We Brought This Fish To America. Now We Can't Get Rid Of It
Earth Month from PBS Playlist: • Earth Month from PBS
The invasive Asian carp, once introduced as a solution, is now disrupting native fish species and shrinking their populations across rivers, streams, and lakes along the Mississippi River Basin. Join Shane as he visits a safeguarded battlefront in a laboratory, gears up for an exhilarating fishing tournament, and chows down on a gourmet delicacy.
Through these escapades, he learns the different ways that people are combatting the invasive carp problem. We discover how innovative solutions - whether it’s gamified, walled in, or fried up - are emerging in the conundrum against this invasive aquatic intruder.
Learn more about Human Footprint: www.pbs.org/show/human-footprint
*****
PBS Member Stations rely on viewers like you. To support your local station, go to: to.pbs.org/DonateTerra
*****
Subscribe to PBS Terra so you never miss an episode! bit.ly/3mOfd77
And keep up with PBS Terra on:
Facebook: / pbsdigitalstudios
Tiktok: / pbsterra
Instagram: / pbsterra
Пікірлер: 419
"huh this video seems interesting, I wonder why this happ-" *Ronald Reagan laughing uproariously from hell*
@artemis_smith
Ай бұрын
It's always Ronald Reagan
@BrandanLee
Ай бұрын
*Self-Reliance Thru Sheer Negligence Intensifies*
@geofflau4215
Ай бұрын
Every new thing I learn about Reagan just solidifies him as the overarching supervillain of the modern era o.O
@tHebUm18
Ай бұрын
10/10 fantastic way of describing the multitudes of terrible that Reagan's legacy is.
@masx4468
Ай бұрын
Reagan is a Republican GOD.
I live in Asia and I can't tell you how much they love to eat carp here!
@MaoRatto
Ай бұрын
Are you making a joke or not? As Carp is sometimes a way to bypass censors when saying crap.
@uhohhotdog
Ай бұрын
@@MaoRattolol there’s no censor for the word crap 😂
@person4211
Ай бұрын
Ew keep them there
@Bardmusic66
Ай бұрын
All the bones should give you some extra calcium
@LXHFIRENKING
Ай бұрын
Carps in US taste totally different from the same species farmed or wild caught in Asia. They have tried to process and export US carp to China and Vietnam but it did not work. One explanation I heard is that carps are bottom feeders and sediment along Mississippi water ways are often polluted with heavy metals, the taste of which accumulates in the fish.
I just learned a while ago how some fish eggs can survive being digested by birds. I can understnad how quickly things can get out of control.
@shadow8865y7
Ай бұрын
Ya the Minnesota dnr has over 250 small unnamed ponds. Some are extremely remote where no human really go. That the dnr have found zebra muscles and some have millfoil and some have Asian carp. Birds legs, feathers and even waist aka poop can transport species everywhere. That why small ponds middle of woods have minnows.
@rusle
20 күн бұрын
@@shadow8865y7 Minnows is used s live bait and some just let the rest of the bait loose into the water when they are done fishing. That is a well known way we got minnows into small lakes that used to only contain trout.
Turn em into fertilizer!
@rustyicepick8462
Ай бұрын
My thought exactly. Or cat/dog food?
@DanielGomez-jk6bv
29 күн бұрын
It's been done already
@GetRocStar
28 күн бұрын
There are to many of them
@scorpionspets9832
18 күн бұрын
All three Eat Dog/cat food And fertilizer Caro taste pretty darn good if I'm remembering correctly
I think another factor in getting people eat carp is the long presence of grass carp in the US. If you don’t prepare them properly they can taste very muddy, so that people may be reticent to eat any “carp”. Rebranding makes sense in this context. Patagonian Toothfish may not sound tasty, but call it Chilean Sea Bass 🤔
@BrandanLee
Ай бұрын
I also associate carp with the muddyboys. But I've also had carp that was worth 800$ a plate served to google network admins. It's all in the preparation. Personally, I'm excited to AI driven killbots practicing on carp for the big anti-human showdown of the 2050s.
