I would like to point out that I've only included some of what Yasir quoted that is originally from Abi Mikhnaf. There are other examples that I did not include since my intention was not to be comprehensive. There are other reports within Yasir's lecture that conflict with the authentic events, but I felt that this specific issue was necessary to highlight, since Yasir himself condemns Abu Mikhnaf as a source explicitly.

@lemonke3774

3 жыл бұрын

Congratulations on 23k subscribers, farid! And also on your 1 year anniversary! Subhanallah how fast time goes...

@yadadoo20

3 жыл бұрын

You mentioned that there is an authentic sunni narration in At Tabari from Hilal bin Yasaf. But you haven't linked to it. Nor did you show it in your video. You made the time and effort to show the narrations of Abu Mikhaf from al-Tabari's book that Yasir used to refute him. But then why didn't shows us the narration from Hilal in Tabari?

@go_gorgeous_diva9820

3 жыл бұрын

Oh no I hope he is not shia!

@imam-_-

3 жыл бұрын

''explicitly'' hmm I guess you have watched lots of YQ videos😉

@sheikprofessional

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you very much for exposing the unreliablness of YQ bcz many people follow his words blindly as authentic speech.

Farid you had to spend time looking into those books, finding the place Yassir was talking about and then do a video about it with the correct information. Appreciate your efforts man.

@abdelhakauxiliary7086

3 жыл бұрын

farid just proved being weasle capable of anything to draw more attention....... problem is, this implies disunity in islamic community, and for what?? making more views.... it became so low and this is big enough of a sin to destroy farid in a so simple, concise and clear refutation, so hear me well farid: In 2 hours of a lecture of Yasi qadhi, all you gave apart from the first two very pitiful attempts to poison the well for free i quote: 1."here is a lot to say about that" while in fact you bring nothing, just trying to make it sounds like there is a lot to say about the lecture 2."the issue is trusting yasir qadhi in his authority" what evidence do you give to refute his idjazat from madina??this is too low from some muslim to say that on another muslim without giving any evidence, and also, could you remind us what authority do you have in religion? perhaps the award for the most lunatic religious youtuber?? or the guy whose half of the arguments are "pffff, I'm not even going to comment on that" your whole arguments are about the fact that yasir qadhi used data cited in el-tabari which says: "ibn mikhnaf said:" ..... you have to be really stupid, or really bastard to bring up such an argument .. ..and I say this because it is very simple, either El-tabari and Ibn Katheer are indeed honest and knowledgeable Sunnis and their analysis of on or two informations given by Ibn Mikhnaf concluded that these two informations were correct and that they could therefore mention it in their books, otherwise they would have dismissed it if it was so "dangerous" as you ridiculously say (its you who put WARNING on the title) .... and Yasir qadhi all he did was trusting the authority of El tabari and Ibn Katheer, and so repeated exactly what they said. Or, its just that there is a little bastard in 2020 who dare to say behind his little room that El-Tabari Ibn Katheer and also Yasir qadhi are malicious people who pass themselves off as Sunnis while they are sympathizers of schiism, and thats why the all quoted ibn mikhnaf.... what a bastard you are...... and for what?? for some more stupid viewers on this dunya who are easily triggered when they hear the terms "Controversy, warning, danger, beware" about renowed scholars?

@1Tim1.15

3 жыл бұрын

@@abdelhakauxiliary7086 I strongly agree with u bro

@RK-ru4sb

3 жыл бұрын

@Shabaka Smkss better say Allah subhana wa ta'ala as a muslim brother and can you shortly explain what all of this trust thing is about and what abdelhax auxiliary wrote.

@infinitybay77

3 жыл бұрын

@@abdelhakauxiliary7086 Did you watch the complete video? Because in the video, while Farid does critics Yasir for taking things from the book of ibn Kathir that ibn Kathir has mentioned are from the shia book (Farid's mistake), Farid does mentions one point which Yasir directly took from the shia sources. I'm not saying Farid shouldn't be critiqued for his mistake but to call him a bastard is I think unwarranted. And we have already seen that Yasir Qadhi can sometimes make statements that are, to put nicely, controversial. So it isn't far fetched to criticize him (or doubt him) sometimes. That's not saying that Yasir isn't a scholar or that he is a bad person (Only Allah knows whats in his heart). Absolutely not. I've a lot of praise for him, and his lectures are quite fun to listen. But just because he is a good scholar doesn't makes him immune to criticism and doesn't makes anyone that criticizes him a "bastard" who is doing it "for the views". And it is a good thing to trust a good scholar's authority (since we might not be able research or verify everything ourselves) but if something (that he says) doesn't feel right to you, its a good thing to research and verify it yourself.

@safwanshahriar4108

3 жыл бұрын

@@abdelhakauxiliary7086 Would agree with you if it wasn't Yasir. I hate him for the sake of Allah.

Yasir qadhi makes mistakes, but that doesn't give anyone authority to call him a kaafir, etc. I'm not a supporter of him, nor a hater but people take it too far sometimes.

@servantofallah17

3 жыл бұрын

@@abdullahdawood1624 he's misguiding youth😭

@logicalreasoning1088

3 жыл бұрын

YOU SAY that’s a problem, let me ask you this, are you saying that everything in Abu Yakifs book is false? Every word? 1. Perhaps this is the individual who was closest to the events, and thus could be the only source who can provide certain details that would have otherwise been fabricated. Again confirmation Bias

@1210saad

3 жыл бұрын

lol

@ads1340

3 жыл бұрын

@@logicalreasoning1088 Yeah what I wanna know is the things yq quote from that Shia book, is that stuff which is written in our books referencing that book because its those parts which are agreed upon to have happened and so they are quoting it to show its even from the Shia books. There are versions of events which are agreed upon and so some stuff from the Shia sources may not contradict our narrative and some of our scholars may have added it into their historical interpretation to back up their point.

@TheJoker12323

3 жыл бұрын

he literally said that the Holy Quran has holes. That proves that maybe he said that intentionally. how can someone who is a "scholar" can be this ignorant about Islam?

Dear Brother Farid, I have high respect for you as you spend your time refuting the enemies of Islam and by doing so, you increase my faith in Islam. Yasir Qadhi too is someone that I look up to but just like everyone else, he is not infallible. If you could be more respectful to him, then we can come to a better understanding. I understand that YQ may have made some mistakes that emboldened people like David Wood, but please speak softly about Muslims. Allah loves those who are merciful to other believers. Jazakallah

@Life-bt9yo

3 жыл бұрын

Farid has had a problem with him for a long time. He's ususally very good at keeping that at bay but it comes out from time to time (especially on twitter)..this is one such disappointing occasion. I don't care about the particular people. I pray they enter Jannah and cross over the siraat with lightening speed and these differences don't come up as embarrassments for any of them. It's just the basic adab and goodwill to a fellow worshipper of Allah azawajal they neglect..the respect you should have for knowledge that Allah swt bestowed and behaviour you should have before Him swt because He's always watching, that these people forget that saddens me. They don't see this from the lay people's perspective. May Allah grant us strength in our imaan and guide our actions ameen.

@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543

3 жыл бұрын

@Mnm Mnm exactly! the big issue is he is an ikwani liar. he has lied on Umar, Ibn Adbul Wahab and supported she'as... he divided and infiltrates based on his gufi sufiness, the daughter cancer of neo paulin she'as! Yasir Qadhis' own teachers in Arabia refuted him!

@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543

3 жыл бұрын

this is why the salafi dawa is so important. REad Sheikh Albani's book Prophet's prayer!

