For Indians, pakistan is a closed chapter

@parthparth433

7 ай бұрын

Spot on.

@channelname1473

6 ай бұрын

lets wait for indian elections for testing this statement

@muhammadali-rn4sd

4 ай бұрын

and for pakistanis india is never being a chapter. this material is only sold by your media

@aneelRmd

4 ай бұрын

Lmao 🤣 😂 ​@@channelname1473

@ansazeem1234

2 ай бұрын

For us Pakistanis, Pakistan is also a closed chapter 😂

I am indian and after listening to shabbar zaidi my conclusion is that he is very partical person n a type of opportunist in a country who live in fool paradise

@rajvanshsingh8165

7 ай бұрын

😂 ye fayda lene walo me se Banda ha

@gulshank4919

7 ай бұрын

@@rajvanshsingh8165 true

@DjLota

7 ай бұрын

Haha yes you are 100% right. He's famous for being opportunist

@indmusiclover

7 ай бұрын

Guest is blabbering or is yet another Pakistani who is a confident lier.

@dourbeen

7 ай бұрын

He is wrong on 65 war. It was started by India in rann of kutch area where India lost area and then pakistan retaliated in kashmir, as a result India crossed international border. Who won it well pakistan defended an aggression so it won it...also it gained area in aakhnoor kashmir and rann of Kutch.

Countries that are defeated badly by their enemies often rebuild But the countries that are destroyed from within thats really the end of line Stephen Kotin Pakistan is a perfect example

@sahilsam41

7 ай бұрын

@syedbakeruddinbekar9433 lumber 1

@aneelRmd

4 ай бұрын

😅😊😂 insaw-alla masa-alla​@syedbakeruddinbekar9433 Bhen-Cho , saare jaankar bhare pade hai pak me

@literally_lore

3 ай бұрын

@syedbakeruddinbekar9433 no InshaAllah Pakistan will prosper remaining Pakistan

@literally_lore

3 ай бұрын

@syedbakeruddinbekar9433 the situation was very much different with Bangladesh sir, it was always meant to part because of their different language , culture and the amount of distance between the two countries

@literally_lore

3 ай бұрын

@syedbakeruddinbekar9433 every country is randistan nowadays, where do you live? in heaven ?

I am currently in Kashmir and I find the people here were happy and loving because of the increase in tourism and uplifting the standard of living. The panel here is living a dream if they think all the Kashmiris will choose azadi. I predict in 10 years kashmir will change so much that Pakistanis will give POK out of sheer humiliation.

@sanji438

7 ай бұрын

Its Illegaly indian occupied J&k IIOJ&K

@parvindersingh9781

7 ай бұрын

they see things in black and white , its irrelevent to discuss these statements of so called anlyst is for internal consumptions their country

@Akshaysen35

7 ай бұрын

so true🤣🤣🤣

@samarthpat

6 ай бұрын

Paxtan and Humiliation are synonyms...but that doesn't mean they'll give POK away cos they don't feel Humiliation and take it as a victory 😂

@KingKong-lb3vh

6 ай бұрын

@@parvindersingh9781 yes same ol' loud farting bongian about falana banega Pakistan, tamkana banega Paaaaaaaaaqistaaaaan

I really love pakistani podcasts......good for comedy😂😂

@haziqmalik8273

7 ай бұрын

Lol same as we enjoy modi,s blunders on international forums 🤣🤣

@FuadJalil

7 ай бұрын

I agree, reminds me of Indian media in general, hilarious as fuck....

@rjrangani

7 ай бұрын

@@haziqmalik8273 Yes....blunders made INDIA 5th largest economy.......you must enjoy my PMs blunder....what else can you do?🤣🤣🤣

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

Says someone who has people like arnab (loud speaker) goswami and the gang of godi media who came only yell on participants 😅😅😅

@puravanshyamalan7975

6 ай бұрын

​@@FuadJalil🐪 piss cahiye?

In 1965, Pakistan was in its strongest position against India. 1. It had not broken up. 2. It had joined CENTO and SEATO becoming an Ally of the USA & receiving Patton Tanks and Field Guns from USA. 3. INDIA had lost a war with China in 1962. 4. Our PM Nehru had just died in 1964. 5. The leadership of Sri Sastri was untested. Yet, Pakistan lost the War as it could not change the position of the State of J&K.

@islamicedits3062

7 ай бұрын

It was draw bro.

@ravindra7791

7 ай бұрын

​@@islamicedits3062The war was initiated by Pakistan sensing the above situation (India weak and Pakistan strong) but they couldn't change the status quo , so even if it was a draw technically it was a strategic loss. It also convinced Indian strategic thinkers that Pakistan will always be looking for a fight and has to be split at the next available opportunity, which promptly presented itself in 71.

@islamicedits3062

7 ай бұрын

@@ravindra7791 look at india size and pakistan compare army strength? Bacho wale baat na karo if we start comparing that phr india comes out as looser

@agnosticatheist4093

7 ай бұрын

@@islamicedits3062 Tab hum apne defense mein utna nahi kharachte the, humari maishat ustime China se bhi bari thi lekin defense budget mein utna nahi kharachte the issi liye humlog 62 war hargaye the. Nehru ek socialist tha woh kabhi Pakistan yah China ko dushman nahi samajhta tha issi liye humara approach kabhi bhi Jung nahi thi. Yeh defensive mindset Indira Gandhi ne pahli dafa change kiya.

