalachicola Estuarine, Apalachicola National Forest, St. Joe's Timberlands among other protected areas. You also see the same going from Big Bend towards the JAX area where you find protected areas such as the Ocala National Forest, Osceola National Forest and hundreds of smaller projects and trust protected areas that run together. Interesting fact though, Florida's peninsula megalopolis is the ONLY megaregion in the US where you can drive NINE consecutive hours without leaving a continuous urban/residential path of less than 5 miles or 8-10 minutes more than once during the entire drive.

I grew up in the northeast. I have lived in Cascadia, Front Range, Texas Triangle, Piedmont, and now live in Florida. I hope I don't have to move again.

For Cascadia, there are many definitions and maps that only include Vancouver BC, Washington, and Oregon. Having lived in Idaho, for a while I never directly assumed there was an association and didn't understand why the RPA/Government included Boise/Treasure Valley and Spokane/CDA in the Cascadia megaregion map. Though when you visit Spokane and North Idaho, the evergreen geography + mountains are very similar and share the same Koppen Climate Type, similar economies, etc. as West Washington/West Oregon. While Boise is more desert, you find a majority of new residents are from Portland and Seattle (not including California). At most, those areas of Eastern WA/North + Western Idaho are anywhere from 3-7 hour car rides to the other cities + coast. Also worth mentioning WA, OR, and ID have been associated together for hundreds of years historically dating back through to the Oregon Territory, Oregon Trail, and through to American Revolution. So while it may seem like a stretch to include Western Idaho, there's been some fair points made about how similar/close it can be.

I was born in Cascadia

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Nice!

9 of 11 US megaregions visited here. Missing Cascadia and Florida. I've been to 45 states - missing WA, OR, ID, HI & AK. When I went to Florida it was Pensacola so barely. Cascadia the farthest that way I've been was Glacier National Park. Amazing sights but be prepared mentally for heights lol

@Booz2010

2 ай бұрын

Is Pensacola safe from wildlife ❓ Especially reptiles

Have you ever driven between Dallas and Houston? They're hours apart with little inbetween but rolling hills. Pretty much the same with the drive between Dallas and Austin. Most of the megaregions are Internet hype being magnified with every "new content maker" who repeats it.

Thanks for telling us that you're from Portugal, as I've often wondered, and have tried to "nail down" the accent without success. Considering that I have a document on my computer 78 pages long with just over 2500 place names with pronunciations that are unanticipated by many, I'd say you do very well at your attempts. So, any that follow are not meant to poke fun, but to point out just how weird many of our place names are. First of all is Lake Tahoe, which is TAH-hoe. Another odd one is Piedmont, with syllable #1 rhyming with 'feed', followed by 'mahnt'. Re. 'gigalopolis', we're using the same prefixes as the computer terminology--megabytes and gigabytes, as in 'good'. In closing, this was a very well done video. Thanks for sharing it with us.

@therealusman

Ай бұрын

you realise you could go to his about tab and see his location is marked portugal also he’s mentioned his nationality in previous videos

@jimgreen5788

Ай бұрын

@@therealusman, thanks, but since I went to school with Yoda, I didn't know about that tab. Then, to part 2: I must have asked him shortly after he'd shared that with his viewers the most recent time. Nevertheless, thanks for both.

Liked growing up where I did in rural Central Pennsylvania. Knew it was near the northeast also known as Bos-Wash or Boston-Washington, D.C. megalopolis but didn’t know there was a Great Lakes one or any others in the us, the history books argued about if the northeast one really was one or not and said it was the first/only one. If the Great Lakes one really extends past Pittsburgh it’s only a matter of time before it merges with the northeast one though because the Poconos are a resort playground for nyc people already for a few decades/generations and State College/University Park, PA is like the 6th biggest city normally or something but becomes the 3rd biggest in the state lagging only behind Pittsburgh and Philadelphia passing even Harrisburg and Erie during Penn State Home game weekends, those game weekends have grown so large people get hotel accommodations in my hometown an hour away because they can’t get a room any closer, some people gave up on hotel rooms and just fly into Pittsburgh airport and drive in the rest of the way there before the game. My great uncle owned a lot of land and helped the state game commission manage a lot of the state game lands and a lot of people from New York Michigan and other states would come in for sight seeing tours and basically safaris or hunting trips or to teach their kids from the city about wildlife and the woods since they had never seen it, some people from the south would come because their kids had never seen significant snowfall and they wanted them to experience a real snow fall and what it looks like when 2 to 4 feet of snow lay on the ground and don’t melt off right away or stay there all winter. Also my hometown and home county were very prominent in the late 1800s and early 1900s up through the 1950s somewhat and with investment could easily grow again. So I can see the northeast and Great Lakes slowly merging into one megalopolis.

@isabellarhoslyn1579

2 ай бұрын

7:37 Clearfield and Centre Counties in Pennsylvania and Cleveland and Gaston Counties in North Carolina are all on this new map of a gigalopolis I see

I live in one of the 'close, but no cigar' areas, but I find this subject interesting. What I found to be most intriguing, was the brief mention of the mashing of these regions into more continuous borders. Those might actually make for more 'sane' politics.

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

It is an interesting idea to think about. Borders are man-made and there's no real reason why they should be permanent if they stop making sense.