@hussamhussain6243

3 жыл бұрын

@Mnm Mnm Yh, I understand that we should behave in a respectful manner however brother Farid has pointed out such a blunder. Of course no one is infallible however the integrity of Yasir Qadhis research is highly questionable now.

@emsa7esm203

3 жыл бұрын

This isn't about mistakes. It's about giving flat out wrong information. Anytime I hear a "scholar" speak and they give me weak hadiths or just flat out wrong information more than once without clarifying they are indeed WRONG. Then that person SHOULD be exposed because he is lying to layman people giving bad/untrustworthy accounts.

If I remember correctly at the start of the lecture, YQ mentioned that for certain details of the event we're gonna have to 'rely' on their sources (shias), he even mentioned that sunni scholars such as Tabari and Ibn Kathir Quotes Abu Mihknaf, because shias are the one who made a big deal out of these events, whereas sunnis don't go into the details as much. Its either on the karbala lecture or the Abdullah Ibn Zubayr lecture.

@sulwhale3171

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah

@sulwhale3171

2 жыл бұрын

Christian also know about the event

@sulwhale3171

2 жыл бұрын

Christian researches i meant they also talk about it historical Christian I meant

@sulwhale3171

2 жыл бұрын

You know what I mean

@khalil7011

2 жыл бұрын

@@sulwhale3171 No I actually don't.

Akhi you need to specify that tarikh attabari isn't like sahih al bukhari, it doesn't guarantee that all the infos in the book are leggit, it's just a collect of all the data that was going on

@ryuzaki5491

3 жыл бұрын

And that's the problem, it's a collection of data and when you don't verify where it came from, you'll gwt something like this. Where you'll say x is not authentic, but y and z are and quote x through y and z.

@yadadoo20

3 жыл бұрын

Why are we even comparing Tabari and Bukhari?Sahih Al Bukhari is a book of hadeeth and prophetic traditions. Authenticity is of paramount importance. Lying or passing down fabricated hadeeth can damage the ummah. Taarikh Al Tabrih is book of history. We don't take our aqeedah, fiqh from it. Using weak narrations is okay for historical accounts as most of history is passed down that way.

@Gazus12345

3 жыл бұрын

Sahih Bukhari isn't completely authentic either.

@mdfahd24

3 жыл бұрын

@@Gazus12345 But that's the most trusted source of Hadith.. Compiled & taken through best of the scholars & strong narrations of that time only.. Read the "Muqaddima"(Introduction) of Sahih Muslim, where Imam Muslim clarified why they made only "Sahih" collection plus you'll get the understanding of their hardwork & authenticity. Insha'Allah!

@alireza8395

3 жыл бұрын

@M A Sahih Bukhari has narrations that go against the Quran itself, so I guess not lol

Subhan'Allah. I watched this lecture way back and was glad we had a Sunni perspective, imagine my dissapointment when i see this video.

Stop giving the enemies of Islam a door to party when you attack your Muslim brother on every matter. And, I remember him mentioning that early Sunni scholars where taking from Abu Mikhnaf as well or did you miss that?

@bobbyjones8091

3 жыл бұрын

Yasir himself Opened the door to Attack Islam. Stop defending this misguided fool. Where is your gheerah for the religion when yasir clearly spreads falsehood.

@abdullaho5994

3 жыл бұрын

@@bobbyjones8091 Don't question my gheerah for the religion. I love my deen. But perhaps I'm a bit ignorant of what Yasir Qhadi has done so enlighten me.

@bobbyjones8091

3 жыл бұрын

@Peace Salaam He also has done more damage to Islam then i could ever do. The Masses he misguieded, isnt something you should brag about it.

@bobbyjones8091

3 жыл бұрын

@Peace Salaam there are plenty, he even doubts that the quran is preserved. so i dont know why you defend him. interesting that your straight up called me names like "madkhali". so the question what is your intentionhere, do you care for the truth or is it just your blind hatred for salafiyyah which makes you defend him and attack me.

@xlrsn

3 жыл бұрын

Agree man I'm literally sick of it, when we should fight against atheists but what are we doing is fight with each other. Trust me it is not helping.

Farid is the brother we neglect when times are good. Life is fun, we have lots of friends and we acknowledge him but choose to ignore him. Then when life turns upside down, friends leave, you're all alone, suddenly we're in a dark place. Then farid comes and comforts us and helps us in our moment of crisis. THANK YOU BRO! You have saved so many people with your videos. Keep up the good work. May Allah reward you. Ameen.

@FaridResponds

3 жыл бұрын

Barak Allah feekum.

@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543

3 жыл бұрын

@@FaridResponds wa Fikum BarakUllah!

@abdur-rahmanmuhammad3426

3 жыл бұрын

@@FaridResponds Bro let's come together (all scholars) to work as one Ummah to defend our deen and spread message of Islam. If one our scholar made a mistake let's call him and correct him in polite way without exposing his mistakes in public

@abdelhakauxiliary7086

3 жыл бұрын

farid just proved being weasle capable of anything to draw more attention....... problem is, this implies disunity in islamic community, and for what?? making more views.... it became so low and this is big enough of a sin to destroy farid in a so simple, concise and clear refutation, so hear me well farid: In 2 hours of a lecture of Yasi qadhi, all you gave apart from the first two very pitiful attempts to poison the well for free i quote: 1."here is a lot to say about that" while in fact you bring nothing, just trying to make it sounds like there is a lot to say about the lecture 2."the issue is trusting yasir qadhi in his authority" what evidence do you give to refute his idjazat from madina??this is too low from some muslim to say that on another muslim without giving any evidence, and also, could you remind us what authority do you have in religion? perhaps the award for the most lunatic religious youtuber?? or the guy whose half of the arguments are "pffff, I'm not even going to comment on that" your whole arguments are about the fact that yasir qadhi used data cited in el-tabari which says: "ibn mikhnaf said:" ..... you have to be really stupid, or really bastard to bring up such an argument .. ..and I say this because it is very simple, either El-tabari and Ibn Katheer are indeed honest and knowledgeable Sunnis and their analysis of on or two informations given by Ibn Mikhnaf concluded that these two informations were correct and that they could therefore mention it in their books, otherwise they would have dismissed it if it was so "dangerous" as you ridiculously say (its you who put WARNING on the title) .... and Yasir qadhi all he did was trusting the authority of El tabari and Ibn Katheer, and so repeated exactly what they said. Or, its just that there is a little bastard in 2020 who dare to say behind his little room that El-Tabari Ibn Katheer and also Yasir qadhi are malicious people who pass themselves off as Sunnis while they are sympathizers of schiism, and thats why the all quoted ibn mikhnaf.... what a bastard you are...... and for what?? for some more stupid viewers on this dunya who are easily triggered when they hear the terms "Controversy, warning, danger, beware" about renowed scholars?

@mathebatica9912

3 жыл бұрын

@@FaridResponds Assalammualaikum! Is it true what I learnt that Yasir Qadhi was an ex-Hindu before converted to ISLAM? That's all! Please correct me if I'm wrong.

Salaam, I am really not sure why you made this video, but I think in order to criticizes a scholar, yourself have to be a scholar or at least have some kind of knowledge in the similar field. In fact, scholars disagree with each other, but don’t criticize. Over the years, I’ve learned and benefited a lot from his knowledge. Hope you did as well. If you are specifically looking for problems and mistakes I am sure there are some. However, if you only focus on those, you will miss a lot of learning opportunities. May Allah guide all of us! Ameen

@user-em9of9ky1m

3 жыл бұрын

Agree. 100 % with you Elaine. United we stand. I don't understand refuting each other, especially scholars. This is some sort of stinginess

@user-em9of9ky1m

3 жыл бұрын

@@abdullahdawood1624 yes. True. But the way he has done it is questionable. I mean he should have just presented his view and moved on instead of refuting scholars. Why does not he appreciate Yasir qadhi for all his good works?

