To Squash Or Not To Squash - Musings On Invasive Species

Subscribe to the Learn Your Land email newsletter here: learnyourland.com
Follow Adam Haritan online here:
Facebook: / learnyourland
Instagram: / learnyourland

Пікірлер: 699

  • @alanseamans7973
    @alanseamans7973 Жыл бұрын

    This gets my award for video presentation of the year (perhaps even decade). To have the intelligence, wisdom, and courage to shine a bright light on our blatant hypocrisy in such a clear, balanced and logical form is priceless. The discouraging thing is I know Adam will get a lot of biased and emotional pushback, not based on facts but on prejudices (Dogma) which people don’t want to give up. Bravo Adam!

  • @bfboobie

    @bfboobie

    Жыл бұрын

    I'd like to second Alan Seaman's statement and contribute my award for presentation of the year and perhaps decade as well. Very well done Mr. Harrington. We are indeed sharing the virtue of your work. A voice of reason on behalf of humanity and our mother earth. Your work is well needed especially in this information age. The lessons on natural history, food and medicine are award winning quality and this latest presentation is a crowning achievement along the way.

  • @yasodamensah2723

    @yasodamensah2723

    Жыл бұрын

    I agree with you absolutely. I think a word Adam could have used was "personalism", The Native Americans had a "personal" relationship with the land, they worked with it in a mutually supportive way and not as an object for exploitation. As a civilization we think we are evolving, actually we are devolving, it is only our manipulatipn of technology that prevents us from seeing how badly off we really are.

  • @matthewh117

    @matthewh117

    Жыл бұрын

    I wish I could've said like you did. Thank you.

  • @Hydrosized

    @Hydrosized

    Жыл бұрын

    Very well said!

  • @Vbluevital

    @Vbluevital

    Жыл бұрын

    @@yasodamensah2723 Devolving sums up realities truth.

  • @paulgroth3345
    @paulgroth3345 Жыл бұрын

    May your comments reside in the hearts and minds of all the people of this land. I fear my age will not allow me to continue to do the work that you were speaking of as I have tried to all my life. At 76 I live in the woods and a 12x16 cabin trying to be a part of the land rather than make the land a part of me. Strength and long life be yours forever.

  • @markjones5561

    @markjones5561

    Жыл бұрын

    "trying to be a part of the land rather than make the land a part of me "...Beautiful

  • @iamthatiam6005

    @iamthatiam6005

    Жыл бұрын

    Praising GOD HEAVENLY FATHER for the land embracing every breath of air , giving thanks we still have some places to maybe not breathing toxins comical or drinking & bathen waters, foods , ect.. After all Heavenly Father has created man from dust/ dirt , Mother Earth . thank you Adam for sharing

  • @iamthatiam6005

    @iamthatiam6005

    Жыл бұрын

    Fear doesn't come from age , I DECREE AND DECLARE you shall live a full healthy complete life in the Mighty Name Of Jesus🙏 I renounce every spirit of fear. I command you to leave go in the Name of Jesus 🙏 I bind and cancel out every lying spirit in the name of Jesus. I command every plan trick tactics snare and strategy of satan again you to be canceled out destroyed. I ask now holy spirit FIRE burn disintegrate every evil spirits in Jesus name, you shall not die a premature death , I DECREE AND DECLARE You Shall Continue To stand in full agreement and in full alignment with every word God has already written and has spoken about you and your own Destiny in the books of Heaven In JESUS name AMEN

  • @Vbluevital

    @Vbluevital

    Жыл бұрын

    Thank You for choosing to live consciously with nature.

  • @valenfitzen

    @valenfitzen

    Жыл бұрын

    I'm 67 and live in a 12 x 16 cabin, building a food forest around me. We continue as long as we can, doing what we can. I have a wild broth simmering on the stove right now, all picked from my yard this morning. Keep on keeping on.

  • @upstny
    @upstny Жыл бұрын

    The automobile has done so much to divorce us from the land, both in insulating us from it and appealing to our desire for comfort, as well as encouraging the construction of roads and highways through wild places, which then leads to development. Thank you Adam for all you do to heighten our awareness and appreciation of mother earth

  • @jeffpaul7420
    @jeffpaul7420 Жыл бұрын

    Something that isn't mentioned in this video is biodiversity. Many non-native and even invasive species can be a decent food source for insects, but many species need specific native plants as larval hosts. Here in Niagara we have seen a massive decline in biodiversity in wild spaces in part because of the success of invasive species. Really great video. Very thought provoking. Thanks.

  • @jardinardennais4355

    @jardinardennais4355

    Жыл бұрын

    Why those "invasive" species had success? Those new species are not the reason of the problem but a part of the solution. A proof of a change in ecosystem. The new "invasive" plants set in because the "native ones" can no longer live or adapt to new geo-ecosystem. It might be caused by some geological or physical processes we do not understand today...

  • @jeffpaul7420

    @jeffpaul7420

    Жыл бұрын

    @@jardinardennais4355 although I understand what you are saying and it's a nice idea, I completely disagree. I understand the stance of let nature be nature, it's always in flux and things change and that's not necessarily a bad thing (and yes, some new plants can be a good addition to an area, very true). The problem with that mentality is that it leaves out a really critical part of the equation... The fact that humans have been impacting nature in harmful ways for a long time. We are only now starting to try to combat climate change and it's a real fight because we let these harmful acts go unchecked for way too long. Many of the invasive species have not only been brought over planted but are being widely cultivated by humans. And I have already discussed the biodiversity issue. So I get where you are coming from and I respect your point and view... But I can't buy it for a second... Especially because we are already seeing clear issues right here in my own area.

  • @Vbluevital

    @Vbluevital

    Жыл бұрын

    Agreeing, you're both in agreement.

  • @ewe392

    @ewe392

    Жыл бұрын

    ​@@jeffpaul7420 what about species cultivated by insects and such?

