Debate Star Wars. Disagree, dispute, discuss everything in lore & legends. I encourage it! However, when the conversation turns personal, when hate and insults are targeted towards one another, you’ve officially lost what it means to call yourself a fan of Star Wars.

@ian9161

16 күн бұрын

I’ve just left the official Star Wars page on Facebook it’s just getting too toxic there are amazing fans out there but it’s getting silly with others I’ve done the same marvel wise I love both fandoms but I just can’t be ding with drama and vile comments opinion is one thing but the hate bigotry and nasty comments is just horrible I’m just keep up do days with yo Carly because you are genuine and kind and lovely if you don’t mind me saying so ❤️

@ian9161

16 күн бұрын

Sorry about my spelling errors I was typing fast lol

@kedarrangan9766

16 күн бұрын

​@@randomiser2267 At the end of the day its just a TV show. You cant deny that there is an absurd amount of toxicity and hate aimed at each other just for the preference of a TV show, its truly just absurd to think about. People can have opinions, people can definitely voice them to, nothing wrong with that, but targeting someone because the like or don't like a TV show is some childish shit.

@pulse1772

16 күн бұрын

This.

@FloydThyshawn253

16 күн бұрын

We call you shill and fake fans for liking the destruction and decannization of George Lucas Star Wars wether that means destroying/not making anakins birth special or whether that means liking the destruction of Luke skywalker being a bum and cutting himself off from the force not doing nonething you enjoy/tolerate what their doing to our beloved character hope you find inner peace Sincerely A real fan

I miss the old times when anakin used to blow up the death star.. 😔

@LeeBrabham

15 күн бұрын

You would think that if they were in the tv show, they would at least know the characters

@deannovak8077

15 күн бұрын

It was actually Gandalf while Joker was saving Harry Potter defeating Thanos

@Manateeus

15 күн бұрын

Seriously who cares about that? He's an actor, his job is to act, whether he knows anything about the franchise is literally completely irrelevant.

@alannerrato3278

15 күн бұрын

@@Manateeus then maybe he shouldn’t have said shit instead of making himself look dumb.

@sevexxan

15 күн бұрын

@@Manateeusyeah! If you’re a doctor, you dont really need to understand anatomy. Just knowing how to use a scalpel is enough.

SW fans arent the ones that spread hate, the showrunners and its directors do

"You can't call someone a bigot for liking something" is correct, but the same goes for not liking something.

@jedison2441

13 күн бұрын

Depends on why they don't like it. If it's because it is a black female actress, and this has happened more than once. Then there seems to be a pattern.

@BB-zd2sf

13 күн бұрын

@@jedison2441 You completely made up this scenario in your head.

@lostvayne104

13 күн бұрын

@@jedison2441 you're part of the problem smh

@voidous7019

13 күн бұрын

​@@jedison2441It's not our fault these black female characters look absolutely ridiculous and farcical.

@haroldb1856

13 күн бұрын

No.

Fine but do not act like the hate doesn’t go both ways. I got hate for saying that I didn’t like it. There’s people who genuinely like it and there’s people who genuinely hate it. Let people have their own opinions. Don’t call anyone racist, misogynist, or homophobes because they said they didn’t like it. It’s ridiculous and what’s even more ridiculous is that the leaders over at Disney Star Wars are the ones spreading that mess smh

@danscifi7370

9 күн бұрын

amen to that.

@brahimy2953

8 күн бұрын

I really dont see why the director Leslye Headland continues to use dirogitory language when refering to star wars fans who dislike Acolyte ! like people are allowed to have their opinions without being hateful. I also dont understand why she continues to state the R2D2 is Lesbian and several other stupid comments she mentioned alongside Actor Amandla Stenberg in an interview, there is literally no need for that! show a better example!!

@danscifi7370

8 күн бұрын

@@brahimy2953 yeah i don't get it too. what makes sense is that they want to kill star wars and turn the fanbase against itself and they have succeeded in that and i feel the death of this beloved franchise is coming a lot sooner than we think.

@J1O2C3K4E5S

6 күн бұрын

Yep. Plus recently a former Lucasfilm employee got out and said that you couldn’t say openly that you don’t like Rey or Acolyte cause other employees would get mad at you for saying that. Worse even.

@steveh4521

5 күн бұрын

Disney: You don't like it cause we have gay characters and women and gay women and pronouns and gay pronouns. Me: Ok Disney you caught me. I don't like Star Wars cause gay people are in it and women. Oh ya don't get me started on the woman characters. Yes, I think woman should just be in the background washing the dishes. Don't mind the fact that the novels and movies had strong female characters that were awesome! And yes pronouns usage is stupid, dividing, not how the English language works (its rules) and on top of that you can't encroach on my freedom of speech to fit your hurt feelings. Disney: See told you you were homophobic and racist. You also don't like it cause C3PO is a lesbian. and sexually orientation is binary. Me: So, C3PO whose a droid is a lesbian now? And I would hope C3PO is binary in general cause you need coding of zeros and ones to bring C3PO to life. Disney: Well..... What if C3PO is? Proves you are a bigot. And well I don't like your binary logic point you made. You bigot. Me: No, it proves you don't know the definition of lesbian, droid or even how reproduction works nor fail to realize protocol droids cannot reproduce. Especially, lesbian protocol droids. Disney: Droids don't choose to be gay. You homophobe. And if we say two lesbian protocol droids can then that's the hill we will die on. Me: ........ This is literally the dumbest conversation I've ever had. This is the hill I hope you are willing to die on because you will keep making shitty stories and characters and probably within a few years. You'll have effectively killed Star Wars.

It goes both ways though. If you like it, fine. If you don’t like it, fine. People are allowed to not like something without being called ists and phobes automatically.

@carlyking

16 күн бұрын

That’s exactly what I said in the video. It goes both ways, of course.

@Boomboy53

16 күн бұрын

@@carlyking Ya but the side of the fandom that likes/enjoys the shows is categorizing everyone else in one bubble. Even when some have legitimate criticisms. We as fans shouldn’t just blindly accept everything because that’s how the quality of the product decreases.

@Bososkey

16 күн бұрын

@@Boomboy53’the people that enjoy the show all categorize the haters’ I may have paraphrased a little, but ironic nonetheless. no h8

@xEllimist

16 күн бұрын

@@Boomboy53 And that goes both ways too. Every time I've ever said "Overall, I like the Sequels", there is, inevitably, someone who chimes in to call me a "Disney shill". Every. Single. Time.

@martychisnall

16 күн бұрын

@@carlykingThat’s not what you were saying previously, you were saying the people disagreeing with you are “racist” and “sexist” showing about five comments with rude words as “proof” that everyone who doesn’t like it thinks like that. It’s only now you’ve gotten criticism that you are trying to claim you never meant it.

“Apathy is death. Worse than death, because at least a rotting corpse feeds the beasts and insects.” - Kreia

@leonlacroix2638

14 күн бұрын

Hands down the best character ever made in my opinion ❤

@daChief-khalife

14 күн бұрын

100

@Dang00TheAlienIAmTheRealOne

14 күн бұрын

KOTOR 2 was amazing! Hands down one of the best Star Wars stories ever.

Well good luck then. "From my experience, there's no such thing as luck." -Obi Wan Kenobi

Younger generations would benefit by understanding definitions & differences between words like “dislike,” “loathe,” & “hate.” I can “hate” a movie, but that doesn’t mean I want harm to befall anyone involved with creating it, …or its fans.

@GamesandNonsenseUnleashed

14 күн бұрын

Sadly people these days cannot tell the difference between disagreement and wanting to actually cause someone physical harm. How the entire silence is violence or if you aren't with us you are against us mentality is so engrained in many Gen Z and younger Millennials.

@straybard_art

13 күн бұрын

Agreed - this is something that would help clear up a lot of confusion.

@jedison2441

13 күн бұрын

If I "hate" a movie or franchise; move on with you life. I didn't spend the 10 years crapping on film I didn't like. It doesn't seem difficult.

@BB-zd2sf

13 күн бұрын

@@jedison2441 No, but you seem strangely committed to defending an awful TV show nearly everyone dislikes.

@jedirogar

11 күн бұрын

@@BB-zd2sf the thing is it’s NOT everyone! And to say “nearly everyone” without cold hard stats in your hands is self delusion! Now if you stated “I and a few(10, 40, 129) ppl think the show is awful, there may be truth in that and for you and those ppl are entitled not to like it! The other part is, it’s not up to you what other are interested in, like or enjoy! Them liking it may be strange to you but what about things you like that are strange to them 🤷🏽‍♂️ We’re not all the same with the same likes and wants! And that’s ok! The problem I’ve seen is that nowadays ppl are NOT ok with others liking different things! There’s a reason we have and make our own choices 🤷🏽‍♂️

Luke looking at the twin suns on Tattooine is the best scene in episode 4.

@carlyking

16 күн бұрын

Agreed

@stevemin559

16 күн бұрын

@@carlyking and the music was perfect

@TimDaco

16 күн бұрын

Completely Agree.

@chloemayhew

15 күн бұрын

@@TimDaco Completely agree with you too.

@AirbenderHawk

15 күн бұрын

Iconic!

Using the KOTOR 2 quote at the end of the video went extremely hard and was surpisingly fitting haha

@TheGreatDeadpoolio

16 күн бұрын

It was perfect 👌

@zen1647

16 күн бұрын

Pow! That was a powerfully timed quote! ❤

@stevesmith42066

15 күн бұрын

Simp

@100StarWars

15 күн бұрын

@stevesmith42066 You're absolutely right I'm a simp for KOTOR 2 quotes.

@Cailus3542

15 күн бұрын

Kudos for supporting Carly. This comment section is a mess.

Let's also point out the fans who resort to ad hominem attacks and personal insults when you DON'T just blindly love and consume every piece of SW content Disney has pushed out. Just because a fan doesn't like Reva, does NOT mean he's a racist sexist incel bigot who should be silenced for voicing that opinion. It goes both ways.