@SweetChilly0410

3 жыл бұрын

Mufti Menk once said an important thing.. That take away the good and leave the bad when it came to scholars.. Yasir Qadhi has his positive points.. So why not focus on that and then respectfully disagree the rest.. He is human after all

@sigmaspirits

3 жыл бұрын

@@abdullahdawood1624 what truth are you talking about?

@logicalreasoning1088

3 жыл бұрын

YOU SAY that’s a problem, let me ask you this, are you saying that everything in Abu Yakifs book is false? Every word? 1. Perhaps this is the individual who was closest to the events, and thus could be the only source who can provide certain details that would have otherwise been fabricated. Again confirmation Bias

Aye y’all a did my first refutation video!

@DrJames_YT

3 жыл бұрын

Sup bro

@lemonke3774

3 жыл бұрын

It’s about damn time you have! Mashallah may allah reward you for your efforts!

@jalaluddeenat-tabarithetim593

3 жыл бұрын

@Le Monke thanks for the support :D

@Mahmood.23

3 жыл бұрын

@Anon Ymous don't call that munafiq a "mufti" 🤡🤡

@lemonke3774

3 жыл бұрын

Anon Ymous I mean your idea of facts is what you want to hear so I don’t believe you for a second.

Maybe Yasir has not read Abi Mikhnaf's version and the other books Yaisr cited may have referenced Abi Mikhnaf's work. We can't say that all of Abi Mikhnaf's narrations on this event is fabricated. Other sunni historians may have authenticated his reports?

@swagmalone8092

3 жыл бұрын

That could be

@logicalreasoning1088

3 жыл бұрын

YOU SAY that’s a problem, let me ask you this, are you saying that everything in Abu Yakifs book is false? Every word? 1. Perhaps this is the individual who was closest to the events, and thus could be the only source who can provide certain details that would have otherwise been fabricated. Again confirmation Bias

@95Gred

3 жыл бұрын

Osama Manan im not sure about the status of Abu Mukhnaf. But if it’s like u said then my earlier comment in defence of yasir Qadhi won’t stand.

@logicalreasoning1088

3 жыл бұрын

95Gred No I’m am not! I agree, excellent point. May the almighty reward you

@affarokurz1486

3 жыл бұрын

@Osama Manan then what is his versions doing in Sunni sources then

Sick and tired of brothers bashing one another. It's exhausting :(

@user-em9of9ky1m

3 жыл бұрын

Agree. I think Farid has some vandetta with Yasir qadhi after that Quran variants instance.

@user-qb2lv8uo4x

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-em9of9ky1m Things like this do not strengthen your Imaan...its sets about doubt..in a world already bashing Islam, it is deflating to see our brothers arguing and picking...i say this about sister's too. I have watched Brother Yasirs lectures..and I have listened with awe...having lost my father recently, his lectures on Barzakh gave me much needed peace Alhumdhulilah. I am not dumb and I don't follow blindly iether. I am aware of some disturbing factors that have come up as matters of concern from The Yakeen Institute...but I don't like this 'jumped up' cat that got the cream attitude that is developing amongst us. May Allah guide and help us see the truth and follow Him. But this? I say, pick up Quran and stick to prayers and keep focussed as much as you can...i am not perfect. But there is good and bad in all... I have just had enough of this finger pointing. Allah swt will judge both brothers accordingly..until then use common sense and pray for a united Ummah. Shaitaan watches and chuckles with glee when disharmony is created. Don't allow him to win..

@user-em9of9ky1m

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-qb2lv8uo4x Oh my God. I've been watching his lecture on barzakh recently. He's a great scholar and has done great job. To pick and choose certain things and make refutation of his entire lecture is problematic. Life is too short. In the end only fear and hope of Allah persists in heart. May Allah bless us all. May Allah Grant unity in ummah. I feel a lot of positivity from you brother. If interested do drop a mail or any id on social media to get in touch. Jazak Allah 🙂

@abdelhakyac7285

3 жыл бұрын

Its just that these days, sorry to say it, but people use trends to make more viewers, and these days the trend is to attack yasir qadhi after the ahruf thing happened, and even if yasir qadhi explained himself in a new video the same the other guy adnan proposed that it has nothing to do with conservation, these guys still attack him, it makes more views, it became disgusting to see that in a supposed religious content

@syedsaad1594

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-em9of9ky1m You are probably the most naive, gullible & ignorant fanboy of YQ to exist on social media. And if you're intentionally acting like this, then I have sincere hatred for you. What else would it take for you to change your mind about this extreme deviant YQ?? The one who considers himself to be the only true representative of Islam in America, and the major scholars of this ummah have no idea about the dynamics of the west, so we shouldn't derive rulings from them?? This sort of extreme arrogance is proof enough of his " sincerity". Ohhh, pulling the classic "quoting things out of context" argument and making excuses for him again and again, accusing others of a "vendetta" against him .... seriously, give us a break, you utter miskeen. How long are you ignorant people going to continue doing this?? I'm sure if it was someone else, people like you would have quickly jumped to conclusions. But hey, it's your favorite celebrity "sheikh" YQ, a "PhD" doctor who, as a "proud American" feels the need to reform Islam and the interpretations of the sharee'ah to make it compatible with the west, because too many American Muslims are leaving Islam, and this is somehow going to make them stop?? Yeah, what a brilliant idea!!!! Instead of building the foundation of our religion, we should all look for compatibility with the west!!! Because frankly, the shuyookh sitting in Saudi Arabia ... what do they know about the dynamics of the west?? They don't have "phD" from Yale like he has, and only he (the great scholar) hknows all about the dynamics of the West, and how to teach Islam to braindead Americans. This is what your "great scholar" believes in. This is how he addresses the scholars of this ummah. And he has not once apologized, instead he continues to express such sentiments to this day. Seriously, shame on you. SHAME ON YOU & anyone who still supports this deviant ideology. Maybe one day you will understand when he is openly going to come & ask you Muslims to stop believing Qur'an as an authentic source and instead, just accept from the book what agrees with your intellect. But then the damage will already be done. The damage is already pretty evident through people like you going to extreme lengths to defend & protect the likes of YQ and attacking those who try to advise you regarding his misguidance. It breaks my heart to see this attitude of Muslims towards safeguarding their iman, and people like you are the same ones who always play that overused "don't judge others" card, as if it is a very trivial matter, and everyone should just stop enjoining good & forbidding evil. This filthy modernist mentality is what makes people like you a cancer to the true teachings of islam. May Allaah treat all of them the way they deserve to be treated. If only people like YQ had any fear of Allaah. But it is clear from his demeanor that he is an extremely arrogant,a selfish and a misguided preacher who only mistakenly considers himself to be a flag-bearer of Islam in the west. But in reality, is only being played by the devil.

Keep up the good work bro. You are providing an amazing resource.

excellent work! it important to learn the correct info

BarakAllah feek Farid for making this clear, this is an evidence to check the information we get. I myself saw this video and even told it to may family and discussed it with other Sunni Muslims thinking that this was the Sunni narrative but to my surprise it wasn't! Slowly but surely Yasser Qadhi has in my eyes lost all credibility.

@logicalreasoning1088

3 жыл бұрын

YOU SAY that’s a problem, let me ask you this, are you saying that everything in Abu Yakifs book is false? Every word? 1. Perhaps this is the individual who was closest to the events, and thus could be the only source who can provide certain details that would have otherwise been fabricated. Again confirmation Bias

Yasir Qadhi, unlike Abu Layth and Rafidah, is not a heretic. If he makes mistakes, call him out respectfully. I think you were not respectful here.

