Was This WWII Rifle Better Than The M1 Garand?

Original Video: • Gewehr 43
-------------------------------------------------------------------------- Yes, this channel is created and managed by Hickok45 and John, mainly John. The video clips on this channel are segments of videos taken from videos originally posted on the Hickok45 KZread channel. John always includes a link to the original video from which the clip is taken.
Hickok45 videos are filmed on my own private shooting range and property by trained professionals for educational and entertainment purposes only, with emphasis on firearms safety and responsible gun ownership. We are NOT in the business of selling firearms or performing modifications on them. Do not attempt to copy at home anything you see in our videos. Firearms can be extremely dangerous if not used safely.

Пікірлер: 295

  • @furmanmackey5479
    @furmanmackey547928 күн бұрын

    The first one I ever saw was in a gun rack (remember when you could hang three or four long guns in plain sight in the cab of your pickup and nobody messed with them....Or you?). It was around 1964 or so and I asked my Dad what kind of rifle it was. Of course, I already knew about bolt, lever, and pump action rifles and shotguns, and knew the M-1 Garand and M-1 Carbine, along with the BAR even back then. Dad knew the man driving the pickup in front of us and simply said something along the lines of "Oh, that's just a German rifle Jim "found" in Germany during the war and brought back home with him. He brought back a bunch of stuff he "found" like a lot of soldiers did. That one he uses for deer huntin'." Now in 2024, that rifle is in the collection of his great grandson, the 4th Jim in fact, and is still used as a deer rifle.

  • @jacka55six60

    @jacka55six60

    28 күн бұрын

    In my early 80's high school parking lot there were plenty of trucks with full racks. In every classroom you could find at least a couple guys with a Buck knife on their belt. Life was good.

  • @furmanmackey5479

    @furmanmackey5479

    27 күн бұрын

    @@jacka55six60 Hell, I'm so old I can recall many of us country boys, and more than few country girls, who wore our skinning/hunting knives to school every day. Since many of us were farm raised our knives were simply tools of the "trade". Not that we didn't also carry a good quality folding knife in a pocket of our jeans too. And yes, life was good back then (early 1970s), and a whole lot more peaceful if you know what I mean. I know for a fact that I was not the only one who felt just a wee bit naked without our sheath knives when we went off to college. But we still had our folders in our jeans pockets....For emergencies.

  • @johnvencill1511

    @johnvencill1511

    23 күн бұрын

    200 grain sp will work

  • @TheWersum

    @TheWersum

    22 күн бұрын

    That is actually german copy of svt-40 russian rifle.

  • @steveblake8509

    @steveblake8509

    21 күн бұрын

    Who messes with you now for having long guns in a rack ? In my state ( Ohio ) it is legal. Thanks to the fucking NRA there are virtually no gun laws anywhere yet gun nuts still whine about being persecuted.

  • @paulkopacz5051
    @paulkopacz505128 күн бұрын

    I had an early Walther G43 years ago. I would NOT have recommended it over an M1. The internals are somewhat delicate compared to the M1 (Yes I own an M1 too). I was fascinated by the G43 and just had to get one. It was interesting to break it down, clean and inspect everything. I did replace the gas system with Apfeltors kit to keep it from beating itself to death. While the concept was good, it was limited to the materials they had available at the time. It was basically a semi-auto they could get out there as fast as possible and not meant to survive in the long term. I read somewhere that the German snipers at the time preferred the K98 for reliability and I would agree with that. When times got tough for me I would up selling my G43 but I will never sell the M1.

  • @caseyquinn9282

    @caseyquinn9282

    28 күн бұрын

    I love my M1, would definitely be the last gun I’d sell, including my EDC.

  • @kennethwood2089

    @kennethwood2089

    28 күн бұрын

    @@caseyquinn9282 Roger THAT, Gents! My old legacy M1 Garand spitting out the M2 ball...nothing like it in the world. After I go, IT goes to the grandkids.

  • @alfonsfalkhayn8950

    @alfonsfalkhayn8950

    15 күн бұрын

    The germans soon had the assault gun 43/44, which was far superior to the G43

  • @tb7771

    @tb7771

    2 күн бұрын

    Loved Apfeltors. Managed to get a few goodies from them for my G-41 (W). Luckily my 43's were later and were ported.

  • @venkataraghotham7586
    @venkataraghotham758619 күн бұрын

    "I SEE A SQUIRREL RUNNING THERE. BUT I AM NOT GOING TO HURT HIM". I salute you for this

  • @ypaulbrown
    @ypaulbrown28 күн бұрын

    this video takes me back to 1968 when my older sister's boyfriend let me take care of his G-43 when he went away to college....... I saw him do some amazing shooting with those iron sights from 200 to 300 yards.......thanks for sharing , an old guy down in Florida, Paul

  • @browngreen933
    @browngreen93328 күн бұрын

    Hickok45 TRUTH on Mauser 98: "It will never die."