@burneracc2567
Ай бұрын
I like to mix some hot and sweet paprika into flour (just to make it pink and then a hair more) and then dip the carp in that mix before frying.
@Bardmusic66
Ай бұрын
I’ve heard the muddy taste but also they’re impossible to clean with all those bones. It’s not worth the time but would make great dog food.
@burneracc2567
Ай бұрын
Their skin tastes like mud, worst skin I ever ate, tbh but the meat is good, and I haven't really noticed then having a lot more bones than something like ide or asp.
As someone who lives in the Great Lakes region, they should just completely cut off the Des Plaines River from the Chicago River. Backfill the locks and replace them with intermodal ports that will shift cargo from a barge on the canal to one on the river, instead of letting barges travel all the way through. If the carp get into the Great Lakes Basin it could destroy economies throughout the region that are already hurting from deindustrialization.
@JilynnFurlet
Ай бұрын
I call BS on the "muddy flavor" . I've personally salvaged carp from a drying up oxbow of the Willamette river in Oregon which were struggling in muddy brown water less than 10 inches deep. They were delicious, light flavored, and without even the slightest trace of "mud". I have no idea where that 'muddy flavor' came from, but I suspect bad cleaning and prep.
@leongoerger9768
Ай бұрын
@@JilynnFurletI’m french and we eat carp here too but when caught from a muddy lake you can put them in a small pool or bathtub of clear water for 2 days and it washes out the muddy taste
@dcgo44r
Ай бұрын
@JilynnFurlet I'm glad you liked them. As the saying goes, "to each their colors and tastes." Now, let me ask you about your fish-eating background, culture, economics, studies, and professional background as well. Then I will take your word into consideration! Sorry, but they are horrible. I don't care how many lies are needed to avoid this ecological catastrophe. There should be other solutions, but I won't lie. I've eaten them, cooked by me (I'm a fairly good cook, especially with fish), and they are best on the grill or in the oven. They need to be over-spiced, at least for me. And I have eaten them cooked by some other cooks. They are too mushy, wet, and have an unappealing taste, not to mention the number of bones they have! Pass!
@morewi
25 күн бұрын
Yeah just completely destroy the economy of the country because of some fish.
@JilynnFurlet
21 күн бұрын
@@dcgo44r Perhaps we've been eating two different species? If you suspect my competence to comment on the quality of a food, be assured I have the same reservations about yours. I too am a fairly good cook. I have college degrees in both Anthropology and Botany, was raised by a Polish-American father who was an avid fisherman, have lived in or visited 16 countries (besides living in 5 US states). I've eaten fish in every one of them, as well as various crustaceans (including barnacles), molluscs (bivalves, limpets, squid, octopus), and a few other less attractive invertebrates. The carp I found good was Common European Carp from the Willamette River in Oregon. The ones I ate in Taiwan and SE Asia were also quite acceptable, although I didn't cook those myself. I haven't eaten any from other parts of the US. Where did the carp you've had come from? Do you know what species they were?
I'm sure pet food companies can turn them into pet food...
@Jeremyho439
20 күн бұрын
They export to China.
Carp are considered delicious in a lot of Asian countries. I haven't personally eaten one yet but I'm looking forward to tasting it. A lot of fish we consider "trash fish" in the USA are actually delicious.
@steven8148
Ай бұрын
yes, there are ways to make it delicious
@jasper5878
Ай бұрын
It's crazy. I live in Mozambique, we don't really have carp here other than some private dams. So I don't really know much of the opinion here. But go to Zimbabwe and South Africa and they see Carp as a low class fish for eating. I tried it once and had the same thing as eating catfish or Tilapia from a Dam. It tasted like Mud. I think the only thing you could do is to Purge them in clean water. But economically that is just a huge cost.
Ngl trying to catch the fish jumping out of the water sounds like a blast
It always goes back to Reagan
These fish are perfectly good to eat. In fact Grass carp is one of my favorites. You can do a number of things to remove the bones - make boneless fillets (more difficult and wastes a fair bit of meat), pressure cook or can them - turns the bones soft, or grind them into carp burger - grinds up and screens out the bones. I have done all of the above. They are delicious fish and agree with the name change.