@f1aziz

3 жыл бұрын

This video has been watched hundreds of thousands of times and is still on the Internet, if YQ accepts he made a mistake and recant his lecture, then what you said is fair enough. So far YQ hasn't admitted his mistake and deserves to be called out.

@ThomasDevereaux-le8mq

3 жыл бұрын

Can we name one muslim scholar, leader, etc., today who is free from making mistakes?

@f1aziz

3 жыл бұрын

@@ThomasDevereaux-le8mq The problem is not with making a mistake, anyone can make a mistake. The problem is not accepting you made a mistake and making corrections even in the face of concrete evidence of your mistake.

@arie188701

3 жыл бұрын

@@f1aziz good one, my brother...

@AndysMusicPod

3 жыл бұрын

@@ThomasDevereaux-le8mq absolutely right brother. Even Allah makes mistakes, how can we expect ourselves to be perfect brother ?

The comment section shows the real reason why Muslim can be so easily divided... fighting over a video made 7 years ago..

@AndysMusicPod

3 жыл бұрын

It's because of drinking water from pond having dead donkeys 🙃

@adamaze2920

3 жыл бұрын

@@AndysMusicPod Dey Onaka roomba rangi lah... Mutal Pailek

@killphaser25

3 жыл бұрын

Correction. Fighting over a video that has been watched multiple times by sunnis. A video that is still out there. You are saying as if that video has been deleted

@abhmd4481

3 жыл бұрын

@@AndysMusicPod or doing beastiality which is okay according to atheists

True Farid bro, I watched this video of Yasir and it really changed my view for Karbala. Thank you for your video and mentioning the flaws that video had. Yasir please prepare yourself. May Allah guide us all. aameen.

I don't understand how can a scholar like yasir mention weak hadith to the audience even after knowing those hadiths are not authentic ! It's so hard for me to digest. THANK YOU BRO FARID FOR CLEARING IT OUT!

@salhim.9409

2 жыл бұрын

He is not a scholar

@salhim.9409

2 жыл бұрын

@SHOW ME WHAT YOU GOT Yassir Qadi is not a Scholar. He is a student of Knowledge

Despite all the controversies of YQ, I thought this was an excellent informative lecture, he made a few mistakes yes but he is human. Him mentioning a couple incidents originating from Shia sources against his own principle of givng the sunni narrative is obviously unintentional. Regardless, those incidents are not problematic from the Sunni perspective.

@aliibrahim4390

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly

@Nima-ec4tr

2 жыл бұрын

for man who acts like he knows it its really so to be that much fool

@MineMeMineMeMineMe

2 жыл бұрын

That's not unintentional! Yasir Qadhi was trained by father of shias i.e. Secular Jews who are running religious studies departments at Yale University and other western universitues including Harvard, Uchicago, Utoronto and many others. . Shias have picked up Mutah and Some usool e fiqh of Jews directly from talmud.

@hamzakhairi4765

Жыл бұрын

I agree I didnt see anything here that made me question yasir qadhi too much at least no more than usual

@reptilespit4433

Жыл бұрын

How's someone's suppose to know where & when he makes sloppy mistakes of quoting from the books he says are unreliable?

Trust me and my authority Says the wise man !

May Allah keep you safe, brother. You are awesome ❤

جزاك الله خيرًا

There were disclaimers at the beginning of the video, you may wanna watch those. Are you suggesting the source is exclusively from this book you are showing? are there no other book from where Yasir Qadhi could have quoted the same thing from? his version concentrates on Ibn Kathir, and he is not wrong to quote from Ibn Kathir quoting abu makhnaf (pardon the spelling) if it is in that book or other sources. he explicitly said that he wont be going over the detailed reasoning behind his beliefs but just drag the summary out of it. Now taking parts of his video as quotation is problematic in my opinion because we should not quote from summarized information. Taking it as a monologue of a detailed study can be more a righteous approach.

Is it possible that ibn Kathir and at Tabari would have quoted abi makhnaf because they agreed with his interpretation of events? Becuase surely there must have been overlapping points. So these maybe were just some of those?

@arifabd

3 жыл бұрын

@@arshaanfur I think Tabari and Ibn Kathir was just tabling the alternative opinions for their readership. They were not necessarily agreeing to them. This possibility has credence because the standard Sunni position conflicts with those narratives and that is why Farid picked on those specific points. Tabari and Ibn Kathir must have tabled these standard sunni positions as well in their book. But I do not know for sure. But I would be surprised if it wasn't.

@Really_Biggah

3 жыл бұрын

Ibn kathir and at Tabari quote things they don’t agree with all the time...

@claudemonet7404

3 жыл бұрын

@@arshaanfur At Tabari collects all narrations including weak narrations in one place & says it is upon researchers to find out what is accurate.

@arshaanfur

3 жыл бұрын

@@claudemonet7404 Farid clarified the same on twitter. Thank you.

@lion_hawk

3 жыл бұрын

Read the introduction of Tarikh Attabary . He says that he didn't made it upon himself to state authentic hadiths and information...

thank you for the videos brother

Masha Allah! Brother Saajid wasn't incorrect. Alhumdulillah. May Allah preserve him, and may Allah preserve you brother Farid.

Jazakallah khair br. Can you please make a full lecture/s about this topic (historical event), or point to any other lecture I can listen to. Also a series on the Seera in detail, chronologically. This is a BIG task and im sure the reward will be too

@FaridResponds

3 жыл бұрын

See community tab.

ALhamdulillah for this knowledge akhi. May Allah bless you. Barakallahu feek.

Brother Farid, did you try and reach out to YQ to discuss these issues. Instead of tearing the brother down on KZread?

@Joseph-qb1es

3 жыл бұрын

Are you real

@imranhaa

3 жыл бұрын

He makes a valid point, did he try to reach out or just post this KZread video so he gets views on the back of a well known scholar?

@glokta1

3 жыл бұрын

Probably not because it's become a trend on Muslim KZread to air disagreements on a loudspeaker to attract views -- to "expose" and "call out" fellow Muslims rather than discussing disagreements in private. This is so cringeworthy and sad.

Barak'Allahu feek I didn't expect

4:46 this says it all. This is exactly Yasir Qadhi had those disclaimers. Yasir Qadhi is quoting Tabari and it was Tabari who was quoting 'Abi Miqnaf'. This means that all that is contained in his work may not be incorrect and Tabari knows what to take and what not to from Abu Miqnaf's work.

@aniiss04

3 жыл бұрын

Interestingly, Al-Tabari himself makes the disclaimer that if something is wrong in his book, then we should not take is as its not his fault but rather due to the primary sources. Watch Farids Video regarding Karbala إن شاء الله

@shabeerali1256

3 жыл бұрын

@@aniiss04 Tabari is not an exception in this. Every scholar would say the same.

@Nima-ec4tr

2 жыл бұрын

@@shabeerali1256 for god sake don't u get it he is telling us as a fact what the shia dude said as if its a truth yq

Brother Farid. I found your channel recently. Since 2015 I first found about David Wood. And I dislikes his lies. Ur destroyed his lies. Please make more videos refuting him.

Thanks for exposing him further.

im glade you talked about him Muslims youtubers and scholars and imams who do so much for the ummah and are also part of the sunnah ,still associate themselves with him for some reason idk(Please dont call out their names) Its not possible that they dont know about his "beliefs" May Allah guide us all and make us sincere

@cOnfidentialcOrp

3 жыл бұрын

but the ones who used to associate themselves with him,they dont talk about it but atleast they dont associate themselves with him anymore

Pls for sake of allah have some personal unmonitored talk with yasir qadhi.

