Tube Vs Solid State Amp Comparison (

Ғылым және технология

Ron, N5AUA, Is wondering which is better a solid state amp or a tube amp. Watch to learn more about the pros and cons of each.
Subscribe: / davecasler .
Giveaway Info: dcasler.com/giveaway/
Edited and Videographed by Aidan Jakeman
To learn more about me, visit: dcasler.com/home/
To support my channel financially: dcasler.com/support (offers several options)
To pose an Ask Dave question: www.dcasler.com/ask-dave/ or www.ke0og.net/ask-dave/
Theme music is "Sour Tennessee Red," by John Deley and the 41 Players, courtesy KZread Music Library. You can listen to the entire song here: • Sour Tennessee Red - J...
I use drawings from OpenClipArt.org, including the "walking man"
Technician training videos, see www.ke0og.net/training/
General training videos, see www.ke0og.net/general/
Amateur Extra training videos, see www.ke0og.net/extra/
Thanks to my sweet wife, Loretta, KBØVWW, for both audio and video assistance! (Her website is www.aldea-art.com.)
My primary website: www.dcasler.com
The ham radio part of my website (direct link): www.ke0og.net
My publishing website: www.mtsneffelspress.com, where you can find my fantasy and science fiction books.
My Amazon author page, which lists my print and Kindle books: www.amazon.com/-/e/B00471I0Q4.
Twitter: @dcasler

Пікірлер: 37

  • @chublez
    @chublez Жыл бұрын

    LDMOS is the way forward, I think.

  • @rbh1151
    @rbh1151 Жыл бұрын

    Another great video, Dave! Thank you from N7RLV. I have an Elecraft kpa500 and matching tuner that I picked up used. It works well and gives me a nice bump in power. I find I seldom bother to turn it on any more. The band conditions are so good recently that I can easily work DX on 100 watts, and sometimes even work DX qrp just for kicks. This is using an endfed 104 foot wire hung from trees fed through a 9:1 unun. I have more fun hunting for approachable stations rather than being the loudest signal in a pile up.

  • @gahvno
    @gahvno Жыл бұрын

    Interesting that Dave appears to have missed mentioning the Mercury 3 amp. 1.2kw ssb on 120v. That thing is a piece of art and only $2700 so you don't have to sell a leg to get one. The only downside is that there is currently a one-year wait on the list. For the quality, features, excellent customer service, and price, it's not surprising.

  • @eddy2561
    @eddy2561 Жыл бұрын

    I ran many years the Ameritron 80A with pi tuning and it was a workhorse! Downsizing forced me to sell the amp, but it also forced me to become a more skilled op - a work in progress...HI HI 73/K6SDW

  • @nicksparozic9924
    @nicksparozic9924 Жыл бұрын

    Nick AA3WA I purchased a solid state Mercury IIIs amp and AT from KM3KM These units are attractively priced but there may be a wait to get them. i am VERY pleased with their operation.

  • @ericdee6802
    @ericdee6802 Жыл бұрын

    Penta labs is providing some fantastic 3-500z's right now, although they are Chinese, Penta labs has been putting a warranty behind these tubes, the are manufactured with a great deal of quality control believe it or not.

  • @adamwhite3584
    @adamwhite3584 Жыл бұрын

    Don't overlook a few of the "Free band" amp builders.. a few will build band switching and filtration into them. They even use LDMOS.

  • @AC3HT
    @AC3HT Жыл бұрын

    Thanks!

  • @glenmartin2437
    @glenmartin2437 Жыл бұрын

    I don't have an amp and my neighbors are already complaining about lights dimming and outages. I think I will forgo an amp. N0QFT

  • @glenmartin2437
    @glenmartin2437 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you, Dave. A great video. N0QFT

  • @g0fvt
    @g0fvt Жыл бұрын

    LDMOS amplifiers are probably the way forward, but there are some bargains to be had with ""old school" amplifiers too. The video mentions Class-A but of course most of our amplifiers operate in Class-AB.

  • @BartVanAllen
    @BartVanAllen Жыл бұрын

    Good one Dave - And you are right, work on the antennas first. Cheaper and it helps reception as well as transmission. Then the amp if needed. I have an old Heathkit SB200 that works fine business, and it goes with the old HK HW101, but also use it on the Yaesu. You said you use the Ameritron at 600 watts - doable but much longer finals life if kept below 500 watts, the same as most other solid state amps. AA7VA

  • @VE2FET
    @VE2FET Жыл бұрын

    Love my fully transistor IC-PW1…

  • @michaelpolimer2128
    @michaelpolimer2128 Жыл бұрын

    I earned my living designing solid state high power military power electronics used to drive microwave tubes.....I know high power semiconductor devices, therefore I have three "pair of 3-500Z" amps in my shack. A Raytrack I bought in 1973, used it for 5 years and carefully packed it away, unwrapped it abt 4 years ago when I got back on the low bands, new filter caps and rectifiers, a carefull Variac run up and then some "cherry red plate" gettering (de-gassing) and works like new, with the original Eimac bottles. I also run a monoband SB-220 on 6 meters and have a Drake L4-B as "backup" ...........73 from Boston, Mike K1FNX

  • @mikezagorsky
    @mikezagorsky Жыл бұрын

    Any hope of using class D amplification for HF like MW commercial transmitters are doing?