@CortexNewsService
Ай бұрын
Illinois is promoting exactly that.
@shmuckling
Ай бұрын
I didn't know that there were so many ways to get rid of the bone. If we get good at doing that we can replace some of the less sustainable industrial fishing with carp fishing - and it seems these fish are basically trying to get eaten by the way they jump into nets LOL. I'd assume between pressure cooking and grinding there's a way to get pretty good consistent product that's completely free of bones.
@lozoft9
Ай бұрын
They could’ve been a bit more inventive about the name. Copi still sounds too much like carp or crappie. They should’ve used the Thai name, planai, or the Tamil one, kentai. Makes it sound foreign in a good way like barramundi or mahi mahi.
@dennisyoung4631
Ай бұрын
Yes, *Karpfen.* Supposedly commonly eaten in Europe.
@jeil5676
Ай бұрын
@@lozoft9 crappie is a prized fish
Wild caught carp aren't any dirtier than catfish and they eat the same diet. Not sure why people consider Asian and European carp to be trash fish.
@Jay-ho9io
Ай бұрын
They are trash fish in the sense that they are incredibly destructive to wild species, and the greater environment as a whole.
@eric2500
Ай бұрын
Because they are bottom feeders Not good to eat bottom feeders if you have certain medical conditions, but if not, eat them. We are all bioconcentrating toxins and plastics anyhow, in almost all of our food. Good news is we are getting better at detecting and treating cancers.
Getting people to eat them seems a much more difficult task than simply using them for fertilizer and or pet food.
@JilynnFurlet
Ай бұрын
Yes, but all of those uses earn income, and both reduce the carp population and boost the local economies.
@bobm3477
Ай бұрын
@@JilynnFurlet Unfortunately we have an emergency. We need to use as many as possible as soon as possible.
@JilynnFurlet
21 күн бұрын
@@bobm3477 I agree. That is why I said we should use ALL of the possible ways to remove them, with the plus that fertilizer, pet food, and human food all produce income and improve economies.
@bobm3477
19 күн бұрын
@@JilynnFurlet Oh yes of course, I was just expanding on your comment for those that may not think of these examples, many more as well. We are all in this together 😄
I live in Michigan and I feel that Michigan Andrews have a vital and special interest in maintaining the natural vibrancy of our great lakes and it's imperative that we keep invasive species out
the carp is so bad that they are in the South Saskatchewan river as well as parts of the British Columbia rivers now too
@davemeise2192
Ай бұрын
Yes. I'm not sure how they got here in Kalamalka lake but I saw a lot of them in the creek that feeds Kal lake into Okanagan lake so they are 100% here in the Okanagan.
@kananaskiscountry8191
Ай бұрын
@@davemeise2192 yep the came from the Pacific ocean and the south saskatchewan River comes through the Lethbridge area and BC rivers
@jeil5676
Ай бұрын
@@kananaskiscountry8191 They dont come from the ocean.
@kananaskiscountry8191
Ай бұрын
@@jeil5676 if they are fresh water fish why are they in the water ways of around the world
@jeil5676
Ай бұрын
@@kananaskiscountry8191 Because people import live specimens and release them. Part of the story is in the video. They cannot survive at all in the ocean. They can not live at all in salt water. Like most fresh water fish. If they could live in salt water, they would have already existed in mississipi and it wouldnt be an introduced species issue. People did this and thats the whole point of the story.
Thanks a lot Reagan
@Vintage206
Ай бұрын
And Nixon
@schnauzpig
Ай бұрын
Reagan didn't import them they were first imported in 1872! Despite receiving government funding PBS terra seems to have omitted these details and visually represented that it happened during the Nixon presidency.
@jerrybenzl8843
Ай бұрын
Thanks government for importing the fish to begin with. Waste of money and unintended consequences. Who could have guessed?
@capnbeenieweenie5603
Ай бұрын
God damn republicans keep deregulating. Every time they do disaster strikes.