  • @lorrainegatanianhits8331

    @lorrainegatanianhits8331

    10 ай бұрын

    I agree, the point you made about niche organisms and their even more niche associates that depend upon them is the biggest reason why I believe nativism should not be discarded entirely.

  • @Maxaldojo
    @Maxaldojo Жыл бұрын

    Thanks for this, Adam. As a conservation professional in Northern Ohio, these are topics we face, discuss, make decisions about on a daily basis. I need to watch this a few more times to get the full message. That being said, I appreciate the thoughtfulness that you put into your videos.

  • @lukecarroll19

    @lukecarroll19

    Жыл бұрын

    Ohio 😂

  • @Maxaldojo

    @Maxaldojo

    Жыл бұрын

    @@lukecarroll19 Yep. Whatchu got?

  • @justintrama5557
    @justintrama5557 Жыл бұрын

    Dude I just want to go camping with you! Love your videos and love the mindset. You're right, in their own minds they don't need it, so much false security. The idea that dirt and rocks are gross and the woods are scary is one of the greatest travesties of human history, a mindset produced by greed that will continue to morph our planet into something it has never been before.

  • @michaela.wilson8264

    @michaela.wilson8264

    Жыл бұрын

    Noice 😁😺🍿💕💯

  • @emcee6152

    @emcee6152

    Жыл бұрын

    Greed has little to do with it. Apathy, sloth, complacency, incuriousness and fear of the unknown is why people don't get into the woods.

  • @justintrama5557

    @justintrama5557

    Жыл бұрын

    @@emcee6152 I’ll have to disagree with you there, all the conditions you named are a result of lifelong programming via a system created and maintained by greed. Books, tv, movies, marketing of any kind, have conditioned you to go to the grocery store to buy that lettuce, just like it conditioned your parents. You might get hurt in the woods! Or run into a bear! Apathy, sloth, incuriousness, fear are byproducts of the training, complacency is just a human trait. Greed doesn’t just apply to the pharma side as you referenced in your other comment. You were created to be the battery that runs the system, not just in one facet but all facets of the system.

  • @tactfulredneck3937

    @tactfulredneck3937

    Жыл бұрын

    Agreed hanging with Adam would be awesome lol

  • @veronikanadtochii2844

    @veronikanadtochii2844

    Жыл бұрын

    I'm Russian. Only here in America I found out that people are scared of woods, mushrooms, nature.. This guy is doing such a great job of changing this approach! Forest is your friend!! Wild mushrooms and berries are the best food ever, making you healthy and strong (just learn how to identify them!) And let nature to do it's work! Don't confront it! This is not our job.

  • @sprROINGG
    @sprROINGG Жыл бұрын

    Thank you, Adam, for offering this refreshing perspective: much to consider and to challenge our mindsets.

  • @chefgiovanni

    @chefgiovanni

    Жыл бұрын

    Exactly. And we all love the mention @ 5:31 is fact. Supporting that horrible company hurts the environment, just look at those nasty large warehouses and fleets of filthy trucks on the roads. Shop small biz.

  • @christinebuckley451
    @christinebuckley451 Жыл бұрын

    Hey Adam... glad to have met you several times years ago at Whole Foods. 🌿😍. Living by natural law! Doing no unnecessary harm to another being. Easy... simplicity.....most will never have this conversation with themselves, let alone with others (because of the so called "norm"). I've seen this for nearly 15 years now. Humans try and control everything. Nature heals itself. Always has, always will. I'm a voice of living vegan for nearly 15 years also. Living consciously! Heart knowing awareness... true beauty🌿. May all beings live free and be loved and respected... Much love to ALL❣ GRATITUDE 🤗

  • @ravenregards
    @ravenregards Жыл бұрын

    Totally Totally agree with you. (Not sure about those blue jays at the beginning of your video. 🙂) Even here in rural America I'm amazed at how people are so oblivious to what the land does for us and how we need the land. I am dismayed when I see cities continue to sprawl and you see all the abandoned properties such as shopping centers, etc. whose land could be reused, but instead we just clear/destroy more "new" land. This nation needs a "Learn Your Land" agency with you at its head. Thanks so much for your thoughts and wisdom.

  • @oleopathic
    @oleopathic Жыл бұрын

    Adam is getting into topics of philosophy, economics, sociology, and others while discussing ecological topics. To have such breadth of understand the man must possess wisdom. It is for this reason I hope that many years from now when he is gone he will be recognized not just as a biologist but as a leader and a philosopher.

  • @clarencerswann1360
    @clarencerswann1360 Жыл бұрын

    A very thoughtful, yet poignant commentary. You certainly made me reconsider some things. Very grateful for your work and obvious passion for the living. Truly salt of the earth.

  • @templarfarmer7755

    @templarfarmer7755

    Жыл бұрын

    Adam is the salt >> and all the gems rolled into one!!

  • @LarryD683
    @LarryD683 Жыл бұрын

    Such a great video! I was struck by your question of whether each one of us feels they need the land and the living landscape; and how clearly it shows, like a perfect mirror, that most do not feel this need on a day-to-day level -- to our detriment. Thanks.

  • @beckyhughesmcmillen2027
    @beckyhughesmcmillen2027 Жыл бұрын

    I always love your videos and appreciate when you question norms. My farmstead is located in a semi-arid part of the United States. I see the effects of climate change everyday. I worked in the invasive species arena as a documentary filmmaker for many years and saw the destruction wrought by hatred of plants and trees. It really does all come down to money on both sides of the debate.

  • @TheKingdied
    @TheKingdied Жыл бұрын

    I don't usually make it through an entire video , this is the best video you made yet. Great job , this needs to be said. Thank you

  • @hazelmartin7911
    @hazelmartin7911 Жыл бұрын

    Well said. I hope people will be open enough to consider this.

