That's confidence, to go back and have the curator judge them side by side! And I'm very glad you did, that's some impressive work!

@pseudomonad

6 жыл бұрын

I bet! But I hope you were happy with the comparison.

@sb-ant6457

6 жыл бұрын

Tod the Brave

@iainburgess8577

2 жыл бұрын

Dedication. Confidence may not check, dedication Does. Also critical feedback, necessary for real improvement.

Toby makes the funniest sounds. And how he asked "do they both have a home?" I think I know where the second one went.

@ryankolick4117

3 жыл бұрын

That was my thought when Todd said this one does and then Toby starts making grunts. The sound of a sword collector going this one's mine now

@wildcrocus

3 жыл бұрын

Toby's reaction does make one think he is doing the math in his head and rehearsing speeches in his head to give his Missus.

@markfergerson2145

3 жыл бұрын

Toby also seemed to hint that if the customer didn't like the replica, he'd be very willing to give it a home.

@IllustriousCrocoduck

2 жыл бұрын

@@wildcrocus "it's for *research*, love! Purely academic, of course." -Probably Dr. Capwell

The curator's approving grunts during unpacking are sooo amusing! Beautiful blade, though!

@Kargush

6 жыл бұрын

And his knowing nod when Tod describes the problem with scaling the drawings and the photos.

@5chr4pn3ll

6 жыл бұрын

The curator, Tobias Capwell, is in a place to actually properly appreciate these things. He was a very active jouster in tournaments and owns several suits of armour made for him. He has been heavily and practically involved in developing our understanding of jousting and how it actually worked, and getting injured while finding these things out. He is very interesting to listen to and he has a lot of practical knowledge that very few people do. Highly recommend his lectures on youtube.

@HereticalKitsune

6 жыл бұрын

Oh, I don't doubt it or wanted to make fun of it, it just came as such a surprise to hear the grunts from the off. ^^;

@TheSeanoops

6 жыл бұрын

Kiono Hiemalis He’s written a few books to, informative text and beautiful pictures.

@tyynymyy7770

6 жыл бұрын

I totally lost it at 12:38-13:07! There is just something very bizarre about the situation.

3:06 "Hrm" and that, ladies and gentlemen, is the sound of a bank balance being carefully considered....

@j.g.elmslie9901

6 жыл бұрын

Someday, you'll break his resolve....

@thehermitdruid

2 жыл бұрын

I’ve made that sound looking at magic cards

i really love that nerd conversation between experts, when they are able to talk about details others can't.

2:58 Sounded like Dr. Capwell was considering giving the other replica a home.

@kaizen5023

4 жыл бұрын

"Hmmm.. hmmmmmmmm"

"This one still wants to kill stuff slightly more than this one"

@neilkirkaldie3659

4 жыл бұрын

I wonder if he would have felt the same if he had switched the swords to the opposite hands.

@kaizen5023

4 жыл бұрын

I've never handled one of Tod's swords, but my experience handling the very best swords is that they "want to kill stuff slightly more" than others... it is hard to quantify. It looks like the original has a bit wider blade around the point of percussion, so that could be it, and the balance might be slightly different.

@fredygump5578

3 жыл бұрын

Not your average curator!

@G1NZOU

3 жыл бұрын

I have to use that quote next time I do a blacksmith bladeseller NPC for DnD.

@G1NZOU

3 жыл бұрын

@@kaizen5023 Yeah I think even tiny variations in balance and weight placement are noticeable, like how even a few milimeters variation in a certain step on a staircase is enough to make someone trip, we notice things. The hand and fingers are some of the most sensitive touch areas after all, so it does make sense, tiny variations and finding that sweet spot of something that feels "just a little better".

It just makes me so happy seeing Toby Capwell giving his approval, because you know he has practical research and experience in the field. And he seems like a great guy. Love his co-ops with Matt Easton on ScholaGladiatoria as well:)

Tod should be entitled to free pints for life, paid for by the National Trust.

So this man is: - Tod Todeschini - Tod Cutler - Tod's Stuff - Tod's Workshop - Tod's Foundry I'm probably just going to start referring to him as 'the historical craftsman known as Tod'.

@Duron0

3 жыл бұрын

THE Tod :D

I love how Dr. Capwell hefts the sword and you can see he's thinking about how he'd actually feel trying to fight with it. You can see the wheels turning. What an utterly lovely interaction.

It’s a rare thing to find a person doing exactly what they were born to do. I think Todd is one of those people. Beautiful work.

I was watching the Vid about this sword that just came out in 2021 last night thinking to myself "Man Tod just really only cares about blacksmithing." In that video he's at his home forge with Matt Easton and you can tell he just tossed on a branded tee over his beat to hell shop clothes. And here he is 3 years back making a film on a beautiful sword he replicated and he turns up in just some beat up old tee again. I love it! This man is more at home covered in suit than anyone I've ever seen!

