Thank you all so much for your lovely comments! Your feedback is very valuable. Can you share the link to the documentary on your social media accounts to support us?

What's crazy is that, in spite of the sheer number of artifacts, monuments, and buildings that have been found, only a tiny portion of the site has been excavated.

I am studying Turkish. I love history too. Beautiful, well made documentary. Turkish language. ❤ Turkish transcript helps! ❤ English subtitles. ❤ I will be watching this many times until I understand the language.

How fascinating. All these finds in Turkey, a new era of archeology. Thanks for sharing, and for the subtitles.

Wonderful documentary. What an honor it must be to unearth such an amazing site of human prehistory. My impression is that those professionals working to learn more about this site are doing so with both high respect for the original members of the early community, and a desire to honor them with significant understanding. Thank you so very much for sharing this documentary with the world. ❤

And speaking of things that make this site valuable and unique... In virtually every other site, finding the remains of the buildings and the residents were two separate things that 1) didn't always happen in conjunction, and 2) didn't provide you with nearly as many clues about the people, and the site in general. It seems to me to be an archaeologist's dream - to find the homes within an ancient settlement in conjunction with the remains of those who lived there - on a generational basis. They are linked at Boncuklu Tarla, like I've never even heard of. I CANNOT stop thinking about this place...

This is an extraordinary documentary. Incredibly well done. I was intensely mesmerized throughout.

Beautiful documentary - thankyou so much for sharing with English subtitles! Not all of us think of ancient peoples as 'less than' us, no matter how often we were told that. It just never made sense that the people who built the world we now inhabit were in any way inferior to us. I would think the opposite is true. Having to do more would make you an excellent problem solver, which these people obviously were. I LOVE that this is finally coming to light!!

Beautiful and enlightening. Thank you to all involved. Stunning. Our history books must be rewritten.

I missed my calling. 46 year old hard working Dad who can't seem to get enough info about ancient civilizations, history and archeology. Thank you so much. This was very well done and I'm hooked.... Also, I think I just fell in love.

Amazing documentary about an amazing discovery. Thank you for adding the English subtitles.

Absolutely wonderful documentary, respectfully communicated by all professionals involved, bringing to light fact that these were thoughtful people with love & respect for each other. Thank you 🙏

Beautifully done, thank you so much for making the effort to translate this into English. Very much wish to visit Turkiye.

Continuous settlement for 4,000 years is a pretty striking fact. A thousand years would be impressive. A nice quiet niche where life just went on as it had always done. But still they maintained connections with other outside communities.

Stunning. Thank you vary much for English subtitles. I am geneticists. Because of relatively dry condition some of these bones may still contain DNA. To prevent contamination the best would be not touching them with bare hands at all and do not even blowing on them. We shed around lots of our own DNA. This applies in particular to the locals involved in excavation as these people may be the closest living relatives. DNA analysis may open a new chapter in history of human kind and civilization. This is all mind blowing.

@Baryshx

8 ай бұрын

Studies on this subject "A genomic snapshot of demographic and cultural dynamism in Upper Mesopotamia during the Neolithic Transition" You can find it in the heading. Google

@philyra8991

Ай бұрын

this is true. However, there are now ways to distinguish ancient from recent DNA when analyzing samples. In addition, certain geneticists do not recommend to wear gloves because they know it is easier to manipulate this kind of very brittle bones without gloves.

@tw9472

Ай бұрын

@@philyra8991 Thanks I know the substitution issue, that was playng a role in neandertal or denisova DNA, but these may be too young to determine. I worked a lot with DNA, holded even my breath for some operations and simply feel terrified seeng the bare hands next to the bones, even oils etc. I can see your point in handling britle bones but on many of these clips the material doesnt seem to be that brittle. If by any chance you are in this field - do you know anything about attempts to sequence the material from sacrificial burrial places like Gazar? Thanks and all the best :-)))

@tw9472

Ай бұрын

There are problems with the differentiatiom here for example kzread.info/dash/bejne/gYZostSNebS4mqw.html It will be easy for very old DNA and highly degraded, but for younder, a few thousand years speciments the issue still exist. Archeologists: Never touch the bones with bare hands!!!! To