@bossheroop8375

7 ай бұрын

@@islamicedits3062 Bahi Pak lost because we started the war and ended up only defending our land, so are you a fool who will call us winners, still we fought with bravery that's where you are true

within next 10 years pakistan will not be there on map 😊😊

@samadislam42

Ай бұрын

Replace Pakistan with India in your comment because time will tell. Remember that, China is ready behind your back and separation is also ready in your Indian States if the current govt doesn't give their rights to them plus many other issues in those states. No doubt, India will attack Pakistan, but after that things will slip out of India's hand. We have strong predictions. Confirm from your Jotishies. First, do your homework then come here for comment.

The irrelevance of Pakistani Army against India can be gauged from the fact that DHA Phase 8 of *DHA LAHORE* developed & maintained by Pakistani Army is about 3 Kms from India Pakistan border as it knows there will be never a battle between India & Pakistan. Pak Army is a gang of feudals who in the garb of national security want & try to have complete control over all the resources of Pakistan leaving about 90% of the public struggling to meet their daily needs

@tahaqasim9572

7 ай бұрын

L pe charho

@ettar-e-murshad

7 ай бұрын

❤😮❤ درست کہا

@trilokyamohanchakra6351

7 ай бұрын

@@tahaqasim9572 yehi toh rasool ne 9yrs ki bacchi ke saath kiya tha

@kolardorpe3161

7 ай бұрын

@@trilokyamohanchakra6351 Dinge Dinge. 🤩🤩🤩😛

@harshsinha6252

7 ай бұрын

Yeh host ko psychological problem hai kyaa😅😅😅

He is the only one who dare to tell the truth about this 🍌 Republic.

@akhileshp4040

7 ай бұрын

Ye bewakoofon ka sardaar hai

Sir i m from kashmir valley belive me not a single person will vote for pakistan because we want peace and you know wat is happening is pakistan from last 75 years

Pakistan or China or both together will never allow Kashmir to remain an Independent State. If Modi's action is a stupidity then such studipity is an welcome move. Pakistan does not have such strong digestive system to consume whole Kashmir. Now, Kashmiris understand the reality and destiny of Kashmir. Kashmir can survive only by becoming a part of Union of India. No other option is available.

@pipipupu5104

7 ай бұрын

Exactly

@parthparth433

7 ай бұрын

Spot on . Instrument of accession is final.

@WHT_QM

6 ай бұрын

Pakistan ki koi value nahi hay

@sehroshkhan1623

6 ай бұрын

As a kashmiri living in POK this will never gonna happen yes if u give us chance of referendum let people decide it can work but by force you weren't able to do that for 76 years try for next 7600 years and you will always face trouble in kashmir

@aneelRmd

4 ай бұрын

​@@sehroshkhan1623 Gulam bola nahi karte @sehroshkhan1623 , chup kar Vaise b tu Punjabi Pakistani hai isliye bolne ka haq b ni rakhta tu

شبر صاحب کا سچ قابل تحسین ہے میں نے دونوں جس میں ریلوے پی آئی اے سٹیل مل کا ذکر ہے سچ پر مبنی ہے سچ ہمیشہ ک

During the 65 war, it was the Kashmiris who reported Pakistan infiltration to the authorities.

@fakharrana8447

7 ай бұрын

Not verified. One side perspective

@pipipupu5104

7 ай бұрын

​@@fakharrana8447it's is verified by several sources Google operation Gibraltar.

@RajeshKumar-ob9zy

7 ай бұрын

True... That fact will never be accepted by disillusioned Pakistanis.

@silver_springs22

7 ай бұрын

@@fakharrana8447 your side perspective is correct the other side is wrong. This is the basis of every muslim. And here lies the main problem. Learn to live with reality.

@Anonymous-px9wk

7 ай бұрын

​@@fakharrana8447 yes only kashmir banega Pakistan is verified 😂😂😂😂

42:26 He didn't even hesitate 😂😂 43:16 Nikaal lo, khatam kro, kyu billions of dollars k loans lete ho 😂😂 🇮🇳

The fact that Pakistan is dying and these Pakistani intellectuals started the conversation with Kashmir shows the intelligence of entire Pakistan on the matter of home affairs. People of Kashmir have already rejected the idea of Pakistan but Pakistan is a lover boy who cant handle the rejection and they will make sure that the Pakistani people die of hunger and basic sanitation/heath issues, not questioning its entire past and rich making money out of it.

@channelname1473

6 ай бұрын

baqi sab theek hai, sanitation issues per INDIANS baat na hi karain tau acha hai... shochaalya 🚽 banwao bhaashan baad mein dena, railway tracks aur beaches per tatti kaun karta saari dunya ko pata hai

Pakistan has no claim on Kashmir, legally or logically. Pakistani azad Kashmir has a very small Kashmiri population. Majority are Punjabi/potohari. Pakistan can’t keep any part of Kashmir based on their own argument

@bilalshoukat2345

7 ай бұрын

@Maybank. tell this extrodinary crap to china and america they will gonna tell u where india is standing india is surrounded by Russia china and with asians muslims . but america is a war starting organization ur on ur own it's not abt kashmir it abt AKHAND BHARAT which will burn india and u have seen it already in afghanistan and in israel which hammas and taliban have done with others. we will never gonna stop them if Modi tries to get smart .