  • @davidtuttle7556

    @davidtuttle7556

    2 күн бұрын

    I mean we flat stole it with the Springfield, and ppl still swear by them. Im not a ballistics expert. I would ask the differences between 30-06:and 8mm mauser?

  • @michaelmacek9433
    @michaelmacek943328 күн бұрын

    The G43 is my dream rifle and would be the crown jewel on my collection. I even have it on my laptop as " wallpaper ".

  • @johnathandavis3693

    @johnathandavis3693

    28 күн бұрын

    It is a good-looking weapon. Very German...

  • @elultimo102

    @elultimo102

    2 күн бұрын

    I G43 back in '68, but considered a POS . Fire one round, and the slide would jam to the rear. (No it was not the follower). I used a piece of 2x4 to pound it back. I tried another round, and the same thing happened. I should have kept it anyway, considering what they are worth. In '63, they sold for $175, equipped with a ZF-4 scope. Of course the same catalog sold artillery Lugers for $110, and the 32 round snail drums and loaders @ $19.95. (They also had early Colt ARs for $189.95 with a 20 rounder).

  • @ApostolicITTech
    @ApostolicITTech28 күн бұрын

    Years from now, someone is going to use a futuristic metal detector and think that a major war happened on that piece of land. 😂

  • @user-on7vr4cs7l

    @user-on7vr4cs7l

    28 күн бұрын

    He reloads old brass

  • @Stand_watie

    @Stand_watie

    24 күн бұрын

    @@user-on7vr4cs7l galaxy brained individual

  • @clivestainlesssteelwomble7665

    @clivestainlesssteelwomble7665

    20 күн бұрын

    The spent lead and copper is what he's referring to I think you'll find . And yes it could track like a major skirmish😂 that or the entrance to an old lead mine ☠️😬..🤣🧙🏻‍♂️ In the UK 🇬🇧 detectorists help walk English Civil war and earlier battlefields to turn up and plot musket and cannon shot.

  • @sixmax11

    @sixmax11

    Күн бұрын

    if it's somewhere in the U.S., then there's a very goof chance a major war was fought there. there have been many small and large battles fought here over the years.

  • @randylarsen1046
    @randylarsen104627 күн бұрын

    Had an invite to attend a sniper course in '83 during my 2nd year of service. The M-1 Grande was the most accurate rifle I've ever got to fire, with or without a scope. Never jammed. Was easy to disassemble, assemble and clean.

  • @GShileikis
    @GShileikis28 күн бұрын

    My father and two Uncles always swore by their M1 Garand and if they could find one, a 1911. Ammo was easy to get in most especially in the Pacific and CBI (China Burma India) areas. As for me, I'd take a semi-auto over a bolt gun any day.

  • @MarshFlyFightWin
    @MarshFlyFightWin27 күн бұрын

    It should be mentioned Germany began developing the G41 before the invasion of the Soviet Union as they recognized the need for a semi-auto rifle pre-WW2. The G43 was developed after the invasion utilizing SVT-40 gas system.

  • @skepticalobserver2135

    @skepticalobserver2135

    25 күн бұрын

    Oh? It's the same system as the SVT-40? The SVT-40 was produced in vast numbers (not as much as the Mosin, of course).

  • @MarshFlyFightWin

    @MarshFlyFightWin

    25 күн бұрын

    @@skepticalobserver2135 The G43 copied the SVT-40 gas system after recognizing that the G41 bang-gas system wasn't that functional in weather like Russian Winter.

  • @lugubriousenclave91
    @lugubriousenclave9126 күн бұрын

    Great great granddad fought in the 2nd Boer war many Australians liked the Mauser over the Lee enfeild .303 for certain use, especially longer range. Both were reliable, rugged, easy maintained and very effective killers.

  • @MB-ms3ud
    @MB-ms3ud28 күн бұрын

    "better" is relative. The G43 was a better design as far as ease and cost of manufacturing, but there were design flaws with the bolt and receiver fragility because they were over gassed. If the G43 design had gotten 10 years of peacetime R&D like the Garand did, then it likely would have the issues sorted out and would have certainly been a better rifle. Same could be said about the M41 Johnson for the same reasons. A rushed wartime development that was equal or better to the garand in many ways.

  • @pieceofschmidtgamer

    @pieceofschmidtgamer

    28 күн бұрын

    The M1941 Johnson is a pre-WWII design.

