One word of caution. As someone currently trying to work in Unreal Engine 5 as an animation tool as opposed to a gaming engine, the amount of information you can find to problem solve things is so limiting that every day I think to myself that I should ditch it and just focus on Blender alone. In Blender you'll always be able to find your answer, in Unreal Engine? Good luck, because all the experts in Unreal Engine, are experts at it from the video game side, NOT the sequencer side. And trust me, there is definitely a difference. I've hired two tutors who specialize in Unreal Engine, and sat there after spending $50 an hour to discover that they have no clue how to do the stuff for the sequencer. I'm learning how to get through it all, but man when I was learning Blender it was easier to figure out what I needed. Only reason I stick around is because of how beautiful the worlds you can create are with all the assets they provide lol wish they'd update their documentation.

@saaaaaaaaadasda

Жыл бұрын

Okay, but is it smarter to do all animation in Blender and setup scene and then import it to render in real-time in UE 5? As far as i know, there's no limitation to rig's, unless you want to use some UE specific stuff. Sadly eevee can't render in real-time thing's like good shadows without it looking like a dud and wasting 15-20 seconds on every frame, which looks playing around with Cycles as a better solution, especially knowing that difference in quality is not even comparable.

@ielohim2423

Жыл бұрын

Currently the tuts for unreal engine 5 are limited but there are tons for unreal engine 4. The sequencer pretty much works the same in both. I started in ue4 so the transition to 5 has been simple. Don't expect to learn everything overnight though. I've been in unreal since 2020

@hartegane7202

Жыл бұрын

Hi! I would please like to connect with you If you wouldn't mind. I'm starting out on my journey and I know how frustrating it is looking for help and not getting any.

@hellerart

Жыл бұрын

@@saaaaaaaaadasda I think a fully set up scene in Blender can't be imported into unreal engine in any straight forward and simple way. Only imagine you use modifiers, animation nodes, blender specific material setups and so on and on... I think there is no realistic way to use Unreal engine only as a renderer for Blender. I think the scene would need to be build primarely in Unreal Engine. You can animate Charakters in Blender, but then I think you need to export them to seperately and put everything together with landscape and so on in Unreal. Of course landscape could be build in blender, too and exported, but here Unreal has more strngthes actually. Or just think of Motition Design stuff with animated booleans or any other modifiers and animation nodes - no change to get all of this to UE intact only for rendering. At least this is my opnion und impression, I use Blender for 7 years, but only learning Unreal now. I would recommend this: kzread.info/dash/bejne/e4V3sKxyfNPeXdY.html

@hellerart

Жыл бұрын

I totally agree for now - I still mess around 2 days to get the timeline and animation working and fidn a workflow for Blender export and Unreal Engine Animation. Yes it is posssible, but so far it does not feel as specially made for animation Artist not interested in interactive games. But I think a more streamlined Layout for Animation and even Adobe Software Support/Integrations is coming this year to UE 5.

I guess the answer is: know the strengths of both, use both. They complement each other quite nicely.

@dylandreisbach1986

2 жыл бұрын

Two amazing free programs that can handle most of what someone at home would need.

@darkconcept.

2 жыл бұрын

copied

@No-cc1fq

Жыл бұрын

@@darkconcept. as long its a good advice is fine

@darkconcept.

Жыл бұрын

@@No-cc1fq plagiarism is never fine bro

I don't start to see the video but Blender is a 3d program and UE5 is a game engine. You can't make assets with UE5 and you can't make games and levels effectively with blender. How can you compare? (After watching the video I think his comparisons makes sense)

@UltimateQball

3 жыл бұрын

Because apparently there are some believers who think Blender is this big mutli bundle software that can or plans to do everything the best. Which is false. You said it best, Blender is 3D program and UE5 is game engine

@UltimateQball

3 жыл бұрын

Also, yes you can do alot in Blender (not the best), but the thing about making game, movies, animations is finding shortcuts to cut down development time. Blender is doing the opposite, or behind. For example, looks like you have to create all those textures through blueprints. You can't just drag and drop smart materials. And that's when Substance Painter comes in.

@UltimateQball

3 жыл бұрын

I guess Blender is confused on what it wants to be. You can't do it all.