In next 10 years, India GDP will touch 10 Trillion Dollar. During same period, Pakistan will go worst, currently Pakistan is bankrupt, It wont survive may be in next 10 years. In that case, What do you think Kashmiri people will decide & whether with this India will allow it to separate. Its a Haseen Sapane of Shabbar Zaidi.

@AvijeetGupta

7 ай бұрын

Whether it's literate or illiterate paxtani mindset will remain same as they got same basic education of talking rubbish & habit of poking their nose into every matter

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

“Pakistan will not survive” we have been hearing this since past 75 years.

@kapilsethia9284

7 ай бұрын

@@msr7373 bhai agar Bangladesh ke bad pakistan survive kar raha hai to sindhudesh, balochistan aur pashtunistan ke bad bhi kar hi sakta hai.

@pipipupu5104

7 ай бұрын

​@@kapilsethia9284ab woh reply nhi karenge janab

@beautyzline5194

7 ай бұрын

​@@kapilsethia9284bengladesh ko start se hi log nahi pasand karte the yaha ayub khud bengladesh ko alag karna chahta tha

If Pakistan and Pakistanis wants Kashmir to be neutral, In that case why Pakistan send army to Kashmir to capture. The whole conflict started after raiders started war in Kashmir.

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

The whole conflict started when hindu maharajah decided to stall the process of accession by delaying . He should have acceded to Pakistan as kashmir was a Muslim majority, all rivers entered pakistan, all roads and sole rail link it had with india was through Pak. If the country was being divided on the basis of religion then Kashmir should have gone to Pakistan just like Hyderabad and Junagadh and bikaner, Jaisalmer Etc became part of india.

@xperiarj1458

7 ай бұрын

​@@msr7373British Raj ended with lapse of paramountcy, and if you understand what this means.. Maharaja of Kashmir was well within his right to not accede and chose to remain independent no matter how impractical that might have proved to be. Pakistan by sending kabayalis and troops violated this.. now you'll say Kashmir was muslim majority, but just go and read each of 565 princely states that agreed to join in with Indian or Pakistani dominion, did so by signing instrument of accession. Nothing was done before signing of instrument of accession, case in point referendum in Junagadh was also held after the prime minister of then Nawab, Mr. Shahnawaz Bhutto signed instrument of accession to India.

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

@@xperiarj1458 kashmir wasn’t the only one. Hyderabad wanted to be independent but did india let it? No. As for Junagadh, it initially signed the instrument in favour of Pakistan but india blockaded the territory and then forced the accession to be signed in favour of india. Let’s be honest. Would india let kashmir be independent had partition not happened and entire british india would have transformed into a united india? Never. When india didn’t allow any state to remain independent then why kashmir? And as for kashmir, the maharaja despite signing the standstill agreement kept on delaying his decision which coincided with the Jammu massacre after which the tribals/Pak entered.Kashmir had no place in india post partition, neither demographically nor geographically.

@ravindra7791

7 ай бұрын

​@mkm4114Indeed , Balochistan's human rights have been totally violated

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

@mkm4114 name one princely state which india or Pak let remain independent? Second Balochistan was not one princely state but consisted of 4 princely states namely Kalat Lasbela Kharan and Makran along with the province of Balochistan which formed the northern most part of the present day Baluchistan province . Only kalat wasn’t acceding to Pakistan, the rest acceded to Pakistan willingly and before kalat.Kalat was never invaded but decided to sign the instrument of accession when it saw that it had a weak case of being independent and when Quaid e Asam himself negotiated with khan of Kalat. Unlike india which literally invaded Hyderabad and Junagadh with forces. Pelampaali India nay 80-90s mein Punjab mein ki , north east mein ki aur ab Manipur aur Kashmir mein kar raha hai. Even south mein bhi daba kar pelampaali ki thi during anti Hindi agitation where it killed more Tamils then number of Bengalis killed during 1952 bhasha Andolan in east Pakistan.

Thanks for this programme and Pak opinion. Believe there is going to be a surprise on the kashmir future, particularly with respect to Kashmiri Pandits. Jai Bharat

I wish such geniuses continue to thrive in land of the pure we will nat have to worry for the next 1000 years. Fyi switzerland has an army of 500k conscription is mandatory for Swiss men.switzerlaand has a foreign minister Ignazio Cassis. Keep it up

Great raftarrr doing podcast with this guyyy he's so much talented and wise knowledgeable personn

Very comprehensive and strong analytical analysis, God bless both of you. Waiting for the next part !

Now I understand why Pakistan collapsed and how PTI got ruined with people like Shabbar zaidi in high post in the govt like FBR and finance ministry.... keep goin on...

@cargeek8419

7 ай бұрын

You are right. In another podcast he outlined how when he proposed tax on agriculture, Shah Mahmood Qureshi lead a team of senators to the PM house to protest. When he wanted to tax the retail sector, he was physically assaulted by trader representative in a high level meeting. So let's give credit where credit is due!