I really wish that my father was alive. He would have been in his element speaking to gentlemen of your caliber. He was a lot like me, trying to learn as much as possible about arms and armour of the medieval to renaissance periods. There is one point especially that the pair of you comment. Mistakes!!! He used to visit a customer of mine that happens to collect authentic arms and armour. He had the most comprehensive private collection I've ever seen. My father would look for any imperfections that he could find, much to my customers annoyance. But my father saw it as a human touch found hundreds of years later. My father's background was in making body panels, parts of chassis and floor pans for hand made classic cars. Ferrari, Maserati etc. He worked for himself and often won concours all over Europe. I have a great deal of respect for you, as he would. I'm so sorry for the story, but I just have so much time for your efforts. Especially teaching youngsters in a non patronising manner. I can't afford even decent replica armour. I do own a few original examples. Between the two of you and Matt Easton do a superb job. Thank you so much. mattbishop1976@yahoo.co.uk.

12:23 Tobias thinking "The fool, he's disarmed! I could kill him and take it for myself Mwa ha ha!"

whenever Tobias Capwell appears on someone video it suddenly becomes a sword ASMR video.

The A489 is my favorite sword of all time. This is a spectacular reproduction.

Amazing work. You're ready for your museum swap/heist caper.

Thank you for this reminder.... The Wallace Collection is one of the best places in London, if not the world.... great Cafe’ too..!

Dear Lord, Tod's recreation is a gorgeous sword. Bravo! Nice to see Dr. Capwell on the channel, too.

Thoroughly enjoyable. Congratulations on such a fine piece of work.

Your recreation is simply phenomenal. Take it from Mr. Capwell, who seemed to like it enough to show interest in its sister. I truly hope to have a blade made by you soon, though I'm still waiting on a couple of commissions already.

So cool to see them having a conversation so long ago knowing how much great work they’ve done together now

This is my favorite sword out of all of them. *ALL* of them. And I really like a lot of swords.

@spyczech

6 жыл бұрын

That would be a good video, if you want to go full on youtuber.

@RheaMainz

5 жыл бұрын

I greatly like the cruciform-semi-baskethilt right next to it~

@goldenageofdinosaurs7192

5 жыл бұрын

Altrantis When it was laying next to the original, I thought it was beautiful work, but not necessarily my particular style, but the second Toby picked it up & I could see it all of a piece, I changed my mind. It’s a gorgeous sword. The blade shape is very nice. I’ve been coming around on sabers lately. When I began to take a renewed interest in swords, it was primarily the medieval long sword & it’s kin, but Matt, over at Scholagladiatora, has brought me around to their beauty & functionality.

When the lines between the artisan and the artist become blurred. What an incredible piece. Putting side by side with the original only highlights how amazing a work you did on it. Congratulations.

As a Swiss man myself, I'm stunned and infinitely jealous. Great job!

Seen this sword at Compiegne, and it was a really, really, nice sword... Loving it.

Wonderful work Mr. Todeschini! I found it very enjoyable to watch and to learn a bit more about forging swords; the art of finding a sweet spot somewhere between underdone and overly sterilized works.

Brilliantly done sword. Very nice.

I love watching the care and love Tobias had for the sword when he first set it down on the table.

I have been so, so excited to see more about this project. Absolutely stunning.

That's amazing Tod! Your work is truly inspiring!

This really is one of the most beautiful swords I've ever seen.

A true masterpiece

The shape of that blade is stunning. Beautiful.

Possibly my favourite sword of all time, that swiss sabre. So beautiful.

Toby Capwell saying your sword feels perfect for fighting must be a great feeling, since he actually fights with them, great job!

absolutely astonishing swords.

Truly wonderful and amazing! Congratulations!

I don't know why, but I visualize that blade in the hands of John Carter (of Mars), and doing much mayhem with it.

Very cool to see you two together and very nice work.

Old video I know but just recently came across your channel. Absolutely love your work beautifully crafted swords. Also great verbal content. You have a great way of discussing and explaining your topics without being snooty condescending. Brilliant. Thank you for all the hard work.

Fantastic work, great to see them side by side. Well done!

Congrats! Awesome work! And really nice idea to take it back to the source and lay them side by side :)

That was so much fun to watch. What a beautiful sword.

I am in awe of sword smiths and armorers, these guys were the rocket scientists of their day, all of these arms produced without any modern technology, least of all electricity or gas, all made with simple hand tools.

It was lovely how he unboxed the replica (beginning at 2:40) next to the original. To see the very close resemblance and the observations on the slight differences was extremely informative.

Exellent job Todd! Looking forward to the next piece!

Wow, just wow! Amazing work

Such quality in Tods work. They both know their stuff.

Simply awesome. I love the passion both have : D

Toby is great to listen to. So is Tod of course, so I'm loving the two talking and discussing rather than overly scripted. Both are knowledgeable, and admit their opinions over absolute fact. And both are really good at explaining "why" things are, on bits I'd never think to ask about. Plus both seem like genuine, lovely blokes.