  • @skaboosh
    @skaboosh2 ай бұрын

    Thanks for the video. Is it normal for me to see over 70 volts AC in my Gallien-Krueger 250ml circuit and on the effects send and return?

  • @AdamosDad
    @AdamosDad Жыл бұрын

    Penta Labs make excellent tubes in the US, Europe and Asia. I choose to run an ALS 500M but also have an older tube amp.

  • @donz7992
    @donz7992 Жыл бұрын

    I just picked up a used Ameritron AL-572 Amplifier that claims it is 1,300 Watts. Runs off 110V but needs a dedicated 20A circuit. I have a 40M dipole and then have a 102' end fed with a 1500W 9:1 unun. I thought I heard that I do need a tuner, and then I don't need a tuner as the output network will match the antenna. Which is it? I do have a lead on 3 different 1,200 W + tuners but two of them were designed in the 1970s. (The owner wants to "thin his herd.") I think I should probably pick up one of them but I am tempted to evaluate the amp without a tuner first (at reduced power, of course.)

  • @cornbread-KO5RN
    @cornbread-KO5RN Жыл бұрын

    DAVE IS 100% RIGHT HIGHT IS MIGHT WITH A GOOD AREAL,EXCELLENT TRANSMITTING AND RECEPTION, and a AMP. Doesn’t hurt.

  • @86casimir
    @86casimir Жыл бұрын

    There are also the ACOMs (I have a 1010) but it is true that with the events in Ukraine, if I ever have to change the tube, it may be long and difficult. Another great instructional video. Thanks Dave. 73/F8MGW

  • @h2osmokey
    @h2osmokey Жыл бұрын

    How did you wire the 500m to power supply with all the red + leads?

  • @ronjoseph7973
    @ronjoseph79736 ай бұрын

    Anything more than 600 watts PEP is diminishing returns. The difference between 100 and 500 watts is 1 S unit. The difference between 500 and 1500 watts is approximately another S unit. In addition to the expense of a 1 to 1.5K amp is the need for a 240v outlet which can cost upwards of 1K depending on your home wiring. Solid state amps are also heavier due to the heat sinks for the unit. The advantage is SS amps don’t need to be tuned and have fault detection for input, SWR, and temperature excesses. Most of the operators that use amps opt for the Ameritron 811H, 800W tube amp for about $1400 less tax and 10/12 meter mod. Tubes are readily available and reasonably priced.

  • @marionmc1
    @marionmc1Ай бұрын

    LDMOS all the way. Palstar LA-1A with matching tuner

  • @FjHenderson
    @FjHenderson Жыл бұрын

    Acom are awesome amplifiers.

  • @jamescouture775
    @jamescouture775 Жыл бұрын

    I will stick with my tube amp it will take much more abuse then any solid state and is much easier to fix if it brakes. Good old 3-500z tubes are cheaper and easy to get. A set of transistors for a high power amp will cost more then the $500 a pair of 3-500z tubes. If you have ever changed power transistors you would know that's no easy task.

  • @d3w4yn3
    @d3w4yn3 Жыл бұрын

    I have the same conversation about guitar amps! Of course, different aspects here, guitarists don't care about 50 ohms or not. Another great video, very educational, as usual!!!

  • @davidc5027
    @davidc5027 Жыл бұрын

    I hear Palstar la-1k is a great amplifier as well.

  • @ChrisCookTech

    @ChrisCookTech

    Жыл бұрын

    I have this amp it’s amazing it pairs great with their ATU too.

  • @cidcolead1115
    @cidcolead1115 Жыл бұрын

    Tube amps are great in the winter. If you want more power out, start with a better antenna, as Dave says, match the antenna first. Why waste your precious signal heating up an expensive tuner?

  • @patrickbuick5459
    @patrickbuick5459 Жыл бұрын

    I want to run an amp off of DC. Up to 48VDC when I get my online solar system going.

  • @davidmilledge221
    @davidmilledge221 Жыл бұрын

    I'm told tube amps are making a come back in the music world is because tube amps have a deeper rich smoother base sound

  • @chublez
    @chublez Жыл бұрын

    A 220 circuit is one more hot wire off the other leg vs 110. If you can run one there's no reason to think you can't run the other.

  • @chublez

    @chublez

    Жыл бұрын

    If you're truly afraid of the hook up. You can pull the wire, set the boxes and have a sparky do final hook up. Depending on the run length this could save you lots of labor and you might find a smaller shop that will cut a deal for such a simple job.

  • @markruby2434
    @markruby24348 ай бұрын

    they may be different beasts but the end result is the same

  • @jimhammer2638
    @jimhammer26386 ай бұрын

    I wouldn't TOUCH anything made by MFJ or the companies they have acquired. Their QC has become so bad, that many distributors don't even want to sell their products anymore because of all the returns. I took a chance on one of their SWR meters and sure enough, it was defective. MFJ is the perfect anacronym for what they've been selling.

  • @davekiernan1
    @davekiernan1 Жыл бұрын

    Thats ogsponsive.

Келесі