@deepakmor9982

7 ай бұрын

😂😂😂

Agreed , he is the best analyst of this country we need a leader like him, but unfortunately we couldn't have a person like him

Well said that winning of 92 World Cup was disaster,

@chandnikhan680

7 ай бұрын

Why? And how come no one wins untill now ? What a shame

@iftikharali6913

7 ай бұрын

all wise mr zaidi please study matters before opening the traps

@zachazia443

7 ай бұрын

Offcource if you Indian you don't want Pakistan to win the world cup, and specifically make a true leader that won't lesten to BJP 😂😅😂😅

Mr Zaidi’s comment regarding Mujibur Rahman being convicted in the Agartala conspiracy case and being released in early 1970 by Yahya Khan is incorrect. Mujib was not convicted and was released in Feb 1969 during Ayub Khan’s rule. My Shoukat Ali Dy Speaker of Bangladesh parliament did accept in Feb 2011 that all charges of treason against Mujib were true. He was also an accused in the case so fully aware of the facts.

@user-cz2cb1os2v

7 ай бұрын

AND HE HAS CONTEST ELECTION UNDER PAKISTAN LAW ;AND DENIED TOGIVE HIS VOTE S RIGHT; 1ST U HAVE SNATCH THE MAJORITY ON EQUILLITY AND LATER NOT ACCEPT THEIR MAJORITY IN ELECTION ;SO U R TRAITOR ;NOT THEY R;;WHY KPK AND BALUCHISTAN R AGAINST PUNJABS ROLE JUST BCZ U SNACH THE COMMUNITY RIGHT AND PAYING 4 IT.

I love all the topics on this channel since from start. I suggest you guys should also make researched base video of caste system of Pakistan.

You cannot imagine willpower and thinking way of Modi., not even 1%. Baki Dil khush rakhne ko galib khyaal accha hai.

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

Says someone who lost galwan to china during Modi Ji and he has been able to convince the people that "koi Aya Nahin" 😅

@sachindhoni2095

5 ай бұрын

​@@msr7373Modiji Ne Sexy Aaisha, Sexy Khadeeja, Sexy Fatima, Sexy Zubeida, Sexy Sawdah, Sexy Hafsah, Sexy Rayhana, Sexy Zaynab, Sexy Safiyyah, Sexy Maria Ka Halaalaa Bandh Karaa Diya Hai.😜🤪😉😃😀😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Kudos to Raftar and Sir Shabbar Zaidi sir ❤❤❤❤❤

India never wanted bangladesh to merge with india. We already had millions of hungry and poor people at that time, if india wanted it could have taken bangladesh but in reality we had no interest in bangladesh.

@AvijeetGupta

7 ай бұрын

paxtani are good in giving lollipop while talking

@umerrashid4940

7 ай бұрын

Ok then merge West Bengal with Bangladesh in the name of Joye Bangla...West Bengal has lower GDP than Bangladesh. It was reverse in 1947.

@AvijeetGupta

7 ай бұрын

@@umerrashid4940 by which logic you think that if WB didn't doing good in current time than GoI will merge it with neighbouring countries, instead of bringing roadmap to bring state back on track? Get some good education instead of reading aasmani kitab

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

Doesn't matter what India wanted. The important thing was that Bangladesh never though of merging back with India despite all of its cultural affinity to west Bengal, being literally surrounded by India on three of its sides and having a decimated economy. This speaks volumes that the so called idea of Akhand Bharat was flawed to begin with

@user-wg6sk6mw4d

7 ай бұрын

that doesn't matter what you toilet less ppl want . matter is what we thing about you.if we wanna merge with you or not.

Till yesterday, I used to consider Shabbir Zaidi as an Intelligent Analyst. But, when he said that Modi made a MISTAKE by Abbrogating Article 370, I could Not help but LAUGH. He does Not know that the Kashmiris have ALREADY REALIZED NOW that the Article 370 was hindering Development & PEACE in Kashmir. They are openly THANKING Modi for bringing Development & PEACE in Kashmir.

92 world cup BAD_QISMATI thi... sb se zabarddast baat ki with smile...

How can Pakistan Army be irrelevant when it is rampaging through the leftovers of Pakistan?

@TruthPrevailz

7 ай бұрын

Lol

@chichha420

7 ай бұрын

irrevelavant for the south asia geo politics

@bossheroop8375

7 ай бұрын

fuck your mind

Always honour to listen sir zaidi

What a man! one of the best podcast 👌

fan of this guy , we need more podcast with him

Good discussion!

Thought provocative analysis. Love Mr. Zaidi's rational approach!

@akhileshp4040

7 ай бұрын

Ye gadha hai

I am impressed, very reasonable talk. Our big problem is that we are mostly unreasonable and don't hear rasonable.

UN ki resolution Israel ki liey, lekin Palestine, aur Kashmir per UN resolution apply nahein....Wah Wah. Eh hi Shabbar ki danishwari !

AoA another masterpiece by team Raftar. Shabar sir is surely a real statement and his views are connected to the ground because he thought about Pakistan issues from the brain, not from the heart. Just a history check Shk Mujib ur Rehman is in jail because of the Agartala case till 22 December 1971 and the fall of Dhaka happened on 16 means Mujib was released 7 days after Dhaka's fall. And Awami League was established by Hussain Shaeed Suharwardi and Mujib took over after his death. The project name of offshore drilling near Karachi was "kakra 1". Keep it up team Raftar.