  • @HealingWoundedJedi
    @HealingWoundedJedi Жыл бұрын

    We love you Adam. Keep making the world a better place. Namaste 🖤

  • @MetatronsWing
    @MetatronsWing Жыл бұрын

    Adam, I'm always surprised at how wise you are! You're a beautiful light worker, even if you don't know it. Thank you for all you do. I truly appreciate you.😁💙☮️👽😎

  • @DavidJVMusic
    @DavidJVMusic Жыл бұрын

    thanks Adam! I wish more people would think like you do, it would improve soooo many things!

  • @barthamburg4351
    @barthamburg4351 Жыл бұрын

    In my opinion definitely one of your best videos ever. Thank you Adam

  • @lzmash3
    @lzmash3 Жыл бұрын

    Always love your perspective, thoughts and research you put into your work. Appreciate you!

  • @mytreasurechess
    @mytreasurechess Жыл бұрын

    The struggle continues 😢 and very grateful to everyone participating with you who keep focus, perspective, knowledge and wisdom rolling on with Hope!

  • @missmartpants2269

    @missmartpants2269

    Жыл бұрын

    God bless!

  • @charlieboutin3341
    @charlieboutin3341 Жыл бұрын

    Nothing I’ve seen in many years makes me think more deeply about myself and my surroundings than your videos Adam. Thank you very much. 👍👍👌

  • @pparker5113
    @pparker5113 Жыл бұрын

    YES ADAM, BRILLIANTLY DONE!!!! Taking it a step you alluded to, we non-indigenous folks should be identified as very, very invasive and destructive, yet we loose that perspective regularly and the insights it could bring. The discussion is complicated and fraught with emotions. This piece is very thought provoking. Thank you.

  • @michelem9341

    @michelem9341

    Жыл бұрын

    Yes. But the “indigenous” people were at one time not of this land. Let’s take it to the farthest perspective.

  • @robertmcmanus636

    @robertmcmanus636

    Жыл бұрын

    @@michelem9341 Well, yes... maybe... Their origin myths disagree with that view. And at any rate, the origin of Native Americans is so obscured by the mists of time, almost geologic time, that their presence here is pretty much equivalent to the native ecosystems of the Americas. Most of what we see in the upper midwest, for example, has evolved in the last 10-12,000 years since the end of the last glaciation. And even then it was a fluid situation, as it continues to be. Dates for the presence of humans in the New World are continually being pushed back into the far, far past.

  • @AlphaQHard

    @AlphaQHard

    Жыл бұрын

    Yeah, cause the natives were totally non destructive 😂

  • @robertmcmanus636

    @robertmcmanus636

    Жыл бұрын

    @@AlphaQHard Such a nuanced view.

  • @billiverschoore2466

    @billiverschoore2466

    Жыл бұрын

    @@michelem9341 the "indigenous" folks touched the land in a véry different way than "we" did - and do, with destruction and a barge pole... 🌳🕊💚

  • @groceriesforsale8169
    @groceriesforsale8169 Жыл бұрын

    Bravo once again Adam. You moved me to tears with this one. This is so important.

  • @cassandraclaman3776
    @cassandraclaman3776 Жыл бұрын

    This video needs to be seen and heard by everyone. You are, among many things, an astute and sentient philosopher. Thank you!

  • @briefcandle
    @briefcandle Жыл бұрын

    Fully agree. One only needs to ask "how did it get here in the first place?". When it comes to planting flowers and trees, I do my best to only include native species, but I'm also fully aware that we are the reason these plants and animals make their ways around the world.

  • @karenurbanski5034
    @karenurbanski5034 Жыл бұрын

    Wow, Adam, Thank you! This is one of your best videos. To answer your question . . . Yes, I do need the land. Not only for food and medicinals, but for grounding (no pun intended). A walk through nature, or even driving and appreciating the Earth's gift of beauty is soul fulfilling.

  • @nathankelly7259
    @nathankelly7259 Жыл бұрын

    Keep making these videos Adam…very much appreciated. Definitely needed to be said 👍🏼

  • @LiseFracalossi
    @LiseFracalossi Жыл бұрын

    This is beautiful, Adam. I have been surprised to find native plant and/or invasive eradication communities full of toxicity and ignorance, and I think you're put your finger on the heart of why. These are complex questions, and I think a lot of the people in the native plant space (but certainly not all) don't have the necessary relationship with the natural world to see the problem of invasive species holistically. For example, I've heard people vilify Queen Anne's lace (Daucus carota) without realizing it's the same species as the common carrot, or that nearly all the vegetables we eat in North America are non-natives. I've heard cries of "save the bees!" next to "destroy non-natives!" not realizing that the honeybee, Apis mellifera, is not a native species, and that the things that are helpful to honeybees may not be helpful to bumblebees or halictid bees or any of the beautiful variety of native bees of North America. I very much agree re: habitat, too, and it breaks my heart whenever I see ground being broken for a new housing development, knowing it will soon turn into a thicket of multiflora rose and bittersweet. But OTOH, there's an estimated shortage of 6 million houses in the U.S.! I want forests, but also want people to have affordable places to live. Can we reconcile this? Or is it a matter of holding the contradictions in our head?

  • @Garradouken
    @Garradouken Жыл бұрын

    Adam, you are wonderful. I’ve been following your videos for so long, and I’ve learned so much about my land and have changed core thought processes based on your exploratory way of understanding the world around you. This video has once again changed how I think. Thanks for that.

  • @argentvixen
    @argentvixen Жыл бұрын

    Rock on, Adam. You blew me away with this one. These are thoughts I have been trying to articulate for a long time and then, Bam!, you concisely knocked it out of the park. Thank you.

  • @heatherthomas7545
    @heatherthomas7545 Жыл бұрын

    This made me laugh, made me think, made me agree. Thank goodness for people like you out here in the information space.

  • @DaveKraft1
    @DaveKraft1 Жыл бұрын

    You are absolutely, positively spot on with your analysis! Thank you for saying this out loud -- something that millions do not want to hear, let alone discuss.