@tjseries3057

3 жыл бұрын

@@UltimateQball can say the same for literally all 3d softwares

@tjseries3057

3 жыл бұрын

@@UltimateQball You've been waiting a damn long time to bash the software of course

"..reacting to dangerous things, like,... birds" 😂

@sebirt

3 жыл бұрын

lol

@Tapajara

3 жыл бұрын

And pigeons or crows nonetheless.

Guys... Learn both of them... I mean both are efficient and free :D

@Maarten-Nauta

3 жыл бұрын

@CLaW PUBG Gaming Its free and you get the full quixel library for free aswell

@bartekl75

3 жыл бұрын

@CLaW PUBG Gaming I started with blender like 2 months ago. I think it is better to get into 3D softwares world (however i dont have any experience with UE). I highly recommend learning from Blender Guru. Watch his "4 weeks curicullum" video to get started and with some hard work you will learn blender. It is not an ad of a channel of sth, that's my personal opinion.

both programs complement each other and if you know how to use both of them then your end products will be better

@blendall5760

4 жыл бұрын

@Artisan That's very professional answer. Why should you pick one, when you can take both?

@pressfinchat

2 жыл бұрын

@@blendall5760 that's called indecisiveness and a jack of all trades is never better than a master of one.

@jonunderscore

2 жыл бұрын

​@@pressfinchat it's called diversification of tools

@Jekiterio

Жыл бұрын

@@pressfinchat You can't sculpt or do proper modeling in unreal as its meant to be used for asset placement and game development, this is 2 different programs which is why you can combine it and use unreal 5 as a endline pipline work for finishing off projects with Lumen render.

Been working on Blender for last 5 years. I see why people like real time rendering of UE 5. With Blender I put things for rendering and watch a movie, take shower and go to sleep. Next day I wake up and rendering still going on. Okay, it's not that slow but Blender rendering is slow for sure. But I don't think UE5 can beat blender in modeling. If I have to choose between Blender and UE5, I will always take blender.

@RebecaPascenco

Жыл бұрын

yes it is that slow 😭

1 year time traveller here. UE5 hands down. Work flow may be different in ue5 but it is definitely not worse than blender and you can buy an asset from the asset store to get studio grade setup. The share fact that render times are removed you can iterate and change things much quicker and with the lack of worry about poly count u can create truly stunning scenes. Efficiency overall more than doubles. Can also higher someone to make particle effect just the way u want them if u lack experience(yes, this is a petty jab at him saying well u can hire for blender).

@kazielbonn

2 жыл бұрын

Are you able to export fully fleshed out films with UE5 right now? Or does the trial/beta restrict exports?

@Gurem

2 жыл бұрын

You can but i recommend exporting each scene seperately and using a video editor to stich them together. For long animation sequences some frames might get jumbled for unknown reasons so i expect thats due to it being beta so just stich seperate scene sequences using a video editor as a work around.

@kazielbonn

2 жыл бұрын

​@@Gurem Perfect! Exactly the info I'm looking for. Really appreciate the details! Will get started soon then :)

@smashedlegends

2 жыл бұрын

Unreal is really clunky and the final results are glitchy.

@slomnim

2 жыл бұрын

you called it!

I'm gonna stick to blender for my modelling purposes, but definately Unreal for final video, it's... beautiful..

@joshepjane2162

Жыл бұрын

can you please explain how we can do this , i am beginner an confused

@Obwah

2 ай бұрын

@@joshepjane2162did you find out ?

Despite them doing completely different functions, I say why not use both

@socialfreak6900

3 жыл бұрын

blender to make and animate characters, unreal to finalize and run it all

@mikemarx9360

2 жыл бұрын

Here is comparison only for composing and rendering. Sure you can't model nothing good in ue5

Blender is 3d asset creation tool like maya, 3ds max, zbrush, mudbox whereas unreal is game engine like unity. Game engines have built in LOD system in terrain, which reduce polygons automatically when far away from camera. They also have occlusion culling, blackface culling and have baked shadows and so on to enable smooth gameplay Objects that are far away from camera are replaced by images known as imposters.