@recoil53

2 ай бұрын

The schools and infrastructure of the 'outside' regions would certainly fall apart. This may as well be a map of the tax base of the US. The wealth disparity would drive up resentment among the 'have nots' and worsen politics, making them more conspiracy-theory prone.

I really think its a stretch to call that whole stretch of the gulf coast connected or continuous. really grasping at straws on that one imo.

I'm from the Front Range Megaregion (Denver specifically). While there's much to like about it (mainly its natural beauty), for good or for ill, it is probably the most isolated and most widely dispersed of any of these megaregions.

From my perspective in upstate New York, I'd suggest that the north-south corridor along Interstate 81 including the cities of Watertown, Oswego, Syracuse, Ithaca and Binghamton should be included in the Great Lakes Region and that the north-south corridor along Interstate 87 including the cities of Saratoga, Glens Falls, and the Capital District (Albany, Schenectady and Troy) should be included in the Northeast Region.

@sean668

2 ай бұрын

Agreed as a Long Islander. If you look at the state, the cultural boundary is the Mohawk Valley. From Albany down the Hudson to here, it's one unit. West and north of Albany, tracing along the old Erie canal, that's another distinct cultural unit

@lyncourt1

2 ай бұрын

I was going to suggest the same. I grew up in Syracuse and have lived in Buffalo for 45 years. Syracuse north to Watertown and south to Binghamton should definitely included be with Rochester and Buffalo as part of the GL Megalopolis. CNY and WNY and the Southern Tier are tied together culturally, as well as structurally the the Thruway, Rt 81, and the Southern Tier Expressway.

@tomfields3682

2 ай бұрын

​@@sean668we're not talking cultural, were talking economic.

Can you make the same video for Europe?

Always strange for me when I see videos like this (about the population spread in the USA) being from the USA, not living there anymore and being reminded of how I came from such a random small place. I was born in a small town not part of any mega region and would be about a 4-5 hour drive to one. I've met quite a few other ex-pats from the USA and I think basically every single one has been from one of these areas (I guess that is just statistics being statistics though haha).

@General.Knowledge

2 ай бұрын

Yeah that's true! Considering the percentage of their population that lives in these areas, it's likely that if we meet an American, they'll be from one of them.

Dang, Great Lakes be crushing it.

I'm from Central California, and even I feel disconnected from the rest of California. I live between Fresno and Bakersfield, but I hardly ever go North, so the only area I feel like I belong is in the South Valley. And when I do go as far as Stockton or Sacramento, I feel like I'm in a completely different state. But there is a lot of evidence to put those two cities in with San Francisco because the bay extends almost to them and there are a lot of roads connecting the bay to the North end of the valley. If I had made this map, I would make the Valley its own region, from Modesto to Bakersfield, maybe not even including Modesto, with how close it is to the bay.

I am watching from Orange County,CA have been here for 28 years

At 3:45 you said Cascadia excludes Boise, ID. Boise is the green circle by itself at the bottom of the screen, but it’s included

In Colorado, anything west of the Continental divide is known as the Western Slope, so i never made sense to me to include SLC in the Front Range area.

Never heard of Santa Fe and Albuquerque being part of the Front Range. Front Range is just Colorado and no New Mexico. The only thing connecting them is one highway with a whole lot of room between Pueblo and Santa Fe.

The only ones of these I HAVEN'T visited are the Gulf Coast, and, oddly, Southern California (I've spent a fair bit of time in the NoCal megaregion, but never SoCal). I've lived most of my life somewhere in the Northeast megaregion, mostly near the two ends of it, in Virginia and Massachusetts. They have more similarities than differences, to be honest--the contrast between being inside and outside of them is greater.

I’d argue that Coeur d”Alene Idaho is part of The Pacific Northwest mega region. It operates as an extension of Spokane and is actually 2 hours closer to Seattle than it is to Boise.

7:57 Where is this map from?

You say the northeast megaregion stretches south to DC, but even your own map shows it stretching further south to include Richmond and Hampton Roads Virginia. North Carolina is planning on building an interstate to connect Raleigh, directly to Norfolk Virginia via Elizabeth City, and if this goes through, it wont be long before the Northeast megaregion is basically connected to the Atlanta/piedmont megaregion enough for it to be called a giggaregion.

I've been in OKC and Tulsa, so I guess I have visited the Texan Triangle?

I think that the Texas triangle is the most realistic one, I live there and visit all of the cities regularly at least one a week, this includes Oklahoma City and DFW.

I really like the map of alternative political boundaries! France changes its political regions occasionally, maybe every five years according to political needs.

So what happened to Virginia? You did not connect it with either the Northeast nor the southeast so where does it fit in?

I live in the Texas Triangle! It's very much "urban sprawl" up here in Dallas at least.

@floycewhite6991

Ай бұрын

Yeah, that horrible grid pattern where you can drive for 20 miles and everything looks the same.

I live in Nashville, im not sure i would consider it part of the "Piedmont," its fairly isolated from both Atlanta and Charlotte. Honestly, other than the Northeast, most of these "mega regions" have a lot of rural land between the cities. It takes 4+ hours to get to Atlanta from here, I wouldn't really call that the same region.