What is hilarious is the thought that 10 billion USD influx basically doubles the market cap of the Pakistani stock exchange while the BSE listed companies have a market cap of 4 trillion USD. Kahan aap India se compare karte hain khud ko, jaiye sub-saharan Africa mein competition dhundhiye

@Noman-gq1hz

5 ай бұрын

Slumdog millionaire

Great Shabbar Zaidi Sahab, I have never watched such an interview in which truth and only truth prevails. Salute to you Sir.

@arundhawan8574

7 ай бұрын

They are both ignorant of basic facts.

Thankyou,Excellent and loved it.

Brilliant vlog and topic selection. One request pl take critical nation building challenges of Pakistan in your future vlogs like - Education Reach & Quality - Quality of healthcare - Population Crisis -Radicalization of society by Mullah & Military - Technology & manufacturing led Investment in Pakistan - Agriculture reforms -New policy framework for social& industrial development

Sorry. It is not shaikh abdulla. But Raja Hari Singh.

370 was abrogated in 2019 not in 2023. If anything, Kashmiris are happy today with more integration with India. SC has merely put a seal of approval on something that was done in 2019.

Great Man Shabbar Zaidi.......His analysis is at fact base...great pod cast bro

The people of Pakistan are not divided about Imran Khan, but they are united on Imran Khan. This division is the first division after Pakistan. That is why the powerful wolves of Pakistan who are scratching Pakistan are angry that why a messiah like Imran has come.

@viswanathbangalore9640

7 ай бұрын

With UR statement & assertion that Imran Khan being the latest Islamic Messiah ( Prophet) , U have challenged one of the basic five pillars of Islamic Belief! Good luck to U 🤞!

@nowie4007

6 ай бұрын

Imran Khan is no messiah of ours ,he is just another politician

Great Men Shabbar zaidi

"Shabbar Zaidi's thought-provoking views resonate strongly. His suggestion to reconsider ties with Israel and focus on strengthening relations with the USA highlights the evolving dynamics in global politics. Additionally, his perspective on China's role in Pakistan's economic challenges adds an important layer to the conversation, urging us to critically assess partnerships for the betterment of our nation's economic future. A compelling stance that encourages reflection on the intricate threads of international relations."Shabbar, sir, you are great, and religious parties of Pakistan should also reconsider their political views ,and Pakistanis should realise that because of china, we lost our total economic growth ...the biggest threat to the world and Pakistan is definitely China

He is a very genus man sir shabar zadi i respect his knowledge and style of talking.

at 28:50 I came up with this exact same argument about two nation theory when I was studying in college 22 years ago. I can't understand why people fail to accept this reality.

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

So true. I never understood why people are so dumb not to think through

@SunnyYadav-ny5kf

7 ай бұрын

There were many factor involved USA was on pakistan sides. Un would pass resolution against india. China could have attacked indian northern border. India was not economic power to deal with all of this. Only with a person with lack of knowledge will buy your argument. Read US declassified reports.

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

@@SunnyYadav-ny5kf he is talking about the 2 nation theory. It’s a known fact that Bangladesh never wanted to join india back despite being separated from it for just 24 years 4 months and 2 days. Thus validating the 2 nation theory and scrapping the idea of akhand bharat. And you really think that India had no backing back then? It had complete support of UK USSR and France. India wasn’t alone in 1971. It had an advantage I’ve tied enemy no other nation ever had ie completely surrounding Bangladesh on three of its sides with Pakistan having no border link to East Pakistan, to top it up a much larger army against Pakistan. It was no miracle if india won.

@govuxyz

7 ай бұрын

2 nation theory was not agreed by INC but India opted for peace and didn't hold itself hostage to the anti 2 Nation Theory - albeit India wasn't capable to to turn Bangladesh into India but neither was the intent. So I guess we'll have to settle with the argument that the 2 Nation Theory has stood the test of time but it comes with a caveat that the Nation carved BY the PEOPLE on Cultural/Linguistic grounds have done better ie Bangladesh whereas the autocratic bureaucracy state (Pak) hasnt done well.

@SunnyYadav-ny5kf

7 ай бұрын

@@msr7373 India never had the intention to join Bangladesh in india. it only joined war to stop genocide by Pakistan army due to millions of refuge coming to india. And read history correctly from authentic source not madrassa chap books. Uk and france denied weapons to india. Uk and Usa send their nuclear fleet to defend Pakistan and attack india. Even china supportered Pakistan. Only ussr was on india side. Usa even saved you in 1971 when india had planned to attack pok but CIA intervention saved u. If india wanted akhand bharat india would easily annexed sri lanka, nepal, bhutan, bangladesh militarily. Like pakistan annexed balocistan and china annexed tibet.

By his telling Imran Khan was really Im the Dim...

جیو شبر زیدی حقائق کو ایسے بیان کر رہے ہیں جو قابل فہم ہے

This is some real intellectual talk... Enjoyed and learned a lot from this. Thankyou Shabbar sb and Raftar

@raftartv

3 ай бұрын

You’re welcome bro 😎

This man was asked by General chief to tell me how to political element imran and pti! So he is.doing well

This country sadly is already in Collapsing Mode and would cease to exist or be of any relevance as it has FUNDAMENTAL FLAWS OF GOVERNANCE & LEADERSHIP . Just pray it does not go the Syrian or Afghanistan way.

