I saw someone's theory about this is that the teens, in limbo where time works differently, were able to watch Penny's complete and fulfilled life. At the end Penny/Jane's voice was her calling to them to join her in the afterlife. I find this absolutely beautiful, so it is how I choose to view it.

@kaydenbrown1790

Жыл бұрын

IM SOBBING SO MUCH

@GuiSmith

Жыл бұрын

This is how I do too. It’s quite poetic for the song. We don’t know any of the context, nothing of how hard she tried, just that Penny/Jane got to live. I bet it almost causes some dissonance with the out-of-time aspect on the other side, in a fun way.

@j.r.cilliangreen4083

3 ай бұрын

Absolutely 100%...also I cry every time I make it to the end of this show...

One of my favorite details about this scene is the fact that in the beginning of the show Ocean reaches for Ricky's hand and he pulls away but by the end of the show he reaches out and takes hers with a smile. That growth and development in their relationship means a lot to me

@singwithAshley

Жыл бұрын

Oh that’s so sweet!

I think this end doesn't tell us what's after death. The ride is just referencing our life which can be fun, terryfying but also will end. It's not a game where we can win or lose, it's a ride we're on as passengers

@two_idixts

Жыл бұрын

I love this summary of the musical bc its so stupid and funny but then at the end you just realise how just deep and amazing the story behind it is

@linus1703

Жыл бұрын

I agree, I loved how the fortune teller made a strong point that even he does not know what will come next.

I'm super late, but some fun tidbits -It was Jane living out her life behind them -Karnak "dies" as he predicted at the beginning before we meet the cast -Ocean is facing out, while Noah and Mischa are huddling over Constance and Ricky bc "She has grown and is choosing to face what's next head on" (a direct quote Oceans actress said to me on tiktok) 💜 I'm so glad I made my way back here to watch you watch this❤❤❤❤

I love how not only does the show finish with the line ‘I know this dream of life is never ending, it goes around and round and round again’ but the motif musically resolves on the very last note, allowing a sense of completion alongside the nostalgia that comes from the motif being repeated.

THIS SONG MAKES ME CRY LITERALLY ALL THE TIME

@CrowLady0_0

Жыл бұрын

SAME! like i will be trying to sing along BUT I LITERALLY CANT THROUGH MY TEARS

@CrowLady0_0

Жыл бұрын

i cried watching this video because i CANNOT MAKE IT THROUGH THIS SONG

@venusgxcha

3 ай бұрын

SAME THE VERY END OF IT ALWAYS MAKES ME CRY

Since this show has had so many versions, practically every song has had rewrites or replacements. It’s interesting: since this song was written, the only noticeable change has been the removal of Ocean and Ricky singing “no one will measure/how hard we tried” at each other after the first chorus. The lyric hasn’t been replaced or retooled to tell a different part of the story that was lacking. It hasn’t been rewritten to better fit a character’s personal growth, or even amended to fit in motifs that were created later. The song has merely had a lyric removed that was sang better in the first half of the song. Its lyrically tight, the technique’s great, and the style brings me joy. Plus, the choreography when they walk in place on the turntable is so satisfying. It’s the second thing everyone’s waiting for when you have a turntable: turning people around a centrepiece comes first, and walking in place comes second. Needless to say, this is my favourite song in Ride the Cyclone. Edit: Ricky sand that line with Ocean, not Noel. Oops.

@wyster14

Жыл бұрын

Tbh my favorite version of the show is the 2016 off broadway. The Fall Fair Suite just ticks right for me, and really other than Ricky’s concession and a few of the rewritten parts since I do love it more than most of the version

@GuiSmith

10 ай бұрын

@@wyster14It was a really good cast, it wasn’t overwritten, and the choreo was clear. Though yeah, some of the Ricky changes were really good until the recent set.

I like to think that at the end Jane had finished her actual life and was back in the afterlife, so at the end of her life she gets this random memory of being with the choir and sings that as her last words so as she goes into the after life it's what she says. As the other five see the light it's telling them that it's there somewhat of and end to this miserable limbo of living their death over and over again so once Jane goes into the after life they are finally let free of that bind in someway. I also have a head cannon that once Jane lives her full life the 5 kids run to see her and call out to her, specifically Ocean. The interaction would go somewhat like this Ocean: "Jane!" She says as all of them run to her Penny/Jane: "huh? Oh, you must be mistaken sweetheart my name's Penny" she says to Ocean. Ocean just smiles and hugs her, the others join in and hug the confused old woman Penny/Jane: "oh! Why are all of you kids doing here in this place?" Constance: "you don't remember?" She says as they all let go of the hug Penny/Jane: "Remember what?" She says as she looks at the kids. They all stare at each other and then back at her Noel: "the accident..." he says as he looks at her showing that her response had hurt him a bit Penny/Jane: "t-the accident...?" She says with a bit of confusion in her voice. The kids look at each other and nod at the same time they hug her one last time All the kids: "we missed you Jane" they say as they let go of her, they smile at her and run off with each other to a different place. Penny/Jane had known what they where talking about once Noel had mentioned the accident but she knew it was better for them to think she didn't remember it at all. She just smiled at the fact that they remembered her after all that time.

@singwithAshley

Жыл бұрын

Beautiful 👏 Encore

@carilemakesmistakes

Жыл бұрын

@@singwithAshley Oh my God! YOU actually replied sorry, I just really liked your reaction vids and it got me into watching ride the Cylon as well as helping me learning how to sing the songs knowing how to do some of the cool things it has!