@paulbinder7434

12 күн бұрын

I agree, it goes both ways for sure. Yet - sadly - from the communities I am in, it seems like it is mostly people who hate the show bashing those who like it.

@dallaskinard3143

12 күн бұрын

@@paulbinder7434 And others will say the opposite.

@paulbinder7434

12 күн бұрын

@@dallaskinard3143 They would. But , without biased, jump into any Star Wars community (I have several in my Facebook, reddit, and so on) As soon as someone post The Acolyate content, someone will always post something about "Not real fans" , "Shills" and so on about anyone who likes it. In reverse, if you see someone post about prequels, original films, or literally anything else about Star Wars - no one attacks them. Additionally, if you see someone post a critique about the show, no one will attack them. Give it a try

@dallaskinard3143

12 күн бұрын

@@paulbinder7434 You seem to be generalizing a lot and providing anecdotal evidence.

@Bravehorizon1

12 күн бұрын

We're fighting with shadows. The real culprits for destroying Star Wars and then gaslighting the longtime fans are Kennedy and Headland.

Im sorry Star Wars has become a political agenda to the real world. I always used Star Wars to escape the real world. It's not hate to say the Acolyte is garbage and Disney has gone too far in destroying the the storytelling nor do to call out people like Kathleen Kennedy who Im telling you is destroying Star Wars on purpose. I'm calling it here and now. It's going to get worst. Expanded Universe (now Legends) in novels (minus the Vong-they came off as characters that should have been in the Star Trek universe) has nothing but renown writers and backstories that could have been put on screen. Movies 7,8,9, and Acolyte are trash in my opinion. I'm not apologizing for the way they have destroyed to core of what George Lucas said Star Wars was a story about. You can't tell me these new characters are better written than Jaina Solo, Fel, Luke Skywalker, Alana Solo, Ben Skywalker, saba sebatyne (im willing to bet half don't know who that is) and all the others from books like Fate of the Jedi. Even how the Old Republic games had creation and character development. Kathleen will destroy that and wipe out all the fans you are attached to that. Mark my words. Star Wars is dying. I don't care that my Sith side says this: I don't like her, Kathleen Kennedy. The way I see it is we all just need to either outlive her or Disney will wise up and finally get rid of her. If that is hate, so be it. I don't care. I'm officially turned to the Darkside. I don't like her nor her agenda. If you want to discuss how Star Wars was better in Legends aka Expanded Universe and how they should of done the movies. I'm all for it. But im not going to sit/stand here and pretend this new stuff is the shite. It's not.

@redvitproductions2829

11 сағат бұрын

SO much wrong and distaste with this comment I wouldn't even know where to start.

Sorry, but I didn't like The Acolyte. But you're completely right when you say that liking or disliking the show doesn't give you the right to offend or hurt someone. Respect is always the most important thing.

@StillSaber

16 күн бұрын

I agree, in fact here's 1 person that did that, Drunk3PO, he disrespected an overweighted person by putting one of those comic bubbles on his review for Acolyte episode 2 saying "Execute Order 66 Chicken Nuggets"

@grumpygrant4537

16 күн бұрын

Don’t be sorry. There’s nothing wrong with being a Star Wars fan and not appreciating the garbage that Disney has been shoving down our throats. The show is trash and that’s the truth. BecUse the people in charge would rather push their agenda on us rather than make good tv

@Ghost_-nz5dy

16 күн бұрын

See this is how people should be. I’m not gonna attack you for not liking the acolyte that’s fine. It’s your own opinion and I’m glad you’re also being respectful. This is how this fanbase should be. We shouldn’t be ripping each other throats out over something we like or dislike.

@kieronbotting5265

16 күн бұрын

Respectfully I disagree with your stance… I can’t say that the Acolyte is good in any way. . I wish you all the best. . May the FORCE be with you.

@majorleaguegains5597

16 күн бұрын

You are a scholar and a gent

0:58 Idk people like SnarkyJay and ThatStarWarsGirl

@my_cousin_mose9782

8 күн бұрын

Same reasons people are here- good looking girl who loves star wars. Difference is Anna doesn't seem to shill for Disney.

@fnspidey3825

Күн бұрын

@@my_cousin_mose9782 exactly

I had to watch this video because I'm an older guy and it's quite interesting to watch all this back and forth in the community play out. When I was growing up being a nerd was not something you announced, it was assigned to you. You weren't necessarily ashamed of it, but you didn't brag about it either. We kept to ourselves and enjoyed the things we loved and we took the heat and kept moving. Newer generations, however, have adopted the idea that it's cool to be a nerd and now seemingly everyone wants in. Well unfortunately, that is going create a bit of a culture clash. Nerds have always argued. ALWAYS. And quite fiercely. But there was a mutual respect because we truly loved the properties we were fans of. And we loved it because of how good the content was, not just because they stamped the label on it. My biggest concern for a property like Star Wars is that, like any business, you have to define your target audience. "Star Wars is for everyone" is a great slogan, but the numbers will never support that. There are groups of people who will like it enough to pour lots of money into it. These are the groups you want to target, and these seem to be the groups with which Lucasfilm has lost touch.

@TheDCbiz

11 күн бұрын

As an old timer I 100% disagree. There is a reason why "nerds" back in the day had "wars". Like star trek vs star wars fans old debates of which was better or DC vs marvel fans etc. even tho these are more groups of geeks than nerds but for sake of this convo they are the same. I remember the hate Lucas got in 1983 for the ewoks. Lucas himself said he got hate for R2 and c3po and then obviously jar jar got hate. Star wars as a fandom has kinda just been sith-esque hate fuelled since 1983. Force awakens and mandalorian s1 brought balance but everything else has been hate filled. Ironic given the protagonists like Luke and Anakin's cautionary tale teach to choose hope not hate. NO ONE LOVES star wars as much as star wars fans. NO ONE HATES star wars as much as star wars fans. Has been this way since 1983 and continues. There could be balance. Star wars doesn't nor did it ever only appeal to a narrow or niche audience. It started off as a fairy tale for everyone to enjoy. But some fans are like the sith driven by hate of a brand they feel is in chaos and needs a strong ruler like Anakin's speech in revenge of the sith. Other fans are like the Jedi, filled with hubris and feeling they know what's best and that star wars is doing great while the hateful fans are right beneath their noses

@cptace

11 күн бұрын

@@TheDCbiz Okay, I'm not sure exactly what we disagree on here. I said that nerds have always had fiery debates and you seem to remember some of them so I'm kind of lost. As an aside though, I will say that I always looked down on the folks who hated on the Ewoks, and R2, and 3PO, and Jar Jar. But I also didn't know too many people like that as well. This speaks to the factional nature of nerds and fandoms as a whole. I NEVER saw any type of significant hate within the fandom, especially not in the 80s or 90s. But that just speaks to all of the various groups I was exposed to. And to be honest, I don't really see much of it in the fandom now. I just see fans getting into arguments with normies. That's about the only time I see it getting personal. Star Wars has, well had, a wide appeal. But it's fans that drive the enthusiasm. And this is the same with many properties. Fan is generally short for fanatic, and just like with a sports team, it's the fanatics who drive the excitement that ultimately produces the revenue. Lucasfilm needs to bring that crowd back.

@TheDCbiz

11 күн бұрын

@@cptace We agree nerds had debates I definitely saw the hate in the 80's and especially the 90's. It did happen. You are lucky I guess you were in less contentious debates. What do you feel Lucasfilm could do to being back fans? The fan base seems so divide. Who will bring balance to the fanbase and how?

@cptace

11 күн бұрын

@TheDCbiz Yup, I know it happened cause I've heard about it from others I've met over the years who saw it firsthand. The days before social media when you weren't exposed to everything going on everywhere. 😄 That's a good question. Unfortunately for them, they have more than just a Star Wars problem. They have customer relations nightmare on their hand. Just from a business perspective, heads would have to roll first. Bob Iger and all the creative executives at Lucasfilm are out. Their PR team leads are out as well. I wouldn't tolerate anything remotely resembling calling customers names while I'm trying to get them to open their wallets for me. Once that's done, we gotta get back to story. The allure of adventure in a galaxy far, far away is what brings the vast majority of people to Star Wars. That would be my only priority.

@TheDCbiz

11 күн бұрын

@@cptace Iger is retiring in the next couple years anyway so he'll be gone soon. Who are the creative execs at lucasfilm? Isn't filoni like the chief creative officer or some title like that? Jon Favreau and Favreau are the main head writers of recent star wars projects. I think the name calling stopping from lucasfilm directly is a good call from a business pov. The only problem is fans call each other names like shill vs racist so how can lucasfilm/Disney stop the fans and even media from calling each other names? But what is the story? That's kinda a big problem I have with star wars, the story is over. Lucas ended the story in 1983 and double downed in the prequels with Disney putting an exclamation mark that balance to the universe was met. Rey was an afterglow of Anakin's story but now that Rey's story definitively made it clear the Jedi and the sith are no more, now what? The return of the empire threat with the first order has been defeated so threatening a return of more empire shenanigans is played out just like death stars are played out. So where do we go from here? The story seems done. They lived happily ever, the end. So now what???

ok but the acolyte is shit

@Cameron-fk5fk

10 күн бұрын

please leave the fandom, you shit up YT with drivel.

@HeyItsRicki85

9 күн бұрын

​@@Cameron-fk5fkthat's not very tolerant of you

@Cameron-fk5fk

9 күн бұрын

@@HeyItsRicki85 No tolerance for the intolerant :)

@cyanidesyn123

9 күн бұрын

Completely fine to have that opinion but you know, could be a little more eloquent about it, or provide actual reasoning...or you know, just don't bother posting if that's all you have to say as you are clearly just fishing for reactions lol

@RobotRebelCinema

8 күн бұрын

@@cyanidesyn123 Ok but why don't YOU provide reasoning of you think it's good

It begs the question though, why do they keep making decisions that actively divide the fanbase?

