How the fuck is that AI technology if you manually have to draw a contour of a person?? I can do the same thing in MS paint

@manuellabor2759

7 ай бұрын

I was thinking the same thing.

Fuzzy select in compose or hsl luminance / hsl Value Selection mode (depending on background) with micro adjustments to Threshold and Fearher Selection can do it a lot quicker on plain backgrounds. It won't be exactly what you want so use the boolean selection tools to adjust badly selected regions and you'll discover a method that can do this very quickly. Fuzzy Select's Feather Selection is great to preserve hair strands. The idea is to select the majory of the image that you want and THEN use boolean subtract / add Selection options with the tool mentioned here to fix the issues. Fuzzy select in combination with smart scissors can get a lot done very quickly

@scottonanski4173

6 ай бұрын

What do you mean "in compose"?

@ikemkrueger

Ай бұрын

I wanna see a video of it in action.

It's funny how every software and website company for showcasing their background removal tools use an image that has its background and foreground in opposite colors and the background is totally empty. If you're trying to impress me, do it with a picture that is complicated.

@GIMPTUT

Жыл бұрын

Great observation! There's a reason why I and others don't use "complicated" backgrounds... it requires editing software that is capable of such feats. Which is to say... NOT GIMP! I use Photoshop for "complicated" backgrounds, just say'n.

@jimking81

Жыл бұрын

Because the main concept and steps are always the same. You need to zoom-in and go around the edges. No "magic" here

@JasonEllingsworth

Жыл бұрын

@@jimking81 Did you not notice the selection line moving automatically to the pixels? That is what is awesome here. You won't find a tool that does everything for you, without using some of your skill or brain....so basically you have no future in using image manipulation software.

@JasonEllingsworth

Жыл бұрын

@@jimking81 i can see why someone like you would be proud of that.

@funnyberries4017

Ай бұрын

@@GIMPTUT I'm just cracking up so hard about your attitude. hahahahaha you've used GIMP enough to the point where you hate it. It's great because most normal people hate gimp too.

Very helpful, thanks!

This isn't AI selection. This is just tracing around the image which takes an extremely long time

@ss4kaioken295

11 күн бұрын

Honestly, I think the free select works better LO.L

Fuzzy selectiion tool with an "high" thresold works for me too. I just add and add pixels in an "incremental" way (holding the shift key, IIRC) and the selected area expands every time and surrounds almost perfectly the area of interest because of different color or contrast. Then simply invert selection with CTRL-I

@edoardomancini180

3 ай бұрын

My ctrl x doesn’t work when I use fuzzy

@giuliobuccini208

3 ай бұрын

@@edoardomancini180 strange... I usually copy the inverted selection (CTRL-C) and then I paste it as new layer (see the Edit menu). Then I delete the old layer, or I simply hide it.

useful, thanks man!

Thanks for the tip on the Feathering Radius.

Quality friend thank you.

LEGEND! Thank you!!!

Ai keeps adding graphics to my mockups. Do you have a vid about hhow to remove or replace them.

Even with a not-so-complex background, it's quite a long way of doing things but it's doable just like the older versions of Photoshop.

I've been using Gimp since 1.6. Even if it sounds nice that AI is suddenly everywhere, it is purely marketing. The magnetic scissors are not AI powered. It is one of the oldest tools in Gimp. There is no AI in the Heal Selection and Transparency Selection plugins released from 2002. These are pixel-dependent algorithms and are therefore veeery far from AI. Even if Adobe claims the Content-Aware Fill feature uses AI, unfortunately that's just marketing, because the feature is based on the Gimp plugins

@julianmahler2388

3 ай бұрын

@@Reggieeeeeeee322There is no object recognition, the software doesn't "think", doesn't really see any patterns, if you try to select a car that doesn't happen to be a black car in front of a white background, it will usually include parts of the background that are clearly not a car because it doesn't have any clue what a car is or looks like, so it can't decide where the car stops and the background begins. It will just make simple decisions based on color and not on pattern or object recognition. AI powered software does a much better job, just look what a modern smartphone can do. Just open a picture, tap on the car, 90% of the time it will recognize the car and do a fantastic job deleting the background, even if the background is a lot more abstract than in the video. Takes 2 seconds.