@RK-ru4sb

3 жыл бұрын

Better say Allah subhana wa ta'ala as a muslim for example but still I agree

@holdshiftt2run308

3 жыл бұрын

Well, he keeps declining people who want to discuss it. He makes posts about people backbiting, having haters and whatnot every time he is refuted.

@Nima-ec4tr

2 жыл бұрын

@@jellyfishi_ so dude telling others that what this guy said is wrong is not backbiting lol go study what backbiting is more over warning about others is ok to and if u think it is wrong to out and tell someone is wrong then what is this comment of yours here ? are u two faced before u go out to to say u r not two faced read the other 2 at the top bro

The signs that prove the prophecy of Muhammad  are numerous. Many books have been written to enumerate them and thoroughly discuss them. We would like to mention some of these signs as reported by Muslim scholars and which prove that Muhammad  was a real Prophet including: - First, his good biography and high morals as well as the noble qualities that distinguished him. He was known before becoming a Prophet as a truthful and honest person, although the community where he lived was a society of ignorance. This was, perhaps, the most important sign of his prophecy. He was not known to have ever lied on people. So, why should he lie on be half of the Lord by claiming that he was a Prophet, if he was not a real Prophet? - Second, the powers and triumphs Allah gave him and the spread of the religion he preached, as well as the triumph of this religion over all existing religions in a short period of time. Had he been a liar, Allah would have humiliated and destroyed him as He did with those before him who falsely claimed Prophethood. - Third, the miracles Allah gave him as supporting evidence were beyond the ability of human beings and were beyond range of natural phenomena. The moon split for him, water gushed from his fingers, food became more abundant in his hands, and similar phenomena were authentically reported and happened in a way that could not be denied. - Fourth, the Prophet  was backed by the greatest miracle which is the Quran. In fact, Quran was a challenge and remains a challenge for Arabs who were known to be good poets and eloquent speakers. Allah challenged them to write a single Surah (chapter) that would be similar to that of Quran, but the Arabs were unable to do so. Indeed, the challenge still endures, none of the Arabs throughout history - since the revelation of the Quran - was able to make anything that was even similar to it. No doubt that the Quran has been preserved intact until it came to us. Groups of people memorized it including children, adults, males and females. So generations brought the Quran to generations until it reached us as it was revealed 14 centuries ago. Hence, the Quran remains intact protected from distortion or alteration. Nothing has been added to it, nor taken from it. Quran is full of scientific facts that were verified only in these times of scientific investigation. No doubt that Muhammad who was illiterate would not have possessed this knowledge 14 centuries ago. Doesn't this prove the authenticity of the Quran and that it is the Word of the Creator of the Universe who knows all its secrets? - Fifth, the things from the unseen that he (the Prophet ) informed us about. Some of them occurred during his life time. Others happened later. Some of these things happened to the Prophets, may Allah exalt their mention, who preceded him and some are still to occur. He also informed about the signs of The Day of Judgment, some of which had already been seen such as widespread killings and genocide, adultery and fornication and the consumption of the alcohol, outnumbering of males by females and the increased number of earthquakes, and afflictions,… etc. - Sixth, the testimony of some of the people of the Book that he was a true Prophet. Some of them believed in him like 'Abdullah Ibn Salam  who was a Jew as well as Negus (king of Abyssinia) who was a Christian. Some of the people of the Book certified that he was a Prophet from Allah but refused to follow him like Huyayy Ibn Akhtab. The above are some of the signs that prove his Prophethood and the authenticity of his revelations. We would like the questioner to visit some of the Islamic centers in her area, and hopefully, they will guide her to some useful references in the matter.

Can anyone guide me to the most authentic book or lecture on the events that took place in the tragedy of Karbala?

@hanbali_

7 ай бұрын

Farid has one on youtubr

جزاكم الله خيرا

Yea Bro Farid , you’re right but the sheikh clearly stated that because the Shia narrator has his own biases and would subjectively narrate some versions of the Karbala story that would suits his Shia prospective, we as Sunnis wouldn’t want trust 100% of anything coming from a Shia.

@logicalreasoning1088

3 жыл бұрын

YOU SAY that’s a problem, let me ask you this, are you saying that everything in Abu Yakifs book is false? Every word? 1. Perhaps this is the individual who was closest to the events, and thus could be the only source who can provide certain details that would have otherwise been fabricated. Again confirmation Bias

U r refuting a six years old video that too on such pity issue ? R u serious What wrong if some one makes some mistakes n learn, grow up and move forward in 6 year. What exactly u wanna prove

@logicalreasoning1088

3 жыл бұрын

YOU SAY that’s a problem, let me ask you this, are you saying that everything in Abu Yakifs book is false? Every word? 1. Perhaps this is the individual who was closest to the events, and thus could be the only source who can provide certain details that would have otherwise been fabricated. Again confirmation Bias

@AndysMusicPod

3 жыл бұрын

Speaking of number six, what was aisha's age when she was kidnapped.... 😂

@logicalreasoning1088

3 жыл бұрын

I'm a Binary Code kidnapped, WTF are you talking about? Go wash it soap and water (your ass) from all of the crusting

@AndysMusicPod

3 жыл бұрын

@@logicalreasoning1088 I'm saying Muhammad kidnapped aisha. Can't read ? Atleast I'll refrain from drinking water from a pond that has a dead donkey, menstrual blood and dead dogs etc...

@AndysMusicPod

3 жыл бұрын

@@theoneandonlyhooda I have sahih hadeeth. But unfortunately it's dayif by your braindead standards 😂😂😂 Funny how Aisha herself says she was 6 and you want me to believe you 😂😂😂 Pity..

Best channel on KZread !

This lecture is from 2013! What is your motive brother? Fear Allah!! Let it go!!!! Make dua for Yasir Qadhis guidance!!! 2moro is Ashura 2020!!!

@hmzzrg5045

3 жыл бұрын

his motive is to guide gullible Muslims who got confused by Yasir Qadhi what are you talking about? And what does Ashura have to do with anything?

@Abrock730

3 жыл бұрын

@@hmzzrg5045 You are 7 years and 3 months late! 16 others get it! May Allah increase you in knowledge! Im totally aware of Yasir Qadhi, his history and positions! Go back and listen and look at the day on the Islamic calendar. Do younot know the relationship between Karbala and Ashura? Ahsura and Musa and The Sunna of Rasul(ص)؟Then maybe you will get it! Relax on the social media brother! Think b4 you post and before talking in real life! And from the looks of it you and i agree! Yasir Qadhi has nad more outlandish and poisonous claims and statements well after this vedio! So when I say let go of something from 7 years ago there is more harmful stuff he has posted within the last 7 months! Yet all one can do is pray for his guidance and educate themselves my young brother. سلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته!!

@hmzzrg5045

3 жыл бұрын

@@Abrock730 I don't think it should be let go I just got to it and that reminder protected me from being misguided with lies about the Sirah idk how one can say fear Allah as if he did something wrong a person in such a high position that gets advised privately and doesn't go back on his statements should be refuted publicly and it isn't considered backbiting and alhamdulillah we agree that he has made worse claims recently with the whole preservation of the Quran scandal may Allah keep us steadfast and increase us in knowledge inchallah and I am sorry if I seemed aggressive I really wasn't but didn't understand the whole fear Allah as if he did something bad

@hmzzrg5045

3 жыл бұрын

@Hamza stepped out of line for shedding light on that nonsense? YQ hides before some sort of scientific methodology so if he doesn't follow it then he should be exposed and he did correct a problem I wouldn't have had the knowledge to face these fabrications and the division was already clear with all the crazy ideas YQ brings it is dangerous to learn from him in my eyes

@hmzzrg5045

3 жыл бұрын

@Hamza could've said the same about your opinion that brother Farid crossed a line I explained how what he did made sense and you tell me to keep it to myself in that case just open word and answer to your own statements if you think like that

Well done Farid!, these mistakes need to be pointed out 👌👏

Brother source you are quoting can you mention that please? Or it is same traditional islamic history? The established islamic history?