@TheDCbiz

11 күн бұрын

Imo I think it's because any decision will anger that fan base. Since 1983 star wars fans have hated star wars. First was the ewoks, then the prequels and Lucas the creator being hated, then Grevious and Ashoka in first season of the clone wars, then came the sequels, and now the Disney+ shows. If you had a meeting with the CEO of lucasfilm/star wars what shows or films would you tell her to make that won't upset star wars fans?

@KnotsOfWonders

11 күн бұрын

@@TheDCbiz Sorry but no, with a franchise this large it is inevitable you're going to attract criticism. So of course you're going to get some fans that don't like some things and characters but majority of the fans do like the Ewoks, prequels and the prequel characters. The scale that Disney has done to divide fans however is quite staggering. If I had the option to speak to her, I would tell her to resign and put the franchise into George Lucas' prodigy Dave Filoni, he may not be perfect. But at least he has an understanding of Star Wars. It's quite painfully obvious that Kathleen Kennedy is only interested in social political agendas and has zero interest in storytelling and film making.

@TheDCbiz

11 күн бұрын

@@KnotsOfWonders NOW fans like the ewoks, prequels, clone wars, etc. with star wars fans time heals all wounds. In 5-10 more years the sequels will become the new prequels and liked as nostalgia grabs hold. I'm an old timer star wars fan. I remember how much the fans HATED George for the prequels. Now they love him again. I remember how after return of the Jedi fans HATED George. With star wars it's a matter of time to be forgiven. What is unique about how Disney has divided the fans? Anf if she didn't resign but just aksed you what shows or films she should make them what?

@KnotsOfWonders

11 күн бұрын

@@TheDCbiz No I disagree yet again, there is a very good reason why people grew to love the Prequels and that is because it had good world building and characters. The same cannot be said for the Sequel Trilogy and most of the TV series. Star Wars fans are smart, they know bad writing and acting when they see it. That's the reason why Mandalorian season 1 and 2, Andor, Clone Wars Animated Series, Bad Batch, were highly praised by the audience while season 3 is criticised heavily along with BOBF, Kenobi, Ahsoka and now Acolyte. What made Disney unique was their extraordinary inability to produce interesting and well written stories and their constant mocking of fans who criticise their work. Then I will tell her to stick to her lane as a producer and not interfere with the creative process, because it's clear that she is bankrupt on that end.

@TheDCbiz

11 күн бұрын

@@KnotsOfWonders the prequel films didn't have bad writing and acting? "I don't like sand" is a well written and acted line? Who are your fav characters from the prequels? Wdym by "good world building"? Andor was the lowest viewed live action star wars show. Rebels first season like clone wars was disliked by the fan base Mandalorian s2 ending divided fans Bad batch I hear is mixed reaction Yes, BOBF, Obi Wan, Ashoka, s3 of mandalorian, and acolyte have been VERY divisive among the fan base. I disagree about Disney making no interesting stories. I despise the prequels but much like the prequels even I can admit both the sequels and prequels have interesting ideas to explore, imo just poor execution. Like a storm trooper going rogue and joining the rebellion is an interesting idea or a hot headed rebel pilot or palpatine returning via sith teachings. In the sequels those ideas were imo just terribly done like the prequels terribly explained the fall of the Jedi at the height of their power. The mocking of fans will be forgotten to time just like Lucas' comments about fans have been for the most part forgotten. But what shows or films do you feel she should make or green light? Imo I'd tell her not to make the Rey film. Imo it's going to flop due to Rey being a divisive character in the fan base

So how do you feel about disney actively not hiring and promoting white males? Is it okay for jewish people to hate like that? Do you think that impacts a IP like star wars with a mostly white male fan base?

How is it review bombing if people don’t enjoy it. Yes, I do hate the acolyte, but that doesn’t mean I hate any certain group of people nor the entire franchise. Why does it make me such a villain just to hit one that part? I couldn’t find a single thing I enjoyed about the acolyte.

@AndyTheGypsy

Күн бұрын

Stinkfest

@redvitproductions2829

10 сағат бұрын

Review bombing DID happen. - The Acolyte was getting 1-star reviews by hundreds of accounts on multiple sites before the first episode even released. - It has more reviews that all 3 Seasons of The Mandalorian combined. - Review bombers and haters accidently posted their "reviews" on a fan-film called Acolyte before the show dropped. - You can go look for the reviews yourself and see the amount that just say non-sensical stuff, admitting they're review bombing or putting 1-star reviews just because of minor things.

BREAKING: The Acolyte Cancelled! *not renewed for another season, Season 2 defunded

When the video doesn't even start and the creator brings up her sex and how she had the opportunity to assist the show's event, you know things are going to be extremely bad.

@dybixs1400

13 күн бұрын

God. It was worse

Here's an idea though... how about they hire people who like and understand Star Wars to produce Star Wars shows? Is that a bridge too far..? I don't think it is.

@carlyking

16 күн бұрын

They… do.

@Michael-zp8fz

16 күн бұрын

@@carlyking No, they don't. The director said that they were deliberately hiring people who doesn't know sh about Star Wars.

@singularitybound

16 күн бұрын

@@carlyking ..come on now.

@simchar4263

16 күн бұрын

They do and they have, The Acolyte creator is a massive Star Wars fan.

@simchar4263

16 күн бұрын

@@Michael-zp8fz No, she said she hired ONE writer who was unfamiliar with Star Wars so they can offer a unique perspective on the show and offer advice that the other writers may miss.

The only truth is they lost another 31% of viewers between the last 2 episodes. No ones gonna watch this with LH, KK, AS and the extreme minorities in the fandoms phobic ist comments and attacks of 90% of the majority. Stick a fork in it, this ones done.

I gave The Acolyte a shot and I thought it was horrible. That’s just my opinion.

@Cameron-fk5fk

10 күн бұрын

please leave the fandom, you shit up YT with drivel.

@madlad1741

9 күн бұрын

@@Viper_75th_RR yeah but if you say that then your are just a hater

In my opinion, the Acolyte is terrible. But with everything in the world that’s going on right now are we really bullying others for having enjoyment of a show? I get it and I agree with plenty that the show and its writing are bad and completely botched in execution, but seriously the last thing we need is to have this stuff divide us. Thanks Carly!!!

@blankken8071

16 күн бұрын

Exactly. It truly is a fan film created by half fans half non fans with a wealthy budget, that’s all it is nothing more nothing less. And if your favorite Star Wars thing out there then good for you that’s fascinating and if you hate it you have a right too

@AKATenn

16 күн бұрын

The way I see it, the acolyte is finally opening people's eyes to what disney has been doing the last decade, and is actually brining the star wars community back together, lessening the divide, even if it is in dislike for disney.

@toddhoward2462

16 күн бұрын

Honestly if someone can find enjoyment in the Acolyte then good for them. I have no problem with that.

@doctorshutup9817

16 күн бұрын

The root cause of this is lack of respect for the product, not the person. The division will never end at this rate b/c the fans are not the ones creating it.

@AshanBhatoa

16 күн бұрын

I believes it's alright - I do not particularly understand the criticism, especially considering a good majority of it is near absurd. Nonetheless - agreed on the point on commentary.

Man she was reading the script HARD

@eddyrodriguez973

15 күн бұрын

🤣 big time

@onlyjuanhope

15 күн бұрын

What?

@SF-eo6xf

14 күн бұрын

Don't wanna miss out on this incredible invitations she is so thankful for, lol

@daurydavis3983

13 күн бұрын

Typical misogynistic crybabies

Umm honest criticism isnt "hate". Perhaps when you grow up you'll understand that

@carlyking

2 күн бұрын

I literally said that in the video. But OK. 😂

@mihaibalan2769

21 сағат бұрын

@@carlyking YOU may have said that. The creators of the show whose set you visited most definitely did not 😉

dear Carly I am 40 years old and I have been following Star Wars since I was 13 and I tell you that, with all due respect, I have the right to criticize what I want and like after having spent a good part of my life collecting, playing and following this franchise. maybe the truth is that it doesn't belong to me anymore, maybe in the end I just have to realize that it has never been as cool as I thought as a kid, moving forward in life, but I always have a little bitterness in seeing what it is becoming. so with all due respect ladies and gentlemen if this is the direction taken by SW I get off the train, good continuation. Small clarification: I have nothing against the series the acolyte at a canon level, the problem is that the story itself does not hold up, it is not engaging, there is no tension or mystery, the characters make choices because they follow a script, there is no logic. maybe if it were a cartoon for children maybe it would make sense, but take away the lightsabers and maybe you will see that in that series the story does not make sense.

@sternfirei8499

5 күн бұрын

She was not saying you had no right to criticize it, she wasn't even defending acolyte, she simply was saying she loves the show and she has every right to enjoy the show without the overwhelming majority of people who dislike it telling her otherwise and how she should feel. I don't understand why that's so hard for conservatives to swallow. You have the right to feel the way you do, and she has the right to feel the way she does.

@oberlanderguidaturistica4354

5 күн бұрын

@@sternfirei8499 Of course, you have the right to say what you want, I have the right to answer what I want. I don't understand what's so difficult to understand. That said, I'm not a "conservative", just a person who appreciates a well-written story.

@Kobozo375

4 күн бұрын

She's saying you're fully welcome to criticize the show regardless of how long you've been a fan or how much you know, but no one has the right to personally attack others for holding the opposite opinion.

As much as I hate some projects, I will never hate those who love those projects

@tomasdaman2

16 күн бұрын

Real, true. Real AND TRUE!

@BrennonA

16 күн бұрын

Amen

@kumagorong

16 күн бұрын

Great way to say it! imho, I also believe, "you can hate the artist, but know that a lot of people benefitted from the art."