Absolutely beautiful!

If ever there was a perfect advertisement for your products, these comparison vids would be it. We get great discussion with two experts in their fields, each cross-analysing 'their' sword with the other. Reason to watch alone. Then to say the lovely new one, up to the expectations of today's consumer, is for sale, and more can be made to order... I don't think a single viewer wasn't inwardly drooling at the prospect.

Incredible workmanship!

This was such an interesting video featuring two beautiful swords, thanks so much for sharing. :)

this is definitely one of the best looking swords ever. i want one.

8:32 "I'm just looking at that terminal over here, and uhm... yours is actually a little bit nicer..." I said something similar about a reproduction I recently had someone make for me. It is great to see modern craftspeople making things that are meeting and exceeding the quality of the originals.

That was an awesome video! So good to see the origional beside the modern version. Amazing!

An incredible reproduction/artifact! The owner will get something truly spectacular!

Beautiful work!

beautiful work Tod. it's amazing for you to work from a photograph and get all the different radius correct not to mention point of balance and all the other details. very impressive thank you for the video

Beautiful work!!

Even the armet at 18:12 can't keep a straight face listening to theese two.

@blackdeath4eternity

5 жыл бұрын

lol nice spot.

Amazing craftsmanship

crazy work.

Beautiful workmanship

Tobias' face when Tod mentions the Wallace Collection photos was amazing.

I love this interaction

Hell yeah that's what I like to see. Never thought that guy would say yours was nicer, thought he would be so critical wow. Good work I will keep watching

Such fine swords both

A sword reborn. Brilliant!

This may seem like an ignorant question, but was the original as shiny and smooth as the reproduction when it was new?

@thrownswordpommel7393

4 жыл бұрын

Yes. It's very likely, as far as I know, medieval people really loved mirror polished arms and armour, the only exceptions I know are blackened to make maintenance easier ( they're 16th century German mercenaries' breastplates, belonging to professional fighters serving in France, the so called " reîtres"). I'm by no means an expert though. Hope this answered your question.

@davidbolton4930

4 жыл бұрын

It's been keeped clean and stored well as well as been oiled which at the time would be expected of by any swordsman

@UAPJedi

4 жыл бұрын

I would imagine so, 500 years can take its toll, remember these were weapons they’ve been used, abused, dropped, dented and tarnished. Possibly some of these arms may of been altered, improved had pieces added or taken away, no different than a guy today may want his rifle, handgun or shotgun, improved or customised.

@neruneri

3 жыл бұрын

@@UAPJedi Hell, even if we discount all of that, 500 years in storage with protective oils is enough to get the discoloring we see. The reproduction does look like what the real one would have looked like 500 years ago.

A lovely piece of work Tod! And it's always nice to see Mr Capwell in a video. Interesting dude.

@cwxdaf152

6 жыл бұрын

It's so nice to listen to two people talking about a subject they love.

You did a great job!! It looks identical

they are both very beautiful

holy cow i am in love

@chris-kp2zq

6 жыл бұрын

you´re not the only one

Aside from the beautiful replica you've made. I'm just super jealous of tobi being able to dual wield Swiss Sabres lol 😆

Your work is amazing!!

Tobias Capwell dual wielding!

Amazing work, man.

I want Tod to do more reconstructions of swords from the Wallace Collection! Seeing how his and the original compare side by side is truly fascinating.

Nice video Tod. It was fascinating watching you examine the sword with the eye of a craftsman rather than the rest of us who would just like to wave it about, I mean train with it :)

I wish I had a spare grand to spend right about now, that sword is excellent! I want one.

@davidbolton4930

4 жыл бұрын

Its probably worth more then 1 grand probably worth closer to 2-3

@alanmackinnon3516

3 жыл бұрын

@@davidbolton4930 actually it's £3.600.00, if you want to buy it.

I have to say i prefer yours over the original! Great work, and gorgeous!

Beautiful sword!

Fascinating, thanks.

Beautiful. I am glad I subscribed to this channel.

thank you for sharing this.

More of you and Tobias please.

I realy love the Blade Geometry and the Seed Shape!

Awesome!

Proper job! Bet that’s not cheap - love that Swiss saber.

That is a fantastic blade. I want one

"He SHOULD be satisfied" had a "or I'll split him with his very own sword" feel.

Great job, it's a gorgeous reproduction.

I great to see the English community of Historical Martial European thingies come together in youtube to educate people. Wish the same thing happened even more for Continental Euro.

beautiful

I make reproduction Flintlock firearms and I believe you two gentlemen were searching for the phrase "Finished in a workman like manner." Which is what one often observes with originals of any era, unless a particular item was made for royalty and every detail taken to perfection. Beautiful job on your sword Tod, excellent craftsmanship.

Great stuff! I would love to see a video of you constructing a complex hilt from scratch!