Brother ! Where to buy this edition of Makhtal e hussain of Abu mikhnaf...

I usually press the like button at the beginning of Farids videos, but this time I pressed the like button after watching the full video. Because I wanted to hear him out and I agree with him.

So how about enlightening us all with the “authentic “ Sunni version, rather than just making a brief comment on Qadhis supposedly “non authentic” Sunni version. People are more interested in acquiring and gaining serious knowledge rather than commenting on point scoring and personal ratings

@FaridResponds

3 жыл бұрын

I made a video about that two years ago on the Sunni Defense channel.

@leonzaki

3 жыл бұрын

Bro he is not trying to gain personal rating or showing off his knowledge or something, but he is trying to warn us about yasir talk, he usually mix truth with false, as far i have seen. And about Our Brother Farid, according to Islam, its a duty upon every single Muslim who see any t Fitna or wrong spreading he should stop it, if he can or else 'he will be accountable'. So he is doing haq, his job, try and understand before commenting.

Wow! Can't believe it , well spotted brother farid 👍🏼 , I watch yasir qadi videos I think his got decent knowledge, but can't believe how he got muddled up here 😳.

Great work brother 👍

I liked this video and I even wrote notes

Wallahi you are not lying. I have watched that video of YQ exactly because I wanted to know the Sunni version and what truly happened at Karbala.

@sheikprofessional

3 жыл бұрын

The scholars were already warning of the likes of YQ now you was also their victim

@look4yourself650

3 жыл бұрын

If you understand Urdu, watch this detailed lecture of the Sunni Research Scholar Hafidh Abu Yahya Noorpuri: Ahle bait ky qatil kon? Who Murdered Hazrat Husain? Sunni Shia Kitabon sy, Hafiz Abu Yahya Noorpuri.

@sheikprofessional

3 жыл бұрын

@@look4yourself650 I have watched it bro and I love abu yahya Noor puri may Allah bless us the company of good and authentic scholars

@look4yourself650

3 жыл бұрын

@@sheikprofessional Ameen !

@themistersmith

3 жыл бұрын

As I said earlier, history is not wahy, so it is continually open to debate

What is the context behind why Abu mihnaf is in the sunni scholars books

Is there anyone else on KZread with the seerah please who can I listen to Thanks

@FaridResponds

11 ай бұрын

Abdul Nasir Jangda and Uthman bin Farooq.

@el_mki2602

11 ай бұрын

@@FaridResponds barakallah u fiik! finally i can study the seerah! this is going to be my first time knowing something about the prophet and i dont know arabic barakallah u fik!

But is it a good idea to trust armchair scholars over real scholars?

@madkhalisupremacy

3 жыл бұрын

Certainly you dont trust keyboard warriors

@checkmate5338

3 жыл бұрын

@@madkhalisupremacy yeah i agree.

@user-bq3cw3bw8t

3 жыл бұрын

Did Farid consider himself to be a scholar? Who from the scholars of Islam consider Qadhi to be a scholar?

@checkmate5338

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-bq3cw3bw8t YQ has a masters in theology graduating from Madinah.

السلام عليكم و رحمة الله وبركاته 🙂

@aboosameer

3 жыл бұрын

‎وَعَلَيْكُمُ ٱلسَّلَامُ وَرَحْمَةُ ٱللَّٰهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ

@warsandempires8208

3 жыл бұрын

و عليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته

jzkAllah khair.

It’s very possible that Shia and Sunni sources overlap mostly I’m not sure what the issue is.

Guys let’s get farid to 23k subscribers before his 1 year anniversary! BTW how will you celebrate such an achievement?

Man if I could do on my papers what Yasir does at 10:40 school would be so much easier 😪

@logicalreasoning1088

3 жыл бұрын

YOU SAY that’s a problem, let me ask you this, are you saying that everything in Abu Yakifs book is false? Every word? 1. Perhaps this is the individual who was closest to the events, and thus could be the only source who can provide certain details that would have otherwise been fabricated. Again confirmation Bias

@muhammadnouman5031

Жыл бұрын

​@@logicalreasoning1088 That's what Yasir Qaadhi said, lol. He said that he (Abu Yakif) is unreliable and such and such but then he (Yasir Qadhi) is quoting from him. Imagine someone (Let's say person A) says this X person is not reliable historian, he's biased and such and such. Then A says ok, I can't provide you the sources, you have to trust me and my authority then he himself (person A) quotes from the historical narrations of person X. You see the problem there?

@logicalreasoning1088

Жыл бұрын

@@muhammadnouman5031 Well reliability is based on what? If a person is inaccurate on a few occasions, he can be deemed unreliable. That said, doesn’t mean they’re unreliable on everything. In this case he was the first person to report on the incident. Truth be told, Yazeed is unreliable. So when he says he had nothing to do with it, can we deem him truthful?

@mcsponge3899

4 ай бұрын

​@@logicalreasoning1088 It seems you missed the point of the video and nearly every comment you responded to. Most of these people, and the video, aren't even talking about whether Abu Yakif is actually unreliable. It's talking about how Yasir is being shown to contradict himself left and right here. You're attempting to start debates that are unrelated, and you say "Every word?" as if that matters. Even if there's a little bit of truth in a work, that does not mean that the writer is still not potentially unreliable or a liar. LITERALLY every single word being wrong is not the argument here at all either, you're strawmanning heavily.

@logicalreasoning1088

4 ай бұрын

@@mcsponge3899 you’re responding to a comment I made 3 years ago. I which I remembered any of it, I’d give a reply.

So what is the take home message? Should part of Abu Maknaf’s narration be trusted since Ibn Katheer also quoted from him? And as for Yasir sahib, was he being ‘deceptive’ or he didn’t actually prepare well to check and get his references? I just want to know

Always have to be careful and double check where someone is getting their information including the scholars of old. Thanks for the correction and the video should be tagged/updated or simply removed.

I can tell from day one when I was even fifteen years old yaser alacadhi always gave a summarized virgin and he has no time to sum everything up

@123littleleaf

3 жыл бұрын

Version 🙈 not virgin 😂 you guys are obsessed with virgins !

He said "By enlarge" That means most part. Getting the details if available from sources is not wrong unless it contradicts with the whole narrative. Don't lower your standard Farid.

Would you like to have a dialogue on the same?

Salaam, may Allah (swt) reward you for your continued efforts. I tried to contact you on twitter but im not able to message ypu for some reason. I was hoping of you could give me a reference to where i can find a sanad for the 10 Qurra of the Quran. Including an alternate asaneed for Imam Khalaf because his qiraat and his riwayat are in fact different. Jazakullah khair and may Allah (swt) accept your diligent efforts PS, There is a very good 1 hour long video of a "SUNNI DEFENDING" their narrative of events online. Im not sure why Farid didnt post the link on his website, but he definitely knows the video im referring to ;)

YOU SAY that’s a problem, let me ask you this, are you saying that everything in Abu Yakifs book is false? Every word? 1. Perhaps this is the individual who was closest to the events, and thus could be the only source who can provide certain details that would have otherwise been fabricated. Again confirmation Bias

@affarokurz1486

3 жыл бұрын

exactly he didn't explain why tabrani qouted him maybe he trusted that part

@jabir5768

3 жыл бұрын

@@affarokurz1486 fair point

@aniiss04

3 жыл бұрын

1) If you looked at the material from Abu Mikhnaf, you would come to the conclusion that this individual seemingly had access to letters back then that were sent to one another by spies. However, only this guy Abu Mikhnaf had access to all that stuff

@aniiss04

3 жыл бұрын

2) You say "perhaps" he was! That's a pure assumption and if we as Ahl-Sunnah don't know these important things, then he is was madjhool (unknown) and therefore he is rejected as well!