@mariolaudato8019

16 күн бұрын

i agree even though i don't like the show i will respect those who like it

@Kikoama

16 күн бұрын

Good for you, I will continue to absolutely hate this woman.

The Schwartz is weak with this one.

The Acolyte is a disaster every other Star Wars project has carefully been crafted around everything canon even though they may have been poorly executed shows ,still nothing broke canon like this . The storytelling is horrendous, very few feel connected to it maybe you feel “included” in the show because you got to watch it early but for most of us regs this show is a disgrace to Georges Star Wars and this is the feedback that has been building since the sequels.

I dislike acolyte… and was attacked for my opinion… it happens both ways…

@jamiestar3362

13 күн бұрын

I had people telling me to go die simply for saying it didn’t enjoy it

@MiguelPais

12 күн бұрын

Exactly, and either way is wrong.

@JustinHart-ep5kk

11 күн бұрын

It’s a shame that ppl can behave so disrespectfully to each over whether a show was good or not

@jamiestar3362

11 күн бұрын

@@JustinHart-ep5kk agreed I really just don’t see the need to attack people for an opinion… I had to block the words on twitter cause it was making me feel ill… no fandom should be like this

@TheDCbiz

11 күн бұрын

Who attacked you?

It's not hate, just because you say something is the most awful thing to ever exist. It's legitimately offered opinion. The show is so horribly awfully written, that kinder gardeners could have done a better job. Stop gaslighting people by using words like "hate".

@TheMeep27mc

12 күн бұрын

I disagree with that option

@jackharrington697

8 күн бұрын

I was just going say this thank you

If you don't want to talk about the things you don't like about Disney stories (NOT REAL SW) that proves what u're da problem. And you ready to sweep it under the rug instead of actually cleaning it up. You never been a CREATOR so how would you like if somebody can change something you created, spending years and decades working on just to be changed in a snap of a blink of an eye. And use your creation or children (if u're the individual goes that deep) as political vises to spread propaganda, the acolyte is a abomination because it's completely unrecognizable it doesn't respect George Lucas creation. U're right SW isn't dead, IT'S beyond DEAD. Just admit you don't care for the Lore because it's obviously you don't can't even tell Yoda's species, he's not a FROG🤦🏽. 0:34 and you just admitted you go to the events.. Humm... I wonder why "it couldn't be I say EVERYTHING POSITIVE about the show couldn't be that" and what ticks me off the most you using your video to emotionally manipulate. Grace Randolph 2.0 y'all.

We can disagree on disney star wars content but gives no one the right to bully and attack each other online about this show but it happens on both ends of the star wars community itself, disney star wars fans and fans from the prequels and the originals. The reasons why the acolyte breaks the star wars canon can be found below and other reasons why this show does not work as a star wars project that is meant to be set 100 years before the phantom menace. 1: the show rewrites what the force is and tries to canonise it as a thread that witches can pluck and pull on. 2: the witches concived the main two twin characters even though it should be impossible to do since no being can create a being from the force unless that character is this god like being. The reason why Anakin was concieved by the force is because plaguies tried to create the ultimate dark side entity and the force basically said that plaguies can't do that and so the force itself answered back by creating Anakin Skywalker. 3: Ki Adi Mundi isn't supposed to be in this show since he says in the phantom menace that the sith haven't been seen in a thousand years . 4: the creators of the acolyte show are trying to interject their political views regarding pronouns and lgbtq themes that don't need to be there at all and brought to the forefront of the story. 5: the story is very predictable and boring where fans knew who the sith's identity was before episode 5 came out. 6: the wookie jedi was clickbaited by showing us that he was using a lightsaber to fight someone but in episode 4 he dies. 7: in multiple interviews the cast and Leslye Headland have said very contraversial things that made fans hate what the acoltye show was going to be about such as Leslye stating that star wars is gay when it isn't and stating that C3PO and R2-D2 are basically a gay couple which they're not coz they're droids, they are machinery with no gender attached to them. 8: the writers who wrote the episodes for this show have come out and said that they didn't even know what star wars is. 9: the production of the show looks very cheap from the sets to the costume design and looks very fanmade and not an official star wars product that had a massive budget behind it. 10: the episode lengths are too short and it feels like the story is rushing its way through to the climax and ending abruptly. A 30 minute runtime for each episode is not a good choice for any show like this whether it's star wars or not. These are my points from what i have seen from this show and the interviews surrounding the show itself so do not come and attack me and call me everything under the sun simply because i don't like the acolyte show. When it premiered i gave it the benefit of the doubt and hoped that it was good but after i watched those two episodes of the show, i was immediately turned off by the show and it did not get me invested in the characters, the story and what was at stake. This is CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM, and not unnessecery hate for this show. If you don't like my points on addressing why this show is bad and if you call me a "toxic fan", fine i don't care. I am simply addressing things from the acolyte show and interviews surrounding the show itself that need to be looked at with an unbiased point of view. If you like the show, more power to you and i encourage you to keep enjoying it but these are the issues that are known surrounding the acolyte. This show and disney star wars itself isn't building off on what George has created, it is frankly destroying the franchise and retoconning things that are clearly established in the main 6 star wars films created by the creator of star wars being George Lucas. This amount of toxicity and hate in the star wars community didn't start with the fans to a certain degree but it mainly started with Disney themselves causing the toxicity and hatred to happen in the star wars fandom. Before George sold star wars to disney, the community was diverse and accepted everyone in all categories gay, black, straight, trans, etc. But now Disney are the ones who are intentionally causing the toxicity labeling and antagonising star wars fans as "toxic" and every other slur and hateful comment that you can think of.

You have to be kidding me....the Acolyte team said they want to change George Lucas's vision and lore. They have no respect. Disney even threw Lucas's treatment of the sequels out the window. Yeah, right compelling stories. I call BS.

@vert2552

11 күн бұрын

my fav part is still R2D2 and C3PO being gay for each other

@andrewmb9982

11 күн бұрын

@@vert2552 when was this said?

@vert2552

11 күн бұрын

@@andrewmb9982 in one of the interviews

@andrewmb9982

11 күн бұрын

@@vert2552 you talking about when she said r2d2 was a lesbian?

@CMONCMON007

11 күн бұрын

@@vert2552 ah yes very compelling storytelling

My issue with Disney is that they block all criticism they get by calling people racist or bigots , it funny bc I’m half black

@vehnashur2771

9 күн бұрын

They use dog whistle terms to indicate the racism and bigotry. An example is calling a black actress a DEI hire. Overall, bigots used to say "affirmative action hires" before that. They blend their bigotry with some legitemate criticisms. It's like a liar who tells some truths. That's how I see it at least.

The fandom can definitely be toxic. But I think Disney has really tainted the franchise over the past 10+ years. But that doesn't mean we should attack those who enjoy the stuff Disney puts out. Ofc we who don't like it should obviously voice our opinions, but respectfully

@belxander293

16 күн бұрын

Not liking something bad doesn't make you toxic... (and yes, we have the right to say that something is bad if it is so low) We need to stop using these shortcuts. If 80% of viewers don't like it, it's because there is a much deeper problem in the series! (I'm not saying that there are no toxic people at all, but it's a minority, the majority of people who don't like The Acolyte are just really very disappointed and sad with the result and expected something else!)

@joncruiser1

16 күн бұрын

@darkwingduck3477 But isn't that sentiment "toxic people" just dividing us anyway? I mean, if someone makes 100 videos about a particular subject (in this case the acolyte) does that mean that they're opinions worth scales down with each consecutive video? Can he, or anyone, not be allowed to make as many points as he wants about a show. Another glaring omission is that Ryan (like Carly) has a fan base and a brand that they are trying to stay consistent with. That is just good business. So my point is, if Ryan is making "hate videos" that's because there is a market for it. You can throw your own personal moral and ethics at me about how people like me are the problem but end of the day....

@eloyvv

16 күн бұрын

@darkwingduck3477 tbf i can make 20 videos about the show to its that incredibly bad but... they should not attack the actors... even tho some of them have made some shocking comments.

@ibrahimasscandy1849

16 күн бұрын

@@joncruiser1 He gets physically aroused whenever he has the chance to type 'toxic' and 'hate/haters'.

@Flettwin

16 күн бұрын

I think it’s also important to realise that while Disney made release date and director decisions that negatively impacted the Sequel Trilogy, they don’t control the creative side of Lucasfilm the way a lot of fans seem to think. Yes they ultimately have to sign off on scripts, but Filoni and others have said there’s no one really looking over Lucasfilm’s shoulder when they create. As long as there’s stuff that can be turned into toys & a new Star Wars food Disney can sell at Disneyland, Lucasfilm are free to pursue any projects. Disney is more like the network Lucasfilm now exclusively makes content for, it’s not some weird shady agenda-driven puppeteer of the creative side of the franchise. Lucasfilm still make Star Wars.

Respectfully, you do realize all those events, early screenings and round tables you have been able to attend are intended by Disney to influence your opinion?

@TorchOnTarget

12 күн бұрын

Being wined and dined by Disney = this type of videos. Every time. Not a single person who gets invited to these events will ever say a negative thing about the show, so they get invited to the next.

@Cailus3542

12 күн бұрын

Carly isn't defending her opinion or declaring herself the ultimate arbiter on artistic quality. She's saying "hey, please stop attacking people for having a different opinion". We're not talking about politics, religion or ethics. We're talking about space wizards, for heaven's sake. People shouldn't be shamed or bullied just because they like or dislike Acolyte. As an aside: I am enjoying Acolyte. Not as much as I'd hoped, but I like it so far. Many people do. Tragically. Disney isn't bribing every single one of us to say this.

@TorchOnTarget

12 күн бұрын

@@Cailus3542 of course they aren’t bribing as many people. The viewership numbers are lower than any other show they’ve put out and the reviews are abysmal.

@christopherhindle8371

11 күн бұрын

Disney is directly and indirectly dangling shiny things & threats in front of Carly to get her to behave like one of their monkeys.