@kaydenbrown1790

Жыл бұрын

IM SOBBING

@carilemakesmistakes

Жыл бұрын

@@kaydenbrown1790 heheh, sorry! I got this idea at like 12 am and it has just stuck with me since, its such a bitter sweet ending to all of their stories but it ties it with a bow on the too perfectly

@L0C4LR4ND0M

2 ай бұрын

Hippity hoppity I’m a year late but may I steal your property?I love this hc

This show always makes me cry. I always find it fascinating when artists explore death and dying in their work. I read an idea that Jane represents death while the other 5 kids represent the 5 stages of grief.

Whenever I hear this song I want to cry because it symbolizes there true end, for all of them including Jane as not only do they watch her life but so do we as well

finally caught up on all the cyclone videos i missed! now i wanna watch the musical again...

The video they’re watching through the song is of Penny Lamb’s (Jane doe’s) life after Jane comes back to life! So you were right :)

Before Karnak dies, everyone huddles up, hiding their faces and their front body. On the other hand ocean faces out, this is her taking her title as group leader and is protecting them all, she’s ready to face whatever they have too. Just there to protect them all.

I know I was super late to joining you watching the full musical, but I'm so grateful that I made it in time for this song at the very least. It's my absolute favorite, and I really enjoyed your reactions to it (and you doing the choreography that you recognized!). I *live* for the jump dancing they do around 6:12. Overall though I just love the message about enjoying the ride of life. Probably the greatest irony about this musical's role in my own life- I've never been a rollercoaster person. They scare me. But this musical, about kids dying on a rollercoaster, has made me want to work up the courage to do rollercoasters more. Theoretically it should have turned me even more off of rollercoasters. But it's done the opposite. Some day I hope to have children, and I don't want my personal fear of rollercoasters to get in their way of experiencing this ride/I want to be able to go on them with them to help comfort them so they can have a good time. And even without children, I don't want to miss out on extra depths of experience I can have in my own life. ...It's just a ride. (obviously we'll try to make sure they're safe first haha, but just that general idea of not letting life pass by and making sure to "ride the cyclone" as it were).

This is one of those songs that makes me tear up every time i hear it!

My favorite little detail is how the musical begins with Jane’s “Karnak’s Dream of Life” and the musical closes with the same song! ❤

@singwithAshley

4 ай бұрын

Same friend! same!

I have a cold right now and I've spent most of my saturday watching your Ride the Cyclone reactions. I love this musical so much, and since my friends haven't seen it, its really nice to hear someone else's thoughts and reactions. Don't you love the way they harmonize? I love the way they harmonize. Anyways, thanks for the awesome video! (Also, if you're taking reaction requests, maybe check out the band halestorm? I'd love to see you break down the singing techniques Lzzy uses, she's the main singer and she's also wicked talented)

@singwithAshley

Жыл бұрын

I’ll check it out! Thanks for watching!

@marsalves6946

Жыл бұрын

@@singwithAshley yeah of course! Thanks for taking the time to reply :) (Also, don’t be surprised if I go back and comment on a bunch of your other RTC videos eventually. I Never Shut Up About Music)

I cry everytime I listen to this song.... The story is just so beautiful and meaningful. It's one of my favorite musicals of all time 💕💕💕

THIS SONG IS SO BEAUTIFUL 😭 I Friggin LOVE this musical, all their voices are so complex, and wonderful, and I just WHWUUWJSJAJS THEYRE SO GOOD!!!! Also, I completely recommend “A Gay Disney prince” or “Disney friend mashup” by Thomas Sanders, they’re so good!!

I remember watching this for the first time and bawling my absolute eyes out at this scene.

I love that of all of the videos I've watched you don't really have any feedback because it's so moving. I like to think that they're not so much reliving their last moments of life but more imagining on a rollercoaster. I really love this analogy of it not being a game but a ride (I know it's not the first to do this but it works so well here)

I started crying while watching this. The end always makes me so emotional

I love your videos!

Love this reaction❤❤❤

@singwithAshley

4 ай бұрын

Love you for being here!

Gus Halper (the guy who played Misha (Ukrainian guy) is such an amazing signer and Kholby Wardell (Noel)

Its even worse remembering (i think) that this accident was a true story (i had to pause this halfway through bc i starting crying)

I think the idea is that like a roller coaster life is a ride. Appreciate the ups and downs

@singwithAshley

2 ай бұрын

I love this!! Totally like a ride!

@Angelicwings1

2 ай бұрын

@@singwithAshleyI also feel that is kind of the Constance message too. How she hated the little town but came to love those tiny moments when her last were happening. It’s ok that life isn’t perfect. It’s what we do with it and the impact we make with our short time

@singwithAshley

2 ай бұрын

@@Angelicwings1 PREACH!

@Angelicwings1

2 ай бұрын

@@singwithAshleywhen you grow up with dying kids it’s teaches you things. The one that is still alive had a lung transplant and then went skydiving. Why? Cause time is short and life is here while you have it.

@singwithAshley

2 ай бұрын

@@Angelicwings1 wow! All we can do is make beauty from ashes. Rise Phoenix 🐦‍🔥 rise

REACT TO THIS SONG IS AWESOME!!!!!

I'm not sure i like the implications of your death theory lol. Brilliant video though