@aniiss04

3 жыл бұрын

3) Al-Tabari himself says in his book that if something is wrong we should not take it as it wasn't his fault but rather due to the issues with the primary sources.

It was really good. In fact, I’m gonna watch it again.

@brother Farid. Why did the Sunni authorities quote that Shia historian? Did they put a disclaimer after quoting him? Maybe they put it in because that part agreed to the Sunni narrative and hence YQ mentions it.

@FaridResponds

3 жыл бұрын

Historians quote everything including material that they don't believe in. Yasir makes a point that he won't quote Abu Mikhnaf, but does so.

Salaam bro Farid. How's it going? Could you give us an exhaustive narrative on the Karbala tragedy? Of course, not as a refutation of anyone but as an academic coverage of the story. I think you doing so, will be a better refutation rather than comparing it to anybody. Wasalaam.

@hanbali_

7 ай бұрын

He has a vid on it already, jus type in karbala and farid

This should have been discussed with him. Brings disunity

@AndysMusicPod

3 жыл бұрын

That's exactly what he wants! Gaining popularity using others

@AndysMusicPod

3 жыл бұрын

@Kamar el-Dawla Fawzy absolutely right brother, as a Muslim you have said one sensible statement your entire life. I appreciate your attempt

@AndysMusicPod

3 жыл бұрын

@Kamar el-Dawla Fawzy You don't have to go through all this my dear friend. Forget Allah, rely on Muhammad. "Life is all about stress management. If you can't handle it, you can kill yourself" - Mohammad Hijab ( Muslim Apologist ) Inspiration : Life of Muhammad ( caveman )

@AndysMusicPod

3 жыл бұрын

@Kamar el-Dawla Fawzy So when I quote him, you interpret it as me asking you to end your life But when that mongoose said it, it's just life advice 😂😂😂 Hypocrite 🤢 Get a life man. You aren't seeking truth. Cz if you were you would have condemned hijab for his stupid so called advice. Here you are shameless defending him and condemning me for quoting YOUR BELOVED TALL BULK OF NOTHINGNESS 😂 Anyways, all that's Islamic Inspiration, quotation, and practice. Just reminded you 😂😂 Ex-muslim

@abhmd4481

3 жыл бұрын

@@AndysMusicPod why are you mad? lol need a towel?

Where is Imam Murrah? I come to Farid's comment section to like Imam Murrah, Jalaluddeen and Ibn Murrah's comments.

More respect to you sheikh Farid. You make refutation on mistakes of dr Yasir Qadhi without takfeer, without using any bad words. THIS IS A QUALITY OF REAL SHEIKH WITHOUT ANY FIRQAWARIYAT.

@Akhan-di1gn

3 жыл бұрын

And in my opinion u r right that dr. Yasir Qadhi makes mistakes bcz he don't prepared for lectures. And he is not get in touched with other scholars( This is also very important thing to All muslims.)

can you please make an actual video on this topic based on the sunni side.

@FaridResponds

3 жыл бұрын

I did. Two years ago. It is on the Sunni Defense channel.

I watched 1 or 2 videos by Qadhi years ago, and I didn't like him, so I never clicked on any videos of his ever since. It's not like you truly dislike someone, but this happens; sometimes you just don't incline towards a person, without even knowing why. Perhaps it's the way someone presents himself, or how he speaks or whatever it may be. I think it has to do with how much of yourself you see in another person. I've never given him any thought or time of mine, and I only hear about him whenever these controversial statements are addressed by other Muslims. Obviously, the "narrative has holes" debacle, or his opposition to Kalaam, and now this. You know, this phenomenon in itself is quite interesting; why we gravitate towards some speakers, but dismiss others, even though we could potentially learn things from them. When you said that millions of Muslims have watched this lecture of his, I'm just left wondering why so many people gravitate toward this brother. I don't even think he's particularly eloquent, and he doesn't seem to have the type of far-reaching knowledge that you often see in other speakers. I don't know, he lacks a certain appeal.. that's just my personal opinion.

@mustafaibnabdullah6392

3 жыл бұрын

I have exactly the same with him, but i very much gravitate to hamza yusuf and nouman ali khan

Bro, please, if you're a bit more respectful with YQ, perhaps he'll even listen to you! أَشِدَّاءُ عَلَى الْكُفَّارِ رُحَمَاءُ بَيْنَهُمْ 48:29

@garsayfsomali

3 жыл бұрын

Don't use this ayab on farid for he has always been rough on the non muslims. Go to his playlist and check it out for your self

@ColdDeath1408

3 жыл бұрын

@@garsayfsomali lol so are you straight up calling YQ a non muslim?

@garsayfsomali

3 жыл бұрын

@@ColdDeath1408 subhannallah that wasn't my intention. I absolutely respect and love Yasir Qadhi. I meant something else

@ColdDeath1408

3 жыл бұрын

@@garsayfsomali my bad, alot of people have the extreme perception that because YQ makes mistakes he is somehow a deviant

@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543

3 жыл бұрын

the big issue is he is an ikwani liar. he has lied on Umar, Ibn Adbul Wahab and supported she'as... he divided and infiltrates based on his gufi sufiness, the daughter cancer of neo paulin she'as! Yasir Qadhis' own teachers in Arabia refuted him!

Is it then fair to say that everything in the book of Mikhnaaf is Not Authentic?? Because it is found in ,Ibn Alhadjr and Ibn Kaseer, ??

Mashaa ALLAH. May ALLAH accept your efforts, brother Farid. May ALLAH grant you jannatul ferdous. Ameen. Jazakallahu khair.

You should have stated the sunni perspective for these events(with references) and how does that differ from yasir qadhi's statements. Because your video only shows that sunni scholars accept some of abu makhnaf's discription of events. If there is an alternative storyline you should have stated that.

@HajjiJesus

3 жыл бұрын

If the source is Abu Makhnaf, run away from it. Abu Makhnaf story is science fiction, you will not be able to believe it. If there was second source, then that should have taken priority. Facts that there is done, means there is nothing. Scholars Qoute weak sources to give the reader all what is said from given event, not that they believe it.

@xorpe7172

3 жыл бұрын

M A Then why doesn’t Farid show us the actual opinions of the Sunni scholars, which should no doubt be just below those quotes of Abu Makhnaf rather than just saying “He’s just quoting”. “Just quoting” doesn’t necessitate that the Sunni scholars *dont* agree with what is written just as much as it doesn’t necessitate that they do

@danoneall4013

3 жыл бұрын

@@xorpe7172 - I agree 100% I love Br Farid. I love Sheikh Qadhi. I feel that Br Faird should have made the Sunni perspective when he claims Sheikh Qadhi was quoting the "Shia" book. It would be nice to hear

@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543

3 жыл бұрын

@@danoneall4013 Watch Yasir Qadhi refutes Yasir Qadhi he lies, in traditional Islam you can't take info from a liar! he lies on Umar, Ibn Abdul Wahab, she'as, lies about Sunnis. hes ikwani like yaqin maybe children of Adam mated with homoinid moneys institute which is now called doubt institute!