@christopherhindle8371

11 күн бұрын

​@@Cailus3542She really isn't.

F Disney.

Still hate this person who is helping to ruin Star Wars.

I honestly think that Star Wars is the most toxic fandom right now. I've never seen so many shitstorms come out of a single fandom, and it's just happening more and more often. It's embarrassing, man.

@randomiser2267

16 күн бұрын

Cope

@Bread_LM

16 күн бұрын

@@randomiser2267 See, you're kinda just proving my point.

@DarksideGmss0513

15 күн бұрын

I agree. And it's not a new thing either. This has been a thing since 1999 when the prequels came out. And it's just slowly gotten worse over the years.

@thecrimsomcardyugioh9810

9 күн бұрын

It’s Disney not the fans lol. When all the movies and lore have told you during the Jedi reign of power the sith had been “extinct” for millennia! Now idk 8 Jedis see a random sith for the first time in hundreds and hundreds of years! It’s lore breaking, this show breaks the movies and books. Palpatine, carefully hides, there’s even a story of Darth Maul using his powers in the underground of the Republic homeworld and is threatened by his master, that if he reveals himself or uses the dark side of the force again he’d kill him himsef, so it was a long drawn out slow plan. There’s no mention of any other sith during the peace time, this show just broke all that lore, wether he’s a real sith or not( I also don’t see how he could obtain a red crystal without being a sith) all of the prequels fall apart the Jedi now know the sith are back and would have the defense up. This show changes the entire 6 star war movies, Palpatine would’ve been found out by the Jedi, Anakin would never become darth Vader, Luke is never born. That’s why people have a problem with this show, this isn’t marvel there aren’t different dimensions of the same planets over and over. I think some fans can be overly rude but this show, shows Disney doesn’t care about the building blocks Star Wars was built off and the reason it has the HUGE fan base it has. You can’t just make shows during canon timelines and break lore, a small lore break is fine but this is a HUGE lore break.

@fnspidey3825

Күн бұрын

toxic?: it's the product that disney is producing

There will be review bombers, review boosters, etc. But the vast majority are the fans who have opinions.

"I'm a woman, I wear makeup, and I like Star Wars..." What genuine SW fan hates those things? Carrie FIsher, Natalie Portman, Rosario Dawson....I think those people fit the same criteria. Beloved. Just saying.

@SabatSch95

16 күн бұрын

Carly is playing the victim. All of those things are precisely WHY she got popularity in the first place.

@onlyjuanhope

15 күн бұрын

@@SabatSch95 telling her that she is playing the victim is wild.

@SabatSch95

15 күн бұрын

@@onlyjuanhope Telling the truth is wild? Why, yes... in this new age of hateful sycophants, doing something like telling the truth is indeed considered outrageous.

@gabebtv

15 күн бұрын

@@SabatSch95 People see that and then stereotype her and sent distasteful messages. That's the issue. Very arrogant of you to think so one dimensioned while claiming to be a "truth teller." Stating your opinion is not "truth telling." Are you monitoring her channel for hate comments 24/7? Reading her DM's? There for all of her interactions with fans in person? If the answer to that is no then I suggest you humble yourself, all knowing "truth teller"

@marcomaceo3559

15 күн бұрын

​@@gabebtvthe show is garbage, she knows it. She's doing this video response to get by with lucasfilm. Which is fine, protect the nest egg if you have to. But we all know the truth, and trying to shame us into liking this show won't work.

Well ultimately the TV ratings and the sales of the Acolyte toys / merchandise will have the final say on what people really think about this show.

@GamesandNonsenseUnleashed

14 күн бұрын

And that has already started to speak volumes. :)

@paulbinder7434

12 күн бұрын

This is actually very funny to me in that so many people "hate-watching" that they only are supporting the show for another season. I like the show...but if I did not...I would just not watch it.

@famousmortimer7933

7 күн бұрын

Nobody asked what you would do. People can watch the show for good reasons, bad reasons, or no reason at all.

We love talk about star wars so much it change our lifes

This girl is such a politician

@D_Cali_Life

5 күн бұрын

Most pretty girls are. That’s why they get views

Disliking something and critique are not hate.

@--mr4yo

14 күн бұрын

You're completely ignoring the issue.

@SabatSch95

13 күн бұрын

@@--mr4yo Bc there is NO ISSUE. Every time ppl ask for proof of this epidemic of "hate", nothing gets provided... bc it isn't happening.

@noahH3379

13 күн бұрын

If u say so

@daurydavis3983

13 күн бұрын

It is though

@liamscorgie8859

13 күн бұрын

She clearly stated that constructive criticism is valid… hate is not. You just repeated exactly what she said in a different way lol

I don't understanding hating people for the media they enjoy. Especially Star Wars. I have a lot of Disney Star Wars I love, and a lot I really dislike - but that's my own personal business. And if someone loves projects I hate - and it brings them joy and escapism and hope - more power to them. My home page is full of channels attacking the acolyte. I haven't seen it, so I can't judge it either way - but it gets ridiculous. I've started hiding channels that are clearly just rage baiting or overly negative all the time to hopefully fix my home page suggestions. Sadly negativity and anger sell better than good news sometimes... but it's great you keep it positive here and are finding success!

@cyanidesyn123

9 күн бұрын

I agree. Literally everything I see coming up about the acolyte is big channels being nasty about the show and the people involved and Im positive a lot of that is because they get more interaction on negative content than positive. Personally I'm enjoying the show, it's up and down but it's good and Qimir is probably one of my top star wars villains after the last episode. Unfortunately these days anger and negativity sells, I'd respect these negative opinions more if they just had their title as a review without adding "yikes" and "star wars is dead" as click bait then just rant the whole time and actually just calmly explained what they did and didn't like. I've enjoyed aspects of every star wars movie and show and dislikes other aspects of all of them too. I remember everyone hating on the Phantom menace as a kid now they all praise the prequels and act like Disney is the worst

I felt like I’m being bullied by Lucas film. And honestly I feel like you are bulling me for not liking the bad writing and directing of this series. I’ll unsubscribe. It won’t do anything to you and I hope you continue to enjoy what you like i]and I’ll keep liking what I like. Have a good evening.

Shills are people who get perks like you admittedly did for the Acolyte show. Star Wars Theory (Biggest SW YT) has not, and he appears to stand on business. It's not about YOU and is more about Modern Society (Values, Morality) that have been Lost!!!🤔

Sorry but acolyte is trash 🗑️

I would like to be positive about Disney Starwars, but I'm not getting Free Disney SW stuff yet 😠 I agree on not bashing artists, but the showrunner is bashing us for not liking her terrible show... She is more concerned about having gay people and struggling powerful women to show off, than actual storytelling. Also, didnt you hear? Disney just got leaked for being racist as f

I love Star Wars not matter what, nothing will ever change that, as a 7 year old child watched episode IV for the first time and loved it, after the 3 movies there was a period without any future to star was and hated those days, now that Disney is giving shows back to back, im in heaven, SW makes me so happy, that will never change. Carly i love your content and share the happiness of Star Wars. Lets celebrate Star Wars for the happiness it brings.

@shimik11

16 күн бұрын

Disney star wats is the farthest thing its ever been from star wars is. They're literally pumping out garbage since mando season 2...

@dbks_

13 күн бұрын

Agreed!

@fnspidey3825

Күн бұрын

cringe

don't worry, im sure disney will still invite you to their parties

I gotta ask, what exactly is there about the acolyte that is genuinely enjoyable? IMO the writing is the worst of any Disney star wars project, the characters are shallow/1 dimensional and forgettable, and the show itself feels more like a targeted bate for certain demographics rather than a plausible/satisfying expansion of the already existing cannon as a whole and the star wars universe overall. As a lifelong fan of the franchise, the acolyte seems to be little more than a really bad parody of what star wars should be, which thus gives the impression of making a mockery of what paved the way to give this show it’s lofty platform and of the respectful and dedicated fans already committed to anything that is “good” star wars. But I’m more than willing to admit I’m missing something here, so if you actually enjoy the acolyte then please fill me in as to why. What makes this show so good in your opinion? Why should I consider this story “good” star wars media rather than simply a poorly executed diversity showcase/cash grab? Why/how/when are characters or their motivations compelling? How does the overall plot contribute meaningfully to existing cannon excluding the clickbaity identity politics that ensnare every aspect of this show? This is a desperate cry for help so please, please help me understand.

@ThePrototypexx

10 күн бұрын

based.

@andrewvidmar3488

8 күн бұрын

thats your opinion i like the characters and actors and the fighting is awesome the only thing i didnt like is moss dying in the first 5 minutes otherwise it is good to me i think book of boba fett is alot worst and i still loved that just like i liked the 2017 justice league movie but loved the zack snyder version same with the last of us part 2 and the first suicide squad as well but your entitled to your own opinion but dont talk like your opinion is fact

@therealdaredevil7504

7 күн бұрын

@andrew vidnar no one is presenting their opinion as fact, open your eyes and read my original comment but please don’t regurgitate an answer laced with your narrative and try to attack me with it. I’ve noticed you didn’t or couldn’t answer any of my questions, you just said I like this and that because its cool I guess. You’ve provided no explanation as to why or why you think I should change my mind about the acolyte. Book of Boba wasn’t great, but I’d still much rather watch that than this dumpster fire that seemingly no one can adequately or rationally defend. I do not fault you for enjoying the acolyte at all, everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but I’m desperate to know why you do or what fans of the show find so “good” about it. I would like to establish a respectful discourse where we can discuss these things, but I’m also worried that few people, if any, will be able to take part in such a discussion without presenting opinions as fact (as you say), getting angry at not being 100% agreed with, or even being able to provide evidence that supports their own claims. If you feel you can handle these parameters then I welcome your incites eagerly, but if you’re gonna continue to conduct yourself in the manner of your initial response then this is where we must agree to disagree and part ways.