@infinitemonkey917
Ай бұрын
@@schnauzpig He eliminated the EPA's ability to regulate them.
For even more fun we have these three insects, the Emerald Ash Boror, the Longhorn Beetle and this noxious new fly - oh and also Murder Hornets. I think I will be relieved to see the cicada broods this year. At least they are OUR bugs..
@bch5513
29 күн бұрын
Don't forget the Japanese beetles , spotted lanternfly, FIRE ants, and ALL the invasive PLANTS
Theyre really singing rhe anthem at a fishing tournament lmaoo
America calls fish, clams and shrimp invasive. Some countries call that food delivery.
They taste amazing!!! Just filet like normal, fry up, break cooked filet in half longitude way , pull bones and eat Amazing
In Scouts we cooked "Planked Carp". Take a nice Carp fillet and tack it to a nice Cedar plank. Lean the plank up across a slow smoky fire. Cook for twenty minutes or so. Remove the Carp and eat the cedar plank...
@josh26566
27 күн бұрын
LMAO
I don't know why they don't try to sell fillets of Asian carp at major grocers like Walmart, Target, etc. I'd love to try them since they would be cheap but most importantly, are healthy, help control an invasive species and provide economic support for those businesses dealing with the situation.. 🤷♂️🤔
Now we need to cook up a sales pitch to get McDonald's, Burger King et al to switch to Copi?
@mikepotter5718
Ай бұрын
We need to do something about marketers attempting to change the name of a fish.
@HaloHighlightz
Ай бұрын
@@mikepotter5718gonna have to research trendy fish before eating it 🫠
@bayouburner281
Ай бұрын
If you like picking bones out, sure
@enginerd1985
21 күн бұрын
@bayouburner281 you only pick out bones if you are manually preparing the fish. McD's would certainly mechanized the process and make a puree patty like they do with their McChicken and current McFish.
Let’s do some European Starling and House Sparrow episodes
@BrandanLee
Ай бұрын
Maybe a little dash of Stinknet? Some Puncture Vine Salad? A little London Rocket Garnish?
@rameneater1437
Ай бұрын
The fact that one man is responsible for the starling population here in the states is insane
@S3lkie-Gutz
Ай бұрын
hell yeah, don’t forget giant hogweed knotweeds nutrias and giant asian hornets(which was for once an accidental introduction, they stowed away on cargo ships kind of like how zebra mussels stow away on recreational boats)
Working the bones out of a full bite is definitely more work, but it becomes part of the experience of enjoying a fresh fish. Not to mention how healthy fish protein is, compared to others.
Grass Carp are technically "invasive" but I currently hold the Virginia state record (71lbs) for Grass Carp. I've seen bigger Carp than my record in 3ft drainage canals, because these fish thrive in low-oxygen environments. If some 12 year old kid beats my record fishing a ditch in his backyard, I wouldn't be surprised, and I'm not mad at this fish for existing in American inland waterways. On the contrary - this fish gives kids who are new to fishing an incredible opportunity to catch an absolute monster in their neighborhood ponds. No other freshwater fish in America gets young people more interested in fishing than common Grass Carp, because they're huge for no reason, and fight like crazy
@thequixoticangler3364
Ай бұрын
Just caught my first GC. Man, that is a mean fighter.
@squillium3091
27 күн бұрын
@@thequixoticangler3364 oh yeah for sure. The fact that you've gotta use small hooks and light line to catch them makes them extremely hard but fun to catch... it's like catching a tuna on a spinning rod
Grind them up and use them for crayfish feed
Carp is never a problem in Asia because they know how to cook it. Their cuisine makes anything look good and taste good.
@rapermini3467
5 күн бұрын
Because carp don't live there . Asian rivers full of plastic trash and excrements
I've always liked steamed carp. The problem is you can get a walleye in the same restaurant. :).
people don't want to eat carp, but I bet if you give those fish out for free they definitely will eat them
@QuesoCookies
28 күн бұрын
The next government cheese should be government carp
@mbthe8731
3 күн бұрын
Lobster used to be considered poor peoples' food many years ago. Once people find ways to prepare carp and use it in dishes it could become more common as a meal.