Thank you for excellently explaining how to use this tool. Since moment one, for more complex background my go to was paths tool, but not anymore :) I've had so much fun watching this video. *automagically* - genius idea... and here I am, ten minutes after, still laughing :D

2:10 it's difficult to use it if we don't know how to use it 🤔... Got it! 😄👍

thank you for this tutorial

Excellent!

It makes a change from the Foreground select Tool and Selection to Path. Thanks.

Why in the world would you recommend a crucial step of feather edges at the end?? That should be noted at the beginning....

thank you!

It works when there are such large contrasts, in the cases where I have tried the tool, it has completely failed...

Link for the gimp version being use😅

Excellent tutorial. Thank you!

I did not know until recently that the lowly Paint program that comes standard with Windows has a background removal tool and it works really well. Nothing in GIMP works well unless there is a lot of difference in the subject and the background. Otherwise, forget about it.

And then what? How do you actually remove the background? So basically - paths tool, invert, delete - should be a 20 second video max. Thanks

That scissors tool leaves artifacts from the background a lot though you really have to work at it

This is something similar to "Magnetic Lasso Tool" of Photoshop and has been used for ages. So not a magic i guess. You didn't even remove the background at the end. While talking about the threshold, why didn't you just decide the threshold for the whole path instead you draw another path? And after that you didn't finish the final product. OMG your brain is really working in an other way!

Nice video on the scissors tool, thank you for sharing. If I may add two (small) suggestions, (...these are only my personal opinions and preferences of course, if you find them helpful great, if not feel free to ignore them :)) First, for a better learning process, a presentation should show how to use the tool with steps in the correct order, and without making mistakes, e.g.- setting the feathering option correctly from the beginning... because that detail should be noticed in the beginning, (and adjusted if so required) every time we use that tool. The order of a presentation is important to how most people remember and use what they've learned, and viewing the first step first is better than waiting to the last couple of minutes of a 12 minute video to see how to avoid a mistake that should never have happened, (but sometimes does:/). This is in contrast to the "discovery" method, which is how children and self taught people learn... but most of us are spoiled, and we're here for a shortcut, or we wouldn't be watching how-to videos, right? And second, as others have already mentioned, there are faster/easier ways to remove plain backgrounds, so maybe you can find and present an example where using this tool is better than using other tools. Thanks again. 👍

After selecting the anchor points and adjusting the feathering, its not stated how to remove the background.

@BelamarEutravos

2 ай бұрын

ctrl c, ctrl v, new layer

67 hours later and you're done people! It's that simple!😏

In top menu Tools /Sellection Tools , it's still called intelligent scissors ✂ ✂

😍💛👍👍👍

But, how do you remove the background?

This is my 1st attempt at GIMP. Did I miss something? I used the AI scissors traced everything out as shown. Hit enter, the path changed to blinking black and white line and......now what??? background still there.

@JasonEllingsworth

Жыл бұрын

apparently you need to watch a basic image editing video first. It should be obvious to you, what you would do after getting your selection.

Are you that guy from American Psycho, mate? The one that killed Patrick's business card.

gimp wont let me undo a scissor point??

@kensleylewis

4 ай бұрын

no it will let you undo a scissor point. But once you hit enter, you can't go back to your scissor points.

After free AI tools available today, none of this make sense anymore. I grew up doing curses in Photoshop 4.0, taking hours to do things like these and now with one click and no skill at all, the background is gone, the photo is color corrected, so on and so forth.

@moviecast13

10 ай бұрын

whats the AI called?

@Mettinkm

9 ай бұрын

​@@moviecast13exactly 💯 👏 😅, Nothing AI 😂

@zKoruja

7 ай бұрын

Yeah, it’s scary as hell. I’ve been facing some anxiety and depression because of how fast these things are moving. I mean, they are great, but the more people know about it, the more they’ll trash my job saying things like “it’s so easy, what makes you better?”. Like people always thought that designers job is easy, but now it’s way more frequent

@Ravitz18

6 ай бұрын

​@@zKoruja Don't be afraid, even though AI is increasingly advanced, it is never perfect, the work of a human Designer will still be necessary for several things, Even if I ask an AI to make art for me, only a human will be able to capture the real essence and meaning of my request, only a human will be able to perfectly reproduce the image that I want. I see AI more as a support and a "third" hand for a Designer (or any other type of work) than a replacement. Even a simple job like removing a background, AI can't does it perfectly, needing someone to correct the mistakes they make when carrying out this process.