@andrewvidmar3488

7 күн бұрын

@@therealdaredevil7504 i said i like the dialog the fighting scenes are awesome the SFX are good and how you presented everything you think is wrong with the series how you said made it sound like factbut like i said the only that i hated about it so far is when they killed carrie anne moss so early maybe im not so specific at everything about it and enjoy it but its ok alot of stuff i love and the majority of people hated it but i dont care the majority of critics and people on youtube just tear down movies, tv shows or videogames just because they can

Why is that when creators/actors who have ties to Star Wars/Disney always seem to only talk about one side of the hate? There are people on both sides doing this. One group calling people fake fans or shills for enjoying it AND the other group calling those who don’t like it xenophobic, homophobic, and afraid of women in Star Wars. That’s what makes this video hard to take seriously. Obviously the vast majority of people agree with you and are anti hate, but when you only talk about one side of the hate in your video, it can’t help but feel intentional. Both sides need to be equally brought into the light

@4KMediaGuy

15 күн бұрын

She cant she will lose her access to disney events.

@DarksideGmss0513

15 күн бұрын

Cuz that's the only side of the hate that she's seen she's not seeing the other side. Because she's been harassed by that side.

@Tri-FectaDi-Recta

15 күн бұрын

Respectfully...... Forget disney! 👎🏼🙄🤣​@@4KMediaGuy

@onlyjuanhope

15 күн бұрын

She literally said both sides. Did you not hear it?

@rhysespeace

15 күн бұрын

@@onlyjuanhope no......they didn't, they refused to

Consider this: if we don’t hold creators accountable for producing subpar movies or stories, will the quality improve? No, it will likely deteriorate. I have no issue with anyone genuinely enjoying such content. If you truly like it, that’s perfectly acceptable. However, if your appreciation stems from ulterior motives-such as wanting to stay on Disney’s invite list for premieres or to receive free merchandise-then your loyalty has essentially been bought. I am not accusing anyone in particular, but this seems to be a trend with the positive reviews for “Acolyte,” given the noticeable disparity between audience and critic opinions. It’s important to note that neither supporters nor detractors should be subjected to hate or name-calling. The key point is that it’s acceptable for most people not to be fans of this new Disney Star Wars. The only reason many continue to engage with it is their love for what George Lucas originally created. They hope for improvements, which is why they keep watching and holding on, despite the increasing difficulty of being labeled for not liking the content. It certainly doesn’t warrant Amandla releasing a diss track, nor should Kathleen Kennedy and Disney blame fans for their dissatisfaction with the product. I understand their motive is to safeguard profit margins, but in doing so, they fail to learn from their mistakes and continue to inject politics and real-world issues into a galaxy meant to be far, far away. Movies should serve as an escape. If you don’t hold them accountable, you are essentially telling them it is acceptable to release poorly written stories. You are saying, “just create it, and I’ll consume.” While it may be fine to just say, “I don’t talk about what I don’t like,” what you are doing is not holding them accountable. When you don’t discuss something, people (at Lucasfilm) may think, “everything is fine here, situation normal,” when that is clearly not the case. You need to talk about these things and discuss-not hate, not scream and yell at each other, and this goes for both sides. But discuss. I had a discussion with someone who likes “Acolyte,” and even they said Mae’s turn in Episode 4 came out of nowhere. Her personality was set. Do people’s personalities you know in your personal life change just like that? No, you don’t see that. That person saw the writing wasn’t perfect but failed to say anything about it because of how they would be judged by some of their other friends who like it. Sometimes, you can’t just bury your head in the sand; you need to speak up. Did we call each other names? No, we had an interesting, non-heated discussion about it and other scenes. We can all have different opinions, and that’s okay. Ultimately, our discussions, critiques, and diverse perspectives can help foster a creative environment where better stories are told, and everyone can enjoy the magic of movies. By holding Disney Lucasfilm accountable, we encourage them to strive for excellence, leading to richer, more captivating narratives that honor the legacy of the stories we all love. If we don’t, we risk being given poorly written content. You may think I am wrong and that’s fine. But heed this warning, would you like it to get worse? Worse leads to not being funded anymore if it looses too much money, worse leads to this franchise dying. Which is something I am sure no one is wishing for. Or maybe people are at this point, which should be even scarier…

Yeah, when you say your channel or platform is all about positivity and not negativity that can be interpreted as not acknowledging constructive criticism when good points are made.

Getting official invites to events huh? we know who can’t relate to that, cough cough Star Wars theory cough ack.

@KingMeneldil

6 күн бұрын

Is she still friends with Theory?

@paulmikkeltaka102

5 күн бұрын

@@KingMeneldil Not with a shill and She Blocked him..

@KingMeneldil

4 күн бұрын

@@paulmikkeltaka102 For real?

@paulmikkeltaka102

4 күн бұрын

@@KingMeneldil Yea She also called him names which I will not go to detail here.

It's been crazy toxic both ways I've never seen so many people attack people's character and obssessively post about influencers and call them bigots and hate anyone voicing a disappointment in the writing.

@foxfire1112

16 күн бұрын

I mean she started this that people who are negative are because she wears makeup. It seems to be a narrative around this show

@foxfire1112

16 күн бұрын

@darkwingduck3477 Of course there are more the show is awful. Having an opinion that a bad show is bad doesn't mean you're sexist, racist, etc. It's such a lazy conclusion. Saying there's more of one thing doesn't make the other thing non existence

@SPIKER1880

16 күн бұрын

@@foxfire1112 there were 15 fouls by Team A, and 2 fouls by Team B. 'It's been crazy rough both ways! players on both teams were committing fouls!' No, don't try to say Team A committed more fouls! that doesn't make sense! the important point is both teams were doing it! /sarcasm

@Cailus3542

15 күн бұрын

​@@foxfire1112 YOU think that the show is awful. You. Does that make you the grand arbiter of artistic quality? Does that mean that other people are not permitted to enjoy something that you have deemed to be bad?

@foxfire1112

15 күн бұрын

@@Cailus3542 you seriously think it's just me? Really? Is your head in the sand? Ok cool, good luck with you waiting for a season 2

We gotta debate whats good for starwars. Most people who actually like starwars and want to fix the shitty mess its in wont just "hate" on people who like this show, they will debate them in good faith. Also 'respect' is a word with alot of debates on its semantics. We gotta be careful that we arent TONE policing.

Please ban me before I say something negative about this terrible writing. This garbage isnt star wars anymore. Oops too late ✌️

When you're a shill without saying you're a shill basically

@joelb5391

5 күн бұрын

Tell me you didn't watch the video without telling me you didn't watch the video.

@dicedoom7162

4 күн бұрын

@@joelb5391 she is a shill

@joelb5391

4 күн бұрын

@@dicedoom7162 I mean you could say "Hammers are made of steel" and it would have just as little to do with this video.

I’ve notice all the KZreadrs defending this show are people who were invited to Lucasfilms and premieres I get it you gotta do what you gotta do

@SecondBreakfastAndThreeH-zo3jp

13 күн бұрын

Star Wars Explained and Kyle Katarn especially. Kyle Katarn is the definition of a shill. Dude’s gone years trashing and bullying Star Wars Theory on Twitter/X, he then gets bought off by Lucasfilm despite not even having 50k subscribers, and now he’s crying victim because his new reaction uploads are getting ratio’d like 1k likes to 3k dislikes. He was also dumb enough to post a video on his channel a few weeks ago with a thumbnail of all of these KZreadrs in a group photo with Leslye Headland and Filoni during “The Acolye Roundtable” at Lucasfilm. And of course not one of these KZreadrs has criticized the show. Meanwhile, Star Wars Theory’s channel is at an all-time high with views, new subscriber count, likes, and popularity. Star Wars is now at a “pick a side” state, and it’s obvious that one side is winning while the other is sinking like a ship.

@MysticTroll

12 күн бұрын

I'm subscribed to SWT and a member, and I like aspects of the Acolyte. I am literally Chaotic Neutral.

@kjata090

12 күн бұрын

or they actively are promoting a positive community and Lucasfilm likes that and wants to associate with people who aren't terrible, arrogant people. Star wars theory is the MAGA idiots of star wars community.

Carly saying SW is male dominated is untrue and very sexist. I initially started watching Carly's channel because I thought it was awesome how she felt about SW. I was beyond hyped to see how Rey's sequels would pan out and the fact they were making new Star Wars movies back in 2013. Alas, I and many other people were completely disappointed and extremely let down on how bad the sequels ultimately came to be. The lack of vision, writing and communication between Rian Johnson and J.J. Abrams is widely known facts. I knew there was a giant problem at Disney when I saw "the force is female" shirt Kathleen Kennedy wore in that famous picture. SW was never about a single race, size or gender. It was already all inclusive. The Acolyte and most of what Disney has done with SW feels irreversibly cheap and horribly produced. SW is the Bentley of cinema and deserves the time and preparation it needs to become something extra. I am honestly sick of the gender war that Kathleen Kennedy and Disney have clearly started. This comment was originally deleted about a day ago and I honestly can't believe that happened. Why did you delete this comment, Carly? That was completely wrong and you know it. Someone clearly doesn't like to see facts in their comment section.

@carlyking

14 күн бұрын

I never said that, bud. Also, never deleted your comment. However, KZread immediately flags any comments that seem hateful, etc.

@KniveLing

14 күн бұрын

@@carlyking Literally said nothing hateful and the comment was not immediately removed. SW is not male dominated, by the way. That's mad sexist and hateful to say.

@carlyking

13 күн бұрын

It is highly male dominated, unfortunately. That’s just facts. Of course, there are female fans. and a lot of them! But it is a male dominated fanbase.