That two minute discussion about bones... Yup
"If you see one tree, you've seen 'em all" -Gov. Ronald Reagan, in opposition to the 1968 creation by Congress of Redwood National Park. Reagan currently burns in Hell.
@MZ99698
Ай бұрын
What a cretin, it boggles my mind that anybody can be such a philistine
The solution is cats. Cats on canoes.
Could they not be fed to pigs or used as fertilizer? There is an overwhelming number of them, This has never stopped us before
Boil it in pressure cooker for 90mins to soften the bone. Add in turmeric, ginger, sugar, salt, bay leaves, cinnamon, pepper, ginger leaves, galangal, cumin, cloves, lemongrass n asterian. Adjust the dose of each herb base on ur preference. Then u can deep fry the fish after straining.
We've eaten carp in Kansas for well over a century. I'm sure Asian carp tastes pretty much like native carp.
@bhoutdoors507
23 күн бұрын
The “native” carp are common carp, imported from europe as a food fish. Native suckers and buffalo aren’t carp.
That chef's dishes look ridiculously good...
Grass carp is great for Sichuan hot pot. You need tough fish so they don't fall apart in the soup.
Seems like a good candidate for more automated processing and use as animal feed
@trleith
Ай бұрын
Well, using animals as animal feed has a spotty history. Maybe as crop fertilizer, you know, like lobster was in the 18th century.
@irenafarm
Ай бұрын
They probably meant as pet food.
@trleith
Ай бұрын
@@irenafarm That would reduce risk for sure.
@BrandanLee
Ай бұрын
That's how you engineer an industry with lobbying power to prevent change.
@lozoft9
Ай бұрын
@@trleith fish and meat don't really make for good compost material. They don't just decompose, they putrify and the microbes and insects that are attracted to rotting flesh can do unholy things to the human body.
catch them to use as fish meal and fish fertilizer
Changing the name can work. In the UK the cheap alternative to cod and haddock is iridescent catfish. People did not goo for it. They changed the name to Bassa or Vietnamese Cobbler and it's becoming a staple for folks who are economically challenged.
Why now make them animal into feed? Seems like that would make a sizable dent.❤️🤗🐝
You can turn this Asian carp into the new tuna fish I mean if you make it taste good humans will eat it and they will eat it till it's gone
Asian carp where introduced to South Dakota when a flood happens in Yankton in 2011
My biggest concern with eating them is that I live near the green river in Kentucky. It of course dumps into the Mississippi. We've been told for years that the river is contaminated, the fish are not safe for human or animal consumption, using it as fertilizer is not recommended. I'm at the point where I won't eat fish if it isn't from a tank farm.
As someone who loves eating fish, I really hope this catches on in Europe.
Make use of the invasive: Fertilizer, pet food, canning will soften and take care of the bones. Lots of ways
Carp is very good, it just all depends on whos cooking it and how they cook it. They are just bottom feeders like catfish.
Shrimp and lobster are bottom feeders and eats waste as well. People pay lots of money in restaurants for them
Very good production thank you.
Wondering why they aren't desiccated and used as fertilizer in the fields?
Have you guys ever heard of the Hmong people. They love eating carp, get a hold of them and they'll get rid of all those carp with a month.
cant forget about the original invasive fish the common carp which we brought in and took over the entire lower 48 in less than 50 years!!
@JilynnFurlet
21 күн бұрын
Those were the European Carp. Pretty invasive, but the Asian species seem to be even worse.
@cowboybowfishingoutdoors5013
20 күн бұрын
@@JilynnFurlet they are all invasive, the common carp is in every state in the lower 48 and in the great lakes, the silver and big heads haven’t made it into every state yet. the common carp which came from asia as well is the main biomass in most lakes currently.
If the bones are a problem, why not grind them up into fish paste to make fish nuggets?
@MarvynG
29 күн бұрын
can them in such a way the bones are soft and chewable, like canned salmon
Yep, carp has lots of bones and not many people like to eat it because of this. Steam carp with spring onion and ginger is a must try.
