Danie Gerber should top the list. A once in a lifetime gifted centre

@AfroGaz71

Жыл бұрын

Read the description of the video.

Gerber and Sella for me but nice list.

I'm glad you mentioned Jauzion. He was a discreet but exemplary player. Mccalister was also an excellent center during the O'Driscoll and Jauzion era, as I recall.

Met Danie Gerber in a lift in 1986 in Durban. Boks were playing NZ Cavaliers. He was brilliant.

Gerber is the best I have seen! Gerber Bunce Sella O'Driscoll Stanley

Danie Gerber and Brian O'Driscoll best centres ever.

@rikimackey7984

Жыл бұрын

Conrad Smith at 3

Solid list. However, Jauzion was more of an inside center. And the fact that you didn't include Sella (probably top 3 all time) makes it a little hard to take it seriously.

@rhyshodge4718

10 ай бұрын

I agree, but this list is regarding the professional era

Danie Gerber

How is jaques fourie above frank bunce. No phillipe sella either

@RelentlessRugby

Жыл бұрын

I never heard much mention of Bunce among the all time greats of Rugby so when researching I couldn't find enough evidence to place him top 5. Check this video for Philippe Sella, I made an error not listing him as a 13 kzread.info/dash/bejne/hX-Np9iJYt3foaQ.html

What happened to Danie Gerber?

Sella Gerber and Gibson are in my top 5 together with O Driscoll and Smith on your list

I believe that Philippe Sella should be in this list

@RelentlessRugby

Жыл бұрын

I will include him in the list for the Inside Centre position

@thomas_corbet

Жыл бұрын

@@RelentlessRugby Why though? He was an outside center and the only other one in the conversation with Smith and BOD for best ever.

@marksheehan8026

Жыл бұрын

True

If you’re counting Bunce’s whole career, he has to be top 3, no question.

I can think of at least two of not three who shouldn't be on this list at all. Not when you leave out Sells and still currently playing Huw Jones. Totally underrated!

No danie Gerber, phillipe sella, nonu, or horan....???

@RelentlessRugby

Жыл бұрын

Most have made it on this list kzread.info/dash/bejne/hX-Np9iJYt3foaQ.html

@benneal9309

Жыл бұрын

@@RelentlessRugby your claim is that it's the top 10 outside center's of all time, and you left the top 2 of all time out of that list, in Gerber and sella. Much like your 1st 5 video where you forgot the likes of naas botha and Barry John from the list completely for more average players like o gara, and farrell, in that list you didnt even have larkham in the top 5.!! Next you will tell me Lomu wasn't good enough to make the top winger of all time, and name chris Ashton or some other equally average northern player

@RelentlessRugby

Жыл бұрын

@@benneal9309 I had never heard of Gerber or Naas Botha before making these videos I was keeping the focus mainly on players of the professional era The wingers list may surprise you kzread.info/dash/bejne/ep5rqNB8hbnSnaQ.html

@matthewtetley7048

Жыл бұрын

Nonu was mostly inside center

@douglasherron7534

Жыл бұрын

@@RelentlessRugby If the lists are from the professional era then the headings should mention that - rather than "in Rugby History".

Danie Gerber obviously

Had to be Drico at #1 💪

@911dionysus

Жыл бұрын

Not to take anything away from o'driscoll, I'd rather have conrad at 13 if i was picking a team. Apart from his offensive skill set, smith is a master at organizing the defensive line.

@niallquinn6683

Жыл бұрын

​@@911dionysus to be fair O Driscoll was extremely good defensively too particularly in his latter days

@tobolee6385

7 ай бұрын

Please ..only in the northern hemisphere ...only scored 1 against the boks and 3 against all blacks in his whole career. No southern hemisphere rates him at all ..danie gerber was the best ever ..

@johnjames6620

18 күн бұрын

When there is a NH bias!

