It is the most underrated channel on KZread! thank you!

@MrLAntrim

7 жыл бұрын

+Moe Joudeh Thank you.

Ich war verwirrt in der Verwendung von Haben und Sein, aber nicht mehr! Vielen Dank!

@MrLAntrim

4 жыл бұрын

Es freut mich, dir zu helfen. :)

Loved this talk

This topic has confused me for so long. Thank you very much for explaining it in Detail.

For those who have studied French or Italian, this concept should be very easy to understand because a similar rule applies in those languages (it also once applied in English, which is why you will sometimes hear "he is gone" for "he has gone").

This was a really important concept for me to understand where I am at right now on my learning German journey. Especially with regards to case and inflection. Thank you so much for all your work online and going in for detail here,really helps understand it holistically.

Love this explanation, as fur mich, it cleared up several questions I've had about past tense and the use of sein vs haben. Trying to break thru to A2 and only today stumbled upon your channel. Danke Herr Antrim, du bist ein Genie!

Please explain a dictionary eg; lanngenscheidt standard dictionary. There are so munch things that I couldn't understand like so many abbreviations etc.. it will be very helpfull for those who are using foreign dictionary 🙌

Totally didn't understand the weird perfekt grammar until now. Thanks!

Wow, I am pretty confused.I think maybe lots of simple examples might help. I am learning vocabulary, but the grammar escapes me. Because of that, I understand what I read, but I can't compose correct sentences.

Thank you so much for this helpful video, I feel like I finally have an understanding of the logic behind haben and sein! It got me thinking though.. there are many verbs that use "haben" regardless of whether they take a direct object. For example: ich habe geschlafen, geschrieben, getanzt Are these exceptions or is there an explanation for this?

Thank you very much 🥰

we appreciate your hard work and please keep it up, we look forward to see a Video about German word order!!!!

@MrLAntrim

7 жыл бұрын

I have a few videos already about word order. I'm not sure exactly which topic you were looking for, but maybe they will help. Basic Word Order: kzread.info/dash/bejne/qoSY15mdoZDSZMY.html Inverted Word Order: kzread.info/dash/bejne/go6kqMWNmdidfqQ.html Question Word Order: kzread.info/dash/bejne/qGmMtKZtgty8Yrw.html Word Order with Direct & Indirect Objects: kzread.info/dash/bejne/poltu7SGc7zacco.html Word Order with Subordinating Conjunctions: kzread.info/dash/bejne/i3tnzNB-dMfTj6w.html Example Sentences with Subordinating Conjunctions: kzread.info/dash/bejne/dYuhyKeBYZS0obg.html

@sallybugs1695

7 жыл бұрын

Learn German with Herr Antrim thank you very much!!!that's what was I looking for 🙂

I am under the impression that "Ich bin ein Mann" and "Ein Mann bin ich" (I am a man), and "Der Mann ist mir" and "Mir ist der Mann" (The man is me) works fine in German and word order is flexible depending on intent.

You are genious!!!

I know the concept of direct and indirect object before, but ur video i think is a bit confusing.

Ich bin gegangen, gefahren, gelaufen, gerannt, gesprungen, gehüpft, aber: ich habe getanzt ;-) Der Mensch kann vieles machen ohne Objekt: sitzen, liegen, stehen, atmen, niesen, husten, schreien, schwitzen; Perfekt wird trotzdem mit "haben" gebildet, weil nur die Verben der Bewegung, des Zustands bzw. der Veränderung (also auch "sein", "bleiben" und "wachsen") das Perfekt mit "sein" bilden. Alle anderen Verben, egal ob sie transitiv oder intransitiv verwendet werden, bilden das Perfekt mit haben. Ich habe gelesen. Ich habe das Buch gelesen. Ich habe gehört. Ich habe Musik gehört. Ich habe geschrieben. Ich habe einen Brief geschrieben. Er hat auf dem Stuhl gesessen, im Bett gelegen, vor der Tür gestanden. Ich habe mich erkältet. Ich habe im Bett gelegen. Ich habe geschwitzt, gehustet, und geniest. Ich habe schlecht atmen können. Perfekt mit "sein": Es ist sehr schön gewesen. Warum bist du gegangen? Warum bist du nicht hier geblieben? Du bist aber gewachsen.

to snow - schneien (vi) seems it should be, "es ist geschneit" but it isn't. is this simply an exception to the rule? i know they exist... thanks!

@MrLAntrim

6 жыл бұрын

schneien is an intransitive verb, meaning it can't take a direct object, but precipitation in all of its forms uses haben in Perfekt. Es hat geschneit. Es hat geregnet. And so on.

@morlewen7218

6 жыл бұрын

As Herr Antrim said schneien (indicates no movemant or status change) uses haben in Perfekt. But there is also the verb einschneien (to snow in). That verb uses sein in Perfekt as the verb indicates a change in status (no snow versus coverd with snow) and it is used in an intransitive way.

ich gebe ihr ein Buch. a word "geben" follows a dative noun and a akkusativ noun. Is this word a transitive or intransitive verbs??

@MrLAntrim

5 жыл бұрын

Transitive. It is only that there is an object. For example "helfen" uses only a dative object. It is also transitive.

nicht zu kompliziert, danke sehr

dooohhh shit he said hes a man

hahaha lustig wenn nen deutscher das hört.... aber keine Ahnung davon hat😂😂😂