  • @pe.bo.5038

    @pe.bo.5038

    26 күн бұрын

    Well,"good" is always outclassed by"better".....and this was the Stgw. 44

  • @coachhannah2403

    @coachhannah2403

    25 күн бұрын

    The M1 used underpowered cartridges for this very reason!

  • @robertcross9175
    @robertcross917522 күн бұрын

    The rubber recoil pad mysteriously appeared at end of the video. 😄

  • @tonyking3125
    @tonyking312528 күн бұрын

    Hickock for President !

  • @user-so1mv9po2f

    @user-so1mv9po2f

    28 күн бұрын

    Hell yeah, better choice than whats out there now

  • @josephburke973

    @josephburke973

    28 күн бұрын

    @@user-so1mv9po2f 100%

  • @Coconutscott

    @Coconutscott

    28 күн бұрын

    I think he's too young.

  • @cschym2705

    @cschym2705

    28 күн бұрын

    Vote Trump so we can keep our guns ​@@user-so1mv9po2f

  • @cooljerkjunior

    @cooljerkjunior

    23 күн бұрын

    Hickok47, eh?

  • @townings9185
    @townings918528 күн бұрын

    30 years ago I had a G 43 and a K 43. They both were good shooters. Both were over gased for reliable use in cold weather . Also they had a side mount for a scope and a detachable 10 round mag. Not easy to break down for cleaning. The G 43 I bought an aftermarket gas bushing to lower the over gassing and reduce wear and tear . One thing to check on these rifles is the rear receivers for bulges from over gassing. Quality control was shoddy after mid 1944 . So if I had to pick a rifle it would have to be a M1 Garand.

  • @kbjerke
    @kbjerke29 күн бұрын

    Don't know if it was necessarily "better," but it sure is *nice!* Thanks for sharing, Hickok45!!!

  • @bad74maverick1

    @bad74maverick1

    28 күн бұрын

    considering that the rear of the bolts and the rear of the receivers are prone to cracking they are no where near as nice let alone better.

  • @kbjerke

    @kbjerke

    28 күн бұрын

    @@bad74maverick1 ...as a rare piece of history.

  • @bad74maverick1

    @bad74maverick1

    28 күн бұрын

    @@kbjerke True. I'm just reaffirming that it was not better in any way in its original form. If you upgrade the gas system so it's reliable and not as violent its a fine gun. In terms of shooting in my collection my favorite is my 41' Johnson rifle, then my M1 then my G43.

  • @kbjerke

    @kbjerke

    28 күн бұрын

    @@bad74maverick1 Gotcha. I love my Garand, but my personal favourites are the "Old West" guns like the Colt SAA or Winchester and Marlin lever rifles. Best wishes to you! OH - forgot - I really like the Swedish AG42B. Sweet rifle.

  • @bad74maverick1

    @bad74maverick1

    28 күн бұрын

    @@kbjerke Everything the Swedish do is perfection. Their guns are a work of friggin art!

  • @dillonc7955
    @dillonc795528 күн бұрын

    If the reliability issues were worth the cheaper costs of manufacturing, I'd say the G43 was decent at being the Axis' twist on the M1 Garand.

  • @NYG5

    @NYG5

    27 күн бұрын

    No shit I never expected the Germans to have a cheaper, more mass producible small arm outside of the trash volkssturm weapons.

  • @seth5308
    @seth530828 күн бұрын

    My grandfather was one of the first in at the Battle of the Bulge and he always had a Tommy gun, Garand, and a samurai sword standing up in the corner of the room I slept in. He didn’t care but they raised good kids back then and had nothing to worry about. 😂

  • @MavHunter20XX

    @MavHunter20XX

    28 күн бұрын

    They? A samurai sword is a tough teacher.

  • @OutdoorGirls7

    @OutdoorGirls7

    28 күн бұрын

    @@MavHunter20XXthe parents of that generation. Moms and dads.

  • @MavHunter20XX

    @MavHunter20XX

    28 күн бұрын

    @@OutdoorGirls7 Thanks, I thought he implied the guns and the sword. They would be rough mentors for sure.

  • @boomstick4054

    @boomstick4054

    28 күн бұрын

    Raised by swords,,, lololololol

  • @vrbonzani
    @vrbonzani23 күн бұрын

    D-K Production Group in Kentucky has plans to make new manufactured G/K43s. Their MP44 rifles are apparently a few weeks away from shipping.

  • @brianwilke592
    @brianwilke59228 күн бұрын

    No need for cosmetics when you got 700 to 800 B-17’s at a time to worry about

  • @charliesierra6919
    @charliesierra691928 күн бұрын

    Beautiful piece! I've got a Gustloff-Werke German trainer rifle in .22 and it is top quality and fantastically accurate. Great vid Hickok!