@soundninja99

3 жыл бұрын

Blender is built for animation too (check out blender animations on KZread), hence the comparison

@dineshdiabolic5451

3 жыл бұрын

@@soundninja99 precisely my point. Blender is a 3d models creation and animation tool while Unreal is a game engine. It's like comparing apple and oranges. You can't even rig a model that don't have vertex groups, let alone animating without using blender,maya or 3ds max at some point in unreal.

@soundninja99

3 жыл бұрын

@@dineshdiabolic5451 this is a video comparing the animation side of things though. No one is saying that blender can take on UE5 as a game engine or that UE5 can take on blender for modelling. They are both great for animation though, which is why this video compared the animation parts of both progrms

@dineshdiabolic5451

3 жыл бұрын

@@soundninja99 I dont know how you can animate 3d mesh inside a game engine. Unreal can't deform character meshes on it's own unless its pre rigged and even then, the animation needs to be stored somewhere inside a fbx file. All it can do is retarget humanoid animation from one rig to next.

@oddn6158

3 жыл бұрын

I don't know much but is Blender a tool to make models? For example, it is used to 3d model a rock. So is UE5 an engine to make games made by 3d models. Like using the 3d modeled rock to make a landscape for a game.

Bro thanks, unreal engine is extremely superior when it comes to real Time rendering and moreover it hardly crash, it saves your work automatically after like 30 secs, it has a view port which is easier to navigate and control.... But only one problem. community support is not enough for unreal engine. U get stuck that is it, u are done. U have to research on your own for weeks to come over the problem while in blender there are millions of tutorials.

@christopherpoet458

3 жыл бұрын

I honestly feel like you a missing something if you are going to sit there and say UE does not have many tutorials. Maybe you just are not using the right keywords? I am not sure, but I still disagree. 1. The community for UE is amazing. There are several highly populated Discord Channels all centered on UE and developing games and animations. DevSquad is one of the biggest developers I know on YT who has a massively strong following and a very supportive and helpful staff. Their YT channel does leave some to be desired in the completion of a "tutorial", but I boil it down to the fact that YT isn't going to pay all of Virtis's bills, and as many followers, he is a game developer and has projects that take time and commitment. In comparison, there are many other YT channels I have visited that either drop tutorials with no explanation, are not specific enough, or don't really categorize their tutorials to a particular genre but instead cover general topics. That said, despite any shortcomings, there may be there, there is a paratha of tutorials to work from. 2. Something I personally appreciate about the UE community too is that no one is going to hold your hand and spoon feed you though the learning process either. There is a tool or reference for just about anything you want to do with UE and people are willing to share. However, as the goal is to also teach and train people to improve and develop their skills, they also encourage and promote self-learning, researching, and well, trial and error. All three are vital aspects of the development process and learning how to use UE. 3. If you really are stuck and can't get through something, the UE Marketplace by Epic supports a massive amount of content ranging from textures to full games. Need an inventory system? Buy a functional one from the Marketplace and all you may have to do is update it to the latest version of UE if the creator has not already. Need models or textures? All are welcome and available. Need a crafting or resource system? Again, the marketplace. Shall I continue the list? 4. The biggest highlight I have here is how open, supportive, and helpful Epic is outside of just the community. Games you develop in UE can be used commercially with no cost to you until your sales breach $3k (Note, sale must be 3001+ per quarter. If you are at 3000 even, there is still no royalty fee. Royalty fee is 5%). There is no fee for films or any content that is made that is not interactive. It supports all platforms of gaming, not just PC. There are advanced licensing options if you need them and a customizable one that can be negotiated with Epic to suit your needs and their requirements. All things considered, Epic has been MASSIVELY generous with UE, their support for UE, and their support of the community. They drop free content on the UE marketplace every month, and some of those assets when not on sale are worth hundreds. Sales rotate often too and they are very supportive (from what I have seen) to the community that uploads products to the Marketplace. 5. Speaking of the marketplace, you can use anything you buy commercially in your projects. Another very generous decision on the part of Epic. Honestly, at this point, do I even need to continue this post? In all honestly, I probably stretched this WAY farther than I needed but the point I am trying to make here is that while at times it may be hard to find guides or tutorials, the community is very helpful in helping you fill in those blanks and if there is no guide, there is plenty of material for you to sit down, read, and learn how to make something on your own without being utterly blind. In any case, you are fully entitled to your optioning and I hope none of this came off as aggressive. This is my counter-argument though. Let me know what your thoughts are on my post here if you like. And honestly mate, if you need help with something on UE, ask. I can easily hook you up with several discord channels, a few other resources, and several good KZreadrs for guides. And beyond that, if you are willing to spend the extra dime, you can also get help from SkillShare.