@_Ismail.

7 ай бұрын

It definatly go the iranian way 1979. Remember???

I really like the way talks and the wisdom you share with us.

Shabbar Zaidi has a hawk eye and look into each matter and problems of Pakistan with an intellectual way.

Brilliant man

Rather than just focusing on his opinion about relations with Israel , Guys try focusing on all OTHER exceptional point of views he presented... like the Bangladesh matter or leaders not knowing the ground reality matter and knowing the right history... JUST OUTSTANDING !!!👏👏👏

@muhammadahsan5454

7 ай бұрын

agreed, although i dont agree with his stance on israel, a very coward thinking, but yes we can appreciate him for the other points too

@umroyaar

7 ай бұрын

Kia israel 🇮🇱 aur pakistan 🇵🇰 ki kabhi war hui ? Kia koi border issue he ? Agr pakistan 🇵🇰 islam k name pe bnna sahih to israel 🇮🇱 yahoodion k liye bnna galat kyun ?

@ANASARIFRIAZ

7 ай бұрын

@@umroyaar Pakistan kisi ki zameen pay kabza kar kay nahi bana hai !!

Pakistani podcasts are real comedy , beating all comedy shows. Keep it up.

18:28. Mulvis don't resist acceptance of Israel, they don't have any other topic. ❤. Wisdom unfolds.

I think, Pakistan should seriously consider how Balochistan can be given independence. A tripartite meeting can be held with India and Baloch people to work out Modus operandi. India should help Pakistan to peacefully transfer the power to Baloch people. I think both Pakistan and Balochistan can develop after that.

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

I think, india should seriously consider how Khalistan and Kashmir can be given independence. A tripartite meeting can be held with Pakistan and sikhs/Kashmiris to work out modi’s operandi. Pakistan should help india to peacefully transfer the power to the Sikhs and Kashmiris . I think both India and Sikhs/Kashmiris can prosper and become more peaceful after that

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

Balochistan is not east Pakistan. India has no border with Balochistan nor is there any Baloch population residing in India. India has no role or say in Balochistan. Second Balochistan is divided between Pak and Iran. Do you really think that Iran will allow Pakistani side of Balochistan to become independent when the same can create instability on their side of Balochistan and start an independence movement there. I am actually enjoying comments from Godi media/WhatsApp university grads from india 😂

Sir, I have a suggestion for you to start a new series What is security of the state? Topic 1. Food Security 2. Water Security 3. Internal & external Security 4. Cyber Security 5. Job Security 6. National interest Security 7. Import & Export Security 8. Educational Security 9. Our friendly country Security 10. And many more

5 साल हो गए आज कश्मीरी खुश हैं इंडिया के साथ 😊 अब क्या बोलना है 😂😂😂😂

I am from Kashmir Mr.shabber is a broad minded person he knows that mullas and sectism molvis has mislead the Islam .

There are few facts regarding 370 Mr Zaidi got wrong, but some opinions he got right:- 1) 370 and 35 A were temporary provisions of Indian constitution signed by Maharaja of Kashmir and not Sheik Abdula...Sheik Abdula and Nehru were friends both were Kashmiri..and socialists ..they both were against Pakistan. 2) Mr Zaidi is right about 370 bringing all political parties in Kashmir together..but fact is that general public in Kashmir has started to give up the idea of violence..it might change in future but as it stands. Also protests in Gilgit Baltistan to join India is seen with interest in Kashmir...ideally they want to be free..but if they can't then they grudgingly prefer to stay with India. 3) With regards removal of 370 increasing land purchase is false idea. For BJP it was there election promise that in one country you can't have two flags two constitution etc. By the article like 370 exist in other states in India..but they all can be amended..when needed..nothing is set in stone. 4) I am Kashmiri Pandit..so I m a bit biased but at the same time..I do have a better understanding..if you do voting by regions in J&K with only India and Pak option..then Azad Kashmir will vote for Pak, Jammu, Laddak and most of Kashmir will vote for India...but area around Srinagar might vote of Pak based on political situation around the time of voting..I think it will be similar in Gilgit ..most likely will vote for Pak but could vote for India based on political situation...so I think practical solution will be changing LOC to international border..and I think Pak and India are starting to work on this..Pak will make Gilgit as new province.

@vinsin328

7 ай бұрын

1) Nehru put Sheikh Abdullah in Jail for no reason. In reality, 370 expired in 1958 itself. 2) The people of GB are not Kashmiri and have no right to vote in a plebiscite. 3) Right 4) People of Azad Kashmir do not have the right to vote on plebiscite. The majority of people in Azad Kashmir are Punjabi. The people from Laddakh are not Kashmiri and again do not have the right to vote in Plebiscite.