  • @scootertrash911
    @scootertrash91127 күн бұрын

    Thanks Big Buddy, you are always entertaining as well as interesting. You made me realize that 6' 5" at 275 was just a pipsqueek.

  • @V8SKULLS
    @V8SKULLS27 күн бұрын

    What an Absolute beautiful rifle, that is on rifle I've been looking for to add to my collection, I have a M1 garand, so proud to have gotten one, and I have 3 different types of mausers. But that Gwer 43 is Beautiful, thank you for taking the time to share with us. You and John make wonderful videos

  • @JG-six-gun
    @JG-six-gun28 күн бұрын

    Excellent as always, thanks !!!

  • @patrickporter1864

    @patrickporter1864

    28 күн бұрын

    The. G43 is probably better than the M14 even though that came almost 20 years later.

  • @DavidHBurkart
    @DavidHBurkart28 күн бұрын

    That is a very cool shooter. Even better with the WWII cred!

  • @robinblackmoor8732
    @robinblackmoor873226 күн бұрын

    You have to compare apples to apples. The M1 was really well made. It was a pretty good design and we could make a lot of them. The Germans had all kinds of metal issues, and manufacturing issues. So that makes the M1 the better rifle at the time. If you fixed the issues with the German rifle and used good steel at a good factory. Maybe the German rifle is better, but that is not how it went. Just like German tanks. Sure on paper they may have been better, but they broke all the time and were hard to fix. Allied tanks were easier to make, easier to repair and did not break down as much. The joke Germans told was a Panther can take out 10 Sherman tanks, but they always bring 11.

  • @cccmmm1234

    @cccmmm1234

    26 күн бұрын

    Exactly right. Part of the design is ensuring it meets requirements including being able to manufacture it with the available materials and systems.

  • @analystanalyst7652

    @analystanalyst7652

    25 күн бұрын

    The ‘German Garand’ had its problems, mostly due to contradicting limitations put on the rifle’s development and not due to material but disagreement from the Heer and the powers that be as to what they wanted. I’ll take the Garand any day. With battle sights and Kentucky windage I took my last deer in the shoulder at 225 yards without a problem. Now the ’03, for me, is the most accurate and that took the Mauser action, so there you go, even though it is not the .308 round. The US government actually paid Mauser royalties during WWI for use of its patent.

  • @TMFShooting
    @TMFShooting28 күн бұрын

    Another Great Clip💯 Thanks for Sharing 💥💥💥💥💥💥💥

  • @peagee4518
    @peagee451828 күн бұрын

    that man can shoot....I'm only 65...when I grow up......))

  • @FootBall-rv6ki

    @FootBall-rv6ki

    28 күн бұрын

    😂

  • @kbjerke

    @kbjerke

    28 күн бұрын

    He's exactly my age. I can shoot, not quite *THAT* well. I don't hope to actually grow up, though. Having too much fun as is.

  • @RubyMarkLindMilly
    @RubyMarkLindMillyКүн бұрын

    Beautiful bit of kit

  • @WhistlinBullet
    @WhistlinBullet28 күн бұрын

    I want one badlyyy

  • @magnusdunning6113
    @magnusdunning61133 күн бұрын

    Recently I was reading a diary memoir from a German sniper in WWII. He wrote that the 98K was very hard on the shoulder, and at one point for close in work he recieved a G-43 Karbine that he said was effective and comfortable to shoot, accurate to 150 meters for his type of work.

  • @LegendaryInfortainment
    @LegendaryInfortainment23 күн бұрын

    It would never have enough production volume to matter materially to the war just as happened. And being intended for sniping and light support duty as WHB Smith mentions made it a lower priority from the start. Great fun and review!

  • @mikelarmanis9340
    @mikelarmanis934028 күн бұрын

    This one hasnt come out in a long time!

  • @Maurice895
    @Maurice89528 күн бұрын

    I once owned a M1 Garand made in 44, and a M1 carbine made in 42, and like the fool that I am I sold the both of them. The G43 seems like a quality rifle, but is it as robust as the Garand? The magazine of the M43 is an improvement over the clips in the Garand that would make a noise when empty, but overall I'm not sure it's better.

  • @bobr7380
    @bobr738027 күн бұрын

    One thing it had over the Garand was the detachable magazine. English bolt guns had them so I can't figure out why the Garand didn't.