@phonemrvmr8363

3 жыл бұрын

@@christopherpoet458 I get your point. But I gave up on UE months ago when I was still trying to learn it. Am not a professional coder but I want to try new things. When I searched on Google. Unreal Engine always comes on the top of the search. Even the KZreadrs recommend UE first, praising it's versatility and power but after two months of struggling I found out that UE is not as friendly as they say it is. I had given up on game engines until I came across Unity. I was able to accomplish many things in just a week with unity. Maybe UE is powerful and it has a community. But for my particular case I didn't find any or a few complicated tutorials were available. I was able to complete my app in two months with unity coz it has a huge support for every possible problem you face. I am not discouraging people from using UE but if are a beginner, go for Unity, coz u will get stuck and no one will help u. Before I put up that post, I was still learning UE and blender but now I am working with blender and Unity

@christopherpoet458

3 жыл бұрын

​@@phonemrvmr8363 Hay, I have no hard feelings against Unity. My reasoning to venturing into UE was more or less for something very different from games. However, i have dabbled into game development and committed a project for this year and all I wanted to clarify in that post is that it is not as unsupported as it may appear. I am not going to sit here and tell you you must use UE, but I will say that if you are ever willing to give it a second chance, reach out to me and I will give you what I have in terms of reference material to help you get going. You mentioned before you had little knowledge in coding and I can sit here and say all I have ever done with coding is 3 months of my learning Java and that is it. You don't "need" to be a coder to get around UE. Just need some patience and a willingness to learn the engine. I only posted all that because it felt a little unfair to say UE was unsupported when the community and the resources provided by said community are so vast. I found all that up there in my first two weeks browsing the internet. But hay, that is just an opinion really. So, good luck to you regardless of what you use. I probably sounded a bit defensive there and I will admit, I am partial to UE (clearly), but best of luck all the same :)

@phonemrvmr8363

3 жыл бұрын

@@christopherpoet458 okay bro, no hard feelings on my side either. But how will you go around the blueprints without logical thinking. But sure I will give it a second try and I will reach up to u.

@VoxRatio

3 жыл бұрын

@@phonemrvmr8363 Check out Unreal Sensei he has a new tutorial up days old for unreal engine 5. It’s much easier to learn than unreal 4.

Started learning UE5 for architectural visualization. First thing I tried was to import an ifcZIP model only to find that UE's datasmith only handles uncompressed ifc. The solution was to use blender with openbim plugin and convert the ifczip model to an fbx and reimport into UE. From there I drifted off and somehow ended up with a TPP shooter setup in a client's new mega store construction.

They're different in some areas. Try animating in Unreal and let me know how much hair is left in your head. Rendering in unreal puts Blender to shame and makes me feel embarrassed for having tried in the first place. But blender is much more user friendly and has a far better support system

@enigmawstudios4130

2 жыл бұрын

@@VirtualWil that and volumetrics. Virtually absent in Unreal. I've tried fluid Ninja but that's not realistic for filmmakers

I'm just getting into Unreal really and I do feel like thanks to lumen you can put out an animated short film without needing crazy rendertimea if you're just doing it as a private person. I'm currently working on a more sophisticated Project and the Rendertime I assume with Blender scares me a litte and I try to save on every corner and edge which will cut down the final product. I think of modelling, texturing and animating the assets in blender but use Unreal to actualy record the footage. Idk if that's a good and right approach to it. Just makes the most sense to me at my current knowledge level

Many thanks to you. You pretty much answered my questions.

"triangles, triangles, triangles!!!!" me: isnt that a rock?

Since the advancements in Blender with CyclesX, the planned new features for Eevee and the already working first few glimpses of the realtime compositor I don`t see that many reasons to use Unreal, which uses a lot of trickery to render so fast and which will show up at some point - and when they show up you`ll have a hard time fixing them or end up in a dead end. In any 3D software you will have numerous ways to fix stuff.