@KniveLing

13 күн бұрын

@@carlyking "Of course, there are female fans. and a lot of them!" - carlyking Yet the franchise and fanbase is male dominated. Hmmmm... Let's look at the current Disney SW content. - Rey sequels - Mandalorian season 3 and Bo Katan being the real Mandalorian the whole time - Ahsoka - The Acolyte - Most the showrunners and the boss of SW itself, Kathleen Kennedy - Princess Leia and Queen/Senator Padme Amidala - Some of my favorite lightsaber wielding characters, Asajj Ventress, Ahsoka, Shaak Ti, Aayla Secura, Princess Leia (Legends version, of course), Mara Jade (Legends), Barris Offee, Luminara Unduli, Yaddle, Kreia(KOTOR), Atris (KOTOR) and the list goes on. Wouldn't say Star Wars is male dominated at all. "Dominated" is sounding extremely hateful and sexist. I would say SW is more female focused currently. But that's just the difference in opinion, i guess.

@KniveLing

13 күн бұрын

@@WhiteLightning476 This is literally what I said when it was deleted. I am not BSing.

I mean Disney caters to you so you have to side with them

Harvey Weinstein’s side kick pissing on us, and Disney has you also trying to call their virtue signaling “rain.” It’s a bad show, dished out from a cradle to grave telecommunications monopoly, fake virtue signaling to make more money; that has spent 10 years retconning and ruining Star Wars. This is what happens when you give a beloved franchise to people to rewrite, who never watched the original movies or ever even opened a Star Wars books…you gotta be outside your mind if you think people are gonna roll over and let you and Disney gatekeep this crap anymore. I follow random people on tictoc with better lightsaber skills than anything Disney has produced.

This feedback seems very biased. How can one's opinion be unaffected while being included in the subject's marketing campaign/VIP treatment?

@notorioust792

11 күн бұрын

Exactly. She says “ nobody is paying me to like it “ riiiight

I personally feel like Star Wars just doesn’t feel like Star Wars anymore and the love I had for it is just not there anymore because of it doesn’t really feel like Star Wars I’m not sure really how to explain why I feel like this but that is how I feel

I enjoy watching Disney Star Wars shills like her getting triggered about toxic haters and then cry about it

How can you say “they want to build upon the rich story George already created” they literally retconned so many things that doesn’t respect the lore at all

@rajon94

10 күн бұрын

Yea she tried with that one 😂 They don't give a damn about George or his vision

@StarWarsThrowbacks

10 күн бұрын

But George never cared for the EU either. He’s stated he doesn’t consider that canon, and that was before 2012.

@ikevizual6969

10 күн бұрын

@@StarWarsThrowbacks that doesn’t mean you retcon things that were already established before to a fan base who knows the source material in and out but if that was the plan all along at least clarify that this story is separate from the cinematic universe but no it’s connected to George’s legacy… would you agree that if it’s not considered canon they should have at least stated that?

@ikevizual6969

10 күн бұрын

@@rajon94 frfr look at how they massacred mundi 😭 that was a disgrace on its own bruh

@PortugueseBadman

8 күн бұрын

@@StarWarsThrowbacks At least he didn't go out of his way to destroy it

Thank you for making this video! Before I started making my own content, I was watching other creators & it was around the time of the Sequel Trilogy that I realized "those" same creators were making me not like Star Wars... something I've loved since I was 6 years old seeing TPM for the first time! It's been insane just how much I've grown to enjoy & appreciate things in Star Wars I probably wouldn't have before, while I was actively watching "those" creators tell me everything that was WRONG with these new projects & that's exactly what eventually made me unsubscribe from them. The constant hate has only grown, to the point where people are literally making money off of it & at the end of the day, all I wanna do is talk about my love for the franchise. Sure there's still things I don't always vibe with, but why would I want to focus on those things? I could list off so many Star Wars quotes that embody this exact sentiment 😂 I'm so thankful for the positive forces in our community & our shared love of the galaxy far, far away... & clearly we need to be more vocal about it. Star Wars is for everyone, but hate has no place in this fandom 🖤

Im sorry, I just dont believe most people who say they love the Acolyte. Its Witcher Origins bad. Also, you have it backwards, Star Wars fans that dont like Disney SW are called bigots and racist, for the sole reason of saying it isnt good. In contrast, the House of Dragon is led by two female actresses and has diversity without making it about current times. No one complains about it because its good. Disney has failed Star Wars in an unbelievable way, starting with the sequel trilogy. Rogue One was ok good, and so was Andor, but those are not our traditional Star Wars. Then only some of Mando was pretty good. They had Ewan for Obi One, and they seriously dropped the ball with it. Its just crazy that it didnt get a big budget with better actors and writers. That can be said for nearly everything they've done

Im a SW fan for 32 years now and Ive been called all names under the sun for not liking trash Disney Star Wars. By the very people now pretend to be offended and cry being called a shill and say "Star Wars is for everyone".

@HeyItsRicki85

6 күн бұрын

And she sadly won't address comments like yours but still comes in to heart the ones that kiss her ass.

That's a lot of words. The show is still shit.

@ItDaBiz

12 күн бұрын

You were also literally an access media shill. People are sick of paid positive opinions

@christyskinner2890

9 күн бұрын

If you don’t like Star Wars, then, why don’t you just leave?

@ItDaBiz

9 күн бұрын

@christyskinner2890 I love Star Wars. But that doesn't mean I'm gonna swallow this CW tier shit that Disney keep foisting on us. The show is still shit.

@redvitproductions2829

11 сағат бұрын

Can you prove she's being paid for this?

@ItDaBiz

11 сағат бұрын

@redvitproductions2829 She's access media, having access to the first four episodes in advance. The only way you keep that title is by only saying good things about the show. Ergo, access media shill.

There is something for everyone in Star Wars. If you don't like a certain project, then it just isn't for you and that's fine. Someone might like that project and it's okay, for example. The Acolyte could easily be the first Star Wars project that children are seeing. If that's how they get introduced into this franchise and love Star Wars for it, then that's awesome and that's. Hating and attacking people based on their opinions is the exact opposite of what Star Wars is about. Keep your head up, Carly! Sam Witwer said it best. "Debate it, please debate it, but the moment you start getting personal and insulting people is when you really don't deserve to call yourself a fan of this franchise."

@carlyking

16 күн бұрын

Sam Witwer always says it best 💯🐐

@CantinaTalkSW

16 күн бұрын

@@carlyking that he does! 🐐

@Dang00TheAlienIAmTheRealOne

14 күн бұрын

Are kids even watching Star Wars now? None of my younger cousins give a flying fuck about it 😂

@CantinaTalkSW

14 күн бұрын

@@Dang00TheAlienIAmTheRealOne there are easily kids still watching Star Wars. Your cousins might not be, but others are.

@Dang00TheAlienIAmTheRealOne

14 күн бұрын

@@CantinaTalkSW that’s fair

As an SG member I dress up in kit choreograph duels, and entertain, I love Star Wars and everything about it I wouldn't have joined if I didn't. I personally dis like most of what Disney has done but its getting out of hand with recent events. ill never stop loving and devoting time to SG because of words and people. but yeah i really do not understand what is happening, it feels political and has become a disaster.

Thank you Carly speaking your truth. Being a dad I appreciate your work and in addition I know you’re a safe place for my two daughters to also appreciate. They only recently watched the 1st 3 movies and have become massive fans. It’s a comfort to know that they have a positive, female creative such as your self to identify with. Thank you.

You don’t like to talk about “the things you don’t like” as it could lead to you losing whatever privileges, access and free stuff you get. Less than a minute from saying you don’t get paid you talk about being invited to the acolyte round table. There is more to payment than money, but I suspect you know that very well.

@fnspidey3825

Күн бұрын

that sealed the video for me right there.

When I was a kid I got beat up and shoved into lockers because I read Star Wars books and always wore Star Wars shirts. Then I went to my first comic con and I realized I wasn’t alone. It’s the best community to be a part of regardless of what creed or side you identify with! Thank you for having us in part of your community Carly! I appreciate you! May the force be with you always! This is the way!

@punk_nugget

16 күн бұрын

may the force be with you.

@Kastle9498

16 күн бұрын

Dam you got lockers in school? I had coat hangers and little boxs for lockers

@christopherhindle8371

16 күн бұрын

The irony is that every kid on the planet liked Star Wars and every kid on the planet got into a fight with someone stronger than him or her.

@SoulSniperEdits

16 күн бұрын

Are u gen X? For whatever reason it was weird to like “nerdy” things back then but yeah that makes no fucking sense, liking star wars like that isn’t even weird, like at all…

@JustinJossart

14 күн бұрын

You do realize that this chick was one of the ones that made fun of people like us, right? She was out there banging the football players that shoved you into lockers and then laughing about it.

I came across your channel when looking for an obi-ani tutorial and I subscribed to your channel instantly cause now I know I’m not the only woman that love StarWars! Thank you Carly for being a positive light in this community and may the force be with you.

As someone who’s always been a Star Wars fan but never got to deep into the lore. I watch all the live action stuff and have enjoyed it all. Hate to see the toxic stuff showing its head all the time. As you said, talk about what’s positive. May the force be with us all

"Fear leads to Anger, Anger leads to Hate, Hate… leads to suffering." -Yoda. I agree with all that you said. While I do not like the acolyte because of how it was written, It doesn't give a right about others to bully others just because one or another likes something others don't like. I used to make SWTOR videos and was sorta made fun of it. Didn't I care? Nope, I still enjoyed what I made, and still, to this day, I like Star Wars.

@fnspidey3825

Күн бұрын

the fact that anyone defending disney star wars is no real star wars fan and needs to be held accountable just like disney.

Its funny how LH KK AS are the ones calling 90+% of the original fans fake fans and payed shills, but are blaming the fans for saying it. Make it make sense?!?! Im pretty sure they call that projection.

