Just saw this channel. All these girls were good.

Sophia's voice is really sweet

I think the third one is the best

I liked the first girl the best. Very sweet.❤❤❤

Linda! How pretty! 😍

1st and 2nd voices are very good

@mikecheeriot2650

7 ай бұрын

2nd was the worst... Song is not meant to be belt out like that. The 1st and 3rd sang it sweetly.

Sophia is the best

Wow 💗

Ohh vincent😢 I really sad for you.

The original song was obviously a singer- songwriter telling an intimate story. These three covers were oversung to a greater or lesser extent, with only the first one even beginning to approach the original almost understated intent. It takes more time than vocal hystrionics to convey a message. For instance the extremely sombre " The Grave" on the same Don McLean album is perfectly phrased without any hint of oversinging and is still full of sorrow and anguish.

Errrrr, no....MonaLisa Twins Forever!!!

kzread.info/dash/bejne/m6Kjp6RwfKzAmrg.html from The Voice of China, it has been my favorite

Mp

Sappy ! Michelle was passionate except for an occasional Tarzan yell that didn't serve the SONG

Vincent is such a simple song to sing, it's funny these judges wowing on basic singing lol effin clowns. It is a beautiful song though, the least these singers can do is play it on guitar too.

Schit hoffentlich muss Don McLean das nicht hören

NO !!! NO !!! NO !!! PLEASE STOP KILLING OTHER ARTIST'S SONG'S NOOOOOO !!

What is so special that they just turn around at the first words the first girl sings? I don't get it. I think the fix was in. Not that special. I've heard a lot of versions. It's one of my favorite songs, and this is not that great. She's clearly better than the average karaoke singer, but as a guitar player, it's quite basic. Where are the embellishments? I'd be blown away at a party, but not on this stage.

@WilliamsDad1989

3 ай бұрын

I for one get soooooo tired of those "embellishments". Just asking, but what does being a guitar player have to do with singing. She had a very pure and quite beautiful voice, and when you have that sound you don't need the attention seeking embells that usually get over done and ruin many a song. Besides, this is a beautiful song that needs to be sung beautifully , not embellished.

@daveg5857

3 ай бұрын

@@WilliamsDad1989 If I were to judge it just based on the vocal and ignore the guitar arrangement, it's perhaps a little better. I don't know, maybe I'm being harsher because it's one of my favorite songs. She's got potential.

Sophia is the best