Question for Blender. How do you hide visibility / "transform" high details model into low-poly models in viewport for working in Blender ? Still trying to learn, but unable to use any of the models I have due to them being too "high quality", and I don't know how to "low-poly them".

@jascrandom9855

4 жыл бұрын

Pablo Dobarro recently implemented a operator that increases viewport performance when having high amounts of polygons. He has also implemented a Multires feature that can decrease the amounts of polys non-destructively. Both of these are coming in 2.90, and you can check his tweeter account twitter.com/pablodp606

@himmatsohi4261

4 жыл бұрын

Well , to decrease polygons of an object, select that object then go the modifiers and select decimate. Then decreace the ratio to small number. Don't click apply unless u want permanently decrease the poly count.

Great comparison! I would like to know if uploading animated stories or movies made in Unreal Engine 5 and monetizing it is okay?

I read “blender boids” as “blender bois”

@Zloy_nub

3 жыл бұрын

same lol

Great info in video, I was just thinking about which one would be better for, and yes, use them both :)

You should use both. Make characters, vehicles, maybe buildings in blender, do the renderings in ue5, maybe the animations of the water too.

You need both blender for modelling,unwrapping and rigging the unreal for real time rendering

@Tapajara

3 жыл бұрын

Cycles may serve that purpose.

@hector3dev

3 жыл бұрын

@@Tapajara Cycles is not real time.

@thecyanglo5005

3 жыл бұрын

@@hector3dev Cycles X or whatever it's called

@watcher271

2 жыл бұрын

@@thecyanglo5005 Cycles X isnt real-time either, just faster than Cycles.

I would use blender for modeling, rigging, animation and would use unreal engine to render and finalize it

There was no real time light bouncing if you look right. The moments that it looks like it has were scripted fake lights that react to another object (ie the roof opening above the statues). Other situations, when the sun change it's direction or the character becomes strongly iluminated, there's no change in the surrounding scenario.

That helps. Thank you.

You are talking about an product that's in development like you have been using for years. So all your theory is based on hypotheses, you should compare ue 4 vc blender because you can actually use both side by side.

can we take a complete blender scene to unreal engine and render over there ? if you can please make a video

hi guys can i make animation video with low end pc or laptop

How does unreal's animation rig plugin compare to animating in blender?

Thanks

Actually now, is UE5 stable or still in Early Access?

thank you

if i want to create a game like farmville , should i use blender or unity?

Blender is a program that now with the latest version ( 3.5.1 ) is only 981 MB. Version 2.91.2 is 531 Mb. The effective size of the functional program. What size is Unreal Engine 5?

I understand your comparison of the two programs and found it very interesting. Thank you so much for your videos..!

weird to compare Blender with an engine that isn't even out, or does the comparison refer to Unreal Engine in general?

I'm at point where Iam confused what to learn first blender or unreal engine

I will definitely stick with Unreal for now, thanks for this vid

which one works better on Mac Users?

I'm hardly hesitating between both solution for two next years, and for what i've seen with lots of vids... i stil don't know 😁. Maybe Blender + UE (especially with face motion link with iPhone, this is... wow!). In fact I don't search best ended quality, with very few action fx... i look for creating environment (mountains, huge cities...) + easy motion (face as body) ; if someone knows wich one is most PRODUCTIVE i'm taker, thanks. (Clarisse looks also great for such kind of need).

Well, I dont think blender will win but pls remake with UE5 (actual release) and Blender 3.0 (in august 2021)

Great video. Thanks.... you are starting way into the workflow of making a video. You miss the fact, that UE dont have a modeller or texturing tools,- you need to creat things in other apps and import them into UE. This is a big bennefit for Blender, that can be you all in one tool. Cheers.

Does knowledge of ue4 translate well to ue5?

You should do an updated video comparing the latest for both, would be nice to see

Game engine vs asset creating program? 🤔

I have zero knowledge in this field n im just getting into it but can u use both the softwares to make a single project ?Like using blender for animating n modeling characters and then using the same characters in UE5 to make the final video?