@Anonymous-px9wk

7 ай бұрын

​@@vinsin328if plebiscite happens ( which will never happen) then it will happen in whole j&k as describing in united nations which includes Gilgit baltistan POK & Indian administered kashmir & ladhak Please check the map & areas under which united nations recommend plebiscite

@edinburghaccies2

7 ай бұрын

​@@vinsin328 Its true ,Nehru did put Sheik in jail...but that was much latter and then Sheik's party did form government with Congress multiple times. *) It's not about Just Kashmir ...it's about whole J&K state...true that Azad Kashmir has lost whole kashmiri culture bcoz of Punjabi and Urdu imposition..but still they do have same rights. *) The only practical solution will be change LOC to International border.

@vinsin328

7 ай бұрын

@@Anonymous-px9wk GB people are not Kashmiri, and so are the majority of people of POK, Ladakhis are not Kashmiri. Pakistan will never agree on a Plebiscite.

@vinsin328

7 ай бұрын

@@edinburghaccies2 1) I never talking about just Kashmir. Nope non-Kashmiri are not part of plebicite. Nehru put the Sheikh in 1954 for saying that Kashmiri Muslims support and will vote for Pakistan.

Election ki Koi zarorat nahin !!

@MUJAHID.KHOKHAR

7 ай бұрын

Waja right to vote basic right hy

@variavaria1

7 ай бұрын

Waja, hamare gaon mein Biryani ki aik plate pey right of vote use hotaa hey.. Phir wohi thagon ki baraat ajaye gi - agar election huey

Always fun to listen to Zaidi saab..

I think I might be wrong but not a single Kashmiri is thinking joining a Pakistani military inc. nation will be better than India in any dimension of time. Pakistanis should focus on how their military is the richest company of Asia and don’t allow private players to compete and hence not much tax collection. The biggest r enemy of Pakistani people is their army. Which is actually a corporate and not an army

Great documentaries , keep it up Raftar

This guys is making the rounds in all of the podcasts, one has to wonder why?

@MrG_11

7 ай бұрын

Yes I'm also curious

@Striker-jg9kv

7 ай бұрын

Is that what your begairat behaya ghasti ammi khala baaji use to do with some idol worshipper kaafir Rana ?😂😂😂

@ranawaleedkhan9846

7 ай бұрын

Not just anti imran khan, hes laying the foundation for the ssentiments for the upcoming election@jang-e-bahadur

@WELSHDESI

7 ай бұрын

‘’5th Generation’’ warfare! If you guys remember these words from someone one years ago!🤫

At 18 minutes you asked a question that why are Religious leaders of Pakistan are not reacting to Pakistan's position to support Israel ? You were right because Pakistan is a Islamic country so even geo politics has to be based on religious principles.

Shabbar is a wise and intelligent person 👍 Pleasure listening to him 😊

Sir please uhyghur Muslims ke topics per bhi baat kijiye

@raghukrishna9841

7 ай бұрын

They don't have spunk in their balls

@AmrikKulana

7 ай бұрын

Us par kya baat kare ge 😂😂 porki hai 😂 such to nahi bolege

Great initiative ... good job.

Excellent and eye opening debate !

Accepting Israel is a political issue, not a religious issue... I accept this logic.

@Anonymous-px9wk

7 ай бұрын

Will your muslim religious people will also accept this logic?

@Ghdaron-ka-dushman

7 ай бұрын

Religious only

@Ghdaron-ka-dushman

7 ай бұрын

​@@Anonymous-px9wkit's religious matter this guy is living in his own world we hate Israel and there are so many reasons for that hate like how they are killing civilians innocents

@daniyalamed2960

7 ай бұрын

Well even politically i dont want the country to associate with an apartheid state. Enough said.

@Anonymous-px9wk

7 ай бұрын

@@daniyalamed2960 Pakistan was also created as a apartheid state on 2 nation theory that states hindus and muslims are different races and cant live together Israel and Pakistan are only 2 country in world which were created on the name of religion

Wow, Wonderful Man he is ❤ Team Raftat Try to bring more such type of personalities in your modcats. I really like him the way he talks and the wisdom he share with us.

@user-cz2cb1os2v

7 ай бұрын

HE IS ONLY BLUNT BUT NOT A WISE ;INFACT HE TEACHES PEOPLE HOW TO MAINTAIN TAX BOOK TO AVOID TAX BUT WE R ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;HHHHHHHHHHHHHAAAAA

Mashallah , very good. Basically it's only Truth. And Truth has own power, no one denies it . Sabar zadi Shahib Zinda Abad.

What an excellent interview by a visionary & sincere person.He analytical approach is very logical n still our political Gurus don't understand the real issue of Pakistan .

He is amongst the few renowned intellectuals in pakistans ,who nevers fails to provide a thought provoking insight with well structured analysis

@malikahmad8170

7 ай бұрын

He failed to bring any reform in the assigned task given to him

@nomi1902

7 ай бұрын

He also answered why he could not with some names and positions.

@kenkenken628

7 ай бұрын

I don't agree, Moreover he is indicating a different direction for Pakistan towards the basic mentality and diversions for Pakistan and Pakistani,I personally think that would be disastrous for Pakistan. He's main object and thoughts are rellyning towards anti army

@SulemanAbbas-jp3im

7 ай бұрын

Iskko intellectual bolna apki intelligence ki insult hai

Kashmir the whole of it has always been integral part of Bharat !!