  • @Stargun-vj1uh

    @Stargun-vj1uh

    26 күн бұрын

    Logistics. The issue with magazines is they cost so much more to manufacture that you don't want to lose them. the clips could just be handed out and not retained as you'll get more. They're cheap. It's thin metal versus much nicer thicker metal with a carefully machined follower spring, and that if it gets damaged it's a problem. Clips are better for impacts and in the grand scheme of things, you can issue a soldier more clips in this case than magazines and take up less space. Back then, there was a good argument in the middle of a war like this to manufacture a bunch of clips and issue them widely, than manufacture a bunch of magazines that cost more, take up more space, and are more costly to lose. Even the british didn't give their Lee Enfield riflemen that many extra magazines. They still preferred them to load with clips.

  • @coachhannah2403

    @coachhannah2403

    25 күн бұрын

    Advantages of internal magazine include topping up, top load, less weight, and others...

  • @TheGhostOfSmedleyButler

    @TheGhostOfSmedleyButler

    25 күн бұрын

    It was the dark of the moon at the pop-up rifle range, Camp Pendelton, California, summer of 1963. My 40-man Recruit Platoon was there to witness the fire intensity of a Platoon in a combat engagement. Each Private was equipped with his M-1. Every forth private was then issued a BAR with three, twenty round magazines, simulating a Fire Team. EVERY ROUND WAS A TRACER! Note, The only thing the Marine Corps. EVER throws away is toilet paper and then...Maybe...The NCO's placed five, eight round clips at each M-1 position. Yes, damnit, they were clips! We were instructed to take up a prone position and upon command, load with one eight round clip, take aim at the targets and await the command to fire. Further block of instruction was to continue to fire for two minutes, loading and firing as many clips/ magazines as possible, in that time, await the command to cease fire, and clear all weapons. Any and ALL, unfired, loose rounds and still loaded clips/magazines were to be left at the firing positions and then fired by the following relay, if possible, in two minutes. The NCOs added Five more loaded clips at each rifle position after each of the firing relays. As the third shooter I found Eight loaded clips at my assigned position for a total of SIXTY-FOUR rounds. Upon the cease fire command, I had Zero unfired rounds remaining. The bolt of my weapon was locked to the rear, the clip had been ejected and my jaw was open in awe of what I had just witnessed! There were NO Alibies among the shooters using our weapons which had been long ago issued to Infantry units then Engineers, then artillery, then Graves Registrations, Chaplains Assist. and Field Musics, before being issued to Infantry Training Regiment. So, is the Garand M-1 rifle obsolete, obsolescent or ineffective? I think not, in the hands of a United States Marine.

  • @Stargun-vj1uh

    @Stargun-vj1uh

    25 күн бұрын

    @@TheGhostOfSmedleyButler Good story, but yeah no...the M1 is absolutely obsolete and obsolescent. It is effective, sure, but compared to a modern military rifle? It's no contest, it's absolutely obsolete. It'll work, in the same way a Mosin will still kill a man at 300 yards. It just isn't an ideal rifle for modern circumstances.

  • @user-nb8er4rk9h
    @user-nb8er4rk9h28 күн бұрын

    It is cool, but I still like my M1's better. Much better! Thanks H45.

  • @jerryware5749
    @jerryware574926 күн бұрын

    Nice shootin'! Noticed from 3:50 to 3:51, somehow that recoil pad made it onto the rear of the stock. Wasn't thumpin' ya was it?

  • @jong4tv
    @jong4tv16 күн бұрын

    G43 was left behind but Mosin-Nagant still used to this today. Mosin-Nagant has good things for it being reliable, accurate. Mosin-Nagant is my best friend in video games.

  • @leneanderthalien
    @leneanderthalien27 күн бұрын

    Another semi-automatic rifle of the period was the MAS 1940, in 7.5mm French caliber and fixed 10 shot magazine, the development was completed , but due to the armistice was its production canceled, but finaly 6200 rifles called MAS 44 was built between 1944 and 1945 for the french marine commandos, with only difference with mle MAS40 a detachable magazine... Ultimately its mass production took place, with minor differences, in 1949, with a modification in 1956 to make it capable of firing heavy rifle grenades: the MAS 49-56 who is very appreciated in the US today : some was converted to 7,62 Nato, but the rifle works better with the original ammo (some ejection issues with low quality 7,62 cartiges)

  • @BAWhite-rf2bs
    @BAWhite-rf2bs28 күн бұрын

    I'm liking the new format and the slightly shorter run times....

  • @user-ic3pj6og3y
    @user-ic3pj6og3y28 күн бұрын

    Got to love the classics

  • @NNITRED
    @NNITRED27 күн бұрын

    The Oil Drum : That all you got Hickok? I'm still standing..

  • @tb7771
    @tb77712 күн бұрын

    I have owned several as well as a Walther G-41. I own a Garand and would choose the Garand over the G/K-43 due to its robust build. The G/K-43 has serious issue with developing stress fractures in the bolt housing. Even the later ones which had holes in the gas housing to reduce stress.