  • @TheyCallTheWindMariah
    @TheyCallTheWindMariah Жыл бұрын

    Thank you for bringing this subject to light! We need to talk about subjects like this a lot more. One love 💚

  • @dorothys8148
    @dorothys8148 Жыл бұрын

    This is a wonderful video and a catalyst for some powerful thoughts. Thank you, Adam.

  • @michaelwilliams4790
    @michaelwilliams4790 Жыл бұрын

    Well said, Adam. I appreciate the attempt to articulate a nuanced position even if it's still a work in progress. This will contribute to the conversation!

  • @sonniskies7686
    @sonniskies7686 Жыл бұрын

    I really appreciate your perspective and obvious love for the ecosystems we share across the world. Thank you for being you!

  • @Blade5019
    @Blade5019 Жыл бұрын

    For quite a while now, every time there is a Japanese Beetle in the yard I say live another day. You didn't ask to be here. Interesting and informative as always. Thanks, Adam.

  • @dianekistner7650
    @dianekistner7650 Жыл бұрын

    Such important questions and observations, Adam. Thank you for putting them out there.

  • @patcoleman
    @patcoleman Жыл бұрын

    Thank you Adam for being willing to share this important viewpoint.

  • @billiverschoore2466

    @billiverschoore2466

    Жыл бұрын

    beautiful thumbnail you have there, Pat 🌳🕊💚

  • @carto4028
    @carto4028 Жыл бұрын

    Very wise of you sir, you've said a lot of things I thought about for years without the proper words to convey and you've opened my eyes on some other things too.

  • @coolvidsdotcompets2751
    @coolvidsdotcompets2751 Жыл бұрын

    very refreshing to hear. I've had a lot of these thoughts and it is often times alienating when talking with others that bring up the "dreaded" invasives. Thanks for making me feel less alone.

  • @ConnieLowell
    @ConnieLowell Жыл бұрын

    Bravo!! So thoughtful and articulate. For me, this is a call to action to stop, consider and change my behaviors. Thank you for the better informed perspective!

  • @willymags123
    @willymags123 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you Adam I always look forward to your videos always so jam-packed full of education that one can use in everyday life. Till next time, God bless

  • @outbackwack368
    @outbackwack368 Жыл бұрын

    Wow, the aspects you highlight resonate on so many levels. I couldn't agree more. Thank you! Many varieties of flora that is generally considered NATIVE now was once NON-NATIVE.

  • @WildGoddess44
    @WildGoddess44 Жыл бұрын

    Just - wow! You are a brave and bright soul. You speak truth and wisdom and open people's minds to new perspectives. All of these things - and more - needed to be said at this time. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

  • @tactfulredneck3937
    @tactfulredneck3937 Жыл бұрын

    So glad to see another video your channel means alot to me I really appreciate you I wouldn't know the things I know or be inspired in the way that I am to be a mycologist if it weren't from you Adam

  • @timothymitchell8310
    @timothymitchell8310 Жыл бұрын

    Well said Adam and a well written newsletter that led me to this video. Great perspectives on native and non native. We that travel the world are considered native to the area in which we were born. Even tribal people all over the world didn’t just spring up out of the land but, they all got there due to travel. Great perspective and thank you for it. I recently suggested you to another one of your neighbors with a KZread channel there in Pennsylvania Fred Dunn from The Way to Bee. I thought that you would be good together.

  • @billiverschoore2466

    @billiverschoore2466

    Жыл бұрын

    i have a funny feeling that Adam may not agree with beekeeping; we take away their honey, even their propolis. What do we feed them after we take away their food? Best thing would be honey, but mostly it's honey bee tea or even the poison we call sugar... 🌳🕊💚

  • @timothymitchell8310

    @timothymitchell8310

    Жыл бұрын

    That’s true but, I don’t expect everyone to have my same opinion. We really are all very different

  • @stanleyschafer4232
    @stanleyschafer4232 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you Adam for sharing not only your thoughts and perspectives of the land , but thank you for sharing your videos with us. 🇺🇸

  • @debk9984
    @debk9984 Жыл бұрын

    Amen brilliant soul! You are amazing! Thank you for speaking the much needed truth! 🍁🍂🦋🪳🐛🌳

  • @DeborahStephenson
    @DeborahStephenson Жыл бұрын

    My husband and I live on 75 acres adjacent to many thousands of acres of national forest. We consider ourselves stewards of the land rather than "owners" and as such we try very hard to keep the landscape in balance and to have a small personal footprint. We have carefully managed our glades to control the aggressive (native) Juniperus virginiana in order to allow native grasses and flowers to come back--which, of course, encourages native fauna as well. Species diversity among natives has always been our goal. When we first moved here 30 years ago we assiduously dug out dandelions, plantain, lespedeza, etc. in our quest to eradicate anything non-native. Then one day, like a light going on in our heads, we realized how beautiful and truly wonderful dandelions were; how healthful plantain was, how much quail enjoyed lespedeza seeds, and it gave us pause. We began to notice how many of the "invasive species" were actually benefiting the native pollinators and providing herbage, fruits and seeds for deer and other wildlife. We began to ask ourselves "how is this bad?" Sometimes, in the case of truly aggressive invasives like kudzu, the answer was obvious and it was definitely NOT good. In other cases, the answer could only be found by study and much contemplation ... with our own devils and angels perched on our shoulders whispering the pros and cons as we tried to think things through. What it has ultimately come down to for us is a test involving two things. The first is a question of balance--does the organism benefit more than it harms, and does it maintain an ecologically neutral or relatively small footprint. The second thing has come to us more recently, and is a direct result of climate change. We see the world changing (getting increasingly hotter, involving more extreme weather patterns with droughts and floods in unlikely places, and so on) and we ask ourselves ... "which of these life-giving organisms is likely to still survive in 10 years or 50 or 100 years? Should we be removing something from the environment if it is the most fit to survive the destruction we are causing to Mother Earth? Shouldn't we, instead, be encouraging anything that CAN grow TO grow and thrive? In a few years (geologically speaking) we may be faced with a desert planet. Too late, people may wake up and then every living thing will be precious to everyone. These invasive species may be the sole survivors of the planet's once bountiful flora and fauna. The very toughness that allows them to claim new space may be the features of the future that let them live when we have killed everything else. So now, we have adopted a policy of live and let live. We monitor for overly aggressive species and take measures to control rampant overgrowth, but we no longer strive to eradicate. Balance is the key word. BALANCE in all things--the Golden Mean.