It’s the silver carp that causes the most problems . Floods let em loose
Asian here, i love to eat carps but only farmed one Because the farm one is put in fresh clean water for few days without food to get rid of the mud flavour
Of course it's Reagan. Of course. 😠😓😥
5:03 Zebra mussels just flipped a bird 🐦at us💀💀💀
They make great fertilizer too
They may be a nuisance, but god damn do they fight hard when you catch them on a rod and reel
it seems that seeing these carp in a river is the only way to see some flying carpet.
In Eurasia that carp nearly extinct as well as all other fishes . America is the only country where fish still plenty
Make them a protein source in animal feed as well.
I doubt they can't get rid of it. What happened to the dodo bird 😅 How to have a "forever job".😊
Did they forget about Tilapia? That one was another big mistake.
@sarpyTurtle11
4 күн бұрын
I don't think tilapia is as cold tolerant as the carp. Tilapia Is a central African fish originally
I would think Carp make good fertilizer. 👍
Thank you.
Hello??? We have countries out there with a lot of starving people and USA has a invasive species that can feed them all!!!
The elites don't want you to know this, but the carp in the river are free, you can take them home whenever you like. I 487 carp at my home /j
Brilliant
You can bet they are in the great lakes.
I love fried fish. I can eat fried fish until the cows come home. ;)
Insanity after insanity after insanity ending with feeding poop fish to collage students, which now makes sense.
If government put a large enough bounty on these fish, fishermen would solve the problem. But the bounty has to be significant so someone could make a living fishing them out. Less expensive than other government measures.
Do the bones become soft and edible when canned??
Oh man, bighead carp is delicious.
Why not just use them as fertilizer?
They bring workers from out of the country to make their lives easier then they complain when there are too many of us. lol I forgot they were talking about fish
Carp have a lot of bones but it’s actually really tasty 😋
the fish is already in Ontario 😂
@JilynnFurlet
21 күн бұрын
Which species? The European Carp that has been spreading across N. Am for ages, or the more recently introduced Asian species?
If it was a bad pun, you gotta hold your ground and not laugh at all
I will fight any battle that I can fight at the dinner table.
Looks like fresh Pet food to me 🤔
The dog food and cat food market would be a great place to use tons of Copi a year.
Whataya mean, we? Gotta start calling out the perpetrators by name!
great episode
At one point politicians thought it’d be a good idea to put hippos in the rivers of America
The fish in family Cyprinidae that I'm most familiar with is Java barb (Barbonymus gonionotus) They are pretty bony, but by cutting the ~0.5 cm stripes perpendicular to the spine on the whole length and both side of the fish, the bones get reduced to small pieces that is edible. you need pretty sharp knife and while you are cutting, you can hear the sound of the bones breaking. Example: kzread.info/dash/bejne/emdm0KadpJnNm7w.html I don't how bony silver carp (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix) is but if there is a similarity in that part with Java barb, then the same method might work as well.
@JilynnFurlet
Ай бұрын
The fact that the bones are large just makes them easier to remove. I've prepared and eaten many carp and found they are no more annoying than many popular fish. Their more subtle flavor makes them good for a wide variety of dishes as well.
@tsuribachi
Ай бұрын
@@JilynnFurlet oh for Java barb it's not that they have big bones. They have a lot of small instramascular Y-shape bones. all the cutting is to break all these bones.
6:35 Is that what it looks like it is?
@howaboutataste
Ай бұрын
The 1894-2020 state flag of Mississippi?
I'll bet Mc Donald's wouldn't have a problem selling that fish and they would simply call it,.... Mc Fish Sandwich.
Oooouuuuu Thats ILLEGAL IMMA SNITCH
I've been on the missouri and kansaa rivers and both are completely infested with them... its sad,
Aren't Grass Carp sterile?
🍚🌮🍉...love dem carps!
....we have to talk about that lady at 6:02. Comments anyone?
Invasive species for $400, Alex.
Even in China they prefer other fish to the silver or big head carp too eat
Is eggs carp sensitive to ph ???? Maybe a solution…..🤔
learn something new everyday!