@hartegane7202

Жыл бұрын

Yes I am a newbie too, but I believe this is what most of the commentary here will advise

what is this video you were playing

if you ask me you should just buy two computers one for blender and other for unreal engine then use those both to make animated videos. what do u say??

Someone failed to mention quixel and realtime performance for effects and stuff in UE5. Just remember how painful in performance is to simulate smoke or fog in sycles. I mean, if i don't have to wait for my short movie to render for a week, i would be happiest man alive

What about created a yt 2d animated video series? (Nothing crazy graphics wise)

whcih game is that just love it name please

I think each one has it own benefits blender is perfect for modeling and one thing I like about unreal is render time a frame in my 3070 take 10-15 mins in blender while in unreal I can get 5-10 sec video in 5min which is crazy, almost the same quality

@saaaaaaaaadasda

Жыл бұрын

Is there a way to directly import Blender scene with animation and just render it in UE5?

your Question is totally Wrong Unreal Engine 5 will come on 2021 and unreal Engine is a Game Development Engine And Blender is 3D Software Both are different in there Field

@ThilakanathanStudios

4 жыл бұрын

Apologies @Crazy Guy, you're right, both are different types of software. I was excited by the features of UE5, and couldn't help but compare to Blender. Some features coming to UE5 would be awesome if it also came to Blender and also the other way around as well. Both are amazing programs that can be used together!

@crazyguy7585

4 жыл бұрын

@@ThilakanathanStudios no Apologies bro actually i am a Indie Developer and i use both Unreal and Blender for me Game Project

@Bill-yd3jg

3 жыл бұрын

@@ThilakanathanStudios No need to apologize. I am guessing that you were comparing those 2 because the fact is that Unreal Engine is being used more and more in film and animation, such as in the Mandalorian for the background.

@pop2147

3 жыл бұрын

Even ue4 is capable for animation. And some people prefer doing animation in ue over blender. It's not a wrong comparison.

Does anyone know where to find good tutorials for animation in UE? I'm a total noob.

@officialVino

3 жыл бұрын

Did you found any?

@VoxRatio

3 жыл бұрын

Unreal Sensei just didn’t an amazing introduction to Unreal Engine 5. It’s extremely detailed but simple enough to grasp. 5 hours long but a must if you’re serious about jumping in to the latest thing. You also don’t need previous unreal engine experience. He starts fresh.

@VoxRatio

3 жыл бұрын

@@officialVino just replied to original poster. See my comment above. Thought I’d reply since your comment is only a week old.

@officialVino

3 жыл бұрын

@@VoxRatio Thank you, I totally forgot about the comment. You are a great guy for letting me know^^

And without evenn seeing UE5 you said that blender's particle system is better. How does that work??

@null6482

2 жыл бұрын

Ue5 particle system is the same ue4

Cant I pick both? Cant they work towgheter?

Why there are no KZreadrs that compare the upbge and unreal engine?

What would it cost to create a tv series with anime/animated characters in Unreal or Blender. Episodes being 20-25 minutes.

@bangzoel7974

Жыл бұрын

let's talk

What if they add lumen to blender

Unreal 5.4 is around with host of new features. Please make a comparison video among the latest versions of both.

In the end, mixing them is the best you can do

Why was Cycles glossed over?

Epic definitely will change the game forever if they ever decide to drop the rendering engine for all 3d software.

I use both, I've been using blender for few years then switched to unreal few days ago, it was so easy for me to use unreal and achieve great results due to my blended knowledge of scale and lighting

Why blender use python as prog.language what if they reprogram it using c++..I guess it helps the software to run faster, slight advantage maybe.

People. You gotta think three-dimensional. You create the assets in Blender, rig/skin/animate them if necessary, and then import them into UE5. What I like about UE4 and soon UE5 is that it handles the rendering and preview. It makes it so much easier to see the final product and adjust within that preview to gather your shots or polish what you have made so far. It also has a much easier workflow to design and create environments. Coupled with real time rendering, you can perfectly craft your settings and shots. You can get the lighting just how you want it. Add particles where you need them. Adjust assets in the scene. Add props without fear of crashing the program or overwhelming your memory and CPU. You're not stuck swapping between proxy and rendering previews. AND it can all be done on a consumer gaming GPU. Blender's renderers are getting better at using more available gaming GPUs every day, but you can't beat a game engine designed to utilize them from the getgo.