  • @robertmcmanus636

    @robertmcmanus636

    Жыл бұрын

    I don't understand the reference to lespedeza. All the lespedeza species I know are native to Minnesota anyway. Perhaps you're referring to a species. I'm referring to the genus lespedeza.

  • @DeborahStephenson

    @DeborahStephenson

    Жыл бұрын

    @@robertmcmanus636 You are correct, I was referring to a species considered invasive and given "noxious weed" status in several states--mine (Missouri) among them. The species I mean is Sericea lespedeza (Lespedeza cuneata).

  • @veronikanadtochii2844
    @veronikanadtochii2844 Жыл бұрын

    Dear Adam! Thank you so much for everything you are doing! You are so right about it! Let the nature do it's work!

  • @timfowler4642
    @timfowler4642 Жыл бұрын

    What a brilliant exposition of this topic. Very introspective and important for considering our place in this grand creation. Love the analogy from little love story from Solomon. Keep up the fight to educate us hard heads. We will eventually get it!

  • @davidledoux1736
    @davidledoux1736 Жыл бұрын

    Good message, Adam. It gives people on both sides of the fence something to think about; not the least of which is to consider doing away with the fence altogether.

  • @USAIRlines6408
    @USAIRlines6408 Жыл бұрын

    Great video! I work for an SLF monitoring and eradication program and these are questions that I spend a lot of time thinking about. The current public sentiment around SLF (that being; kill on sight) is helpful from a management perspective, but it certainly places the blame on an insect that is simply performing its normal biological functions. In reality, the invasion of SLF and its host Ailanthus altissima are the result of increased volume of oversees shipments, lax international trade regulations, and irresponsible development/construction projects. I try to make that a part of the conversation when I'm speaking to the public but most people just want me to say "smash 'em!". That being said I do still think that the control of invasive species is necessary for preserving our ecosystems. I don't know if you meant it this way but I don't necessarily agree with the idea that just because native populations also migrate into new territory, the 1492 cutoff being mostly arbitrary and ignoring indigenous history, and the lack of data on the nutritional value of invasives, is reason enough to throw our hands up and allow these invasives to run rampant. Certainly it can be said that species like ailanthus, bittersweet, barberry, and kudzo, are a threat to biodiversity. These species choke out native plants and turn diverse ecosystems into monocultures. Even if native birds and mammals are able to get their nutrition from these plants, if the environment changes or a disease introduced and the invasive species die off, the native consumers are left without any source of food and will likely die off as well.

  • @jardinardennais4355

    @jardinardennais4355

    Жыл бұрын

    I would never take part to such a "eradication" program. Not only this method is pointless but dangerous. To spread such an idology which separates the plants in bad and good ones based on "origins" and on our very young and poor knowledge of complex process, is the base line for all hatred based idologies. Or the nature and human society are much more complicated thant that.

  • @markjones5561

    @markjones5561

    Жыл бұрын

    @@jardinardennais4355 I agree in some respects, but I have also seen once biodiverse forest understories, filled with many types of plants and animals, be almost completely eradicated because one plant (in my instance barberry, and mile-a-minute). And I waited, for about 8 years, to see the balance shift back. It never did. Now I spend my free time in the woods near me, clearing, these invasives so that many more plants may take their place. Would these locations find balance in time? Yes probably in hundreds to thousands of years. Where I live there are less and less forested areas. More concrete and blacktop everyday. I try to help where I can. The problems are laid out so well in this video. It's us that is the problem. But...If you had a sick friend, would you ignore their needs, let them fail, or would you help them in any way you could? The land is my friend, and I will always choose to help it.

  • @AlphaQHard

    @AlphaQHard

    Жыл бұрын

    @@jardinardennais4355 You’re extremely soy and are definitely overthinking this. These are destructive pests, they need to be eliminated. Your worldview is naive and frankly downright stupid

  • @ksbrook1430
    @ksbrook1430 Жыл бұрын

    Mind blowing! You have tied so many topics of discussion into one broader and more encompassing perspective. Thank you.

  • @frankcowan6625
    @frankcowan6625 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you again, Adam. This talk has made me feel diffrent about what it is to be invasive and native. Hugs.

  • @benjaminross7064
    @benjaminross7064 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you so much for this thought provoking video. As usual, it was really well made!

  • @adolfreynolds
    @adolfreynolds Жыл бұрын

    Great perspective and thanks for sharing your thoughts. Most of us unfortunately are not even self aware of who they are much less conscious about the land.