@philyra8991

Ай бұрын

@@tw9472 There are several things to be said. First, I understand your concern, and you are right about the issues concerning the differentiation. However, the bones are extremely brittle. I have worked in this area and seen it for myself. Animal bones are usual less fragile. Secondly, samples are most of the time not taken from the bones touched directly. When the archaeologists are removing the skeleton, they take samples with tweezers from bones left untouched. A paper about the results from DNA samples from Boncuklu Tarla was published, perphaps you could have a look. Wishing you the best as well =)

Perfect I felt the history with the documentary 😍

BRAVO!! EXCELLENT!!! An absolutely stunning film! WOW! Thank you kindly for the subtititles! Really, really, reeeeally nicely done!!!

@izyapim

2 ай бұрын

Thank you so much!

What a beautiful, informative documentary. The recent archeological discoveries must make Turkish people very proud of their deep and fascinating history.

Hauntingly relevant to our arguments of who was here first and whose culture gave rise to whom. Beautifully written...

@Baryshx

8 ай бұрын

Studies on this subject "A genomic snapshot of demographic and cultural dynamism in Upper Mesopotamia during the Neolithic Transition" You can find it in the heading. Google

İlçemizi tüm dünya tanıyacak bu emeğinizle.teşekkür ederiz

Proper archaeology.....excellent!

Beautiful film! Thank you!

Wow!! ... that was amazing ........ Thank you .. Much love from Dublin Ireland ❤

A wonderful short documentary that would make one cry while watching.

seems to me that for a long time before true agriculture, hunter-gathers spent thousands of years living a nearly settled lifestyle, the population grew, common traditions and cultural beliefs took hold among ever larger groups of people, it was a long transition phase from hunter-gather to Neolithic farmer and from the evidence we now have, the Temple, and the changing spiritual beliefs that it represents was a huge part of that transition, like Klaus Schmidt I think the Temple was first, before cities, before writing, before agriculture.

An aspect of looking back into the Past of this era and time, scale, is to understand or have knowledge of the flora and fauna in that area at that time period. Was it forested? Semi-Forested? Does any one have a speculation as to how the terrane looked back then during the 4 K of occupation? These are important questions also. The desert South West of Arizona for instance looked very different 16 K years ago with forests and water etc. instead of cactus in abundance as is now. The Video was - very interesting. The Woman who is featured as narrator is a very attractive Lady, which made the video much more interesting and pleasant to view.

Fantastic presentation!

Fascinating. Just heard about this, not yet in the general public so much. Keep working at it. From California.

I believe burying the dead under the floors of the houses they used to live in, and now occupied by their descendants or families, is a culture that used to be followed in pre-historic settlements found in ancient Ireland and the British Isles in general.

A connection with past lives lived and lost. Very well presented.

Super well done. Thank you! (I watched all the way through.)

Thanks for a wonderful documentary. Very interesting and informative. I was spending my summers when i was much younger in a small village only 20 km from this area. You guys did a very good work with this documentary. Thanks again ❤

Beautiful! Well Done, Thank You ❤

I love that there are people out there who care about the history of humanity.

@izyapim

6 ай бұрын

Ah! Thank you so much!

Correction, sometimes when they use the "private buildings" in the subtitles, the person speaking means the opposite. They should've translated it as "special buildings" because they are referring to buildings that were open to the public. But most of the time they got it right and translated it correctly. For example, this one is a mistranslation: 20:27

This is mind blowing. What a fascinating documentary.

Emeğinize sağlık teşekkürler.

Amazing I say. Thanks so much for the video and info.

great stuff. these people were the fathers of the culture of Europe, middle east and the Mediterranean.

Amaizing story, congatulations . Thank you all .

Amazing! Very well done video. I hope more will be found.

This is so well done. These were obviously an amazing settled people… i think we owe more than we know to these ancestors.

Many thanks.