It goes both ways. I wish you and Disney SW the best. But think of all the name calling that has come from Disney!!! If you don’t like it you’re racist, you’re homophobic or racist. Kennedy literally did an interview saying that a few weeks back. Name calling comes from Lucasfilm as well as the fans. I think the fans that do respond with respect want to be heard and see change. And they’re not getting it. Daisy Ridley seems very nice was fine as an actress in SW. But the character was dull and fans told Disney. So they decided to make a Rey movie and if you don’t like it the Disney says you hate women! One of the 2 stars from the Acolyte is out insulting!!!! I don’t know. Without fans there wouldn’t have ever been Star Wars. You’ve been blessed with a very successful KZread channel because of fans and I wish you the best! Don’t let Disney control you by offering you gifts! And if you really like the show then God Bless of course. I enjoyed Jedi Tales, Clone Wars and loved Rogue One that had a female lead. I’ve given up.

You be careful not to dislike any upcoming Star Wars projects, they might decide not to invite you to a future Star Wars celebration. Might I add, before I sound like a bigot or something, most of us don’t hate these things just because there is a woman are any diverse character, we just want a good story, for example have you seen Arcane (my favourite show of all time) it’s arguably even more diverse than the acolyte. Arcane has a female protagonist who is a brilliant likeable character who goes through struggles and huge character development, the whole show is amazing. I’m sorry, the acolyte just isn’t that… the action was cool though.

Agree on everybody getting along, and agreeing to disagree on what we like without hate, only two pieces of criticism- 1. When I said that the comment section of the last video had fake positive comments in it paid for by corpos, Carly responded as if I had said she was paid to give a fake review, I didn't, and ignored what I actually said, going "I have no idea where people are getting this idea" as if it isn't common public knowledge that studios pay for fake positive reviews comments etc 2. Review bombing. If you watch any popular review, like Charlies new video "Somehow it got worse", or go outside and ask the average person, it is clear the majority of people do not like the show, and that there was no 'review bombing', the reviews are just negative because most people do not like it. The opposite is true, the studio's are paying for positive reviews, this is not an opinion, this is a fact, it has been proven repeatedly. That said no hate for Carly or her community, if she says she wasn't paid for a positive review, I'll take her at her word, and if corpos are leaving fake comments, I'll assume they are doing that without her permission, but in the future be aware that if you collab with corpos they will do that to your comment section. ~Peace, Love, Unity, Respect

@Octaaf92

16 күн бұрын

I have a hard time telling if her opinion is sincere. Keep in mind that she gets invited to many Star Wars related events and gets many opportunities to meet cast members, directors etc. Im quite sure she realises that if she would get "negative", the door might get shut. So is it weird to think she might get paid for a positive review? Not really. Im not trying to blast her at all, but i do think its hard to stay 100% honest when you know certain people are watching your content.

@Piratequeen010156

15 күн бұрын

As I was reading the Acolyte reviews on Google, I was curious and clicked on the profiles of the first 20ish comments. Most all of them were accounts who have ONLY reviewed the Acolyte and/or other Disney films (strong indicator it's a Disney employee, even saw some pfp's with Disney shirts on...lol). There are also a good handful of SEO-boosting 5-star reviews littered with positive keyword vomit. No one wants to talk about that though. Without those forced reviews, the show would be below 1-star right now.

I respect your passion for spreading positivity and trying to make people be more joyful, but there needs to be people in communities to hold the studios to a standard and while some people go overboard, I believe most people are upset with the way Disney is treating Star Wars and that is how a consumer should act.

@talondiwisch5206

9 күн бұрын

95% of people go overboard. They might be more willing to listening to fans’ opinions if that wasn’t the case.

I'm an old school Star Wars fan, and I clicked on this mostly because I was liking that modern, clean, Star Wars themed office in your thumbnail😊. I really enjoyed this talk and you're absolutely correct, too much hatred directed towards something that's supposed to be full of positivity and fun. I'm enjoying The Acolyte. Is it perfect, no, no show or movie is. But I'm all for continuing the lore. New subscriber😊.

I agree to a certain extent. While whether liking the show or not is completely subjective, the quality is not. We need to show Disney we don't want this bs. Just look at the interviews and you'd see how out of touch and delusional these writers are. They are objectively ripping off the canon piece by piece. They retconned over half of the Universe and replaced it with this feminist political movement nobody cares about and nobody wants to see. I don't care if you're gay, black, female or not, I just want to watch good Star Wars content. They are NOT respecting the source material, they're actively framing George as this patriotic sexist bigot and blaming the fans as phobes for disliking their content. They're even changing their own canon! Half of the Ahsoka content had already been written and was just suddenly retconned lmao. Also 0 originality between the last couple of shows, most of them just copied the plots from other videogames and pasted them into Star Wars. It's just sad to be honest. Sure some parts of the stories might be good and all, but Lucasfilm is going down a very very dark path, same thing goes to Marvel. We don't want TV shows that extend the plot way more than it should be, we want good movies. Literally all we're asking for 😭🙏

Works both ways, why Tf is StarWarsTheory getting hate and threats for calling out clear issues and problems with and surrounding the series as well as Lucasfilm and how they’re handling Star Wars. Also these new writers don’t respect Star Wars and what it is at all, you’re either bought off of just ignorant because they are clearly only using the brand as an outlet for there own agenda and politics.

@SabatSch95

10 күн бұрын

Carly will never respond to this and it completely exposes her.. Why? Bc she's blocked SWT and called him a woman hater and bigot on numerous occasions. This proves that Carly thinks disliking this show or Disney SW is hatred and that any type of disapproval towards the political pandering that is OPENLY being pushed by the creatives is heresy and is perfectly fine to send death threats and obscene hatred. Carly has uplifted and agreed with and supported the very people who have done this repeatedly.

@V0cticl

9 күн бұрын

@@SabatSch95 exactly, these people aren’t fans, no matter how much they claim they are. They’re sellouts, plain and simple, purely because they want free stuff from Disney, or they’re just too stupid to actually notice anything wrong. Honestly exhausting having to see these people repeatedly run to the defence of Disney every time they make something shit - which is quite often nowadays.

Are you telling me with a straight face, that C-3PO is straight?

@JuicySmellit-hr6ep

16 күн бұрын

Apparently he(?)'s now been re-imagined as a (post-op) lesbian.

@daurydavis3983

13 күн бұрын

Jesus Christ y'all are unintelligent

@robert7984

13 күн бұрын

I guess having an English accent and using proper edict makes one GAY!

@fnspidey3825

Күн бұрын

he's a robot

What about the hate for 'not liking' these shows?...Or do we just not moan about it, because we've been getting it far worse for so long... I don't agree with abuse either way, but it's funny that I don't see SW Theory who pretty much lives and breathes Star Wars, crying about the stuff he's had to put up with (which is a lot worse). He's had to get on with it... I would say the abuse we get for not liking these shows, is worse, because we are being essentially told that we are not star wars fans (when some of us have been our whole lives and poured a lot of money into it). We also get told we're ists and phobes at every turn, you don't...and it's with no real evidence to prove it too, because there isn't any...that is defamation and putting a target on people's back... And It's like if somebody gets accused of being a racist now, even if not true, their reputation still takes a huge hit...and it's all down to people like the ones which like this show usually, who just believe and take in information without questioning it, headlines are more important than the actual stories to these people...they get off on hating and defamation it seems...and hypocritically, defend something that is doing the very thing they claim to not like (I mean Disney has become racist in itself, check the stories that are coming out at the moment) It's also funny that people who claim to be about liberalism, want to destroy anybody who has a different opinion to them now...they are now the masters at divide and conquer. But in terms of Star Wars, it's actually not worked, it's united us more, because we've had enough of crap content now and watching one of our most beloved franchises being destroyed unnecessarily and not being able to speak out about it... Honestly though, if you truly like this show and not just a shill for Disney or defending an agenda you tend to agree with, great, no problem with you...Just as you should have no problem with me disliking the show for the terrible writing, mistakes and biggest plot holes I've ever seen. Also, if nobody ever said anything when something was bad, you'd only ever have positive reviews and how would that ever help anything?

Just admit you cant critize the company you are directly influenced by. They fly You out, you meet the cast ect. No starwars fan is ok with what they are doing to the show. They literally are changing the time Mundi was born to fit him in the show & the writer admitted to not know he is the one that said “1000 years since sith siightings” . Everyone has a right to there opinion. But these writers are trying to group the dislike of the new series as some sort of “bigotry” when its just the lore that has so many holes to it, the acting isnt good and the story is bad.

@bigwhopper6501

15 күн бұрын

Exactly, she literally can't say anything bad about acolyte without having her access to lucasfilm revoked.

@trashboat4731

14 күн бұрын

I think the point to take away is don't take things too seriously or start taking things personal. Don't get upset if you hear someone saying they like something that you don't, Certainly don't harass or bully them for liking something. That being said the acolyte is a terrible show. I absolutely hate it. Bad story and no respect to lore.

Lucasfilm won't go after her, but they will target and blacklist others.... wonder why that is......

If people have a problem with others having a opinion on a show (Acolyte), you shouldn’t be on the internet when the show is literally that bad. Storytelling, characters, the writing, the directing etc is all horrible. Idc if the ppl who made this saying “oh they know Star Wars” when they clearly don’t, they probably lied in their reassume or bs their way into LucasFilm like Leslye. If you like the show, cool, as long as you’re ready to have examples as to why you like it. We have to have opinions, otherwise we’re just gonna keep getting crap like the Acolyte

There are things I dislike and like all across Star Wars. As a kid watching boba fett fall into the sarlac was very upsetting, his return in season 2 of Mando *chefs kiss. As for the acolyte, I have mixed feelings, there’s parts of it I’m like “that’s cool” and other parts I’m sorta “meh” about. In short, I agree with you. Enjoy the parts you like and it’s okay to dislike things, just don’t be toxic about it.

The assolyte

@ZacAttack98

10 күн бұрын

underrated comment xD

@ElAssoWipe-o

10 күн бұрын

The Lesolytes.