Danie Gerber was probably the best Centre ever. He didnt play much international because of South africa isolution. But the little bit he did he showed what he could do. - kzread.info/dash/bejne/pppsxpeonb2sn7g.html

@championthewonderhorse9733

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for the link - great footage of a great player.

@mosreloaded

Жыл бұрын

@@championthewonderhorse9733 Phillipe Sella rate him also the best centre he ever played against.

Lukhanyo Am!

Davies Highlight reel is outrageous

Fourie was a beast

@Wolf-hh4rv

Жыл бұрын

Incredible athlete incredible skills. Unusual for a rugby player he worked hard on keeping himself light.

Sonny Bill Williams ….best 12 ever. Gerber best 13 ever. But great list. Jacques Fourie was an incredible athlete

Philippe Sella??

You definitely missed Danie Gerber. He was definitely the all time best

@douglasherron7534

Жыл бұрын

Agreed, he was a devastating player.

@andriekos80

Жыл бұрын

Oh Gerber the greatest ever!!! In any era. End of discussion

@guygardiner1920

Жыл бұрын

Agreed and Bruce Robertson

@imrugbymad

Жыл бұрын

It says professional era

@douglasherron7534

Жыл бұрын

@@imrugbymad It does now, but it didn't when the video was originally posted. Then it said "Of All Time".

Wasn't ma nonu a 13 as ad hav him as number, add also hav tana umaga as no2

Brian O’Driscoll definitely 5th place or less. Would have Umaga, Conrad Smith, Bunce, Manu Tuilagi or even Ma’a Nonu before O’Driscoll. O’Driscoll’s level of capability looks higher than it is because of the tier 2 teams he has played for, however the previous super stars I’ve mentioned shine brighter than him even amongst their Tier 1 teammates of similar calibre.

Tim Horan and Philippe Sella both played in the professional era, and were better than anyone here except BOD. Jeremy Guscott also played during the professional era.

@mpgnz73

11 ай бұрын

Tim Horan was incredible, but was an inside centre.

@tobolee6385

7 ай бұрын

Gerber beats them all ..no one comes close ..

12 *NONU* 🇳🇿 13 *GERBER* 🇿🇦

For best Inside Centre all time it's gotta be Tim Horan

@marksheehan8026

Жыл бұрын

Yes l agree he was head n shoulders above alot of these nominations

@rikimackey7984

Жыл бұрын

Horan and Gerber in midfield for me.

@tomfabozzi5353

Жыл бұрын

Horan also played a lot of 13

I'd say the list of really great no. 13's is quite lengthy so in the end, it's a matter of opinion. Having said that, my choice is Danie Gerber 😂

Tana Umaga💪

Got it right again

Ringrose isn't too far away from this, may be considered Top 10 before he retires

@MeanAzz_13

Жыл бұрын

😂😂

Phillipe Sella, then all the others.

Jason little,Joe Stanley have to get a mention, danie gerber top of list hampered by lack of internationals

@chriskelly6010

Жыл бұрын

Jason Little had a much bigger impact on Australian rugby than Adam Ashley Cooper. Cooper may be one of Australia's best utility backs - but he was never an automatic selection in the starting line up for any position..

@troyopenshaw8763

Жыл бұрын

@@chriskelly6010 Horan and Little hard to beat as a midfield combo, and that's coming from a kiwi.

Stanley - JB Smith Bunce - Little Tana - Iremia Ma'a - Smith

nonu and sbw

Buddy! Danie Gerber! Maybe you are just young and your memory limited. Danie Gerber was the king of centers. He would have been a nightmare for all the players on your list.

Smith best center easily

BOD definitely best. You need get Mike Gibson in here

No Tim Horan🤷‍♂️ are you on glue

Where's Nonu

@user-oc1fh6eb8g

Жыл бұрын

incide centre this is 13 list

@rickster5120

Жыл бұрын

@@user-oc1fh6eb8g he played both positions during his career...showed the class and versatility of him and depth of All Black's rugby ...he played on wing for kiwis too..O'Driscoll GOAT in 13 Jersey .and yes Nonu at 12 ..