Superb...and golden..

ellere dillere saglik muazzam calismalar🍀

Tarihi yeniden yazıyorsunuz. Emeğinize sağlık.

One thing is certain, modern humans existed 12,000 years ago. It is as if they suddenly appeared, and knew how to build, craft, and draw. They were of the same intelligence as us. If stuck a nuclear scientist in the miiddle of a barren land, he could only work with what he could find. They were the same. They were not primitive at all.

Güzel hazırlanmış

Çok ilginç. Çok teşekkür ederim

Pek uzun maşallah tekrar izlerim

It’s incredibly moving living with your dead in the same house, we strayed away from community

Elerinize sağlık

Excellent!

Bulgular cok onemli suphesiz, ve bu belgesel de onlardan haberdar etmesi acisindan degerli. Yalniz daha teknik bir belgesel aydinlatici olurdu. Mesela araya serpistirilen garip romantik laflar yerine, roportajlari yapan kisinin anlatilanlari anlamli sorularla detaylandiracak kadar arkeoloji alt yapisi olabilirdi.

@izyapim

6 ай бұрын

Eleştiriniz için teşekkür ederiz. Aslında bu bir tercih meselesiydi. Teknik ve salt bilimsellikten ziyade biz biraz o insanların ardındaki anlamı da eşelemek istedik…

Güzel olmuş, elinize sağlık

Perfect 👌

Megnézem majd élőben is! Remélem.

nice voice but damn I wish this was in english. I like using documentaries as background for when I am doing something else.

Binlerce yıl öncesinden yaşam izleri olan bil bölgede yürümek ve bunu bilmek yada anlamaya çalışmak. Var oluş nedenimizi sorgularken, düne dünden bu güne ve yarına

Muhteşemm❤

Çok emek var

Wow. 😍

Çok ama çok guzel

Başka alt yazılı dil iyi olmuş

Turkey will keep giving if they keep digging, the gateway to asia and one of the greatest civilisations and some the longest/oldest inhabited lands

Amazed

Have you ever asked yourself why there are no hive mind spider or scorpion species on this planet, when hive mind insects, plants, and humans are so prevalent? Seems a pretty significant observation that might be related to the spider symbolism of the cultures you are investigating.

@stephanieyee9784

10 ай бұрын

Pardon? Your question, theoretical or otherwise, does not really make sense. What is a hive mind spider?

@theomnisthour6400

10 ай бұрын

@@stephanieyee9784 the kind that are using the world wide web to enslave the minds of naive and foolish souls through social media right now. What do you suppose spiritual war is all about? One hive mind to rule them all versus free thought and free will as the drivers or destroyers of all creation. Anyone who doesn't see that humanity is at a critical spiritual juncture is pretty unconscious and probably an NPC replacement for a soul already moved on to the apocalypse they deserved

she’s extremely gorgeous ❤

@cocochocookiedough

9 ай бұрын

❤

❤

❤❤❤

What is that graphic novel she's reading?

@izyapim

Жыл бұрын

The Fox is the name of the book written by Moritz Kinzel and Nuka Konrad Godtfredsen

@jeffdee

Жыл бұрын

@@izyapim Thank you!

I believe the dead were buried in the houses because it was thought that the loved one's spirit would provide protection to the rest of the family.

@cocochocookiedough

9 ай бұрын

Probably. That's a good guess :)

@SquashFiend

8 ай бұрын

Keep your Graham Hancock BS speculation out of this please

@cocochocookiedough

8 ай бұрын

@@SquashFiend You keep your closed mind out of this.

😁

On binlerin dönüşünde ki kitabında tmm burayı anlatıyor.

Just wait til they start finding ones much much older under the waters of the persian gulf...

I think they decided this subject was not going to be interesting enough in and of itself without the enticement of a pretty female to drive the archeological storyline. In a way her role is a distraction although they use her as a vehicle to reveal information about the historical site. The approach is stilted and artificial and the focus on her body and facial features are also a competitive distraction.

@izyapim

10 ай бұрын

Thanks for your comment. We chose a female actor in order to provide a balance between men and women in the movie. Thanks.