  • @willheel9143
    @willheel9143 Жыл бұрын

    Thanks for this video. You make some good points and a lot of points I personally don't agree with. Re: globalization and invasives. We live in a capitalism-driven world and i don't believe we can practically change that at this point. We opened pandora's box in the industrial revolution and i don't believe we can go back in any practical sense. However, i do believe we can learn from our mistakes with invasive species introductions and management practices and develop better mitigation and management strategies. Developing smarter invasive management policies is much more likely to happen than ending globalization, world trade, and cancelling Amazon (which ain't never gonna happen unfortunately). Also i don't really understand the argument that all species have the right to travel in the same way humans do... we shouldn't anthropomorphize non-human life. No invasive WANTED to travel to another ecosystem, they just got brought there by chance and tried to survive. Travelling from China to America in untreated pallet wood on a container ship is very different than going to Amalfi Coast for a vacation. And citing gypsy moth chemical treatments from the early 1900s as an argument against invasive treatments is a bit short sighted given we have massively improved treatment methods since then. Yes that was a disaster but we've learned so much since then. Is there a reason you didn't mention hemlock woolly adelgid?? Arguably the most damaging invasive in the Eastern US, given eastern hemlock is a keystone species with a massive influence on birds, insects, riparian systems, erosion control, and carbon sequestration. Our generation may very likely watch the eastern hemlock become eradicated from eastern forests which will be an ecological tragedy. Your argument in this video kind of reminds me of the argument "If you care about the environment... Then why are you driving a car?" Which always struck me as a moot point. I drive a car because I live in a society that forces me to do that. I need to make money to survive. I try to limit the damage I cause in this pursuit but inherently i cause damage every day and i understand that. I also understand ways in which i can limit my damage. Similarly we live in a capitalist, multinational corporation-driven world. I wish we didn't but that is the reality we live in. Given this reality I believe we can take measures to reduce our harm on natural systems. One of the ways we can reduce our harm is to try to reduce the spread of invasive species when possible and promote native species/native habitat when beneficial. Are all non-native species bad? Of course not. And you are right that it is good to have that perspective. But its undeniable some non-native species devastated our forests and ecosystems. I feel like this video may serve more as a distraction to practical efforts we could make to reduce our harm than as a helpful dialogue. Some of these points you make feel a little nihilistic. I am not triggered, just have some thoughts on this video. Thanks for this. -will

  • @PaulKempLFM

    @PaulKempLFM

    Жыл бұрын

    Great comment. Thanks for making it. I think the argument in the video was nicely presented but deeply flawed. It touched on a lot of points but most were irrelevant to the question of whether to squash Spotted Lantern Flies in the US. The answer to me is an empathic "yes". The immediate threat they present to local ecosystems and agriculture is simply too great to ignore.

  • @pipedreamism1

    @pipedreamism1

    8 ай бұрын

    Well said

  • @Jim-uj3ty
    @Jim-uj3ty Жыл бұрын

    Thank you Adam for this very thought provoking video. Love your videos.

  • @seneca114
    @seneca114 Жыл бұрын

    Once again you've succeeded at delivering a very thought provoking video! Thanks so much, Adam!

  • @terryallaway5881
    @terryallaway5881 Жыл бұрын

    This is one of the top ten of your videos, if not the top! Great to hear a conversation about this, especially to point out that there has been human management for many more years than most people consider and to the broader point of just what is a "native"?

  • @billbarnes9718
    @billbarnes9718 Жыл бұрын

    Adam Harrison for President 2024! Great video my brother. If more people had your insight and outlook this world would be a much better place.

  • @jennifercall9014
    @jennifercall9014 Жыл бұрын

    Nicely articulated Adam. I have recently stretched my limited followers with the idea that today‘s greatest oxymoron is a human declaring another organism as an invasive species.

  • @stonerubber
    @stonerubber Жыл бұрын

    "The land is a mirror." So true. Just as we are a mirror of our environment. Thanks for this video.

  • @rayandmelaniemelograne7209
    @rayandmelaniemelograne7209 Жыл бұрын

    Thank You! Thank You! Thank You! Very well stated. Finally, Common sense is brought into this topic of conversation. ( I saw a lantern fly the other day and did not have the heart to squash it for the very reasons you explain in this video. I thought I was alone in feeling this way). We truly do ignore the root problems and only treat the symptoms. I hope the change will happen that is needed

  • @goodun2974
    @goodun2974 Жыл бұрын

    Personally, I would indeed squash Amazon like a bug if it was in my power to do so. Theoretically, it's in my power to get my wife to give up her Amazon account and stop buying things from them, but I have been unable to convince her. I guess you could say that Amazon has become an endemic species to virtually the entire world, at great cost to local economic systems and institutions (the same applies to Walmart, "dollar" stores, banking conglomerates and so on). The similarity between Amazon (and other global/corporate invasive entities), and invasive plants and animals, is that at one point in time humans had *a choice* as to whether or not we allowed or brought them into our own local biosphere/eco(nomic)sphere. Once the invasive species, be it corporate, political or biological, gets a foothold in an area that has been modified or developed by humans in a way that promotes the invading organism's growth, it becomes virtually impossible to eradicate them merely by pulling them up by the roots or squashing them like a bug.

  • @missmartpants2269

    @missmartpants2269

    Жыл бұрын

    Yep. Amazon is just a leg of the invasive bug we are dealing with there. A leg of a puppet controlled by the ultra elite depopulation loving rulers. God bless!

  • @goodun2974

    @goodun2974

    Жыл бұрын

    @Null , I tried to get my wife to give up Facebook and Twitter as well, but to no avail. I try to tell people that you cannot change the paradigm of the world by using the tool that was constructed by unscrupulous people specifically to control it by monetizing our likes and dislikes, to their advantage and our disadvantage. I've got issues with Google, who own KZread, as well, but I ignore all the ads that they throw at me and I try not to give them too much information with which to try and monetize me. I also use a non- trackable browser instead of Google for most of my Internet searches. Perhaps one of the points I was attempting to get at in my previous post is that as individuals we need to develop a better immune system with which to ward off manipulation and control, or at least to recognize attempts by others to adapt our sociopolitical and environmental landscape to their advantage, so that we can make a decision as to whether or not and to what degree we join in, reject it, or fight against it. Resistance should not be futile, and we should insist on having a choice as to whether or not to assimilate.

  • @squidward5110

    @squidward5110

    Жыл бұрын

    Amazon is the symptom youre hate is misdirected. capitalism is the rot. the small business owner is just as guilty

  • @michaela.wilson8264

    @michaela.wilson8264

    Жыл бұрын

    Noice observation h'm 🤔🙀💯

  • @michaela.wilson8264

    @michaela.wilson8264

    Жыл бұрын

    @@goodun2974 yeah I use the Brave Browser yet am still on fakebook and the boobtube hopefully brining some to the conditions of our world stage 😂😹🍿💕💯

  • @templarfarmer7755
    @templarfarmer7755 Жыл бұрын

    Adam…beautiful..you are the essence of great concioussness to the land, and why you can so rationally and brilliantly speak of it, and to it…what a great human you are ‘traveling’ on on land…This video was GREAT in so many hundreds of ways..Thank you (hugs)

  • @goss67
    @goss67 Жыл бұрын

    Wise words with an excellent presentation.