  • @tomford5416
    @tomford541627 күн бұрын

    i like how the mag is changed and the bolt cocked left handed ~ dont have to shift around to much and stay pointed in a dangerous direction , but there is the bolt slaming towards the left eye if running and gunning close range

  • @joshuabanner8542
    @joshuabanner85423 күн бұрын

    I have one of the 1st 5 thousand made... if you've done your research the earlier one had threaded barrels and locking mechanism on the bolt and scope mount . And it also has the ability to lock back when you shoot the final round. The first five thousand is rare since the plant was bombed and they where force to move the plant underground which forced the developers to cut corners on certain aspects of the rifle. For instance the gewehr 43 hickock 45 is shooting is a later war g43.

  • @FullTekAuto
    @FullTekAuto26 күн бұрын

    My personal favorite German WW2 firearm is the Volksturm rifle, it was a last ditch designed semi auto rifle at the very end of the war for the volunteer civilians fighting the Western Allies and the Soviets. It used StG 44 mags but what was cool about it, the reason I love it because it's the only gas driven blowback rifle I've ever seen... It's really cool to see in slow motion.

  • @kmcd1000
    @kmcd100028 күн бұрын

    Its on my list

  • @Hothenrik
    @Hothenrik28 күн бұрын

    Well, there's another one I will have to get to add to my ars--uh--collection. 😉👍

  • @norman7179
    @norman717927 күн бұрын

    A sporting goods store near me had an M-1 Garand with a new, original design stock in very good condition (metal not restored, reblued, etc) $ 1,600.

  • @mountainadventures7346
    @mountainadventures734628 күн бұрын

    Detachable box mag!👍

  • @Ben-ni3oc
    @Ben-ni3oc28 күн бұрын

    He put the butt pad on there real slick 😂

  • @elultimo102
    @elultimo1022 күн бұрын

    I never read how the German soldiers liked the G43, but they were enamored with the M-1 carbine, and all wanted to get one.

  • @richardminnich4249
    @richardminnich424927 күн бұрын

    I noticed that between the first and second magazine’s worth of ammo, he slipped a recoil pad over the back of the stock. I guess that metal buttplate was a bit rough on the shoulder! LOL

  • @JurgenKrace
    @JurgenKrace16 сағат бұрын

    The soviets actually put together earlier quite a nice gun SVT 40. It was far better than G43, and especially G41. And even before SVT 40, they had AVS (automatic rifle of Simonov) which dates back to 1936. Originally was intended to serve as semi-automatic, eventually it could fire in full auto. Although, it was highly recommended to shot short-burst only, as the gun was not very reliable..

  • @mirrorblue100
    @mirrorblue10028 күн бұрын

    Nice rifle. Thanks.

  • @dawsonschmidt3714
    @dawsonschmidt371428 күн бұрын

    The stg44 now that was a game changer! Now luckily the Austrian corporal did not like it.

  • @jimomaha7809

    @jimomaha7809

    23 күн бұрын

    At that point in time, they had limited resources, they made a new type of cartridge and a huge other type weapons that needed the same resources were made. Stopping these and retooling and educating the skilled employees might be a to difficult operation in a time they could not afford it. And a Austrian corporal also prefered tanks, big huge complicated tanks,

  • @IamDoogy
    @IamDoogy20 күн бұрын

    I have never heard of this semi automatic German rifle. I knew they had the “assault rifle“ and of course, the main weapon, the bolt action but I never in all my life, seen this semi automatic rifle in the German arsenal. Thanks Hickok.

  • @edwardabrams4972
    @edwardabrams497228 күн бұрын

    Us old guys may not be good for much but we do know how to handle these old guns and shoot what we are aiming at🙌

  • @dalejohnson2047
    @dalejohnson204728 күн бұрын

    I would say the M1 is more reliable my Dad swore by the M1 and his M14 but I own a SVT 40 and it’s a reliable period gun also

  • @SmokinLoon5150
    @SmokinLoon515027 күн бұрын

    Keep in mind that the G43 was loaded primarily with the 5 round stripper clips just like the K98. Typically, the German rifleman that was issued the G43 was given 1 spare magazine and the rest of his ammo was issued just as if he were a rifleman with the K98k. Same with the Soviets and the SVT-40, it was typically loaded via 5 round stripper clips.

  • 22 күн бұрын

    Methinks this man may practice a fair bit.

  • @TheSpritz0
    @TheSpritz024 күн бұрын

    HICKOK- I still think the Russian SVT-40 (WHICH YOU TESTED YEARS AGO) takes the cake on the entire semi-auto rifle question in WW2 VERY accurate and you have the added bonus of 10 aimed rounds instead of 8 in the M-1. The G-43 also has 10 but I really wouldn't trust it in winter, unlike the Russian equipment!!