@danoneall4013

3 жыл бұрын

@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 - I'm not here to protect Sheikh Qadhi All I am saying is that Br Farid should have given the Sunni perspective when he says Sheikh Qadhi was quoting Shia sources. I'm sure there are some quotes belief in history that Sunni Muslims have that are the same as Shia in some areas. Doesn't mean Sunnis are quoting from the Shia etc etc.

The standard narrative of Karbala has HOLES in it. Edit: It was just a joke. Calm down😂😂😂.

@TomSuckAtFinance

3 жыл бұрын

Troll, get a life

@1Tim1.15

3 жыл бұрын

lol... i heard someone say "Holey Quran" 😂😂😂😂... get it .... 😉

@sadekirfan8582

3 жыл бұрын

@@TomSuckAtFinance vai Mohammed hijav and Apus er debate dekhso?

@AhmedBAY

3 жыл бұрын

@[DELETED] nonsense, Get lost.

@AhmedBAY

3 жыл бұрын

@[DELETED] i was talking about your language 😒😒.

I'm waiting for someone to link the vid of farid's in the comments lol I'm so early ibn murrah and imam murrah aren't even here

@jalaluddeenat-tabarithetim593

3 жыл бұрын

@Muhtasim but i was here. why did you ignore me 😭

@Bulayla1426

3 жыл бұрын

@@jalaluddeenat-tabarithetim593 well I can't make a lie ya imam

@Bulayla1426

3 жыл бұрын

@@jalaluddeenat-tabarithetim593 cp give jalaludeen his account back

Thanks ustad Farid, May Allah give you prosperity more and more

The irony lol he should of actually read the sources and he wouldn't of made such a big blunder

This is not the end of the world what Yasir Qadhi said ....he is prominent and very respectable caller to path of allah inshallah .he did many great things as well beijnillahi ta'la ...although I respect you but here it wasn't necessary to point out such issue that doesn't make much difference in iman of a believer.but this can create problem in people's mind to follow him or not....hope in future u make videos that are more on serious issues for Muslim Ummah . Salamalaikum.

@f1aziz

3 жыл бұрын

Who made you an authority on what Muslim Ummah needs or does not need. I found this video to be very educating.

@user-em9of9ky1m

3 жыл бұрын

Agree. I think Farid has some vandetta with Yasir qadhi after that Quran variants instance.

strange that this video comes out on the day I started watching your video from 2018 on the sunni view.

Is the seerah series of Yasir Qadhi reliable? I was thinking about watching it.

@EarlEBird

3 жыл бұрын

@Mohamed Ismail Can you suggest me any other series?

@osmanyasin5857

3 жыл бұрын

Belal Assad has a good seerah series

@user-bq3cw3bw8t

3 жыл бұрын

I would suggest learning Arabic and benefitting from the scholars of Islam directly.

This video is pure Hate. Farid you were doing great job refuting non muslims, how can you resort to this? Even though you know that classical scholars have also taken that reference? Even though YQ said "by and large? Even though he warned and disclaimed that he would be using his judgement as to which version?

@Ahmad-qx6pg

3 жыл бұрын

How is it hate? The man gave you clear cut facts in a non-emotional manner. If someone is preaching falsehood on an enormous platform to millions of people, they should be called out. End of story

@ifrsmasterclass

3 жыл бұрын

@@Ahmad-qx6pg I love Farid's responses, including the one where he addressed YQ's "hole in the narrative" thing. But what's wrong in this response is that it is delibrately or inadvertently designed to give impression that YQ is "preaching falsehood". While history is not black and white and many great scholars have taken different notions. This calling out culture inevitably "judges" and belittling other Muslim just because he holds a different view. I'm not saying any scholar is perfect. But calling out people will keep dividing us in smaller and smaller chunks.

@ifrsmasterclass

3 жыл бұрын

@@Ahmad-qx6pg I have similar thoughts about daniel haq. He is doing a great job being bold and truthful. But when he starts judging Omar Sulaiman for not being as bold, that's the problem. You cant criticize in a way which makes people judge the other guy as ill intentioned. Unless you are sure that he is ill intentioned.

I love Farid and Yasir ❤🙏🏻

@glasgowblackchigowski6117

3 жыл бұрын

One of them is genuinely trying to destroy islam from inside

@glasgowblackchigowski6117

3 жыл бұрын

@EH • 7 years ago qadhi

@GS-tu9no

3 жыл бұрын

@EH • 7 years ago yasir qhadi

Brother Farid, can you make a video on Karbala from a Sunni perspective?

@projectwebquranrecitations3336

3 жыл бұрын

@Mohamed Ismail Yeah I just found it literally after swiping out. May Allah reward you.

My question is does bro Farid regard Sh Yasir Qaadhi as a modernist or a sunni based on his opinion changes?🧐🤔

From the entire YQ:s long videos Farid finds few instances where YQ uses Miqnaf(mostly things that incriminate shia) and makes look like as YQ entire lecture is based on Miqnaf

Dr.Yasir Qadhi has also used many weak and fabricated narrations in his lecture series on the Seerah of The Prophet ﷺ. In sha Allah some day will have to make a series on fact checking that.

@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks alot for that info, I know the seerah's aren't as hadith checked as the hadith books, Can you tell me alittle more? yasir is an ikwani liar who lies against Sunni Salafis!

@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543

3 жыл бұрын

this is why the salafi dawa is so important. REad Sheikh Albani's book Prophet's prayer!

@authenticseerah

3 жыл бұрын

@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 Alhamdulillah Akhi now there are many books on purely authentic seerah.

@AR-ds7fi

3 жыл бұрын

@Voice of the Desert original sin....

@AtiqKhan-bj4fm

3 жыл бұрын

Voice of the Desert why don’t you try learning Islam without bias ? Start fresh ? Without any baggage? Just start

Assalama alaikum brother Farid..i don't listen to bro qadri lectures..but did he go on to describe the standard Sunni narrative later on in the lecture and that u just didn't take a small segment from his talk.

Farid's power is growing 👏

It’s amazing how someone’s general public image can plummet so quickly.

@1Tim1.15

3 жыл бұрын

its amazing how desperate people are to still blindly believe, even though there are holes in the narrative 😂😂😂😂😂

@TheCynicalOptimist

3 жыл бұрын

@@1Tim1.15 There are holes in your body.

@Al-Maghrebi

3 жыл бұрын

Trust source

@themistersmith

3 жыл бұрын

whose image are you talking about?

@ayyylmao101

3 жыл бұрын

@@themistersmith Dr. Qadhi

"Dear Da'wah Channel..."

@RK-ru4sb

3 жыл бұрын

What is that supposed to mean . I know might sound a little bit lost now.

@amer8011

3 жыл бұрын

Watch the video again from 1:35 kzread.info/dash/bejne/ZqSgzLyhl9CfpLQ.html

So where can,which video is more accurate to watch for the story of Karbala

@procrastinatingmedico007

2 жыл бұрын

You can see it in sunnah discourse channel given by br.farid

@digitalizotakugamer_

2 жыл бұрын

@@procrastinatingmedico007 oh jazakallah khair

Baaraka llaahufiikum

Yasir Qadhi's lecture is still brilliant!

@osman.s1405

2 жыл бұрын

How can you still say this after truth has been mixed with falsehood.

@sulwhale3171

2 жыл бұрын

@@osman.s1405 o

@geeque4853

10 ай бұрын

​@osman.s1405 do u think this guy Farid is an angel ?!