@teresabutler6250

7 ай бұрын

You mean as Arunachal is the integral part of People Republic of China 😂👍😊

@dwirajesh

7 ай бұрын

@@teresabutler6250 I mean the whole of Americas belong to the aboriginals

Magnificient analysis by respected Shabbar Bhai.

Excellent analysis as a logical rationale individual, well informed and very well educated.

Kya aaj jo Pakistan main ho raha hai iska dilo main darar paida nahin horaha ?

Kashmir historically, in fact Spiritually has been a critical Part of Bharat.

I get a peace of mind by going thro' Pakistan's comedy. Nothing in this world can beat it.

Kashmiri will like to buy atta at Rs 150, instead of Rs 20, article 370 was temporary which has been removed

@bommasrinu7679

7 ай бұрын

Well compared 😅😅😅

Even if recognition of Israel is a political matter, still it would be disaster for Pakistan considering the murderous acts done by Israel and committing genocide. Pakistan did not recognize South Africa for a very long time because of its apartheid regimes and practice.

@yasirpk2002

7 ай бұрын

China also destroyed Muslim population in Xinjiang and the US also destroyed Iraq and Afghanistan so your point is invalid

@owaisahmed5549

7 ай бұрын

Using the same analogy or rationale, what is the point to recognize USA and France? Read about their current atrocities.

@Abstract.x

7 ай бұрын

Pakistan should un-recognize itself based on these merits

@silver_springs22

7 ай бұрын

@@Abstract.x i agree. Existence of pakistan itself is a huge issue for the world.

@abhinashkumar3161

7 ай бұрын

Like pak did with Bangladesh?

Really I never forgot his comment that 92 world cup was our bad luck. Solute to S Zaidi

This guy has no chill. So clear and honest.

Please release the 2nd part.

Shabbar sahb ek gohar-e-nayab hain jo aaj bhee bebaang-e-dehl sach bolte hain.

@SulemanAbbas-jp3im

7 ай бұрын

Kaddu... adha such boltay hein

@aahan1

7 ай бұрын

@@SulemanAbbas-jp3im unn ka sach aapko nahin pasand tau kuch nahin karr saktay hain

@SulemanAbbas-jp3im

7 ай бұрын

@@aahan1 yar Allah ko manu bhai... Acha aik bat batao, yeah kabhi kisi judge ko kisi chartered accountant ko corrupt q nahi bolta?!

@SulemanAbbas-jp3im

7 ай бұрын

@aahan1 agar yeah itna hi Sacha hai tu kabhi corrupt fbr officer ko kisi court mein q nahi ly kr gaya?! Halanky yeah khood fbr mein Ry chukka hai

@SulemanAbbas-jp3im

7 ай бұрын

@@aahan1 aik interview mein bakwas kr ra tha ky zardari ka cousin rto commissioner hai mein usko q Hataoon... o jahil ganwaar masla zardari ky cousin ky rto na honay ka nahi hai, masla zardari ky cousin ky fbr mein hotay huay kisi shareef admi ka kabhi na Ana hai

As someone who has spoken to many Kashmiris, Muslims at that. All Kashmiris seem happy with the abrogation of Article 370. There is more development and they are getting more benefits. In fact, I would like to think that the people in PoK might be envious of the development in Indian Kashmir. The panelists are thinking of political entities in Kashmir who were thinking of themselves and not the people of Kashmir. They are not looking at the ground reality.

BEST INTERVIEW!!!!

Very useful discussion.

29:10 True. Two-Nation Theory lives on.

@xperiarj1458

7 ай бұрын

In your fantasy, more than Bangladesh and more than Pakistan.. Muslims live and thrive in India, more mosques are there in India giving azaan than what's in Pakistan or Bangladesh.. and they are now a critical part of world's current fourth largest economy, moving forward in all walk of life.

@SunnyYadav-ny5kf

7 ай бұрын

Only a stupid will say that. There are many factors because of which Bangladesh didn't join. Main reason was it will give a reason ro usa and un to attack india.

@msr7373

7 ай бұрын

@@xperiarj1458 😂😂😂😂😂first if all Pakistan has more Muslims then India. Pal has a pop of 245 million if which 235 are Muslims compared to India's 210 million (15% of 1400 million). Second. Indian Muslims have the lowest par capita in India , they are heavily under represented in parliament , armed forces, judiciary etc. A few khan's in Bollywood and a few names like Azim Premji don't mean that all or even most Indian Muslims are well off. Even india's own various commission reports have proven this fact. Third since 2014 it is common for Indian Muslims to get lynched by cow vigilante , not getting homes in Hindu locality, made to prove their patriotism, prove thier citizenship after CAA, getting acused of love jihad, land jihad, Corona jihad, this jihad that jihad, being made to chant jai Shree ram, being called out abusive slurs like mulla mad@£(@d etc. etc. your vishwa guru is hell bound on proving the validity of partition. Bangladesh and Pakistan have their set of issues but thanks a lot we do not and will become a part of India. That was the best decision out forefather took.

@TaimoorTahir

6 ай бұрын

​@@xperiarj1458Stop giving logics of Grade 5 students.

@xperiarj1458

6 ай бұрын

@@TaimoorTahir hahah.. surely, i should keep quiet moreso when Pakistan has done doctorate level development... Deal with TTP first and if you're able to weather them, BLA stands in anticipation.