  • @RobChatburn
    @RobChatburn Жыл бұрын

    Absolutely brilliant. Keep up the good work

  • @danieldevier9861
    @danieldevier9861 Жыл бұрын

    Hi Adam! I want to Thank you for making this well thought out thought provoking video. I am originally a from a suburb of Pittsburgh but currently live in Sydney Australia. Australia shares a similar past not unlike America with respect to how indigenous cultures are recognized and treated. I would venture to say that it is not commonly known but likewise here in Australia the Indigenous people played a major role in managing the land prior to colonization. Some of the lands here were often managed in such away as to be reflective of contemporary European gardens and estates at the time( 1788) . The English were quite surprised to find Australia in such a state I am told. There also exists here a strong sentiment with respect to native and exotic species and their impacts on the environment and relations with each other. On Tuesday of this week I attended a workshop by a lovely and passionate immigrant (non native) to Australia who shares his knowledge and stories of edible weeds with those who care to take an interest. While on this foraging course this same theme of native vs. exotic or non native species came up in discussion as one of the other attendants to the course was heavily involved in what is referred to her as bush regeneration. Two seemingly opposed sides or viewpoints on first inspection. However, as the course went on and more knowledge and stories were told, it turned out that a cooperative relationship between foragers and bush management was very profitable for both parties. I thought you might be interested in this as I think it illustrates to some extent that these thoughts are arising to and through the consciousness of those whom try to walk in and with respect for "Country" as it is called here. I guess I just wanted to share that as I miss the Pennsylvania wilderness and enjoying watching your content. Thanks Again Mate!

  • @Goaterd
    @Goaterd Жыл бұрын

    This is the kind of philosophy that brings the universe together. Thank you!

  • @johnatyoutube
    @johnatyoutube8 ай бұрын

    Wow, thank you! You made some incredibly deep points that expanded my thinking. I'm a watershed steward and environmentalist and I'm seeing invasives literally taking over. But, we brought them here because we travel everywhere. Many, we actually invited. I totally resonate with the stress aspect of seeing an environmen devolve. Once your eyes are open, it's shocking to see how much impact we've made on our ecology and environment. Especially how some native species are struggling. We've lost 24 mature oak trees in my community this year to sudden oak death and I performed a lot of detective work to understand why. It's a complex web of factors, but we're the cause. And it literally hurts to watch them dying and feel helpless to save them. It was a lesson in nature and how precious our trees are. And how vulnerable they are to our impact. You're right, it's important for us to see how we ourselves are not living in harmony with the Earth. Perhaps it's not possible. Perhaps we're the primary invasive species of the entire planet. But, we could also be its loving gardners if we're more consciously involved in our relationship with it. The best we can be is to be conscious of our relationship with the Earth and our inevitable footprint on it and tread lightly and with intention. We're part of it. And it's part of us. We need to remember that symbiosis.Many of us have become detached unconcious consumers rather than conscious stewards - both within and without.

  • @HuckleberryHim

    @HuckleberryHim

    7 ай бұрын

    Thank you for having an open mind and the ability to think rationally about this very divisive topic, being a person actually employed in the field. It is rare, because so many of the institutions which employ people in this capacity take the default paradigm of invasion biology deeply for granted. I commend you, again, beautifully written thoughts.

  • @jonc.6271
    @jonc.6271 Жыл бұрын

    Great video! "We have to be willing to question our beliefs, also practice what we preach" the world will be a much better place if majority of us could do that

  • @rotgut14
    @rotgut14 Жыл бұрын

    GREAT VIDEO! I have always been a fan of your educational videos, and had great respect for you, and it increased even more so with this video. The simple notion of judging situations through rational thought instead of emotions is an ever increasing rare occurance, unfortunately. Keep it up and stay strong, brother of the woods.

  • @traceuse13
    @traceuse139 ай бұрын

    This is my favorite video I have ever seen by you so far. Thank you. At the core, I think there are two major problems with today's discourse about invasive species and about the land in general: 1. We are disconnected psychologically from the land 2. We humans are largely in denial about the fact that we are also animals. We think we somehow transcend being animals, like there's some essential part of us that is not animal. And so we neglect to see that we are also an invasive species by our own definition of that term. We point fingers but do not have the humility to see that we are NOT above the rest of life.

  • @charlieadams1313
    @charlieadams1313 Жыл бұрын

    You are a breath of fresh air! Thank you! I try opening peoples eyes on topics like this daily. Love your content!

  • @dianeleirer9878
    @dianeleirer9878 Жыл бұрын

    Adam, this was excellent: the reasoning, the writing and deliverance, imagery, video editing. This could be a TED Talk!

  • @pathdoc60
    @pathdoc60 Жыл бұрын

    Adam, I agree with your thoughts which give us much to ponder on the Non-Native species topic. Thank you for another excellent and thought provoking video. Cheers.

  • @lh3540
    @lh3540 Жыл бұрын

    I don't know a lot about plants or bugs, and I'm always happy to see them. I genuinely love Russian olive blooms and Japanese beetles. I know they're not "supposed" to be here, but they're so pretty.

  • @paxtianodirtfrog8947
    @paxtianodirtfrog8947 Жыл бұрын

    Awesome video as usual. To one of your last points about the impact of the native peoples on this land, I am reading a great book that is showing me that. "Tending the Wild" by M. Kat Anderson. It focuses on California but is like a trip back in time.