@user-oc1fh6eb8g

Жыл бұрын

@@rickster5120 i remember him on the 13 o`driscoll beat him to go score great try he then played more 12 was getting bit slow on the wing like umaga but when he started playing 12 everything fell into place for him and all blacks was unstoppable

@rickster5120

Жыл бұрын

@@user-oc1fh6eb8g the conveyor belt of talent in New Zealand was phenomenal at that time ..thought Shelford was unreal then Zinzan Brooke comes along then Kieran Read..thought josh Kronfeld unbelievable then along comes McCaw..they seemed to have a team waiting to take over after each world cup .

Matt Giteau at 12 & Brian Odriscoll at 13 Ma nonu at 12 & Manu Tuilagi at 13

Philippe sella the greatest

The late Bruce Robertson is generally regarded as our greatest centre since the mid 1950s

@jpr7365

11 ай бұрын

In fact he was named as ABs best centre ever.

@guygardiner1920

11 ай бұрын

I think of him as having Conrad Smith's brain in Rico Ioane's body.

Tim Hogan Aussie

WI agree wih nany of ghe other comments , gus like O'Driscoll, Umaga, Bunch, Sella, Mortlock, Conrad Smith was great too. We can look back in history and dig up names like Mannetjies Roux from the 60s. So , how far back do we want to go? At least all those guys had the opportunity to show their talents to the world. It would have been amazing to pitch Danie Gerber against the best of his time. He was absolutely brilliant, but could not display this enough due to International Isolation, as a South African Springbok. He may be the best of my generation, ( Late 60s to today)P.S Before the 90's in most cases, there were not Inside and Outside centre's. There were left and right.

Eh.....Mike Gibson?

@mtnstrand2819

Жыл бұрын

It clearly says 'professional era'!!!

No Phillippe Sella? The dude was better than at least half of these players...

If it is an All Black player....discussion over

I understand that this list is for the professional era but Joe Stanley was better than most of these.

O Driscall is the best player I've ever seen

@tobolee6385

7 ай бұрын

You have never seen danie gerber ...do yourself a favor..Google him ..

Such a bias to NH players. I just wonder how come only one NH team has won the RWC's because in the two reviews I have seen there is a proliferation of NH players.

Herbert? Better than many of these players

Bud you don't know much about rugby could name 20 players better than what you picked.

You clearly have a bias against South African rugby players.

O Driscoll was ok l never saw great game from him ..

@fawltyoldboybasil.2178

Жыл бұрын

Were you living on another planet at that time?

@marksheehan8026

Жыл бұрын

@fawltyoldboybasil.2178 l may only have seen 10 or so games with him playing , which in reality isn't much compared to most of the others l watched but in each of those he was OK didn't stand out . Maybe you could mention a game of his and ld watch it .

@fonz114

Жыл бұрын

Sounds like you were a kid when O Driscall was in his last year or so Go watch videos Best ever

@alcoyne3333333333333

Жыл бұрын

Mate if your just looking for a 13 to score trys you'll not see the real great players. BOD was a real hard working team player he defence was out of this world. And possibly if you seen him play on BT SPORTS the terrible Commentary probably didn't highlight all his skills to you.

@Wolf-hh4rv

Жыл бұрын

I Driscoll was really good but not top 10

Davies isn’t better than mortlock or Fourie lmao

@morapelimokokomali7907

7 ай бұрын

From most if the videos from this channel that I've watched, I've concluded that the author mostly watches northern hemisphere rugby. A lot of average players can look wonderful against a lot of Six nations teams, and when they faced the southern hemisphere they didn't look that good. For example, Davies is no doubt a good player, but even in his prime he wouldn't get picked for New Zealand or South Africa, probably even Australia.

No Jean De Villiers?

@morapelimokokomali7907

7 ай бұрын

He was a 12