@sharonhearne5014

8 ай бұрын

@@izyapim The actress was lovely…no question. As a student of serious archeology I guess I prefer a less esoteric, or even romantic approach to the subject matter but I am not Turkish so may not understand some traditions which are common to film making there.♥️

DNA çalışıldığını biliyoruz sonuçlarını açıklar mısınız

@izyapim

8 ай бұрын

O bulgular kazı ekibinde mevcuttur Aynur Hanım. Dilerseniz onlarla iletişime geçebilirsiniz.

Turkey is full of wonderful surprises.Could all these Megalithic sites be part of the Garden of Eden?

@cinattra

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, Adam and Eve built all that by themselves. I'm gonna guess that's a no.

@ceroid3752

10 ай бұрын

The garden of Eden was a single place at the top of a mountain/hill. It's the Sumerian E-KUR(hill house/house of gods). That's where the Abrahamic version of Garden of Eden comes from. Although the original Sumerian myths and texts show the truth in more shocking detail....

@stephanieyee9784

10 ай бұрын

Oh for goodness sake. No one knows where "The Garden of Eden" was, if it was real, how long ago it allegedly existed etc etc etc. Regardless, it was in the Jewish bible. Not Christian. It's the sort of story that usually starts with.."Once upon a time..".

@salatnedir.blogspot

9 ай бұрын

Göbekli Tepe and other T-shaped pillar locations explain *Harran Plain* was the garden which Adam settled.

Genesis says the Garden of Eden was between the Tigris and the Euphrates. Perhaps this was the abode of Tubal Cain.

@stephanieyee9784

10 ай бұрын

Just leave it alone.

Turkish

🔱🐍🔥🪘

çok çok ilginç. Türk hükümetini tarihine sahip çıktığı için takdir ediyorum!!!

men in that culture need to learn to NOT interrupt women every time they speak...

Thank you for continuing to record and show the new Mirazan sites (the original, local Kurdish name for the recent official gov name). Mirazan ("miracle maker"). the local, childless women give offerings at the hill, hoping for a child. The fertility myth of the hills, still lingers. Mirazan is the meaningful, local name for this entire super old civilization/culture. A lot better than the silly name of Gobekli ("potbelly")-- given to it by the ruling government there . I hope you continue showing us more and more of the Mirazan sites as they get dug up

Very interesting, but it's the underwater structures and pyramids such as those off the coast of Bimini and India that are older still and not at all primitive, but signs of ancient advanced technology.

Burying skulls elsewhere smells of the fear of zombies and vampires recorded in later traditions. It may be less veneration than fear of the spiritual possessed and reanimated survivors of NDE experiences, which may have been a very novel occurrence at that time - unlike today - when these folks are venerated and worshiped, no matter what sort of universe they visited when they "almost" died and what sort of messages they bring back from their spiritual "guides". Maybe we have become more gullible and programmable than our ancestors, not less?

WE WILL SOON BE LIVING THIS WAY AGAIN THE SUN NOVAS EVERY 12K YEARS SENIDING US BACK TO THE STONE AGE WE HAVE PROOF IF THIS IN ALL RECORDS

@andrewrehnert4997

Жыл бұрын

Everyone is worried about global warming and they have no idea that all the Sun has to do is burp in our direction and chaos becomes the norm of the day!

çobanlar dağda kendilerine çardak yapmışlar yada orası bir yayla evi. bir sürü gizem kattı büyük bir tarihi eser haline getirdi. gelin bizim yaylada bir sürü öylesine derme çatma evler var. çünkü dedelerimiz geçici barınak yapmışlar.

@avigares

11 ай бұрын

sizin dedeler 11bin yaşında galiba?

@stephanieyee9784

10 ай бұрын

That is by the by and has nothing to do with this archaeological excavation. Your grandpa must have been a Very Old Man if he built a shelter 11,000 thousand years ago.

I couldn't get past the first few seconds. What a pretentious selfie of a documentary. Maybe you got to something substantive eventually, but I was disgusted with the beginning. It's not about you.