@BungieStudios

3 жыл бұрын

Simply put, use them in tandem.

For animating videos, Blender is the right tool between the two, because Blender was build for that, while Unreal Engine is not. You can't create assets in UE like you can in Blender, nor do character animations.

@landonp629

3 жыл бұрын

I would say it depends. If you are using motion capture instead of hand animation, Unreal Engine has a much easier and faster pipeline to make that happen than does Blender. Reality is though, no single program is used when 'making an animated film'. While you can certainly render, and possibly even animate and texture within UE, UE still lacks any real modeling capabilities, and basically has little useable editing features.

@gamingninjaplayz8518

3 жыл бұрын

you can use vroid with UE install plug-in form github

@BungieStudios

3 жыл бұрын

You can animate in UE5. It's not practical but it can be done similar to SFM.

@AYoutubeUser0

2 жыл бұрын

nor games too

@hector3dev

2 жыл бұрын

totally agree. UE is not for modeling. With Blender you can do all, Modeling, animating and rendering.

I wouldnt say blender wins for particles at all. You completely skipped over Niagara in UE5. It is by far one of thee best particle simulation tools out there.

1:35 You compared Blender's Eevee render engine to Unreal Engine 5 but not Cycles. That's not even close to a fair comparison.

Use both since it looks better if you use multiple engines that have there pro’s.

Blender uses too many approximation method, and are usually lighter to run compared to Unreal Engine.

Isnt the title kinda like asking "Do you want butter or cheese on your sandwich?"?

@socialfreak6900

3 жыл бұрын

B O T H

You model / put materials on blender then export to ue5 if you need...

Blender seams easier to learn. Thanks 4 the brief! Cheers.

if you want animation, use blender, maya, harmony or any other animation software. but if you are into game development, then use unreal or unity. this isnt the right way to compare theme without pointing out what their main features are for.

Whats the name of the game?

Tf2 animators: The old SourceFilmMaker Baby. Gmod Animators: MOD-

Bro insta id kudunga bro oru periya doubt bro

My biggest issue with Unreal is the fact that I can't actually animate characters on any terrain.

You forgot one point extra to Blender. It's completely free!

@TencoForever

4 жыл бұрын

PEFF DESIGNER unreal and quixel libraries are free now my guy

@gtaonline3542

4 жыл бұрын

I thought Unreal was also free, moreover, it's source code is also available on github

@keshinro...6979

3 жыл бұрын

@@TencoForever quixel is also working with blender,double win for blender

@ticoliro3392

3 жыл бұрын

@@keshinro...6979 but it is free? Unreal is also free

@johnaart

3 жыл бұрын

I think he means Unreal is not completely free as there is Royalty Free once u start making sum decent cash

Why not use both? Why limit yourself to one over the other?

Blender is good for 3d modelling, but it's way too slow for rendering films/animations especially when you have tens of thousands of keyframes. Unreal Engine on the other hand can handle huge amounts of polygons and can render frames insanely fast, but it pales in comparison to Blender when it comes to 3d modelling.

Blender is great... For me...Has a Low end PC user I trying both. But unreal engine compile shaders is crashing so many times. But blender can handle it. Blender need low storage space ,Running in old graphics card.. My PC spec is 4 GB ram, Intel dual core,Nvidia Gt 710 2gb graphics card

why cant blender just have a game engine render engine, that would be so good

@saaaaaaaaadasda

Жыл бұрын

They need to rewrite eevee completely then to be a full-blown real-time engine, that would be fantastic and free so much render time for animators.

Btw be aware of comments like "wanna be friends?" With the user name like "Logan/Ted". If you see one don't reply or better remove. If you don't know what I am talking check the internet about "wanna be friends" comment. They are attacking growing small channels.

@thehandsomeanimator2474

4 жыл бұрын

He commented in my videos is that the one you said? see my videos... why hes attacking me I only have twelb subscribers hahaha

@monishvj5172

4 жыл бұрын

@@thehandsomeanimator2474 it is targetting only small channels, if you see one don't reply anything, just remove it.

@magnuscoles5010

4 жыл бұрын

@@monishvj5172 what will happen?