@zKoruja

6 ай бұрын

@@Ravitz18 I hope you are right! 🙏

There are free background removal AI websites that will do this in a few seconds.

@moviecast13

10 ай бұрын

can you tell me the name of it please?

Yea not really AI if you have to still sit and click along an edge for hours

This is click bait, you didn't use AI

@squarerootof2

2 ай бұрын

That's why it's called artificial, lol. Because it's not real.

Has nothing to do with AI

Never used GIMP and this was the first video I watched about the software because I kept hearing about it as a 'Photoshop' alternative. Very bad idea to watch this, I'll be honest, coming from Photoshop 2023. I can literally do a cloud-based Select Subject that now works superbly on some of the most complicated backgrounds that'll take about 3 seconds to do what would manually require at least half an hour. Calling that scissors thing "AI" is just like calling the Magnetic Lasso or MAgic Wand in PS "AI". You perhaps need to revise your info about machine learning.

@Reggieeeeeeee322

6 ай бұрын

lol he was being "tongue-and-cheek". and this is not that serious, don't be so uptight

@esphilee

6 ай бұрын

GIMP is very different from Photoshop. There are things that you can do better in GIMP, there are others that is easier in Photoshop. That said, lately photoshop has a lot of new tools that take it far ahead of GIMP.

I hate your videos lol. I'm using these tools but still have zero idea what to press to actually delete the selected area.

@kipp0man

Жыл бұрын

Exactly! I'm a complete newbie to GIMP and after I diligently selected the area, closed the loop, pressed 'Enter' .... now what ?? 🤔

@JasonEllingsworth

Жыл бұрын

@@kipp0man how do both of you not know what to do after you have made a selection? What you are wanting to know, would come from an absolute beginners video, which you should have watched before learning the details of a specific tool.

@kipp0man

Жыл бұрын

@@JasonEllingsworth Thanks Jason, that was very helpful (sarcasm!). I think you answered your own question there - "how do both of you not know what to do"? The reason why I jumped to the video was to find a shortcut to a specific task, I have no desire to learn how to use GIMP, as I won't be using it much. NOTE: "GIMP 2.10 For Beginners {10+ Hours of Tutorials}"

@JasonEllingsworth

Жыл бұрын

@kipp0man stop whining and take the time to learn the very basics before complaining.

@kipp0man

Жыл бұрын

@@JasonEllingsworth Haha .. Irony!! 😂😂😂

D

I can remove background in Photoshop in one click without all that. The author was fucking with selecting the contour of a person and didn't remove the background because the selection alone took the whole video timeline. AI? Don't think so. It's not enough to simply select the contour of a person, invert the selection and remove the background. There's lighting & shadow issues, hair, etc. All edges of the person must be smooth to properly separate it from the background. All these aspects of background removal are handled by Photoshop in one click without even having to select the contour of the person.

Sorry, I didn't find the image

@GIMPTUT

Жыл бұрын

I can't find the original photo but here is a similar one; www.pexels.com/photo/strict-female-teacher-with-book-pointing-at-scribbled-blackboard-3771074/

Unless this tool has been updated a whole lot the last time I tried this it did a crappy job.

I don't see anything "intelligent" or faster here from what we already know. You still need to zoom in and go around the edges no matter what tool you want to use. 12:00 of pointless showcase...

@JasonEllingsworth

Жыл бұрын

It is pretty obvious that this tool can do a lot more than the typical method of pathing around an object using points and curve handles. Certainly not a pointless showcase. This comment just makes you look like an idiot.

title is very misleading..., not AI

Clickbait! This is very old-school manual background extraction and has nothing to do with AI.

This is AI??????? 🤦 And they say GIMP is Photoshop's main competitor. They must be joking.

@squarerootof2

2 ай бұрын

You just don't have a sense of humour.

Thanks a lot sir, I would like to invite you to accept Islam it is the best religion.

@squarerootof2

2 ай бұрын

No doubt, it's one of my favourites too.

AI my arse. This is horrible clickbait. Your should be ashamed of yourself.

Are you joking, awkward man? What is this? Is that Ai and proper background removing? This video should be removed from YT.

@GIMPTUT

8 ай бұрын

Are you joking? Bullies like you should be removed from KZread.

@ThatOneAnimationGuy

6 ай бұрын

@@GIMPTUTyour the best don’t listen to him he must be 4 years old

Very helpful!!! Thanks!