  • @user-cg7kq4bx9r
    @user-cg7kq4bx9r26 күн бұрын

    in 10.000 years scientists will dig up the earth on hickock45's ground, assuming that there was a heavy battle: "look at all this deformated rounds..."

  • @bubbajackson7878
    @bubbajackson787828 күн бұрын

    Thank you John!

  • @jasonz7788
    @jasonz778828 күн бұрын

    Awesome thanks hickock45

  • @rickcole2301
    @rickcole230128 күн бұрын

    I'll tell you one thing. The semi-automatics got some nice looking wood on it. I wouldn't mind having something with that wood beautiful, especially if your Jake can put a polyurethane or something over it. It looks pretty good the way it is though, but when that wood looks that good I like it a little shiny

  • @thelastjohnwayne
    @thelastjohnwayne27 күн бұрын

    Notice how Hickock added a Butt Pad to the G43 mid video.

  • @markjones7063
    @markjones706327 күн бұрын

    You keep hitting with it.

  • @LTTUSA
    @LTTUSA28 күн бұрын

    I had 2 FN49’s (8mm) sold them and wish I never had. 8mm is a lot of fun !

  • @jeffadams9807
    @jeffadams980721 күн бұрын

    NO Military Rifle Ever Made In History, Will Ever Surpass The The M-1 GARAND Or The M-1 CARBINE, Ever...

  • @toga1022
    @toga102223 күн бұрын

    I have used both for many years and the they both get the thumbs up, but the M1 is by far more long term reliable in heavy usage . . . and using enblocs instead of mags, the M1 gets a second nod-

  • @fenrisulfur842
    @fenrisulfur84219 күн бұрын

    The G43 was made to be a Combat Rifle, nothing more! And its a beauty! Its like wanting to shave using the Lock of a M1as a mirror. And if they tell you it will shoot itself into piece...well ok! But the livespan of a Rifle was even shorter back then than the man who had to fire it. At least sometimes

  • @johngaither9263
    @johngaither926327 күн бұрын

    The G41 gas system was the result of some goofy German military rule against drilling a gas hole in the barrel. That regulation really hamstrung efforts at making a reliable and simple semiautomatic rifle. The Germans were so impressed with the Soviet SVT40 they incorporated some facets of its action into the G43.

  • @hisdudeness8328
    @hisdudeness832827 күн бұрын

    Doesn’t really matter if it was or not. At the end of the day, the US produced millions of M1’s and Germany only made a few thousand of the G43. Logistics always wins out in the end.

  • @Weimar893
    @Weimar89323 күн бұрын

    Having owned G-43's, G-41, SVT40's, M1's, M1 carbines, and a Johnson I find that the G-43 has a number of deficiency's, the extractor can work its way loose, it is a bit heavy and the difference between early manufactured ones and late war is really evident. The Tokarev is actually a great weapon and was used by the Germans when one was captured. The M1's main failure is in sub-zero weather as the operating rod has a tendency to have metal failure. As an aside the best semi auto rifle which had been invented but not put into production is and was the FN49 in 30-06. If it had been put into production in say 1939 the Germans would have suffered a lot more casualties when they invaded Belgium. I have owned four FN49's and love them. When I started collecting in the mid 60; s you could pick up an FN49 or G43 for under $90.

  • @lancewilliams4190
    @lancewilliams41904 күн бұрын

    The shooter is old but he sure aint obsolete.

  • @tanker1668
    @tanker166828 күн бұрын

    I noticed you rested your thumb along the right side of the receiver. Does the G43 bust a thumb knuckle when recoiling?

  • @dobermanpac1064
    @dobermanpac106428 күн бұрын

    I’m sticking with the M1. However it was cool.

  • @jerryodell1168
    @jerryodell116827 күн бұрын

    Did not like the M1 Garand clip. The right thumb was black and blue many times. Loved the carbine.

  • @fortnex9972
    @fortnex997226 күн бұрын

    I read somewhere it was kinda delicate. But, with a 20 round mag it woul be great

  • @robertmoulton2656
    @robertmoulton265626 күн бұрын

    I do love the G43

  • @whirving
    @whirving27 күн бұрын

    Built because the STV 40 was no longer falling into their hands. Still didn't equal the STV 40 or the Garand, but nice looking rifle. Of course meanwhile the Enfield Mk 3 is sipping tea with a smirk.

  • @DavidDavidunderthebridgeChampi
    @DavidDavidunderthebridgeChampi27 күн бұрын

    DK Production Group based in Kentucky makes old rifles new.