@MotionDesigner009

3 жыл бұрын

wanna be friends

Blender is now 3.6. Time to revisit this...

Haha funny, a Technical Director explained to me that Lumen is indeed highly optimized Raytracing - just very low sampled and ai denoised. Thats that to "surely no Raytracing"

Great video!!! You made that with blender?

And yes, what he says at the end of the video is %100 correct, it should be a pipeline, not an either or

Good luck finishing your projects in UE5 when it's not even out yet.

@christopherpoet458

3 жыл бұрын

Mate, no one said UE5 was out yet. And even then, is expected to be out at the end of this year. It is not far off before we get to start exploring UE 5.

@showmedesign

3 жыл бұрын

Unspoken Uprising I’m not stating anyone said it was out... I’m simply stating it is not out yet and you are actually confirming this. Expected but not available doesn’t really help you right now, or does it.

@christopherpoet458

3 жыл бұрын

@@showmedesign I got that as much but you made it sound like be said in the video that UE5 was already out and he even admitted it was not. Hence my slight confusion on the wording of your op.

Omniverse Create ?

TL:DR - A TIE CHOOSE WHATEVER U WANT

but wont the high amount of polygons say billions, also increase the file size as well?

@soundninja99

3 жыл бұрын

Yes

@jahluu6825

3 жыл бұрын

yes, but it is for pros so be prepared to have at least 5tb as a base for real if you plan on being remotely serious, it can be HHD's or whatever though they will be slow, but cheap

I don't think that ue5 has better fluid simulations than blender

blender is free software and free to learn and can model any complex design and UE5 can model and can create games.If your comparing about the output of rendering its up to the user bake. But if you want an effecient work buy desktop or laptop with higher specs thats it.

Great video but it's an unfair comparison but an interesting one with different perspective, that's why it is unfair, other than that both are and will be amazing programs, at the end of the day anyone can access it since both are free🔥

@ThilakanathanStudios

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks Monish, you're right, apologies for the unfair comparison. They both are different software for different uses. I was comparing the similar features from a filmmaker's perspective as both UE and Blender can be used to make animated movies. Some of the features coming to UE5, would also be awesome if it was coming to Blender as well, like real-time global illumination and large number of polygons in the viewport. At the same time, also wish UE would have a smoother character animation workflow. Yes, at the end of the day, both are amazing, free programs!

@monishvj5172

4 жыл бұрын

@@ThilakanathanStudios man don't apologise, yeah now I can see why you compare some particular things instead of literally comparing straight ahead like I assumed. UE4 is used for making Mandalorian which is a different workflow compared to blender. After thinking that I realised this comparison is needed and not unfair. I totally didn't see your perspective properly , sorry for that. If we compare and criticise both programs will improve so thanks for this video to see a big picture 😁.

@foss2116

4 жыл бұрын

UE is free to use, but you cant use the result for free, only privat use, or you have to pay for it. Same like in UE4. But Blender is TOTAL FREE!!!

@TheAbRaMaX

3 жыл бұрын

Foss I think for UE filmmaking purposes it’s entirely free, you only pay for it if you compile the project into a playable game and distribute it. But if you render it in engine you can use the render for free.

Now theres a Addon that will turn Eevee to Semi-Cycles.

@johnaart

3 жыл бұрын

Which one?

What's this video? It is totally missing the point. It is comparing apples with oranges. Blender is a classical 3d design software. Which means you can model things and render them, by now you can also rig and animate them. UE5 is a Game Engine, which is used for real time rendering (mostly for video games). So you use blender to design all your models, rigging and animating them. Then if you want something dynamic in realtime you use UE5 and import your assets from blender. If you want a movie you render it with Blender. Obviously there are use cases in which you might want to do a movie in UE5 in a small operation because it is faster in production. But if you have a big project and want to control every aspect of it, you would use blender as (central) part of your workflow combined with many other tools, but probably not a game engine. There are some applications where real time engines are used for producing a Hollywood movie, but they are either for preview on a virtual/motion capture set or as for the mandalorian for mostly static background in a certain distance. And be not mistaken no real time engine is anywhere near photo realism yet at least for all kind of scenes. There you have no choice but to use a classical rendering engine.