  • @divine3ssence481
    @divine3ssence481 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you Adam you are always, Ey love all the love you put into every video. Truly it’s a blessing to hear mama/father earth through your voice expressing your passion for your home “EARTH”🌱Ey love you my treehearted 💚🌳brother keep earthing🌱

  • @murrayshekelberg9754
    @murrayshekelberg9754 Жыл бұрын

    You are 100% as responsible as every land developer or politician. Not only operating as part of, but contributing to the growth of the system that causes it, makes you as guilty as the rest. The act of using youtube helps support and strengthen the system. There are no innocents actively in modern society and each of us share the blame equally. If we care, we can walk away, if we stay, we support the negatives.

  • @mechanicallyinclined9320
    @mechanicallyinclined9320 Жыл бұрын

    I wasn’t so sure about your travel analogy and i might’ve been happier to hear more on the topic of the impacts of invasives on biodiversity but I guess there’s plenty of doom and gloom content in the topic. I personally don’t patronize Amazon and prioritize indi shops but hasn’t drawn such a close parallel between the natural and retail ecosystems before you did. Your presentation was very thoughtful and informative as always! Thanks so much for the wholesome and informative content you create!!!

  • @tedbomba6631
    @tedbomba66315 ай бұрын

    Thank you, thank you, thank you ! I can't possibly tell you how strongly I have felt same way you do about the disconnect many people have on this topic.

  • @TheFarmacySeedsNetwork
    @TheFarmacySeedsNetwork Жыл бұрын

    Yes! I share exactly the same perspectives, thoughts, ideas, and values that you illustrated in this video. You did an excellent job of illustrating those thoughts, ideas, opinions and perspectives. I completely agree with everything you stated here! And yes, it is true. The natives that were here before us Europeans inhabited this land were excellent stewards of the land and they managed it to near perfection. Hopefully we can get back to some assemblance of that in the future. Between permaculture regenerative egg education and many other pieces over time, maybe we can fix at least some of this ecosystem. Thanks so much!

  • @trumpetingangel
    @trumpetingangel11 ай бұрын

    Shared on social media. These ideas need to be spread far and wide!

  • @loiskampp5105
    @loiskampp5105 Жыл бұрын

    I like you, Haritan. I like the way you look at the broader picture. I like that you don't take the short and easy road, that you are more far-sighted than most and that you continue to learn and to teach. I'm always happy to see a new posting from you.

  • @Stolensouls69
    @Stolensouls69 Жыл бұрын

    You are SPOT ON ....lots of truth in your message. Keep it up. Most cannot think like this. I agree totally!!!!

  • @caseyoneill4235
    @caseyoneill4235 Жыл бұрын

    Thanks for your perspective. I've had a lot of the same thoughts over the years particularly with the spotted lantern fly. Walking with friends in the parks of Philadelphia really highlighted the irony to me: obsessively killing as many as they possibly could in this artificial ecosystem, with its borders defined by what small patches of land haven't yet been paved and developed, and furious at these non sapient creatures as if it's their fault they're here. Anyone interested in Adams comments about native land development should check out the book "1491" about the topic, super interesting.

  • @timamiljus7803
    @timamiljus7803 Жыл бұрын

    Adam, I just want to tell you that you are the best! I really enjoy all of your videos! I am learning so much from you sharing your knowledge. Please don’t stop doing these videos anytime soon, because you are simply amazing! I really admire you, and all of your knowledge. I just want to say thank you.

  • @hridoygovindadas914
    @hridoygovindadas914 Жыл бұрын

    I love your attitude! Please keep shedding light and spreading knowledge.

  • @greenspiritarts
    @greenspiritarts Жыл бұрын

    Yes! Yes to all your insightful questions and thoughtful answers. I would only add that why is it that humans think it is necessary to anchor a landscape to a particular point in time when nature does No Such Thing. Nature is always experimenting as climate changes naturally on its own and also now under the extreme pressures that we have added to the process. But nature is always experimenting moving plants and animal species around to see if they can thrive in other environments. It is such hubris to think that we know what is best. Love this talk! Thank you so much! ❤

  • @corryshaffer1577
    @corryshaffer1577 Жыл бұрын

    Really I think this is one of the most important conversations we need to have when we talk about being stewards of our ecosystem...I think we should have a meeting to make community to have this conversation.

  • @kennethelsman3959
    @kennethelsman3959 Жыл бұрын

    In my lifetime I have been able to bicycle end to end many times from Front Royal, Virginia to Gatlinburg, Tennessee via the Shenandoah National Park and Blue Ridge Parkway starting in 1979. I read the history along the way about the importance of the Chestnut trees, which are all gone. I have camped in the 80’s with literally thousands of caterpillars dropping from majestic trees and of late the scourge of the Hemlock Wooly Adelgid taking out entire hillsides. It is difficult to know how to feel really but I have tried to accept Nature is opportunistic and evolving, in fact I believe something like 99.5% of all species on this planet have gone extinct. But if I live to a 100 and manage one more ride in the Appalachian Mountains it would be a bit sad to not recognize any longer what is growing there if non-natives take over.

  • @jonsmith5503
    @jonsmith5503 Жыл бұрын

    Bravo! Thank you Adam, everyone needs to hear/watch this

  • @alicecooper820
    @alicecooper820 Жыл бұрын

    Adam this is a brilliant and you have put words to important thoughts. It is time for humanity to realize it is part of the land and we have responsiblities. ❤

  • @LindaMcification
    @LindaMcification Жыл бұрын

    Love this content. Thank you...This video is about growing awareness and how fragile our ecosystem is. Each organism depends and interconnected with each other.

  • @chelwesch68
    @chelwesch68 Жыл бұрын

    Great video Adam. Today I took my mother on a country drive. Back in the '70s and '80s, there were fields after fields of corn. Fields after fields of cows, horses, and pigs. Today there was drilling fields, housing plans, and very few farms. You're right Adam.

  • @rfldss89

    @rfldss89

    Жыл бұрын

    those fields are very much part of the problem too. We can meet our nutritional needs, without razing acres and acres of forests to grow corn, to feed cattle. Thank god, more and more farmers are coming to the realisation that conventional agriculture is not sustainable and are moving towards farming and grazing practices that mirror more resilient and biodiverse ecosystems.