  • @gregcleveland3498
    @gregcleveland349828 күн бұрын

    Great history.

  • @kenricnarbrough8191
    @kenricnarbrough819122 күн бұрын

    He said BOLT-GUN and my mind went......... elsewhere.

  • 28 күн бұрын

    Whenever the title of a video is a question, the answer is “No.”.

  • @johnhickok45

    @johnhickok45

    27 күн бұрын

    Haha absolutely. Honestly I hate that you have to play these games but the algorithm is driven by comments in a big way. People respond better to something they might disagree with than something they agree with. I used to feel guilty about doing titles like this but at this point my attitude is as long as the content is pure I have a right and a responsibility to get people in the door however I can.

  • @denniscrowell3317
    @denniscrowell331726 күн бұрын

    Have one my grandfather sent back home very accurate. Pron to jamming. Sweet gun though

  • @trinab9612
    @trinab961223 күн бұрын

    How many soldiers carried these? We’re they issued in numbers equivalent to the M1 in US service or did a limited number of units have them?

  • @fload46d
    @fload46d25 күн бұрын

    What a heck of a rifle. Later they developed the Sturmgewehr.

  • @donswearingen9805
    @donswearingen980526 күн бұрын

    And no mention of the M1 Garand in the video. Although you did in the headline. Incidentally, the M1 was still in used in 1961 when I went through basic training with the Army. Although the troops in Europe were being issued the M-14.

  • @peterm7548
    @peterm754828 күн бұрын

    Jeez your'e a good shot!

  • @erwinschmidt7265
    @erwinschmidt726523 күн бұрын

    '90s when General Reno, & Handler some Slick Willy, said our churches had to be BATF Approved, I beat it to local Gun Club for NRA Natl Match Course, givin 5 - Cartridges in old worn-out Garand, but only put 3 holes in target @200 yds. Old WW2 surplus ammo, guys! Shots #1 & #2 both Rangers, #3 exact center of bullseye, #4 shot out glass spotter, & #5 shot out new glass spotter. So you're sayin' we should check out some come along too late for WW2 German semi-auto, to get better performance? Local Priest at Club borrowed target w/appropriate qualifications, was at local Business Supply for copies @8AM, put them in beautiful Oak Framed Plexi holders w/Local Press covering installation, ON EVERY CHURCH IN THE COUNTY!! RENO'S Henchmen showed up as threatened, studied Target on door...AND LEFT, never challenging Mich Milishia!!! M1 Garand to the rescue, one more time, my friends!!! Father had labeled target's, "New Member's First Day"!!!

  • @freedomishere868
    @freedomishere86823 күн бұрын

    Imagine if every German soldier had a G43 instead of a K98.

  • @andycandal5934
    @andycandal593428 күн бұрын

    The SL7 is a modern rendition of this rifle. The SL7 is a blowback rifle. Difficult to find and EXPENSIVE

  • @nomadmarauder-dw9re

    @nomadmarauder-dw9re

    28 күн бұрын

    SL 7 was a standard H&K in a G 43 looking stock. Nice attempt to jump the shark on the assault rifle ban. Thing is, people looked at it and wondered why.

  • @philipfreeman72
    @philipfreeman7220 күн бұрын

    Fuel was the German prob. They were running on charcoal fumes on trucks .

  • @martinfromseacity2010
    @martinfromseacity201026 күн бұрын

    Thanks

  • @N4JAB
    @N4JAB24 күн бұрын

    Having the m1Garand, SVT40 and the G43, I can say the Garand is the best all around. The other two are more finicky and delicate compared to the robust M1.

  • @couespursuit7350
    @couespursuit735028 күн бұрын

    Johnson Automatic was superior with its ability to top off magazine with 5 round stripper clips.

  • @kennethcaine3402
    @kennethcaine340228 күн бұрын

    You didn't show anything on the M1 Garand which was used by soldiers and Marines in WWII in Europe and the Pacific. My Father was in the 1st Marine Division in the Pacific, he was given a M1 Gurrand in boot camp in 1942 and when the war was over he turned the same one in, it had 3 machine gun rounds in the stock and it still functioned perfectly. That says a lot because on Cape Gloster it rained every day he was there and on Pelielu and Okinawa wasn't much better. I believe it speaks for itself.

  • @redtobertshateshandles

    @redtobertshateshandles

    28 күн бұрын

    Yep. It was so bad my wife's great uncle shot himself in the foot to get out of New Guinea. He was on the Kokoda track and his mate was killed by the Japs.

  • @bushcraft6884
    @bushcraft688428 күн бұрын

    I like the K98k and the Russian Mosin Nagant.